Review Comments Report Comment

(Architectural) importance
Project:ALKHUWAILDI villas - Project No. 22761 High
Date of issue 02-12-2019 Mid
Revision No. 0 Low
V.E.

S. No. Drg. Drg. Title Comment Description Remark

No.
OO1 General Note
Provide stone finishes at plans / or add notes : Contractor to provide shop
1 drawing for stone cladding to the engineer approval with maintaining the
clear distance of external openings

2 Coordinate with Str. to reduce width of columns at grids (3,C), (3,E) to 20 cm

to avoid projection inside the rooms at Gr. & 1st.
3 Amend scale at title block of all drawing (

OO2 Missed Drawings & Details
OO3 A001 Settingout
Plan
4 Amend line type scale of all hidden lines which indicate arches & void
opening
Detail of Pergola in front of living hall& Car parking shed details.
Wall sections, i.e. (main entrance), (pergola), Garbage room), …
Arches & opening between rooms.
Kitchen & Pantry details
Waterproofing details
Landscape & green area details
Typical door details
Aluminum typical details
Wardrobe schedule & Details
Waterproofing & exposed floor above basement
Stone cladding detail
Ladder detail.
Sky light details.
Clarify the differ in level +0.30 (near protection fence & level at parking (-
1 0.02 or +0.03) , i.e. (provide slope ≈ 2% from protection fence toward
parking) or (provide step at end of parking).
2 Provide all roof levels.
3 Provide SRI ratio as per DM.
4 Refer to comments (Drg. A101 ), (3 Drg. A-405)
1 Resolve the gap at ceiling of Wash & WC & stair void.

2 Amend plan to match with perspective & elevation to provide projection

beside window of guest bedroom.
3 Provide car parking shed & resolve intersection with structural.

4 Provide reference to window between dining & Kitchen and provide detail at
Sch. of windows.
5 Clarify partition & door into pool deck along grid C, grid E, & grid 6

6 Clarify the line with curved corners from gate door to window W1 beside
OO4 A101 Ground entrance steps, i.e. (step so provide level +0.15)
7 Cancel duct at corner of kitchen at grids 4,E

Architectural Page 1 of 7
 Review Comments Report Comment
(Architectural) importance
Project:ALKHUWAILDI villas - Project No. 22761 High
Date of issue 02-12-2019 Mid
Revision No. 0 Low
V.E.

OO4 A101 Ground

S. No. Drg. Drg. Title Comment Description Remark
No.

Review level of outdoor area in front of maid room which is lower 15 cm

8 than entry, i.e (cancel the step / or coordinate with Mech. Eng. to amend
level of manholes MH-04 & 05.

9 Indicate levels of parking, all outdoor areas, (noting pool deck level is +0.45,
parking levels are -0.02 & +0.03 as per site plan).
10 Shift laundry door to allow provide architrave.

1 Coordinate with Str. & Mech. Eng. to shift duct at grids 4,E into pantry &
avoid projection in bedroom-1.
2 Provide similar duct of above comment at pantry at grids 4,C

OO5 A102 FIRST FLOOR

3 Coordinate
PLAN with Str. & Mech. Eng. size of duct at bath of bedroom-1 to fit
(ducts shown at AC Drg.), (Drainage pipes), (water supply pipes)

4 Clarify the rectangle at flooring in front of stair.

5 Amend thickness of block wall at back of WC at bath of bedroom 2

1 Provide number to glass opening along grid 2 & provide detail at Doors &
Windows schedule.

2 Coordinate height of wall along grid D (1.90 as shown in section B) with sky
light as per section A.
OO6 A104 Roof floor
3 Indicate all ducts at roof.
4 Provide SRI ratio as per DM.
5 Provide slope to drain.
6
Amend Mismatch elevations with plans, i.e. (projected wall beside ladder),
1 (windows of bathroom at ground & first at elev 2 & 4), (kitchen door at
ground)

Review height of glass window & doors noting bedrooms at front elevation
2 designed with large opening while living & dining at back elevation with
smaller opening.
A201 3 Draw the pergola at side elevations 2 & 4 (after grid 8).
OO7 to Elevations
A204 Provide finishes material of (pergola at elevation 3 between grids C,H)
4 (parking shed at elevation 2 & 4), (Columns at elev. 1 at grids A & G), (Walls
of maid at Elev. 1,2,4), ….

5 Review finish No. 2 around window of maid room at Elev.1 with stone at
perspective.
6 Provide levels of all parapets.

1 Coordinate level outside plot limit at Sec. A (+0.15) & at site plan (±0.00).

2 Amend plot limit at Sec. BB (to outer face of boundary wall).

A301
OO8 to Sections
A304
Architectural Page 2 of 7
 Review Comments Report Comment
(Architectural) importance
Project:ALKHUWAILDI villas - Project No. 22761 High
Date of issue 02-12-2019 Mid
Revision No. 0 Low
V.E.

S. No. Drg. Drg. Title Comment Description Remark

No.
A301 3 Draw boundary wall at Sec. AA in front of maid room.
OO8 to Sections
A304 Coordinate sections with plan, i.e. (Amend size of opening between living &
4 dining as per plan), (thickness of wall between stair & bath at ground), (Store
& door below stair) ….

1 Amend location of FT at plan to be at corner of the floor tile.

2 Align joint between floor tiles & wall tiles.
A401 Bath Dtls.
OO9 to 3 Coordinate FC at plan & sections, & indicate FC levels.
403
4 Enhance washbasin section detail.

1 Draw wall along grid D at plan

O1O A404 STAIRCASE 2 Refer to comments (1 at Drg. A101 ), (4 at Drg. A-301)
DETAILS

1 Amend section to indicate FFL & (provide upstand to avoid leaking into tank),
(provide concealed access with finish to match with flooring of pool deck).
O11 A405 U.G.Water T.
2 Amend location of section view at plan at access.
3 Amend location of access at section to match with plan.

1 Amend pool plan to comply with section noting the width of overflow to
pool edge ≈ 50 cm, & Review pool size accordingly
2 Provide overflow at both sides at section to match with plan.
O12 A405 Swimming 3 Provide Typ. Details of swimming pool sections.
Pool Details
4 Amend water level to +0.45 as per ground plan.
5 Provide dimensions & levels.
6 Amend drawing number.
1 Indicate garbage room doors at elevation & resolve door height.
O13 A406 Boundary wall 2 Provide sections at roller shutter gate.
3 Coordinate with Tech. Eng. to specify gate doors, i.e. H.D.G.I.
1 Amend drawing numbers.
2 Coordinate FC at bathrooms with bathroom details.
O14 A102 F. C. layout
3 Provide levels of FC.
4 Amend FC at kitchen to avoid small cut pieces.

1 Amend type of D1, i.e from aluminum swing door to solid wood hinged door.

2 Amend width of kitchen door (D2) from 90 cm to min. 110 cm.

O15 A501 Doors-win.
Sch. 3 Amend dim. (height of W1), (FD1),
4 Amend size of W5
5 Amend all swing doors to hinged doors (D1 to D5).

Architectural Page 3 of 7
 Review Comments Report
(Structural)
Project:ALKHUWAILDI villas - Project No. 22761
Date of issue 02-12-2019
Revision No. 0

Drg.
S. No. Drg. Title Comment Description
No.
OO1 General Note
refer to Arch general comment to reduce width of columns at grids (3,C),
1
(3,E) to 20 cm to avoid projection inside the rooms at Gr. & 1st.

Coordinate walls of swimming pool with architectural layout considering the

OO2 S101 Under Gr. Col 1
detail section of overflow
1 Amend slab limit to include opening at center of staircase.
Coordinate with Mech. Eng. ducts at Drg. AC101 conflict with beam B4
2
between grids 3,5 along grid C & grid E.
Coordinate with Mech. Eng. ducts at Drg. AC101 conflict with beam B1
between grids 5,5 along grid B & grid F.
OO3 S201 1st slab
Amend height of B1 between grids 1,2 along grid C & grid E to 70 cm to
3
match with Arch. Elevations.
Coordinate height of beam B2 between grids 5,7 along grid C & grid E
4
(noting opening between living & dining at Arch. Drg.).
5 Align columns along grid 5 (shift column at grids C,5 & E,5).
Coordinate with Mech. Eng. ducts at Drg. AC102 conflict with beam B4
1
OO4 Roof slab between grids 3,5 along grid C & grid E.
2 Amend location of water tank.
OO5 S203 Top roof 1 Indicate reinforcement of CB1 at section Y-Y
1 Refer to Arch. Comment Drg. & amend section to provide upstand.

OO6 S302 WT Sec. 2 Refer to Arch. Comments on swimming pool Drg. & amend section & plan

3 Amend Drg. title to include swimming pool.

Structural Page 4 of 7
 Comment
importance
High
Mid
Low
V.E.

Designer Response Remark

Not possible to be reduced width of Columns

Waiting for architectural dwgs. To be modified to modify Structural dwg.

Slab Limit has been amended

Coordinated with MEP Engr and a place has been marked in layout to pass sleeves

MEP designer by pass ducts layout to avoid beam B1

We have increased Beam depth to 70cm

We have increased Beam depth to 108cm to meet architectural requirements

Columns has been aligned

Coordinated with MEP Engr and a place has been marked in layout to pass sleeves

Over Head water tank location has been amended in roof layout
provided details for CB1
Waiting for architectural dwgs. To be modified to modify Structural dwg.

Waiting for architectural dwgs. To be modified to modify Structural dwg.

Structural Page 5 of 7
 Review Comments Report Comment
(Mechanical) importance
Project:ALKHUWAILDI villas - Project No. 22761 High
Date of issue 02-12-2019 Mid
Revision No. 0 Low
V.E.

S. No. Drg. Drg. Title Comment Description Remark

No.
OO1 General Note
1 Coordinate grids & plans layout with Arch. Drawings.

AC

1 Coordinate with Str. Eng. ducts conflict with beam between grids 3,5 along
grid C & grid E.
OO2 101 Ground floor
Coordinate with Mech. Eng. ducts conflict with beam between grids 5,6
along grid B & grid F.

1 Coordinate with Str. Eng. ducts conflict with beam between grids 3,5 along
OO3 102 1st floor grid C & grid E.
103 Roof 1 Coordinate location of water tank with CU-GF-6

1 Coordinate detail of external column & external drop beam with Arch. &
OO4 U-VALUE Tech. Eng.

DR

1 Revise BDO & CO above living hall with CO, & note this pipe conflict with
O1O 108 Grd. H/L beams along grid C & grid E.

1 Relocate FT at bath of bedroom 2 to be above bath of maid room noting the

O12 109 1st floor clear height above stair landing (i.e. between duct & WC or any other).

Water Supply
Ground Provide water point for green area on both sides of open shower.

LPG
O18 Ground floor 1 Provide Alu. Louver cabinet to fit gas cylinder.

Mech Page 6 of 7
 Review Comments Report Comment
(Electrical) importance
Project:ALKHUWAILDI villas - Project No. 22761 High
Date of issue 02-12-2019 Mid
Revision No. 0 Low
V.E.

S. No. Drg. Drg. Title Comment Description Remark

No.
OO1 General Note
1 Coordinate grids & plans layout with Arch. Drawings.

Light
1 Coordinate light fittings at bathrooms with FC layout.
2 Remove light fitting at void at mid of stair.
OO2 103 Ground floor
3 Review location of light above entrance steps.

1 Coordinate light fittings at bathrooms with FC layout.

OO3 104 First floor

Power

Elec Page 7 of 7