Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Examining Discourse Communities
Examining Discourse Communities
Sol Padilla
RWS 1301
DISCOURSE COMMUNITIES: EL PASO POLICE DEPATMENT 2
Discourse community-a group of people who share a common goal, communicate and
write in a specific manner, have specialized language, have a hierarchy or membership, and must
be literate in the fields of lexis and genres. Throughout my ethnography I will use the
perspectives of analysts John Swales and James Gee. to determine whether the El Paso Police
Department is a discourse community. We have so many groups around us that the actual
Law enforcement is a very vague term to describe a discourse community not to mention
you have different force groups that fall under that category. The El Paso Police Department is a
small local force community here in my city that I decided to study to prove they do fall under
Literature Review
John Swales is a linguist best known for his work on genre analysis, particularly in the
fields of rhetoric and discourse analysis. In his article “The Concept of Discourse Community”, -
simply defined as a group of people who with a common goal. Now, not just any kind of people
and Swales explains why that is so. Six key components. That’s it. In order to be classified as a
discourse community the group must meet all six characteristics. One, the group must share an
agreed set of common goals. Two, have a mechanism of intercommunication among its
members. Three, uses its mechanisms to provide information and feedback. Four, utilizes one or
more genres. Five, it has acquired some specific lexis. Lastly six, has a threshold level of
explains what a discourse community is and how linguistics is a social practice versus a
DISCOURSE COMMUNITIES: EL PASO POLICE DEPATMENT 3
language. Using his powerful example of two women applying for the same job and not one got
hired, show that it is the certain language you must use in the different types of communities.
James also talks about the levels that are acquired within the group and how they can be born
into or learned from. He explains what his understanding of “Literacy” is why it is only
beneficial to those who are on the same page. Otherwise its pointless because they won’t change.
Gee. ends the article with speaking about “Filtering and Transferring” , giving the example of a
boy who reads a book and ends up using what he learns to change his views on his own
discourse community.
Both articles covered the same concept just in different ways. Swales said with only six
solid characteristics a community is titled discourse. James Gee. went into depth as to what
discourse was and the various types there is and how tricky they can be to fit in. However, both
explained the importance of understanding discourse before defining a community. The El Paso
Police Department was proven a discourse community thanks to Swales and James articles.
Methods
For this assignment I was tasked to understand the meaning of a discourse community,
and with that use my knowledge to look into communities around me that I think fit the title. So I
did, and it came to me at my job noticing the streets and the many police cars passing. That is
when I then decided The El Paso Police Department was my target. To make sure it was a
I first before anything asked a few police officers if they knew what a discourse
community was if they did not know I educated them and then asked the question one more time.
My responses were yes, they would consider themselves as a discourse community. I then did
some research on their webpage to find out more about their culture. I got some pretty interesting
DISCOURSE COMMUNITIES: EL PASO POLICE DEPATMENT 4
information from there and used that for interview questions that I was lucky enough to get and
was pretty confident in their responses. Though with that extra help it made my decision easier
Discussion
The El Paso Police Department is a group of individuals that serve and protect our city.
The EPPD is one of the first responders in any situation and do their best to make the issue(s)
resolved. Not many people can fit into this group because it takes certain qualities to cooperate
as one, that is why I will explain in all six of Swales characteristics why The EPPD defines a
discourse community.
First characteristic- independently of one’s own personal goals, the group must have one
or more goals that they all consent to. Therefore, the EPPD follow six core values in their
community. One, they respect life. Two, they revere the truth. Three, they enforce the law. Four,
they seek community partnership. Five, they honor their police power. Lastly six, they conduct
communication for example, in their car they can use voice commands on their mobile phones
that allow them to answer phone calls using voicemails and blue tooth that allow them to send
up-to-date communication about crimes. They also have two-way radios to commute via a
specific channel with headquarters, have an individual frequency for every patrol car and officer.
members of all levels should be able to communicate. In the EPPD the first responder is the
police constable that takes down the notes about the situation then feeds the information to the
next level which would be the sergeant, then onto the inspector, chief inspector and so on. Then
DISCOURSE COMMUNITIES: EL PASO POLICE DEPATMENT 5
lastly ends back up at the first responder so they can get the information and feedback to learn
for the next situation on what can be done different or even what was done good.
Fourth characteristic-using certain genres to communicate and reach goals. The EPPD
uses many genres to reach their such as being the first on any scene, using the evidence and
being able to use their systems to look deeper into findings, they also have the different levels to
Fifth characteristic- using a specific language. Using their modes of communication, they
Sixth characteristic- must have a ladder of success meaning everyone in the community
must be able to move up but obtain levels of expertise. The EPPD has many rank structures such
as the police constable, which is the basic level, goes higher into degree with the sergeant,
inspector, and into chief inspector, then superintendent, after chief superintendent, assistant chief
constable, deputy chief constable, and chief constable being the boss of the force.
Conclusion
the qualities of receiving the title “discourse community”, I chose The El Paso Police
Department with the perspective help of John Swales and James Gee. to prove this was indeed
true I used my knowledge from what James explains about discourse and how they intertwine
and influence other communities also Swales six characteristics to break down the EPPD
References
Gee, J. P. (1989). Literacy, Discourse, and Linguistics: Introduction. Journal of Education, 171,
1-17
Swales, J. (1990). The concept of discourse community. Genre analysis: English in academic
research settings (pp. 21-32). Boston: Cambridge UP.