Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BUSINESS LAW
Submitted to
Qurat ul Ain Farooqi
Submitted by
Muhammad Kamran Arshad MBL-18-16
Ayman Ejaz MBL-18-14
Muhammad Atif MBL-18-13
2
﷽
WITH THE NAME OF ALLAH THE MOST BENEFICIAL AND THE MOST MERCIFUL
Contents
ACKNOWLDGMENT ................................................................................................................................. 4
Debenture ...................................................................................................................................................... 5
3
ACKNOWLDGMENT
All praise and thanks belong to ALLAH, THE LORD OF THE WORLDS, the Gracious, the
merciful, the master, and the master of the Day of Judgment. Countless thanks to Allah whom alone do
we worship and whom alone do we call for help, who made me Muslim by birth. Allah gave me potential
and ability to complete my work. All respects and regards to HOLY PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH),
who enable us to recognize our creator and to understand the philosophy of life. I would like to express
my deep and sincere gratitude to my learned and renowned research supervisor respected Sir Shahid
Raza Azami kindly provide me a chance to study this topic and provide me with all necessary facilities
for carrying out my research work.
5
Debenture
Meaning
If a company needs funds for extension and development purpose without increasing its share
capital, it can borrow from the general public by issuing certificates for a fixed period of time and
at a fixed rate of interest. Such a loan certificate is called a debenture. Debentures are offered to
the public for subscription in the same way as for issue of equity shares. Debenture is issued under
the common seal of the company acknowledging the receipt of money
Debentures Explained
Similar to most bonds, debentures may pay periodic interest payments called coupon payments.
Like other types of bonds, debentures are documented in an indenture. An indenture is a legal and
binding contract between bond issuers and bondholders. The contract specifies features of a debt
offering, such as the maturity date, the timing of interest or coupon payments, the method of
interest calculation, and other features. Corporations and governments can issue debentures
Governments typically issue long-term bonds—those with maturities of longer than 10 years.
Considered low-risk investments these government bonds have the backing of the government
issuer.
Real world Example of Debenture
An example of a government debenture would be the U.S. Treasury bond (T-bond) T-bonds help
finance projects and fund day-to-day governmental operations. The U.S. Treasury Department
issues these bonds during auctions held throughout the year. Some Treasury bonds trade in the
secondary market. In the secondary market through a financial institution or broker, investors can
buy and sell previously issued bonds. T-bonds are nearly risk-free since they're backed by the full
faith and credit of the U.S. government. However, they also face the risk of inflation and
Features of Debenture
1. Debenture holders are the creditors of the company carrying a fixed rate of interest.
2. Debenture is redeemed after a fixed period of time.
3. Debentures may be either secured or unsecured.
6
4. Interest payable on a debenture is a charge against profit and hence it is a tax deductible
expenditure.
5. Debenture holders do not enjoy any voting right.
6. Interest on debenture is payable even if there is a loss.
Advantage of Debenture
(a) Issue of debenture does not result in dilution of interest of equity shareholders as they do not
have right either to vote or take part in the management of the company.
(b) Interest on debenture is a tax deductible expenditure and thus it saves income tax.
(c) Cost of debenture is relatively lower than preference shares and equity shares.
(d) Issue of debentures is advantageous during times of inflation.
(e) Interest on debenture is payable even if there is a loss, so debenture holders bear no risk.
Disadvantages of Debentures:
(a) Payment of interest on debenture is obligatory and hence it becomes burden if the company incurs
loss.
(b) Debentures are issued to trade on equity but too much dependence on debentures increases the
financial risk of the company.
(c) Redemption of debenture involves a larger amount of cash outflow.
(d) During depression, the profit of the company goes on declining and it becomes difficult for the
company to pay interest.
Different Types of Debentures
Ordinary Debenture:
Such debentures are issued without mortgaging any asset, i.e. this is unsecured. It is very difficult
to raise funds through ordinary debenture.
Mortgage Debenture:
This type of debenture is issued by mortgaging an asset and debenture holders can recover their
dues by selling that particular asset in case the company fails to repay the claim of debenture
holders.
Non-convertible Debentures:
A non-convertible debenture is a debenture where there is no option for its conversion into equity
shares. Thus the debenture holders remain debenture holders till maturity.
7
Dissolution of Firms
When the relationship between all the partners of the firms comes to ends this is called dissolution
of firm
8
2. Compulsory Dissolution (Sec.41):- In case, any of the following events take place then it becomes
compulsory for the firm to dissolute:
(i) Insolvency of Partners
In case all the partners or all the partners except one become insolvent.
(ii) Unlawful Business
In case the firm is engaged in more than one business which may have become unlawful, the better view
appears to be that the firm will not dissolve as to the other legitimate businesses unless all of them are so
inter connected that stoppage of one would paralyze the others e.g. A and B charter a ship to go to foreign
port and receive a cargo on the joint venture. War breaks out between England and the country where the
port is situated before the ship arrives at the port, and continues until after the time appointed for loading.
The partnership between A and B is dissolved
3. Dissolution on the happening of contingent event (S.4)
A firm may be dissolved on the happening of any of the following contingent event
(i) Expiry of Fixed Period
9
A firm constituted for a term is of course not exempt from dissolution by any of the other possible cause
before the expiration of the term. The contract may expressly provide that the partnership will determine
in certain circumstances but even if there is no such express term, an implied term as to when the
partnership will determine may be gathered from the contract and the nature of the business. The
provision of this section make it clear that unless some contract between the partners to the contrary is
proved, the firm, if constituted for a fixed term would be dissolved by the expiry of that term.
order for the dissolution of firm on the application of any of the partner. where a partner is imprisoned for
a long period of time the court may dissolve the partnership was held in case ofWhitwell v. Arthur
PROVIDED that the firm is in no case bound by the acts of a partner who has been adjudicated insolvent;
but this proviso does not affect the liability of any person who has after the adjudication represented
himself or knowingly permitted himself to be represented as partner of the insolvent.
11
Mode of settlement of accounts between partners (S.48) settling the accounts of a firm after
dissolution, the following rules shall, subject to agree
(a) Deficiencies of capital
When a partnership is dissolved, and after the debts to the third parties have been paid and advances made
by a partner have been repaid, the assets are insufficient to repay each partner his capital in full, any
deficiencies must be borne by the partners in the same proportion as the profits would have been divided
(b) The assets of a firm are to be applied in paying
1. Joint debts to third parties
2. Advances, as distinguished from capital, of each partner
3. to each partner what is due from the firm to him in respect of capital.
In after the above payments are made, there is surplus, that surplus is to be divided in the proportion.
Nowell v. Nowell in this case A and B trade as partners and it is agreed that profits should be shared and
losses borne equally. On dissolution it is found that A has advanced more capital than B to the extent of
Rs.1900. the net assets were only Rs.1400. there is thus a deficiency of capital to the extent of Rs500.
Under sub section (a) both the partners must contribute in the proportion in which they have agreed to
share profits that is equally. Therefore B should pay to A sum of Rs 250.
Proviso – Where on dissolution a partner has bought the goodwill of the firm, he may use the firm name
even before the affairs of the partnership have been completely wound up. Clements v. Hall In this case A
and B carry on business in partnership. The firm holds leasehold for the purpose of the business. A
dies.before the affairs of the firm are completely wound up, the lease expires and B renews it. The
renewed property is partnership property.
Alder v. Fouracare. In this case A,B and C are partners. A agrees to take a lease in his own name, but in
12
fact fact partnership purpose, and dies before the lease is executed. The representative of A cant deal with
lease without the permission of B and C
(1) In settling the accounts of a firm after dissolution, the goodwill shall, subject to contract between the
partners, be included in the assets, and it may be sold either separately or along with other property of the
firm.
(2) Rights of buyer and seller of goodwill-Where the goodwill of a firm is sold after dissolution, a partner
may carry on a business competing with that of the buyer and he may advertise such business, but, subject
to agreement between him and the buyer, he may not-
(a) use the firm name,
(b) represent himself as carrying on the business of the firm, or
(c) solicit the custom of persons who were dealing with the firm before its dissolution.
(3) Agreement in restraint of trade—Any partner may, upon the sale of the goodwill of a firm, make an
agreement with the buyer that such partner will not carry on any business similar to that of the firm within
a specified period or within specified local limits and, notwithstanding anything contained in section 27
of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (9 of 1872), such agreement shall be valid if the restrictions imposed are
reasonable.
Curt Brothers Ltd. V. Webster in this case A sells the goodwill of his business to B and sets up a new
business. X who remains customer of the old firm deals his own accord with the new firm set by A. A is
not entitled to solicit even such a customer as X, though if X continues to deal with A of his own accord,
A would be entitled to deal with him
What is a Shareholder?
A shareholder can be a person, company, or organization that holds stock(s) in a given company.
A shareholder must own a minimum of one share in a company’s stock or mutual fund to make
them a partial owner. Shareholders typically receive declared dividends if the company does well
and succeeds. Also called a stockholder, they have the right to vote on certain matters with regard
to the company and to be elected to a seat on the board of director
If the company is getting liquidated and its assets are sold, the shareholder may receive a portion
of that money, provided that the creditors have already been paid. When such a situation arises,
the advantage of being a stockholder lies in the fact that they are not obliged to shoulder
the debt and financial obligations incurred by the company, which means creditors cannot compel
Roles of a Shareholder
Being a shareholder isn’t all just about receiving profits, as it also includes other responsibilities.
Let’s look at some of these responsibilities.
Brainstorming and deciding the powers they will bestow upon the company’s directors,
including appointing and removing them from office
Deciding on how much the directors receive for their salary. The practice is very tricky
because stockholders must make sure that the amount they will give will compensate for
14
the expenses and cost of living in the city where the director lives, without compromising
the company’s coffers.
Making decisions on instances where the directors have no power over, including making
changes to the company’s constitution
Checking and making approvals of the financial statement of the company
Types of Shareholders
There are basically two types of shareholders: the common shareholders and the preference
shareholders.
Common shareholders are those that own a company’s common stock. They are the more
prevalent type of stockholders and they have the right to vote on matters concerning the comp ny.
As they have control over how the company is managed, they have the right to file class of
action against the company for any wrongdoing that can potentially harm the organization.
Preferred shareholders, on the other hand, are more rare. Unlike common shareholders, they
own a share of the company’s preferred stock and have no voting rights, or any say in the way the
company is managed. Instead, they are entitled to a fixed amount of annual dividend, which they
will receive even before the common shareholders are paid their part.
Though both common stock and preferred stock see their value increase with the positive
performance of the company, it is the former that experiences higher capital gains or losses.
Can the Shareholder be a Director?
The shareholder and director are two different entities, though a shareholder can be a director at
the same time.
The shareholder, as already mentioned, is a part-owner of the company and is entitled to privileges
such as receiving profits and exercising control over the management of the company. A director,
on the other hand, is the person hired by the shareholders to perform responsibilities that are related
to the company’s daily operations, with the intent of improving its status.
The two terms are often used interchangeably, with many people thinking that they are one and
the same. However, the two terms don’t mean the same thing. A shareholder is an owner of a
company as determined by the number of shares they own. A stakeholder does not own part of the
company but does have some interest in the performance of a company just like the shareholders.
However, their interest may or may not involve money.For example, a chain of hotels in the US
that employs 3,000 people has several stakeholders, including its employees because they rely on
the company for their job. Other stakeholders include the local and national government, because
of the taxes the company must pay annually.
15
The number of shareholders in a company depends upon the type of company which they are
opening.
Shareholders’ Rights
There are various rights available to a shareholder. Different type of rights has been discussed
below:
Appointment of directors
Shareholders play an important role in the appointment of directors. An ordinary resolution is
required to be passed by the shareholders for the appointment. Apart from this, shareholders can
also appoint various types of directors. They are:
An additional director who will hold the office until the next general body meeting;
An alternate director who will act as an alternate director for a period of 3 months;
A nominee director;
Director appointed in the case of a casual vacancy in the office of any director appointed
in a general meeting in a public company.
Apart from this shareholder also can challenge any resolution passed for the appointment
of a director in the general body meeting.
Any act done by the director in any manner which is prejudicial against the affairs of the
company.
16
Any act done which is beyond the law or against the constitution.
Fraud.
When the assets of the company are being transferred at an undervalued rate.
When there is a diversion of funds of the company.
Any act done in a mala fide manner.
4.Voting rights
Shareholders also have the right to attend and vote at the annual general body meeting. Every
company registered in India should comply with the provisions of the Companies Act 2013. It is
mandatory for every Indian company to hold an annual general meeting once in every year. The
meeting can be held anywhere at the head office of the company or any other place as given by
the company. At the meeting, there are various mandatory agendas which are to be discussed.
These include the adoption of financial statements, appointment or ratification of directors and
auditors etc.
When a resolution is brought by members of a company then according to companies act 2013 it
can be passed only by the means of voting by the shareholders. Companies Act 2013 recognizes
following types of voting:
Voting by the showing of hands – Every member present in the meeting has one vote. So,
in this type of voting shareholders vote just by showing of hands.
Voting done by polling – In this type of voting the chairman or the shareholders’ demand
for a poll. However, in case of differential rights as to voting, a particular class of equity
shares may also have weighted voting rights.
Voting done by electronic means– every company who has more than 1000 shareholders
has to put up a facility of voting through online means. Every member should be provided
with the means of voting of online.
Voting by means of postal ballot– any resolution in the meeting can also be passed by
means of a postal ballot.
A shareholder also has a right to appoint proxy on his behalf when he is unable to attend the
meeting. Though the proxy is not allowed to be included in the quorum of the meeting in case of
voting, it is allowed by following a procedure mentioned in the Companies Act 2013.
17
When the sale of any material of any company is done then the shareholders should get the
amount which they are entitled to receive;
When a company is converted into another company then it requires prior approval of
shareholders. Also, all the appointment has to be done according to all the procedures and
also auditors and directors have to be done;
Right to approach the court in case of insolvency.
Shareholders’ Duties
There are also responsibilities and duties of shareholders which they should perform. Besides
several rights which they have, there exists several duties. They are:
Shareholders should participate in the general body meetings so that they can see and also
can advise on the matters which they feel is not going good.
Shareholders should consult on the matters of finance and other topics.
Shareholders should be in touch with other members of the company so that they can see
the work progress of the company.
rights which is a drawback for investors issuing companies face a higher cost for this type of
equity when compared to debt