Sugar storage in silos: A slow conditioning approach
By Vadim Kochergin and ‘Mark Johnson*
{Amalgamated Research Inc, 20. Box 228, Twin Falls, ldaho 89909 USA
“Amalgamates Sugar Company LLC, P.O, Box 87, Nampa, daho £9689 USA,
Introduction tine, therefore Scruton in product + All produced sugar should be
Aualiy sgnicanty let the rate of maintained a deal stnage eects
Sidra ales ae coiteing water enoval Mos condoning slos ar 2000 and aa
ton wey aoe elie ar dined or retention tie a2 Ne pe Re Se by
most widely cused isues inthe lt. 72 hours. Conldoned saga eho ‘suger crystals should be continuously
‘Site Large variation in ypes of foto a storage laclty all atpeces aD ‘the sme ime overdeying
See amy eet, climate conditions 9 moisture migration and posse sae atten
‘of sugar plans or sorage facies and hardening, * Air should be disributed evely
fologn oceania EN Simple eines cntroed ht toned enone een
COE Ig czamlate sgnlfcant oven “maned” signs as enough dot
Sing Ti achiamstyamicondt more o cae bardening prop "+ Supe cd be moved ead
sea conengiem areca Hit, Dehuldied sir was own openness
‘Mors sl’ contins oreant Bama: through a bed of gar in aoad = Rat of on Coe eet
‘ators til contains enough bound ear containing about 1900 crt of cede
Ieisture fort be sow relesed in Sugar which had beer previous 1 Temperature gradients leading to
Eoistre mayne elongated in aslo fr several onthe. eras lormaton ee ens
saa seen au tefellowing probs Temperature and relative uml) Slecea
lene Ronit nares banding: (RH of eating ar were reeorded, “aay conditioning sos wesally
ding non ane ate, Mit eating als rated apposite: say mat ois ee
Udi pecs 2" SMCS and OR RIL 270th cara selena ea
Joading problems ind le for 24 hours, Measurements especially for revolting tin ae
1 Glia formation daring torage. taken the allowing day showed RETin, sek ease
*Crustformaton on he walls reduc. the head space of 699 aon
ing the effective vole ofa slo ‘Though sugar conditioning systems Factors affecting storage and con
<_actilogal problems rated work very eficenty in may gee neg
‘0 water condensation on silo wall plants worll-wide istlone of
cing perenne NO WACO DRG oF reoitg of eld Tine of condoning, sr quy and
leaning is performed. Impaired by high capt ivestment. quay are not independent ean
cate and ones show sows ars report tht gi and shoud Cee ee
ring pce ncenetnet cnt capil ives of SKE. tne tae he ee
TAT te bls ee, NO_IS reguted to comer xing amoumtstmonane ee)
drewanmontee tae elie, storage sls to codiionng mode: air danas hee ee ae
Trot Ths apanayCeneibsommon Ther, the tamed raver” Renton tin Ia eae eee
tad anak ent Senta storage nomcal soln, which wl combine pales rag sls
ecfascmcs erie ait Maes of iar inning withthe Sinn bse ed acon
‘sue of dicussion between sugar tech: opportuniy torent men Pine ee ‘ain requirements ona slo design,
My eed Se maenne aro. Ing storage facilis. Increasing con“ ReTarnen ae ally
eee he Bk rend for ces ever sugar qulity tnd sey of cele eee exchanger
ome cian a adtals sear Landing ae driving forces nbd on comin ney taaBe
pte cad hate ote condo searching fornew economical soons eet sed Ta usm soear
aly peoticcigrntska gles, Sear sergeandcondioag, Calan Sp tte
‘resly produced sugars loaded into the project goal new slo or retrfiing
Stored soccer as MET What woud be considered ideal tsa) na ye ee
‘ransfered to one ofthe avalable stor conditioning sean large variavon in data svalabe inthe
age silos. This approach certainly Ineratre fer specie air fweses A
tral dreubaces Conn ass=r- ‘The requrements for ideal gar con: review By Mee and wages 8
Stuy conga eaten ae honing and wore sytenay be mune dpe ean 8
+ Ssully designed for certain retention summarised nee Europe with air flowrate varying 0.02
194 IN SUGAR NE, 2001, VOL aR NO.to 86 hr per mete on of supa. 5.
Brain etal india thatthe pe
valve ascepted for many commercial
Installations fuctustes azound 3
smfyton.Calaltons shouldbe ca.
‘ed out on a case by-case bai,
Understanding ofthe mechanism of
mass trasfr is extremely important
to correctly calculate the air parame:
ters required for conditioning. The
‘iyi process i diven bythe aie.
fence between the pari water vapour
pressure of a drying agent and the
fuilvium vapour pressure corre
‘ponding tosuper molsture. Therefore,
the commonly used asimption dst
the diference between RH oir and
‘equlleiam relatve humidity (ERI)
fsa earring ore ofa dying
preci i aig only when the temper:
tres of sugar and surrounding si
sre equal, However: this ascumption i
‘ot valid for mort practical problems.
The kines of moire release by
sugar may significantly affect the ca
alton of required air owrates. The
sffets of condoning tempersute,
frase and other parameters on the
‘ondtioning process have been thor
fughly studied Results indicated
tn ft, very litle al eure
for condoning” Reduction of air
flowrate does affect the inital rate of
ater removal but has slost no effect
Aer 48 hous. The authors alo ind
fate that higher than required
Foverates are generally applied jus to
maintain uniform. air distrbmtion
eros the slo, These are very impor
tant conclusions which helped jusuly
‘our approach to sugar condoning
“Apical dying curve is shown in
gure 1. The fist at” prio reflects
the dying process when water read.
Ay svalale for removal, Thus. sir
parameters and Dowrate wil deer.
rine the rate of water removal. Most of
‘he remsining surface moisture ay be
removed during the period. Various
sources indicate dat condoning
tie humidity ad temperature have an
‘fect on sugar moister only ding
(he fine 2048 hours. These rambers
will vary depending on relative
flowrates and parameters astociated
‘wih the sugar and conditioning aie
Inthe second period the rat of diy
ing willbe determined by ersaliestion
and intemal diffsion through the
Smoephous layer of macros (an excel
lent review ofthe condoning mecha.
nism is gin by D. M. Meadows). A
this tie ale venation may be help
tostabilie sugar but exces awl ead
to over drying. Aitemperstate, bu
lity flowrate wil have very Ite or m0
lfc on mob remora.
Today excelent commercial cond-
tioning systems are salable frm var
ous manufacturers, High com i oi
aly payment for high quality One
should realise hat significant number
of sls inthe USA and other countries
‘were not orginally designed for cond
ning. Retrofiting is sometimes df
cult oF impossible to jurifyeconom
calls The adaiton of double walls for
heat compensation reduces uf a
time of a slo and ereater strvtaral
Droblems. Changing distributors,
Adding ar cirelaton systems and
‘redirecting the Dow of sugar are com-
plicated and expensive procedures
Tr is worthwhile discussing how
Insulation oF heat compensation of
condoning slo alfecte the operating
parameter. Heat compensation (or
heating of slo wall) creates a uniform
temperature profile acrose the silo. On
the oer hand besuze of the igh cost
{is opin, it may be only feasible for
few insalations. Our evaluations show
that just the insulation of rlitiely
srl 40 ft lamer slo may cost se
eral hundred thousand dolar. It fs
‘worth meationng thatthe presence of
Insulstion wil change the erperstre
rant across he slo wal but cannot
‘Deconsdered stan ultimate solution.
Specialists kom BC Sugar have ind
cited that nthe absence of inauaton,
‘moisture migrason othe walls ato
be eliminted tut st veil no longer
cause problems provided the air
Daramneters ae correct" This rales the
‘gestion whether insulation ofthe silos
1S necessary measure in etrfitng
spplicaons
is well recorded inthe lieraane
that good beet nagar quay ean be
‘malatained at temperatures about 20:
with an average noite of 0.025% It
‘would be extremely dieu 9 main-
fain these condone in the condition.
Ing ios because ofthe futastions in
product moisture and rates of water
fliminaion. Matting the RH of air
Inthe head pace af ilo berwoen 55.
(60% has a posite fleet on agglomer-
lation of dust particles and accumula:
tion of sai charge. Overdrying of the
Inead space, which may occur when
‘moisture is ot resiy released by
sugar, leads to mereased dust and a
Potential rik of explosion. although
ome silos are equiped with misters
for moisture conta inthe headspace,
few of tem actly tle this option,
‘The ‘slow condoning approach
The goal of removing « signicant
amount of water during limited pei
‘dof time impises certain require
rents on = conditioning stem
design. Sugar cendioning i accom:
plished by suppbing the: dying air
TNT SUGAR RL, 203, VOL, 108, NO. eB
195wrth partial water pressure lower with freshly produced sugar, whlk A portion af condoned aii intro-
‘an that fas serounding the sugar the ‘others are either resting cr deed to the head spon of al ties
sal. Typical provide sufficient unloaded, The general approach wax manning constant relative bung
ater removal re either a large air to conto al produced sugar ant around 38% tar mining the ak
anti siculated or desicants are then maintain good storage cond- of explosion, Seven condiees hove
teed for tir dshumidiicaon. ons with continuous venation. be sataed slmulascoaly for cole
Significant al flows moving through x Thus condoning in the traditonal son to occur inna fnkion one
bed of gar usualy create ‘meaning ofthe term will be applied to gy, dat concentration within explosive
sure drop and caus excessive dstfor- all stored sugar. The principle flow tang and ignition oares By tect,
‘mation, therefore some degree of sir diagram ofa sytem with one silo lng sr RH nthe heed pace Teche
ehumidfcation is wsually required to shown in Figure 2 Airis circulated a) the sale level dt aggomercios ol
‘Provide sufficient drying capacity. a relatively low flowrate, and only 2 lower sac change ae be nate
‘An shernative ‘slow conditioning refrigeration unit was used for partial Te above author alse resoned ta
approach, was inroduced "and sir dehumiifestion No desicaus dhstamannae cones oa Tepes
naire by & group of specialists were required. Conditioning air hat elect on he srongthofeaplon,
from Amalgamated Research Inc.and suffcent drying capacity to remove Contos areulstion dig the
‘Amalgamated Sugar Company for the excess moisture fom sugar crys ent songs prod ere a ee
‘etrofiting an existing cluster of con- tals and runintain suger at optimal migration te slo walls keteoa oe
crete silos. Typically one sles eaded storage condition. arow band adjacent tthe wall and
oes not afer the blk ofthe sugar The
system canbe eal modified fora clas
ter of hs by adding booster Mower
under each slo One head space vata:
‘ion fan may be used for several slo,
The proposed stem wes relatively
low air Bowrate (hrough sage) of
about 0.8 mite per metre ono ga
This quanti of drying ale sitet
to remove avaiable moleure without
overdyng the sugar A rectal distr
tor manta was incall on the bot
tom of each slo preventing ir from
channeling inside the saga bed and
—— ‘minimising the required pressure dep,
Sent . Vow sir flowrates do not adversely
‘ eee fect a disibution across the slo.
Me Bcaee eae ss BeOS ‘The main features of fatals~ inva
es rans How Dram Sie Ginaioang Sto ance to sang and yale equiv
lence ofall ott as ben peoven in
Indastrial chromstograply ‘columas
used for molarses derugarsation *
‘Therefore, the bower blowers should
only provide enough pressure to ove:
‘come friction within the bed of sugar
Results and Discussion
‘concept of “slow” sugar conditioning
» | hasbeen tented atthe Nampa factory
| of The Amalgamated Sugar Company
LLC. The project had been initiated
| mainly because of concerns about
safety during slo cleaing. Complete
2 unloading ofthe silos wa diet due
es toshigh level of sugar build-up onthe
Hot oso 2 este 5 Ashi! ~~ | walla Ttalsoereted unsafe condone
Pees att perm natn) | fee eit cea Soe
196 TN SUGAR INL, Oe, VOL THR WO. 129Namps factory seas parialyretoft-
ted to accommodate the new concent,
‘One 40 diameter silo wat complete
ly eonverted othe new operation.
‘system for slo ead space vent-
lation ‘was installed ae at sep
towards the implementation of the
news cSnditioning process The
Absolute humidity fm the head space
(erains of water pee pound of dy)
wes monitored. Is clearly shown
Figure 3 thatthe treble humiiey