Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Papaya, is an important nutritious, climacteric fruit with a very short holding life and extremely
popular throughout the year which also makes it prone to misuse of practices. One of the famous
misuse is use of harmful ripening chemicals. Two major ripening chemical viz. ethylene (C 2H4),
a natural ripening hormone and calcium carbide(CaC 2) are extensively used for ripening of many
climacterics so an experiment was performed to compare the efficacy of ethylene and CaC 2 on
ripening parameters of papaya fruit in the following ratio ethylene 50 ppm, 100 ppm and 150ppm
and calcium carbide viz., 1mg, 5mg and 10mg per fruit with three replications under ambient
storage. Fruit quality was assessed by measuring weight loss in fruit, acidity, decay, soluble
solids concentrationx, total sugars, reducing sugars and β-carotene content. At full ripened stage
of the fruit, total soluble solids, total sugars, reducing sugars and β-carotene were higher in fruits
treated significantly with ethylene 150 ppm/fruit, followed in turn by calcium carbide 10
mg/fruit, whereas the treatments caused a significant decrease in the ascorbic acid content and
titratable acidity of the fruit.
Keywords: Papaya, ethylene, calcium carbide, ripening, biochemical changes,
INTRODUCTION
Papaya (Carica papaya L.) belongs to family Caricacea, a native of tropical America and was
introduced in India in the 16th century from Malacca. Papaya fruits are delicious and rich source
of vitamins and minerals. The medicinal, healing, curative and nutritive properties of papaya are
well documented. It is a powerhouse of nutrients and is generally available year round. It is full
of vitamins C, A and E and the minerals like potassium and magnesium. Papaya juice has an in
vitro anti proliferative effect on liver cancer cells due to carotenoids. Asmah et al., (2002).
Papaya is climacteric fruit and these fruits show a decline in respiration at pre-climacteric stage.
As the ripening is initiated, respiration increases, reaches the climacteric peak and then declines.
Respiration is accompanied by various biochemical changes which brings about characteristic
taste, aroma and palatability of fruits, while senescence brings about the degradative process
which makes the fruit unfit for consumption. By adopting proper postharvest handling practices
and proper understanding of the biochemical changes in ripening and senescence, the postharvest
losses can be controlled to a greater extent.
Ethylene production rates in ripening fruit is 6 to 10 μL/ kg/ h. Paull and Chen (2004). Papaya
fruits treated with ethylene ripe faster and uniformly in terms of softening, skin degreening and
flesh color. Since the papaya ripens from the inside to outwards, the mesocarp tissue has not yet
started to ripen, so the ethylene treatment is given to accelerate rate of ripening. Ethylene, a
natural plant hormone is produced by all plants and plant parts. It is also applied artificially to the
plants. Ethylene is supposed to regulate fruit ripening by coordinating the expression of genes
responsible for increasing the rate of respiration, chlorophyll degradation, carotene synthesis,
autocatalytic chlorophyll degradation, increased activity of cell wall-degrading enzymes and
conversion of starch to sugars. Gray et al. (1992). The ethylene is used to ripen climacteric fruits
like Papaya, Banana and Mango.
Calcium carbide is a corrosive and dangerous chemical compound. It is proven to cause various
adverse effects on human health, even then it is widely used for commercial ripening of fruits by
small traders. It is colorless when pure, but black to greyish-white in colour otherwise, with
slight garlic-like odour. Calcium carbide produces acetylene gas when it reacts with water. This
process is similar to ethylene and so quickens the ripening process. Downey (1987). Traces of
arsenic and phosphorus hydride as impurities are also found in Commercial grade calcium
carbide. Chow (1979). CaC2 is reported to possess carcinogenic properties and is commercially
used in gas welding. Rahman et al. (2008). In India, the usage of carbide gas for artificial
ripening is banned under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (FSSA, 2011). It’s clearly
mentioned in the Act that no fruit should be sold which have been ripened using carbide gas, a
source of ethylene. Even though the gas has been banned in the country its use is still rampant.
Acetylene, an analogue of ethylene hastens the ripening process. With the application of this gas
sometimes only the colour of the fruit screen changes whereas the inside portion remains raw
and slightly unripe. The taste of fruit also remains unpalatable. It produces an unpleasant odour
and flavor. Smith and Thompson (1987). Trace of arsenic and phosphorus have been noted in
calcium carbide treated food which cause vomiting, diarrhea, burning sensation in the chest and
abdomen, weakness, thirst and problems in esophagus. In contrast the fruits ripened with natural
hormone ethylene have better taste, colour, flavor, odour, and shelf life. Siddiqui, (2008),
Medlicott et al. (1987), Kulkarni et al. (2004).
2. MATERIAL AND METHODS
2.1. EXPERIMENTAL MATERIAL
2.1.1Collection and preparation of papaya fruits:
Fruits of papaya cv. Taiwan-786 (Red Lady) which were used in the experiment were taken from
a orchard, Indian Agriculture Research Institute, Pusa, New Delhi. Well-developed mature green
uniform size papaya fruits, physiological mature and free from any pest and disease incidence
were collected and brought to the laboratory. The fruits were washed under running water and
cleaned with dry cloth, divided into 6 treatments under strict hygienic condition. The treatments
were T1: 50 ppm ethylene, T2: 100 ppm ethylene, T3: 150 ppm ethylene, T4: 1mg Calcium
carbide, T5: 5 mg Calcium carbide and T6: 10 mg Calcium carbide stored at temperature- 24 0C
and relative humidity 60-70%).
3.3.5. β-carotene
The results during the investigation presented in Figure 3 clearly indicate that all the treatments
of ethylene and calcium carbide significantly improved the β-carotene content which is
responsible for colour in the fruits. In ambient condition ethylene 150 ppm (T 3) treated fruit
shows highest β-carotene content (1.85 mg/100g) significantly higher than the calcium carbide
10 mg (T6) treated fruit at 1.11 mg/100g. Nagaraj et al. (1984), Tauqir et al. (1989), Padmini and
Prabha (1997) evaluated the imapact of CaC2 treatment at 2 and 4g/kg fruit on mango cvs.
Alphonso, Dashehari and Desi reported higher concentration of carotenoids (colour) then the
other treatments at four days of storage.
4. CONCLUSION
Minimum ripening period of 5 days was needed in fruits treated with calcium carbide 10 mg
followed by ethylene 100 ppm (T2-6 days) and 150 ppm (T3) 7 days under the ambient
condition but the ripening by Calcium carbide was uneven and the storability only upto 4 days
whereas ethylene ripened fruits were storable and marketable upto 6 days. Under ambient
condition the lowest PLW (%) of papaya fruit was recorded in T3 (Ethylene 150 ppm) 9.24%
and T4 (calcium carbide 1mg) 11.17 % during subsequent storage. A sharp increase was
witnessed at the fully ripened stage in the total soluble solids of papaya fruits. At the fully
ripened stage ethylene 150 ppm (T3) treated fruits had significantly higher total soluble solids of
8.27 0Brix in ambient condition followed by 8.100 Brix fruits treated with calcium carbide 10 mg
(T6). On comparing the titratable acidity of fruits towards the final ripening stag it was found
that higher concentrations of ethylene and calcium carbide significantly lowered the acidity of
the fruits. Ethylene 150 ppm (T3) treated fruits recorded the lowest acidity followed by calcium
carbide 10 mg. Towards final stage ethylene 150 ppm/fruit treated fruits shows ascorbic acid
content of 74.50 mg/100g was significantly higher than the calcium carbide 10 mg at 55.67
mg/100g (ambient condition). A sharp increase was witnessed during ripening in the β-carotene
content of papaya fruits. In an ambient condition ethylene 150 ppm treated fruit shows highest
β-carotene content of 1.85 mg/100g followed by calcium carbide 10 mg treated fruit shows β-
carotene content of 1.11 mg/100g. The ethylene 150 ppm/fruit (T3) treated fruits had a total
sugar content of 6.55 %. In addition, calcium carbide 10 mg (T6) treatment also increased the
total sugars up to 10.05 per cent in an ambient condition. At the completion of ripening of the
fruits, the reducing sugar in papaya fruits were found significantly increased in fruits treated
with ethylene 150 ppm at 7.01 per cent in an ambient condition as compared to calcium carbide
treated fruits. In conclusion it was found that under ambient condition dipping of fruits in
ethylene 150 ppm (T3) solution immediately after harvest at physiological maturity, hastened
the ripening and improved the biochemical composition of the fruit for TSS, soluble solids,
ascorbic acid, reducing and total sugars. Ripening treatment with ethylene had more acceptable
colour and a higher shelf-life (6 days) as compared to calcium carbide treated fruits (4 days).
Further experiments are required to carry out the impact of ripening chemicals on its
organoleptic and nutritional properties.
REFERENCES
1. Adinarayanan, N.P. 1975 Ethrel plant growth regulator for earlier and uniform ripening of
mango fruits. Indian Food Packer 29: 15-19.
2. Asmah R, Rozita R, Wan N, Lzzah W M, Zain, S E Huzaimah A S 2002. Anti-
proliferative activity of pure lycopene compared to both extracted lycopene and juices
from watermelon (Citrullus vulgaris) and papaya (Carica papaya) on human breast and
liver cancer cell. Linus Journal Medicinal Science, 2(2): 55-58.
3. Bal E. and Kok D. (2007). The effect of glycerin added ethephon treatment on fruits
characteristics of Actinidia deliciosa Cv. Hayward. Bulgarian. J. Agri. Sci., 13(2007),
291-300
4. Bhullar J S 1982 Ripening of Langra mangoes with ethrel and calcium carbide.
Progressive Horticulture.14:71–72.
5. Chow M. 1979 The preoccupation with food safety. In Critical Food Issues for the
Eighties (eds Chow, M and Harmon Jr T D P), Pergamon Press, New York, 1979, pp. 14–
42.
6. Das S.C., Balamohan T.N., Auxcilia J. and Nalina L. (2011). Early and uniform ripening
of mango cv. Alphonso with ethrel treatment. Asian J. Hort. Vol.6, No. 1, June, 2011:
189-190.
7. Downey G. 1987 Review and assessment of food and nutrition policies. In Food, Health
and the Consumer (ed. Gormely T R, Downey G and O’Beirne D), Elsevier Applied
Science, 1987, pp.121–212.
8. FSSA 2011 Food Safety and Standards Act 2006, Rules 2011, Regulations, 2011. 7th
edition, International law Book Company, Delhi pp. 643.
9. Gray J, Picton S, Shabbeer J, Schuch W, Grierson D, 1992.Molecular biology of fruit
ripening and its manipulation with antisense genes. Plant Molecular Biology. 1(19): 69-
87.
10. Hale C R, Coombe B G, Hawker J S 1970. Effects of ethylene and
2Chloroethylphosphonic acid on the ripening of grapes. Plant Physiology. 45: 620-623.
Hale C R, Coombe B G and Hawker J S. 1970. Effects of ethylene and
2Chloroethylphosphonic acid on the ripening of grapes. Plant Physiology. 45: 620-623.
11. Krishnamurthy S, Subramanyam H. 1973. Pre- and postharvest physiology of the mango
fruit. Tropical Science.15: 167-193.
12. Kulkarni S G, Kudachikar V B, Vasantha M S, Keshava Prakash M N, Aravinda Prasad
B, Ramana K V R 2004 Studies on effect of ethrel dip treatment on ripening behaviour of
mango (Mangifera indica L.) variety Neelum‟. J. Food Sci. Technol.,41(2): 216-220.
13. Kumar Ashwani, Dhawan S S. 1995. Effect of post-harvest treatments on the
enhancement of ripening of mango (Mangifera indica, L.) fruits cv. Dashehari. Haryana
Journal of Horticultural Science. 24(2):109 115.
14. Kumar S, Das D K, Singh A K and Prasad U S. 1994. Sucrose metabolism during
maturation and ripening of mango cultivars. Plant Physiology and Biochemistry.21: 27-
32.
15. Lakshminarayana S. 1973. Respiration and ripening patterns in the life cycle of mango
fruit. Journal of Horticultural Science.48: 227-233.
16. Lane J H, L Eynon 1923 Determination of reducing sugars by Fehling’s solution with
methylene blue as internal indicator. J. Soc. Chem., India., 42: 32- 37.
17. Mann S S, Dhillon B S 1974. Effect of ethrel and calcium carbide on ripening of mango.
Progressive Horticulture 6:59-62.
18. Maxie E C, Crane J C, Rao H L 1971. Chemical and physiological effects of ethrel and
ethylene on fig (Ficus carica L.) fruit. Hort Science 6(3):303.
19. Medlicott A P, Sigrist J M M, Reynolds S B and Thompson A K. 1987.Effectsof ethylene
and acetylene on mango fruit ripening. Annals of Applied Biology. 111(2):439-444.
20. Nagaraj P, Ramana K V R, PrasadB A, Mallikarjunaradhye S, Pat Wardhan M V,
Ananthakrishna S M, Rajpoot H C, and Subramanyan L. 1984. Effect of Calcium Carbide
on ripening and quality of Alphonso mangoes. Journal of Food Science and
Technology.21: 278-281.
21. Padmini S, Prabha T N 1997. Biochemical changes during acetylene-induced ripening in
mangoes (var. Alphonso). Tropical Agriculture. 74(4): 265-271.
22. Paull R E, Chen C C 2004. Mango. In: Gross K C, Wang C Y and Saltveit M (eds), The
Commercial Storage of Fruits, Vegetables and Florist and Nursery Stocks. USDA,
Agriculture Handbook 66 on the website of USDA, Agricultural Research Service
(Http://www.ba.ars.usda.gov/hb66).
23. Rahman A U, Chowdhury F R, Alam M B 2008 Artificial ripening: What We Are Eating?
J Medicine, 9, pp. 42-44.
24. Ranganna S 2008 Handbook of Analysis and Quality Control for Fruit and Vegetable
Products. 2nd ed. Tata McGraw Hill Publishing Co., New Delhi, India.pp: 31-65.
25. Rom R C, Scott K R 1971. The effect of 2-choloro ethyl-phosphonic acid (Ethephon) on
maturation of processing peach. Horticultural Science 6(2):134-35.
26. Salunkhe D K, Desai B B 1984. Mango. In: Postharvest Biotechnology of Fruits, Volume
I. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, USA, pp. 77-94.
27. Satyam S M, Patwardhan M V 1983. Organic acid metabolism during ripening of fruits.
Indian Journal of Biochemistry and Biophysics. 20:311-14.
28. Sethi Vijay 1987. Quality characteristics of chausa mango ripened with calcium carbide
for pulp storage. Indian Food Packer 41:14-18.
29. Selvaraj Y, Kumar R, 1989. Studies on fruit softening enzyme and polyphenoloxidase
activity in ripening mango (Mangifera indica L.) fruit. Journal of Food Science and
Technology. 26: 218-222.
30. Shanmugavelu K G, Selvaraj P 1974. Effect of ethrel on ripening of mango. Madras
Agricultural Journal. 61(10-12):983-987.
31. Siddiqui M W. 2008. Studies on some aspects of mango ripening. Thesis submitted to
Department of Post-Harvest Technology of Horticultural Crops, Bidhan Chandra Krishi
Viswavidyalaya, Mohanpur, Nadia, India.
32. Singh R V, Singh S K, Ram H B 1979. Effect of ethrel and smoking treatment on ripening
and storage of banana cultivar of Himachal. Progressive Horticulture. 11:69-75.
33. Smith N.J.S. and Thompson A.K. 1987. The effects of temperature, concentration and
exposure time to acetylene on initiation on banana ripening. Journal of the Science of
Food and Agriculture. 40: 43-50.
34. Sukhatme P V, Panse, V. G. 1995 Statistical methods for agricultural workers. New Delhi:
ICAR.
35. Tauqir A, Javaid I, Musahib U D K 1989. Effect of calcium carbide on physical changes
in mango fruits (cvs. Desi and Dusehari) during ripening. Journal of Agricultural
Research. 27(2): 121-126.
Table 1: Effect of different ripening chemicals on TSS, Titrable acidity and Ascorbic acid of
Papaya cv. Taiwan 786
ASCORBIC ACID
TREATMENT TSS (°B) TITRABLE ACIDITY (%) (mg/100g)
/PARAMETER UNRIPE RIPE MEAN UNRIPE RIPE MEAN UNRIPE RIPE MEAN
T1 7.00 8.77 7.88 0.45 0.39 0.42 48.83 59.67 54.23
T2 7.00 9.07 8.03 0.44 0.35 0.39 49.43 57.5 53.46
T3 7.00 9.67 8.33 0.44 0.30 0.37 48.80 55.5 52.16
T4 7.00 8.03 7.51 0.44 0.40 0.42 49.40 53.33 51.45
T5 7.03 8.23 7.63 0.45 0.38 0.41 49.57 51.83 50.70
T6 7.03 9.13 8.08 0.45 0.33 0.39 49.57 50.33 49.86
MEAN 7.01 8.82 0.44 0.35 49.27 54.69
CD0.05 0.166 0.009 0.518
T1: 50 ppm ethylene, T2: 100 ppm ethylene, T3: 150 ppm ethylene, T4: 1mg Calcium carbide,
T5: 5 mg Calcium carbide and T6: 10 mg Calcium carbide
List of figures
Figure 1: Effects of Ripening Chemicals on Reducing Sugar
Figure 2: Effects of Ripening Chemicals on Total Sugar
Figure 3: Effects of Ripening Chemicals on β-carotene