Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cosmic Collisions The Hubble Atlas of Merging Galaxies PDF
Cosmic Collisions The Hubble Atlas of Merging Galaxies PDF
Gi`ek\[feXZ`[$]i\\gXg\i%
0/.-,+*)(
jgi`e^\i%Zfd
QFFD@E>@EFE8IG/.@EJ@;<=IFEK:FM<I
Kf^`m\Xe`dgi\jj`fef]k_\jZXc\f]k_\dXep?lYYc\`dX^\j`ek_`jYffb_\i\n\j_fnXÈqffdÉfe8ig/.%K_\Ôijk`dX^\c\]k j_fnjk_\]lccZfejk\ccXk`fef]C\fXjkXb\en`k_X
i\^lcXiZXd\iX%K_\j\Zfe[`dX^\d`[[c\ j_fnjXÔ\c[f]m`\n]ifdk_\;`^`k`q\[JbpJlim\pZ\ek\i\[fe8ig/.%K_\k_`i[`dX^\i`^_k j_fnjX?lYYc\`dX^\f]8ig/.#ifl^_cp
)%*XiZ$d`elk\jXZifjj(&),[\^i\\ %@k`j\m`[\ekk_Xk?lYYc\Ëjm`\n`jm\ipeXiifnXe[k_XkfecpjdXccXi\Xjf]k_\jbpZXeY\`dX^\[XkXepfe\k`d\%8ig/.`jXjklee`e^gX`if]
`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\j%JkXij#^Xj#Xe[[ljkÕfn]ifdk_\cXi^\jg`iXc^XcXop#E>:*/'/k_\cXi^\if]k_\knf^XcXo`\j niXgg`e^Xe\em\cfg`e^XidXifle[`kjZfdgXe`feE>:*/'/8
XYfm\%E>:*/'/`jXe\Xicp]XZ\$fejg`iXc^XcXopn`k_XYi`^_ki`e^f]jkXi]fidXk`feXe[j\m\iXcgifd`e\ek[ljkXidj%E>:*/'/8`jXjg`iXc^XcXopj\\e\[^\$feXe[`jjliifle[\[
YpXifkXk`e^i`e^k_XkZfekX`ejjkXijXe[`ek\ijk\ccXi^XjZcfl[j%K_\i`e^`jg\ig\e[`ZlcXikfk_\gcXe\f]k_\_fjk^XcXop[`jbXe[`jZXcc\[XÈgfcXii`e^%ÉK_\j_Xg\jf]Yfk_^XcXo`\j
_Xm\Y\\e[`jkfik\[Ypk_\`i^iXm`kXk`feXc`ek\iXZk`fe%8ig/.`jXggifo`dXk\cp*''d`cc`fec`^_k$p\XijXnXp]ifd<Xik_%8j`jXcjfj\\e`efk_\ij`d`cXi`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\j#k_\Zfib$
jZi\nj_Xg\f]k_\k`[XcdXk\i`Xcjl^^\jkjk_XkjkXijXe[^Xj[iXne]ifdk_\cXi^\i^XcXop_Xm\Y\\eZXl^_k`ek_\^iXm`kXk`feXcglccf]k_\jdXcc\ife\%
K?<K8;GFC<>8C8OP@EJ@;<98:B:FM<I
8^X`ejkXjklee`e^YXZb[ifgf]k_fljXe[jf]^XcXo`\j#k_`jf[[$cffb`e^^XcXopn`k_Xe\efidfljk`[Xcjki\Xd\if]jkXijXgg\XijkfY\iXZ`e^k_ifl^_jgXZ\#c`b\XileXnXpg`en_\\c
Ôi\nfib%;lYY\[k_\ÈKX[gfc\#Ék_`jjg`iXc^XcXop`jlec`b\k_\k\okYffb`dX^\jf]jkXk\cp^XcXo`\j%@kj[`jkfik\[j_Xg\nXjZXlj\[YpXjdXcc`ek\icfg\i#Xm\ipYcl\#ZfdgXZk^XcXop
m`j`Yc\`ek_\lgg\ic\]kZfie\if]k_\dfi\dXjj`m\KX[gfc\%K_\KX[gfc\i\j`[\jXYflk+)'d`cc`fec`^_k$p\XijXnXp`ek_\Zfejk\ccXk`fef];iXZf%
Gi\]XZ\ .
( >XcXo`\j1K_\9`^G`Zkli\ 0
) ?fn;f>XcXo`\j=fidXe[<mfcm\6 +(
* >XcXop:fcc`j`fej ,*
+ K_\:fcc`[`e^>XcXo`\jDfm`\ .(
, K_\<e[ 0(
- >Xcc\ip 00
K_\8lk_fij (*-
I\jfliZ\j (*/
@dX^\:i\[`kj (*0
8dfe^k_\dfjk]XjZ`eXk`e^Xe[[iXdXk`Z\m\ekjk_Xk?lYYc\_XjY\\eXYc\kfj_fn`e_`^_i\jfclk`feXi\k_\
Zfjd`ZZfcc`j`fejY\kn\\e^XcXo`\j%K_\j\^`^Xek`Z\eZflek\ijZi\Xk\g_\efd\eXk_Xk^`m\i`j\kfjkiXe^\]\Xkli\j
`emfcm`e^Zcljk\ijYlijk`e^n`k_e\njkXij#kn`jk`e^cXe\jf]^XjXe[[ljk#Xe[k`[XckX`cj\ok\e[`e^fm\i_le[i\[j
f]k_fljXe[jf]c`^_k$p\Xij%
K_\ `dgfikXeZ\ f] k_\j\ Zfjd`Z \eZflek\ij i\XZ_\j ]Xi Y\pfe[ k_\ X\jk_\k`Z ?lYYc\ `dX^\j n\ gi\j\ek _\i\%
K_\j\Zfcc`j`fejdXpY\jfd\f]k_\dfjk`dgfikXekgifZ\jj\jj_Xg`e^k_\le`m\ij\n\`e_XY`kkf[Xp%:fcc`[`e^
^XcXo`\jm\ipc`b\cp_fc[jfd\f]k_\dfjk`dgfikXekZcl\jkffli^XcXZk`ZXeZ\jkipXe[kffli[\jk`ep%@kefnj\\dj
Zc\Xik_Xkk_\^XcXopn\Xccc`m\`e#k_\D`cbpNXp#`jjk`ccZfek`elfljcple[\i^f`e^d\i^`e^\m\ekj#Yfk_dXafiXe[
d`efi#Xe[k_Xkk_`jgifZ\jj`jdlZ_dfi\`dgfikXek`ek_\c`m\jf]^XcXo`\jk_Xegi\m`fljcpk_fl^_k%
?lYYc\Ëj`dX^\jXi\jeXgj_fkj`ek`d\Xe[_Xm\ZXl^_kk_\`e[`m`[lXcjkX^\jf]`ek\i^XcXZk`ZZfcc`j`fej%K_\j\[`]$
]\i\ekjkX^\jZXeY\glkkf^\k_\i`ekfXdfm`\:_Xgk\i+ j_fn`e^_fnk_\j\dfeld\ekXcZfcc`j`fejgif^i\jj%
@ek_`jYffb#n\n`cc^`m\XYi`\]Xe[lg$kf$[Xk\`ekif[lZk`fekfk_\c`m\jf]^XcXo`\jÇ_fnk_\pn\i\Yfie#\mfcm\
fm\ik`d\#Xe[Zfcc`[\Çlj`e^k_\Y\jkg`Zkli\jkXb\eYpk_\?lYYc\JgXZ\K\c\jZfg\%DXepf]k_\j\`dX^\jXi\
]ifdX_l^\`em\jk`^Xk`fef]cld`eflj`e]iXi\[^XcXo`\jZXcc\[k_\>F8CJgifa\Zk>i\XkFYj\imXkfip8cc$jbpC@I>
Jlim\p#^fXcj%`gXZ%ZXck\Z_%\[l %K_\?lYYc\fYj\imXk`fejn\i\c\[Yp8XifeJ%<mXej]ifdJkfep9iffbLe`m\ij`kp
L%J% %
N\nflc[c`b\kfk_Xeb9`ccB\\c]figifm`[`e^`ejg`iXk`feXe[X[m`Z\#Xe[n\Xi\^iXk\]lckf_`d]fij_Xi`e^_`j
[\\gbefnc\[^\f]k_\Ô\c[%8XifeJ%<mXejXe[k_\>F8CJk\XdXi\kfY\k_Xeb\[]fikXb`e^k_\XdXq`e^?lYYc\
[XkXk_XkdX[\k_\j\m`jkXjgfjj`Yc\#Xe[DXlipJfcfdfeXe[?Xiip9cfd]ifdJgi`e^\i]fikXb`e^fek_`jgifa\Zk%
K_Xebj Xcjf kf :fcc\\e J_Xib\p# ?\ei`b Jgffe Xe[ 9fY =fjYlip ]fi mXclXYc\ [`jZljj`fej Xe[ jl^^\jk`fej kf k_\
k\ok%
CXijC`e[Y\i^:_i`jk\ej\e#IXhl\cPld`J_`[X;Xm`[\;\DXik`e
Dle`Z_Xe[M\e`Z\#(DXiZ_)''0
K _`jYffb`jXYflk`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\j#Ylkn_Xk`jX^XcXop6K_\^XcXopn\befnY\jk
`j#efkjligi`j`e^cp#k_\fe\n\c`m\`eÇk_\D`cbpNXp%=ifdflimXekX^\gf`ek`ej`[\
fli^XcXop#`k`j[`]ÔZlckkf_Xm\XZc\Xi`[\Xf]_fnk_\D`cbpNXpd`^_kcffb]ifdk_\
flkj`[\%DXgg`e^k_\D`cbpNXp`jdlZ_c`b\kip`e^kfdXgXZifn[\[#]f^^pZ`kp]ifd
Xj`e^c\mXekX^\gf`ek`ej`[\k_\dlib%@kkffb_ldXeb`e[Xcfe^k`d\kf\jkXYc`j_k_\
\o`jk\eZ\ f] k_\ D`cbp NXp Xe[ kf i\Zf^e`q\ Xe[ XZbefnc\[^\ k_\ \o`jk\eZ\ f] fk_\i
^XcXo`\j`ek_\le`m\ij\%
;`jZfm\ipf]k_\D`cbpNXp
@]pfl_Xm\\m\i_X[k_\fggfikle`kpkffYj\im\k_\e`^_kjbp]ifdXgcXZ\n`k_flkc`^_k
gfcclk`fe# pfl n`cc Z\ikX`ecp _Xm\ efk`Z\[ i\^`fej n_\i\ k_\ ZfeZ\ekiXk`fe f] jkXij `j
_`^_\iÇcffb`e^c`b\XZ_XcbpYXe[Zifjj`e^k_\jbpY\_`e[k_\jkXij%N_\ej\\e]ifdX
i\Xccp[Xibj`k\#k_\D`cbpNXp`jfe\f]k_\dfjkXdXq`e^[`jgcXpjf]eXkli\%
@eXeZ`\ekk`d\jk_\i\nXjefjZ`\ek`ÔZ\ogcXeXk`fe]fik_`jZ_XcbpYXe[%K_\M`b`e^jjXn
`kXjXifX[nXcb\[Ypk_\[\X[kfi\XZ__\Xm\e2]fik_\@eZXj`knXjXi`m\i]ifdn_`Z_
k_\ n\Xk_\i ^f[ 8gl @ccXgl [i\n nXk\i kf dXb\ iX`e2 k_\ <^pgk`Xej k_fl^_k `k nXj X
^i\Xki`m\i`ek_\jbpfiÈk_\E`c\`ek_\?\Xm\e%ÉK_\D`cbpNXpkXb\j`kjeXd\]ifdk_\
CXk`eL_WBWYj[W#`eklie[\i`m\[]ifdk_\>i\\b'ALAXIA6>XcXo`Xj %@e>i\\bdpk_fcf^p#
?\id\j#k_\d\jj\e^\if]k_\^f[j#Xkk\dgk\[kfdXb\k_\`e]Xek?\iZlc\j`ddfikXcYp
c\kk`e^_`djlZbc\Xkk_\Yi\Xjkf]k_\jc\\g`e^^f[[\jj?\iX#Ylk?\iXnfb\Xe[k_iljk
k_\YXYpXnXp#k\Xi`e^_\iYi\Xjk]ifdk_\YXYpËjdflk_#jfk_Xk_\id`cbjglik\[XZifjj
k_\jbpkf]fidk_\D`cbpNXp%
<XicpjZ`\ek`jkjZflc[efkgcXZ\k_\D`cbpNXp`ek_\`infic[m`\n#jfk_\pk\e[\[kf`^$
efi\`k%K_\Ôijkkf^\kZcfj\kfk_\kil\eXkli\f]k_\D`cbpNXpnXjk_\@kXc`Xe>Xc`c\f
>Xc`c\`#n_ffYj\im\[`kk_ifl^__`je\ncp`em\ek\[k\c\jZfg\`e(-'0Xe[(-('%?\nXj
'&
gifYXYcpk_\Ôijkg\ijfekfefk`Z\k_Xkk_\gXkZ_\j`ek_\D`cbpNXpn\i\]fid\[]ifd
dXepjkXijk_XkXi\XggXi\ekcpm\ipZcfj\kf\XZ_fk_\i#efk`e^`eI_Z[h[kiDkdY_kik_Xk
k_\D`cbpNXpnXjÈdej^_d]ej^[hj^WdWcWiie\_ddkc[hWXb[ijWhiiYWjj[h[Z_dYbkij[hi%É
?fn\m\i#efk\m\e>Xc`c\f]lccple[\ijkff[k_\`dgc`ZXk`fejf]_`j[`jZfm\ip#Xe[_\[`[
efk kip kf \ogcX`e ]lik_\i k_\ jkiXe^\ Xe[ le\m\e [`jki`Ylk`fe f] k_\ jkXij XZifjj k_\
jbp%
K_\Ôijkg\ijfekfkipkfÔe[Xe\ogcXeXk`fenXjk_\<e^c`j_XdXk\liXjkifefd\iK_fdXj
Ni`^_k%@e(.,'Ni`^_kglYc`j_\[XYffb`en_`Z__\\ogcX`e\[k_\Xgg\XiXeZ\f]k_\
D`cbpNXpXjÈWdefj_YWb[\\[YjZk[jeekh_cc[hi_ed_dm^WjbeYWbboWffhen_cWj[ijeW
ÔWjbWo[he\ijWhi%É
K_\^i\Xkg_`cfjfg_\i@ddXel\cBXekkffblgNi`^_kËj`[\XXe[\cXYfiXk\[fe`k%@e_`j
Yffb#k_\Kd_l[hiWbDWjkhWb>_ijehoWdZJ^[ehoe\>[Wl[d#ni`kk\e`e(.,,#_\Xii`m\[Xk
X jligi`j`e^cp XZZliXk\ g`Zkli\% BXek Y\c`\m\[ k_Xk k_\ D`cbp NXp nXj X cXi^\ ÕXk [`jb
f] jkXij n`k_ X Z\ekiXc Ylc^\% BXek Xcjf k_fl^_k k_Xk k_`j _l^\ jpjk\d _X[ kf Y\ aljk
''
'(
D\Xjli`e^Xe[N\`^_`e^k_\D`cbpNXp
K_\D`cbpNXp`jXi\XjfeXYcpcld`efljjg`iXcjpjk\dXe[ZfekX`ejknfkf]fli_le[i\[
Y`cc`fejkXij#dXepc`b\flifneJle%N\ZXefecpj\\k_\e\Xi\jkfiYi`^_k\jk-#'''f]
k_\dn`k_flileX`[\[\p\jY\ZXlj\n\ZXeefkj\\k_ifl^_k_\Zcfl[jf][ljkXe[^Xj
k_Xkg\imX[\k_\D`cbpNXpXe[YcfZbk_\c`^_k]ifddfi\[`jkXekjkXij%8ck_fl^_knf
_le[i\[Y`cc`fe`jXeXcdfjk`eZfeZ\`mXYc\eldY\i#`k`jfecpk_\Y\^`ee`e^%8jkifefd\ij
Y\c`\m\k_\i\Xi\dfi\k_XeX_le[i\[Y`cc`fe^XcXo`\j`ek_\le`m\ij\%
K_\dXjjf]k_\jkXij`ek_\D`cbpNXp`jk_fl^_kkfY\XYflk+''Y`cc`fejfcXidXjj\j%
?fn\m\i#\m\edfi\dXjj`jgifYXYcp_`[[\e`ek_\]fidf][XibdXkk\ij\\Yfofe
gX^\+. #jgi\X[i\cXk`m\cp\m\ecp`ekfX[XibdXkk\i_Xcfn`k_Xkc\XjkXeX[[`k`feXc
'*
-'' Y`cc`fe jfcXi dXjj\j% K_\i\ `j X Zfej`[\iXYc\ leZ\ikX`ekp `e k_`j \jk`dXk\# n_`Z_
jk\dj]ifdk_\[`]ÔZlckpXjkifefd\ij_Xm\`ed\Xjli`e^k_\dXjjf]Xdpjk\ipfYa\Zk
f]lebefne\ok\ekXe[Zfek\ekXkX[`jkXeZ\f]_le[i\[jf]k_fljXe[jf]c`^_k$p\Xij%
K_\m`j`Yc\gXikf]k_\D`cbpNXp^XcXopd\Xjli\jXYflk(''#'''c`^_k$p\XijXZifjjXe[
`jXYflk(#'''c`^_k$p\Xijk_`Zb%K_`j`jÇdfi\fic\jjÇ`ek_\jXd\gifgfik`fejXjXe
fc[$]Xj_`fe\[CGm`epc[`jb%K_\D`cbpNXp_XjXZ\ekiXcYlc^\jfd\('#'''kf()#'''
c`^_k$p\Xijk_`Zb#Xe[k_\n_fc\_l^\Yf[p`jifkXk`e^%
FliJle#Xcfe^n`k_`kjjdXccjpjk\df]gcXe\kj#dffej#[nXi]gcXe\kj#Xjk\if`[j#Xe[
Zfd\kj#c`\j`ek_\jfZXcc\[Fi`fe8id#jfd\)-#'''c`^_k$p\Xij]ifdk_\Z\ek\i%
Kf^X`ejfd\`[\XXYflkk_\j_\\ij`q\f]k_\D`cbpNXp#`dX^`e\XjZXc\df[\cn_\i\
(Zd`j\hlXckf('d`cc`febd%Fek_`jjZXc\#k_\Jlenflc[Y\k_\j`q\f]X^iX`ef]i`Z\#
Xe[<Xik_nflc[Y\Xd`ZifjZfg`Zjg\Zbf][ljkXYflk(,Zd]ifdk_\Jle%K_\n_fc\
JfcXiJpjk\dnflc[Y\aljk()d\k\ij`e[`Xd\k\i#Xe[k_\e\Xi\jkjkXi#Gifo`dX:\ekXli`#
nflc[Y\Xefk_\ii`Z\^iX`eXkX[`jkXeZ\f]+'bd%9lkfek_`jjZXc\#k_\D`cbpNXpËj[`jb
nflc[_Xm\X[`Xd\k\if]Xd`cc`febd%8jg\Zbf][ljke\XiXi`Z\^iX`e`eX[`jbfe\Xe[
X_Xc]k`d\j^i\Xk\ik_Xek_\DffeËjfiY`kÇk_XkËjfligcXZ\`ek_\D`cbpNXp
Fe\f]k_\dfjkjligi`j`e^]XZkjXYflk^XcXo`\j`j_fn\dgkpk_\pXi\%N\_Xm\j\\e
k_XkjkXijpjk\djjZXc\kfk_\j`q\f]i`Z\^iX`ej#j\gXiXk\[Ypk\ejf]\dgkpb`cfd\k\ij#
Ylkc\kljdXb\Xefk_\i`dX^`eXip\og\i`d\ek#jZXc`e^jfk_Xkk_\n_fc\JfcXiJpjk\d`j
efnk_\j`q\f]XjdXcc^iX`ef]i`Z\%@dX^`e\Zfcc\Zk`e^Xcck_\dXkk\i`ek_\D`cbpNXp`e
Xj`e^c\jg_\i\n`k_k_\jXd\[\ej`kpXjk_\Jlen`k_flknfiip`e^XYflk_fn`kZflc[
Y\[fe\#c\kXcfe\n_fnflc[[f`kÇk_`j`jk_\afpf]k_fl^_k\og\i`d\ekj% K_\ek_`j
jg_\i\# dX[\ lg f] ifl^_cp (#''' Y`cc`fe Jlej# nflc[ _Xm\ X [`Xd\k\i f] fecp X c`kkc\
dfi\k_Xekn`Z\k_\[`jkXeZ\f]k_\JlekfGclkf#fi(,Y`cc`febd%K_\[`Xd\k\if]k_\
D`cbpNXpefn\dgkp nflc[Zfii\jgfe[kfk_\[`jkXeZ\Y\kn\\eD`cXeXe[Kli`e`e
@kXcp(+'bd#fialjkfm\iXe_fliYpZXi %>XcXo`\jXi\m\ip\dgkp`e[\\[%
'+
K?<G@EN?<<C>8C8OP
K_\^`^Xek`ZG`en_\\c>XcXop
D\jj`\i('( #fe\f]k_\
Y\jkbefne\oXdgc\jf]
È^iXe[[\j`^ejg`iXcj#ÉXe[
`kjjlg\i^`XekjkXi$]fid`e^
i\^`fej%K_\^`Xekjg`iXc[`jb
f]jkXij#[ljk#Xe[^Xj`j
(.'#'''c`^_k$p\XijXZifjj#fi
e\Xicpkn`Z\k_\[`Xd\k\if]
D@CBPN8PD8G
fliD`cbpNXp%K_\^XcXop`j
K_`j`ccljkiXk`fei\gi\j\ekjk_\jkilZkli\f]fliD`cbpNXpXj`k`jbefnekf[Xp%K_\D`cbpNXpËj[`]]\i\ekjg`iXc
\jk`dXk\[kfZfekX`eXkc\Xjk
XidjXe[`kjZ\ekiXcYXiXi\j\\e`ep\ccfn %K_\cfZXk`fef]k_\Jle`jdXib\[XjX^i\\e[fk%
fe\ki`cc`fejkXij%8ggifo`$
dXk\cp(''Y`cc`fef]k_\j\
jkXijXcfe\d`^_kY\c`b\fli
Jle`ek\idjf]k\dg\iXkli\
Xe[c`]\k`d\%?lYYc\Ëj_`^_
i\jfclk`fei\m\Xcjd`cc`fejf]
k_\^XcXopËj`e[`m`[lXcjkXij
`ek_`j`dX^\%
',
Fk_\i@jcXe[Le`m\ij\j
Lek`c k_\ kn\ek`\k_ Z\eklip# k_\ D`cbp NXp nXj Zfej`[\i\[ kf Y\ k_\ n_fc\ le`m\ij\%
FYj\imXk`fej[`[j_fnjfd\jkiXe^\jg`iXce\YlcX\jZXkk\i\[`ek_\jbp#jlZ_Xjk_\Ki`$
Xe^lcld>XcXop#k_\G`en_\\c>XcXopgX^\(. #Xe[fk_\ij#YlkXjkifefd\ijZfej`[\i\[
k_Xkk_\j\jg`iXce\YlcX\n\i\aljkj`dgc\^Xj\fljfYa\Zkj`ej`[\k_\D`cbpNXp%
<Xicp`ek_\kn\ek`\k_Z\eklip#k_`e^jY\^XekfZ_Xe^\#Xe[jfd\Xjkifefd\ijY\ZXd\
Zfem`eZ\[ k_Xk BXek nXj i`^_k Xe[ k_\ jg`iXc e\YlcX\ n\i\ j\gXiXk\ `jcXe[ le`m\ij\j#
fk_\i D`cbp NXpj% K_\ Zfekifm\ijp c\[ kf Xe _`jkfi`ZXc [\YXk\ fe ÈK_\ JZXc\ f] k_\
Le`m\ij\ÉXdfe^Xjkifefd\ij%K_\È>i\Xk;\YXk\#ÉXj`kY\ZXd\befne#kffbgcXZ\fe
8gi`c )-# (0)'# `e k_\ 9X`i[ Xl[`kfi`ld f] k_\ Jd`k_jfe`Xe Dlj\ld f] EXkliXc ?`jkf$
ip`eE\nPfib%K_\>i\Xk;\YXk\nXjXi^lXYcpXj`dgfikXekkfflinfic[m`\nXj#]fi
`ejkXeZ\#jfd\f]k_\[`jZfm\i`\jdX[\Ypk_\\ogcfi\ijXkj\X`ek_\j\m\ek\\ek_Z\e$
klipÇXZc\Xi\oXdgc\f]_ldXe`kpjkil^^c`e^kfÔe[`kjgcXZ\n`k_`ek_\Zfjd`Zfi[\i%
K_\c`e\jn\i\[iXneXe[k_\ZfdYXkXekj`egcXZ\#\XZ_Xid\[n`k_\m`[\eZ\k_Xk#[l\
kfk_\jkXkljf]fYj\imXk`fejXkk_\k`d\#XkY\jknflc[Y\]iX^d\ekXipXe[Xknfijk
gcX`enife^%Fefe\j`[\#?XicfnJ_Xgc\p#fe\f]k_\dfjkefkXYc\Xjkifefd\ijf]_`j
k`d\#Xi^l\[`e]Xmfif]k_\D`cbpNXpY\`e^k_\\ek`i\kpf]k_\le`m\ij\%?\Zfii\Zkcp
glkk_\JfcXiJpjk\dflkj`[\k_\Z\ek\if]k_\D`cbpNXp#YlkY\c`\m\[k_Xkjpjk\djjlZ_
Xj8e[ifd\[XXe[k_\fk_\ijg`iXce\YlcX\n\i\aljke\XiYp^XjZcfl[jXe[j`dgcpgXik
f]k_\D`cbpNXp%?\ZcX`d\[k_Xk`]8e[ifd\[XXe[k_\fk_\ie\YlcX\n\i\efkgXikf]
k_\D`cbpNXp#k_\ek_\[`jkXeZ\kfk_\dnflc[Y\XjdlZ_Xj_le[i\[jf]d`cc`fejf]
c`^_k$p\XijÇXÔ^li\k_XkdfjkXjkifefd\ijf]k_\k`d\]fle[gi\gfjk\iflj%
?\Y\i;%:lik`j#Xefk_\igifd`e\ekXjkifefd\i#]fik_\fk_\ij`[\#ZcX`d\[k_Xk8e[ifd$
\[XXe[fk_\ijlZ_e\YlcX\n\i\j\gXiXk\^XcXo`\j#fiÈ`jcXe[le`m\ij\j%É?\jlggfik\[
_`jXi^ld\ekjn`k_fYj\imXk`fejj_fn`e^k_Xkk_\i\n\i\dfi\efmX\`e8e[ifd\[X
k_Xe `e k_\ D`cbp NXp% N_p nflc[ k_\i\ Y\ dfi\ efmX\ `e fe\ jdXcc j\Zk`fe f] k_\
^XcXop k_Xe k_\ fk_\ij6 K_`j jlggfik\[ k_\ `[\X f] 8e[ifd\[X Xj X j\gXiXk\ ^XcXop#
'.
[`]]\i\ek`eX^\]ifdk_\D`cbpNXpXe[n`k_`kjfneiXk\f]fZZlii\eZ\f]efmX\%:lik`j
gi\j\ek\[fk_\i\m`[\eZ\#jlZ_Xjk_\[XibcXe\j]fle[`efk_\i^XcXo`\j#Xe[Xi^l\[k_Xk
k_\pn\i\j`d`cXikfk_\[ljkZcfl[j]fle[`eflifneD`cbpNXp%
K_\gifkX^fe`jkjc\]kk_\Xl[`kfi`ld`eE\nPfibn`k_flkXi\jfclk`fekfk_\`dd\ej\cp
`dgfikXekgifYc\df]k_\jZXc\f]k_\le`m\ij\#Ylkk_\[\YXk\Zfek`el\[Xe[jki\e^k_$
\e\[n_\e#`eDXp(0)(#k_\9lcc\k`ef]k_\EXk`feXcI\j\XiZ_:fleZ`cglYc`j_\[knf
gXg\ijYpJ_Xgc\pXe[:lik`jcXp`e^flkk_\`ii\jg\Zk`m\gfj`k`fej%
K_\ÔijkZcl\k_Xk:lik`jnXjfek_\i`^_kkiXZbZXd\]ifdM\jkfD\cm`eJc`g_\i%8j\Xicp
Xj(0()#n_`c\nfib`e^Xkk_\Cfn\ccFYj\imXkfip`e=cX^jkX]]#8i`qfeX#Jc`g_\i_X[fY$
kX`e\[jg\ZkiXf]jfd\jg`iXce\YlcX\Xe[efk\[k_Xkk_\jg\ZkiXcc`e\jf]^XcXo`\jn\i\
j_`]k\[kfnXi[k_\i\[\[^\f]k_\jg\Zkild#[\dfejkiXk`e^k_Xkk_\j\^XcXo`\jn\i\
i\Z\[`e^]ifdfligf`ekf]m`\n%Jc`g_\iXcjfefk\[k_Xkk_\jg`iXce\YlcX\_X[ef\d`j$
j`fec`e\jYi`^_kc`e\j`ek_\`ijg\Zkild #Xjnflc[_Xm\Y\\e\og\Zk\[`]k_\pn\i\i\Xccp
k_\^Xj\flje\YlcX\f]k_\k_\e$Zlii\ekk_\fip%
Kf[Xp#_fn\m\i#k_\Xjkifefd\i<[n`eGfn\cc?lYYc\`jk_\dX`eg\ijfeZi\[`k\[n`k_
i\jfcm`e^ k_\ `jjl\% @e (0(0# >\fi^\ <cc\ip ?Xc\ f]]\i\[ ?lYYc\ X jkX]] gfj`k`fe Xk k_\
DflekN`cjfeFYj\imXkfip#n_\i\_\Zfek`el\[kfnfiblek`c_`j[\Xk_%Lj`e^k_\e\n
(''$`eZ_?ffb\ii\Õ\Zkfik\c\jZfg\#k_\cXi^\jkXe[dfjkgfn\i]lc`ejkild\ekf]k_\
k`d\#?lYYc\ZXgkli\[`dX^\jf]jfd\f]k_\jg`iXce\YlcX\#i\jfcm`e^k_\j`e^c\jkXij
`ek_\dXe[`[\ek`]p`e^:\g_\`[mXi`XYc\j`ej\m\iXcfYa\Zkj#`eZcl[`e^k_\8e[ifd\[X
>XcXop%
:\g_\`[j Xi\ X gXik`ZlcXi kpg\ f] jkXi# [`jZfm\i\[ kf Y\ mXi`XYc\ Yp Af_e >ff[i`Zb\ `e
(./+%8:\g_\`[jkXimXi`\j`kjcld`efj`kp`eXm\ipi\^lcXinXp#\ogXe[`e^Xe[ZfekiXZk$
`e^`eglcj\j#c`b\k_\Y\Xkf]X^`XekZfjd`Z_\Xik%:\g_\`[j_Xm\Xm\ipjkife^i\cXk`fe
Y\kn\\ek_\g\i`f[f]k_\`imXi`XY`c`kpXe[k_\`ii\Xc#fi`ek\ieXc#Yi`^_ke\jjbefneXj
'/
k_\XYjfclk\cld`efj`kp %8:\g_\`[n`k_Xk_i\\$[Xpg\i`f[_XjXeXYjfclk\cld`efj`kp
f]XYflk/''k`d\jk_Xkf]k_\Jle%8:\g_\`[n`k_Xk_`ikp$[Xpg\i`f[`j('#'''k`d\j
XjYi`^_kXjk_\Jle%
9\ZXlj\ f] k_`j i\cXk`fej_`g [`jZfm\i\[ Xe[ jkXk\[ Yp Xjkifefd\i ?\ei`\kkX JnXe
C\Xm`kk`e(0'/ #Xe[k_\_`^_cld`efj`kpk_XkdXb\j:\g_\`[jm`j`Yc\Xk^i\Xk[`jkXeZ\j#
X:\g_\`[mXi`XYc\ZXeY\lj\[XjXle`hl\ÈjkXe[Xi[ZXe[c\Ékf[\k\id`e\k_\[`jkXeZ\
kf`kj_fjk^XcXop%
<[n`e?lYYc\#kf^\k_\in`k_D`ckfeC%?ldXjfe#lj\[k_`ji\cXk`fej_`gkfd\Xjli\k_\
[`jkXeZ\j kf jfd\ jg`iXc e\YlcX\# gifm`e^ k_Xk k_\p Xi\ d`cc`fej f] c`^_k$p\Xij [`jkXek
ÇdlZ_]Xik_\ik_Xegi\m`fljcpk_fl^_kÇXe[jfZfeÔid`e^k_Xkk_\pn\i\XZklXccp
^XcXo`\j#n`k_k_\`dgc`ZXk`fek_Xkk_\D`cbpNXp`jaljkfe\f]dXep^XcXo`\jjZXkk\i\[
k_ifl^_flkk_\le`m\ij\%?lYYc\XeefleZ\[k_\[`jZfm\ipfeAXelXip(#(0),#X[[`e^
dfi\]l\ckfk_\Ôi\f]k_\fe^f`e^[\YXk\Xe[`eÕl\eZ`e^k_\flkZfd\[\Z`j`m\cpn_`c\
]le[Xd\ekXccpZ_Xe^`e^flim`\nf]k_\le`m\ij\%
;`]]\i\ekKpg\jf]>XcXo`\j
8]k\idXb`e^k_\b\pfYj\imXk`fejk_Xk\jkXYc`j_\[k_\j`q\f]k_\le`m\ij\Xe[k_\kil\
ifc\f]fliD`cbpNXpn`k_`e`k#<[n`e?lYYc\ki`\[kfZcXjj`]p^XcXo`\jXZZfi[`e^kfk_\`i
j_Xg\`eXeXkk\dgkkf[`jZfm\igXkk\iejn`k_g_pj`ZXcd\Xe`e^j%@e_`jYffb#glYc`j_\[
`e(0*-Xe[\ek`kc\[J^[H[Wbce\j^[D[XkbW[k_\nfi[È^XcXopÉfecpjcfncpY\ZXd\
Zfddfe[li`e^k_\(0*'j #?lYYc\\jkXYc`j_\[XZcXjj`ÔZXk`fejZ_\d\]fi^XcXo`\jk_Xk
kf[Xp`jZXcc\[k_\È?lYYc\j\hl\eZ\#Éfik_\È?lYYc\kle`e^]fibÉY\ZXlj\f]`kjgXik`Zl$
cXij_Xg\%
?lYYc\ËjZcXjj`ÔZXk`fejpjk\d_Xjgifm\[jligi`j`e^cpifYljk%8ck_fl^_k_`jjZ_\d\`j
efnZfej`[\i\[jfd\n_Xkkffj`dgc\#k_\YXj`Z`[\Xjjk`cc_fc[%@knXjk_fl^_kfecpkf
[\jZi`Y\k_\m`jlXcXgg\XiXeZ\f]^XcXo`\j#Ylk`k`jXcjfn\ccZfii\cXk\[n`k_g_pj`ZXccp
(&
('
`ek\i\jk`e^gXiXd\k\ijjlZ_Xjjk\ccXiZfek\ek#^XjZfek\ek#Xe[\em`ifed\ek%K_\jpj$
k\dnXjcXk\i\ok\e[\[Ypk_\Xjkifefd\ij>iXi[[\MXlZflc\lijXe[J`[e\pmXe[\e
9\i^_Xe[_XjY\\ek_\dfjkZfddfecplj\[jpjk\d]fik_\ZcXjj`ÔZXk`fef]^XcXo`\j%
K_\[`X^iXdj_fnjk_\j_Xg\jfiÈdfig_fcf^pÉ f]^XcXo`\jXe[`jifl^_cp[`m`[\[`ekf
knfgXikj1\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jXe[jg`iXc^XcXo`\j%?lYYc\^Xm\k_\\cc`gk`ZXcjeldY\ij]ifd
q\ifkfj\m\ek_XkZ_XiXZk\i`q\k_\XggXi\ekj_Xg\f]k_\^XcXopÇÈ<'É`jXcdfjkifle[#
n_`c\È<.É`jm\ip\cc`gk`ZXc%<cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jj_fnc`kkc\kfefjkilZkli\Xe[Xi\^\e\i$
XccpZ_XiXZk\i`q\[Ypfc[jk\ccXigfglcXk`fejXe[m\ipc`kkc\f]k_\^XjXe[[ljke\\[\[kf
]fide\njkXij%
Jg`iXcjXi\jlY[`m`[\[`ekfXj\hl\eZ\af`ekcp[\Ôe\[Ypk_\[\^i\\f]k`^_ke\jjf]k_\
jg`iXcXidjXe[k_\`dgfikXeZ\f]k_\Z\ekiXcYlc^\%ÈJXÉ^XcXo`\j_Xm\XYi`^_kYlc^\
Xe[k`^_kcpnfle[Xidj#n_`c\ÈJZÉ^XcXo`\j_Xm\cffj\cpnfle[XidjXe[Xi\cXk`m\cp
c\jj `dgfikXek Zfi\ i\^`fe% K_\ Z\ekiXc Ylc^\ ^\e\iXccp ZfekX`ej fc[\i jkXij# j`d`cXi kf
k_fj\j\\e`e\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j%K_\i\`jXk_`eflk\i[`jb\eZcfj`e^k_\Ylc^\#n`k_Yi`^_k
Xidj]fid`e^k_\Z_XiXZk\i`jk`Zjg`iXcjkilZkli\%<XZ_f]k_\jg`iXckpg\j\o`jkj`eXm\i$
j`fen`k_Xe[n`k_flkXZ\ekiXcYXi%K_\YXii\[jg`iXcj_Xm\XjkiX`^_kYXif]jkXijk_Xk
ilejk_ifl^_k_\Z\ekiXcYlc^\%K_\jg`iXcXidj`eYXii\[jg`iXcjljlXccpjkXikXkk_\\e[
f]k_\YXi`ejk\X[f]Xkk_\Ylc^\%9Xii\[jg`iXcj_Xm\XÈ9É`ek_\`iZcXjj`ÔZXk`fe%8eÈJ9ZÉ
`jk_ljXcffj\cpnfle[YXii\[jg`iXc^XcXop%
?lYYc\]fle[k_Xkjfd\^XcXo`\jn\i\[`]ÔZlckkfÔk`ekf_`je\XkcpXiiXe^\[kle`e^$]fib
[`X^iXd%K_\j\`eZcl[\`ii\^lcXi^XcXo`\jn`k_f[[j_Xg\j#k_\m\ipjdXcc[nXi]^XcXo`\j#
Xe[k_\^`Xek\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jk_XkXi\]fle[Xkk_\Z\ek\ijf]jfd\Zcljk\ijf]^XcXo$
`\j%K_\j\f[[YXcc^XcXo`\jn\i\cXi^\cp`^efi\[YpXjkifefd\ijlek`ck_\d`[$(0,'j#Ylk
_Xm\j`eZ\klie\[flkkfY\ZilZ`Xc]fiflile[\ijkXe[`e^f]_fn^XcXo`\j\mfcm\%
=fiXk`d\#k_\?lYYc\kle`e^]fibnXjk_fl^_kkfY\Xe\mfclk`feXipj\hl\eZ\jlZ_k_Xk
^XcXo`\j d`^_k \mfcm\ ]ifd fe\ kpg\ kf Xefk_\i# gif^i\jj`e^ ]ifd c\]k kf i`^_k XZifjj
k_\kle`e^$]fib[`X^iXd%?\eZ\\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j#`eZcl[`e^J'#n\i\ZXcc\[È\Xicp$kpg\#É
((
()
n_`c\jg`iXcjn\i\ZXcc\[ÈcXk\$kpg\%ÉK_`j\mfclk`feXipg`Zkli\Xgg\XijkfY\jlggfik\[
Ypk_\]XZkk_Xkk_\[`jbjf]jg`iXc^XcXo`\jXi\fYj\im\[kfY\_fd\kfdXeppfle^jkXij
Xe[i\^`fejf]XZk`m\jkXi]fidXk`fe#n_`c\\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jXi\Zfdgfj\[f]gi\[fd`$
eXekcpfc[\ijk\ccXigfglcXk`fej%
@e]XZk#Zlii\ek\m`[\eZ\gf`ekjkfaljkk_\fggfj`k\1k_\\Xicple`m\ij\Xgg\Xijkf_Xm\
Y\\e[fd`eXk\[Ypjg`iXcXe[`ii\^lcXi^XcXo`\j%@ek_\Zlii\ekcp]Xmfi\[g`Zkli\f]^Xc$
Xop]fidXk`fe#ZXcc\[k_\c[h][h^ofej^[i_i#gi\j\ek$[Xp\cc`gk`ZXcj]fid\[XjXi\jlckf]
d\i^\ijY\kn\\ek_\j\\Xic`\iYl`c[`e^YcfZbj%
8jkifefd\ijjk`cclj\?lYYc\Ëj^XcXopZcXjj`ÔZXk`fekf[Xp#Xck_fl^_k_\`e`k`XcZfeZ\gk
`jefnj\\eXjXefm\ij`dgc`ÔZXk`fe%>XcXopZcXjj`ÔZXk`fe`jX]Xidfi\Zfdgc\ogifZ\jj
k_Xe?lYYc\`dX^`e\[#`emfcm`e^efkfecpn_Xkfli\p\jZXej\\`ek_\m`jlXcgXikf]k_\
jg\ZkildYlkXcjfk_\Zfe[`k`fejf]X^XcXopËj`e`k`XcZfccXgj\#`kjZfdgfj`k`fe#Xe[\jg\$
Z`Xccp`kj\mfclk`fe%
Jg`iXc>XcXo`\j
8j?lYYc\ËjZcXjj`ÔZXk`fej_fnj#jg`iXc^XcXo`\jZfd\`e[`]]\i\ekj_Xg\j#Ylkk_\p[f
j_Xi\ X Zfddfe jkilZkli\% K_\p Xcc _Xm\ X [`jb n`k_ jkXij# ^Xj Xe[ [ljk# Xe[ X k_`Zb
jg_\i`ZXcZ\ekiXcZfeZ\ekiXk`fef]jkXijn`k_c`kkc\^Xjfi[ljk#befneXjk_\Ylc^\%K_\
(*
n_fc\jkilZkli\`jjliifle[\[YpXdlZ_]X`ek\iifle[_Xcff]fc[jkXij#jfd\f]n_`Z_
i\j`[\`e^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij%K_\iXe^\f]dXjj\j]fijg`iXc^XcXo`\j`j]ifdXYflkfe\kf
(#'''Y`cc`fejfcXidXjj\j#Xck_fl^_k_\kpg`ZXcdXjj`jXYflk(''Y`cc`fejfcXidXjj\j%
Kpg`ZXccp#k_\j`q\f]k_\m`j`Yc\[`jb`eXjg`iXc^XcXop^f\j]ifd(,kf*''k_fljXe[c`^_k$
p\Xij`e[`Xd\k\iÇkffcXi^\kfi\Xccp]Xk_fdÇXe[Xk_`Zbe\jjf]fecpfe\Ô]k`\k_f]
k_\[`Xd\k\i%I\dXibXYcpk_`e#iXk_\ij`d`cXikfXgcX`e[`ee\igcXk\%
K_\n_fc\jpjk\difkXk\jXifle[XeXo`jaf`e`e^k_\^XcXZk`Zgfc\j%8ck_fl^_k_\`ee\i
gXikifkXk\jc`b\Xjfc`[Yf[p#k_\flk\i[`jbjkilZkli\_XjX[`]]\i\ek`XcifkXk`fegXkk\ie%
Dfi\k_Xe_Xc]f]XccfYj\im\[^XcXo`\jXi\jg`iXcj%K_\pXi\dfjkcp]fle[`jfcXk\[`ecfn
[\ej`kpi\^`fejXe[Xi\iXi\`ek_\Z\ek\ijf]^XcXopZcljk\ij%
Knffidfi\Xidj\ok\e[]ifdk_\Ylc^\#\eZcfj`e^`k%K_\i\Xi\Xcjfj\m\iXcXZk`m\jkXi$
]fid`e^i\^`fej#n`k__fk^cfn`e^Zcfl[jf]^XjXe[[ljk]fid`e^k_\Èjk\ccXielij\i`\jÉ
k_Xkn\j\\Xje\YlcX\flkc`e`e^k_\jg`iXcXidj%K_\dXep_fkpfle^Ycl\Xe[n_`k\$
Ycl\jkXijdXb\k_\jkilZkli\f]k_\Xidjm\ipgifd`e\ek%8Yflk_Xc]f]Xccjg`iXcjj_fn
XeX[[`k`feXcZfdgfe\ek`ek_\]fidf]XZ\ekiXcYXi\ok\e[`e^]ifdk_\Ylc^\#Xkk_\
\e[jf]n_`Z_k_\jg`iXcXidjY\^`e%
K_\elZc\ljf]Xjg`iXc^XcXop`jkpg`ZXccpdlZ_i\[[\iXe[jdffk_\ik_Xe`kjflk\igXikj#
f]k\ei\j\dYc`e^\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j2k_`j`e[`ZXk\jk_\gi\j\eZ\f]dXepfc[jkXijXe[efk
dXepjkXi$]fid`e^i\^`fej#`eZfekiXjkkfk_\XZk`m`kp`ek_\Xidj%
K_\jgXZ\Y\kn\\ek_\jkXij`ek_\j\^XcXo`\j`jÔcc\[n`k_^XjXe[[ljk#Zi\Xk`e^Yi`^_k
Xe[[XibgXkZ_\jXe[cXe\jXcfe^k_\jg`iXcXidj%@ek_\D`cbpNXp#j\\e]ifdflim`\n$
gf`ekfe<Xik_#k_\Z\ek\i`kj\c]`j_`[[\e]ifdflim`\nYpk_`ZbcXp\ijf]^XjXe[[ljk%
@k`jk_fl^_kk_Xkdfjkjg`iXc^XcXo`\j#`]efkXcc#_XiYfiXjlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\Xkk_\
Z\ek\i#n`k_XdXjjY\kn\\e(''#'''Xe[('Y`cc`fejfcXidXjj\j%JlZ_YcXZb_fc\j_Xm\
(+
e\m\iY\\efYj\im\[[`i\Zkcp#YlkXYle[Xek`e[`i\Zk\m`[\eZ\]fik_\d\o`jkj%8+$d`cc`fe
jfcXidXjjjlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\`jcfZXk\[Xkk_\Z\ek\if]k_\D`cbpNXp%
Dfjkf]k_\jkXij`eXjg`iXc^XcXopXi\cfZXk\[\`k_\i`ek_\[`jb#]fccfn`e^dfi\fic\jj
Z`iZlcXifiY`kjXifle[k_\Z\ek\i#fi`eXjg_\i`ZXcYlc^\Xifle[k_\^XcXZk`ZZfi\%?fn$
\m\i#XeldY\if]jkXij`e_XY`kXdfi\[`]]lj\jg_\i`ZXc_Xcf#\`k_\i`jfcXk\[fiZfcc\Zk\[
`e^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij%K_\fiY`kjf]k_\j\jkXijXi\le[\iZcfj\jZilk`epYpXjkifefd\ij#
Ylkk_\pdXpY\lec`b\k_fj\f]dfjkjkXij`ek_\D`cbpNXp%Jfd\fiY`kk_\Z\ek\i`e
k_\fggfj`k\[`i\Zk`fefin`k_X_`^_cp`eZc`e\[fi`ii\^lcXifiY`k%@kdXpm\ipn\ccY\k_Xk
k_\j\_XcfjkXij_Xm\Y\\eÈXZhl`i\[Éfm\ik`d\]ifdjdXcc^XcXo`\jk_Xkd\i^\[n`k_
k_\D`cbpNXp%
K_\dfk`fef]_XcfjkXij[f\jYi`e^k_\dk_ifl^_k_\[`jbfefZZXj`fe%8eldY\if]
jdXcci\[[nXi]jkXijZcfj\kfk_\JleXi\#]fi`ejkXeZ\#k_fl^_kkfY\cfe^kfk_\^XcXZk`Z
_Xcf# jlZ_ Xj BXgk\peËj JkXi Xe[ >iffdYi`[^\ (/*'% ;l\ kf k_\`i `ii\^lcXi dfm\d\ek
Xifle[k_\Z\ek\if]fli^XcXopk_\j\jkXijf]k\edfm\i\cXk`m\cp]Xjkn_\ed\Xjli\[
p\XiYpp\Xii\cXk`m\kffk_\ijkXij%
(,
K_\fi`^`ef]k_\jg`iXcjkilZkli\_XjY\\eXdXkk\i]fim`^fiflj[`jZljj`feXdfe^jZ`$
\ek`jkj]fi[\ZX[\j%JffeX]k\ik_\[`jZfm\ipf]k_\eXkli\f]jg`iXc^XcXo`\j#jZ`\ek`jkj
i\Xc`q\[k_XkjkXijZflc[efkg\idXe\ekcpjkXpXiiXe^\[`eXjg`iXcjkilZkli\%J`eZ\k_\
ifkXk`fejg\\[f]k_\^XcXopmXi`\jn`k_[`jkXeZ\]ifdk_\Z\ek\if]k_\^XcXop#k_\Xidj
nflc[hl`ZbcpY\Zfd\dfi\Xe[dfi\Zlim\[#k`^_kcp\dYiXZ`e^k_\Zfi\X]k\ifecp]\n
ifkXk`fejf]k_\^XcXop%J`eZ\n\[fefkfYj\im\k_`j\]]\Zk#k_\i\_XjkfY\Xefk_\i\o$
gcXeXk`fe%
Kf[XpËjdfjkXZZ\gk\[\ogcXeXk`fe#k_\[\ej`kpnXm\k_\fip#[\jZi`Y\jk_\XidjXji\$
^`fejf]\e_XeZ\[[\ej`kpifkXk`e^`ek_\[`jbf]k_\^XcXop%8ZZfi[`e^kfk_`jk_\fip#k_\
eldY\if]jkXij`ek_\jg`iXcXidj`jefkm\ip[`]]\i\ek]ifdk_\eldY\if]jkXij`ek_\
^XgjY\kn\\ek_\Xidj%K_\f]k\e$lj\[XeXcf^p]fik_\[\ej`kpnXm\k_\fip`jXkiX]ÔZ
aXdfeX_`^_nXp#n_\i\ZXij\ek\iXe[c\Xm\k_\aXd#Ylkk_\aXd`kj\c]g\ij`jkj%@eX
jg`iXc^XcXopk_\Xidj_Xm\jkXij\ek\i`e^Xe[c\Xm`e^#Ylkk_\Xidjk_\dj\cm\ji\dX`e%
K_\[\ej`kpnXm\ifkXk\jdfi\jcfncpk_Xek_\dXk\i`Xc`ek_\^XcXZk`Z[`jb#jfk_XkjkXij
Xe[^XjXi\XYc\kfÈfm\ikXb\Ék_\nXm\%8j^Xj`ek_\`ek\ijk\ccXid\[`ldgXjj\j`ekfk_\
[\ej`kpnXm\#`kY\Zfd\j[\ej\i#c\X[`e^kfk_\]fidXk`fef]e\njkXij%
K_\_fkk\jkXe[Yi`^_k\jke\njkXijYliek_\`ielZc\Xi]l\cXkX_`^_iXk\#jfk_\p_Xm\
m\ipj_fikc`]\jgXej#c`m`e^Xe[[p`e^m\ipZcfj\kfk_\[\ej`kpnXm\%K_`j`jn_pk_\jg`iXc
XidjXi\kiXZ\[flkYpk_\Yi`^_k\jkjkXij#Xe[`ek_\^XgjY\kn\\ek_\Xidjk_\i\Xi\
dXep]X`ekjkXijYlk]\nm\ipYi`^_kfe\j#j`eZ\k_\Yi`^_k\jkjkXij_Xm\Xci\X[p[`\[%
>XjXe[[ljkZcfl[j`e[`ZXk`e^jkXi$]fid`e^i\^`fejZXeXcjfY\j\\efek_\`ej`[\f]k_\
jg`iXcXidj#cp`e^jc`^_kcpY\_`e[k_\[\ej`kpnXm\k_Xk_XjZfdgi\jj\[k_\dXe[ki`^$
^\i\[Xe\ogcfj`fef]jkXiY`ik_%
(-
(/
<cc`gk`ZXc>XcXo`\j D<JJ@<I/(
8dlck`$nXm\c\e^k_m`\n
;\jg`k\k_\jdffk_#]\Xkli\c\jjXgg\XiXeZ\Xe[k_\jcfn\idfk`fef]k_\`ijkXij#\cc`g$ f]D\jj`\i/(Ëjjpjk\df]
jkXij#[ljk#^XjZcfl[j#Xe[
k`ZXc ^XcXo`\j Xi\ hl`k\ \oZ`k`e^ [peXd`ZXc jpjk\dj% K_\p Xgg\Xi Xj Xj ]lqqp \cc`gk`ZXc
jg`iXcXidjn`e[`e^Xcck_\
gXkZ_\jf]c`^_k#iXe^`e^]ifde\Xicpjg_\i`ZXckf_`^_cpÕXkk\e\[\cc`gjf`[j#[`d`e`j_`e^
nXp[fne`ekfk_\elZc\lj%
jdffk_cp`eYi`^_ke\jj]ifdk_\Z\ek\iflknXi[jXe[iXi\cpn`k_Xepkil\jkilZkli\m`j$ K_fl^_k_\^XcXop`jcfZXk\[
`Yc\%K_\p_Xm\c`kkc\m`j`Yc\^XjXe[[ljkZfdgXi\[n`k_jg`iXcj%JkXij`e\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j ((%-d`cc`fec`^_k$p\XijXnXp#
Xi\fc[Xe[]fccfnfiY`kjk_XkXi\iXe[fdcpfi`\ek\[n`k_`ek_\^XcXop%@kXcjfcffbjXj`] k_\?lYYc\JgXZ\K\c\jZfg\Ëj
Xcc\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j_Xm\jlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\j`ek_\`iZ\ek\i#Xe[k_\dXjjf]k_\j\ m`\n`jjfj_Xigk_Xk`kZXe
YcXZb_fc\j`jZfee\Zk\[n`k_k_\dXjjf]k_\^XcXop%<cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j[fefk_Xm\[`jbj i\jfcm\`e[`m`[lXcjkXij#
Xcfe^n`k_fg\ejkXiZcljk\ij#
Xifle[k_\d#Xck_fl^_jfd\Ylc^\jf][`jb^XcXo`\jcffbj`d`cXikf\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j%
^cfYlcXijkXiZcljk\ij#Xe[
\m\e^cfn`e^i\^`fejf]
<cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jXi\Y\c`\m\[kfdXb\lgXggifo`dXk\cp('kf(,g\iZ\ekf]^XcXo`\j`e Õlfi\jZ\ek^Xj%K_`j`dX^\
k_\cfZXcle`m\ij\%K_\pXi\dfjkf]k\e]fle[Zcfj\kfk_\Z\ek\if]i`Z_#i\^lcXi^XcXop ZfdY`e\j[XkX]ifdk_\
Zcljk\ijXe[Xi\c\jjZfddfe`ek_\\Xicple`m\ij\k_Xek_\pXi\efn% ?lYYc\JgXZ\K\c\jZfg\#k_\
Jg`kq\iJgXZ\K\c\jZfg\Xe[
<cc`gk`ZXcj[`jgcXpX^i\XkmXi`Xk`fe`edXjj#iXe^`e^]ifd[nXi]jn`k_XdXjjf]aljkX k_\>XcXop<mfclk`fe<ogcfi\i
>8C<O d`jj`fej%
]\nd`cc`fejfcXidXjj\jkffm\ife\ki`cc`fejfcXidXjj\j]fi^`Xek\cc`gk`ZXcj%K_\`ij`q\
mXi`\j]ifdX]\nk_fljXe[c`^_k$p\Xijkf*''#'''c`^_k$p\Xij%K_\jdXcc\jkf]k_\\cc`gk`$
ZXc^XcXo`\j#n_`Z_Xi\ZXcc\[[nXi]\cc`gk`ZXcj#dXpY\fecpXc`kkc\cXi^\ik_Xek_\cXi^\jk
^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij%8kk_\fk_\i\oki\d\#^`Xek\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jjlZ_XjD\jj`\i/.Xi\
Xdfe^k_\cXi^\jk^XcXo`\j`ek_\le`m\ij\%K_`j`jXdlZ_cXi^\iiXe^\f]j`q\jk_Xe`j
j\\e]fijg`iXc^XcXo`\j%>`Xek\cc`gk`ZXcjf]k\e[fd`eXk\X^XcXopZcljk\i%
)'
dXafi`kpf]\cc`gk`ZXcjXi\f]`ek\id\[`Xk\k_`ee\jj#Xe[k_Xkk_\?lYYc\ZcXjj`ÔZXk`fej ^`Xek\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXop<JF
Xi\f]k\eXi\jlckf]k_\Xe^c\Xkn_`Z_k_\^XcXop`jfYj\im\[% *),$>''+cffdjcXi^\Xkk_\
Zcljk\iËjZ\ek\i%K_\^XcXop
`jXjdXjj`m\Xj(''Y`cc`fe
jfcXidXjj\j%?lYYc\_Xji\$
jfcm\[k_fljXe[jf]^cfYlcXi
jkXiZcljk\ijfiY`k`e^<JF
*),$>''+#n_`Z_Xgg\XiXj
g`egf`ekjf]c`^_kZfekX`e\[
n`k_`ek_\[`]]lj\_Xcf%
Fk_\i]lqqp\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j
[fkk_\`dX^\%Jfd\_Xm\
\m`[\eZ\f]X[`jbjkilZkli\
k_Xk^`m\jk_\dXYfn$k`\
j_Xg\%J\m\iXcjg`iXc^XcXo`\j
Xi\Xcjfj\\e%
))
)*
)+
@II<>LC8I>8C8OP @ii\^lcXiXe[G\Zlc`Xi>XcXo`\j
E>:+++0
?le[i\[jf]k_fljXe[jf]
8eldY\if]fYj\im\[^XcXo`\j[fefkÔe[XgcXZ\`ek_\?lYYc\j\hl\eZ\Xe[ZXeefki\$
m`YiXekYcl\Xe[i\[jkXijXi\
XccpY\ZcXjj`Ô\[Xj\`k_\i\cc`gk`ZXcfijg`iXc%K_\j\Xi\eXd\[`ii\^lcXi^XcXo`\j#Xe[_Xm\
m`j`Yc\`ek_`j`dX^\f]^XcXop
E>:+++0%?fkYcl`j_$n_`k\
c`kkc\jpdd\kip`ek_\`ijkilZkli\#fi[fefk_Xm\XjkilZkli\XkXcc%K_\p[fefk_Xm\X
Zcljk\ijf]dXjj`m\jkXijXi\ Ylc^\#Xe[Xck_fl^_k_\pjfd\k`d\jXgg\Xikf_Xm\k_\i\dX`ejf]XjkilZkli\`ii\^lcXi
jZXkk\i\[k_ifl^_flkk_\ kpg\@ #`k`jefkZc\Xi\efl^_kfi\XccpÔkk_\d`ekfk_\?lYYc\j\hl\eZ\%@ii\^lcXikpg\
^XcXop#`ek\ijg\ij\[n`k_ @@j_Xm\efkiXZ\f]XjkilZkli\%
eld\iflj[ljk`\ii\[[`j_
i\^`fejf]Zlii\ekjkXi]fidX$
@ii\^lcXi^XcXo`\j_Xm\]\njpjk\dXk`Z]\Xkli\j%K_\pmXip`edXjj]ifd(''#'''kf('d`c$
k`fe%DXjj`m\[XibZcfl[jf]
c`fejfcXidXjj\jXe[`ej`q\]ifdX]\nk_fljXe[kfj\m\iXck\ejf]k_fljXe[jf]c`^_k$
^XjXe[[ljkXi\j`c_fl\kk\[
X^X`ejkk_\ÕXd`e^jkXic`^_k%
p\Xij%
E>:+++0_XjY\\e]fid`e^
jkXij]fik_\gXjkj\m\iXc @ek_\\Xicp[Xpjf]?lYYc\Ëjfi`^`eXcZcXjj`ÔZXk`fe#`knXjZfddfekfZcXjj`]pXcc^XcXo`\j
Y`cc`fep\Xij#Ylk`jZlii\ekcp k_Xkn\i\e\`k_\ijg`iXcefi\cc`gk`ZXcXj`ii\^lcXi#Ylk`k`jdfi\Zfddfekf[XpkfdXb\
]fid`e^jkXijXkXdlZ_ X]lik_\i[`jk`eZk`feY\kn\\eÈefidXcÉ`ii\^lcXi^XcXo`\jXe[g\Zlc`Xi^XcXo`\j#n_`Z_
_`^_\iiXk\k_Xe`ek_\gXjk%
_Xm\XeleljlXcj_Xg\#j`q\#jkilZkli\#fiZfdgfj`k`fe%Dfjkf]k_\j\Xi\fYa\Zkjk_Xk
8kk_\Zlii\ekiXk\#k_\^Xj
_Xm\Y\\ek`[Xccp[`jkfik\[j\\gX^\/, Yp`ek\iXZk`fen`k_Xefk_\i^XcXop%K_\pf]k\e
jlggcpk_Xk]\\[jjk\ccXi
gif[lZk`fen`ccfecpcXjk]fi
Xgg\Xi`egX`ijf][`jkfik\[d\dY\ij#n`k_kX`cjf]jkXijXe[^Xjk_Xk_Xm\Y\\eÕle^flk
Xefk_\iY`cc`fep\Xijfijf% ]ifdk_\dX`eYf[pf]k_\^XcXop%
@ek_\(0-'jk_\8d\i`ZXeXjkifefd\i?Xckfe8iggf`ek\[k_\nfic[]Xdflj,$d\k\i
GXcfdXik\c\jZfg\kfnXi[**/f]k_\j\g\Zlc`Xi#`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\j#ZXgkli`e^jfd\f]
k_\dfjkd\dfiXYc\Xjkifefd`ZXc`dX^\j`e_`jkfip%?`ji\dXibXYc\ZXkXcf^#glYc`j_\[
Xjk_\7jbWie\F[Ykb_Wh=WbWn_[i#nXjXg`fe\\i`e^Xkk\dgkkfjfcm\k_\dpjk\ipf]k_\
Y`qXii\j_Xg\jf]^XcXo`\jfYj\im\[Yp^ifle[$YXj\[k\c\jZfg\ji\X[dfi\XYflk8ig`e
:_Xgk\i* %
Kf[Xp#k_\g\Zlc`Xi`kpf]k_\^XcXo`\jj\\eYp8igXe[fk_\ij`jn\ccle[\ijkff[#Xjk_\
jkilZkli\jZi\Xk\[Yp^iXm`kpËj[\jkilZk`m\[XeZ\n_\e^XcXo`\jZfcc`[\Xe[d\i^\%
),
;N8I=@II<>LC8I
@QN@:BP(/
@Qn`Zbp(/`jZcXjj`Ô\[XjX
[nXi]`ii\^lcXi^XcXopXe[
`jdlZ_jdXcc\ik_Xefli
D`cbpNXp%K_\ZfeZ\ekiXk\[
Ycl`j_$n_`k\befkj\dY\[[\[
`ek_\_\Xikf]k_\^XcXopXi\
knfdXafijkXiYlijki\^`fej
n_\i\jkXijXi\]fid`e^XkX
]li`fljiXk\%K_\n`jgpYcl\
ÔcXd\ekjjliifle[`e^k_\
Z\ekiXcjkXiYlijki\^`fejXi\
YlYYc\jf]^Xjk_Xk_Xm\Y\\e
YcfneXnXpYpjk\ccXin`e[j
Xe[jlg\iefmX\ogcfj`fej
]ifdXgi\m`flj^\e\iXk`fef]
_fk#pfle^jkXij%K_`j^Xj`j
efn_\Xk\[Yp`ek\ej\lckiX$
m`fc\kiX[`Xk`felec\Xj_\[Yp
_fk#pfle^jkXij%8ZfdgXe$
`fe^XcXopc`\jaljkkfk_\c\]k
f]@Qn`Zbp(/Xe[`jc`b\cp`e$
k\iXZk`e^n`k_@Qn`Zbp(/Yp
^iXm`kXk`feXccpkl^^`e^fek_\
^XcXop%K_\`ek\iXZk`fedXp
_Xm\ki`^^\i\[k_\^XcXopËj
i\Z\ekjkXi]fidXk`fek_Xk`j @ii\^lcXi^XcXo`\jXi\efkXe\oZ\gk`fe`ek_\le`m\ij\%@k`jk_fl^_kk_XkXYflkfe\Ô]k_
i\jgfej`Yc\]fik_\pflk_]lc f]Xcc^XcXo`\jXi\\`k_\i`ii\^lcXifig\Zlc`Xi`ejfd\nXp%
Xgg\XiXeZ\%K_\i\[[`j_
\ok\e[\[fYa\Zkjjliifle[`e^
K_\ jkl[p f] k_\j\ kpg\j f] ^XcXo`\j _Xj ^iX[lXccp glk dfi\ \dg_Xj`j fe k_\ `dgfi$
@Qn`Zbp(/Xe[`kjZfdgXe$
kXek\mfclk`feXip`eÕl\eZ\f]`ek\iXZk`fejY\kn\\e^XcXo`\j%8jkifefd\ijXi\efnZfe$
`feXi\XeZ`\ek#]lccp]fid\[
^XcXo`\jf][`]]\i\ekj_Xg\j
m`eZ\[k_Xkk_`jgifZ\jjgcXpjX]le[Xd\ekXcifc\`e\jkXYc`j_`e^k_\dXep[`]]\i\ek^Xc$
k_XkXi\dlZ_]Xik_\iXnXp% Xopj_Xg\j%K_\j\`ek\iXZk`fejXi\Xcjf`dgfikXek`ejk`dlcXk`e^k_\]fidXk`fef]jkXij
Xe[jkXiZcljk\ij%
).
*'
K _\ ]fidXk`fe Xe[ \mfclk`fe f] ^XcXo`\j `j fe\ f] k_\ dfjk _fkcp [\YXk\[ kfg`Zj `e
df[\ieXjkifefdp%N_p[fn\j\\[`]]\i\ekkpg\jf]^XcXo`\j#Xe[_fn[fk_\jlg\i$
89<CC(.'*#8D8JJ@M<
>8C8OP:CLJK<I
CfZXk\[`ek_\efik_\ie
dXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\jk_XkXi\]fle[`eXcc#fie\XicpXcc#^XcXo`\jÔk`ekfk_\\hlXk`fe6
Z\c\jk`Xc_\d`jg_\i\#
8Y\cc(.'*`jZfdgfj\[f]
@dgfikXekZcl\jkfk_\fi`^`ef]^XcXo`\jXi\]fle[Ypcffb`e^Xkjlim\pjf]cXi^\Xi\Xjf] _le[i\[jf]^XcXo`\j#_\i\
k_\jbp%Jfd\i\^`fejXi\dfi\[\ej\cpgfglcXk\[k_XeXm\iX^\#n`k_^XcXo`\j]fle[`e j\\e`ep\ccfn%Dfjkf]
jdXcc^iflgj#fi`ecXi^\Zifn[jf]k_fljXe[jf]^XcXo`\j#ZXcc\[^XcXopZcljk\ij%:cljk\ij k_\j\Xi\\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j%
Xi\f]k\e^iflg\[`ejlg\iZcljk\ijXe[\m\ecXi^\ijkilZkli\jk_Xk\ok\e[XZifjjcXi^\ K_\Zcljk\i^XcXo`\jXZkXjX
gfn\i]lcZfjd`Zk\c\jZfg\#
jnXk_\jf]k_\dXggXYc\le`m\ij\%
fi^iXm`kXk`feXcc\ej#k_Xk
Y\e[jXe[jki\kZ_\jk_\c`^_k
>XcXopZcljk\ijXi\k_\cXi^\jk^iXm`kXk`feXccpYfle[fYa\Zkjn\befnXe[_Xm\Xn\cc$
]ifddfi\[`jkXek^XcXo`\j
gfglcXk\[Z\ekiXcZfi\Xe[Xjg_\i`ZXcj_Xg\%Kpg`ZXccp#k_\`ij`q\jiXe^\Y\kn\\e,Xe[ dXepf]n_`Z_Xi\jg`iXcj %
*'d`cc`fec`^_k$p\Xij#n_`c\k_\`idXjj`jf]k_\fi[\if]fe\d`cc`feY`cc`fejfcXidXjj\j% @ek_\gifZ\jj`k[`jkfikjk_\`i
:fdgXi\[ kf k_\ Ô\c[j flkj`[\ k_\ Zcljk\ij# k_\ Zcljk\i Z\ek\ij Xi\ gfglcXk\[ Xcdfjk j_Xg\jXe[gif[lZ\jdlck`gc\
jfc\cp Yp \cc`gk`ZXc Xe[ c\ek`ZlcXi fi J'2 fe k_\ Yfi[\i Y\kn\\e \cc`gk`ZXcj Xe[ jg`iXcj YXeXeX$j_Xg\[`dX^\jf]k_\
fi`^`eXc^XcXo`\j%8Y\cc(.'*
^XcXo`\j#n`k__Xi[cpXepfe^f`e^jkXi]fidXk`fe%Jf#k_\i\`jXZc\XiZfee\Zk`feY\kn\\e
`jcfZXk\[*Y`cc`fec`^_k$p\Xij
k_\\em`ifed\ekXe[k_\^XcXopkpg\j]fle[%K_`ji\cXk`fej_`gdXb\jdXepjZ`\ek`jkj
]ifd<Xik_%
Y\c`\m\ k_Xk jg`iXcj n\i\ feZ\ eld\iflj `e Zcljk\ij Ylk _Xm\ Y\\e kiXej]fid\[ `ekf
\cc`gk`ZXcfic\ek`ZlcXijpjk\djm`X^XcXopd\i^\ij%
Cffb`e^9XZb`eK`d\
8j`e^c\_ldXec`]\k`d\#fi\m\ek_\c`]\k`d\f]k_\\ek`i\jg\Z`\j#`j]Xikffj_fikkffYj\im\
k_\\mfclk`fef]X^XcXop%9lkk_\jg\\[f]c`^_kZfd\jkfflii\jZl\`eXZli`fljnXp%@k`j
Xm\ip_`^_jg\\[`e[\\[Çifl^_cp*''#'''b`cfd\k\ijg\ij\Zfe[ÇYlk`k`jjk`ccÔe`k\%
>XcXo`\jXi\d`cc`fejfi\m\eY`cc`fejf]c`^_k$p\Xijk_\[`jkXeZ\kiXm\c\[Ypc`^_k`eXp\Xi
XnXp]ifd<Xik_%;l\kfk_\Ôe`k\jg\\[f]c`^_k#k_\dfi\[`jkXekXefYa\Zk`j#k_\cfe^\i
k_\kiXm\ck`d\f]k_\c`^_kkf<Xik_#Xe[jfk_\]lik_\i`ekfk_\gXjkn\fYj\im\`kfeZ\k_\
c`^_kXii`m\j%FYj\im`e^X[`jkXek^XcXop`jc`b\kiXm\c`e^YXZb`ek`d\%K_`j^`m\jljk_\XY`c`kp
kfjkl[pk_\Z_Xe^\j`e^XcXo`\jfm\ik`d\YpfYj\im`e^k_\dXk[`]]\i\ek[`jkXeZ\j#Xe[k_lj
Xk[`]]\i\ek\gfZ_j%
*)
**
@ek_\9\^`ee`e^%%%
K_\9`^9Xe^nXjk_\\m\ekk_XkYifl^_kXYflkk_\fi`^`ef]jgXZ\Xe[k`d\Xe[k_\cXnj
f]eXkli\Xe[f]XccdXkk\iXe[\e\i^p%;li`e^k_\Ôijk]\n_le[i\[k_fljXe[p\XijX]k\i
k_\9`^9Xe^k_\le`m\ij\nXji\dXibXYcp_fdf^\e\fljXe[]Xikff_fk]fiZ_\d`ZXc\c\$
d\ekjkf]fid%K_\le`m\ij\Zfej`jk\[f]Xjflgf]jlYXkfd`ZgXik`Zc\jXe[iX[`Xk`fe%
8ifle[ */'#''' p\Xij X]k\i k_\ 9`^ 9Xe^# Xj k_\ le`m\ij\ Zffc\[ kf *#''':# k_\ Ôijk
Zfdgc\k\_p[if^\eXe[_\c`ldXkfdjY\^Xekf]fid%@dX^\jf]k_\d`ZifnXm\YXZb$
^ifle[iX[`Xk`fe#\d`kk\[Xifle[k_`jk`d\#`e[`ZXk\k_Xkk_\j\\d`e^cp]\Xkli\c\jjj\X
f] Zfjd`Z gXik`Zc\j Xe[ iX[`Xk`fe Xci\X[p k_\e j_fn\[ j`^ej f] jkilZkli\% @e k_\ dfjk
XZZ\gk\[g`Zkli\f]^XcXop]fidXk`fe#k_\j\jlYkc\mXi`Xk`fej#c`b\cp[fd`eXk\[Yp[Xib
dXkk\ij\\YfofegX^\+. #`eXefk_\in`j\jdffk_le`m\ij\n\i\k_\j\\[jk_Xk^i\n
kf]fidk_\Ôijk^XcXo`\j%K_\j\Ôijkgi`dfi[`XcjkilZkli\j^iXm`kXk`feXccpXkkiXZk\[^Xj
Xe[[XibdXkk\ikfk_\[\ej\jkXi\Xj#n_\i\k_\Ôijkgifkf$^XcXo`\j]fid\[Xe[cXk\i
^i\n`ekf^XcXo`\j%
8kk_`jgf`ek`ek`d\k_\ÈefidXcdXkk\iÉ`ek_\le`m\ij\nXjZfdgfj\[Xcdfjk\oZcl$
j`m\cpf]_p[if^\eXe[_\c`ldXck_fl^_k_`j`jfecp]flig\iZ\ekf]k_\]lccjkfip2j\\
k_\Yfo1;XibdXkk\i% =ifdk_\j\^XjZcfl[jk_\ÔijkjkXij\d\i^\[Xe[k_\Ôijkm`j`Yc\
gifkf$^XcXo`\jn\i\]fid\[#\e[`e^n_Xk`jbefneXjk_\È;Xib8^\j%É
K_\\Xic`\jk^XcXo`\jfYj\im\[jf]Xi[Xk\YXZbkfifl^_cp.,'d`cc`fep\XijX]k\ik_\9`^
9Xe^# Ylk \Xic`\i ^XcXo`\j dXp n\cc \o`jk% 8ck_fl^_ .,' d`cc`fe p\Xij dXp j\\d c`b\ X
cfe^k`d\#n_\eZfdgXi\[n`k_k_\le`m\ij\ËjX^\f](*%.Y`cc`fep\Xij#k_\Ôijk^XcXo`\j
]fid\[n`k_`ek_\ÔijkÔm\g\iZ\ekf]k_\le`m\ij\Ëjc`]\k`d\%:fdgXi\[kfXeXm\iX^\
_ldXec`]\jgXek_\le`m\ij\_X[efkp\ki\XZ_\[jZ_ffcX^\%8cfk_Xgg\e\[`ek_\le`$
m\ij\Ëj`e]XeZp
*+
<mfclk`fef]>XcXo`\j
K_\Zfem\ek`feXcg`Zkli\f]^XcXop]fidXk`fe#k_\d\i^\i_pgfk_\j`j#\ogcX`ejk_Xkgifkf$
^XcXo`\j^i\nXe[\mfcm\[`ek_\\Xicple`m\ij\Ypk_\È]lj`feÉf]jdXcc\iYl`c[`e^YcfZb
^XcXo`\j%CXi^\jbpjlim\pj_Xm\j_fneljk_Xk^XcXo`\j`ek_\e\XiYpXe[È_Xc]$[`jkXekÉ
le`m\ij\j\\dkf^Xk_\i`ecXi^\ÔcXd\ekj#Zi\Xk`e^X^i\XkZfjd`Zn\Y%K_\`ek\ij\Z$
k`fejn_\i\k_\ÔcXd\ekjd\\kXi\_fd\kfk_\[\ej\jkZcljk\ijf]^XcXo`\j%
N\Xcjfbefnk_Xkn`k_`eXY`cc`fep\Xijf]X^XcXopËj]fidXk`fe#b\pjkilZkli\jY\^`e
Y\ m`j`Yc\% >cfYlcXi Zcljk\ij# k_\ Z\ekiXc jlg\idXjj`m\ YcXZb _fc\# Xe[ X ^XcXZk`Z Ylc^\
f]jkXij]fid%K_\Zi\Xk`fef]k_\jlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\Xgg\XijkfgcXpXb\pifc\`e
XZk`m\cpi\^lcXk`e^k_\^ifnk_f]X^XcXop%@k^ifnjYp\Xk`e^`eefZ\ekjkXijk_Xk_Xgg\e
kf Zfd\ kff Zcfj\# Ylk Xcjf `eÕl\eZ\j k_\ Y`ik_ f] e\n jkXij% FYj\imXk`fej f] [`jkXek
^XcXo`\jXcjfj_fnk_Xk[li`e^k_`j\Xicp\gfZ_`ek_\le`m\ij\Ëjc`]\#^XcXo`\jle[\i^fX
dXafiYlijkf]jkXi]fidXk`fe%
;\jg`k\`kjdXepjlZZ\jj\j#k_`jZfem\ek`feXcg`Zkli\_Xj`kjc`d`kXk`fej%@kZXeefkZfd$
gc\k\cp\ogcX`ek_\mXi`\kpf]j_Xg\jn\fYj\im\`e^XcXo`\j#]ifdk_\]\Xkli\c\jjifle[
\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jkfk_\gXeZXb\$ÕXk[`jb^XcXo`\j%
<mfclk`fef]Jg`iXc>XcXo`\j
Fe\f]k_\dX`eZ_Xcc\e^\j]fik_\d\i^\i_pgfk_\j`j`jkf\ogcX`ek_\^i\XkeldY\if]
jg`iXc^XcXo`\j`ek_\gi\j\ekle`m\ij\Çdfi\k_Xe_Xc]f]k_\fYj\im\[^XcXo`\j%Jg`iXcj
Xi\]iX^`c\#Xe[`ek\iXZk`fejn`k_e\XiYp^XcXo`\jhl`Zbcp[\jkifpk_\`ij_Xg\%@kdXpY\
k_Xkk_\jg`iXcjn\j\\_Xm\efkp\k`ek\iXZk\[n`k_fk_\icXi^\^XcXo`\j#Xe[k_Xkk_`j`j
k_\i\Xjfek_\pjk`cc_Xm\k_\`iY\Xlk`]lcjkilZkli\Xe[fe^f`e^jkXi]fidXk`fe%
;li`e^k_\Ôijk]\nY`cc`fep\Xijf]X^XcXopËjc`]\#k_\XZZldlcXk\[dXkk\ij\kkc\j`ekfX
^XcXZk`Z[`jb%K_\^XcXopZfek`el\jkfXYjfiY`e]Xcc`e^dXk\i`Xc]ifd_`^_m\cfZ`kpZcfl[j
*,
K_\Xjkifefd\i=i`kqQn`ZbpnXjk_\Ôijkkfefk`Z\k_\Èd`jj`e^dXjjÉ`e(0**#fYj\im`e^k_\dfk`fejf]k_\^XcXo`\je\Xik_\\[^\jf]k_\:fdX:cljk\i%K_\
d\Xjli\[dfk`fef]k_\^XcXo`\j`ek_\Zcljk\i`jkff]Xjk]fik_\dkfY\_\c[kf^\k_\ijfc\cpYpk_\^iXm`kpf]k_\m`j`Yc\jkXijZfdgi`j`e^k_\^XcXo`\j%
8efk_\iÈ[XibdXkk\iÉd`c\jkfe\nXjk_\fYj\imXk`fef]ifkXk`feZlim\j`ejg`iXc^XcXo`\j%@e(0.,#M\iXIlY`e[`jZfm\i\[k_Xkk_\jkXij`ejg`iXc^XcXo`\j
fiY`kn`k_ifl^_cpk_\jXd\jg\\[#n`k_flkk_\\og\Zk\[jcfn\idfk`fee\Xik_\\[^\f]k_\m`j`Yc\gXikjf]k_\^XcXop%K_`ji\jlckj_fn\[k_XklgnXi[jf]
,'g\iZ\ekf]k_\dXjjf]^XcXo`\j`jZfekX`e\[`ek_\i\cXk`m\cp[Xib^XcXZk`Z_Xcf%
K_\eXkli\Xe[Zfdgfj`k`fef]k_`jlej\\edXkk\ii\dX`elebefne%@kZfejk`klk\jX_Xggp_lek`e^^ifle[]fifYj\im\ijXe[k_\fi\k`Z`Xej%GifgfjXcj_Xm\
`eZcl[\[Yifne[nXi]jkXijXe[gcXe\kjZfcc\Zk`m\cpZXcc\[D8:?Fj #hlXekldYcXZb_fc\jgif[lZ\[`ek_\\Xicple`m\ij\#Zcfl[jf][Xib^Xj#fi[`eXipXe[
_\Xmpe\lki`efj#Xe[Xn_fc\qfff]\ofk`ZgXik`Zc\j#jlZ_XjN\Xbcp@ek\iXZk`e^DXjj`m\GXik`Zc\j%
I\jlckj]ifdk_\N`cb`ejfeD`ZifnXm\8e`jfkifgpGifY\Xe[fk_\ik\c\jZfg\jc\X[kfk_\jfd\n_Xk[`jZfliX^`e^ZfeZclj`fek_XkXccf]flik\Z_efcf^pXe[
YiX`egfn\ijf]Xi_XjfecpdXeX^\[kfk\ccljXYflkk_\Zfejk`kl\ekjf]+g\iZ\ekf]k_\Zfjdfj%8cdfjkXhlXik\if]k_\i\jkf]k_\le`m\ij\`jZfdgfj\[f]
[XibdXkk\i))g\iZ\ek #n_`c\k_\i\dX`e`e^.+g\iZ\ek`j`ek_\]fidf]k_\\m\edfi\\clj`m\Xe[dpjk\i`flj[Xib\e\i^p#XYflkn_`Z_n\befn_Xi[cp
Xepk_`e^%N_Xkn\[fbefn`jk_Xk[Xib\e\i^p\o\ikjXi\glcj`m\]fiZ\fek_\le`m\ij\k_Xkfggfj\jk_\^iXm`kXk`feXcXkkiXZk`feY\kn\\e^XcXo`\jXe[
k_\i\]fi\Ôkjn\ccn`k_i\Z\ekfYj\imXk`fejk_Xkk_\\ogXej`fef]k_\le`m\ij\`jXZZ\c\iXk`e^%
K?<9LCC<K:CLJK<I
G\i_Xgjk_\dfjkZfem`eZ`e^\m`[\eZ\]fi[XibdXkk\i`jk_\9lcc\k:cljk\i%K_`j`jXZklXccpZfdgfj\[f]knfZfcc`[`e^Zcljk\ij#dXepd\dY\ijf]n_`Z_ZXe
Y\j\\e`ek_\YXZb^ifle[m`j`Yc\$c`^_k`dX^\%Fm\icX`[fek_`j`jk_\[`jki`Ylk`fef]k_\dXafi`kpf]k_\efidXcdXkk\i`ei\[Xm\ip_fkO$iXp\d`kk`e^^Xj
Xe[XdXgf]k_\dXafi`kpf]k_\dXjjf]k_\Zcljk\i`eYcl\d\Xjli\[]ifdk_\\]]\Zkf]^iXm`kXk`feXcc\ej`e^ %K_\f]]j\kY\kn\\ek_\i\[O$iXp^XjXe[
k_\Ycl\dXjjd\Xjli\d\ekj_fnjXeXdXq`e^[`]]\i\eZ\Y\kn\\ek_\efidXcXe[k_\[XibdXkk\i`ek_\knfZcljk\ij%K_\i\[Ylcc\k$j_Xg\[Zcldgfek_\
i`^_k`jk_\_fk^Xj]ifdfe\Zcljk\i#n_`Z_gXjj\[k_ifl^_k_\_fk^Xj]ifdk_\fk_\icXi^\iZcljk\i[li`e^k_\Zfcc`j`fe%9fk_^XjZcfl[jn\i\jcfn\[YpX
[iX^]fiZ\#j`d`cXikfX`ii\j`jkXeZ\#[li`e^k_\Zfcc`j`fe%@eZfekiXjk#k_\[XibdXkk\i`eYcl\ nXjefkjcfn\[Ypk_\`dgXZkY\ZXlj\`kÇXggXi\ekcpÇ[f\j
efk`ek\iXZk[`i\Zkcpn`k_`kj\c]fik_\^Xj\oZ\gkk_ifl^_^iXm`kp%K_`ji\jlck`j[iXdXk`Z[`i\Zk\m`[\eZ\k_Xkdfjkf]k_\dXkk\i`ek_\Zcljk\ij`j[Xib#Xe[
m\ip[`]]\i\ek]ifdefidXcdXkk\i
Xe[[nXi]^XcXo`\jk_ifl^_flk`kjc`]\%K_`jdXkk\i`jdfjkcp_p[if^\eXe[_\c`ld%K_\
ZpZc\f]jk\ccXiY`ik_Xe[[\Xk_jcfncp`eZi\Xj\jk_\XYle[XeZ\f]\c\d\ekj_\Xm`\ik_Xe
_p[if^\eXe[_\c`ld%
K_\k_\fi`\j]fik_\]fidXk`fef]jg`iXc^XcXo`\j`eZcl[\k_\Zcljk\i`e^f][XibdXkk\i
_Xcfj%@ek_\\Xicple`m\ij\#^XcXo`\jn\i\Zfdgfj\[dfjkcpf]^XjXe[[XibdXkk\iXe[
efk kff dXep jkXij% 9p XZZi\k`e^ jdXcc\i ^XcXo`\j X jg`iXc ^XcXop ÈnXeeXY\É Y\Zfd\j
dfi\dXjj`m\#n_`c\k_\[XibdXkk\i`jdfjkcpZfeZ\ekiXk\[`eX_Xcf`e`kjflk\igXikj%
K_\^Xj#_fn\m\i#ZfekiXZkji\cXk`m\cphl`ZbcpXe[XjXZfej\hl\eZ\Y\^`ejkfifkXk\]Xjk$
\i#aljkXjXjg`ee`e^jbXk\ijg\\[jlg`]j_\glccj`e_\iXidj%K_\ÔeXci\jlck`jXk_`eXe[
iXg`[cpifkXk`e^[`jb^XcXop%
N_p k_\ ZfekiXZk`fe jkfgj `j jk`cc X dpjk\ip# Xe[ Zfdglk\i j`dlcXk`fej f] [`jb ^XcXop
]fidXk`fe_Xm\efkp\kY\\eXYc\kf]lccpi\gif[lZ\k_\ifkXk`fejg\\[Xe[j`q\f]k_\j\
[`jb^XcXo`\j%@k_XjY\\ejl^^\jk\[k_XkiX[`Xk`fe]ifdYi`^_k#e\ncp]fid\[jkXij#fi
k_\jlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\`edfjk#fiXcc#^XcXopZ\ek\ij#ZXei\^lcXk\k_\gifZ\jjYp
jcfn`e^k_\ZfekiXZk`fef]X[`jbXj`k]fidj%@k_XjXcjfY\\ejl^^\jk\[k_Xkk_\_Xcff]
k_\[XibdXkk\iZXe\o\ikXÈ[iX^Éfek_\^XcXop#k_ljjkfgg`e^[`jbZfekiXZk`fe%DXpY\
Xci\X[p Xk k_`j jkX^\ ^XcXop Zfcc`j`fej Xe[ d\i^\ij gcXp Xe `dgfikXek ifc\ Yp ]\\[`e^
Èe\nÉ^XjjkXijXe[[XibdXkk\ikf^XcXo`\j%
<mfclk`fef]<cc`gk`ZXc>XcXo`\j
K_\kiX[`k`feXcgfikiX`kf]\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jgX`ekjk_\dXj^XcXo`\jn_\i\jkXi]fidX$
k`fe_XjÔe`j_\[X]k\ik_\`e`k`XcYlijk#c\Xm`e^k_\dkfj_`e\n`k_fecpk_\c`^_k]ifd
k_\`iX^`e^jkXij%@ek_\flk\ii\^`fej#cXi^\\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jkpg`ZXccp_Xm\Xe\ok\ej`m\
jpjk\df]^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij%
CXZbf]]fidXe[Xefc[jk\ccXigfglcXk`fe`e`k`Xccpc\[Xjkifefd\ijkfY\c`\m\k_Xk\cc`gk`$
ZXc^XcXo`\j]fid\[\Xic`\ik_Xejg`iXcj%?fn\m\i#i\Z\ekfYj\imXk`fej_Xm\]fle[pfle^#
*.
Ycl\jkXiZcljk\ij`ej`[\X]\n\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jXcfe^n`k_fk_\ijkilZkli\jk_XkZXeY\
\ogcX`e\[Yp^XcXZk`ZZfcc`j`fej%K_\d\i^\i_pgfk_\j`jgi\[`Zkjk_XkXe\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXop
`jk_\i\jlckf]Xcfe^gifZ\jjn_\i\knf^XcXo`\jf]ZfdgXiXYc\dXjj#f]Xepkpg\Zfc$
c`[\Xe[d\i^\%JlZ_dXafi^XcXZk`Zd\i^\ijXi\k_fl^_kkf_Xm\Y\\eZfddfe`e\Xicp
k`d\jYlkdXpjk`ccfZZli#k_fl^_c\jj]i\hl\ekcpkf[Xp%
FYj\imXk`feji\m\Xck_Xkifl^_cp_Xc]f]Xcc\cc`gk`ZXcj_Xm\]X`ekj_\ccjk_XkdXpY\k_\
i\jlckf]_\X[$feZfcc`j`fejn`k_jdXcc\i^XcXo`\j%8]k\ik_\Zfcc`j`fe#k_\ZXgkli\[jkXij
ifZbYXZbXe[]fik_Xe[]fidk_\]X`ekj_\ccjaljkXjnXk\i]fidji`ggc\jn_\en\kfjjX
ifZb`ekfXgfe[%
N`k_k_\d\i^\i_pgfk_\j`j#`k`jkf[Xpn`[\cpXZZ\gk\[k_Xkk_\dX`e[i`m`e^]fiZ\]fi
k_\\mfclk`fef]\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j`jk_\d\i^\ijf]jdXcc\i^XcXo`\j%@]knfXggifXZ_`e^
^XcXo`\jXi\f]j`d`cXij`q\#k_\i\jlckXekd\i^\[^XcXopn`ccefki\j\dYc\\`k_\if]k_\
knfgi\$d\i^\i^XcXo`\j%;li`e^k_\d\i^\i#jkXijXe[[XibdXkk\i`e\XZ_^XcXopXi\
*/
E>:((*)#8>@8EK X]]\Zk\[Ypk_\XggifXZ_`e^^XcXop%KfnXi[k_\cXk\jkX^\jf]k_\d\i^\i#k_\j_Xg\f]
<CC@GK@:8C>8C8OP
k_\^XcXopZ_Xe^\jjfhl`Zbcpk_Xkjk\ccXifiY`kjXi\X]]\Zk\[[iXdXk`ZXccpXe[efcfe^\i
E>:((*)`jXZfjd`Z]fj$
Y\XiXepi\cXk`fekfk_\`ifi`^`eXcZflij\j%@]knfjg`iXc^XcXo`\jZfcc`[\#k_\`ijkXijdXp`e`$
j`cÇk_\X]k\idXk_f]Xe
k`XccpY\ifkXk`e^`eXefi[\icpdXee\i`ek_\gcXe\f]k_\[`jb#Ylk[li`e^k_\d\i^\i#k_`j
\efidfljdlck`$^XcXZk`Z
g`c\$lg#n_\i\k_\ZXieX^\
fi[\i\[dfk`fe`jkiXej]fid\[`ekfiXe[fddfk`fej%K_\i\jlck`e^^XcXop`j[fd`eXk\[
f]Zfcc`j`feX]k\iZfcc`j`fe_Xj YpjkXijk_XkfiY`kk_\Z\ek\i`eXZfdgc\o#Xe[iXe[fd#n\Yf]fiY`kj#aljkk_\Y\_Xm`fi
Yl`cklgXYi`cc`XekYlk]lqqp n\j\\`e\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j%
^`Xek\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXop]Xiflk$
j_`e`e^kpg`ZXc^XcXo`\j%E>: JkXi]fidXk`fenXjdfi\gifefleZ\[[li`e^k_\d\i^\ijk_Xk]fid\[dfjkf]k_\\cc`g$
((*)#kf^\k_\in`k_k_\jdXcc
k`ZXc^XcXo`\jn\j\\kf[Xp#n_`Z_c`b\cpfZZlii\[Y\kn\\efe\Xe[k\eY`cc`fep\XijX^f#
[nXi]^XcXo`\jjliifle[`e^`k#
n_\e k_\i\ nXj dlZ_ dfi\ ^Xj Xe[ k_lj dfi\ dfc\ZlcXi Zcfl[j `e ^XcXo`\j% 8nXp
Xi\[lYY\[XÈ]fjj`c^iflg#É
Xjk_\pXi\dfjkc`b\cpk_\
]ifdk_\Z\ek\if]k_\^XcXop#^XjZcfl[jiXe`ekf\XZ_fk_\iXe[gif[lZ\[j_fZbjk_Xk
i\dX`ejf]X^iflgf]^XcXo`\j jk`dlcXk\[k_\]fidXk`fef]e\njkXij%K_\i\jlckf]Xcck_`jm`fc\eZ\`jk_Xk\cc`gk`ZXcj
k_Xkd\i^\[kf^\k_\i`ek_\ k\e[kf_Xm\m\ipc`kkc\^XjXmX`cXYc\kf]fide\njkXijX]k\ik_\pd\i^\%
i\Z\ekgXjk%E>:((*)`jj\\e
jliifle[\[Ypk_fljXe[j
f]XeZ`\ek^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij#
jnXid`e^Xifle[k_\^XcXop
c`b\Y\\jXifle[X_`m\%K_\j\
^cfYlcXiZcljk\ijXi\c`b\cp
kfY\k_\jlim`mfijf]k_\
[`jilgk`fef]k_\`iZXee`YXc$
`q\[gXi\ek^XcXo`\jk_Xk_Xm\
Y\\e\Xk\eYpE>:((*)Xe[
dXpi\m\Xc`kjd\i^\i_`jkfip%
@ek_\YXZb^ifle[#k_\i\`jX
jklee`e^kXg\jkipf]eld\i$
flj^XcXo`\jk_XkXi\dlZ_
]Xik_\iXnXp%
+&
E>:*),-
C`b\dXa\jk`Zj_`gj`ek_\^iXe[\jke`^_k#^XcXo`\jZXejc`g\m\i
E>:*),-`jXe`dgi\jj`m\
\oXdgc\f]Xg\Zlc`Xi^XcXop%
Zcfj\i lek`c k_\`i dlklXc ^iXm`kXk`feXc `ek\iXZk`fe Y\^`ej kf
K_\k\cckXc\j`^ejf]k_\
Zfcc`j`feXi\knf\ok\e[\[
cld`efljkX`cjjn`ic`e^flk dfc[k_\d`ekf`eki`ZXk\Ô^li\jk_XkXi\ÔeXccp#Xe[`ii\m\ij`Ycp#
]ifdk_\^XcXop%E>:*),-
Y\cfe^jkfk_\?p[iX$:\ekXl$ nfm\ekf^\k_\i%@k`jXe`dd\ej\Zfjd`Z[XeZ\#Z_fi\f^iXg_\[
iljjlg\iZcljk\iZfdgc\oXe[
gifm`[\jXe\XiYpk\dgcXk\
Yp^iXm`kp%
]fijkl[p`e^k_\gifg\ik`\j
f]pfle^jkXiZcljk\ij`e
k`[XckX`cj%K_\jpjk\d_`[\jX
[flYc\elZc\ljXe[XkXe^c\
f][ljkcXe\j`ek_\Z\ekiXc
i\^`fe%K_\kX`cjXi\jkl[[\[
n`k_XgXik`ZlcXicp_`^_[\e$
j`kpf]jkXiZcljk\ij%
+)
N _\eknffidfi\^XcXo`\jZfcc`[\#`kËjefkc`b\dXiYc\j_`kk`e^\XZ_fk_\i%K_\`e$
[`m`[lXc Zfdgfe\ekj f] ^XcXo`\j Ç jkXij# [ljk# ^Xj# [Xib dXkk\i Ç Xi\ jgi\X[
n`[\cpXe[dXpgXjjle_Xid\[k_ifl^_k_\Zfcc`j`fe%8knfijk#^iXm`kpn`ccÕ`e^k_\d
flknXi[j# Zi\Xk`e^ cfe^ jki\Xd\ij k_Xk jki\kZ_ ]fi X _le[i\[ k_fljXe[ c`^_k$p\Xij fi
\m\edfi\%
K_\ Zfcc`[`e^ ^XcXo`\j k_\dj\cm\j# kiXgg\[ `e k_\`i [\X[cp ^iXm`kXk`feXc \dYiXZ\# n`cc
Zfek`el\kffiY`k\XZ_fk_\i#i`gg`e^flk^Xj#jkXij#Xe[Zi\Xk`e^kiX`cjf]dXkk\i`ek_\
Zfjdfj%<m\eklXccp#_le[i\[jf]d`cc`fejf]p\XijcXk\i#k_\^XcXo`\j`emfcm\[`ek_\Zfcc`$
j`fen`ccj\kkc\`ekffe\j`e^c\#ZfdY`e\[^XcXop%@k`jY\c`\m\[k_Xkdfjk`]efkXccgi\j\ek$
[Xp^XcXo`\j#`eZcl[`e^k_\D`cbpNXp#n\i\]fid\[]ifdjlZ_XZfXc\jZ\eZ\f]jdXcc\i
^XcXo`\j#fZZlii`e^fm\iY`cc`fejf]p\Xij%
:fjdfcf^`jkjk_`ebk_Xkk_`j`j_fn^XcXo`\j^ifn#k_ifl^_Xe`eki`ZXk\gifZ\jjf]Zfe$
k`elfljd\i^\ij%>XcXo`\j^ifnY`^^\iYp[\mfli`e^jdXcc\ife\j#[nXi]^XcXo`\jY\`e^
k_\]Xmfi`k\d\Xcjf]cXi^\i^XcXo`\j%
Dfi\ Zfddfe `e k_\ \Xicp le`m\ij\ k_Xe k_\p Xi\ kf[Xp# ^XcXop d\i^\ij Xi\ k_fl^_k
kfY\Xgi`dXip[i`m`e^]fiZ\f]Zfjd`Z\mfclk`fe#jgXib`e^]i\e\k`ZY`ik_jXe[\ogcfj`m\
jk\ccXi[\Xk_j%FlifneD`cbpNXpZfekX`ejk_\[\Yi`jf]k_\dXepjdXcc\i^XcXo`\j`k_Xj
\eZflek\i\[Xe[[\mfli\[fm\iY`cc`fejf]p\Xij%9lk\m\efli^XcXop`jefkXkk_\kfgf]
k_\]ff[Z_X`ej\\:_Xgk\i, %
K_\=`ijkFYj\imXk`fej
FliljlXc`dgi\jj`fef]k_\jkXiipe`^_kjbp`jk_Xkf]Xe\Xicpdfk`fec\jj[fd\%8j`e^c\
_ldXec`]\jgXe`jaljkk_\Yc`ebf]Xe\p\feXZfjdfcf^`ZXck`d\jZXc\%@ei\Xc`kp#k_\
le`m\ij\`jc`b\XZ_lie`e^ZXlc[ife#`eZfejkXekdfm\d\ek#Ylkn\nflc[e\\[kfnXkZ_
`k]fimXjkcpcfe^\ik_XeXc`]\k`d\kfg\iZ\`m\k_\dfk`fejf]dfjkjkXijXe[^XcXo`\j%
+*
>`m\e\efl^_k`d\#n\nflc[j\\jkXijXe[^XcXo`\jdfm\%JkXijfiY`kk_\Z\ek\if]k_\
D`cbpNXp#Xe[^XcXo`\jXi\glcc\[kf^\k_\iYp\XZ_fk_\iËj^iXm`kp#Zfcc`[`e^Xe[\m\ekl$
Xccp^\e\iXk`e^Èe\nÉ^XcXo`\j%
K_\Ôijki\Zfi[\[^XcXop`ek\iXZk`fej^fYXZbY\]fi\n\be\nk_Xk^XcXo`\jn\i\dX[\
f] jkXij# [ljk# Xe[ [Xib dXkk\i% N`cc`Xd GXijfej# k_\ k_`i[ <Xic f] Ifjj\# fYj\im\[ k_\
_\Xm\ej`e@i\cXe[n`k__`j]Xdflj(%/$d\k\i.)$`eZ_ k\c\jZfg\#ZXcc\[k_\ÈC\m`Xk_Xe
f]GXijfejkfne%É8[iXn`e^_\dX[\`e(/+,j_fnjefkfecpk_\Zc\Xijg`iXcjkilZkli\
f]k_\N_`icgffc>XcXopD\jj`\i,( Ylkfe\f]k_\jg`iXcXidjZfee\Zk`e^kf`kjZfd$
gXe`fe^XcXop%:fdgXi`e^k_`j[iXn`e^n`k_Xi\Z\ek?lYYc\`dX^\j_fnjXi\dXibXYc\
i\j\dYcXeZ\%Efkfecpk_\gcXZ\d\ekf]k_\Zfee\Zk`feXidY\kn\\ek_\dX`e^XcXop
Xe[k_\ZfdgXe`feXi\`eY\Xlk`]lcX^i\\d\ekn`k_i\Xc`kp#Ylkk_\[Xib[ljkgXkZ_\j
jkXe[flkn_\i\k_\dX`e^XcXopZifjj\j`e]ifekf]k_\ZfdgXe`fe%
++
K_\=`ijkJ`dlcXk`fej K?<=@IJKI<:FI;<;
>8C8OP:FCC@J@FE
D\jj`\i,(Xjj\\eYpN`cc`Xd
N`k_k_\X[m\ekf]g_fkf^iXg_pXe[k_\`eZi\Xj`e^j`q\f]k\c\jZfg\j#dfi\Xe[dfi\
GXijfe`e(/+,kfg Xe[
`ek\iXZk`e^ jpjk\dj Zflc[ Y\ i\Zf^e`q\[# Xe[ k_`j eXkliXccp XkkiXZk\[ k_\ `ek\i\jk f]
k_\?lYYc\JgXZ\K\c\jZfg\
k_\fi\k`Z`Xej% 8ifle[ (0+' k_\ Jn\[`j_ Xjkifefd\i <i`b ?fcdY\i^ nXj ZXkXcf^`e^ Yfkkfd %N`cc`XdGXijfeËj
Zcfj\gX`ijf]^XcXo`\jXe[Y\^Xekfnfe[\in_Xknflc[_Xgg\ekf^XcXo`\jXjk_\pXg$ [iXn`e^`jk_\Ôijkbefne
gifXZ_\[\XZ_fk_\i%?\j_fn\[k_Xk^XcXo`\jf]k\eXgg\Xi`e^iflgjXe[gX`ij#Xe[_\ [\g`Zk`fef]`ek\iXZk`e^^Xc$
Xcjfi\Xc`q\[k_Xk`knflc[Y\gfjj`Yc\#lj`e^jkXk`jk`Zj#kf[\k\id`e\k_\dXjj\jf]gX`ij Xo`\jÇcfe^Y\]fi\g\fgc\
\m\ebe\nn_Xk^XcXo`\j
f]^XcXo`\jbefn`e^k_\dfk`fejf]k_\Zfdgfe\ekj%K_\fYj\imXk`fejXcjfi\jlck\[`e
i\Xccpn\i\%
k_\[`jZfm\ipk_XkjXk\cc`k\^XcXo`\jf]k\edfm\`eZ\ikX`efiY`kj#n_`Z_`jbefneXjk_\
È?fcdY\i^\]]\Zk%É
;li`e^ k_\ \Xicp gXik f] k_\ J\Zfe[ Nfic[ NXi# ?fcdY\i^ [\m`j\[ Xe \okiXfi[`eXi`cp
Zc\m\i\og\i`d\ek`eX[Xib\e\[YXie`eJn\[\e%?\lj\[c`^_kYlcYjkfi\gi\j\ekk_\
jk\ccXi [`jki`Ylk`fe `e X ^XcXop# Xe[ k_\ `ek\ej`kp f] k_\ c`^_k j`dlcXk\[ ^iXm`kXk`feXc
jki\e^k_%K_\^iXm`kXk`feXc]fiZ\jn\i\k_\ed\Xjli\[Ypg_fkfZ\ccj#Xe[jf?fcdY\i^
Zflc[#jk\gYpjk\g#Xe[n`k_ZXi\Xe[gXk`\eZ\#]fccfn\m\ekjXjknf^XcXo`\jgXjj\[
Zcfj\kf\XZ_fk_\i%?\nXjXYc\kfj_fnk_XkjlZ_Zfcc`j`fejZXedXb\^XcXo`\jjg`iXc
Zcfj\ikf^\k_\iXe[d\i^\#Xe[\m\e]fle[k_\il[`d\ekjf]k_\k`[Xcjg`iXcjkilZkli\j#
Yi`[^\j#Xe[kX`cjk_XkXi\jf]Xd`c`Xikf[Xp%@e(0+(?fcdY\i^glYc`j_\[k_\i\jlckjf]
k_`j`e^\e`fljXeXcf^j`dlcXk`feÇgifYXYcp_`jdfjkj`^e`ÔZXeknfibfek_\\]]\Zkjf]
`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\j%
?fcdY\i^Ëj \og\i`d\ek nXj jf X_\X[ f] `kj k`d\ k_Xk _`j i\jlckj n\i\ efk ZfeÔid\[
lek`cXYflk*'p\XijcXk\i%@ek_\d\Xek`d\#fYj\imXk`fejf]Zfcc`[`e^^XcXo`\j_X[Y\^le
kf j_fn Xe XdXq`e^ mXi`\kp f] ]fidj% JkXik`e^ ]ifd k_\ GXcfdXi Jbp Jlim\p# 9fi`j 8%
Mfifekjfm$M\cpXd`efm`eDfjZfnZXkXcf^\[`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\jXe[fk_\if[[`k`\jXe[
glYc`j_\[_`jÔijkZXkXcf^#7jbWiWdZ9WjWbe]k[e\?dj[hWYj_d]=WbWn_[i#GXik(#`e(0,0%
K_`jnXjXc`d`k\[g_fkf^iXg_`Zgi`ek`e^`eIljj`XeXe[nXjefk[`jki`Ylk\[Xjn`[\cpXj
`k[\j\im\[#\jg\Z`Xccp`ek_\N\jk%
+-
=fccfn`e^k_`jnfibXe[X[[`e^fk_\i^XcXo`\jXj_\Y\ZXd\XnXi\f]k_\d#k_\Xjkifef$
d\i?Xckfe8ig`e(0-)klie\[k_\^i\Xk\p\f]GXcfdXifek_\**/g\Zlc`XiXe[`ek\iXZk$
`e^^XcXo`\j`ccljkiXk\[`e_`j]Xdflj(0--XkcXj#J^[7jbWie\F[Ykb_Wh=WbWn_[i#n_`Z_jk`cc
i\gi\j\ekjjfd\f]k_\Ôe\jk^XcXop`dX^\j\m\ifYkX`e\[g_fkf^iXg_`ZXccp%Jfd\f]_`j
^XcXopgX`ijn\i\efkfecp[`jkfik\[Ylkj_fn\[Zfee\Zk`e^ÔcXd\ekjf]jkXijk_XkZ_Xc$
c\e^\[k_\Zfek\dgfiXip`ekl`k`m\le[\ijkXe[`e^f]k_\nfib`e^jf]^iXm`kp%
8ig Zfdg`c\[ k_\ ZXkXcf^ `e X g`fe\\i`e^ Xkk\dgk kf jfcm\ k_\ dpjk\ip f] k_\ Y`qXii\
j_Xg\jf]^XcXo`\jfYj\im\[%?\Xcjfnfib\[n`k_9XiipDX[fi\#Zfdg`c`e^Xdfi\Zfd$
gi\_\ej`m\jlim\pf]k_\jflk_\iejbp#glYc`j_\[`e(0/.%Kf[Xp#k_\g\Zlc`Xi`kpf]k_\
^XcXopjkilZkli\jj\\eYp8igXe[fk_\ij`jefnn\ccle[\ijkff[#Zi\Xk\[Yp^iXm`kpËj
gXikcp[\jkilZk`m\#gXikcpZi\Xk`m\#[XeZ\Xj^XcXo`\jZfcc`[\%
9\Xlk`]lc[`^`kXcjZXejf]k_\fc[g_fkf^iXg_`ZgcXk\jZXeY\\oXd`e\[fec`e\XkE8J8Ëj
<okiX^XcXZk`Z;XkXYXj\%J\\k_\I\jfliZ\jj\Zk`fe`ek_\YXZbf]k_`jYffb%
I\XcZfdglk\ij`dlcXk`fejf]d\i^`e^^XcXo`\jn\i\g`fe\\i\[Ypknf<jkfe`XeYifk_$
\ij#8cXiXe[Ali`Kffdi\#`e(0.)%K_\p[\dfejkiXk\[k_XkZfcc`j`fejXi\]Xidfi\Zfd$
dfek_Xegi\m`fljcpk_fl^_kXe[k_XkgX`ijf]^XcXo`\jXggifXZ_\XZ_fk_\iXkm\ip_`^_
+.
m\cfZ`k`\jÇ_le[i\[jf]k_fljXe[jf]b`cfd\k\ijg\i_fli%9lkY\ZXlj\k_\[`jkXeZ\j
Y\kn\\ek_\jkXijXi\jfcXi^\#m\ip]\nXZklXcZfcc`j`fejY\kn\\ejkXijfZZli%Dfjkf]
k_\`ek\iXZk`feXj^XcXo`\jd\i^\`j^iXm`kXk`feXc#k_\glccf]k_\^`XekdXjj\j^\e\iXk`e^
`dd\ej\k`[Xc]fiZ\jXZifjjk_\`ek\id`e^c`e^jkXij%
K_\Kffdi\Yifk_\ijlj\[Zfdglk\ik\Z_e`hl\jÇhlX`ekcpgi`d`k`m\ZfdgXi\[kfdf[$
\iefe\jÇkfdf[\ck_\N_`icgffc>XcXopXe[jfd\f]k_\dfjkglqqc`e^f]8igËjgX`ij
Ç k_\ D`Z\ gX^\ /. Xe[ k_\ 8ek\eeX\ ^XcXo`\j Zfm\i `dX^\ % Dfjk Xjkifg_pj`Z`jkj
]fle[ k_Xk k_\`i `ekl`k`fe XYflk _fn ^iXm`kp Zflc[ `eÕl\eZ\ ^XcXo`\j _X[ c\[ k_\d
XjkiXp#Y\ZXlj\^XcXo`\jZfekX`edXkk\ijgi\X[fm\iXn`[\Xi\XXe[k_lji\jgfe[m\ip
[`]]\i\ekcpkfX[`jkliYXeZ\%K_\Xdflekf]È[XdX^\É`j_`^_cp[\g\e[\ekfek_\i\cXk`m\
+/
m\cfZ`k`\jf]k_\knf^XcXo`\j#k_\Xe^c\f]`eZ`[\eZ\#k_\`ijg`em\cfZ`kp#jg`e[`i\Zk`fe
Xe[dfi\%
9\ZXlj\f]k_\c`d`kXk`fejf]Zfdglk\ijXkk_Xkk`d\#k_\Kffdi\j_X[kfdXb\XeldY\i
f]j`dgc`ÔZXk`fej%K_\pZfeZ\ekiXk\[k_\dXjj`ek_\Z\ek\if]\XZ_^XcXop#dX[\\XZ_
Zfdglk\[gf`ekjkXe[`e]fiXY`cc`fejkXij#\kZ%K_\pjk`ccdXeX^\[kfYl`c[Xe`dgi\j$
j`m\ ZXj\ \ogcX`e`e^ k_\ Zflek\i`ekl`k`m\ k`[Xc ]\Xkli\j% 8j Zfdglk\i j`dlcXk`fej _Xm\
\mfcm\[Xcfe^n`k_k_\k\Z_efcf^p#k_\p_Xm\Y\Zfd\dfi\Xe[dfi\i\Xc`jk`Z#dXkZ_`e^
efkfecpk_\j_Xg\jf]^XcXopgX`ijYlkk_\`ifYj\im\[`ek\ieXcdfk`fejXe[kiXZ`e^jkXij#
Zfc[^Xj#Xe[lej\\e[XibdXkk\i`e[\g\e[\ekcp%K_\eldY\if]gXik`Zc\jXe[k_\c\m\c
f]jfg_`jk`ZXk`fei\XZ_e\n_\`^_kj\m\ipp\Xi%
,&
JkXi9`ik_
=ifdfYj\imXk`fejf]^XcXZk`ZZfcc`j`fej`k`jZc\Xik_Xkefkfecpk_\j_Xg\jf]k_\Z_Xi$
XZk\ij`emfcm\[Z_Xe^\2k_\`iZfcfij#Yi`^_ke\jj\j#Xe[k\dg\iXkli\jXi\Xcjfdf[`Ô\[
[li`e^ k_\ `ek\iXZk`fe% FYj\imXk`fej `e k_\ `e]iXi\[ YXe[ j_fn k_Xk jfd\ `ek\iXZk`e^
^XcXo`\j _fjk k_\ dfjk \oki\d\ c\m\cj f] jkXi ]fidXk`fe n\ ZXe Ôe[ Xepn_\i\ `e kf$
[XpËj le`m\ij\% K_\ m`fc\ek ]fiZ\j [li`e^ X d\i^\i ZXe ki`^^\i jfd\ ^XcXo`\j kf dXb\
k_fljXe[jf]jfcXidXjj\jf]e\njkXij\XZ_p\Xi%@ek_\D`cbpNXpfecpXYflkfe\e\n
jkXi]fidjg\ip\XifeXm\iX^\%8ck_fl^_jkXijXcdfjke\m\i^\kZcfj\\efl^_kfXZklXccp
Zfcc`[\`e^XcXopd\i^\ij#^`Xekdfc\ZlcXiZcfl[j[fZfcc`[\n`k_fk_\idfc\ZlcXiZcfl[j%
K_\j\Zfcc`j`fejk_\e`e[lZ\k_\Zcfl[jkfZfe[\ej\`ekfe\njkXij%
GX`ijfi^iflgjf]`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\jXi\`e^\e\iXcYcl\ik_Xe`jfcXk\[^XcXo`\j%=lik_\i$
dfi\k_\pXi\Ycl\i`eXnXpk_XkZXeY\XZZflek\[]fifecp`]k_\p_Xm\`eZi\Xj\[jkXi
]fidXk`fe%K_\L%J%ÆL%B%Æ;lkZ_@e]iXi\[8jkifefd`ZXcJXk\cc`k\@I8J [\k\Zk\[X_Xe[$
]lcf]^XcXo`\jk_Xkn\i\\okiXfi[`eXi`cpgfn\i]lc\d`kk\ijf]`e]iXi\[iX[`Xk`fe%Jfd\
f]k_\j\ÇeXd\[lckiXcld`eflj`e]iXi\[^XcXo`\jLC@I>j Ç\d`kXki`cc`fek`d\jXj
dlZ_\e\i^pXjk_\Jle#XcdfjkXccf]`k`ek_\[\\g`e]iXi\[%8dfe^k_\ÔijkjlZ_È@I8J
^XcXo`\jÉ`[\ek`Ô\[n\i\8ig))'gX^\-) Xe[E>:-)+'gX^\-* #knfjpjk\djn`k_
Xcck_\jkilZkliXcj`^ejf]Y\`e^^XcXopd\i^\ijm`\n\[Zcfj\kfk_\ÔeXcXZkXjk_\elZc\`
f]k_\knfgif^\e`kfijjg`iXckf^\k_\i%N`[\i$iXe^`e^jlim\pji\m\Xc\[k_XkXcdfjkXcc
LC@I>jXi\`e]XZkjkife^cp`ek\iXZk`e^fid\i^`e^^XcXo`\j%K_\\efidfljYlijkf]jkXi
]fidXk`fek_Xk^\e\iXk\jk_\\e\i^pkf_\Xk`kdljkjfd\_fnY\ki`^^\i\[Ypk_\^Xc$
XopZfcc`j`fe%
8 dXafi Xjg\Zk f] k_`j \okiX jkXi ]fidXk`fe `e Zfcc`[`e^ ^XcXo`\j nXj fecp gifg\icp i\$
m\Xc\[n_\e?lYYc\Ëjj_Xig\p\jn\i\klie\[kfnXi[jj\c\Zk\[jpjk\dj%8dfe^k_\fY$
j\imXkfipËjÔijkjZ`\ek`ÔZ[`jZfm\i`\jnXjk_Xk^XcXo`\jn`k_m\ipXZk`m\jkXi]fidXk`fe#
gXik`ZlcXicpk_fj\`eZfcc`[`e^Xe[d\i^`e^jpjk\dj#ZfekX`ecXi^\eldY\ijf]jlg\ijkXi
,'
,(
,)
Zcljk\ijÇZcljk\ijdfi\ZfdgXZkXe[i`Z_\i`epfle^jkXijk_Xen\Xi\lj\[kfj\\`e^
`eflie\`^_Yfi_ff[%Kf[Xpk_\i\`jXgXik`ZlcXi]fZljfeÔe[`e^flkn_Xkk_\j\dXjj`m\
jkXiZcljk\ijn`ccjfd\[Xpklie`ekf%K_\pcffbdlZ_Xjn\nflc[_Xm\\og\Zk\[k_\fc[
^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij`ek_\D`cbpNXpXe[fk_\i^XcXo`\jkf_Xm\Xgg\Xi\[n_\ek_\pn\i\
m\ippfle^%
@]\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\j`e[\\[klie`ekf^cfYlcXiZcljk\ij#`knflc[\c`d`eXk\Xe`dgfikXek
gifYc\dn`k_k_\d\i^\i_pgfk_\j`j%<cc`gk`ZXc^XcXo`\jf]k\e_Xm\XcXi^\ieldY\if]
^cfYlcXi Zcljk\ij ZfekX`e`e^ fc[ jkXij k_Xk nflc[ efk \Xj`cp jlim`m\ X d\i^`e^ \m\ek%
?fn\m\i# `] k_\ d\i^\ij gi\]\i\ek`Xccp Zi\Xk\ jkXij `e jlg\i jkXi Zcljk\ij# Xe[ `] k_\j\
\m\eklXccp \mfcm\ kf cffb c`b\ k_\ ^cfYlcXij# k_\ d\i^\i _pgfk_\j`j j\\dj kf \ogcX`e
k_`e^jn\cc%
=\\[`e^9cXZb?fc\j
8jlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\cfZXk\[XkX^XcXopËjZfi\]\\[jfek_\^XjXe[[`jilgk\[jkXij
Zfd`e^]ifdk_\jliifle[`e^^XcXop%8jk_\dXk\i`Xc]Xccj`enXi[j`kn`ccljlXccp]fid
`ekfXjg`ee`e^[`jbfiY`k`e^k_\YcXZb_fc\%8jdXccgfik`fef]k_\`e]Xcc`e^dXk\i`Xce\m\i
i\XZ_\jk_\YcXZb_fc\Ylk`jjglelgYpk_\jliifle[`e^dX^e\k`ZÔ\c[jXe[\a\Zk\[Xk
e\Xicpk_\jg\\[f]c`^_kXjfggfj`k\cp[`i\Zk\[a\kjj\\E>:++*/fegX^\)- Çf]k\e
iX[`Xk`e^Zfg`fljXdflekjf]iX[`fiX[`Xk`fe%@]fe\f]k_\a\kjgf`ekjifl^_cpkfnXi[j
lj#n\n`cc_Xm\Xi\cXk`m\cpZc\Xim`\nf]k_\i\^`fejm\ipZcfj\kfk_\YcXZb_fc\#n_\i\
dlZ_f]k_\c`^_k`j\d`kk\[#Xe[n\j\\XhlXjXi%@]n\j\\k_\[`jb\[^\$fe#flim`\n
f]k_\YcXZb_fc\XZk`fedXpY\fYjZli\[Ypk_\dXk\i`Xc`ek_\[`jb%@k`jfecp`ek_\cXjk
Zflgc\f][\ZX[\jk_XkXjkifefd\ij_Xm\Y\^lekfXggi\Z`Xk\_fnk_\dXep[`]]\i`e^
kpg\jf]jf$ZXcc\[XZk`m\^XcXo`\jZXeY\le[\ijkff[j`dgcp`ek\idjf]_fnk_\`iXgg\Xi$
XeZ\mXi`\j[\g\e[`e^fen_`Z_[`i\Zk`fen\m`\nk_\d]ifd%
K_\i\ _Xm\ cfe^ Y\\e _`ekj k_Xk ^XcXop Zfcc`j`fej dXb\ Zfe[`k`fej dfi\ ]XmfiXYc\ ]fi
k_\fZZlii\eZ\f]XZk`m\^XcXo`\j%Gfjj`Ycpk_\dfjkZfdg\cc`e^Zfee\Zk`feXgg\Xi\[`e
,*
,+
,,
,-
?lYYc\`dX^\jf]k_\^XcXo`\jXifle[hlXjXijgX^\-/ %K_\j\^XcXo`\jXi\ljlXccpcfjk
`ek_\Yi`cc`XekXe[Yclii\[c`^_kf]k_\Zfi\jXjj\\e]ifdk_\^ifle[%J\\en`k_?lYYc\
dXepf]k_\j\^XcXo`\jj_fn\[efkaljk`ek\iXZk`e^ZfdgXe`fejYlkXgXik`ZlcXikpg\
Çm\ipjdXccZfdgXe`fe^XcXo`\jcp`e^Zcfj\kffin`k_`ek_\hlXjXi^XcXop`kj\c]%JlZ_
X ZfeÔ^liXk`fe `j k_\fi\k`ZXccp m\ip \]]\Zk`m\ Xk Z_Xee\c`e^ jkXij Xe[ ^Xj `enXi[ Xe[
flknXi[`ek_\m`Zk`d^XcXopXe[`jfe\nXpk_XkX]fid\icp[fidXekYcXZb_fc\Zflc[
Y\iflj\[kfXe\g`jf[\f]hlXjXi\d`jj`fe%>Xj`j]\[kfk_\_l^\YcXZb_fc\`ek_\Z\e$
k\if]XdXjj`m\^XcXop#XZk`mXk`e^k_\elZc\lj`ekfi\c\Xj`e^le`dX^`eXYc\Xdflekjf]
\e\i^p%
K_\i\`j]lik_\i\m`[\eZ\k_XkXjlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\Xgg\XijkfY\XYc\kfi\^lcXk\
k_\^ifnk_f]^XcXo`\jk_ifl^_jfd\b`e[f]Çjf]XiÇleZ\ikX`e]\\[YXZbd\Z_Xe`jd%
@kdXpY\k_Xkk_\YcXZb_fc\]\\[jfek_\jliifle[`e^^XcXZk`ZdXk\i`Xc#gif[lZ`e^\efi$
dfljXdflekjf]\e\i^p\og\cc\[`ek_\]fidf]c`^_k Xe[_\Xk`ekfk_\jliifle[`e^
dXk\i`Xcjfk_Xk`kZXeefcfe^\iZffcXe[Zfe[\ej\`ekfjkXijXe[jfj_lkk`e^[fnejkXi
]fidXk`fe`ek_\_fjk^XcXo`\jfeZ\k_\p^ifncXi^\\efl^_%K_\YcXZb_fc\XZk`m`kpdXp
XcjfY\k_\Zlcgi`kY\_`e[\og\cc`e^n_Xki\j`[lXc^Xj`jc\]k`eXe\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXop#jfk_Xk
jkXi]fidXk`fe`j\]]\Zk`m\cpYcfZb\[X]k\iXZ\ikX`egf`ek%
,.
,/
-'
@ dX^`e\pflZflc[dfm\YXZbXe[]finXi[`ek`d\Xe[kiXm\c^i\Xk[`jkXeZ\jn`k_X
jg\\[^i\Xkcp\oZ\\[`e^k_\jg\\[f]c`^_k%FYj\im`e^X^XcXopZfcc`j`feXj`kle]fc[j
]ifdjkXikkfÔe`j_fm\iY`cc`fejf]p\Xij]ifdXccXe^c\jnflc[^`m\pflXjklee`e^m`\n
f]g_\efd\eXk_Xkeffe\_Xj\m\ij\\e`ei\Xc`kp%K_`j`jeXkliXccpXe`dgfjj`Yc\[i\Xd#
Ylk n\ ZXe ^f gXik f] k_\ nXp Yp lj`e^ jlg\iZfdglk\ij kf j`dlcXk\ X Zfcc`j`fe lj`e^
i\Xcg_pj`Zj%K_\m`jlXc`qXk`fef]X^XcXopZfcc`j`fej_fnekfk_\c\]k`ek_\gXe\cjfek_\
]fccfn`e^k_i\\gX^\j`jZi\Xk\[]ifdfe\j`e^c\jlg\iZfdglk\ij`dlcXk`feXe[j_fnj
k_\ \ek`i\ Zfcc`j`fe Xj X dfm`\ j\hl\eZ\ ]ifd [`]]\i\ek Xe^c\j% 8j n\ ZXeefk fYj\im\
k_\jXd\Zfcc`j`fefm\ik_\e\Z\jjXipk`d\jZXc\n\ZfdgXi\k_\j`dlcXk`fen`k_Z_\\[h#
[dj`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXopgX`ijfYj\im\[Yp?lYYc\%@k`jXY`kc`b\kip`e^kfi\ZfejkilZkk_\
ZlckliXcZfee\Zk`fejf]g\fgc\fe<Xik_]ifdaljkfe\jeXgj_fkf]\XZ_Z`kp%EfkXe\Xjp
kXjb#Ylk\m\ejfk_\Zfii\jgfe[\eZ\Y\kn\\ek_\j`dlcXk`fejXe[k_\g`Zkli\j`jjkle$
e`e^%K_`jZfdgXi`jfef]i\j\XiZ_j`dlcXk`fejn`k__`^_i\jfclk`fefYj\imXk`fejXccfnj
Xjkifefd\ijkfle[\ijkXe[k_\j\k`kXe`ZZiXj_\jY\kk\i%@k`jZc\Xik_XkdlZ_f]k_\[`$
m\ij`kpf]fYj\im\[^XcXopZfcc`j`fej`j[l\`egXikkfk_\mXip`e^Xe^c\jn\fYj\im\k_\d
]ifdXe[k_\[`]]\i\ekk`d\j`ek_\`ic`m\jXkn_`Z_n\fYj\im\k_\d%
K_\j\hl\eZ\jkXikjn`k_knf[`jk`eZk`e[`m`[lXcle[`jkliY\[jg`iXc^XcXo`\jf]ifl^_cp
k_\jXd\j`q\%>iX[lXccpk_\knfdX`eYf[`\jXkkiXZk\XZ_fk_\i#Zi\Xk`e^j_fZbnXm\j
k_Xk`eZi\Xj\k_\gifZ\jjf]jkXi]fidXk`fe%Cfe^kX`cjf]jkXijXe[^XjXi\Õle^flkYp
k_\k`[Xc]fiZ\j%Jcfncpk_\i\dX`e`e^jkilZkli\jf]k_\^XcXo`\jXi\jdffk_\[flk#Xjk_\
k`[XckX`cjXi\\`k_\icfjk`ek_\jliifle[`e^jgXZ\fiÔeXccpiX`eYXZbfekfk_\e\n^XcXop
Zi\Xk\[`ek_\d\i^`e^%=fiXn_`c\cfe^\ik_\knfjlg\idXjj`m\YcXZb_fc\jg\ij`jkXj
k_\fecpk\jk`dfepf]k_\gXjkf]k_\ZfdY`e\[^XcXopk_XkYpefn_Xjcfjk`kjjg`iXcgXk$
k\iejXe[jkilZkliXccpcffbjdfi\Xe[dfi\c`b\Xe\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXop%
EXkliXccpk_\[\kX`cf]X^XcXopZfcc`j`fegcXpjflk[`]]\i\ekcp[\g\e[`e^fe_fn\m\ecp
dXkZ_\[ k_\ Zfek\e[\ij Xi\ `e dXjj# fe k_\ XggifXZ_ jg\\[# Xe[ Xe^c\ ZfdgXi\[ kf
k_\jg`eXo\jf]k_\`emfcm\[^XcXo`\j%K_\i\Xi\gc\ekpf]f[[$cffb`e^jpjk\dj#jlZ_Xj
gfcXi$i`e^^XcXo`\j#n_\i\k_\[\Yi`jj\kkc\j`ekfi`e^jfm\ik_\gfc\f]k_\cXi^\^XcXop
]fiXn_`c\j\\gX^\.- %
-(
8ig*')Zfej`jkjf]XgX`if]m\ip^Xj$i`Z_jg`iXc^XcXo`\j`ek_\`i\XicpjkX^\jf]`ek\iXZk`fe1MM*+'8`jj\\e\[^\$fekf <eZflek\i
k_\c\]k#Xe[MM*+'9]XZ\$fekfk_\i`^_k%8e\efidfljXdflekf]`e]iXi\[c`^_k`jiX[`Xk\[Ypk_\^Xj]ifddXjj`m\
jkXijk_XkXi\]fid`e^XkXiXk\j`d`cXikfk_\dfjkm`^fiflj^`XekjkXi$]fid`e^i\^`fej`eflifneD`cbpNXp%
8]k\ife\f]k_\ÔijkgXjjX^\jXj_fZbnXm\\]]\ZknXjgif[lZ\[`e8ig(+/k_XkÔijk[i\ndXkk\i`ekfk_\Z\ek\if] GXjj`e^k_ifl^_
k_\^XcXopkfk_\i`^_kXe[k_\eZXlj\[`kkfgifgX^Xk\flknXi[j`eXi`e^%
;`jkfik`fej\kj`e# <JF..$(+`jXjklee`e^gX`in`k_Zc\Xij`^eXkli\jf]k_\^iXm`kXk`feXckl^f]nXiY\kn\\ek_\^XcXo`\j`ek_\]fidf]
k`[XckX`cj XYi`[^\f]dXk\i`Xck_XkZfee\Zkjk_\[`jilgk\[dX`eYf[`\j%K_\^XcXopfek_\i`^_k_XjXcfe^#Ycl`j_Xidn_`c\`kj
ZfdgXe`fe_XjXj_fik\i#i\[[\iXid%K_`j`ek\iXZk`e^gX`i`j`ek_\Zfejk\ccXk`fef]@e[lj#k_\@e[`Xe#jfd\,,'d`cc`fe
c`^_k$p\Xij]ifd<Xik_%K_\[ljkcXe\jY\kn\\ek_\knf^XcXopZ\ek\ijj_fnk_\\ok\ekf]k_\[`jkfik`fekfk_\fi`^`eXccp
ÕXk[`jbjk_Xk_Xm\Y\\eglcc\[`ekfk_i\\$[`d\ej`feXcj_Xg\j%
<JF(+/$)i\j\dYc\jXefnc`eÕ`^_k%@kZfej`jkjf]XgX`if]]fid\i[`jb^XcXo`\jle[\i^f`e^XZfcc`j`fe%K_\Zfi\jf] :fi\jZfdY`e\[#k`[Xc
k_\knf`e[`m`[lXc^XcXo`\jXi\\dY\[[\[`e_fk[ljkXe[ZfekX`eXcXi^\eldY\if]jkXij%Knf_l^\Èn`e^jÉjn\\g kX`cjjk`cciX`e`e^[fne
flk]ifdk_\Z\ek\iXe[Zlim\`efggfj`k\[`i\Zk`fej%K_`jÈZfjd`ZfncÉ`jfe\f]k_\dfjkcld`eflj`e]iXi\[^XcXo$ fek_\e\ncpd\i^\[
`\jbefneXe[`jcfZXk\[jfd\-''d`cc`fec`^_k$p\Xij]ifd<Xik_%
^XcXop
-,
K_\ flkZfd\ f] X Zfcc`j`fe [\g\e[j efk fecp fe _fn Zcfj\ k_\ ^XcXo`\j Zfd\ kf \XZ_
fk_\iYlkXcjffe_fnk_\XggifXZ_Xe^c\Xe[k_\jg`ef]k_\^XcXo`\jXc`^e%@]k_\^Xc$
Xo`\jjg`e`efggfj`k\[`i\Zk`fejXjk_\pXggifXZ_\XZ_fk_\i#iXg`[Z_Xe^\jZXefZZli#
n_\i\Xj`]k_\pifkXk\`ek_\jXd\[`i\Zk`fek_\pZXek\dgfiXi`cpi\`e]fiZ\\XZ_fk_\iËj
dfk`fe%
<eZflek\ijkXb`e^gcXZ\e\Xik_\^XcXZk`ZÈ\hlXkfijÉn`ccf]k\egif[lZ\knfjpdd\ki`Z
k`[XcXidj#n_`c\gfcXi\eZflek\ijk\e[kfgif[lZ\Xm\ipfe\$j`[\[[`jkfik`fe%ÈI\kif$
^iX[\É\eZflek\ij#n_\ek_\ZfdgXe`fedfm\jkffggfj\k_\^XcXopËjj\ej\f]ifkX$
k`fe#gif[lZ\c\jjcXi^\$jZXc\[XdX^\Xe[j\klgjdXcc\iÈjZXccfg\[Éi`ggc\j`eX^XcXopËj
[`jb%
K_\k_`e[`jbjf]jg`iXc^XcXo`\jXi\n_XkjZ`\ek`jkjZXccÈZfc[ÉÇXcck_\jkXijXe[^Xj`eX
Z\ikX`eXi\Xj_Xi\Xcdfjkk_\jXd\fiY`kj%N_\e[`jkliY\[#k_\pZXeY\glcc\[`ekfm\ip
k_`eYi`[^\j#kX`cj#Xe[[`jkfik\[Xidj#n_`Z_i\kX`ek_\`i`[\ek`kp%@eZfekiXjk#\cc`gk`ZXc
^XcXo`\j_Xm\jkXijdfm`e^`eXcc[`i\Zk`fej#jfk_\`ii\jgfej\kfX^iXm`kXk`feXc[`jkli$
YXeZ\p`\c[jm\ipYifX[]Xejf]jkXij#fiXefm\iXccXjpdd\kip%E>:+,+gX^\./ j_fnj
k_\[`]]\i\eki\jgfej\jf]k_\j\knfb`e[jf]^XcXo`\j`eXZc\XinXp%
>iXm`kXk`feXc[`jkliYXeZ\jXki`^_kXe^c\jkfk_\[`jbZXedXb\`knXig#^`m`e^ljXZcl\
kfgXjk\eZflek\ijk_XkZXei\dX`em`j`Yc\\m\eX]k\ifk_\i`ek\iXZk`fegifZ\jj\jkXb\
gcXZ\%n\j\\k_`j#]fi\oXdgc\#`eE>:--.'gX^\.0 %
--
-.
-/
JgcXj_`e^:fcc`j`fej
N_\e X [\ej\ ^XcXop gcle^\j k_ifl^_ k_\ [`jb f] X jg`iXc# Xcdfjk g\ig\e[`ZlcXi kf
`kj gcXe\# k_\ i\jlck`e^ k\dgfiXip `eZi\Xj\ `e k_\ `enXi[ ^iXm`kXk`feXc ]fiZ\ Zi\Xk\j X
ÈjgcXj_É `e k_\ jg`iXcËj jkXij Xe[ ^Xj% Aljk Xj X g\YYc\ k_ifne `ekf X gfe[ Zi\Xk\j Xe
flknXi[cpdfm`e^Z`iZlcXinXm\#XgifgX^Xk`e^[\ej`kpnXm\`j^\e\iXk\[Xkk_\gf`ek
f]`dgXZkXe[jgi\X[jflknXi[%8jk_`j[\ej`kpnXm\Zfcc`[\jn`k_dXk\i`Xc`ek_\kXi^\k
^XcXopk_XknXjdfm`e^`enXi[[l\kfk_\^iXm`kXk`feXcglccf]k_\knf^XcXo`\j#j_fZbj
Xe[[\ej\^XjXi\gif[lZ\[#jk`dlcXk`e^jkXi]fidXk`fe%K_\i\jlck`e^j_fZbnXm\f]k\e
c\X[jkfXYi`cc`Xeki`e^f]e\njkXij#n_`Z_dfm\jflknXi[XjjkXijX^\Xe[e\nfe\j
Xi\Yfie%K_\:Xikn_\\c>XcXopgX^\/) nXjfe\f]k_\Ôijkf]k_\j\i`e^^XcXo`\jkfY\
jkl[`\[`e[\kX`cXe[Zc\m\iXjkifefd\ij[`jZfm\i\[k_XkXjgcXj_`e^Zfcc`j`feY\kn\\e
knf^XcXo`\jnXjkfYcXd\]fik_\f[[Xgg\XiXeZ\f]i`e^^XcXo`\j%Fk_\i\oXdgc\jf]
k_`jZli`fljg_\efd\efeXknfibXi\j\\e`e8ig(+/gX^\/( #8ig(+.gX^\(*, #8D
'-++$.+(gX^\(') Xe[?fX^ËjFYa\ZkgX^\('* %
D\jjpD\i^\ij
FeZ\^XcXo`\jjkXikkfd\i^\#k_\Zfdgc\o`k`\jf]k_\`i`e`k`XcjkilZkli\jXe[XggifXZ_
dXb\ k_\ d\i^\i `kj\c] X jkilZkliXc d\jj% Jfd\ \oXdgc\j ]ifd \Xic`\i Xi\ E>: */'/
`ej`[\]ifekZfm\i #k_\`e]iXi\[Zflj`ejE>:-)+'gX^\-* #Xe[8ig))'gX^\-) %
@e k_\ >Xcc\ip Xi\ dfi\ \oXdgc\j f] Èd\jjpÉ Zfcc`j`fej# n_\i\ \m\e k_\ Y\jk Xjkif$
[\k\Zk`m\n`ccY\_Xi[gi\jj\[kfi\jfcm\k_\dpjk\ipf]n_Xk_Xgg\e\[1@://*gX^\
('- #E>:-'0'gX^\('. #E>:*),-gX^\,) #D:>"'/$(($'')gX^\('0 #E>:,),-
gX^\((' #L>:,('(gX^\((( Xe[DXibXi`Xe).*gX^\(() %
.&
.'
.(
@ek\iXZk`fejY\kn\\e^XcXo`\jXi\dXeX^\[Xcdfjk\oZclj`m\cpYp^iXm`kp#k_\n\Xb\jkf]
k_\]fli]fiZ\jf]eXkli\Ylkk_\fecpfe\k_XkZXeXZkXkm\ip#m\ipcfe^[`jkXeZ\j%>iXm$
`kpb\\gjljfek_\^ifle[Xe[b\\gjfYa\Zkj`ek_\JfcXiJpjk\d`efiY`kXifle[k_\Jle%
>iXm`kp`jXcjfi\jgfej`Yc\]fik_\g_pj`ZXci\cXk`fej_`gn\_Xm\n`k_flie\XiYp^XcXo`\j%
K_\D`cbpNXp#kf^\k_\in`k_k_\8e[ifd\[X>XcXop#k_\Ki`Xe^lcld>XcXop#Xe[XYflk
Ô]kpjdXcc\i^XcXo`\j#dXb\lgn_Xk`jZXcc\[k_\CfZXc>iflg%
>8C8OP>IFLG
>XcXop^iflgjn`k__Xe[]lcjf]d\dY\ijXi\efkleZfddfe`ek_\le`m\ij\Xe[f]k\e J<P=<IKËJJ<OK<K
[fÇefkjligi`j`e^cpÇj_fnj`^ejf][`jkliYXeZ\% J\p]\ikËjJ\ok\k`j\e^X^`e^
`eXjcfn[XeZ\f][\jkilZ$
k`fek_Xkn`cccXjk]fiY`cc`fej
f]p\Xij%K_\^XcXo`\jXi\jf
k`^_kcpgXZb\[kf^\k_\ik_Xk
^iXm`kXk`feXc]fiZ\jXi\Y\^`e$
e`e^kfi`gjkXij]ifdk_\d
Xe[[`jkfikk_\`ij_Xg\j%
K_\j\jXd\^iXm`kXk`feXc
]fiZ\j\m\eklXccpZflc[Yi`e^
k_\^XcXo`\jkf^\k_\ikf]fid
fe\cXi^\^XcXop%K_\eXd\
f]k_`j^iflg`e^#J\p]\ikËj
J\ok\k#`dgc`\jk_Xkj`o^XcXo$
`\jXi\gXik`Z`gXk`e^`ek_\
XZk`fe%9lkfecp]fli^XcXo`\j
Xi\fek_\[XeZ\ZXi[%K_\
jdXcc]XZ\$fejg`iXcn`k_k_\
gifd`e\ekXidj`ek_\Z\ek\i
`jXYXZb^ifle[^XcXopXcdfjk
Ôm\k`d\j]Xik_\iXnXpk_Xe
k_\fk_\i]fli%FecpXZ_XeZ\
Xc`^ed\ekdXb\j`kXgg\XiXj
`]`k`jgXikf]k_\^iflg%K_\
j`ok_d\dY\if]k_\j\ok\k`j
efkX^XcXopXkXccYlkXcfe^
k`[XckX`cf]jkXijcfn\ii`^_k %
.)
.*
K`[XcKiXldXj
N_\eknf^XcXo`\jgXjjZcfj\Yp\XZ_fk_\ik_\^iXm`kXk`feXc]fiZ\X]]\Zk`e^k_\jkXij
e\Xi\jkkfk_\XggifXZ_`e^^XcXop`jmXjkcp^i\Xk\ik_Xek_Xk\og\i`\eZ\[Ypk_\jkXijXk
k_\fk_\i\e[%K_`j[`]]\i\eZ\ZXlj\jk_\jkXijkfY\glcc\[`efggfj`k\[`i\Zk`fejXe[`j
ZXcc\[k_\k`[Xc\]]\Zk%Fe<Xik_Xj`d`cXi\]]\Zkilc\jk_\kn`Z\$X$[Xp\YYXe[Õfnf]k_\
fZ\XejXe[k_\Ziljk %@ek_`jZXj\#k_\\]]\Zk`j`e[lZ\[Ypk_\[`]]\i\eZ\f]k_\^iXm`kX$
k`feÈ]\ckÉfe<Xik_Xk`kje\Xi\jkXe[]lik_\jk[`jkXeZ\jkfk_\DffeXe[j`d`cXicp#Ylk
kfXc\jj\i[\^i\\#kfk_\Jle%
K`[\jY\kn\\e^XcXo`\jXi\#_fn\m\i#dlZ_dfi\[`jilgk`m\k_XefZ\Xek`[\jY\ZXlj\
k_\ jkXij Xi\ dfi\ cffj\cp Yfle[ kf k_\ ^XcXop k_Xe k_\ Zfdgfe\ekj f] <Xik_# n_`Z_
Xi\Yfle[kf^\k_\iYpZ_\d`ZXc]fiZ\j%K_\k`[Xc]fiZ\jY\kn\\eknfZfcc`[`e^^XcXo`\j
ZXei\j_Xg\Xe[i`gk_\^XcXo`\jXgXik`ejlZ_Xe\eZflek\i%K_\i\jlck`e^k`[XckiXldXj
ZXlj\Yi`[^\j#Xek\eeXj#XiZj#kX`cj#Xe[dfi\%JkXijXe[^XjXi\Õle^`ekfjgXZ\%
K_\cfe^\ik_\`ek\iXZk`fecXjkj#k_\Y`^^\iXe[dfi\[iXdXk`ZXi\k_\[`jilgk`fej%Jf#
k_\Zfej\hl\eZ\jf]XZfjd`Z\eZflek\iXi\f]k\edfi\j\m\i\`]k_\i\cXk`m\m\cfZ`kpf]
k_\knf`ek\iXZk`e^^XcXo`\j`jcfnÇk_\fggfj`k\f]n_Xk`jefidXcfe<Xik_%
J`eZ\k_\^iXm`kXk`feXc]fiZ\`j[`i\Zkcpgifgfik`feXckfk_\`emfcm\[dXjj\j#`kZflc[j\\d
k_Xk`k`jfecpk_\dXjjk_Xkilc\jk_\_`\iXiZ_p`ek_\Zcfj\ \eZflek\ijY\kn\\ejk\c$
cXijpjk\dj%K_`j`j#_fn\m\i#efkXcnXpjkil\%@ek_\`ek\iXZk`fejY\kn\\e^XcXo`\jk_\
ZfdgXZke\jjXcjfgcXpjXifc\%Jf#^`m\eknf^XcXo`\jf]ifl^_cpk_\jXd\dXjj\jYlk
m\ip[`]]\i\ekj`q\j#k_\cXi^\ife\#n_\i\k_\dXkk\i`jc\jj[\ej\cpgXZb\[#n`ccgifYXYcp
jl]]\ik_\dfjkj\i`fljZfej\hl\eZ\j%
.+
.,
<[n`e?lYYc\ÔijkZf`e\[k_\k\idÈCfZXc>iflgÉ`e_`jYffb#J^[H[Wbce\j^[D[XkbW[#
kf[\jZi`Y\k_fj\^XcXo`\jk_Xkn\i\`jfcXk\[`ek_\^\e\iXcÔ\c[Ylkn\i\`ek_\m`Z`e$
`kpf]k_\D`cbpNXp%N`k_k_\`eZi\Xj\[j\ej`k`m`kpf]df[\iek\c\jZfg\jXe[[\k\Zkfij
k_\CfZXc>iflgf]^XcXo`\j_Xj^ifne#n`k_dXepe\njdXcc\id\dY\ij`[\ek`Ô\[%K_\
j\XiZ__XjdfjkcpY\\eZXii`\[flkYpj\ej`k`m\cXi^\$Xi\Xjlim\pjf]_Xcfjf]k_\D`cbp
NXpXe[k_\8e[ifd\[X>XcXopk_Xk_Xm\cffb\[]fijc`^_kfm\i$[\ej`k`\jf]jkXij%K_`j
_XjdX[\`kgfjj`Yc\kfcfZXk\[fq\ejf]m\ip]X`ek[nXi]jXk\cc`k\jk_Xk_Xm\gi\m`fljcp
\cl[\[[\k\Zk`fe%
Jfd\f]k_\j\[nXi]^XcXo`\jXi\Zc\XicpdXib\[Yp`ek\iXZk`fejn`k_k_\fk_\i^XcXo`\j
`ek_\CfZXc>iflg%8jjdXcc`ekil[\ijk_\pZXeY\j_i\[[\[Ypk_\k`[Xc]fiZ\jlec\Xj_\[
YpXeXggifXZ_`e^dXjj`m\^XcXop#c\Xm`e^Y\_`e[XkiX`cf][\Yi`j%@eflifne^XcXop[fq$
\ejf]jk\ccXijki\Xdj_Xm\Y\\e]fle[%K_\j\Xi\]fid\i[nXi]^XcXo`\jk_Xk_Xm\Y\\e
\okil[\[ `ekf cfe^# ]lqqp# jgX^_\kk`$c`b\ jkiXe[j f] jkXij k_Xk niXg Xifle[ k_\ D`cbp
NXp%;li`e^\XZ_gXjjf]k_\D`cbpNXpdfi\jkXijXi\jki`gg\[XnXp]ifdk_\gXjj`e^
`ekil[\iXe[af`ek_\_Xcff]fli^XcXop%@k`jk_fl^_kk_Xkk_\j\b`e[jf]\m\ekjdXpY\
hl`k\Zfddfe`ek_\\mfclk`fef]dfjkcXi^\^XcXo`\j%
..
./
L>:/**,
8]lqqpZcfl[f]c`^_k`ek_\Zfejk\ccXk`fef]8e[ifd\[XZfee\Zkj
L>:/**,`jXjkife^cp`ek\i$
XZk`e^gX`if]jg`iXc^XcXo`\j
ljkffli]lkli\%K_\]Xk\f]k_\\ek`i\D`cbpNXp>XcXop#Xe[
i\j\dYc`e^knf`Z\jbXk\ij%
K_\`ek\iXZk`fe_Xjle`k\[
k_\^XcXo`\jm`XXYi`[^\f] g\i_Xgj<Xik_`kj\c]#`j`ek\ikn`e\[n`k_k_\8e[ifd\[X>XcXop%
dXk\i`XcXe[_XjpXeb\[
knfjkife^cpZlim\[kX`cjf] K_\cXk\jkXjkifefd`ZXc\m`[\eZ\jkife^cpjl^^\jkjk_Xkk_\knf
^XjXe[jkXij]ifdk_\flk\i
gXikjf]k_\`iÈYf[`\j%É9fk_
^`Xekjg`iXcd\dY\ijf]fliCfZXc>iflgXi\feXZfcc`j`feZflij\#
^XcXo`\j_Xm\[ljkcXe\j`e
k_\`iZ\ek\ij%L>:/**,`j
cfZXk\[`ek_\Zfejk\ccXk`fe
n`k_Xd\i^\ic`b\cpfZZlii`e^`eÔm\Y`cc`fep\Xij%
f]LijXDXafi#k_\>i\Xk9\Xi#
XYflk+''d`cc`fec`^_k$p\Xij
]ifd<Xik_%
/'
D`cbfd\[X#k_\<e[f]k_\D`cbpNXp
K_\8e[ifd\[X>XcXop`jfe\f]k_\dfjkXn\$`ejg`i`e^Xjkifefd`ZXcfYa\Zkjm`j`Yc\`e
k_\efik_\iejbp%K_fl^_gifYXYcpbefnej`eZ\Xek`hl`kp#`knXjÔijkefk\[XjXe\Yl$
cfljgXkZ_`ek_\k\ek_Z\eklipYpk_\G\ij`XeXjkifefd\i8Y[Xc$JlÔ%N\efnbefnk_Xk
k_`j]X`ekgXkZ_f]c`^_k`jXZklXccpX^i\Xkjg`iXc^XcXop#Xe`jcXe[f]_le[i\[jf]Y`cc`fej
f]jkXijcfZXk\[XYflk)%,d`cc`fec`^_k$p\XijXnXp%@k`jk_\dfjk[`jkXekfYa\Zk_ldXej
ZXej\\n`k_k_\eXb\[\p\%I\dXibXYcp#k_\c`^_kn\j\\]ifdk_\i\Y\^Xe`kjaflie\pXk
k_\[Xnef]_ldXe`kp%
@k `j \og\Zk\[ k_Xk# `e k_\ ]Xi ]lkli\# fli D`cbp NXp n`cc Zfcc`[\ n`k_ k_\ 8e[ifd\[X
>XcXop#flie\Xi\jkcXi^\e\`^_Yfi#^\e\iXk`e^Xjg\ZkXZc\ledXkZ_\[`efliZfie\if]
k_\le`m\ij\%D`cbfd\[X`jk_\eXd\jfd\Xjkifefd\ij_Xm\^`m\ekfk_\\e[gif[lZk
f]k_`jd\i^\i%
K_\knf^XcXo`\jXi\XggifXZ_`e^\XZ_fk_\iXkXcdfjk,''#'''b`cfd\k\ijg\i_fliXe[#
`ek_i\\kfÔm\Y`cc`fep\Xij#n`ccZfcc`[\_\X[$fe%K_\[`i\ZkZfcc`j`fen`ccc\X[kfXdX^e`Ô$
Z\ekd\i^\iY\kn\\ek_\knf^XcXo`\j#[li`e^n_`Z_k_\D`cbpNXpn`ccefcfe^\iY\k_\
jg`iXc^XcXopn\Xi\]Xd`c`Xin`k_%@ejk\X[#kf^\k_\in`k_k_\8e[ifd\[X>XcXop#fm\ik_\
Zflij\f]XY`cc`fep\Xij`kn`cc\mfcm\`ekfXj`e^c\#_l^\#\cc`gk`ZXc^XcXop%
/(
E\nZXcZlcXk`fejdX[\`e)''/YpK_fdXj:foXe[8YiX_XdCf\Y?XimXi[$Jd`k_jfe`Xe
:\ek\i]fi8jkifg_pj`Zj ^`m\X^ff[`[\Xf]k_\]Xk\f]k_\JleXe[JfcXiJpjk\d`ek_\
gifZ\jj%
:fdglk\idf[\c`e^j_fnjk_Xkk_\knf^XcXo`\jn`ccdXb\k_\`iÔijkZcfj\gXjjfecpknf
Y`cc`fep\Xij]ifdefn%@kn`ccc`b\cpkXb\Xefk_\iknfkfk_i\\Y`cc`fep\XijY\]fi\k_\p
d\i^\%K_\Ôm\Y`cc`fep\Xijk_XkdXp\cXgj\Y\]fi\k_\Zfcc`j`fe`jfm\i`jXk`d\jZXc\
ZfdgXiXYc\kfk_\c`]\k`d\f]k_\Jle#n_`Z_dXp^`m\]lkli\Xjkifefd\ij`ek_\JfcXi
Jpjk\dk_\Z_XeZ\kfn`ke\jjgXikjf]k_\jg\ZkXZc\%9lk`k`jle]fikleXk\cpc`b\cpk_Xk#
fe`kjnXpkfY\Zfd`e^Xi\[^`Xek#k_\Jlen`cc_Xm\Xci\X[p^ifnecXi^\\efl^_kfYf`c
XnXpk_\<Xik_ËjfZ\XejXe[]ipXccc`]\Ypk_\k`d\k_\d\i^\i`jZfdgc\k\%@]efk#Xep
jlim`m`e^[\jZ\e[Xekjf]_ldXejn`cc_Xm\Xm\ip[`]]\i\ekm`\n]ifdkf[Xp%K_\D`cbp
NXpYXe[`ek_\e`^_kjbpn`ccY\i\gcXZ\[Ypk_\_l^\\cc`gk`ZXc$j_Xg\[^cfnf]Y`cc`fej
f]jkXij%
;li`e^k_\Zfcc`j`fe#k_\knf^XcXo`\jn`ccjn`e^Xifle[\XZ_fk_\iXZflgc\f]k`d\j#
`ek\id`e^c`e^ k_\`i jkXij Xj ^iXm`kXk`feXc ]fiZ\j d`o k_\d kf^\k_\i% K_\i\ `j X Z_XeZ\
fii`jb`]pfln`cc k_Xkk_\Jlen`ccY\\a\Zk\[`ekfXcfe^k`[XckX`c]fccfn`e^k_\Ôijk
gXjjX^\f]k_\8e[ifd\[X>XcXop%@k`jXcjfXckf^\k_\igfjj`Yc\k_Xk[li`e^gXikjf]k_\
m`fc\ek\eZflek\ik_\Jlen`ccY\dfi\k`^_kcpYfle[kf8e[ifd\[X%=lkli\Xjkifefd\ij
`ek_\JfcXiJpjk\dd`^_kk_\ej\\k_\D`cbpNXpXjXe\ok\ieXc^XcXop`ek_\e`^_kjbp%
Fk_\i\]]\Zkjf]k_\d\i^\inflc[c`b\cpY\\e_XeZ\[Zfd\kj_fn\ij[l\kfk_\dXep
jkXijgXjj`e^Ypk_\JfcXiJpjk\dXe[el[^`e^k_\Zfd\k$Ôcc\[Ffik:cfl[#Xjn\ccXjX
Ôi\nfibf]e\nYfiejkXij`ek_\e`^_kjbp#gfjj`YcpgXm`e^k_\nXp]fie\ngcXe\kjn`k_
e\nZ`m`c`qXk`fejZXgXYc\f]Yl`c[`e^jgXZ\k\c\jZfg\jkfcffb]fik_\`ifi`^`e%
/)
/+
/,
//
'&&
'&'
'&(
'&)
'&*
'&+
'&,
'&-
'&.
'&/
''&
'''
''(
'')
''*
''+
'',
''-
''.
''/
'(&
'('
'((
'()
'(*
'(+
'(,
'(-
'(.
'(/
')&
')'
')(
'))
')*
')+
?\fYkX`e\[_`jDXjk\iËj;\^i\\`eg_pj`ZjXe[Xjkifefdp]ifdk_\Le`m\i$
j`kpf]:fg\e_X^\e#;\edXibXe[_Xjdfi\k_Xe(''glYc`ZXk`fejkf_`jZi\[$
`k#dfjkf]k_\d`egfglcXijZ`\eZ\Zfddle`ZXk`feXe[`kjk_\fip%?`jfk_\i
gif[lZk`m\ `ek\i\jkj Zfm\i j\m\iXc dXafi Xi\Xj f] Zfddle`ZXk`fe# `eZcl[`e^
^iXg_`ZXc#ni`kk\e#k\Z_e`ZXcXe[jZ`\ek`ÔZZfddle`ZXk`fe%?\_Xjni`kk\ej`oYffbj#`eZcl[`e^;o[iedj^[
Ia_[i">_ZZ[dKd_l[hi["J^[>WdZi#Ed=k_Z[\ehIY_[dY[9ecckd_YWjehiXe[>kXXb[Æ'+O[Whie\:_iYel[ho%
?`jYffbj_Xm\Y\\ekiXejcXk\[kf=`ee`j_#Gfikl^l\j\#;Xe`j_#>\idXe#Bfi\XeXe[:_`e\j\%
CXij`jGi\jjF]ÔZ\i]fik_\@ek\ieXk`feXc8jkifefd`ZXcLe`fe@8L #X]fle[`e^d\dY\iXe[j\Zi\kXipf]
k_\@8L:fdd`jj`fe,,:fddle`ZXk`e^8jkifefdpn`k_k_\GlYc`Z#dXeX^\if]k_\<J8&<JF&E8J8G_f$
kfj_fg=@KJC`Y\iXkfigifa\Zk#\o\Zlk`m\\[`kfif]k_\g\\i$i\m`\n\[:fddle`ZXk`e^8jkifefdpn`k_k_\
GlYc`ZaflieXc#[`i\Zkfif]k_\?lYYc\ZXjkXe[<JFZXjkm`[\fgf[ZXjk#dXeX^\if]k_\@8L@ek\ieXk`feXc
P\Xif]8jkifefdp)''0J\Zi\kXi`XkXe[k_\<o\Zlk`m\gif[lZ\iXe[[`i\Zkfif]k_\jZ`\eZ\[fZld\e$
kXi`\j;o[iedj^[Ia_[iXe[>kXXb[Æ'+O[Whie\:_iYel[ho%@e)'',CXijnXjk_\pfle^\jki\Z`g`\ekjf
]Xif]k_\KpZ_f9iX_\D\[Xc]fi_`jXZ_`\m\d\ekj`ejZ`\eZ\Zfddle`ZXk`fe%CXijc`m\j`e>XiZ_`e^e\Xi
Dle`Z_#>\idXep#n`k__`jn`]\Xe[jfe%
IXhl\cPld`J_`[X
IXhl\cjkXik\[fek_\ifX[kfk_\ZfjdfjXjXeXdXk\liXjkifefd\i`e9iXq`c#
_\i_fd\Zflekip#_Xm`e^dX[\_\ifnek\c\jZfg\`e_\ik\\eX^\p\XijXe[
gifm`[`e^fYj\imXk`feXc[XkXXe[`dX^\jf]mXi`fljXjkifefd`ZXcfYa\Zkjkf
jZ`\ek`jkjXe[fi^Xe`qXk`fejnfic[n`[\%
?\i Ôijk gXik`Z`gXk`fe `e ?lYYc\ gifa\Zkj nXj YXZb n_\e j_\ nXj Xe le$
[\i^iX[lXk\ jkl[\ek# n_\e j_\ nXj XnXi[\[ X i\j\XiZ_ `ek\iej_`g Xk
k_\ JgXZ\ K\c\jZfg\ JZ`\eZ\ @ejk`klk\ `e k_\ LJ8% 9\]fi\ af`e`e^ k_\ k\Xd
f] <J8Ëj ?lYYc\ ^iflg `e >\idXep `e )''-# j_\ nfib\[ Xk k_\ 8jkifefdp
;\gXikd\ek Xk k_\ Le`m\ij`kp f] Jf GXlcf# 9iXq`c# `e k_\ [\m\cfgd\ek f]
'),
:lii\ekcp#j_\`jgXikf]X^iflgf]jZ`\ek`jkj#XjkifefdpZfddle`ZXkfij#Xe[[\j`^e\ijXkk_\<lifg\Xe
Jflk_\ieFYj\imXkfip\[lZXk`feXe[GlYc`ZFlki\XZ_;\gXikd\ek`e>\idXep%J_\]fZlj\jfek_\lj\
f]`ek\ie\k$YXj\[k\Z_efcf^`\j]fiYi`e^`e^Xn`[\mXi`\kpf]m`jlXcgif[lZkjXe[`dgfikXekXjkifefd`ZXc
e\nj]ifd?lYYc\#<JF#k_\@ek\ieXk`feXc8jkifefd`ZXcLe`feXe[k_\@ek\ieXk`feXcP\Xif]8jkifefdp
)''0kfk_\^\e\iXcglYc`Z%
@e_\ijgXi\k`d\#j_\jk`cc\eafpjdXb`e^XdXk\liXjkifefdpfYj\imXk`fejXe[g_fkf^iXg_p%
;Xm`[\;\DXik`e
;Xm`[\`jXe\c\Zki`ZXc\e^`e\\infib`e^`eM\e`Z\]fik_\cXi^\jk@kXc`Xegfn\ijlg$
gcpZfdgXep%?\`ji\jgfej`Yc\]fik_\ZfdgXepËjÕ\\km\_`Zc\dXeX^\d\ekXe[`j
`emfcm\[`ek_\[\m\cfgd\ekXe[`dgc\d\ekXk`fef]e\nk\Z_efcf^`\jXe[d\k_f[j
kf`dgifm\nfib$]fiZ\dXeX^\d\ek%
;
Xm`[\ _Xj Y\\e Xe XdXk\li Xjkifefd\i j`eZ\ _`j Z_`c[_ff[# n_\e _\ jkXik\[ kf
[\mfli\m\ipk_`e^XYflkXjkifefdp%?\_XjY\\eXe\[`kfif]k_\@kXc`XedX^Xq`e\
9e[bkcj`eZ\(00-#ni`k`e^[fq\ejf]ZfcldejXe[Xik`Zc\jiXe^`e^]ifdk_\_`jkfip
f]XjkifeXlk`ZjkfXjkifefdpgfglcXi`qXk`fe%?\_Xji\Xc`q\[fiZfccXYfiXk\[`eXmX$
i`\kpf]XjkifefdpgfglcXi`qXk`fegifa\ZkjXjn\Yj`k\j#dlck`d\[`Xjlggfikj#j_fnj#
\o_`Y`kjXe[Yffbj%
I\Z\ekcp#;Xm`[\_XjdX`ecp]fZlj\[_`jXZk`m`k`\jfegifZ\jj`e^fc[[XkX]ifdfYj\imXkfipXiZ_`m\jXe[[\m\cfg`e^
k\Z_e`hl\jkfkliek_\d`ekf`dX^\j%Dfjkf]_`jnfib`jgi\j\ek\[Xknnn%jbp]XZkfip%fi^%
?\_XjY\\egXikf]k_\<lifg\XeJflk_\ieFYj\imXkfip\[lZXk`feXe[GlYc`ZFlki\XZ_;\gXikd\ekXjXe`dX^\
gifZ\jj`e^k\Xdd\dY\ij`eZ\)'',#gif[lZ`e^jfd\f]k_\dfjkgfglcXi?lYYc\Xe[<JF`dX^\j%8ck_fl^_;Xm`[\
_XjY\Zfd\lj\[kfcffb`e^Xkk_\le`m\ij\k_ifl^_?lYYc\Ëjfgk`Zj#_\jk`cccfm\jk_\[`i\Zk\p\ZfekXZkn`k_k_\
e`^_k$jbplj`e^_`j;fYjfe`Xek\c\jZfg\%
')-
N`b`g\[`XXik`Zc\j1
_kkg1&&\e%n`b`g\[`X%fi^&n`b`&>XcXop
_kkg1&&\e%n`b`g\[`X%fi^&n`b`&>XcXopV]fidXk`feVXe[V\mfclk`fe
_kkg1&&\e%n`b`g\[`X%fi^&n`b`&8kcXjVf]VG\Zlc`XiV>XcXo`\j
').
')/