Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PDFsam - Stereo Review 1997 09
PDFsam - Stereo Review 1997 09
PDFsam - Stereo Review 1997 09
CD player to buy if you wish. (and engineers about speaker design) When expressed in the physical world
Work up a sweat deciding than their forebears, but the perfect in which loudspeakers operate, a ten -
whether an 18 -bit DAC is worth fifty loudspeaker has yet to be created. octave musical spectrum is a range
bucks more or less than a 1 -bit con- I can't select the perfect speaker for that has a bit more than a thousand -to -
verter. Spend your nights poring over you, then, but I can map a road through one frequency ratio from top to bot-
amplifier spec sheets so you won't the technicalities so you'll understand tom. A 120 -dB dynamic range implies
"make a mistake." Whatever turns you how different factors interact and can a power range with a ratio of
on. But, as many have written in the make an informed choice. 1,000,000,000,000 to 1 (a thousand
pages Of STEREO REVIEW over the billion to one). The numbers suddenly
years, the sonic differences among What Loudspeakers Do seem more impressive!
amplifiers and CD players of reason- It seems simple. A speaker's only job "Cycles per second," the old no-
ably comparable price and specifica- is to move air, or, more precisely, to menclature for hertz, was a much
tion are subtle to say the least. That's set up variations in air pressure that more descriptive term. A frequency of
not true when it comes to speakers. propagate through the room as sound 20 Hz means 20 cycles (increases and
Whether it's used for music listen- waves. When these pressure variations decreases) in air pressure each second;
ing or home -theater applications, no impinge upon the eardrum, we per- a 20 -kHz signal means 20,000 com-
component has a greater impact on ceive sound. I put it this way not be- plete cyclic variations per second.
sound quality than the loudspeaker. cause I want to get into a philosophi- Loudspeakers face a problem be-
The other weak links in the sound cal discussion of whether a tree falling cause the laws of physics require that
chain - phono cartridge, turntable, in the forest makes a sound if there's a lot more air be put in motion to de-
and tape deck - have been replaced no one there to hear it, but to empha- velop the same SPL (volume) at bass
by a far closer to perfect one (the CD size that the sound from the speaker frequencies than in the treble. Thus,
player), and they've left the speaker travels through the room to the listen- the speaker diaphragm that puts the
holding the bag. Unlike other compo- er, and, as we'll see, there is a strong air in motion must be physically large,
nents, there's no direct relationship be- interaction between the speaker and or move back and forth a considerable
tween a speaker's price and its sound the room. The interaction is more distance, or both, to develop high
quality. There might be a rough one, acute with some speakers than with SPLs in the bass. On the other hand,
perhaps, but it's easy to pay more for others, but it's always present. the diaphragm must be extremely light
less. Specifications don't necessarily Although moving something as and delicate if it is to respond linearly
mean much either; there's not even light as air might seem easy, a loud- and accurately to a signal that's exe-
one generally agreed -upon method of speaker faces conflicting require- cuting 20,000 variations each second.
testing loudspeakers. ments. Human hearing is generally Elephants don't pirouette. 3,
While everyone complains about considered to span a music spectrum The earliest and still most common
speakers, no one has figured out how of ten octaves and a dynamic range of type of loudspeaker driver, the dynam-
to do without them. Speakers have about 100 to 120 decibels depending ic cone driver, uses a cone -shaped dia-
been studied, analyzed, and examined on frequency and other factors. The phragm that's suspended at the outer
with laser interferometers. As much numbers don't seem large viewed this edge by a compliant surround (often F,
technical know-how has been devoted way because octaves and frequency formed of foam or butyl -rubber) and,
to developing speakers as to any other are related exponentially, and decibels at the neck, by a spider that usually I
hi-fi component, yet today's loud- and power are related logarithmically, takes the form of a concentric -ringed g
speakers are far more similar to those which, in both cases, reflects the way waffle. The "motor" that drives the sz
of a half -century ago than a CD is to a we hear. Each octave increase is a cone consists of a voice coil (a coil of mr:,
shellac 78 -rpm record. doubling of frequency, and each 10 - wire wrapped on a former and at-
That's not to say that today's scien- dB increase in sound -pressure level tached to the small end of the cone) a
BY EDWARD J. FOSTER
i'Cl)
r
Jr4
60 STEREO REVIEW SEPTEMBER 1997
Left, a two-way Celestion Al bookshelf speaker
($1,499 a pair) with three pieces from the Rock
Solid Sound's Solid Solutions, home -theater sys-
tem ($999; see page 74); center, the 451/4 -inch -
tall Klipsch KLF 30 horn -loaded tower ($1,800 a
pair); right, NHT's VT 1.2 three-way tower with
a side -mounted woofer ($1,100 a pair).
with a variety of plastics in between, is
CONE DRIVER (CUTAWAY) proof enough that nirvana has not
been attained.
SURROUND
Hard cones like the metals and stiff
plastics may resist breakup, but when
they do break up, the sound can be
quite unpleasant since stiff "high -Q"
VOICE COIL
cones may emit a characteristic sound
of their own. Softer materials like felt-
ed paper and some plastics have better
internal damping and resist ringing,
but because they are softer they're
usually heavier for a given structural
GASKET
strength and are often relegated to
bass reproduction.
Multiway Speakers
Since no cone driver can deliver high-
fidelity sound over a ten -octave range,
speaker systems almost invariably di-
vide the frequency range into seg-
ments and use drivers of appropriate
size and design for each segment. A
two-way system divides the audible
SPIDER range into two segments, a three-way
system into three, and so on.
DUST Crossover networks are filters that
CAP direct signals to the appropriate driv-
ers. In a three-way system, the drivers
consist of a woofer for the bass, a mid-
FRAME range for the middle frequencies, and
a tweeter for the treble. In a two-way
The dynamic cone driver is, by far, the most popular kind of speaker element. system, the bass and lower midrange
The "motor" that drives the cone consists of a voice coil in the field of a perma- are sent to a "woofer/midrange" or
nent magnet. Current from an amplifier flows through the voice coil, creating a "bass/midrange" driver.
varying magnetic field that causes the coil to move the cone in and out. Woofer cones usually range from
about 8 to 12 inches in diameter; mid-
ranges run from about 3 to 5 inches in
that's immersed in the magnetic field the outer edge of the cone gets the sig- diameter. The bass/midrange driver in
created by a gap in the magnet assem- nal to move, the inner portion by the a two-way system is likely to be be-
bly, which is made up of a permanent voice coil may already be reversing di- tween 5 and 8 inches in diameter.
magnet and a pole piece. There, you've rection. Different portions of the cone Drivers larger than 8 inches have diffi-
got all the terms! are pushed in different directions at culty reaching high enough into the
Current from the power amp flows the same time, and the cone "breaks treble to hand off to a tweeter without
through the voice coil and creates a up." Although it doesn't really disinte- the aid of a midrange, while the bass -
magnetic field that follows the musical grate, it no longer vibrates as a whole output capability of drivers smaller
wave. This field interacts with the fixed but in segments. If nothing else, this than about 5 inches is quite limited
one created by the speaker's magnet affects the frequency response and di- unless more than one is used.
assembly and moves the voice coil in rectionality of the sound wave that is Almost invariably, the bass and
a manner that reflects the original sound produced. Usually, cone breakup is a midrange are handled by cone drivers
wave you're trying to reproduce. major source of distortion as well. as described above; the most common
So far, so good. The voice coil fol- Cone -type drivers work best over a tweeter is shaped like a dome. Dome
lows the music. But does the cone? relatively limited range of frequencies, drivers work in a manner similar to
Well, that depends. Clearly, the part of a range determined by the size and cone drivers, but the dome is mechani-
the cone close to the voice coil proba- construction of the cone, motor assem- cally supported only at its outer edge.
bly follows the coil motion pretty ac- bly, and so on. To maximize the range, That limits its maximum feasible di-
curately, and if the cone is being driv- engineers seek light, rigid materials ameter. Dome tweeters are usually 1
en relatively slowly (in the bass range), and adopt cone designs that promote inch or less in diameter, although there
there's a good chance that it will move structural rigidity. You're likely to see have been a few midrange domes
as a whole. Engineers call this "piston- many claims made for the wonderful about 3 inches in diameter.
ic" motion because the cone moves as attributes of this or that cone material, Domes are driven by a voice coil
a solid piston, which is what we want. but don't be taken in. If there were one that's usually attached at the periphery
But as the cone is driven faster in perfect material, everyone would use near the support point. Many people
the midrange and treble ranges, strange it, so the very fact that cones are made think that domes radiate like the theo-
things begin to happen. By the time of everything from paper to metal, retically ideal "pulsating sphere" be -
62 STEREO REVIEW SEPTEMBER 1997
cause of their spherical shape, but On the other hand, if an electronic Even if the two drivers are in phase
that's not true. Driven from the periph- crossover isn't designed specifically through the crossover region, there
ery, domes simply move in and out; for the speaker system, it is unlikely will be interference between the sound
they don't expand and contract like a that you will be able to adjust it opti- waves in the room because of the
pulsating sphere. (Dome -like drivers mally without test equipment and a physical separation between the driv-
have been developed that more closely good set of ears. Even with test equip- ers and the resulting different path -
approximate a pulsating sphere, but ment, the results may not match what lengths from each to the listener. Inter-
they're not in common use.) can be achieved with a dedicated ference causes the waves to add con-
The voice coil of a dome tweeter crossover, which can be designed to structively (increasing sound pressure)
sits in the gap of a magnet structure compensate for problems in the vari- at some points in the room and de-
just like the coil of a cone driver. Be- ous drivers. structively (decreasing sound pres-
cause the tiny tweeter coil doesn't dis- The crossover network affects the sure) at others, both of which depend
sipate heat well, it's common to fill the sound of a speaker system far more on frequency and driver placement.
magnetic gap with ferrofluid, a ther- than many audiophiles realize. In the That's why it's important for a speaker
mally conductive magnetic fluid that's crossover region, both drivers radiate and crossover to be designed as a unit.
held in place by the magnetic field and the same signal, but the two sound With potential problems occurring
wicks away the heat. (Ferrofluid is al- waves may not be synchronous (in in every crossover region, we are
so used to cool some larger drivers.) phase) because of different phase faced with another of the unending
The dome may be made either of a shifts that occur through the two paths questions to be answered: Is it better
light cloth impregnated with a stiffen- of the crossover network. to minimize the number of crossover
er, a light plastic with or without a points and choose a two-way sys-
stiffener, or a light metal like alu- tem at the risk of forcing each
minum or titanium. The advan- RIBBON SPEAKER driver to work over a wider fre-
tages and disadvantages of each quency range than it's comfortable
material parallel those of cone ma- with? Or is it better to choose a
terials: high stiffness -to -mass ratio INPUT three- or four-way system, relieve
CURRENT
at the risk of ringing or high inter- the stress on the drivers, and take
nal damping with a less attractive your chances with multiple cross-
stiffness -to -mass ratio. overs? There's no answer, but the
MAGNETS
laws of physics apply. Powerful
Crossover Networks deep bass requires a lot of air mo-
"Passive" crossover networks are tion, which translates into a large
usually built into the speaker cabi- cone area, a large cone excursion,
RIBBON
net and use inductors, capacitors, IN AIR GAP
or usually both. You can get fairly
and resistors to direct the energy deep bass response from a small
from the power amplifier to the ap- two-way system, but not at high
propriate drivers. "Active" elec- sound -pressure levels without ex-
tronic crossovers divide the spec- cessive distortion. Deep bass re-
trum before power amplification. RIBBON
DIAPHRAGM
sponse with loud clean sound
Some powered subwoofers use a MOTION
means a large system.
combination of both: an active
low-pass section that feeds the in- Puffing Interference
ternal power amplifier and a pas- to Good Use
sive high-pass section that feeds Nothing in the laws of physics pre-
the main speakers. cludes increasing the radiating area
Electronic crossovers require by using several small drivers -
separate power amplifiers for each each of which is better able to han-
driver or group of drivers, which is dle the midrange - rather than
costly but has certain advantages. A ribbon driver's diaphragm is a thin metal- one large driver. In the bass region,
A power amp can control a driver lic ribbon suspended in a magnetic field. where the wavelength of sound is
better if it is connected directly to Current through it generates the driving longer than the distance between
it rather than through passive com- force. Apogee's Ribbon Monitor RM-1 (be- the drivers, all drivers act together
ponents, and an electronic crossov- low, $1,200 a pair) uses a ribboi tweeter. and interference problems are es-
er is unaffected by level -dependent sentially nonexistent. The prob-
changes in driver impedance, which lems come at higher frequencies,
can occur with passive crossovers. where multiple sound sources give
(Current flowing through the voice rise to the phase effects mentioned
coil causes it to heat up, which, in earlier. Let's see how this works.
turn, affects the crossover charac- The wavelength of sound is
teristics.) Efficiency is higher, too, equal to its speed (roughly 1,000
because power isn't lost in inter- feet per second) divided by the fre-
vening components, and it's easier quency. A 100 -Hz signal, for ex-
to design exotic adjustable cross- ample, has a wavelength of about
over slopes with active circuits 10 feet. It's easy to get a number of
than with passive components. small drivers to act together at 100
STEREO REVIEW SEPTEMBER 1997 63
each other, and with the direct sound
ELECTROSTATIC SPEAKER wave from the speaker, causing peaks
and dips in response at different fre-
quencies in different places in the
z room. It's generally considered helpful
i.
SUPPORTING
FRAME
to minimize these effects.
One way to reduce floor and ceiling
t. "r1 "bounce" is to control the radiation
0,1 pattern (directivity) of the speaker to
minimize sound propagation in the
vertical plane while maintaining uni-
form spread horizontally. This can be
accomplished by using multiple driv-
ers in a vertical line array and operat-
ing them over the same frequency
OUTER
range. The drivers must be spaced and
ELECTRODE phased properly to get the desired ef-
fect, but it can be done and is, in fact,
DIAPHRAGM
the most common way of achieving
INNER
the directivity pattern required for
ELECTRODE THX-certified front speakers. The pri-
mary goal, in the case of THX speak-
The diaphragm of an electrostatic speaker, a thin sheet of metallized plastic ers, is to enhance the clarity of dia-
suspended between metal grids, is charged by applying a voltage between logue and other on -screen action.
them. Most electrostatic speakers, like the Martin -Logan Aerius i (right, $1,995
a pair), use a cone woofer to augment their bass output. Alternatives to the Cone
Many of the problems associated with
cone speakers come from driving them
Hz because they're almost certain to drivers and effectively shrink the num- from a point at the narrow neck and
be much closer together than 10 feet. ber of drivers as the frequency rises. expecting the whole cone to move as a
But at 1,000 Hz, where the bass/mid- We can also put interference effects unit. Wouldn't it be better if the dia-
range drivers are still active in a two- to use. As noted earlier, every speaker phragm were driven uniformly over its
way system, the wavelength is only 1
foot and interference sets in. The inter-
ference can be ameliorated by using a
interacts with the room because sound
reflects from every rigid surface -
floor, ceiling, walls, furniture. The re-
entire surface rather than from a
point? Since structural rigidity would
no longer be important, a light, fast -re-
more complex crossover to reduce the flected sound waves interfere with sponding diaphragm could be used.
midrange output of the more distant That's the idea behind the electrostatic
speaker and its close cousin, the elec-
tromagnetic (or planar -magnetic) pan-
el. Of the two, the electrostatic is far
more common, so we'll examine it.
An electrostatic diaphragm is a thin
sheet of metallized plastic suspended
between a grid of metal rods. The sys-
tem is charged by applying a voltage
between the diaphragm and rods or by
The Martin -Logan Logos ($1,750) is an using a permanently charged dia-
electrostatic center -channel speaker phragm called an electret. Under static
with a cone woofer for the bass. conditions, the system is stable and
the diaphragm doesn't move. Howev-
er, when the voltage is varied by a mu-
sic signal, the diaphragm is attracted
alternately to the front and rear of the
grid and moves accordingly, thus set-
ting air in motion. The diaphragm
doesn't move far, so it must be large to
deliver bass, but the driving force is
applied uniformly across the entire
surface. (Actually, the force distribu-
tion can be controlled by the geometry
of the gridwork so that a nonuniform
drive can be employed if desired.)
Cambridge SoundWorks' Surround 5.1 Bipolar speakers like the Mirage M-7si Electrostatic speakers are known for
Multipoles ($400 a pair) let you select ($1,500 a pair) have front and back fast transient response and a bright,
either bipolar or dipolar operation. drivers that operate in phase. open sound. Although a large electro-
64 STEREO REVIEW SEPTEMBER 1997
static panel can span a wide frequency ly to be more linear than the mechani- sound sources of their own. And effi-
range by itself and avoid the problems cal suspension, acoustic -suspension ciency is not a minor consideration.
of multiple drivers and crossover net- systems are also noted for low -distor- Loudspeaker efficiency can vary over
works, most electrostatic systems use tion bass reproduction. a range of 10 dB or more, which
a cone woofer to augment the deep Efficiency is not the strong suit of means that ten times more amplifier
bass and have a crossover network for acoustic -suspension systems, however, power can be required by a low -effi-
it. Some power amps have difficulty because half of the sound energy is ciency speaker to produce the same
driving an electrostatic speaker be- trapped and absorbed in the box. In volume as a high -efficiency system.
cause it presents a capacitive rather fact, it's important that a sealed box be One way to increase bass efficiency
than a resistive load. Electromagnetic built sturdily and have adequate ab- is to vent the box and make use of the
panels share many characteristics of sorbent material within so that the back wave's sound energy. Obviously,
an electrostatic driver and present an trapped energy does not cause the this has to be done properly, because
easier load on the amplifier. However, sides of the box to vibrate and become the point of the enclosure is to prevent
like the "ribbon" tweeter, another fast -
responding device, they are difficult to
make large enough to qualify as a qua-
si -full -range transducer.
Enclosures and
Radiation Patterns
By itself, a loudspeaker driver has a
dipolar radiation pattern; as its dia-
phragm moves forward, compressing
the air in front of it, it causes a rarefac-
tion (reduction in pressure) behind. If
placed unenclosed in the middle of a
room, two diametrically opposed (out -
of -phase) sound waves are created,
one propagating forward, the other
rearward. At wavelengths greater than
the distance around the speaker (in the
bass), the air sloshes around the driver,
the two waves cancel, and little useful
sound results. That's why cone drivers
are enclosed. Magrepc n's Magneplaner MMG ($500 a
Electrostatic panels are free-stand- pair) combines a planar -magnetic bass/
ing because they're physically large midrange driver and a ribbon tweeter.
enough that cancellation doesn't occur
until a relatively low frequency. At The DCM TimeWindow 7 ($1,600 a pair)
lower frequencies, the panel is usually is an example of a speaker with a
augmented by an enclosed cone woof- transmission -line vented enclosure.
er anyway. In the upper bass, mid-
range, and treble, however, the electro-
static panel does radiate forward and
rearward, and the sound is strongly af-
fected by its placement in the room.
The simplest speaker enclosure is a
sealed box that contains and absorbs
the back sound wave. If such an enclo-
sure is large, it is called an infinite baf-
fle, because it is physically equivalent
to mounting the driver in the center of
an infinitely large board (or baffle) so
that the back wave can't get around to
the front. When a small box is used,
the system is described as acoustic -
suspension because the air trapped in
the box acts as an acoustic spring or
"suspension" behind the woofer cone.
The acoustic spring aids the mechani-
cal suspension (the surround and spi-
der) in restoring the cone to rest quick-
ly, and acoustic -suspension systems Acoustic Research's three-way AR -303A The Klipsch KLF 30 ($1,800 a pair) us,.s
are characterized as having "tight ($1,300 a pair) is a classic acoustic -sus- horns to control its treble and midrange
bass." Since the acoustic spring is like- pension (sealed -box) speaker. directivity and improve efficiency.
CROSSOVER NETWORK Electrical filters complishes The same thing. TRANSMISSION LINE A loudspeaker enclo-
that divide the audible spectrum into two or more LOUDSPEAKER Although the term can refer to sure design in which the back wave from the woofer
frequency bands for distribution to separate loud- a single sound -generating element, or driver, it is is coupled to the room through a waveguide or trans-
speaker drivers. preferable -o restrict its use to a speaker system misston line.
DAMPING The decoy of motion after a stimulus comprising one or more drivers in an enclosure and TWEETER In a multiway loudspeaker, the driver
has been removed; the way in which a loudspeaker usually including a crossover network. that is primarily responsible for reproducing treble
cone ceases to vibrate after the driving force has MIDRANGE In a three-way loudspeaker, the frequencies above approximately 2 kHz.
been removed. driver that is primarily responsible for reproducing VENT See port.
DIAPHRAGM The moving element in a loud- the middle frequency range, from approximately
VOICE COIL The driving element of a dynamic
speaker driver that is primarily responsible for gener- 500 Hz to approximately 2 kHz.
driver. A coil of wire, wound on a "former," physical-
ating sound waves. MONITOR A descriptive term suggesting that the ly connected to the diaphragm and immersed in the
DIFFRACTION A phenomenon that causes loudspeaker in question is of adequate quality to magnetic field within the gap of a magnet assembly.
wove -propagated energy, such as sound, to change monitor recordings in professional studios. Electrical current through the wire creates a magnet-
direction (bend) when reaching a sharp edge. The N EAR FIELD The spatial region sufficiently close ic field that interacts with the fixed field of the mag-
angle of diffraction depends on wavelength, so to the sound source (loudspeaker) that direct radia- net, causing the voice -coil assembly to move.
sound diffraction at the edges of an enclosure is tion predominates and reflections and other room ef- WOOFER In a three-way loudspeaker, the driver
more pronounced at short wavelengths (treble re- fects can be ignored. Small studio monitors are fre- that is primarily responsible for reproducing bass fre-
gion) than at long wavelengths. quently designed to be used in the near field. quencies below approximately 500 Hz. In a two-way
DIPOLE A loudspeaker that radiates equally in PASSIVE RADIATOR A diaphragm mounted system, the woofer may be called a woofer/mid-
opposite directions but in which the front and back on the surface of a loudspeaker enclosure and driven range and operate up to a higher frequency.