SPEED-POST ard dare fear wae e@ Human Resource Development Group EI wr denier cen stent srepeiert oftee wisi Council of Scientific and Industrial Research aheasngant aiecoae, ange wary, yer, aS Rech-110 012 CSIR Complex, Library Avenue, Pusa, New Delhi-110012 ‘Beast /Ref: CSIRCx/A/2020/0003 ‘faf&/Date: 29/01/2020 First Appeal - Order MrShaurya Gupta 284, Hostel 1, IIT Bombay. Powai, Mumbai Maharashtra 400 076 fava: quar & arfdare afOieerr 2005 3 siete 08/01/2020 ar AT Tg wer artTeT Subject: Your First Appeal under RTI Act 2005 dated 08/01/2020 nelea /eert, Sir/Madam, Appellant through his RT! dated 15/11/2019 had sought information related to his CSIR-Fellowship payments. RTI was replied by CPIO vide his letter no. 30-1(0342)/2019-RTI dated 15/12/2019. Not satisfied by the RTI reply of the CPIO, the Appellant has filed this First Appeal. Hearing of the First Appeal was held on 29/01/2020. Appellant opted to be absent. Mr Harpal Singh, Assistant, EMR-I section was present as respondent. In his RTI Appeal, the Appellant has stated that he has not received the Fellowship of July 2019 to November 2019. He also stated that his institute has been sending claim bill of previous month in the first week of next month wef Oct to Dec 2019, During the hearing Mr Harpal Singh, Assistant, EMR-I section submitted that Fellowship bills for July 2019 to Dec 2019 have been processed at EMR-| and send to account section for further processing. FAA observed that in RTI reply it was stated that bills from July 2019 to Nov 2019 were not received. But now it has been submitted by EMR-I section that these bills have been processed. FAA is of the view that in his RTI Appellant had asked 3 specific questions but no specific answers have been given to the appellant. CPIO/DPIO is directed to provide revised point wise reply to the Appellant. In the reply, transaction IDs should be mentioned wherever available. The Appeal is disposed of as above. PTOaf ant sac Auer & alge & ch ame quar & afters aa A eT 19(3) & Stevia Sa TT & Rat H 90 fea H star Falla Yuen aren Harter ae wad EI Sear Yaar sieht ar sar faeafefeer e: In case you are not satisfied with the above information, you may like to file a second appeal under section 19(3) of the RTI Act-2005 with the Central information Commission within 90 days from the date of receipt of this decision. The Address of CIC is as under: eh YTAT 3A / Central information Commission ‘arat aat aren are / Baba Gang Nath Marg ‘AeA / Munirka ‘a feral 110067 / New Delhi 110067 sada, Yours Sincerely, (Rajesh Verma) we ade often war aftss wera dori First Appellate Authority and Sr Principal Scientist, CC: 1. Mr Harpal Singh, Assistant, EMR-I section, CSIR-HRDG 2. CPIO, CSIR-HRDG