Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Indian Caste System Past and Present A C
Indian Caste System Past and Present A C
“Caste was the system of social life, in which Hinduism was expressed. Hinduism
was the ideological and emotional buttress of caste…. Caste and Hinduism
succeeded in doing in India, what no state, no conqueror and no economy was
able to do – the establishment of a single unified system of society throughout the
whole of India (accommodating numerous semi-autonomous communities arising
at many times and in many places), a system of society, which was able to
comprise a greater range of local differences in a single system than any society
has previously accomplished.”
Introduction
Caste system has always been a centre of attention for Westerners, politicians,
intellectuals, activists or reformers from other faiths. It has been both defended
and opposed vehemently in the political circles of modern India. Many assaults
have been made on caste-system, especially because of the deformities and rigidity
developed into the system during a very long period of its evolution and its being
under alien rule. However, after each assault, caste system has re-emerged with
greater force.
In the past, British Imperial rulers and missionaries had criticized caste-
system vehemently.In recent past, caste has become more of a politician crutch. It
is often misinterpreted as “an exploitative social system for retaining economic and
social status of certain vested interests of ruling class. … Indian caste system,
which has evolved an answer the requirements of civilization at a later phase of
development of culture, was integrated with Varna system as enunciated in the
ancient scriptures and Dharmasastras.” (Quoted from Ancient caste system worked
well: ICHR head, p.1, TOI July15,2014)
Many activists, academicians and writers condemn caste system saying, “Vemula (a
student of Hyderabadad university) committed suicide (in 2016) against an ugly
caste system in India. It shows the treatment being meted out to Dalits in
educational institutions and other fields of daily life”. (Quoted from TOI, p. 13,
March 28, 2016)
Deep roots of caste system in India – Positive aspects of Indian culture and its
caste system are so deep that it is almost impossible to bring caste system to an
end and create a casteless society in India. The caste system had worked well in
ancient times and people do not find any complaint against it even now. To a great
extent, Don Martindale is right in saying, “Caste was the system of social life, in
which Hinduism was expressed. …… Hinduism was the ideological and emotional
buttress of caste…. Caste and Hinduism succeeded in doing in India, what no state,
no conqueror and no economy was able to do – the establishment of a single
unified system of society throughout the whole of India (accommodating numerous
semi-autonomous communities arising at many times and in many places), a
system of society, which was able to comprise a greater range of local differences
in a single system than any society has previously accomplished.”
Indian culture and caste inseparable – Indian culture and caste are
inseparably related each other by traditional customs. It is virtually impossible to
think of one without another. Being a very old and indigenous system,
conceptualized, developed and practiced exclusively in India, it is difficult for
Westerners and non-Indians to understand what ‘caste system’ is and what caste
means to a common man.
Mystified Western World – Western world is mystified by amazing pluralities
and unique social structure of India. It is difficult for the western world to
understand role of caste – past or present – in Indian society because –
Stratification of a Society
Usually, class stratification begins with individuals. Division of society along ‘Class’
lines forms different groups on the basis their economic and cultural level. What
determines ‘class’ varies from one society to another. Usually possession of wealth
determines hierarchical distinctions between individuals or groups within a
community . Distinction between two groups depends on their being powerful and
powerless. Social classes with more power usually subordinate classes with less
power, which Power was closely linked to ability to assert one’s status through
physical strength. Usually different variables are adopted to decide status of
different groups within a society, like occupation, education and qualifications,
income, wealth, ownership of land, property etc.
Besides, there are other factors as well considered as important as one’s wealth in
determining class status, at least at higher levels, like costume and grooming,
manners and cultural refinement (tastes and sensitivities of different groups).
Political standing vis-à-vis church/temples/ mosques, government, and/or social
clubs, as well as use of honorary titles, reputation of honor or disgrace, language,
race determines degrees of influence on class standing.
Caste-system separates wealth from status, power from authority and knowledge
from temptations of worldly comforts. All individuals within a caste group –
irrespective of ones financial position – are equal having similar rank, rights and
duties. Its constituent members are supposed to be independent, yet their roles
complementary.
‘Caste’, an oldest social institution – Caste system is one of the oldest social
institutions in the world. Caste-system gives Indian society a distinguished identity
and a solid social structure with a system of thought, way of life, and sense of
direction.
Covers entire social fabric of India – It covers almost the entire social fabric of
India. Not only in the past, but at present also, caste system commands respect
and attention of a common man in India as a natural, valid and inevitable unit of
society. It is popular not only amongst Hindus, but amongst other sects as well
living in India, whether foreign or indigenous. Muslims or Christians, Sikhs or
Buddhist could not remain immune from its caste system for long. They also have
been influenced and absorbed many of the systems and practices of caste-system.
in India transformed into Varna system and finally into caste system has been as
following –
Start during ancient pastoral society – The beginning of the system can be
traced from the times of pastoral tribal society, when people started forming small
groups mostly living in hilly areas, not far from rivers. Tribal communities were
nomadic or semi nomadic and egalitarian. They depended on nature for its
subsistence.
Clans and tribes settled permanently in different parts of the country. Possession of
land, slaves and hired laborers started. People hardly possessed more than what
was needed for their subsistence/survival. The practice of cultivation, rise of crafts
and iron tools transformed the egalitarian society into fully agricultural and
stratified society sometime during 6th century BC.
Beginning of settled life – After entering into India, first Aryans conquered
India’s original inhabitants of Northern part of India, colonized and established
kingdoms. Most of original inhabitants moved to Deccan and then south. During
the period, it was possible to have high ranks, but not high social classes. Initially a
simple class division was seen in the social structure, i.e. nobility and the ordinary
tribesmen. The units of social-political organizations were family, clan, village, tribe
and Jana. Family was the unit of society headed by father. Three or four
generations lived together, and probably owned property in common. A number of
families living in one locality formed ‘grama’ (village). A number of such fighting
units dwelling in a particular region constituted a ‘vis’ (canton), ‘Jana’ (a group of
tribes) consisted of a number of such cantons, with a king as their ruler.
Mixing up of their culture with native culture of the land – Starting with
arrival of Aryans in waves and mixing up of their culture with native culture of the
land evolved a social structure based on the principles of “Varna” (giving birth to
caste system), “Dharma” and “Karma”, which together distributed, organized
performance of various functions and contributed to the growth of Indian society.
In the beginning, Varna – meaning color – guided the division of the society. These
principles gave Vedic society a distinct character, defined roles and organized inter-
relationship of various sections of society. Fair skinned Aryans, being the
conquerors, kept themselves on the top. They spread their language and culture
allover the North. Many changes started taking place in the life, manners, religion,
language and literature of people.
Possession of land, slaves and hired laborers started. People started producing and
possessing more than they needed. The kings collected their surplus yields. The
power of kings gradually increased. For regular collection, administrative and
religious methods were devised.
Rise of caste system – As more and more indigenous and foreign groups were
merged into the Hindu-fold, Vedic Varna system gave rise to caste system. For
making place for new groups, caste system provided a mechanism. Through it, the
job of assimilation of different tribal, local and immigrant groups was done
cordially, at different points of time. Each new group joining it was given a
separate caste identity. It neither disturbed the existing internal social order nor
any new group was prevented from joining it and still allowed new groups to
preserve its specialties and indigenous culture. It gave each one opportunities to
develop within its own parameters. Thousands of endogamous groups were
included into it. Each group was allowed to maintain its own rules, regulations,
customs, way of life and power to control conduct of its members. However,
principles of Varna, Dharma, and Karma remained the foundation stones of caste
system and contributed to its growth in a systematic way.
Natural response – As Basham has pointed out, Caste system may well be called
a natural response of many small and primitive groups of people, who were forced
to come to terms, with a more advanced economic and social system. It provided a
mechanism, by which numerous discrete tribes, all sorts of groups and associations
arising for political, sectarian or other reasons could be internalized and preserved
within the whole.
Connection between ‘Varna’ and ‘Caste’ -Castes had its ethnic roots as
denoted by ‘Jati’, and a ritualistic and symbolic significance in its ‘Varna’ aspect.
Different castes found their place under a ‘Varna’ on the basis of their being ritually
clean or unclean, nature of work and amount of self-discipline they
exercised. Numerous castes and sub-castes emerged within each ‘Varna’. Four
‘Varnas’ remained the same. These were never more or less than four. For over
2000 years, their order in precedence remained the same. As far as castes were
concerned, they rose and fell in their social order, some died out and new ones
were formed from time to time.
Castes in the Making around 5th century – Perhaps, the first faint trace of
caste is to be found in the careful cataloguing of traders and professions in later
Vedic literature. Many traders were organized into guilds around 5th century AD, in
which, some authorities have seen the origin of commercial castes. These can be
seen as the castes in making. Even up to 7th century AD, people showed no clear
knowledge of the existence of castes. Huan Tsang, in the Seventh century was well
aware of the existence of Varna, but not of castes.
Salient features of Caste System – All the strength of caste system comes from
its basic principle of Varna, which gave Indian Society a stable, sustainable and a
solid social structure with a system of thought, a way of life and sense of direction,
accompanied by principles of Dharma, and Karma, The principles which ensured
the continuity despite numerous foreign invasions, migrations and assimilation of
various groups. Caste system could survive for such a long period because –
When the world was passing through the Dark Age, India was full of light. The first
few centuries are recognized as the golden period of Indian history. During this
period, arts, commerce, crafts, philosophy and knowledge flourished magnificently.
Its people reached a high level of intelligence having specialization in different
areas. Many travelers visiting India, from alien lands at different points of time,
confirmed that India possessed huge wealth, knowledge, and quality of life. It was
a cheerful land. Each person found a niche in the social system. Its people reached
a high level of intelligence having specialization in different areas. It was a cheerful
land.
Caste system has travelled a very long distance since then. Many changes have
taken place in the system especially during centuries of foreign rule in the country.
Duties assigned for each caste group – All castes including untouchables were
assigned important social duties. Harijan women helped all castes at time of child-
birth. Harijan males beat drums in front of Hindu’s houses or in front of a
procession on important occasions/ceremonies. Village barber spread news,
arranged marriages and served food during celebrations. Occasionally non-
Brahmins or Harijans served as priests of temples of goddesses like Sita or Kali,
where all castes made offerings.
All the activities of urban or rural areas were confined within a small area, having
very little links with the outside world because of the slower means of transport.
Only merchants visited different distant places. The local societies used to be self-
sufficient mutually `supporting and caring” for each other. People in power and
position cared for the lower castes in order to acquire and retain local followers.
The monopoly of powerful peasant was a reality of the rural life of Medieval India.
Indian peasantry in UP, Bihar and MP were armed. In fact, non-Kshatriya peasant
provided leadership of most armed bands, which were numerically predominant
and economically and politically strong at the village level.
Acted as a shield – During medieval India, caste system was a major force for
failure of Islam, Christianity and other religions to make headway even after mass
conversion. Though many evil practices developed in the system during this period,
but it acted as a shield for Hindus to retain their cultural identity, while living under
alien rule, whether it was of Mughals, Portuguese or British.
New Changes Done by British Rulers – After Census Operations, British rulers
codified all the castes and standardized the system by placing them into four
Varnas or in the categories of outcastes and aborigines. So far, Hindu Society was
classified into four Varnas embracing numerous castes and sub-castes within its
fold. Later on, earlier British rulers and now politicians of Independent
India have divided it into five new unbridgeable compartments by census
operations – Backward caste, forward caste (caste Hindus), untouchable or
scheduled caste, scheduled tribes and minority. Through legal process, they gave
each one a new separate and distinct identity.
Like modern Manu, “The census operations divided all the castes and communities
into following groups – Brahmins, Non-Brahmins, Muslims, Anglo-Indians,
untouchables, non-Hindu Communities and backward castes”. This division remains
a by-word even for the present leaders of Independent India.
BR Ambedkar has said “By independence, we have lost the excuse of blaming the
British for anything going wrong” BR Ambedkar, (quoted from TOI, P.20, Jan 26,
2010) ()
Caste more liberal in social sphere – In modern India, spread of literacy and
growing awareness among masses has already brought to an end slowly but
steadily many of the discriminatory practices and deformities developed in Caste
system, while living under alien rule. It has become more liberal and less restrictive
in social life of the people. Castes no longer enjoy legal or religious sanctions.
Castes Less restrictive – Expulsion from castes means little, while earlier it
meant complete social ostracism. Old style of authority and power exercised by
caste-elders has already diminished except for a few rural areas especially in
Haryana and Rajasthan. Restrictions or interactions between different castes
arising due to considerations for purity and pollution are fading away from public
life even from rural areas. Traditional barriers on marriage, hereditary occupations
and commonality are loosing its importance.
Poor governance – Despite all the above mentioned efforts, there is no respite to
a large number of people from discriminatory practices. Even now after 70 years of
Independence, millions of people suffer from poverty, disparity, discrimination and
deprivation. They are still exploited mercilessly by strong men of society. Why?
It is not the caste-system, but the bad politics and poor governance, which is
responsible. Modern India is sharply divided into two – “haves” and “have-nots”.
The most important factors responsible for disparities are vote-bank politics,
irrational and corrupt ways of pursuing the paternal policies and government’s
failure to address real issues at central and State levels.
‘Caste’, the most powerful tool for creation of vote-banks – ‘Caste’ has
become a bye-word for Indian politicians. For the present-day political leaders
caste is the easiest and most powerful tool to sway public opinion emotionally and
to create a larger vote bank for them. It may be called ossification of caste-system
fallen into the hands of power brokers and vote guzzlers.
Narrow loyalties of caste and religion – Narrow loyalties of caste and religion
are encouraged in political arena. It has generated sub-cultures like caste-ism,
favoritism, and lure for easy money, nepotism, parochialism, communalism,
regionalism etc. Bigoted sentiments and irresponsible comments are spreading in-
discipline in the society. The rising aspirations and demands of people, with the
spread of education and awareness, has created added problem for the
government.
Under-currents of caste politics – Under-currents of caste politics have made
the government incapable to solve the burning national issues. It has made to
maintain law and order difficult. Inter-caste and intra-caste, inter-community and
intra-community and inter-tribal and intra-tribal conflicts are increasing day by day
in order to get more space in the corridors of power.
Real issues pushed into the background – Real issues like mass-scale
illiteracy, poverty, unemployment, inflation, deteriorated law and order situation,
increasing violence or general coarsening of moral fiber of the Indian society etc.
are pushed into the background. the voice of upright and honest people
belonging to middle class is being continuously throttled mercilessly. They are
being punished for following sincerely family-planning norms, which has decreased
their numbers. In present day vote-bank politics based on game of numbers, it is
very easy now for the pursuers of political power to sideline them.
Winding up
Caste still a strong social institution – Not only in the past, but at present
also, caste system appears to be a valid and useful, a natural and inevitable unit of
society. It is popular and commands respect and attention of majority of Indian
masses of all sects present in India, whether foreign or indigenous. For them
following four are fundamental social institutions. An individual is supposed to be a
natural member of a family, which is a unit of an extended family, extended family
of Kula, Kula of a tribe (Vish) – and a tribe of a Jana or Jati (Caste).
Caste second only to family – A person’s relations with members of his caste
are closer than with those, belonging to other castes. Caste values, beliefs,
prejudices, injunctions as well as distortions of reality are the indivisible part of a
person’s psyche and conscience. Internalized caste norms defines an individual role
in the society. It makes one feel good and loved, when he lives up to these norms,
and anxious and guilty, when he transgresses them. In a way, caste is still second
only to the family in widening a person’s social radius and in getting importance in
his/her private and occupational life.
Politicians blaming Caste for all evils – In political circles, caste is blamed for
all the agonies of submerged sections of Indian society – it could vary
from illiteracy to creating disparities of power, wealth and culture,
escalation of violence, crimes and corruption leading the nation
towards disintegration and discrimination and exploitation of weaker,
unprivileged sections of society, forcing destitution on vast number of
people. But the fault for it lies somewhere else.
Despite centuries of foreign rule over 75% of Indian population remains Hindu
and have strong feelings for caste-system.
Had caste system become obsolete, it would have given place to other system.
Caste system has influenced all other communities living in India.
Acted as a shield to keep Hindu religion alive – Systems and values of caste-
system have acted as a shield. During medieval and initial period of modern India,
caste system has been a major force for failure of Islam, Christianity and other
religions to make headway during the Muslims or British rule. Even after the mass
conversions of Hindus into Islam and Christianity, more than 75% population have
faith in Hinduism.
C. Rajgopalachari points out “If there is honesty in India today, any hospitality, any
charity- any aversion to evil, any love to be good, it is due to whatever remains of
the old faith and the old culture”.