Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
Keywords
Precision medicine · Thyroid cancer · Thyroid nodule · The concept of precision medicine implies that every
Differentiated thyroid cancer · Medullary thyroid cancer patient is unique [1, 2]. Precision medicine emphasizes
that physicians are not dealing with diseases but with par-
ticular individuals who are ill.
Abstract The easy access to health care resources and the wide
The management of thyroid nodules, one of the main clinical use of periodic medical check-ups have led to the frequent
challenges in endocrine clinical practice, is usually straight- diagnosis of thyroid nodules in many individuals who live
forward. Although the most important concern is ruling out in developed countries. There are no 2 identical thyroid
malignancy, there are grey areas where uncertainty is fre- nodules in the same way as there are no 2 identical thyroid
quently present: the nodules labelled as indeterminate by cancers. A thyroid nodule (whatever it might be: benign
cytology and the extent of therapy when thyroid cancer is or malignant) has a particular anatomical (size, echotex-
diagnosed pathologically. There is evidence that the current ture, location, etc.) and molecular signature (harbour a
available precision medicine tools (from all the “-omics” to number of specific gene mutations). Additionally that
molecular analysis, fine-tuning imaging or artificial intelli- particular nodule exists in a distinctive individual, with a
gence) may help to fill present gaps in the future. We present well-defined phenotypic and genotypic background. The
here a commentary on some of the current challenges faced molecular signature of 2 thyroid nodules might be very
by endocrinologists in the field of thyroid nodules and can- similar but the individuals in whom they are placed are
cer, and illustrate how precision medicine may improve their precisely unique. Identifying these differences and tailor-
diagnostic and therapeutic capabilities in the future. ing their management are the main challenges that face
© 2017 European Thyroid Association precision medicine.
132.239.1.231 - 3/14/2017 4:30:04 PM
E-Mail karger@karger.com
Avenida Pio XII, 36, ES–31080 Pamplona (Spain)
www.karger.com/etj
E-Mail jcgalofre @ unav.es
Color version available online
Thyroid nodule
US + FNA cytology
Surgery Follow-up
Molecular test
and specificity to identify malignant tumours [7]. In this – Rossetta genomics is a platform recently developed that
regard, other promising markers are being studied, such analyses the expression of a combination of micro-
as CD44 [8] or Ki-67 [9]. RNA (miRNA) species. The platform includes a set of
24 miRNAs and is reported to improve the malignan-
Molecular Tests cy risk assessment [19].
The advances in understanding the molecular path-
ways in tumorigenesis have identified many of the genet- Developing Advances in Imaging Techniques
ic abnormalities involved in thyroid cell transformation Advances in US technique have improved the ability
[10, 11]. The presence of a single mutation (such as BRAF) to recognize suspicious nodules [20]. In addition, other
has shown high specificity but low sensitivity [12, 13]. radiological and molecular imaging methods have also
The new approaches in diagnostics based on genetic ab- been tested to differentiate benign from malignant thy-
normalities are testing a number of genetic alterations si- roid nodules. Potentially these techniques could improve
multaneously. Several platforms are currently marketed the accuracy in cancer diagnosis at earlier stages.
to improve the malignancy risk assessment in indetermi-
nate nodules [14]. These techniques are widely used in the Liquid Biopsy
USA but not in Europe. Innovations in genetic technologies have enabled the
– The Afirma Gene expression classifier analyses the detection of circulating tumour cells, free DNA or even
mRNA expression of a panel of 167 genes. Fine-needle miRNA [21]. The detection of such abnormalities would
aspiration samples of the screened nodules are labelled help in the diagnosis of thyroid cancer in patients with
“benign” or “suspicious” [15]. Gene expression clas- thyroid nodules, or in the follow-up of patients with thy-
sification has been proposed as a “rule-out” test [16], roid cancer. Pupilli et al. [22] investigated the presence of
that is, a test with a high sensitivity and high negative the DNA BRAF mutation in plasma from 103 patients
predictive value. with nodular goitre and reported 65% specificity and 80%
– ThyroSeq is a dynamic panel that analyses a panel of sensitivity to discriminate papillary thyroid carcinoma
specific thyroid cancer-related mutations. The Thyro- (PTC) from benign nodules. miRNAs have also been
Seq approach has been proposed as a “rule-in” test quantified in serum, and differences have been found in
[16–18], that is, a test with a high specificity. blood samples from patients with PTC compared with
132.239.1.231 - 3/14/2017 4:30:04 PM
Univ. of California San Diego
Multi-kinase
Role of TSH vs. single-
stimulus kinase
TKI and Combined TKI and
other
Single TKI inhibitor
radiotherapy
strategies targeted
therapy
Best method
of response Combined vs.
assessment sequential
(RECIST, Tg, therapy
etc.)
Best strategy Efficacy of TKI and
to treat TKI 2nd- and 3rd- conventional
resistance line options therapy
Fig. 2. Topics that remain to be elucidated in the treatment of thyroid cancer with TKIs. TKI, tyrosine kinase in-
hibitor; Tg, thyroglobulin; TSH, thyrotropin.
my, the indication for prophylactic neck lymph node have been evaluated to restore the sodium iodide sym-
dissection, or the usefulness of radio-iodine ablation porter action with the aim to reverse the refractoriness
(Table 2). At present we are not able to identify the “io- [52, 53]. In this scenario, TKIs are used only for a few
dine-refractory thyroid cancer” (IRTC) tumours from days, with the objective of increasing iodine uptake and
the outset [48]. Initial tumour molecular characterization permitting 131I therapy.
could tip the balance between conservative and aggressive Despite the important role of TKIs in the management
management. of advanced thyroid cancer, several concerns remain to
The targeted therapy era for thyroid cancer started be addressed (Fig. 2).
nearly a decade ago. To date, 2 tyrosine kinase inhibitors Some new exciting approaches are on the therapeutic
(TKIs), sorafenib and lenvatinib, have been approved for horizon, including immunotherapy [54] or locally direct-
treatment of IRTCs. Both compounds have demonstrated ed treatments such as radiofrequency and cryo-ablation
a significant improvement in progression-free survival for solid tumours or cementoplasty for bone metastasis
compared to placebo [49]. It is not clear whether the mu- [55].
tational tumour status modifies the effectiveness of these
drugs. In theory, a more specific target-based therapy Molecular Imaging
might improve its efficacy. A number of clinical trials Several molecular imaging technologies will improve
with different TKIs is currently in progress in patients the accuracy of the radiological follow-up of DTC pa-
with IRTCs [50]. tients. Specific targeted probes will help to characterize
Decreased expression of the sodium iodide symporter the outcome of specific targeted drugs in a precise tandem
is the main cause of the IRTC phenotype. Although the model. The dual role (diagnostic and therapeutic or ther-
aetiology of sodium iodide symporter loss of function is anostics) of such molecular imaging techniques will ex-
not completely understood, hyperactivation of some mo- pand the contribution of this to thyroid oncology.
lecular pathways, such as the MAPK and the PI3K path- Current positron emission tomography (PET) modal-
ways, plays a primordial role [51]. Several approaches ities are designed to visualize specific molecular and cel-
132.239.1.231 - 3/14/2017 4:30:04 PM
Univ. of California San Diego
MTC risk level RET mutation Exon Age for prophylactic surgery in children
Adapted from Wells et al. [68]. MTC, medullary thyroid carcinoma; RET, rearranged during transfection; CT,
calcitonin. 1 Mutations associated with multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2B.
lular processes such as glucose uptake (18FDG-PET), cell sive than that of DTC, although some MTC patients with
proliferation (18F-fluorothymidine) and, more recently, distant metastases have an indolent course. Total thyroid-
tumour hypoxia (18F-fluoromisonidazole) [56]. A step ectomy, central neck dissection, and therapeutic dissec-
forward in PET technology is the development of probes tion of involved lateral neck compartments are the cur-
with specific molecular targets such as monoclonal anti- rent recommended surgical treatment for patients with
bodies, pro-angiogenic molecules, or somatostatin recep- MTC [68]. Recent data have shown that bilateral disease
tors [57]. The role of these new techniques has not been is identified in 5.6% of patients with sporadic disease,
established in thyroid cancer, beyond anecdotal cases while multifocal disease was noted in 16.0% of patients,
[58–60]. These findings have prompted the development suggesting that total thyroidectomy should remain the
of peptide receptor radionuclide therapy with yttrium- standard of care for initial surgery, as less complete thy-
or lutetium-labelled somatostatin analogues to treat roid surgery may fail to address fully the primary site of
advanced DTC tumours [60–62]. Additionally TKI- disease [69].
PET tracers have shown encouraging results [63]. Finally,
124I-PET has demonstrated clinical and functional value
The Question of Prophylactic Thyroidectomy
in the analysis of DTC metastases [64, 65]. The specific RET mutation enables us to intervene in
Magnetic resonance imaging has also been used to as- multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2 patients with a pro-
sess tumour angiogenesis by targeting integrin αvβ3 ex- phylactic thyroidectomy in susceptible individuals
pression, and as a measure of the efficacy of anti-angio- (Table 3) [68]. Although decisions based on the known
genesis drugs [66]. With the same purpose, contrast-en- genotype-phenotype are established on a solid rationale,
hanced US with microbubbles targeting angiogenesis there is great heterogeneity in the age of onset and aggres-
markers has been studied in a preliminary mouse model siveness of MTC among individuals with the same RET
of thyroid cancer [67]. mutation. Undoubtedly, other epigenetic, metabolomic,
and environmental factors will contribute to making
more precise decisions on the timing of thyroidectomy.
Medullary Thyroid Carcinoma
Contribution of Genetics
Currently, it is difficult to predict the course of medul- A precision approach to patients with MTC implies
lary thyroid carcinoma (MTC); thus, it is challenging to accurate identification of the molecular signature. To
tailor the appropriate treatment to every individual case date prediction of phenotype through the genotype is far
of MTC. Usually MTC clinical behaviour is more aggres- from perfect.
132.239.1.231 - 3/14/2017 4:30:04 PM
Univ. of California San Diego
References
1 Galofré JC, Díez JJ, Cooper DS: Thyroid dys- 12 Fnais N, Soobiah C, Al-Qahtani K, Hamid JS, say for diagnosing indeterminate thyroid
function in the era of precision medicine. En- Perrier L, Straus SE, Tricco AC: Diagnostic FNA smears from routinely prepared cytolo-
docrinol Nutr 2016;63:354–363. value of fine needle aspiration BRAF (V600E) gy slides. Cancer Cytopathol 2016; 124: 711–
2 Ladenson PW: Precision medicine comes to mutation analysis in papillary thyroid cancer: 721.
thyroidology. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2016; a systematic review and meta-analysis. Hum 20 McQueen AS, Bhatia KSS: Thyroid nodule ul-
101:799–803. Pathol 2015;46:1443–1454. trasound: technical advances and future hori-
3 Misiakos EP, Margari N, Meristoudis C, Ma- 13 Jia Y, Yu Y, Li X, Wei S, Zheng X, Yang X, zons. Insights Imaging 2015;6:173–188.
chairas N, Schizas D, Petropoulos K, Spathis Zhao J, Xia T, Gao M: Diagnostic value of 21 Ignatiadis M, Lee M, Jeffrey SS: Circulating
A, Karakitsos P, Machairas A: Cytopathologic BRAF (V600E) in difficult-to-diagnose thy- tumor cells and circulating tumor DNA: chal-
diagnosis of fine needle aspiration biopsies of roid nodules using fine-needle aspiration: lenges and opportunities on the path to clini-
thyroid nodules. World J Clin Cases 2016; 4: systematic review and meta-analysis. Diagn cal utility. Clin Cancer Res 2015; 21: 4786–
38–48. Cytopathol 2014;42:94–101. 4800.
4 Cibas ES, Ali SZ: NCI Thyroid FNA State of 14 Nishino M: Molecular cytopathology for thy- 22 Pupilli C, Pinzani P, Salvianti F, Fibbi B, Ros-
the Science Conference. The Bethesda System roid nodules: a review of methodology and si M, Petrone L, Perigli G, De Feo ML, Vez-
for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology. Am J test performance. Cancer Cytopathol 2016; zosi V, Pazzagli M, Orlando C, Forti G: Cir-
Clin Pathol 2009;132:658–665. 124:14–27. culating BRAFV600E in the diagnosis and
5 Hsiao SJ, Nikiforov YE: Molecular approach- 15 Alexander EK, Kennedy GC, Baloch ZW, Ci- follow-up of differentiated papillary thyroid
es to thyroid cancer diagnosis. Endocr Relat bas ES, Chudova D, Diggans J, Friedman L, carcinoma. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2013;98:
Cancer 2014;21:T301–T313. Kloos RT, LiVolsi VA, Mandel SJ, Raab SS, 3359–3365.
6 Gómez Sáez JM: Diagnostic usefulness of tu- Rosai J, Steward DL, Walsh PS, Wilde JI, Zei- 23 Yu S, Liu Y, Wang J, Guo Z, Zhang Q, Yu F,
mor markers in the thyroid cytological sam- ger MA, Lanman RB, Haugen BR: Preopera- Zhang Y, Huang K, Li Y, Song E, Zheng XL,
ples extracted by fine-needle aspiration biop- tive diagnosis of benign thyroid nodules with Xiao H: Circulating microRNA profiles as po-
sy. Endocr Metab Immune Disord Drug Tar- indeterminate cytology. N Engl J Med 2012; tential biomarkers for diagnosis of papillary
gets 2010;10:47–56. 367:705–715. thyroid carcinoma. J Clin Endocrinol Metab
7 Wu G, Wang J, Zhou Z, Li T, Tang F: Com- 16 Eszlinger M, Hegedüs L, Paschke R: Ruling in 2012;97:2084–2092.
bined staining for immunohistochemical or ruling out thyroid malignancy by molecu- 24 Graham ME, Hart RD, Douglas S, Makki FM,
markers in the diagnosis of papillary thyroid lar diagnostics of thyroid nodules. Best Pract Pinto D, Butler AL, Bullock M, Rigby MH,
carcinoma: improvement in the sensitivity or Res Clin Endocrinol Metab 2014;28:545–557. Trites JR, Taylor SM, Singh R: Serum micro-
specificity? J Int Med Res 2013;41:975–983. 17 Nikiforova MN, Wald AI, Roy S, Durso MB, RNA profiling to distinguish papillary thy-
8 Das DK, Al-Waheeb SKM, George SS, Haji Nikiforov YE: Targeted next-generation se- roid cancer from benign thyroid masses. J
BI, Mallik MK: Contribution of immunocyto- quencing panel (ThyroSeq) for detection of Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2015;44:33.
chemical stainings for galectin-3, CD44, and mutations in thyroid cancer. J Clin Endocri- 25 Manning T, Sleator RD, Walsh P: Biologically
HBME1 to fine-needle aspiration cytology di- nol Metab 2013;98:E1852–E1860. inspired intelligent decision making: a com-
agnosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma. Diagn 18 Nikiforov YE, Carty SE, Chiosea SI, Coyne C, mentary on the use of artificial neural net-
Cytopathol 2014;42:498–505. Duvvuri U, Ferris RL, Gooding WE, Hodak works in bioinformatics. Bioengineered 2014;
9 Su JJ, Hui LZ, Xi CJ, Su GQ: Correlation anal- SP, LeBeau SO, Ohori NP, Seethala RR, Tub- 5:80–95.
ysis of ultrasonic characteristics, pathological lin ME, Yip L, Nikiforova MN: Highly accu- 26 Sheikhtaheri A, Sadoughi F, Hashemi De-
type, and molecular markers of thyroid nod- rate diagnosis of cancer in thyroid nodules haghi Z: Developing and using expert systems
ules. Genet Mol Res 2015;14:9–20. with follicular neoplasm/suspicious for a fol- and neural networks in medicine: a review on
10 Cancer Genome Atlas Research Network: In- licular neoplasm cytology by ThyroSeq v2 benefits and challenges. J Med Syst 2014; 38:
tegrated genomic characterization of papil- next-generation sequencing assay. Cancer 110.
lary thyroid carcinoma. Cell 2014; 159: 676– 2014;120:3627–3634. 27 Shapiro NA, Poloz TL, Shkurupij VA, Tarkov
690. 19 Benjamin H, Schnitzer-Perlman T, Shtabsky MS, Poloz VV, Demin AV: Application of
11 Fagin JA, Wells SA Jr: Biologic and clinical A, Vanden Bussche CJ, Ali SZ, Kolar Z, Pagni artificial neural network for classification of
perspectives on thyroid cancer. N Engl J Med F; Rosetta Genomics Group; Bar D, Meiri E: thyroid follicular tumors. Anal Quant Cytol
2016;375:1054–1067. Analytical validity of a microRNA-based as- Histol 2007;29:87–94.
132.239.1.231 - 3/14/2017 4:30:04 PM
Univ. of California San Diego