Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/258120296
Shear Modulus and Damping of a Stiff Clay from in Situ and Laboratory Tests
CITATIONS READS
24 213
4 authors, including:
Oronzo Pallara
Politecnico di Torino
46 PUBLICATIONS 663 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Assessment of Liquefaction potential in Tuscany using available mechanical CPT database View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Antonio Cavallaro on 20 May 2014.
Paul WlMayne
School of Civil and Environmenîal Engineering, Georgia Institute ofTechnology, Atlanta, U SA
VOLUME 2
Shear modulus and damping of a stiff marine clay from in situ and laboratory
tEStS
ABSTRACT: This paper describes and compares the results of in situ and laboratory investigations which
were carried out il order to determire the soil profile of the Saline di Augusta site (also Saline site), with
special attention being paid to the variation ofshear modulus and damping ratio rvith depth. The soil deposits
at this site mainly consist of a medium stiff, overconsolidated (OCR : 2.0 to 6.0), Pleistocene marine clay
with low to medium PI, overlaid by a l5 m thick Holocene silty clay stratum. The Saline site is located near
the city ofAugusta on the east coast of Sicily which is one ofthe most seismically active areas of ltaly.
1293
{}r +
il '[J,
l-------l BuildiDg
€
!o
fofi'
to
a
o tl
ll" o
LI oLJ * Eór-+
ruo
l}ol
T*--f--c--f-i-'l+ oo
Borabolat
a Ost rbdg
l} Sbclby s4lcs
E Pieoctct
s..qlcs
O DMT
Dyrlmic i[ iitu a€sts
. CH-DH
-.-SASW aliaoncnr
loM
cF (%) wp-wtr-wl(%) IC
tt l.r- {a,
l0'
J -li r rt
25*I
Pleistocene marine clay which is locally called in the range of between 60 - '10 %. This percentage
Augusta blue clay. decreases to 30 - 40 To at certzrn depths where a sand
The Holocene deposits mainly consist of fraction of 15 - 30 yo and a gravel fraction of2 - l0
alternating layers of grey silty clay and silty sands. o/o
are observed. The silt fraction is in the range of
Stifi CaCO3 cemented, layers of sand were found about 25 - 40 o/o. The values of the natural moisture
at depths olbetween 10 and l5 m. content wo prevalently range fiom between 30 and
The Pleistocene deposits mainly consist of a 35 %. Characteristics values for the Atterberg limits
: 2.0 to 6.0),
medium stiff, overconsolidated (OCR are: wr=60 - 65 lo and w r=22 - 26 c'/o, wirh a
marine clay with low to medium PI. plasticity index of PI:30 - 40 Yo. The data shown in
Fig. 2 clearly indicate a very high degree of
homogeneity of the deposit. This indication is also
3, INVESTIGATION PROGRAM AND BASIC confirmed by comparing tlre penetration resistance
SOIL PROPERTIES q" from mechanical cone penetration tests (CPT)
perlormed at different locations over the investigated
The investigated area has plane dimensions of4100
area (Fig. 3). The variation of q" with depth clearly
mq and a maximum depth of 80 m. The area
shows the existence of layers with very different
pertaining to the investígation program and the
mechanical characteristics. The upper Holocene silty
locations of the boreholes and field tests are shown
clay has very poor mechanical characteristics with
in Fig. l.
q" of about 0.3 to 0.ó MPa. The lower Pleistocene
Undisturbed samples were retrieved by means of
clay has q" values of about 2 to 4 MPa. A transition
an Osterberg (1973) piston sampler and by means of
an 8ó mm Shelby tube sampler. zone with interbedded stiff sand layers (q"=t516 35
The general characteristics and index properties MPa) exists between these two strata at depths of
of the Augusta clay are shown, as a function of about l0 and 15 m. The soil deposits can be
depth, in Fig. 2. The clay fiaction (CF) is prevalently classified as inorganic clay ofhigh plasticity.
1294
a [MPrl Pleistocene clay, the OCR values obtained from
0 510 152025 30 35 DMT range fiom 5 to 7 (K" = 1.0+ 1.5) with an
average vaÌue equal to 6 up to about 30 m depth.
The OCR values inferred from oedometer tests
are lower than those obtained from in situ tests. C)ne
possible explanation of these differences could be
that lower values of the preconsolidation pressure
oo are obtained in the laboratory because of sample
disturbance.
20
5. SHEAR MODULUS AND DAMPING RATIO
&
l0 "s
4 15 t5
k:
20 3
";-a .s
30
1295
from RCT, CLTST aad MLTST performed on drainage, to a RCT. The size and shape of the
undisturbed specimens which were isotropically specimens are also indicated in Table l.
reconsolidated to the best estimate ol the in situ
mean effective stress. The G" values are plotted in Table 1.. Test
Iest Condition i A
Condltion for
Fig. 5 against depth. In the case of laboratory tests, Tes oi. PI MLTST c"(l) G"(2) G.(3) Speci
the G" values are determined at shear sîrain levels No. lkPal CLTST lMPal lMPul men
of less than 0.001 %. It is possible to see that quite a RCT lMPal
good agreement exists between the laboratory and in I 259 0_889 40 U 70 75 H
situ test results. A better agreement between the 2 182 0.6 84 29 U 84 85 S
laboratory and in situ tesî results is observed in the 3 r 55 0.693 30 U 46 H
case of the Osterberg samples than for the Shelby 4 0.834 38 U 67 75 H
tube samples. On average the ratio of G.(Lab) to 5 398 0.768 38 U 70 H
where:
G"(Field) was equal to 0.86 with a Standard
U: Undrained. G" (1) from MLTST, G. (2) from
Deviation of 0.095.
CLTST, G" (3) from RCT. H: Hollow cylindrical
co [MPa] specimen (R" = 25 mm Ri = 15 mm h:100 mn). S:
Solid cylindrical specimen (R = 25 mm h:100 mm).
0 50 t00 150
0+
The G" values, reported in Table 1, indicate a
lo l moderate but measurable ilfluence of strain rate and
to o1 gpe of loading even at very small strains where the
20, of soil behaviour is supposed to be elastic. In order to
30- cr( appreciate the rate effect on G", it is worthwhile to
remember that the equivalent shear strain rate
E40+
=l o
Q = 2a0 . f . y t%/sl) experienced by the specimens
go 50 l during RCT can be three orders of magnitude greater
than those adopted during CLTST. The effects of the
rol rate and loading conditions become more and more
CH Tst
T0lrRcr
- relevant with an increase of the shear strain level. as
o RCTlms can be seen in Fig. 6 where the G-y curves obtained
8o v, tst from MLTST, CLTST and RCT are compared. Ir is
^
possible to notice that the lowest decay ofG with y is
Figure 5. Ge from laboratory and in situ tests-
observed in RCT, while the maximum decay occurs
during MLTST. In order to quantify the rate effect,
The G. values for the upper Holocene silty clay the coefficient of strain rate a(7) was computed from
steadily increase from 20 to 80 MPa with depth. In
CLTST and RCT, as shown in Fig. 6.
th€ transition zone, where stiff sand layers exists, The experimentally determhed cr(1) values are
G" increases up to ll0 MPa. lt is worthy to note summarised in Fig. 7. Other data available in
that CH tests results can ignore the existence of soft
layers interbedded between stiff layers because of
the occurrence of refraction phenomena. In the
lower Pleistocene bìue clay G. values are in the
interval of 80 îo 120 MPa, slowly increasing with (j)
depth. .;
1296
literature are also shown in ùis Figure. These data A comprehensive comparison between the results
were obtained by means of undrained compression of the CLTST and RCT is shown in Fig. 9.
tests or CLTST-RCT performed on both remoulded Considering that the influence of N on D has been
and undisturbed clays. The data, on ùe whole, found to be negligible, in the case ofclayey soils for
clearly show that cr(y) increases with the plasticity strain levels of less than 0.1 %, it is supposed that
index and, for a given soil, with the shear strain RCT provide larger values of D than CLTST
level. Considering that, at small strains, a(7) is not because of the rate (frequency) effect, in agreement
greater than 5 o/o, rt is possible to conclude that very with data shown by Shibuya et al. (1995) and
similar values of G" can be obtained from different Tatsuoka et al. (1995). According to these
kinds oftest such as MLTST, CLTST, RCT. researchers the nature of soil damping in soils can
be linked to the following phenomena:
.
I
MùI|b|d rl (199,)
l,tulròi d rI r
úri.n-.ls
.111 |
l$l ) úd.ti. Pf
I
- Nonlinearity which govems the so called
. adF rd a@rr,r{r'2) Pl.,o$ ct@ hysteretic damping controlled by the current shear
lt--00t
. Abict rl ltyr5ì - Pr.2r- n c6 strain level. This kind of material damping is absent
I
0,0001 0,001 0,01 0,1 kPa. This data was obtained by d'Onofrio 1996. The
She.r strrin 17. I considered soil is a stitr, highly overconsolidated,
Pliopleistocene, marine clay with a PI of about 26
Figure 8. Damping ratio from CLTST and RCT tests.
%. In the same figure the data of Augusta clay,
obtained in this research and tlose of Pisa clay
1297
obtained byLo hesti et al. (1997b) have been b) Hryciw ( 1990)
of the whole data is in good
reported. The trend
agreement with the findings of Shibuya et al. o" =.'*L.-, z./-f ;l
(a,tp")"'- ;lDry*
K3"'(o"'p")05 (3)
(1ee5). DtT||
where: G",o" and p" are expressed in the same unit;
p"=l bar is a reference pressure; yo and K" are
respectively the unit weight and the coefficient of
ir- o or \l l^s"d.ros. earth pressure at rest, as infene.d from DMT results
according to Marcheni (1980).
1298
modulus greatly increased (Maugeri et al. 1994). - the damping ratio, measured in the laboratory,
However the method by Hryciw ( 1990) was not resulted to be mainly influenced by rate effects.
capable of detecting these stiff stròta as can be seen - empirical correlations befween the small strain
in Fig. I l. shear modulus and penehation test results were used
Go [MPal to infer G, from SPT, CPT and DMT. The values of
Go were compared to those measured in a CH test.
0 100 200 300
This comparison clearly indicates that a certain
relationship exists between G" and the penetration
test results, which would encourage one to establish
empirical correlations lor a specific site. This
approach makes itpossible to consider the spatial
variability of soil properties in a very cost effective
\ ay.
- relationships like those proposed by
Jamiolkowski et al. (1995) or Shibuya and Tanaka
(1996) seems to be capable of predicthg G. profile
with depth in both Holocene and pleistocene
deposits. The accuracy of these relationships could
obviously be improved if
the parameters which
appear in
the equations were experimentally
determined in the laboratory for a specific site.
Figure I l. Gq from different empirical eorrelations.
1299
De Rubeis V., Gasparini C., Maramai A. and Recenî Advances in Geotechnical Earthquake
Anzidei M. 1991 "Il terremoto Siciliano del 13 Engineering and Soil Dynamics. S. Louis,
Dicembre 1990" Proc. Contributi allo sndio del Missouri, Vol. II, pp. 653-658.
Terremoîo della Sicilia Oríentcle del 13 Maugeri M., Castelli F. and Motta E. 1994 "Pile
Dicembre 1990. National Institute of Geophisics. Foundation Performance of an Earthquake
Roma Damaged Building" Proc. of the lîalían-French
d'Onofrio A. 1996 "Cornportamento Meccanico Symposium on Strengîhening and Repaír of
dell'argilla di Vallericca in condizioni lontane Strucîures in Seismic Areas, Nice, France
dalla rothrra". Ph. D. Thesis, University of Mayne, P.W. and tux, G.J., 1993 "G* -q"
Naples, Deparhnent of Geotechnical Engineering Relationships for Clays," Geotechnical Testing
Frenna S.M. and Maugeri M. 1995 "Microzoning of Journal, Yol. 16, No. I, pp. 54-60.
the Saline site of Augusta Town (Sicily, Italy)" Olivares L.
1996 "Caníeiz,zazione dell'argiÌla di
Proc. l}th European Conference on Earthquake Bisaccia in condizioni monotone, cicliche e
Engineering, Wien 1995, Vol. 1, pp- 43-49. dinamiche e riflessi sul comportamento del Colle
Ghisetti F. and Vezzani L. 1980 "The strucftìral a seguito del tenemoto del 1980." Ph. D. Thesis,
of the Iblean Plateau and the Mount
features University of Naples, Departmenî of
Judica area (SE Sicily): a microtectonic Geotechnical Engineering.
contribution to the deformational history of the Osterberg J.O. 1973 "An improved Hydraulic Piston
Calabrian Arc" Bulleuin of the ltalîan Geologícal Sampler" Proc, 8th ICSMFE, Moscow.Yol1.2.
Society 99,57 -102. Ohta Y. and Goto, N., 1978 "Empirical Shear Wave
Hryciw R.D. 1990 "Small strain shear modulus of Velociry Equations in Terms of Characteristic
soil by dilatometer" JGED, ASCE, Yo. 116, No. Soil Indexes," Earthquake Engineering and
11, pp. 1700-1715. Structural Dynamrcs, Vol. 6.
Jamiolkowski M., Lo Presti D.C.F. and Pallara O. Postpischl D. 1985 "Atlas of isosismal maps of
1995 "Role of ln-Situ Testing in Geotechnical Italian Earthquakes" CNR (halían National
earthquake Engineering," 3rd Internatiotnl Research Councíl) Geodyrnmical projecî. Rome
Conference on Recenr Advances in Geotechnical Santucci de Magistris F., 1996 "Comportamento di
Earthquake Engineering and Soil Dynamic, State un limo sabbioso ed argilloso costipato ed
ofthe AÍ 7, Vol. 3, pp. 1523-1546. addizionato con bentonite," Ph. D Thesis,
Lo Presti D.C.F., Pallara O, Lancellotta R., Armandi University of Naples, departrnent of
M. and Maniscalco R. 1993 "Monotonic and Geotechnical Engineering.
Cyclic Loading Behaviour of Two Sands at Shibuya S., Mitachi T., Fukuda F. and Degoshi T.
Small Strains," Geotechnícal Testing Journal, 1995 "Strain Rate Effect on Shear Modulus and
Vol 16, No 4, pp 409-424 Damping of
Normally Consolidated Clay."
Lo Presti D.C.F., Jamiolkowski M., Pallara O. and Geotechnical Testing Journal l8:3, 365-375.
Cavallaro A., 1996 'Rate and Creep Effect on the Stokoe K.H. II, Hwang S.K. Lee J.N.-K and Andms
Stifftess of Soils", ASCE Conrention, R. 1995 "Effects of Various Parameters on the
Washington, l0-14 Nov. 1996, Geotechnícal Stiffness and Damping of Soils at Small to
Special Publication No. 61, pp. 166-180. Medium Strains." Keynole Lecture 2, IS
Lo Presti D.C.F., Jamiolkowski M., Pallara O., HokkaÌdo I 994 2, 785-816.
Cavallaro. A. and Pedroni S. 1997a" "Shear Tatsuok4 F. and Shibuya, S. 1992 "Deformation
Modulus and Damping of Soils", accepted for Characteristics of Soil and Rocks from Field and
publication on Geolechnique Symposium in Print Laboratory Tests." Keynote Leclure, Proc. IX
September 1997. Asian Conference on SMFE, Bangkok, l99l 2,
Lo Presti D.C.F., Pallara O. and Cavallaro. A.M.F. l0l - 190.
1997b, "Damping ratio of soils from laboratory Tatsuoka F., Lo Presti D.C.F. and Kohata Y. 1995
and in situ tests", Proc. ICSMFE, Hamburg 1997, "Deformation Characteristics of Soils and Soft
Special Volume TC4. Rocks Under Monotonic and Cyclic Loads and
Marchetti, S., 1980, "In Situ Tests by Flat Their Relations." 3rd International Conference
Dilatometer," Journal of Geolechnical on Recenl Advances in Geotechnical Earthquake
Engineering,,4SC{ No. GT3. Engineering and Soil Dynamic, State of the Art
Maugeri M. and Frenna S.M. 1995 "Soil-response 1, 2, 851-879.
aralysis for the 1990 south-east Sicily
earthquake" 3rd Inlernational Conference on
1300