Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Inglese 5
Inglese 5
Victoria succeeded to the throne of England at 17, very young. She had to face a very
complex society, it was called the age of contradictions, social complexity. (1837 - 1901)
Queen Victoria's reign was the longest, it must be considered as a bridge between the 19th
century and the following one. She opened the way to the 20th century. She was very young
but determined, but she was not alone, his husband Prince Albert, who was Queen Victoria's
cousin.
They got married, their marriage was very happy, and they had 9 children.
A real photo of the time with Victoria and their children. Without his husband she wouldn't
have been the same queen. Prince Albert was her counselor, she made with him her
decisions, he was more open minded, he understood the necessity of changing the society.
If queen Victoria passed so many reforms in favour of the working class, it was thanks to
prince Albert. He died very young, and it was such a trauma for her that she was so sad, she
felt lost because she relied on him. The last part of her reign was more gloomy than the first
one.
Queen Victoria: on the one hand she represented the determined woman, on the other hand
she liked to be photographed with her family. She wanted to represent and to symbolise the
perfect mother and wife. Political woman and stereotyped idea of woman - the role of the
woman. Many women started to understand that their role could be different at the time. The
woman taking care of the family.
Florence Nightingale was a nurse. During the Crimean war, she moved from the battlefield,
healed wounded soldiers, children and civilians who as a consequence of the war were
injured. The nurses of the Red Cross act nowadays as Florence Nightingale acted. She
opened the first training school for nurses in a hospital. She opened the way for many
women to become nurses.
Charles Dickens
Charles Dickens: like Verga he denounces the awful conditions in the workhouses, his
novels were set in the workhouses, so that the majority of people could be aware of this
problem. In the workhouse women were separated from men. Many of them were crowded
in very small hoods, like slums. Oliver Twist painted this.
Big problem of immigration, the mechanism is the same as in the workhouses, there are
charity organizations in order to support these people, giving them food and lodging, and
giving them a job. But then these money are not spent for the aim they were given for, and
so immigrants have become a good business, where mafia has tried in the recent years to
get the control of the situation, and this is the same thing which happen in these years.
The political system which was born in the Enlightenment (Tories and whigs) changed
(conservatives and liberals). Then, there was foundation of the labour party, to support and
protect the working class.
These Victorian age was very conformist, but this denounce opened the way to the 20th
century. The contradiction between the role of the women and the rebels / the exploitation of
workers and the new movement to guarantee more rights and the right to vote.
The first reform bill satisfied the middle class, extended the right to vote to some workers, but
not to all of them.
→ Connection with Charles Darwin. (Page 27-28). Each country which wants to colonise
another country always finds good excuses. Charles Darwin was a scientist, and he didn't
support any idea of British imperialism, his book had nothing to do with this idea, but it could
be easily misinterpreted, it was easy to misinterpret his idea in that way. Charles Darwin was
the first who put in doubt the existence of God. The scientist in the Enlightenment didn't put
in doubt the existence of God. Instead, Charles Darwin created a break between science
and religion. His story seemed to show how the strongest survived and the weakest
deserved to be defeated. The weakest needed to be colonised and submitted from the
superior race. All living creatures have taken their living force through a slow process of
change and adaptation. In the struggle for survival, physical conditions determined the
survival of a species and the extinction of another. Man evolved, like any other animal, from
less highly organised forms, namely from a monkey.
This theory was taken from Herbert Spencer. Herbert Spencer misused Charles Darwin's
theory and found a philosophical current called social darwinism, the social justification for
the British empire. He affirmed using Darwin's theory that as there are some animals
stronger and superior than others, the same happens in the world inhabited by men. There
are men who are superior and the men who are inferior needed to be submitted. He applied
Charles Darwin's theory to men. He affirmed that there are races who are superior to other
races, and the races who are superior had to colonise other countries.
John Stuart Mill: he's one of the voices who started to contradict the principles of the
Victorian age. Legislation, the state, the laws of the state should help men develop their
natural talents. If you are good at something the state should help you fulfill your desire. The
individual with his energy can make the country move on, not the machines of factories. This
is progress according to Mill. If you want population who can express their talents and
energy, it needs education, total education, not only for the middle class children. Queen
Victoria supported this with the Education Act. He also supported:
- Trade Unions, because the workers needed to be represented
- Extension of the franchise
- Emancipations of women, they needed the right to vote and to choose their role in
society. He's the philosopher who supported the suffragette movement.
Charles Darwin didn't think that there were some races superior than others, his idea was
totally different from Spencer's one. Spencer misinterpreted his theory.
(Ogni volta che un paese o una nazione cerca di imporre le proprie idee su alcune cultures
prescindere da quelle culture, riceve un rifiuto. Per quanto a noi possa sembrare che quelle
culture siano sbagliate e crudeli, non possiamo pensare di esportare la nostra cultura,
perché inevitabilmente quei paesi si ribelleranno.)
(10/08/19) According to Herbert Spencer, the poor deserve to be poor, because poor people
are not good and fit enough to compete in that very competitive society. The same happens
to colonised people, they are inferior, not as educated as the more civilised people.
Mill and Marx went against this theory. The optimism, symbolised by the Great Exhibition
was substituted by pessimism. When Karl Marx wrote his manifesto of communism he was
in England: he criticized what he could see travelling throughout England. He criticized the
unequal distribution of wealth. Those who produced wealth couldn't profit from it. They didn't
profit from their work, because it was taken by the factory owners, and this was unequal.
George Orwell, in Animal Farm, in the very beginning of the book, wrote about a man who
speaks to animals, reproducing Karl Marx's ideas. He wrote about some animals, the pigs,
who are the rulers and exploited the other animals, the working class, and the other animals
died of starvation. He reproduced the same ideas Karl Marx had expressed in his manifesto.
Progress was based on the past. The new Gothic movement, Pugine (architect), they looked
back to the Middle Ages. Spirituality in the Middle Ages was more important than money.
The individual in the British society was not enough valuated. George Orwell realised that it
was a utopia. Any form of democracy turned out to become a dictatorship. The seeds of a
certain criticism of that model of the capitalistic society were made. When a woman got
married she had to give all her properties to her husband.
Celts never accepted domination. India and Ireland, since Henry VIII, never accepted of
being English. Ireland and Scotland hadn't accepted the imposition of the Anglican Church.
Relations with Ireland had always been difficult, since the Celts. The Irish people had always
maintained their spirit of independence. They have never accepted the domination of the
English.
The potato blight, an epidemic of the potatoes. The Irish people who were only based on
potato had problems of starvation. They didn't accept England's impositions anymore. When
the potato blight destroyed the crops (raccolti), the Irish people accused the English of
having stolen their food. Lots of Irish people emigrated to America, some Americans now are
of Irish origin. Some Irish people preferred the long journey to America rather than the short
journey to Britain, which was the cause of their problems.
Civil war broke out in northern Ireland. The leader of this new movement is Charles Palmer,
who tried to convince Gladstone to pass a reform (Irish Home Rule Bill), but he didn't accept.