ífléÚø‰÷]

^éqçÖçeæ†nÞù]
‚è‚¢] Ñ]†Žj‰÷] » íe…^ÏÚ

‫ﺃﺭﻧﺴﺖ ﻏﻴﻠﻨﺰ ﺃﹸﻧﻤﻮﺫﺟﺎﹰ‬

‫ ﻋﺎﻣﺮ ﻋﺒﺪ ﺯﻳﺪ ﺍﻟﻮﺍﺋﻠﻲ‬.‫ ﺩ‬.‫■ ﺃ‬

‫ﻣﺪﺧﻞ‬

    !"# ; 
  
     
 
 

   

$%%& '( '  )*+ ,-./( *+  012 3" 4( 5678
1 97:; < 9 :=> ?@ AB *+ C4 DE# ,G'@/ -. $H1& (
N
,%I 7%&( %I JK( I L M   HO %I J78 %I /

 P Q& CB LH ( 7%&( RSM8( T=%
 O < ,I :U78(
7:= (B %I %> 7:=) :4 =YV $H1&W QVM ( ; 5678
ZG%I V/% 7:= (B I =

"7:;( %I [6 #

\ ]^L7 _ `4 %I /a 4 b 5678-
  > f= _ =( ,%I [6 #
\ c %I /@ T  d%e ( ,Q\4 
ih / %I 1& P 5678 j " b ( ,%I [6 T:g1 %I  %1 '@
%I [6 :g/ 01 S%# '@1 H=
 ,& _ Q  _
Z3"#
-(

 $H1& ,a iS1 j%[  T: 9IV./ 5678 k LH S4 -

( ,b J7K = 7:; _ `4 %I H;4B ;/B D 7:; iME/ '@
]="& DP ,GT:g( ,6( ,l: ) :< 1UW $H1&W T% QV M
ZGn)' ,a( '  $H1&W 3m7:;

I p (-
_ C `  $V[  '@ < "o 5678 d12> CB
<  CB 
%W  q L
I ,1UW %I /(:(q 3MH1 &/ r%&/ (
56& H14 ( ,,\L/ D [ "o =[ jJ7K sU/( 9V;B( 56 @
   9 / < Arberry A/:t "# ,567 d12> [ "o =[
=B jnwxy 7 < C4 G56& ) uJ2s8 vsq  =W(" 
 R e W
Anthony ;(( { Vt ks( jnwzn 7 <( "%I VV % (B %I [6 &%L igB
] 9V./ D | G9/V b[67) 9V./ Samuel Clarke !:J4  HsWood
Childe Harold's Pilgrimage _ 9
%1 < C(,/( Z%I [6 @1 }/
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

ZG€)"0%H 567 _ = T,\L 9WP( C V: - ~&W  =


 ,CH l:( 56 31 :9/4 < ,A M k Q&/(-
_ ] [  $/ ( 56 iVB }/ :; P R2
V8 $/ p‚   SIVPZZZ"
|ƒ  "# ,%I V&VK #
\  L < -I B b f„L %I /;q %I ( f

C=H  L < 1UW    C.… :=
 CB 9VL E/( ,H=
 :g :;
ZGx)ZZZ g" (B J
h \ |27  C(
 <

h H 5678  †7B I  c  " 

I b I `4W %I g
 C./ -
 ˆ
C  L h ƒ ,56 %I  ]% :‡(;` ]= 56 `a '@ CB b
,bH7 5678 C.… ( ,56 01* =%% ( Zs‰ 9#=B b[67
'@ = S4 561 T: s a%s (B ,?  c k%4 ,<
\( A:S78
J*  : >  5=s _ 8=78 HL( ZG=%7 ;:(;P o( Q&/)
:b( ,%I 77B  ‹=( 5678 Œ 
I b W 7:;
(B 1W c = GColonial Orientalism): A:S78 5678
4/ h :( c: "o  5678 9/ iM  4 3g( ,5678 
C e: f( ZA;J% $7( S&( kB j P h8 s(( %I /@ %I &V (
‚ p B=/
Ž % #
- jJ7K _ ?(:(q ]
 ‘ _" =%&
=/ CB
-B  94  ( ,1%( 1% kB '4 5 4.−-2"/0 /!1%'"’V
%I &V ( “ ,A;J%W 6  \ C
 < $%/(:(q $
\W  V <
ZG•)"Z”% / %I /(:(q

b"# GPost Colonial Orientalism): A:S78 =/  5678  I B

–21I 7( ,A;J% $7( S&( kB j =/  : ƒB B=/ b 1W
 
 

   

*;P J*  "%# ,-. LH b I @1( %I #

\ QV — _ i g
Z"%1 I :— ,@

=/  4 : "o( :S78 

 =/ AB T,L 8  =/ (=

12W %  9%# ' a ,a 5678 –1M =[ b( :S78
 ==M L… " #; %I Y" ;
V  ˜ A ™"W( %I M  =q
9%P s(  =B  GNew Orientalism): ==— 5678  5678
%I = : q ]="7( ,š C
 p12 p – ` b 91 ( 5678

. Z;#›
8O _ `%4~ P 5678 7:; |& :5678  / j&[B
h 4 H^( ,s* $H1&W( 56 T% < T; I=ž
( ;>[8( l:) :œ. I J
31 ( &1 ( C;q ( C  ( C&VK 31 ( ';+ ( @1 ( %#@—
ZGŸ)G:-+
%I /@ Vq $/ [J < T==M  \H " ==— 5678" d12>
3=
 b[678 '2‰ $/ >  01¡ CB  (¢  £E# b[6 *+(
p ; M  P "o b 7:=( Sq  == –17 D ==M *t (
c =H =[( ,6 C
 =/( A;J%W 6 p7 C
 £
%V&1):\ %I #W 
( %I 1H ™W  == _ 7:=
j 1  ,\4( GZZZZ%M  -8( ,%M  %7 & ,%#a -K ,%M  /(\Vq(
c –V4 DP( Z%I V&VK( %I SM8 7:=/ r b f*q T=&W
–1L… DP ,QVMq $\( $7:=  == Œ j[ b /q( M
"%I %V  L 7:="(B "I :S78 %#a 27K"¤/ 9%1 d12>  R HO
 ==1 (`a V š(BI =%"H4 "%o  3( A:S7 p/2/  7 –1I o b
h > Sh 4( h M = ,D /
< £E# ,%
#P S… 
2 " ( ,0ƒW
J
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

I 0
( %2  Œ r:  3L/ e( %I H1 H%[ H¥ h
[= (
H"
S4 ,I :S78 T2%&1 –g* b HYW 3m b 1UW QV —  
%I  e W H%
 f & _ T:=> p[ ¢ ` 8 7:= c CB
b sJ‰( ™( "o( b ™W %ƒ 4( ,Œ ; b %I H1(
Z"%P –"V

( f & _ 0& s %I V LV 7:=( /q =(

?@W pHYW( ,  >/ %I /:@W HYW f=  I  T%  k1¦

%I V7q( %I V &47 1YV8 7:=# D  3a _ L( ,s* >/
  ˜*  =/ S%78 ,/L( /q c p[( _ §‰ "[(  C4
*; h ==M h ¨ 1IL…  $[ W $\( $7:=  == :SgW
( A2V ,/(: ( !,/ !M ) :=YV ,i8© ”/B  ,%I %V  L 7:= 

( C L7/  / ( ,% (  M C H: ( A /(( C M ( `1%a –&V:B
&Gw)ZZGZ: =%;( 4\ LVJ/ %1%H

I  3a _(
$[6&W  3"&VB C(= 8 %M  /(\VK iS1 CB
3":= CB  D Q7( ; i:;”/ $=%1
 $[6&W  C(   ha(
56 l:( ';t ( @ < 3":=  f [B %M  /(\V8 31 
 *;
4 ": 56&H1 =%7 ;:(;P k He  C 
 D p 3"ILZ r7(q
9s / 5678 ] 9IVB 3- ,Gª) " 56 : B <  (B QL (B := 
$/( " 56" $/ bM  H&/P ( bM  2VB 0 _ =H ,L ' 17B "
I f( "'@"
56 p  1 H  &7© "  T: 5678 C./
ZGy) " 9HL( / 9s(( 9H%1

I
„ b 8 $[6&W ™ _ 9 =
( ™"W f & < ]J*8 CE#
 
 

   

H= 21&/( 9/ "ƒ:( ,==— 5678/ "ƒ:  %M  /(\V8

_ H%( 9HL 3-
I  ( *+ # _ H
 "&V @(  1
 ?@ '2‰ < H"
I VL C 1¥ ==— 5678 M: =¨  ; 9:=

%I 7%& %I /@ &7©W < H" VL J( %Y%~78 37: J*
Z %I H1(

7:;(  I  '@ < bM  /(\V8 ™"W 7:; MB  /:

W  œ.
(q
I : -J- J*   q (V CB  (V ] 7 D ; `1%a –&V:B
/\H/ \ W œ.( `1%a –&V:B Ti[ ˜ < {\( ™"W %s. <
4
Z %M  /(\Vq O < $\   HO f= I =
V /:

 ‫ﺍﻟﻤﺒﺤﺚ ﺍﻻﻭﻝ‬

‫ﺍﻟﺘﺄﺻﻴﻞ ﺍﻟﻤﻔﻬﻮﻣﻲ ﻟﻸﻧﺜﺮﻭﺑﻮﻟﻮﺟﻴﺎ ﻭﺗﻴﺎﺭﺍﺗﻬﺎ‬

L/ %I V&V8 j 1 < H" VL %I M  /(\V8 ™"W  IL… =

  (Z ==— 5678 ™ =B = f*B %V  ( ,%V  m8 ¢
{\( ,%M  /(\V8/ k (q
I =/ < Z  < 9( %I «B œ.
Z%I [678 m%M ( "žJ 3B( %I &
V8 (

:  !!"#$%6 :8#'9

‹ ,hgB( " h %SM( h %%ƒ C&VK 7:; 31 b

I 6 S— 31
ZA:g( ‫ﻋﻲ‬SM( ‫ طﺒﻴﻌﻲ‬4
N 9IVB J*  C&VK 31 ZmMV( "4 17(
ZI 6 HYW( :g 31
‹
k J*  LH( ¬
," I  %M  /(\V›" ‫  ﻫﻲ‬c
‹
9V 4 J*  C&VK 31 :£B _ "%I SM8 %M  /(\Vq" ]
­ V
® C./ p/
-J- < ;=%# %M  /(\Vq R(# ;= < HL 1L^W( "Z‫ﻋﻲ‬SM 4
N
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

,%I SM8 %M  /(\Vq ,%I %2 %M  /(\Vq :b( ,r

# &%: >>¡
Z Gz) " %I #
\ %M  /(\Vq

I (=
9s / G C=%W)  %I V&V8 j 1  
  < H"W  CB
 ( , 8  _ =%4.  iS1  ,\4 Q S4 %M  /(\VJ h „¦
_ =H –V4 HYW < b"# "7:=V ] 7 b ‡DS  9^&V ] 7
A  _ h ` C4 =
#; m%s  =%4. ( m: > i/ < {=%W 
− 
 < − 7:= %I  :¯ CB  %M  /(\V8 
 < / j

h %=/ C4 i 7 ±% ²SVB  h 2HV \  –V4 %I  ' … 7:; J*  
 S4 ,b=/ ,a jB A g  g L…B P bL%VL%W  g L…B _ j

j "  †%7. < Gn³)jGnznª−nyŸy) " 34:(; % P"  P QD
I $/I =
# ; RSM8 31 C=% < Gsegmentarité) %I &
VP
HYW C./
bL%VL%W  g L…B  ,%I ¯: m:(,s J* ™:=/ 
 %I V&VK
ZA g  g L…B P

ƒ P  Q DP bM  /(\Vq  ™" < c=YV  (

3"\;B P pH&%# ,91H/ j
 bL ; 7:=1 h  e c:* A Q^
,3=%
  3.&( ZZ A; 3"4 17 ´J( 3"7
ƒ µ¥( ,3m %/ :(`(
hVM 1I ¥ (B ,3"#
-  1 … TL# 9= d> | 3m% 
ƒ p k¶(
98
k%s   > | C=%W  9 1 pH· 9IVB AB Z"V M  h s*
: B j= 8 7:= c"# ,`W ' ^ 1 T% s 

I S" (q
_ j
 b"# 7:= 1 "1MB  |& %I 7%7 I a  CB I
I / ; Q&# %I H1 a MB  †% ' ^ 1 7:;
a & ! CB
(=1 "& | ' ^ 1 %ƒ  bH1 : > 3=
 MB  %7%7
 
 

   

 ' ^ 1 _ T2%& < "   02 %"& MB   1 H=
Z %I /@ (= [

I :{\  q
j
 
/7 %I H1 %I 1* C(;  "1H/ j
 8   c CP
j=
 (B 
/& %I e _ =4© £B  I P  # C=%W <  ™ / "%1
Z ™V  C=%W < "   7B _ Sh 
( h =
V 

¸%& '2‰  m bH1  Y%# (8 =%> _  I B

,*+ : I=
_ H% a MB  ; $\ ; "M U&( Sh ; j=
 A
: 7:; P ,%I V2„ rg/( ,%I V &L7 1YVq %M  /(\Vq =H  =
`4: DP %I V\ %I W ' =/ %
#( r7 W }%/q  ˜  HO
ZHYW c *; 21& To _ ’%: L^/

<W 
  9M  b %I 7%& @ ”/P _ =4©  (ƒB‹
h g# 
&W jLq/ j Lž 9V./  "  9IVE# %I J
78 b I= A
 J
_ =4© b %I 7%& "—( %I H;48 &7©W f= %I 7%& %I Y%~78
i`M Π( %I 7%7 ]=B 0%
¢ MB  ( *+ # MB   9%M 
 L ; 1 2 H/ '@W < H A 3=
 b[678 R(6W 
0%
¢ MB  %V2/ [   =    i`M 9IVB ™"W  S7
 i`M b b ? '@W 
2 < h s >*( 56 < %I 7%& =s

,%I V &L7 1YVq %M  /(\Vq 9%P =H  ( ,?@ 5678 R(6
Z%I V2„ rg/(

: 9   ;
"'# <=% >?@: %A
" C L7/  / " c I= DP ™"W  S7 3B  j&
V8 j " =(
 '~
 8 |  G %I &
V8) j " i>
7( / =/ GjnzyŸ−nz€x)
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

S4 − ,C % 31 12>  h D *. h " c=M( / j 1 ( i`% O

= D " %I &
V8 " j " koI ( / (B 34:(; % P = −
/7 e
,Gi/B) :T==M i`Mq h :=> =  %— d> $ 3" :2^V8  
b " R ,T==M G%I J7 T=() L^ – T= _ 4 – 3:(=/ i8©(
Z%(; L( ,T==M %I J7 =( f*q

$% h :=> 9&V :2^V8  d> $ (=%# ,:">V8    I B

d> ,CDP L^ ΠZb &
V8 0& *;  T==M "j&[B" (B "i`MB"
4
 (q f &W# :*=( j&
V8  f & =&·
® ;=Mq  %M 4
  \( ,"†H‰" 9%1 d12>() v
 R (B H&
  {\( ,1%

Z; 3- %I 1 T=  DP f & |V;B P h8 s( ;%I J& T= 

":2^V8" b%t  4 @^ k%4 :  u(2W ©& |

 ,L
G Structuration) %/ _ CJH k%4( ?Gh %M  %7 7) $ ":">V8"(
(B ?b &
V8 pHYW *;  L…B( %I 7%&( %I SM8 T%  &
T;P( ‡VP _ $%+ $ 0#( _ b &
V8 0& H k%4 ,5;B |H/
j=
 /  ?c; I=" b  ( R“     3a _ ,9&V ‡VP
ˆ
†7© T=
4( ,%11 ‡D H4 Gk) ( G˜:) b
C % &
V8
R` L…B( “ –V4 DE# ZI :H78 ²(6/ c I= ( b &
V8 0&1
2 [( \®   – %I  9 & k1¦ „ −b &
V8 pHYW ="^ b
C % &
V8 =4© S4 – %I 1*= 9g[( ,pHYW D %/ ²:8 =…B
< R“# Zh gB ;¢8( 7S  L…B ; M( b 8 D CE# −h ƒ
,_B  & < k( C(  L…B ; M( h =/B b 8 ,|V;B  &
ZGnn)%I 
1 T: >/(

:( =/( 3- j "W  _ =I4B b b %I V=%W 7:= –V4 =

 
 

   

R e ==M  ;6„ uƒ $7:= 1 _  7 6 š 

_ ;S8 J*  ,$%V &L7 1YVq $\ p ,%I 1
 %I / HYW
Z 9
12 ( ,b &
V8 ‡D HVq %I e#

]=Œ ,%I 1W %I 7%& H Vq 7:; <  a: $%V2„ CB P D ;
h %1%1¢ h MD HVB %M  /(\Vq C=% < ”/ L( "%1 5 2 jLP  =`W
< SŒ C"& 8 iaP( %I /DM :S 0ƒ %14 ,GI „) HYH1 h ==M
I 1I - = _ 0%2 < 9M(B
 H" I ¹1%7 A( { &L7 1YVq 31 O
4 h
,==¢  M C H:( Gn€),jnzxz A: /(( ,1%a :/ =>[B $\
 Gnx) "Z%1  ‡D HV.4 1%a  _ `47 c (ž < 9IVB 8P

_ %I /a I L# /2* ²

7P !"# 
&W jLq =%s _  I B
 m " ·( %I Y "H%[    1 =
 ²
7P ,*B ' …
j=¯ 4 Œ h W C4 i 7  " 012V b I :g( %I #
\ jLq
Z h %7%7 9M ?a R(6

D uJ2s8  9&H1#; %M  /(\V8 O < ' $\ k[  I B

I ´JW 
$/ 
#  ];> º %I / @1 P 
V  = %I &
V8 j " C./
j "W $/ >¥ =[ A ( }/  † JV Zd12>W/ 01 S%# $\
= 9/
I '@W/( 9 J/
I »`Y d12> H‹7 †V  b# Z d12>W(
b b( ,%I &
V8 T: 0%#  =¼B H7 S%/ ½`Y  1/ b%2‰ ,L
f & _  B uJ2s8 f & _  Z$*:©W  == f= 
# W –V
I I  
:$%77B B= _ j
 %I &
V8 I   CE#

< I (&W =  $/ R“(   P A;©W b

#q ˜: B= -
Z"M  %I &
V8  W He  b
#q f &W
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

f &W < 1&1&W =  $/ C( P ¾W  L B= (-

< T,"^ 
W :g7 LH ,r%&1( Zf*B "M  "¢( A; H
$\/ [  =
  ,\L I   c –e
I =[( ; {(=1‰ %I > j V
A; ¼ ¿ =( À% C M 4/ ÁUV /:@W $/  ( Z/:@ ,a( /:@
.^V £./
I I   c ¸7q =
( Zs‰ 9
12  4 ,A( ¿ =(
  P s  Â
® b"# œ+/( (= %­ / P 
 HO ™
A;©   V LW =  $/ R“ 0ƒ  %I 1
 HYW < :
78
s H/ (;( h %1[ h HO '@H1 CB $ < ,"%/ S%# C”  P " < 4
 %I V`UW 0-   3"W =%s _ h ;S( 7:= c  h [J2V Zs*
p I   c ”(¨ CL K/ 9V./ $
I ,
( C`UW $/ [J/ > b
k%s  %I &
V8 (= T: H7B CB bMK  " # " T;78
 =%&( v
 j  p k%L (; b( ,:S78 [ %I V`UW (=
%I 1
 =  $/ “ ™%M./ (B 3%L 0ƒ   P 9%17( 9%/·P
ZGn•)%I YW 4 ==/ (B

}/ `YVB 7:=( /q   HO 9 –gU    

B=/ =
 Z'@W [  ;=   ,C &L7 1YVq bM  /(\Vq  ;(:
dsB( ,\4B ”`
I 3"ƒ^V CB ,a ,%I V\ %I W '  '@W/ i8© jS
@^V :ƒP < D ,& LH( Z6 C
  %& J* h o 1
;h ==¢ T=W 8 ( ~1YVE4 :%I S7B (= } bY%~7 − %M
( ,[  7q ]= C4 =
 Z%
#P S…( r7(q 56 
2H/
,;J ="^ b I ;>[8( %I 7%&( %I SM8 : 2 HO ,Q\4
−
2W C=1/ b[/ :a _( – '@W ™ =/ 1%L & ,&%  h ƒ ]=(
ZGnŸ)"%I „ K – %I S7B 5 &   <
 
 

   

I %I &
V8 7:= 1 –>U…
0& ‡D HVB '@W/ 1%
 C./ I =[(
,i`MB _ :(=/ 3&
 c( ,R(# _ 3&
 1%[ L# ,Z 3[ b &
V
*;  H%"W  Q&   |
( Z%I 1 =  f & P > CB P
HYW < ,9S7( %I &
V8 j " “ G`1%a) u~[ DP ,pHYW 
[J4 –S&
 $/ [J =%
 ;r
# c=( Q& _ =H b
I ; Gnw) " %I 7%7( %I SM
:  B _ =4© –V4 %I &
V8 7:= Q1aB CP

I
< ,vW 3L( T:;K , 4^  "  W  1 j=
 9IVP S(BI
4
 I B Z bL%VL%W  g _ =H £ 4 s( b %I 1W( %I = HYW
,HYW c < p A:g ,%@ JL^ — j=
 9IVE# {\
LH h8 1   1 u~
 CB  =/8 œ+/( ZQ7W k%I L < T=&W(
I bL( ) ;   1 ™V H\& b %I 7%& 21& "
2 CB
º 0
¥
9-/./ j
 CB =%1
 fM =
# ,97:;( 9- /( 9#=q uY %M  /(\Vq
#
\1 b¯: :% ‡:* ±% b Gnª)G%=) ' ^ f= %I V=%W
I
%@/ D( ,/L ] b TµW
I f*q #
\ (B ,%I L B −(:(q
#
\1 I : 2
I %I ¯: [%& < ]J*8( 9/^ 9M(B ;·P( V:
W
I |H/ Gny)G1UW %I V&VK

 < : 2 3"# C m ] 7   1 CB
 
V < A6 C( L…B _ B2 b 8 ( bSM8
%e 21& ¨ [J( L…B  91I *  ( ,%I L%VL%W %I = [J
< h : 2 \4 L…B  8 s( I ^ [J _ =H HO o <
31 dsB œ+/( ,h   1¦ [J  L…B _ =H TÃW HYW
,1UW ' ^  sB <  bH1 Á>¡ j L^/ %M  /(\Vq
h
%I 1%1¢ 7:; m#
- :=( ,}/ "g/ m[J( "” (
I ,">>*(
pHO < =%
( ]q( =
 ,@( j V %M  /(\Vq =s ,V:

() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

Z%I [ (B %I SM (B %I ; "M c; &

‫ﺍﻟﻤﺒﺤﺚ ﺍﻟﺜﺎﻧﻲ‬
‫ﺣﻴﺎﺓ ﻭﻣﻨﻬﺞ ﺇﺭﻧﺴﺖ ﻏﻴﻠﻨﺮ‬

:BCDE# BCF −n
< =(, GjnzzŸ −nz€Ÿ) 1%a –&V:P  ™"W  _ 1\ q ”/B 
4-
 91 M Zb4# 17 L%^ −A; Ä sB  †:/ < jnz€Ÿ „H&; z
 1 M jnzxz 7 %4# 17 L%^ A” (`@ =/( ZÅ/  †:/
%I 7%& j 1( &1 :; =[(Z cH  6 \\ < ( C=  1a
=/ GOxford)Z ;: &4B  Y/ GBalliol College)  %/ %I 14 < I ;>[8(
ńV;B  Y/ h i=/ I `%1LV8  — < †:= O 3[ jnz•ª 7 
&1  %I H1 9,& < : 2
I Z%I 7%&( I ;>[8 j 11 C=  Y/ 3-
I
j[ jnz٥  h [J2V( Z%I SM8 %M  /(\Vq  9 ( RSM8 31 
%I M  /(\VK    h ;= `Y%; %
#P S… P J  ==/
–¢ `YVB b c: 4=1 9(ƒB R e " ( †1ƒq Y/ ¹” q  
–1¼ DP jnzwn 7 GJohn Mac Murray) A, ! C M D7q ]ÆP
h g#  Z":(;( "H%  :/„ f= I (`" V 
ÆW 94L  J
˜@  < kI B =[( 3=
( $H1&W ; _ 9#(
I %I J7K #
\/
Gnz)ZjZnzwz 7"GSaints of Atlas) †1ƒq i%(B" " T
I= I ©

:$@G0 H<%I @ 9 J  !!"#$% −€

L^/( ,? Ç:

 P 9 ®=
V A "31& pHO " 9/4 < 1%a de(
 
 

   

%I J7K HYW 7:= A,& ‡D HV (B I  V 3=

 P |& 9IVP ,de(
CE# ,˜g# 
V º CP ,,4 u H2  CB  3a _( Zj L^/ %I / (B
¬
”YVP  9L ( / ,D %I VL E/ =
 C4 DP 9 - < ,:H7/ ,9%1 =4B S%#
I `1%a f  %2/( Zc¨8  < H"
\H SVP 9 =
  CB I %I (B T; &
9M( _( ,h H %I SM8 j 1 ‡DSV(  V (B 3%  012 h : 
ZG€³)!%I V2„ 
2 _ bSM8 bM  /(\Vq : W § >‰

(B %I VL K J*  jJ7K %M  /(\VB .& ( O < &(
4.
== D ( =
1# ,%1( 7:=/ 9H=
 LH bH1 R e H4 %I «q
, 9 I=
V A `1%a –&V:P 'L c=
V < G€n)=7B Jƒ 3”/B  ;
 
7:; %I «B( %I VL E/ H17 CP –  HÄ  CP Zh
8 D P T;   C L7(
h MD HV L^ £BI : _ ”;W/“ ;:  ( ,”%I J7K HYW ”
ZA  9MD HV `1%a j=[ k%4  – º iVB #4 < h Œ^ h =(

:BC $ K ?DL9 # M 9  $N

L^/ =H 9L ,9MD HVq 9H=
 < T== :;> _ 1%a =H −n
/ 9/ iM A (. `1%a ko( =
 ,C(=1* /  =
_ ¸7B( A: ž
9 / h%ƒ L º -.  L %I >/ ; ] b %I >1 C(=1*
b &
V8 ™"W _ =H b %I [678 Ti
 "M (B I V\ c=s

_ iM  º < f*B 4 B < 
/7 i[  T= W 
&W 9 LB(
/ ,&( i:t CB  h [J2V 7q < j
 ,C(=1* / I ») ;=ž : >
(`@( %I > _ 3
 v
 i _ =H SVP %
#B S… HYW C(=1*
I ZG€€)GTH&W
j
 b( C(=1* / "7:; b %I > CP I %I &
V8 3-  (
pH¨  ;#q SVP( S— 012 b 8 b > (B %I > k%s  _
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

MB  3"%/  ”JW ²Æ P #eK/ i8  (B k1 2/: (B j= 2/: 3"%/

:H7( ;#q i8© ; M /  ( TH& |
( ,bSM8  3 CB
3"g C > 3( #=W( T W P A;© : … ;#B $/ .^%# ,3"17
<( ,9> B  B`Y 8 i`M 9V./ ; ^( ,Q>1 Rˆ ; ! C L S%
b‚ : … ( ,S— %I >U… < '( DP I ; 9%I >U… =
  c
†%( , HYW( ; $/ %I 77B %I ‚ @s (D "# > ;#B f= !~^
 c < " %# C(= P > ˜  <( ,r
# *t( ;# $/
3"g/ P > ;#B =^ A  "b> b  " ( ,%I >/ "b " 4
 4( 2W( #=W( S C L Πb " %I >/ " C(=1* / 9%H&  (
SVP " %I ># " ,4 %I >( I  $/ ':
()) C L œ+/( 9%1 pH·  B
/( Z >( k( i8   ( " c <  (B Q&/ j8 "  C L
j8( 1s  c < SVP 9V( , 9 
%
 8 h %«( h  B Q& DP " f C(=1*
9%1 =4© CB = S4 h /- †%(  ¢  : > "%# 2/ _ =%4.# ;G€x)GGZ
 ( Z 9 =V A 'L  < `1%a 7:; " ( ,I :S78 7:=
I 
 d> 
T=%( i[ "s / § > 1))  bH 9: > C./
L j=
 ==— 02W # /
W/ I ( \ 02 _ j
 A:S7 ig#
,r%W ,@ Q&/ T,@W [J( b&/ 
( \ =
V j " _ j

I = Q%Y& –V4 3%[ b / mD < h %I 17 –&% 3%[ b I (= 3%
#
#
- i/ j B 0 P – ¢  31( -= 02W Q%Y& = º %I 
Gۥ)ZGGZ;=
I
I U&V _ ,j
 0%H( b
%
 c-. −€
%I &
V8 I    

H" I f C4 AZG E.Pritchard) ;:^/ `V) " =[ S& %I V2„
I C./
 
 

   

3 V L… h a UI A bSM8 ! 1& 7:=/ “ bM  /(\Vq

%I V V
 iMK( ¸%& j ( /
 0&V( 1 j 4 %I SM 5&VB(
1 $/ [J 7:; QVM P iMK( 3   ,a( %I = ;(
< ,%I …( h  %… \4q %I &
V8   b(, G€Ÿ) Z5&Vq( 3 
CB `1%a ( D Z %I /:@W HYW 
  Â –V4 b ,%%&
b
#q pHYW  T I=H&W :L#q 1 0%2 < ,";^/ `VP":L#B 3"1&
< 
 _ 3
 9H%1[P( A(> pHYW k%s  < " "17 (¥ CB
I :%+ S&/ 9>%U^ ( 
 v[ pHYH4 '@W
7: (D jJ7K CP
44
3-Z%I ; 217 P T% 8O }/ 3=
 C(;   ¥   *( 1 4 %I P
T:g  jJ7K k[  9#; < j 1 1=/ : s 3=
 %I VL P / s
,@ b -= iM jJ7K _ Bƒ b ,@ HO DP ,S"%/ R“(
iM jJ7K _ Bƒ ,%@  =¥  C./ )):(— †  º( :ƒ
†% 9V./ d%s( ,GG r º jJ7K CB 8P J# h ,%@ =B 9V./ ,T:g
b= L ™ Cq c =  D( ," =%&W 9VP 8P -=1 h :=>
G€w)Z,&( 9M7  ,\4 %1¢ < T=%
4 †%( %Y"H4
I

_ "ƒ
7E/ j
 C4 b %I /@ %I MW  $ B C4 %V- %V 
 :L#q( 3%W    HO _ 4 `1%a =H D k1¦ p[(
= CB"¤/ j % f DP G€ª)= < ci:t( j %  u(~ 1¦ T;= :;>
`1%a f 9 h ( ,I ;=( G; M  T=() =%  TL# $/ dM:. pHYW <
I
< = 4 3"# J*  LH b :78 f [B  T: > c C./
%I J7K HYH1 %I ¯: 4 9/ `%   CB( ,h %¯: b J7K pHYW
P( G€y) "ZÊ
I ɚ sq jJ7K ]ƒ c¨ < (= !¢ = “ <
7:=  ,\4 < -B 9 C4 A h gB "„%# †4 " 3%W %I
%#  % 
–V4( ,=  =(   _ 9SB 4 –>V D %M  /(\V8( %I SM8
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

,mJ(. f=K (B ,%I %&H1 %I /·K  "7K C% ,(q :$- :& UI
,f*q V= Œ –H"7B b [ W C% {\ Z%I S7B ,> %L^ <
/4 < "    (;G€z)Z/(:(B ,a f*B 0ƒ < ,%I S7B ”(/ p <
 $
I L^/ 01W "=%1
" ”(/ Œ ˜7 b %I V&(„ 5J*q
h \  *B =[( ,;>[8
\= I ;>[8 T% u(: $/ [J D _ J
 e –V4 3-  ()ZGx³) %I L& %I V&(„ f= %I VJ
 5J*q $/(
-B  C L ] 7 b "%I `:L 21&" 9( < „%# f= ”/ =[ =
4
; M( 7B _ j
 ,„%# = 21& c"#, ?@W pHYH1 9%s  < `1%a <
 i8© 3L Œ pH b %I 6# ,I ;% ,a %I \7 s 1H ÁU…
iË  :(M =H& =[ b [:‰ 3m>/  ;
  p ;#q
ƒ7 / "  =[ b (B 34 Œ pH b %I ( f
/ ;
8 \ ,b%a
f*q 8YW k1¦ < (B ,'( < %W 9:>V ƒ7 / (B `YW
! L º DP |…J =[ 21& c \ L( ,Q^ ;#B ds < b b
,34 Œ pH b I ;%8 ,a (B [:‰ > s _ 8=  iË
T&( i%Vq ) :H^ 21& c ¸: _ G„%#) ;:  b 1\ q(
T
/ `%H ZZ;#q  3" W '`q }/ i7»:( ,: "^W T;
(
b 7=
 c _ bW j / ( 3%` ÁU^ 7=
W %I s‰ ( [:‰
ZGxn) G21& cŒ `%H ; (B M [:‰ H%
/ 3%1& P igq p#=
9 C4 ,*q 9Vq ; iM =
# ,Gjnznª−nyŸy) 3"4:(; % E/ c-.  I 
"M  ( ,"M  L 91·  ( pHYW T.^V ,& J*  ( »:
( Zb
2W L 5\V < pHYW :(; _ i g r%1& P f*B
I _ 3"4:(; =4© DP Z$%L…K $  uH4 = _ ,3"4:(;
CB
 
 

   

9J*  ( ,h %¨ h Y" 3"4:(; |I ,%I ‚ J\  %I = J\H
W %I = T% 7q/ –( ,%I V=% 7:;  /MK 1 §JU7
9/4 <( Z%I Hƒ 2 %I 7
2 7:SW h s >*( ,"%I =" HYW/ |H&
I 9[  3"4:(; „ , 9 @* QRG 9 #6 OP6
3 L^ = C./
4 I =  9&V < Hg" 3"4:(; AB: < =#, T:g 9%# =( A
ZGx€)"ZZZ%I SM8 T% "   k1¦ 5\V P ;I B b Ã

9/4 < "o  ( `%1a L# < HL ( TÌ –V4 %I MW 1
=& j :% p h   
/2 (q 1  < (= =[ ,'@W < jJ7K 
4:
3% ,bSM j  %I SM T; &H4
I jJ7K j=
 9 &# Z$H1&W $/
%I V V
 %2 D T; &W c( ZT% b V #4 b2@( %I 1%> 9%# jJ7K
LI ^ /( Zm"M W CDK( Πj`8 $H1&W  Q12 ,%I [J*q
 c,a  `%I H `1%a  V < jJ7K( Z7q  _ 9: s 3( pHYW
%I >U… (D ( ,9B _ 9=
 ( 9H% ˜# _ 9[ ( 9:=[ < C;q
,%@ ,C4  L LH 8 b 7 I=
W 9s >V < 9B #“  1
&
9%H&
/ G31&W pHYW) /4 < c=s: LH  4 ZŒ  (B  ¢ (B
I > < iM  (  e W < h ;= ΠC \ =s: DP A 
( (8
, S8 < ;=  `1%a  ]    ; ( %I
W f*q  > <
h #( h gB C4 =
# ,$%V2„ %M  /(\Vq iS1 ”/B  9IVB P #eK/ "#
O < 1  I `%1YVK 7:=H1 c=
V( c:  < / ( %I &1 9 "7E/
RSM8 31 7:; O < #( h ; "M `1%@ CE# ,D  J
h g# Z@1 &1#
"V:
( %7t r7( < T(=/ 9 S § >‰ 9M( _( ,Gh
/7) b%%# &
"# ,-= =/  ( -= g
/ `%H jS 9( Zh H r7(q 56 T(=/
9=M( 91*= –V4 S/:( ,=/ "[J < sU/( ,3”/B( ;
VI „4B 
 <( " -= =/  ( =( 
" : T,*q 94 f=P < =¼ „4B p
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

jJ7K 3"# V " 012 b » J*  0/& 9/4 p  L 'L
 
2 b(  W Hm( 6 ( ,–/\ _ =4© b » b(
,
12W %I /@ I &1 RDJ c=
V "%# j=
 CB  9&V –[  < |& , "#
"1\H  g#B C./ f b( ,*Í %I >[K %I [ -  %I  sq 4(
b J7K pHYW %­ / k> "#, {\ /L/ "   ( ,¸%& jJ7K
h %1*; c:2^V  jJ7K < J
h # %I «B \4q( A`4W j
W C L =[ " :
/
jJ7P( ,C(LW( iS1( i"
 %1 9#
- \H p%#: A UV jJ7P 
_ c=%4. „ 
  1¥ "# "Z %V= 9#
-   \® H A=[ A … 
 : "o( = 
 < jJ7K < %I 7%& %­  –/sB b ,@
h \H 31&W 34 3= A 2‰ C4 ": 
/ J
78
L( ‡ =V < J
:”© T;=^W %I = 
%
 _ Î _ “ %I % 4 :$
 $
I L& T„‰ 1 ( 1& ( ¼J ,3L %I D %I : %I 1ž HO 3;
A=
 CSK  h 1¦ h %#
- J
h L… T; < %I 1W HYW c –7:
b\=¢ L# $/ –‚ £q; \= 8  =s 9IVB |H/ "Z Gb^)
&7©W <  S4 j c:ƒE/ b6 L _ " #ž QVM  bJsP
"# œ+/( , i%(q( %I # > 52 <  S4 b^ jJ78 QVM  %I =
b…  :$- $/ R“  rHV  jJ7K *; “ RM:P =
I f( Z bH7: (
p%# A U jJ7K 0 :$2H $/ 5 C./
pH¨ DP :Y 
ƒ  h a i8© bH() I µ `4W < iS1( i"

|27  
21 %I %2 3%
(  %W †L( GT:Y( 31( #
\) :$/
,Vs( V”( ,=
( $V
/ =%
( ,j ) :3%
 c H^( %I V=W
bƒ ‡%8 < ]ÏK( I ,& 8  h ==… h : V ( 31(
6V _ T=&W I “ %I H& :S\7J ²W S78( Z {=M (
 
 

   

,I =%  %2 _ A U jJ7K  p%# º rH  ;=^ Z G=
 DP( Z    k1UH# %V= 9#
\/ b^ A=
 jJ78P (B j jJ7K  I B
˜aq /L H& ’%: L^/ D  "# /L( Ti
 ]
T ^( ,31  \4B TD ^ _ ;=^ ( #
\( 311 T;.4 †%( Z&
'L "# Gxx) Z j ( C V
/ =%
  \4B < > 'YV8( =M (
b( 6  Q1>( –/\ QV— _ =%4. < c:”©( (q
I 9/4 3=
(B ,&% TL" :
 ,c=YV  %I e  $V
( -= ˜: b
 j  Th ; & ®L^ jJ7K CB   :(= 'L   : H b I  
T;:P  1
&W ,`W( %I ”q =
   HO ; M(  „ 9Vq ,bSM
o W( T; M W =
 b( ,pHYH1 d%> j  ;=¢ b 6
 "&%4" P M b  ,%I ; %I  (B 
ƒ = < –&%( p%HY1 W(
ZGx•)" pHYW < "i"
" ; M(  b@1 CB C(;

S./ C=W <  ; 7 j

 =[(" :9
/ l:   q pM (
h «; h ,2* h ==m L^8 9IL; j~8( %/ | ¥ º 9%
# T;%[ –¢ Q@^
9%
# $/ k < HL ;=" A b
%
 2‰ H
 %I H7 21&1
_ %­ aƒ s ! –V4 Z I L& T
/ pH %I #ƒ [( j~8/ pH
jJ7P "HL¥ I `4 (; $/ TB`O
I (= –V4 DP jJ7K  %I L%7JL 

%I JsP : - £B m: - 4 k> œ+/( Z %I  T:;K/ pH ]ƒB( º
ZGxŸ)91>( $ ©H1 b[J*q ! 1& Sh ; d> o
I DP I :(; (B %I £ 8

‫ﺍﻟﻤﺒﺤﺚ ﺍﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ‬
‫ﺍﻟﻤﻮﺍﻗﻒ ﺍﻟﻨﻘﺪﻳﺔ ﻣﻦ ﺍﻟﻤﻨﻬﺞ ﺍﻻﻧﻘﺴﺎﻣﻲ ﻟﺪﻯ ﺇﺭﻧﺴﺖ ﻏﻴﻠﻨﺰ‬ () ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

 9/4 h s >*( cL# (V A `1%a –&V:P QL C4 =


7:= h  e C4 =[( %I H1 ²7(q < ]( jJ78# %M  /\V8
(ƒB ( "g# Z`1%a 9 =[   T== QV M –( ZT== ;
V(
Z7:=( =
/ %I 77q `1%a

(B `%I ¢ AB  Ä`V ” %I  e ” h :L#B "s / c:L#B ˜ `1%a (

I / ,"7:= b HYW _  ¢
 V4 $H1&W %M  /(\Vq iS1 }/ CP
$H"W( 9 $#=W [q _ (B 31&W AB1 ÃW ”/B  9V( I=

#W < : g 3; C4 `1%a CB ,"%«B i:+ c \W ·  ( !9#(=
 7:= ¸4 Q>W 91@… ( ,H"W %I /(:(q( %I V2„ %I 7%&
3"   ,jJ7K 7:=/ 9 S ”/P 3-  ( ‡=„H4  M < %I M  /(\Vq
9M( _ ‡=„ 4 l: <( h H %I M  /(\Vq 7:= l: < ­ @1
ZGxw) !§ >‰

:' OT −
Jƒ 9%# f A( ”jJ7K %— /(\V8 j "  “ 9
<
$H1&W l: I % ¨(
­ ¦ L^/ "7:= b %I L…K r&/ `1%a CB =7
I f ( ,%I 77q %I J7K § > p 3"1  %ƒ(
`1%a 9 I=[  C./
 4 3"s / $H1&W Q%I a  DP ,i  < H =
ÁV  T:
%I  V <   T;P ,:SgW  < =7B u~
( Z=
W Á 3% ±%(
I / =7B f( ,c V < `1%a 91Y A  q ,9 / b J7K '2‰
3B  C.
G&( Ct
)  I=
W Á _ bH4 A,& ;27 9VB '2‰  `%
h g#
%I 7%&( I ;>[8( %I SM8 [%&( ]( ( %I ¯: 0/ &  J
§ > p  %I 1H =  : q c   ( ,pHYW Œ H b
 
 

   

Z"  ( 7=

W

< %I &

V8 j "W $[6&W k%o  < c=
V _ =4© C./ ((
I _ =I4B  = `1%a 9%1 H7 A ( ?@W pHYW
31&W pHYW S7 CB
;"  A:%W 1%
 =#Z h =M 1¦ 3% -J- 7B _ %I  A=%1

Z ;%q < bH4:(; j "  =&Y `1%a S14 <( " $2/W( ±(:=
 H^ = j " CE#  1%sB( : %I  ( =
iÐ4 H" "1·(
c=YV  q( – =
H £ 4 : _ %I S— 
2 Ti[ P T:…K
 Z %I V L( %I SM8 %1 h ` : J
h %\  = :/ 34:(; = 4
0^ ( h %14 k1¦ "# µ i
# ; ks  H&W j "W <  I B
b(" = CB 7B _ D( =  †4:W T®LW /L  u e /
$/~@ ( 
& ,a( :(M C(=/ 3( »
# =H1 ": `1%a QL%# " k”
T(&
 P %H 3"[(D( '( (B 7S ( ‡ =V8  =  9V M¥  (
Z h gB C%&V  A( b= ]2 < ²UV p T:-K(

T==M =YV %I H%  h :L#B 9M V VE# I ” M„ ; P –1V S%  I B
 C L  =/B  A µ A” M„ CP": 
%# `1%a 01®  DP ,h gB
( ,31 _ j
 b f
 < 1[ W g( ,  88 5(
ZGxª) "I :Y 97: ( 9„4 p h &V¨ \4B 5(D 

( v
 – =  = < 1UW 52 c": =7 Jƒ 
 
1¦ ¹%s( i/ £P Z 9&V iÐ1 1¦ QV M ;O –&% b – Aµ

%
 %ƒ) :  1¦ e~# }#( ,1¦ i%…B j ®=
 CB (¢
–&% £E# ,Q& ( ,G %I #
\ {W :„ ( M%8  sB ( %I SM8
$/ C:
V 8 VE# "% T:…K = ( , i/ £PI / ,1¦ S=
 ;O
ZGxy)"Œ^
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

7:; < 9/   A b

%1 ' 17q `1%a _ =7B Q% 4
S7 %I %4 § >‰ 9M( _( ,9/4 < 9 =
 A %I
#B S^ HYW
–V4  S4 "1M( „%#( 34:(;( †4: = 9o(( = j "W `1%a
,Gxz) Z"%P bH b I    W  h =%/ m:7 LH 1> 3%
,%I 4D | (B Y ( T„ o < (= =[ b :78 1 pM:B L(
(:=W r%W p "½% C(;  "%o  3 s "
%
 < £BI 8P
'@ $/ %I SM8( %I #
\ ½%  R º L^/ "ƒ
7P 3
I / "'@W"
-
 s  Y%V †% b"# =7B Jƒ "^4 S4 m%M $ < "o S4 '@W(
 _ "ƒ
7P( "1
V 3 k1¦ pHO  T=  ™V ²
7P / ; %I V=% ':¨ =/
=7B "^4 S4 TÌ (:= 1 ` º DZ 9M¦( 9J*= < k1¦ pHO
i`Mq c Q&/ ;(ƒq HO  [ < ;;~V 1M 7:SW c Y%V( Z
Zm[%7  `W

:Q"+ M −
I f "# ,h   1¦ I (”  h [J2V `1%a =

(B `1%a ‡D HV C./
"7:; b %
#B S… < I (= HYW _ 5=> SVE# 5=s CP ,9(ƒB
!C(=1* / 9 I=[  _ "%P ,\L `1%a kg º b( C(=1* / sq <
<( Z-K ‡¥  B %I J7K HYW _ `1%a (ƒP 3%H 3-  (
I _ h =4© *+ 1 =  9e~ c=%/” j ®=
 p[ 
8 I (= HYW CB
56( b J7K º < "o f*B ]sB  ks (B i`M f 7 L^
( ”{S\ pHYW“ ‡D H4 j=
 5%&  <( Z§ >‰ 9M( _ r7(q
T%( 7( %I ƒ[(,/ `%H Q4 Aµ ¸%7( bSM j / `%I   pHO
\  97:= I  V ‡DSV j I=[ pHYW  \ CP d%s ZI4 I µ
 
 

   

A %7+ ‡VK ' 17B (B %I W HYW (B b[6 ;=78 HO
h g# ,9#J*(
c: s ;=  3a _( ,pHYW  \ B 7:; %I VL P  J
T`— HO #eP LH  %2/ ZI : ƒ„ P HO "s / ,9MDSV(
' M( ' M HO 4( ,k1UW bSM8 l:( i D %I /
b( ,%
#B( /(:(B( %7t < H1&W %I 1[q ( ,%7t r7( 4( %7t 5Æ
I : >V CB Q>  C4 S/: %I HO ‡DSV j ®=

j ®=
 CB LH `1%a ‡D HVB C./
I "  B: <( Z"%# T% ' 17B( "% J
§ >‰  < c=%/” i:t C./ h %1¢
7:; < T: >ž `1%a (ƒB ¨ £BI  91  4 –V4 CP( Zs
.
ZG•n)ZG•³) !%
#B S… HO
 :;U0# V
!W X , −
 /:@W $\  I =
 7:=  f*B  HO "o
$ =
,%
#B S… HO 7:= b &
V8 ‡D HV‹q %I Js _  e~
A  ‡D H %I Js j= _ %I SM8( %I ¯: 1\ q  == 3=
V <
h # A· C4  ,& 9%I [=> (B
_ `4 =
 C4 CP( ZHYW 1 < J
(;q _  JW 1  ( Z(ƒq HYH/ †%( 3%W( (;q
:%I +  JW
I / bV( :‡D HVq ²
7P −B
‡D HVq l# < –2
7 %I &
V8 CB
:ƒP < ;6/ `V  c”YV HL7( 07 S%# 9W 37: =[ 34:(; C4 A
Z[/ 
2 < b J7K pHYW  c`%  %I s >* 9 v%V pHO
I 07  P ]g :bSM8 Q~( b¯: = «P − '
}[ CB
"7:=/  [ b 
 p[( p }[  C % &
V8 9%# p[( A ”:
Zj b¯: "[%7  
 ># P 3Πf;B A  (
h g#( :%I L1W L…B «P −‡
'@78 _   CP D  J
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

%I L1W L…B %1¢ .&W 3«P b &

V8 |W A(D $\ f= ^=(
j V _ jJ7K ,-. < –  ==^ 3 D( ;%I 1
 HYW *;
Z%I L1W
=— .& _ %I &
V8 I   `4: S% :!~^W =— I  V =
V −;
S/ –\ p[ # Zh ,\4 ' > –VM / £E# 1%
 9 := A !~^W
Zh %1# h =M C L 8 =[ j `W !~^W =— CB
I ,'%:J h8O R= 8
I 07  $ :3%L |/ ƒ( C 2/W −¤
f >[ %I «B b2 `%1a C./
b 7:= }/ =% $ < ;1%
 C”  _ Î < %I 2/W &7©H1 
 I ?@W bSM8 l: 
 < `YVB
 ' M:  V4 i1> C./
C( „ C21& :”B =…( ; ;ÑP j"H/ C 1I L  V4 =
# ;(q M:=
ZQ%a~/  I B( Q%~/ , P CL& Rg*K $%1W C`UW v\ p

%I &
V8 I =
 97:; < Gnz•Ÿ =% ) "A; ¼ ¿ =" ( =[(
I k%4 $/ ;`1%a
=
/ | ¢ f„4 J ; M(  q 2 º ,*q  CB
H1L b( ":*B" ; "C:*" ¤¤¤/ C #(W 3( $(2 C=  ,L
h  V; 7 C(L¥  3 "C:* " ¤¤¤# Z j
 ,4É,L (B l%^
S&
 h o Q& ; I=¥" ::ƒK  < A; ¼ 
 Z3" 4( 3"&V [
"1¢ b j&
V8  &W( I 6  HYH1  " :/ %I SM8
Z":2^V8( :">V8 ²
 4(

%I 1
 “ Q&/ 9V./ A; ¼ D7q f “ § >U/  I B
‡ ;P 3%# f*B 1%[ _ (B :(;B _  1%[ š & CB =¥ TH&W
,i Y1 0 "gB d ( ;@  HYW He  / 1@W  HYW
];( Z"g*P 3 b 0ƒH1 T==M iS7B i2P ]2W I £ <( #%g(
 
 

   

Ò:B _ 3D 7( 3; M( %I Æ T`@ :„ ' 17q Œ " :J[ A; ¼
b  HYW  ‡:U1 &/ &VY T: s i2P C (¥ S4 ,I 

i1> " j "W `1%a k%o  –( b 2
 <( ,"3"%1
& “ p £ 1L^
I :A; ¼ ¿ = f"
T:=
/ C(`%H  V4 `1%a "7:; b (” i1s C./
I 
 P V· A iÐ A:g 
/  ;ÑP _ 1
"j4q" C./
$e:W 0 < %I ^( :”O h V%B Œ QL b 9 ‚ ;
 AL& 3%”
C./ 
 P / ]
  ( Z9&V C21& _ h 2* 9 bg A  q
­ a < V=
 <   ;”W S&
 $/ %I H%L 3:(;B( ,i1> W&
4 Z`1%a D ´8 S4 ,%I &
 : 
 #
I
:; A *& =— _ pÏ L^/( ™   I=/ 8  %2/
$#ƒ $/ ÊU^ bM  =K ( _ 3
( `1%a( =%7 ;:(;P $/
b   "M  bH7 "\HW" C L C./ ( S"%14 CB k%4 de  A(
< 2 (B   < `H@ *+/ 01 CB D < ‡ 8( , (B " =

Z( %I H1( #W 0H
I  3a _
$[6&W  3"&VB C(= 8 %M  /(\V8 iS1 CB
I  D Q7( ; i:;”/ $=%1
 $[6&W  C(   ha(
3":= CB
56 l:( ';t ( @) < 3":=  f [B %M  /(\V8 31 
 *;
4 ": 56&H1 =%7 ;:(;P k He  C 
 D p 3"LZG r7(q
5678 ] G•€) " 56 : B <  (B QL (B := 
® 9IVP 3- ,
" 56" $/ bM  H&/P ( bM  2VB 0 _ =H ,L1 h / 17B " 9s /
56 p  1 H  &7© I f( "'@" $/(
I "  T: 5678 C./
ZG•x)"9HL( / 9s(( 9H%1
I
„ b 8 $[6&W ™ _ 9H=
( ™"W f & < ]J*8 CE#
H= 21&/( 9/ "ƒ:( ,==— 5678/ "ƒ:  %M  /(\V8
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

_ H%( 9HL 3-  ( "&V *+ # _ H

 @(  1
'2‰ < H" I =YV  ,9:=

I VL C 1¥ ==— 5678 M: C./
%I 7%& %I /@ &7©W
I < H"
I VL J( %¨~78 37: < ?@
h H ==— 5678 H^ =%7 k C L C./ LH   ( Z %I H1(
,9 S ;=/ ] =
#, 5678/ ,4 ²: 9 M# ,s >* `1%a(
P "%# |& A 9/4 ' 17B( ,I VB T„V  1¯ 8 A 9/ 17B Q&/(
Œ %I [ -( T„/(, p[  ( P r
# †% (, 
&W _ ©( jLB ²
7P
%I H1 VLW :8  / V*B  DP( Z†/ ”`8( TB—  ,4 :=[ 
  H%[( f=s :=
V C./ 3"  34 4:;B ,`1%a 91@… A bH;4q Q>W(
Zh V%B %I > 98
(B 94 < i 7 i:t( :L#B  9e

=%7 ;:(;P SB( 5678 '4 < =

( =—  T,4 ƒ :-
I =%7 ;:(;P 3” CI P :9
/ ,`1%a –&V:P fB: =
# ,f*q
2%7 =[ '@ C./
%I VS\ I : ƒ„ K –V4 =
1# ,%&  B j €³³³  \4B T=W 56 _
G••)Z/(:(B _ h ,4 h 2* ®L^‹ A;J%W 6 p/& C
 *(B |

* R, Z ![ *
(1) http://mawdoo3.com/
Zy§ ,nz•w ,C= ZbÄ  b[ 7= =Hž QZ C %V2„ C [6&W ZA/:t ‡ Z G€)
Zn•−nn§, cnx•ª (8 p%/ ,i` ,CH l:( 56 31 ,A M ZBZj Gx)
wwwZalkottobZcom ,$%[6&W iS7 3Y ,; v 27 /
,n² ,b J7K :=W 6V ,>W ( ,-.( i ^– CW8 C [6&W ,=%& C e: G•)
Znn§ ,j€³³ª
 
 

   

(5) http://mawdoo3.com/
Z%#a -K *= ( %M  /(~Vq 1½7B :?@W k  1%[ ,a:( –B ,=” =Hž Gw)
,=%7 ;:(;  V( Zyz §, ? º %M  /(\VB < I   8YW ,=@1 /B _% Gª)
,nzyn ,(,/ ,n² ,%/ /q &7© ,Q; /B S4 %/  91
V ,5678
Z€wz §
,=%7 ;:(;  V( ,? º %M  /(\VB < I   8YW ,=@1 /B _% Gy)
Znzw § ,5678
bƒ  †1YW ,#W º ,C&V8 31 l: <  ># %M  /(\Vq >[ ,3%"# $& Gz)
Zny § ,jnzyw ,– L ,n² ,';+ ( C ( #
\1
`  ,T;O 
%
  h ; h , "s / %I Hƒ 2  9 V < Y% 34:(; : s
I =[ Gn³)
: §* ` :( ,"M  bHƒ 2 9K/ |H& W 7 &W %I M:‰ T: > b"#, $½%… P
9K CB 34:(; o 7q  _( ,f* "M  ^ b[/  `%  T,^1
T,^ = º 3-  ( ,"&V T,^  T,^ 9P CB AB, =( iË f 7 &% S—(
Z "&V = / h P
Z 
/7 7:;, %I /@W 1%
 § >U/ b &
V8 u2 ™V 3B ,’:;K b2 Gnn)
/ b@ = :‚ ,%/@W %7%& U ( %21W " $ ©W , B ,A: /( C M : V Gn€)
Z€³nx ,²/ ,n²,b@ &7© ,C(*( j`
(13) :‫( ونظر‬M iddelton (J)- Tait (D): 1958 ; Tribes without Rulers , Studies
in African Segmentary Systems ; London ; Mair (L) M 1962, Primitive
government.
Zj€³nŸ „H# V15 C; WZ, Ó:©W :   %I V&VK j 1 3% }/ ,¼ = Gn•)
I $ DP 9&V :=>W GnŸ)
r7(q – ,L †1ƒq [   G14 –&V:P) 7:;" :C./
 %I /@W 
 p[( :;  (B = A G:Z;) 91[( ,>B I (` %I  W
,†1ƒq/ G2 –t) :b [ -J- 7:=/ j[ % ;b &
V8 %1 ‡D HVB J*
`4: A G M C H:) ,*B( Zr7(q k/ Ga:( b/) ( ' —/ G4;)
01  q( ,b[6 k [ f=P _ ,"4„( ˜"   T,"^ 97:;
Z"%I 1[" 1%
/
−C=HW : , %I /@W 1%
 § >U/ b &
V8 u2 ™V 3B ,’:;K b2 Gnw)
³ª − • É € É €³n³ − €z³ª :;=
`%H b I%^  1W :œ+ L^/ I 6 l:    3%&
 ! :%I = Gnª)
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

%I V\ 1W( AY “ 8t S7( I „ V % (  _ ±%/
f
 < %I S— T%  R V( %I V=W 8+( :` : " / `%H b I /„
_…B:  VBZ /L # C&VK k^4  = B=/ b =HW 1W( Ì (
ZŸ•§ ,– L, #W º ,: > =Hž ‚ ,%I = , %aV
%I V=%W 7:=( bM  /(\Vq ™"W ,[
ƒ / !(„ Gny)
: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100006738151849
19 http://www.mominoun.com
h -. iM =[ %o ( bSM8 i 7:; V $%V2„ $%M  /(\V8 9M  CP
I G€³)
7:=W –"M  L( ZRSM8 31 %I &V 7:=W :L#./(   bY c¨8/
i( Social Systems %I SM8 5&Vq 7:; V %I V2„ 9%I M  /(\V8 :
 p 0/2 3= %I #
\ %M  /(\V8 j "  M  Social Structures %I SM8
b %I L q 7:=W ]J* _ Social Anthropology %I SM8 %M  /(\V8 j "
S4 %I SM8 %M  /(\V8( %I #
\ %M  /(\Vq $/ `%H % h #2 h [ ¡
< S4( bSM8 ! 1& 7:; «P( #
\ 7:; _ 3`%4  h %1M D (=
;¢ ,C&VK 31 P *= ,S… ’% : V Z  /( C "4J4( C  k: SB
Znw§ ,j€³³• ,0^ ; ,' 'L
" ©W  == 9 ,%I V2„   Y/ %M  /~V8 D7B :=7 Jƒ Z; G€n)
 :ž 9V 4  Jh g# C; & < ±%/L (=/  7:;( Z:S78 ( ,%M  /~V8
ZpHYW ( ;>[8 A:ž
„H# V nŸ Z ,Ó:©W :   %I V&VK j 1 3% }/ ,C; W C¼ = : V G€€)
Z¤¤7:; < j€³nŸ
Znx³§Zjnzyz, 31
 :;, (,/,  =
W, C(=1* / G€x)
Znz§ ,n ², (,/, ==— 5#8 :;, ? pHYW %I / %I >, {[ `` = G€•)
< : &%#(/ C4 Z%I SM8 %M  /(\V8  2 < 3"7B ,4 f`%1YV %M  /(\V º G€Ÿ)
H Zjnzª³ – nz•w 7  ~1YV Ö ;: &4(  M < %I SM8 %M  /(\V8
( A=V”q 1%[  9H" / ( 7:; H Zj nzx€ 7 T
  M < h Ìž
%
# Ö  
 
 

   

. https://arz.wikipedia.org/wiki
−³•−j€³nŸ ,`1%a –&V:t (ƒB i e < É= %M  /(\V( %I [ %I >U^ 52
http://www.baytalhikma.iq/News_Print.php?ID=302 :€€
(27) Hume ,A Treatise of Human Nature .Edited by LA Selted-Bigge (Oxford:the
Clarendon pres,1896.
,n² ,C% 1O ,%(  =
==— 5678   ,b%  ¼ = / ¿= G€y)
Zn³Ÿ § ,¤n•xŸ ,˜
,n² ,I “W LW ,%I S7 sB < ;gW  ( „%# †4 ,1% v : V G€z)
Zj€³³• ,I :=L7K
iSV8 `4 ,=1
v =Hž ,‚ ,%I S7 u(:( %I V&(„ 5J*q ,„%# †4 Gx³)
:
Zn€§,(,/ ,n² ,b

(31) 2-J. Beckford, Religion and Advanced Industrial Society (London: Unwin-
Hyman, ‫م‬1989(p:32.
(32) LaCapra D., (2001), Emile Durkheim. Sociologist and Philosopher, Aurora,
Colorado: The Davies Group, Second Ed., p. 236
Z (,/ ,n² ,6( 21 f=W :; ,-= =/  ( =( 
 ,`1%a ,–&V: Gxx)
:;[/ =¼B L/ /B ‚ 1%a –&V:q 31& pHO 'L ˜ :²(»V:q j =Hž Gx•)
Z /(~V:B p[ ,j€³³Ÿ
x•§ ,-= =/  ( =( 
 ,`1%a ,–&V: GxŸ)
:;[/ =¼B L/ /B ‚ 1%a –&V:q 31& pHO 'L ˜ :²(»V:q j =Hž Gxw)
Z /(~V:B p[ ,j€³³Ÿ
L/ / ‚( ¢  {\ > He ,jJ7K %M  /(\V TL# ,=7 Jƒ : V Gxª)
ZŸx−•z § ,j€³³Ÿ ,(,/ ,n² ,A; :; ,jJ7K %M  /(\V ,:;[/ =¼B
Zª•−ª³ ,9&V :=>W Gxy)
:;[/ =¼B L/ /B ‚ 1%a –&V:q 31& pHO 'L ˜ ,²(»V:q j =Hž Gxz)
Z /(~V:B p[ ,j€³³Ÿ
Z1%a –&V:q 31& pHO 'L ˜ ,²(»V:q j =Hž G•³)
 ,\ > He ,? º %M  /(\VB < I   8YW ,=@1 /B _% G•n)
,(,/ ,n² ,A; :; ,jJ7K %M  /(\V ,:;[/ =¼B L/ / ‚( ¢
() ! *+ , $&
&'
  !!"#$%

−yŸ§,€³³Ÿ
,=%7 ;:(;  V( Zyz §, ? º %M  /(\VB < I   8YW ,=@1 /B _% G•€)
Z€wz § ,5678
Z >( :=>W †V G•x)
http:ÉÉalmadasupplementsZcomÉnewsZ º "M Ö k
\ ZZ=%7 ;:(;P G••)

***
: