Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transgender Women - Evaluation and Management
Transgender Women - Evaluation and Management
Authors:Vin Tangpricha, MD, PhDJoshua D Safer, MD, FACPSection Editors:Peter J Snyder, MDAlvin M
Matsumoto, MDDeputy Editor:Kathryn A Martin, MD
Contributor Disclosures
All topics are updated as new evidence becomes available and our peer review process is complete.
Literature review current through: Dec 2019. | This topic last updated: Aug 22, 2018.
INTRODUCTION
The terms transgender and gende
This topic will use the term transgender in the broadest sense to include any person
with incongruence between gender identity and external sexual anatomy at birth.
The evaluation and management of transgender men are discussed here. The
evaluation and management of transgender women, the primary care of the
transgender adult, and gender diversity in children and adolescents are reviewed
separately. (See "Primary care of transgender individuals" and "Gender development
and clinical presentation of gender diversity in children and adolescents" and
"Management of transgender and gender diverse children and adolescents".)
STANDARDS OF CARE
Several large medical professional organizations have issued guidelines to assist
providers in the care of transgender individuals (the World Professional Association
for Transgender Health [WPATH] [1], the Endocrine Society [2], the American
College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists [ACOG] [3]).
The Endocrine Society has released updated guidelines for the treatment of gender
dysphoria/gender incongruence [2]. The new guidelines replace the term
"transsexual" with "gender dysphoria" or "gender incongruence" and specify detailed
professional qualifications for clinicians who diagnose, assess, or treat individuals
with gender dysphoria/gender incongruence. Specifically, they now suggest that
decisions regarding social transition for prepubertal youth be made in conjunction
with a mental health or similarly experienced professional. They continue to
recommend the management and monitoring of transgender adolescents and adults
by a multidisciplinary team, as well as counseling patients about the time course of
hormone-induced physical changes and options for fertility preservation. We agree
with the updated guidelines.
OVERVIEW
The following considerations are similar for transgender men and women and are
discussed in detail in the topic on transgender women.
Gender dysphoria — Patients also may be diagnosed with gender dysphoria, which
is defined as the discomfort arising in some individuals from the incongruence
between their gender identities and their external sexual anatomy at birth.
The diagnosis of gender dysphoria is generally done by a mental health professional;
however, other health care professionals who have the appropriate experience and
training can also diagnose gender dysphoria. Mental health providers typically use
the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5) to
make a diagnosis [6]. Core components of the DSM-5 diagnosis of gender dysphoria
include longstanding discomfort with the incongruence between gender identity and
external sexual anatomy at birth along with interference with social, school, or other
areas of function [6].
HORMONAL THERAPY
In transgender men, the typical goal is to stop menses and induce virilization,
including a male pattern of sexual and facial hair, change in voice, and male physical
contours. The principal hormonal treatment is a testosterone preparation.
Criteria for starting — Criteria for starting hormone therapy include [5]:
●
Persistent, well-documented gender dysphoria/gender incongruence
●
Testosterone gel (1% or 1.6%, 2.5 to 10 g/day) may also be used [4], but virilization
might be slower if lower serum testosterone concentrations are achieved than with
testosterone injection. Some clinicians switch to gels once initial virilization is
complete. This may help to avoid supraphysiologic testosterone concentrations [12].
(See "Testosterone treatment of male hypogonadism", section on 'Is the testosterone
dose therapeutic?'.)
Masculinizing effects — There are a variety of consequences of hormonal therapy
in transgender men (table 2). Testosterone causes male-pattern hair growth and an
increase in lean body mass, muscle mass, and fat mass. It also causes growth in
midline structures like the larynx and the clitoris (which may be associated with an
increase in sexual desire).
Hair – The development of sexual hair follows the pattern observed in pubertal
boys: first the upper lip, then chin, then cheeks, etc [13,14]. The degree of hair
growth might be predicted from the pattern in male members of the same family.
The same applies to the occurrence of androgenetic alopecia, "male-pattern
baldness."
●
Voice – Deepening of the voice may occur due to oropharyngeal growth and
may be irreversible [15,16].
●
Clitoral enlargement – Clitoral enlargement occurs in all, but the degree varies.
●
Sexual desire – Most subjects will note an increase in sexual desire [19-21].
●
The relatively lower height and the broader hip configuration of transgender men
compared with nontransgender men does not change with testosterone
treatment.
In addition to monitoring weight and blood pressure, lab testing should include a
hematocrit because erythrocytosis is a common consequence of testosterone
administration, reported more with testosterone ester injections. Details of
biochemical testing, bone mineral density (BMD) testing, and need for mammograms
are outlined in the table (table 3). (See 'Adverse events' below.)
Adverse events — Androgen therapy is safe for most patients [23,25]. However,
there are some potential adverse events.
The criteria for initiating genital surgical treatment include the same criteria for
hormone therapy, but an additional criterion is added due to its increased
invasiveness [1] (see 'Criteria for starting' above):
One year of continuous hormone therapy and living in the desired gender role
is expected, unless it has been determined the hormone therapy is not medically
indicated. This criterion is not required for surgeries like chest reconstruction or
other nongenital surgeries.
Additional details for surgical procedures are available in the World Professional
Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) Standards of Care [1]. (See
'Standards of care' above.)
Prior to surgery, the clinician should continue to counsel the patient to acknowledge
the limitations of what gender confirmation surgery can achieve. In addition, the
patient should continue to work closely with the supporting medical and mental
health providers as appropriate.
The most commonly desired gender confirmation surgery for transgender men is
chest reconstruction surgery (breast reduction [31]). Note that surgeons experienced
with this surgery for men should be sought out (similar to men with gynecomastia in
general).
Genital reconstruction procedures are best performed in the few centers with
specialized expertise. The surgeries can be less popular because of their cost and
relatively high morbidity. One option is creation of a neophallus [4,32]. In other
cases, a metaidoioplasty may be performed [32,33]. With this technique, the urethra
is lengthened using an anterior vaginal wall flap to reach the tip of the phallic glans,
and the clitoris is partially released and stretched by resection of the ventral chordae.
From the labia majora, a scrotum can be constructed in which testicular prostheses
can be implanted. This surgical intervention allows the patient to urinate standing.
Alternatively, free flaps removed from arms or legs can be used to construct a
neophallus.
Sexual function after genital reconstruction surgery — Little attention has been
given to this subject, and research has been based on self-reports. As expected for
those transgender men with a neophallus, there is a correlation between sexual
function and the quality of the neophallus [34]. While not all transgender persons are
orgasmic after a neophallus is created, many report sexual satisfaction [20,35-37].
Transgender men receiving androgens generally report an increase in sexual
interest [38]. Systematic investigation is needed to gain more insight [21].
Management of hyperprolactinemia
Author:Peter J Snyder, MDSection Editor:David S Cooper, MDDeputy Editor:Kathryn A Martin, MD
All topics are updated as new evidence becomes available and our peer review process is complete.
Literature review current through: Dec 2019. | This topic last updated: Oct 20, 2019.
INTRODUCTION
This topic will review the major issues concerning the therapy of hyperprolactinemia
due to lactotroph adenomas and other causes, with the exception of treatment during
pregnancy, which is discussed separately. The causes, clinical manifestations, and
diagnosis of hyperprolactinemia are also discussed elsewhere. (See "Management
of lactotroph adenoma (prolactinoma) during pregnancy" and "Causes of
hyperprolactinemia" and "Clinical manifestations and evaluation of
hyperprolactinemia".)
There are two principal reasons why patients with hyperprolactinemia may need to
be treated: existing or impending neurologic symptoms due to the large size of a
lactotroph adenoma, and hypogonadism or other symptoms due to
hyperprolactinemia, such as galactorrhea [1,2].
A third indication is in women with mild hyperprolactinemia and normal cycles who
are trying to conceive as they may have subtle luteal phase dysfunction (see
"Clinical manifestations and evaluation of hyperprolactinemia", section on 'Menstrual
cycle dysfunction'). Our approach to management is similar to that suggested by the
Endocrine Society Guidelines [2].
In contrast to the extremely high serum prolactin concentrations that may be seen
with lactotroph macroadenomas, prolactin levels due to nonadenoma causes rarely
exceed 200 ng/mL (8.7 nmol/L). (See "Clinical manifestations and evaluation of
hyperprolactinemia", section on 'Serum prolactin concentrations'.)
Premenopausal women
●
Postmenopausal women
Men
In men, hypogonadism can cause decreased libido and energy and eventually
loss of sexual hair, loss of muscle mass, and osteoporosis. Hyperprolactinemia
in men may also be associated with erectile dysfunction, even when the serum
testosterone concentration is normal. The mechanism is unknown, but the
erectile dysfunction usually improves dramatically when the hyperprolactinemia
is corrected [5-7]. Gynecomastia and galactorrhea may occur, but both are rare.
OVERVIEW OF DOPAMINE AGONISTS
A dopamine agonist drug should usually be the first treatment for patients with
hyperprolactinemia of any cause, including lactotroph adenomas (prolactinomas) of
all sizes, because these drugs decrease serum prolactin concentrations and
decrease the size of most lactotroph adenomas [8,9]. Other approaches must be
considered for the minority of patients whose adenomas are resistant to dopamine
agonists or who cannot tolerate these drugs, and for those who are taking a
medication (such as an antipsychotic drug) that cannot be discontinued. (See
'Intolerant or inadequate response' below and 'Drug-induced hyperprolactinemia'
below.)
Choice of drug — For most patients with hyperprolactinemia, cabergoline is our first
choice, and bromocriptine is our second. Pergolide had been used for Parkinson
disease and hyperprolactinemia, but it was withdrawn from the market in the United
States because of concerns about valvular heart disease. Quinagolide is available in
some countries, but not the United States. (See 'Valvular heart disease' below.)
Pergolide – Pergolide is an ergot derivative that had been used primarily for the
treatment of Parkinson disease [15]. At the high dose used for Parkinson
disease (>3 mg/day), pergolide was associated with an increased risk of valvular
heart disease [13,14]. It was withdrawn from the United States market in 2007
[16], but it is still available in some countries. (See 'Valvular heart disease' below
and "Initial pharmacologic treatment of Parkinson disease", section on 'Limited
role of ergot dopamine agonists'.)
●
Overall, the greater the decrease in serum prolactin concentration, the greater the
decrease in adenoma size, although there is considerable variation from patient to
patient. The effect on adenoma size is most apparent in patients with lactotroph
macroadenomas (image 1) [21].
The therapeutic efficacy of dopamine agonists may be blunted by the concurrent use
of drugs known to raise serum prolactin concentrations, including neuroleptic drugs,
metoclopramide, sulpiride, domperidone, methyldopa, verapamil, and cimetidine.
Time course of clinical response — The fall in serum prolactin typically occurs
within the first two to three weeks of therapy with a dopamine agonist (figure 2) [10];
in patients with macroadenomas, it always precedes any decrease in adenoma size
[18]. The decrease in adenoma size can, in many patients, be detected by imaging
within six weeks after initiation of treatment; in some patients, however, a decrease
is not apparent for six months (image 1) [21]. These benefits occur even in patients
who have impaired visual fields before therapy, occurring in 9 of 10 such patients in
each of two reports [23,24].
Following the decrease in serum prolactin and adenoma size in patients with
macroadenomas, visual and pituitary function often return to normal. Vision usually
begins to improve within days after the initiation of treatment [21,23]. There is
recovery of menses and fertility in women and of testosterone secretion, sperm
count, and erectile function in men [8,10,25-27]. Patients with macroadenomas who
are hypothyroid and/or hypoadrenal may also have a return of these functions to
normal [28].
Adverse effects
Typical — The principal side effects of dopamine agonist drugs are nausea, postural
hypotension, and mental fogginess. Less common side effects include nasal
stuffiness, depression, Raynaud phenomenon, alcohol intolerance, and constipation.
Nausea appears to be more common with bromocriptine than cabergoline.
Side effects are more likely to occur when treatment is initiated or the dose is
increased. They can be avoided in most patients by starting with a small dose (eg,
one-half of the lowest strength pill of bromocriptine once a day or half a pill of
cabergoline twice a week) and by giving it with food or at bedtime. A small
percentage of patients have side effects even at the lowest doses. In women,
nausea can be avoided by intravaginal administration [29].
Impulse control disorders — An adverse effect that has been recognized is the
onset or exacerbation of impulse control disorders, such as hypersexuality and
compulsive gambling, shopping, or eating. These behaviors had originally been
described in case reports. In a small, controlled study, 10 hyperprolactinemic
patients who were treated with cabergoline had a higher score on one scale of
impulsiveness than hyperprolactinemic patients not treated or 10 patients with a
normal prolactin [30]. In an uncontrolled study of 308 patients who had lactotroph
adenomas and were treated with cabergoline for at least three months, 17 percent
developed an impulse control disorder [31]. The increased risk of impulse control
disorders has also been described in up to 50 percent of patients taking dopamine
agonists for Parkinson disease (See "Initial pharmacologic treatment of Parkinson
disease", section on 'Impulse control disorders'.)
Valvular heart disease — Cabergoline and pergolide have been associated with
valvular heart disease in patients with Parkinson disease [13,14]. The association
appears to be dose dependent, and the pergolide doses used for Parkinson disease
were much higher than those used for hyperprolactinemia. In the United States,
pergolide was voluntarily withdrawn from the market in March 2007 due to this risk
[16]. (See "Initial pharmacologic treatment of Parkinson disease", section on 'Limited
role of ergot dopamine agonists'.)
One hundred and ninety-one of patients who were reported in one of the studies
above [41] were followed for an additional median time of 34 months, during which
time they took a median additional 232 mg of cabergoline and had a transthoracic
echocardiogram at the beginning and end of the additional observation period. No
association was found between the dose of cabergoline and the prevalence of a
valvular abnormality [43].
However, new onset of valvular heart disease has been reported in a few patients
taking cabergoline. In one patient who was treated with 6 mg of cabergoline a week,
serial echocardiograms showed no valvular disease when the cumulative dose was
3272 mg, but a thickened and restricted aortic valve when the cumulative dose was
4192 mg [44].
Based upon the available data, we suggest using the lowest dose of cabergoline
necessary to lower prolactin to normal. We also suggest ordering cardiac
ultrasonography approximately every two years in patients who take larger than
typical doses of cabergoline (eg, greater than 2 mg per week). There are no
available data for cabergoline use in patients with preexisting valvular heart disease.
However, for patients with a lactotroph adenoma and mild valvular heart disease, we
feel it is reasonable to use cabergoline therapy since the doses used in this setting
have not been associated with an increased risk of valvular heart disease.
MICROADENOMAS
Initial therapy (dopamine agonists) — Given the high rate of efficacy and low rate
of side effects with dopamine agonists, as well as the consequences of
hypogonadism, we recommend that these agents be used in patients with lactotroph
microadenomas who have any degree of hypogonadism. Decreasing the size of the
pituitary adenoma is not a treatment goal in these patients.
Similarly, when treating women with bothersome galactorrhea, the goal of therapy is
to lower the serum prolactin low enough to resolve the galactorrhea. This may not
require lowering prolactin into the normal range for the galactorrhea to remit.
If the serum prolactin concentration has not decreased to normal but no side
effects have occurred, the dose should be increased gradually to as much as
1.5 mg of cabergoline two or three times a week or 5 mg of bromocriptine twice
a day. Whatever dose results in a normal serum prolactin value should be
continued. (See 'Prolactin normalized' above.)
●
To initial therapy:
•
If the serum prolactin concentration does not decrease sufficiently to restore
normal gonadal function in response to bromocriptine (if it was chosen as
initial therapy) and if compliance seems good, changing to cabergoline may
be effective. The cabergoline dose should then be adjusted until the serum
prolactin concentration is normal. (See 'Prolactin normalized' above.)
Approximately 25 percent of patients are resistant to bromocriptine [10,12],
and most (80 percent) can achieve normal prolactin concentrations with
cabergoline therapy [12,50]. It is estimated that 10 percent of patients are
resistant to cabergoline [2].
•
If the patient cannot tolerate the first dopamine agonist administered
because of side effects, another can be tried. In women, nausea can be
avoided by vaginal administration [51], although other side effects cannot.
●
Since estradiol treatment might pose a slight risk of increasing the size of the
adenoma, the serum prolactin concentration should be measured periodically in
these patients. Estradiol should not be used as the sole treatment for lactotroph
macroadenomas.
Estradiol and progestin can be administered separately in low doses as they would
be for the treatment of hypogonadism of any etiology, or estrogen can be
administered in the form of an oral contraceptive. (See "Combined estrogen-
progestin oral contraceptives: Patient selection, counseling, and use".)
After approximately one year of treatment (if prolactin is normal), the dose can often
be decreased. If the prolactin has been normal for two or more years and no
adenoma is seen on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), discontinuation of the drug
can be considered. (See 'Withdrawal of dopamine agonists' below.)
If the drug is discontinued, prolactin should be measured after three months and
yearly thereafter. If the prolactin increases substantially (eg, to >100 ng/mL),
especially in a patient who originally had a macroadenoma, an MRI should be
performed.
We recommend not stopping the dopamine agonist if the prolactin increases above
normal while gradually decreasing the drug.
Higher rate of remission in studies in which cabergoline was used (35 percent in
four studies) than in those in which bromocriptine was used (20 percent in 12
studies).
●
Menopause — After menopause, the drug can be discontinued and the serum
prolactin concentration can be allowed to rise. Imaging should be performed if the
value rises above 200 ng/mL to determine if the adenoma has increased to a
clinically important size. If so, drug therapy should be resumed.
MACROADENOMAS
Titration of dose and monitoring — The serum prolactin should be measured and
the cabergoline dose should be increased every one to three months, if necessary,
until the serum prolactin concentration becomes normal.
If vision was abnormal before therapy, it should be reassessed within one month,
although improvement may occur within a few days. Magnetic resonance imaging
(MRI) should be repeated in 6 to 12 months to determine if the size of the adenoma
has decreased.
The size of the adenoma decreases to approximately the same degree as the
serum prolactin concentration, although the relationship varies from patient to
patient.
●
The decrease in size usually cannot be demonstrated until weeks or months
after the prolactin secretion has decreased (image 1).
●
If the clinical picture is stable (no evidence of adenoma growth on MRI and no
symptoms such as headaches or visual symptoms), serum prolactin should be
measured in six months, and if normal, it should then be measured yearly.
●
Serum prolactin should be measured at any point if there are recurrent or new
symptoms.
Candidates for stopping therapy — If the serum prolactin concentration has been
normal for at least one year and the adenoma has decreased markedly in size, the
dose of the dopamine agonist can be decreased gradually, as long as the serum
prolactin remains normal [62]. Discontinuation can be considered in those patients
who had macroadenomas of modest size (eg, 1.0 to 1.5 cm), whose serum prolactin
concentrations have been normal for more than two years, and whose adenomas
can no longer be visualized by MRI for more than two years.
If the drug is discontinued, the prolactin concentration and the size of the adenoma
by MRI must be monitored.
Discontinuation should probably not be considered if the adenoma was initially >2
cm, if it can still be visualized by MRI during treatment, or if the prolactin has not
become normal during treatment. The agonist should not be discontinued entirely,
even after menopause, because hyperprolactinemia will probably recur and the
adenoma may increase in size [52,59,60]. (See 'Withdrawal of dopamine agonists'
above.)
Inadequate response or drug intolerance — We recommend the following
approach in patients who do not have a complete response to dopamine agonist
therapy:
If bromocriptine was tried first and the patient cannot tolerate it or the adenoma
does not respond to it, cabergoline should be tried.
●
If the patient cannot tolerate or the adenoma does not respond to agonist
therapy, transsphenoidal surgery should be performed, and if a significant
amount of adenoma tissue remains after surgery, radiation therapy should be
administered (see "Radiation therapy of pituitary adenomas", section on
'Lactotroph adenomas (prolactin-secreting adenomas)'). Surgery can also be
considered for the woman who has a giant adenoma and is contemplating
pregnancy. (See 'Role of transsphenoidal surgery' below.)
A woman has a giant lactotroph adenoma (eg, >3 cm) and wishes to become
pregnant even if the adenoma responds to a dopamine agonist. The rationale
for this approach is that if the patient becomes pregnant and discontinues the
agonist for the duration of pregnancy, the adenoma may increase to a clinically
important size before delivery.
Not all of the adenoma tissue is excised in many patients, particularly those with
macroadenomas. (See "Transsphenoidal surgery for pituitary adenomas and
other sellar masses", section on 'Lactotroph adenomas'.)
●
The adenoma and hyperprolactinemia may recur within several years after
surgery. (See "Transsphenoidal surgery for pituitary adenomas and other sellar
masses", section on 'Lactotroph adenomas'.)
Complications are the same as may occur during and after transsphenoidal surgery
for any kind of pituitary adenoma.
Contributor Disclosures
All topics are updated as new evidence becomes available and our peer review process is complete.
Literature review current through: Dec 2019. | This topic last updated: Jul 17, 2019.
INTRODUCTION
The polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is an important cause of androgen excess,
menstrual irregularity, and cardiometabolic dysfunction in women. When fully
expressed, the manifestations include irregular menstrual cycles, hirsutism, obesity,
insulin resistance, and anovulatory infertility.
The treatment of PCOS will be reviewed here. The epidemiology and pathogenesis,
diagnostic criteria, and clinical manifestations of PCOS are described in detail
separately. (See "Epidemiology, phenotype, and genetics of the polycystic ovary
syndrome in adults" and "Diagnosis of polycystic ovary syndrome in adults" and
"Clinical manifestations of polycystic ovary syndrome in adults".)
OVERVIEW OF APPROACH
Women with PCOS have multiple abnormalities that require attention, including
oligomenorrhea, hyperandrogenism, anovulatory infertility, and metabolic risk factors
such as obesity, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and impaired glucose tolerance.
Weight loss, which can restore ovulatory cycles and improve metabolic risk, is the
first-line intervention for most women. Our overall approach is similar to that
described by the Endocrine Society Clinical Guidelines [1] and the international
guidelines for the assessment and management of PCOS [2].
Lifestyle changes — We suggest diet and exercise for weight reduction as the first
step for overweight and obese women with PCOS. Available evidence suggests that
lifestyle interventions (diet, exercise, and behavioral interventions) are more effective
than minimal treatment for weight loss and for improving insulin resistance and
hyperandrogenism [3]. In addition, there appear to be reproductive benefits as well.
(See 'Weight reduction' below and 'Weight loss' below.)
Our approach to the use of COCs in women with PCOS is the same as in women
without PCOS. Risk factors for VTE including obesity, patient age, and family history
of VTE should be assessed. We currently suggest using caution if COCs are
prescribed to obese women (body mass index [BMI] ≥30 kg/m2) over age 40 years
because these women are at particularly high risk for VTE. Other relative and
absolute contraindications to COC use are outlined in the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC) United States Medical Eligibility Criteria for
Contraceptive Use. Alternatives to COCs include cyclic progestin therapy,
continuous progestin therapy (progestin-only pills [the "mini-pill"]), or a progestin-
releasing intrauterine device (IUD). Cyclic progestin therapy can induce regular
withdrawal uterine bleeding and reduce the risk of endometrial hyperplasia. Both
continuous progestin therapy (eg, a progestin-only pill such as norethindrone 0.35
mg/day) and the progestin-releasing IUD provide contraception and reduce the risk
of endometrial hyperplasia. (See 'Endometrial protection' below and "Combined
estrogen-progestin contraception: Side effects and health concerns", section on
'Cardiovascular effects'.)
Patient satisfaction with care — Women with PCOS commonly report long delays
in diagnosis and dissatisfaction with their care. In a cross-sectional study of 134
women with PCOS and 198 controls without PCOS who completed an online
evaluation of their health care providers, those with PCOS had less trust in their
primary care providers, perceived them as less qualified to treat PCOS-related
health concerns, and argued with them more often [4]. These observations highlight
opportunities for improving care for women with PCOS. (See "Diagnosis of polycystic
ovary syndrome in adults", section on 'Delays in diagnosis'.)
Menstrual dysfunction
COCs affect insulin sensitivity, carbohydrate metabolism, and lipid metabolism; the
effects depend upon the estrogen dose and androgenicity of the progestin. However,
there is no evidence that women with PCOS are at greater risk for either metabolic
adverse effects or cardiovascular complications of COCs. (See 'Metabolic effects of
COCs in PCOS' below and "Combined estrogen-progestin contraception: Side
effects and health concerns" and "Clinical manifestations of polycystic ovary
syndrome in adults", section on 'Venous thromboembolism'.)
An approach to starting COCs in women with PCOS is described below (see 'Choice
of oral contraceptive' below). Risks and side effects of COCs (including unscheduled
bleeding) are similar to those for women without PCOS. Unscheduled bleeding and
an overview of estrogen-progestin COCs are reviewed in detail separately. (See
"Combined estrogen-progestin contraception: Side effects and health concerns" and
"Combined estrogen-progestin oral contraceptives: Patient selection, counseling,
and use".)
For women with PCOS who choose not to or cannot take COCs, alternative
treatments for endometrial protection are intermittent or continuous progestin
therapy, or a progestin-releasing intrauterine device (IUD) [5]. In this setting, we
recommend medroxyprogesterone acetate (5 to 10 mg) for 10 to 14 days every one
to two months. An alternative, but one that has been less well studied, is natural
micronized progesterone 200 mg (given for the same duration every one to two
months). Patients should be made aware that progestin therapy alone will not reduce
the symptoms of acne or hirsutism, nor will it provide contraception. However,
continuous progestin therapy with norethindrone 0.35 mg daily provides both
contraception and endometrial protection. This is a progestin-only contraceptive that
is also referred to as the "mini-pill." An alternative progestin option that provides both
endometrial protection and contraception are the levonorgestrel-releasing IUDs.
(See "Intrauterine contraception: Background and device types", section on
'Levonorgestrel IUD' and "Intrauterine contraception: Candidates and device
selection", section on 'Endometrial protection'.)
Androgen excess
Higher doses of ethinyl estradiol (30 to 35 mcg) are needed in some women for
optimal suppression of ovarian androgens and management of hyperandrogenic
features. Although transdermal or vaginal ring preparations are potential options,
they have not been well studied for the management of hirsutism. The risk of VTE
with the transdermal and vaginal ring preparations appear to be similar to COCs
containing levonorgestrel. (See "Hormonal contraceptive vaginal rings", section on
'Cardiovascular and thromboembolic events' and "Transdermal contraceptive patch",
section on 'Risk of venous thrombotic events'.)
Antiandrogens — After six months, if the patient is not satisfied with the clinical
response to COC monotherapy (for hyperandrogenic symptoms), we typically add
spironolactone 50 to 100 mg twice daily. (See "Treatment of hirsutism", section on
'Antiandrogen therapy'.)
Although some clinicians use metformin to treat hirsutism, the Endocrine Society
Clinical Practice Guidelines suggest against its routine use as it is associated with
minimal or no benefit and is less effective than treatment with COCs and/or
antiandrogens [10]. (See "Metformin for treatment of the polycystic ovary syndrome",
section on 'Hirsutism'.)
Acne and androgenetic alopecia — The management of acne and scalp hair loss
(androgenetic alopecia) in women with PCOS are reviewed in detail separately. (See
"Treatment of acne vulgaris", section on 'Hormonal therapy' and "Treatment of
androgenetic alopecia in men".)
Metabolic abnormalities
Obesity — Weight loss, which can restore ovulatory cycles and improve metabolic
risk, is the first-line intervention for most women. The approach to obesity
management is the same as that for patients without PCOS, starting with lifestyle
changes (diet and exercise) [11], followed by pharmacotherapy, and, when
necessary, bariatric surgery [12]. (See 'Weight reduction' below and "Obesity in
adults: Overview of management" and "Outcomes of bariatric surgery", section on
'Polycystic ovary syndrome'.)
Even modest weight loss (5 to 10 percent reduction in body weight) in women with
PCOS may result in restoration of normal ovulatory cycles [14-16] and improved
pregnancy rates [17] in short-term studies. However, the response to weight loss is
variable; not all individuals have restoration of ovulation or menses despite similar
weight reduction [11,12,18]. In addition, there are no randomized trials and no long-
term data on reproductive or metabolic outcomes with weight loss.
Weight loss results in a decrease in serum androgen concentrations and, in some
instances, improvements in hirsutism. However, data demonstrating an improvement
in hirsutism are limited [3,11].
There is no good evidence that one type of diet is superior to another for women with
PCOS. Low-carbohydrate diets have become very popular for women with PCOS,
based upon the notion that less carbohydrate leads to less hyperinsulinemia and
therefore less insulin resistance. However, a 12-week study of a high protein/low
carbohydrate diet (30 percent protein, 40 percent carbohydrate, 30 percent fat) and a
low protein/high carbohydrate diet (15 percent protein, 55 percent carbohydrate, 30
percent fat) were equally effective for weight loss, improvements in menstrual
cyclicity, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and abdominal fat in one study of 28
overweight women with PCOS [19]. It is not known if an extremely low carbohydrate
diet would be any more effective for these endpoints. (See "Obesity in adults: Dietary
therapy", section on 'Low-carbohydrate diets'.)
Bariatric surgery — Bariatric surgery is another strategy for weight loss in women
with PCOS. In one study of 17 obese women with PCOS with a mean body mass
index (BMI) of 50.7 kg/m2, bariatric surgery was associated with a mean weight loss
after 12 months of 41±9 kg, restoration of ovulatory cycles, and improvements in
insulin resistance, hyperandrogenemia, and hirsutism scores [12]. A retrospective
chart review and meta-analysis of 29 studies reported similar benefits for women
with PCOS [20,21]. (See "Bariatric operations for management of obesity: Indications
and preoperative preparation" and "Outcomes of bariatric surgery", section on
'Polycystic ovary syndrome'.)
Thiazolidinediones have been less well studied than metformin, but they appear to
improve insulin sensitivity and hyperandrogenemia [22-28]. However, because of
limited clinical data, potential weight gain, and a possible association with
cardiovascular adverse events, we do not recommend the use of thiazolidinediones
in women with PCOS who do not have diabetes. (See "Thiazolidinediones in the
treatment of diabetes mellitus".)
Though not specifically approved for PCOS, liraglutide is approved for individuals
with a BMI of 30 kg/m2 or greater. Limited data in women with PCOS suggest that
liraglutide results in greater weight loss than placebo [29,30]. (See "Obesity in adults:
Drug therapy", section on 'Liraglutide'.)
There are also theoretical concerns that women with PCOS may be at particular risk
for cardiovascular complications with COCs, given their other underlying
cardiovascular risk factors. However, there are no COC risk data specific to women
with PCOS. (See "Combined estrogen-progestin contraception: Side effects and
health concerns", section on 'Cardiovascular effects'.)
Statins — Statins are effective for dyslipidemia in women with PCOS but do not
appear to have other clinically important metabolic or endocrine effects. In a meta-
analysis of four trials in 244 women randomly assigned to a statin (simvastatin or
atorvastatin) or placebo for 6 to 12 months, statin therapy decreased serum low-
density lipoprotein (LDL) and triglycerides, but had no effect on high-density
lipoprotein (HDL), fasting insulin, or C-reactive protein. A small decrease in serum
testosterone was observed, but there were no improvements in menstrual cycle
regularity, ovulation, acne, hirsutism, or BMI [36].
Weight loss — For anovulatory women with PCOS who are overweight or obese,
we suggest weight loss prior to initiating ovulation induction therapy. The approach
to obesity management is the same as that for patients without PCOS, starting with
lifestyle changes (diet and exercise) [11], followed by pharmacotherapy (if not
pursuing pregnancy), and, when necessary, bariatric surgery [12]. (See 'Weight
reduction' above and "Obesity in adults: Overview of management" and "Outcomes
of bariatric surgery", section on 'Polycystic ovary syndrome'.)
●
The Treatment of Hyperandrogenism versus Insulin Resistance in Infertile
Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (OWL-PCOS) Women, an open-label study of
overweight or obese women with PCOS and anovulatory infertility assigned to
16 weeks of pretreatment with continuous oral contraceptives (COCs; n = 47),
lifestyle modification (including caloric restriction, antiobesity medication,
behavioral medication, and exercise; n = 48), or the combination of both (COCs
and lifestyle; n = 47) followed by up to four cycles of clomiphene citrate for
ovulation induction.
●
In PPCOS II, after four cycles of clomiphene (with no pretreatment), the cumulative
per-cycle ovulatory and live birth rates were 45 and 10.2 percent; (227 of 619 cycles,
19 of 187 patients). In OWL-PCOS, a 16-week pretreatment lifestyle intervention
resulted in an approximate 6.5 percent weight loss from baseline and improvements
in ovulatory and live birth rates (62 and 25 percent, respectively; 80 of 129 cycles
and 12 of 48 patients). Pretreatment with oral contraceptives (alone or combined
with lifestyle intervention) did not affect outcomes.
Although we encourage weight loss in obese woman with PCOS and anovulatory
infertility, our approach is somewhat different in older women (≥37 years) or in those
whose testing shows diminished ovarian reserve. In these settings, we typically offer
either immediate ovulation induction or a short (three-month) attempt at weight loss
followed by ovulation induction. We do not suggest a longer attempt to lose weight.
●
For oligoovulatory women with PCOS undergoing ovulation induction, we now
suggest letrozole as first-line therapy over clomiphene citrate, regardless of the
patient's BMI. Before starting letrozole, the clinician must discuss that this use
of the drug is not approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for
this purpose and that there is an available alternative (clomiphene citrate). (See
"Ovulation induction with letrozole", section on 'Outcomes'.)
●
Clomiphene citrate had been the first-line drug for this population for many
years, with metformin used as an alternative. However, both clomiphene and
metformin appear to be less effective for live birth rates than letrozole [47]. In
women with PCOS, an ovulatory rate of 80 percent and a cumulative pregnancy
rate of 30 to 40 percent can be expected. Cumulative pregnancy rate is
dependent on patient BMI, with higher BMI levels associated with lower
cumulative pregnancy rate. (See "Ovulation induction with clomiphene citrate".)
●
Other medications
•
Thiazolidinedione therapy has been investigated for induction of ovulation
[8,51-53], but we do not suggest its use because of concern about its
cardiovascular safety. (See 'Insulin resistance/type 2 diabetes' above and
"Thiazolidinediones in the treatment of diabetes mellitus".)
•
Although women with PCOS are not likely gonadotropin-releasing hormone
(GnRH) deficient, pulsatile GnRH is moderately effective for ovulation
induction. It is currently available in Europe, but not in the United States. In
one study of 41 patients undergoing 114 ovulation induction cycles, 56
percent of women ovulated, and 40 percent of ovulatory patients achieved
pregnancy [54]. Ovulatory cycles were associated with lower BMI and
fasting insulin, and higher baseline serum follicle-stimulating hormone
(FSH) concentrations. Thus, pulsatile GnRH may be a reasonable option,
particularly for lean women with PCOS.
Acupuncture — Infertility centers often offer acupuncture as an adjunctive therapy
to women with PCOS undergoing ovulation induction or in vitro fertilization. However,
available evidence suggests that it does not improve live birth rates when used alone
or combined with clomiphene citrate (compared with sham acupuncture alone or with
clomiphene) [55,56]. The addition of acupuncture during in vitro fertilization cycles
does not improve outcomes. (See "In vitro fertilization".)
For women who do not respond to ovulation induction with either letrozole or
clomiphene citrate, laparoscopic ovarian drilling (also referred to as laparoscopic
ovarian diathermy or electrocoagulation) is a surgical option for second-line
treatment. When compared with gonadotropin therapy, another second-line
treatment, ovarian drilling has similar efficacy but results in lower risk of high order
multiple gestations or OHSS (table 3) [57,58]. Disadvantages of ovarian drilling
include surgical risk and potential adhesion formation. Although laparoscopic ovarian
drilling has been utilized for decades, the technique has never been standardized
regarding the energy source, number of punctures, dose and duration per puncture,
or whether one or both ovaries should be treated. Based on limited dose-ranging
studies, three to six punctures per ovary at 40 W of coagulating (modulated) current
for four seconds per puncture seems reasonable [59,60].
Ovarian drilling likely reduces ovarian secretion of androgens and proteins, resulting
in an increase in LH and FSH secretion. In turn, following ovarian drilling, the ovary
is more responsive to stimulation by endogenous gonadotropins favoring the growth
of a dominant ovarian follicle and ovulation. Following ovarian drilling ovulatory
cycles occur in approximately 80 percent of patients with a range of 30 to 90 percent,
in published studies [61]. The normalization of ovulatory function continued for many
years in the majority of patients following ovarian drilling [62-65].
UpToDate offers two types of patient education materials, "The Basics" and "Beyond
the Basics." The Basics patient education pieces are written in plain language, at the
5th to 6th grade reading level, and they answer the four or five key questions a patient
might have about a given condition. These articles are best for patients who want a
general overview and who prefer short, easy-to-read materials. Beyond the Basics
patient education pieces are longer, more sophisticated, and more detailed. These
articles are written at the 10th to 12th grade reading level and are best for patients
who want in-depth information and are comfortable with some medical jargon.
Here are the patient education articles that are relevant to this topic. We encourage
you to print or e-mail these topics to your patients. (You can also locate patient
education articles on a variety of subjects by searching on "patient info" and the
keyword(s) of interest.)
Basics topics (see "Patient education: Polycystic ovary syndrome (The Basics)")
●
Beyond the Basics topics (see "Patient education: Polycystic ovary syndrome
(PCOS) (Beyond the Basics)")
Weight loss, which can improve metabolic risk, restore ovulatory cycles and
possibly improve live birth rates, is the first-line intervention for most women.
(See 'Overview of approach' above and 'Weight loss' above.)
●
Our approach to the use of COCs in women with PCOS is the same as that for
women without PCOS. Risk factors for venous thromboembolism (VTE),
including obesity, patient age, and family history of VTE, should be assessed.
More information can be found in the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) United States Medical Eligibility Criteria for Contraceptive
Use.
We suggest caution when prescribing COCs in obese women (body mass index
[BMI] ≥30 kg/m2) over age 40 years because of their greater risk of VTE. Other
relative and absolute contraindications to COC use are outlined in the CDC
United States Medical Eligibility Criteria for Contraceptive Use. (See 'Oral
contraceptives and risk assessment' above.)
●
If the patient is not satisfied with the clinical response to six months of COC
monotherapy (for hyperandrogenic manifestations), we suggest adding
spironolactone (Grade 2B). (See 'Androgen excess' above and "Treatment of
hirsutism".)
●
For women with PCOS who choose not to or cannot take COCs, we typically
use intermittent progestin therapy. (See 'Menstrual dysfunction' above.)
●
For women with PCOS undergoing ovulation induction, we now suggest
letrozole as first-line therapy over clomiphene citrate (Grade 2B). Before starting
letrozole, the clinician must discuss that this use of the drug is not approved by
the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and that clomiphene is an
alternative. (See "Ovulation induction with letrozole", section on 'Suggested
approach'.)
●
For women with PCOS and a BMI >30 kg/m2, we also suggest diet and exercise
to promote weight loss. (See 'Women pursuing pregnancy' above.)