CASE REFERENCE NOTES

Nature and Concept

Ang Yu Asuncion vs. CA 238 SCRA 602

Sagrada Orden vs. Nacoco 91 Phil. 503

Pe vs. CA 195 SCRA 137

Sources of Obligations
Leung vs. O'brien 28 Phil. 182

Sagrada Orden, supra G.R. NO. L-3756

JUNE 30, 1952

People's Car Inc. vs. GR No. L-36840

Commando Security
Service Agency

Clemente Brinas vs. GR No. L-30309

People of the Philippines,
CA

Araneta vs. De Joya 57 SCRA 59

Philippine Rabbit Bus 189 SCRA 158
Lines, Inc. vs. CA

Gutierrez vs. Gutierrez 56 Phil. 177

Viluan vs. CA 16 SCRA 742

Ex Lege
Pelayo vs. Lauron 12 Phil. 453

Delicts
Diana vs. Batangas 93 Phil. 391
Transportation Co.

Quasi Delicts
Barredo vs. Garcia and 73 Phil. 607
Almario

Elcano vs. Hill 77 SCRA 98

Baksh vs. CA 219 SCRA 115

Valenzuela vs. CA 253 SCRA 303

Manila Railroad Co. vs. 38 Phil. 875

Compania Transatlantica

2 possible sources
Air France vs. Carrascoso L-21438

Nature and effect of obligations

Chavez vs. Gonzales 32 SCRA 547
(1970)

Rose Packing Co. vs. CA 167 SCRA 309

(1988)

Namarco vs. Federated 49 SCRA 238

Distributors

Inducil vs. de los Santos 17 SCRA 332

(1966)

Delay or mora
Vermen Realty vs. CA 224 SCRA 549
(1993)
Penacio vs. Ruaya 110 SCRA 45
(1981)

Agcaoili vs. GSIS 165 SCRA 1 (1988)

Arrieta vs. National Rice GR L-15645 (Jan.

and Corn Corp. 31

Vda de Villaruel vs. Manila 104 Phil. 926

Motor

Fortuitous events
Maranan vs. Perez 20 SCRA 412
(1967)

Dioqunio vs. Laureano 33 SCRA 65 (1970)

Republic vs. Luzon 21 SCRA 279

Stevedoring (1967)

Lasam vs. Smith 45 Phil. 657 (1967)

Victorias Planters Assn. vs. 97 Phil. 318
Victorias Milling Co. (1955)A

Arrieta, et al. vs. National G.R. No. L-15645

Rice and Corn Corporation

Usurious transactions
Angel Warehousing vs. 23 SCRA 19
Chelda

Briones vs. Camayo G.R. No. L-23559

(1971)

Presumptions
Manila Trading Supply Co. 2 SCRA 549 (1961)
vs. Medina

Pure and conditional obli

Smithbell vs. Sotelo Matti 44 Phil. 875 (1922)

Pure obligations
Pay vs. Palanca 57 SCRA 618
Classification of conditions
Gaite vs. Fonacer 2 SCRA 381

Pay vs. Vda de Palanca 57 SCRA 618

(1974)

Parks vs. Province of 49 Phil 142 (1976)

Tarlac

Songcuan vs. IAC (191 SCRA28)

Coronel vs. CA GR No. 103577

Javier vs. CA 183 SCRA 171

(1990)

Tayag vs. CA 219 SCRA 480

(1993)

Kinds of conditional obligations, suspensive and resolutory

Jacinto vs. Kaparaz 209 SCRA 246
(1992)
Lichauco vs. Figueras 7 Phil. 339
Hermanos

Ducusin vs. CA 122 SCRA 280

(1983)

Parks vs. Province of supra

Tarlac

Protestative, casual and mixed contitions

Rustan Pulp vs. IAC 214 SCRA 662
(1992)

Hermosa vs. Logara 49 OG 4287

Osmena vs. Rama 14 Phil. 99 (1909)

Trillana vs. Quezon 93 Phil. 383 (1953)

Colleges

Romero vs. CA supra

Naga Telephone vs. CA 230 SCRA 351
(1994)

Smith Bell and Co vs. 44 Phil. 847

Sotelo Matti

Recission in Reciprocal Obli

Gimenez vs CA 195 SCRA 2005

Bosque vs Yu Chipco 19 Phil 95

Taguba vs Vda de Leon GR L-59980

Definition of reciprocal obli

Borromero vs. Franco 5 Phil. 49

Party entitled to rescind, requisites

UP vs. de los Angeles 35 SCRA 102

Philippine Amusement 21 SCRA 284

Enterprises vs. Natividad (1967)
Roque vs. Lapus 96 SCRA 741
(1980)

Angeles vs. Kalasanz 135 SCRA 323

(1985)

Boysaw vs. Interphil 148 SCRA 635

Promotions (1987)

Earth Minerals vs. 194 SCRA 1

Macaraig

Gimenez vs. CA 195 SCra 205

Jacinto vs. Kaparaz supra

Taguba vs. de Leon 132 SCRA 722

(1984)

Both parties in breach, reciprocal obligations

Tan Guat vs. Pamintuan (CA) 37 OG 3494
Bosque vs. Yu Chipco 14 Phil 95

Periods
Gaite vs. Fonacier supra

Benefit of term
Lachica vs. Araneta 47 OG No. 11 5699

Ponce de Leon vs. Syjuco 90 Phil. 311

When courts may fix a period

Araneta vs. Phil. Sugar 20 SCRA 330
Estates Dev't. Co.

Orit vs. Baldrogan 106 SCRA 800

(1969)

Facultative obligations
Quizania vs. Reduguerio 50 OG 2444
Joint and solidary obligations
Ronquillo vs. CA 132 SCRA 273
(1984)

Right to demand
payment
PNB vs. Conception 5 SCRA 745
Mining

Solidary debtor
Wilson vs. Berkenkotter 49 OG 1410

Defenses of the Solidary debtor

Ynchausti vs. Yulo 34 Phil. 978

Obli w/ Penal Clause

Makati Development vs. 20 SCRA 557
Empire Insurance

Cabarroguis vs. Vicente L-14304

Payment or Performance
Arrieta vs. NARIC 10 SCRA 79
Kalalo vs. Luz 34 SCRA 337

St. Paul vs. McCondray 70 SCRA 112

PNB vs. Pineda 197 SCRA 1 (1991)

New Pacific Timber & G.R. No. L-41764

Supply Company, Inc vs.
Señeris

Extinguishment of Obligations
Saura vs. DBP

Namarco case 49 SCRA 238

Suapengco vs. Manotoc Article 1250 on

currency

Legarda & Hermanos vs. G.R. No. L-26578

Saldana
Aranas vs. Tutaan 127 SCRA 828

Filinvest vs. Phil Acetylene G.R. No. L-50449

Lopez vs. CA 114 S 671

Soco vs. Militante G.R. No. L-58961

Limkako vs. Teodoro 74 P 313

Pp. vs. Franklin G.R. No. L-21507

Laguna Tayabas vs. G.R. No. L-23546

Manabat

Occena vs. Jabson G.R. No. L-44349

Sycip v. CA G.R. No. L-38711

Gan Tion vs. CA G.R. No. L-22490

Perez vs. CA legal

compensation

Republic vs. de los 148-B Phil. 902

Angeles (1971)

Loreto vs. Solinap G.R. No. L-50638

Uy Tong v. Silva G.R. No. L-28377

Mindanao Portland G.R. No. L-62169

Cement Corp. v. CA

Unsorted Cases
Manila Lodge No. 761 vs 73 SCRA 168
CA
Co vs Balance G.R. No. 71694,
August 16, 1991

Tibajia vs. CA G.R. No. 100290.

June 4, 1993

Esguerra vs. Villanueva G.R. No. L-23191.

December 19,
1967

Tolentino vs. CA G.R. No. 50405-06.

August 5, 1981

Filinvest Credit vs. Phil G.R. No. L-50449.

Acetylene. January 30, 1982

Legaspi vs. CA G.R. No. L-45510.

May 27, 1986

Baritua vs. CA G.R. No. 82233.

March 22, 1990

Riesenbeck vs. CA G.R. No. 903E9.

June 9, 1992
Caltex vs. 1AC G.R. No. 72703.
Nov. 13, 1992

Mota vs. Serra G.R. No. 22825.

Feb. 14, 1925

Enriquez vs. Ranola G.R. No. 40908.

Sept. 8, 1934

PNB vs. Acero G.R. No. L-69255.

Feb. 27, 1987

CKH vs. CA G.R. No. 111890.

May 7, 11997

Pioneer insurance vs. CA G.R. No. 76509.

Dec. 15, 1989

Orata vs. IAC G.R. No. 73471.

May 8, 1990

Millar vs. CA 38 SCRA 642

Dormitorio vs. Fernandez 72 SCRA 388

Zapanta vs. De Rotaeche G.R. No. 6910. Jan.

9, 1912

Sangrador vs. Sps. G.R. No. 79552.

Valderrama Nov. 29, 1988

Pacific Timber vs. 101 SCRA 685

Macondray

McLaughlin vs. CA G.R. No. L-57552.

Oct. 10; 1986

Hahn vs. CA G.R. No. L-55372.

May 31, 1989

Aquino vs. CA G.R. No. 91896.

Nov. 21, 1991

Occena vs. Jabson 73 SCRA 637

PNCC vs. CA G.R. No. 116896.
May 5, 1997

Trans-Pacific vs. CA G.R. No. 109172.

Aug: 19, 1994

BPI vs. CA G.R. No. 116792.

March 29, 1996

Tiu Siuco vs. Habana G.R. No. 21106.

Feb. 21, 1924

Guerrero vs. CA G.R. No. L-22366.

Oct. 30, 1969

Sandico vs. Timbol G.R. No. L-26115.

Nov. 29, 1971

Garcia, Jr. vs. CA G.R. No. 80201.

Nov. 20, 1990

Ligutan vs. De La Llana G.R. No. 138677.

Feb. 12, 2002
Broadway Centrum vs. G.R. No. 79642.
Tropical Food July 5, 1993

Sanchez vs. Rigos 45 SCRA 368

Hill vs. Veloso 31 Phil 161

Mapalo vs. Mapalo G.R. No. L-21489

and L-21628.
May'! 9, 1968

Sps. Santos. vs. CA G.R. No. 120820.

August 1, 2000

Santos vs. Heirs of G.R. No. 143325.

Villanueva October 24, 2000

Dumez vs. NLRC G.R. No. 82340.

Aug. 12, 1991

Somoso vs. CA G.R. No. 78050.

October 23, 1989
Pernaez vs. Delos Angeles 27 SCRA 1276

Alano vs. Barbara G.R. No. L-4274.

March 23, 1908

Sps. Theis vs. CA G.R. No. 126013.

February 12, 1997

Sps. Guiang vs. CA G.R. No. 125172.

June 26,1998

Coronet vs. Constantino G.R. No. 121069.

February 7, 2003

Regal Films vs. G.R. No 139532,

Concepcion August 9, 2001

NPC vs. National G.R. Nos. L-33819

Merchandising and
L33897.October
23, 1982

Land vs. CA G.R. No. 125531.

February 12, 1997
Cenido vs.Apacionado G.R. No. 132474.
Nov. 19, 1999

Villanueva vs. CIA G.R. No. 107624.

January 28, 1997

NYCO Sales Corp vs. BA G.R. No. 71694,

August 16, 1991

Salao vs. Salao 70 SCRA 65

Fabian vs. Fabian 22 SCRA 231

Bueno vs. Reyes 27 SCRA 1179

Tamayo vs. Callejo 46 SCRA 27

Mindanao Dev. Authority G.R. No. L-49087.

vs. CA April 5, 1982
Tala Realty vs. Banco G.R. No. 137533.
Filipino November 22,
2002

GSIS vs. COA G.R. No. 138381,

Nov. 10, 2004;

GSIS vs. Pineda, et. al. G.R. No. 141625,

Nov. 10, 2004

Sebastian Siga-An vs. G.R. No. 173227,

Alicia Villanueva January 20,2009

Philippine G.R. No. 147324,

Communications Satellite May 25, 2004
Corp vs.Globe Telecom,
Inc.

Cruz vs Sun Holidays, Inc. G.R. 186312, June

29, 2010

MIAA vs. Ala Industries G.R. No. 147349,

Corp. Feb. 13, 2004

Lalicon vs. National G.R. No. 185440,

Housing Authority July 13, 2011
Gobonseng and G.R. No. 160026,
Gobonseng Sr. vs. Corona December 10,
and Unicard Corp. 2007

Jayme vs. CA G.R. No. 128669,

Oct. 4, 2002

Tan Shuy vs. Spouses G.R. No. 190375.

Guillermo Maulawin, et al. February 8, 2012.

Selegna Management and G.R. No. 165662,

Development Corp. vs. May 30, 2006
UCPB

Dela Peña and Villareal vs. G.R. No. 177828,

CA and Rural Bank of Feb. 13, 2009
Bolinao, Inc.

FEBTC vs. Diaz Realty Inc. G.R. No. 138588,

Aug. 23, 2001

Spouses Oscar and G.R. No. 171298;

Thelma Cacayorin vs. April 15, 2013
Armed Forces and Police
Mutual Benefit
Association, Inc.

Sps. Benos vs.Sps.Lawilao G.R. No. 172259,

Dec. 5, 2006
Leonardo vs. CA, G.R. No. 125485,
Sept. 13, 2004

The Roman Catholic G.R. No. 174118;

Church vs. Regino Pante April 11, 2012

Swedish Match, AB vs. CA G.R. No. 128120,

Oct. 20, 2004

Anthony Orduña, et al., vs. G.R. No. 176841;

Eduardo J. Fuentebella, et June 29, 2010
al.

Villaranda vs. Villaranda G.R. No. 153447,

Feb. 23, 2004

Spouses Jose and Milagros G.R. No. 169055.

Villaceran vs. Josephine February 22, 2012.
De Guzman

BPI vs Boston Bank G.R. No. 94676,

Sept. 30, 1992

Ace-Agro Development vs G.R. No 119729,

CA Jan. 21, 1907