Professional Documents
Culture Documents
POLYUNSATURATED
FATTY ACID-INDUCED ANTIOXIDANT
INSUFFICIENCY
Richard S. Lord, PhD, and J. Alexander Bralley, PhD, CCN
The consumption of essential fatty acid dietary supple- of cellular glutathione and marked elevation of malondi-
ments has risen sharply in recent years due to increasing aldehyde and 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal. This concentration-
awareness of epidemic deficiencies and a rising tide of sci- dependent, toxic effect of AA is prevented by the addi-
entific evidence of adverse clinical effects caused by defi- tion of antioxidants.2 Potential toxic effects of AA are
ciency. However, just as the development of essential fatty especially of concern in alcoholic liver injury where sali-
acid deficiency is an insidious process, so is the free radical cylates have been shown to enhance the resulting mito-
pathology induced by excessive intake of polyunsaturated chondrial damage.3 Diets high in AA induce liver injury
fatty acids (PUFAs). Quantitative concentration determi- in alcoholics by inducing a mitochondrial membrane
nations of arachidonic acid (AA) and eicosapentaenoic permeability transition. Such effects are related to the
acid (EPA) in plasma, malondialdehyde, and thiobarbituric ease of oxidation of PUFAs and the tendency to deplete
acid-reactive substances (TBARS), and vitamin E in serum tissue antioxidant status. The mechanism is similar for all
were made on 478 individuals. Serum TBARS values of .90, classes of PUFAs, but it is of most concern for the 20-car-
1.07, and 1.28 nmol/mL were found for populations in low, bon eicosanoid precursor fatty acids, AA, and eicosapen-
middle, and high quartiles of plasma AA and EPA. Evidence taenoic acid (EPA), because the concentrations of these
is presented for a strong linear relationship of lipid perox- members, of all fatty acids with more than 2 double
ide (LPO) values and the AA and EPA sum. The elevation bonds, are generally the highest in both depot fat and cell
of LPO is found even when serum vitamin E is normal. Five membrane phosphatides of most tissues. Diet and dietary
cases with widely varying medical histories illustrate slight supplements of fatty acids also are most likely to have
to extreme elevations of LPO when either AA or docosa- effects on these fatty acids.
hexaenoic acid (DHA) is elevated. We conclude that PUFA- Discussions of excessive PUFA consumption have
induced lipid peroxidation is common among patients who centered on the potential for vitamin A overdosing with
supplement flax and fish oils with inadequate antioxidant high-dose cod liver oil supplementation.4 Many studies
protection. Clinical management of fatty acid and antioxi- of high-dose fish oil supplementation have shown ben-
dant supplementation is aided by testing for fatty acid bal- eficial short-term effects. Arthritic patients who took
ance and measuring markers of oxidant damage. 130 mg/kg/d of fish oils had fewer tender joints, and
some were able to discontinue nonsteroidal anti-inflam-
Animal models have clearly shown the potential for matory drugs.5 For the average 70 kg person, this intake
increased oxidative damage from vitamin E deficiency of 9 g/d is high enough to raise plasma EPA levels sig-
induced by high polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) nificantly. Antioxidant status was not evaluated in this
intake. Muscle weakness due to necrotizing myopathy is study. EPA levels also may be raised by supplementation
a characteristic sign of increased tissue peroxidation, but of flax oil and subsequent desaturation and elongation
there are many other risks.1 A substantial body of evi- in human tissues.
dence has demonstrated the toxic potentiation of arachi- Short-term benefits of high essential fatty acid (EFA)
donic acid (AA) under certain conditions. In cells intake may be found concurrent with insidious effects
expressing cytochrome P4502E1, AA produces depletion leading to long-term toxicities if antioxidant status is
TABLE 1
LIPID PEROXIDE AVERAGES IN SUBPOPULATIONS BASED ON PUFA LEVELS*
AA+EPA (µM) n LPO (nmol/mL) t test Vitamin E (mg/L) Coenzyme Q-10 (mg/L)
*PUFA indicates polyunsaturated fatty acids; AA, arachidonic acid; LPO, lipid peroxides; EPA, eicosapentaenoic acid.
TABLE 2
FIVE CASES OF ELEVATED AA OR EPA WITH INCREASING LEVELS OF LPO*
Case No. Age Sex Description AA (µM) EPA (µM) Vitamin E (mg/L) LPO (nmol/mL)
[300-700]† [20-80] [12-50] [<1.0]
*AA indicates arachidonic acid; EPA, eicosapentaenoic acid; LPO, lipid peroxides.
†Numbers in brackets are laboratory reference values.
‡Numbers in bold are above laboratory reference values; those in italics are below.
2.5
2.0
Lipid Peroxides (nmol/mL)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Age (years)
FIGURE 1
SERUM LIPID PEROXIDES PLOTTED AGAINST AGE SHOW A SLIGHT RISE IN AVERAGE RATES OF
EXCRETION IN OLDER INDIVIDUALS.
2.5
Serum Lipid Peroxides (nmol/mL)
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
Plasma AA+EPA (µM)
FIGURE 2
SERUM LIPID PEROXIDE CONCENTRATIONS ARE PLOTTED AGAINST THE SUM OF ARACHIDONIC AND
EICOSAPENTAENOIC ACIDS IN PLASMA, SHOWING THE POSITIVE RELATIONSHIP OF OXIDATION PRODUCT
EXCRETION AT HIGHER LEVELS OF POLYUNSATURATED FATTY ACIDS.
diabetic patients die of kidney failure, and the damage is tive damage along with profiling of plasma fatty acids
related to eicosanoid metabolites of AA. Vitamin E has allow significant improvements in patient management.
been shown to specifically reduce the formation of Corrections may include lowering PUFA intake, adding
thromboxane A2 in kidney microsomes in streptozotocin- antioxidant nutrients (vitamin E, N-acetylcysteine, cur-
induced diabetic rats.15 Similar effects are found in cumin, vitamin C, or others), or increasing other antioxi-
ethanol-induced liver damage where vitamin E, curcum- dant categories such as the trace elements selenium, zinc,
in, and N-acetylcysteine were all found effective in lower- copper, and molybdenum.
ing AA-induced prostaglandin formation.16 The use of
EPA for controlling serum lipoprotein levels should be ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
combined with antioxidant support. Impaired status of We wish to thank our colleagues who so ably assisted
vitamin C and glutathione in patients with coronary in the laboratory testing for this study. Overall laboratory
artery disease may be a manifestation of PUFA peroxida- supervision by Dr Robert David was required for quality
tion effects.17 assurance in such a large set of data, and Joe George both
Association of higher levels of plasma gamma linolenic implemented improvements in the GC/MS method and
acid and erythrocyte DHA with coronary artery luminal nar- assembled the data for analysis. We also thank the clini-
rowing could be another effect of PUFA-induced vitamin E cians who selected patients for analysis and who cooperat-
deficiency and other endothelial sequelae of lipid peroxida- ed by supplying medical history information.
tion.18 PUFA-fed animals have increased peroxidation prod-
REFERENCES
ucts and altered activities of enzymes that control oxygen 1. Diehl JF. Vitamin E deficiency in rabbits receiving a high PUFA diet with
radical concentrations and these effects are worsened by ele- and without a non-absorbable antioxidant. 1. Incorporation of [1-
14C]glycine into skeletal muscle proteins. Z Ernahrungswiss.
vated thyroid hormone status.19 1986;25(2):103-113.
We conclude that patients with elevated levels of 2. Chen Q, Galleano M, Cederbaum AI. Cytotoxicity and apoptosis pro-
serum PUFA are at increased risk of oxidative damage due duced by arachidonic acid in HepG 2 cells overexpressing human
cytochrome P-4502E1. Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1998;22(4):782-784.
to lipid peroxidation. Laboratory evaluation of the status 3. Wu D, Cederbaum AI. Cyclosporine A protects against arachidonic acid
of specific antioxidant vitamins and markers of peroxida- toxicity in rat hepatocytes: role of CYP2E1 and mitochondria.