Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Course Description
CORPORATION LAW
The course will provide students a comprehensive understanding of the Revised Corporation Code, other
special laws governing private corporations, and the current jurisprudence on the subject matter. The aim
is to equip students with the ability to interpret and apply Philippine corporation law to issues commonly
encountered by corporations in corporate management, equity structuring, and corporate business
transactions.
Grading Policy
Students are expected to attend, prepare for, and participate in, every session. Final grade will be based on
the following:
1987 Constitution
The Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines (“RCC”)
The Revised
Corporation Code of the Philippines (Its Theories and Applications), Teresita J. Herbosa and Eric R.
Recalde, 2019 (“RCC Text Book”)
Philippine Corporation Law, Cesar L. Villanueva, 2018
(“Villanueva”)
Related Laws
Relevant Jurisprudence
Relevant SEC Opinions and Memorandum
Circulars
Session Topics
I. Introduction A. Constitutional Basis – Article XII, Section 16, 1987 Philippine Constitution
Feliciano v. COA, GR No. 147402, January 14, 2004; Section 1 RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
1. Single Proprietorship
2. Partnerships
3. Joint V entures
II. Corporations: Nature, Attributes and Classification
A. Definition; Attributes; Classification – Sections 2-4, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
1. Theory of Concession – pp. 10-12, Villanueva
Tagay v. Benguet Consolidated, Inc, 26 SCRA 242
(1968)
Ang Pue and Co v Secretary of Commerce and Industry, 5 SCRA 645 (1972)
Torres v.
Court of Appeals, 278 SCRA 793
2. Theory of Enterprise Entity – pp. 12-15, Villanueva
Philippine Stock Exchange, Inc. v. Court of
Appeals, 281 SCRA 232
3. Doctrine of Legal Entity
Palay Inc. v Clave, 124 SCRA 638
Soriano v Court of Appeals, 174
SCRA 195
4. Doctrine of Piercing the Veil of Corporate Fiction
Cagayan Valley Enterprises Inc. v Court of
Appeals, 179 SCRA 218
5. Corporation as a Creation of Law SEC Opinion dated July 22, 1992, Ms. Rosalina B. Villena
6. Right of Succession
SEC Opinion dated July 22, 1992, Ms. Rosalina B. Villena SEC Opinion dated
January 18, 1993, Mr. Fred P. Cladera
7. Express Powers Granted by Law – Section 35, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
Filipinas Broadcasting Network v AMEC-BCCM, GR 141994, January 17, 2005
First Lepanto-
Taisho Insurance Corporation v Chevron, 663 SCRA 309 (2012)
D. Classes of Corporations - Sections 3, 86, 87, 95, 115, 116 RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
1. Stock Corporation
- are corporations are those which have capital stock divided into
shares and are authorized to distribute to the holder of such shares, dividends, or
allotments of the surplus profits on the basis of the shares held. (Section 3)
Any profit may obtain incidental to its operation shall whenever necessary be
used for furtherance of the purpose for which the corporation was organized.
Cooperatives – considered as middle ground entitites between stock and nonstock corporations.
Similar to stock corp that they may engage in for profit activities to their members.
Condominium Corporations – formed for the purpose of taking title over the common areas in
the condominium project.
3. Close Corporation –
one whose articles of incorporation provides that a) all the
corporation’s issued stock of all classes, exclusive of treasury shares, shall be held
of record by not more than a specified number of persons not exceeding twenty
b.) the transfers of shares and c) the listing of any of its shares in the stock
exchange.
4. One Person Corporation – a corporation with single stockholder, provided that only a
natural person, trust, or an estate may form a one person corporation.
Banks, and quasi-banks, trust, insurance, preneed, public and publicly listed
companies, and nonchartered government owned and –controlled corporations
may not incorporate as one person corporations.
a single person owns the corporation, with other shareholders as mere nominees
or trustees. OPC differs from a corporation sole.
OPC is not a religious corporation, however, the law does not prohibit its
formation for the purpose of a religious denomination, sect or church.
A sole proprietor is liable for debts and OPC has only limited subject to certain
obligations up to all of his personal conditions such as adequate financing and
properties. absence of any reason to apply the doctrine
of piercing the viel of corporate fiction.
Sole proprietorship is subject to single OPC subjected to two levels of taxes such as
personal income tax due to an individual corporate income tax and at the single
taxpayer. shareholder level.
Sole proprietor does not need a separate OPC should have a separate TIN, business
business registration and separately secure a permit, and local license for itself.
tax identification number (TIN), business
permit, or local license.
5. Special Corporations
a. Public Corporation
- Public corporations are those created for political purposes connected
with the public good in the administration of the civil government such as barangay,
municipality, and province. It possess being a mini-state three great powers: police
power, eminent domain, and taxation.
Three types: a.) organized under Corporation Code for private ends and b) those
organized under the Corporation Code as GOCCs to achieve certain purposes of the
government
c.) those GOCCs organized with their own charters.
b. Foreign Corporation
- one formed organized or existing under any laws other than those of
the Philippines and whose laws allow Filipino citizens and corporations to do business in
its own country or State. It shall have a right to transact business in the Philippines
b. De Facto Corporation – an association of persons existing under a valid law under which it may be
incorporated after having attempted in good faith to incorporate and assuming corporate powers
a. Holding Company – is one which holds stocks in other companies for purpose of control rather than for
mere investment.
Parent company- is an entity that controls one or more entities and in turns defines
control of investee. It is a corporation which has control over another corporation
directly or indirectly through one or more intermediaries.
b. Affiliate – person that directly or indirectly through one or more intermediaries, controls or is
controlled by or is under common control with, the person specified through the
ownership of voting shares by contract or otherwise.
c. Parent and Subsidiary Companies
- when a corporation has a controlling financial interest in
one or more corporations, then one having control is known as the “parent
company”and the others are known as the “subsidiary companies”
Control is presumed to exist when the parent owns, directly or indirectly through
subsidiaries, more than half of the voting power of an enterprise unless in exceptional
circumstances, it can be clearly demonstrated that such ownership does not constitute
control
Section 140, 141 RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book Foreign Investment Act of 1991
Negative Foreign
Investment List
Grandfather rule as a subtest of the control test- where the various nationality tests
shall first be applied on the shareholdings of the holding companies, to determine
the nationality of the equity in the target corporation and thereby arrive the
nationality of such target corporation.
Three level relationship test that gave it the name grandfather rule: grandson- target company;
holding company – father; entity holding shares in the holding company would be considered
the ‘grandfather’.
Grandfather rule – is the method by which the percentage of Filipino equity is computed in a
corporation engaged in fully or partly nationalized areas of activities provided for under the
Constitution and other nationalization laws in cases where corporate shareholders are present in
the situation, by attributing the nationality of the second or even subsequent tiers of ownership
to determine the nationality of the corporate shareholder.
Jose M. Roy III v Herbosa, SEC, and PLDT, GR No. 207246, Nov. 22, 2016
Jose M. Roy III v Herbosa, SEC, and PLDT, GR No. 207246, April 18, 2017
SEC-OGC Opinion No. 18-24 Re. Nationality Requirement of Third Telco (Addressed to Romulo
Mabanta) dated December 20, 2018
Shareholders and members as corporators have the power to elect directors and trustees,
respectively and reinforced by the power to remove such directors and trustees by a vote of
shareholders holding at least 2/3 of the members entitled to vote, at a meeting for that
purpose with prior notice.
Sections 5 and 10, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
B.
Classification of Shares
1. Common Shares
- shares without preference; does not have the same rights, privileges, and
restrictions (they should vote)
Major corporate actions even if nonvoting share as a say; right to vote such as section 6 under
section 6. A.) amendment of the articles of incorporation (check page 41)
4. Redeemable Shares
- may be issued by the corporation when expressly provided in the
articles of incorporation. They are shares which may be purchased by the corporation
from the holders of such shares upon the expiration of a fixed period, regardless of the
existence of unrestricted retained earnings in the books of the corporation and the
certificate of stock representing the shares subject to the rules and regulations issued by
the Commission.
- Shares which can be redeemed by the corp at a specific period ‘ causes cancellation of
shareholder
- When you issue redeemable share that doesn’t form part of trust fund. Whether or not the
redemption option is with the corporation or shareholder. Corporate creditors know it already
they are not going to rely; they can redeem at the option of corporation or shareholder.
- The corporation maintain a sinking fund.
- The option of corporation – it’s the corporation control when to redeem
5. Treasury Shares
- are shares of stock which have been issued and fully paid for, but
subsequently reacquired by the issuing corporation through purchase, redemption,
donation or some other lawful means. Such shares may again be disposed of for a
reasonable price fixed by the board of directors.
SEC Office of the General Counsel Opinion 16-16 (June 27, 2016)
Process of Incorporation
a. Corporate Name –
Section 17, RCC
SEC MC No. 5, Series of 2008 SEC MC No. 8, Series of 2012 SEC MC No. 5, Series
of 2015 SEC MC No. 14, Series of 2017 SEC MC No. 9, Series of 2018
b. Primary Purpose – See also: Section 41, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
C.
5. Commencement of Corporate Existence – Section 18, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
D. Amendment of Articles of Incorporation and By-Laws – Sections 15 and 47, RCC; Annotations, RCC
Text Book
E. Grounds for Rejection or Disapproval of the Incorporation or Amendment – Section 16, RCC;
Annotations, RCC Text Book
F. Incorporation Fees – See SEC Website; Section 175, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
IV. Corporate Organization
A. Board of Directors/Board of Trustees
1. Power and Authority of the
Board – pp. 284-323 Villanueva
Acuna vs. Batac Producers Corporative Marketing Association, 20 SCRA 526 (1967) Tan vs Sycip, 499
SCRA 216 (2006)
2. Qualifications/Disqualifications and Powers
Sections 22, 23 and 26, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text
Book; pp.325-328, Villanueva
SEC Opinion dated 17 September 1991, Mr. Racaza
Powers v Marshall, 161 SCRA 176
Zamboanga
Transportation v Bachrach Motor Co, 52 Phil 244 Sales V SEC 169 SCRA 109
SEC Opinion dated 9 December 1988, Siguion Reyna Montecillo and Ongsiako Gokongwei v SEC, GR
L-45911, 11 April 1979
SEC Opinion dated 7 October 1983, Ms. Armida Siguion Reyna
SEC
Opinion dated 13 August 1986, Rural Bank of Margarita (Samar), Inc. SEC Opinion dated 6 June 1991,
Sacred Heart Memorial Corporation
3. Removal and Vacancies - Sections 27-28, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
Ponce vs Encarnacion, 94 Phil 81 (1953)
Valle Verde Country Club, Inc. v Africa, 598 SCRA 202
(2009) Raniel v Jochico, 517 SCRA 221 (2007)
4.
B.
Corporate Officers
Powers and Qualifications - Section 24, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book; pp.
San Juan Structural and Steel Fabricators v Court of Appeals, 296 SCRA 631 (1998) 2. Disqualification
and Removal – Section 26, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
Gomez v PNOC Dev and Management Corp, 606 SCRA 187 (2009) Gurrea v Lezama, 103 Phil 553
(1958)
Pamplona Plantation Co v Acosta, 510 SCRA 249 (2006)
Matling Industrial and Commercial
Corp v Coros, 633 SCRA 12 (2010)
C. Fiduciary Duties
Prime White Cement Corp v IAC, 220 SCRA 103 (1993)
Palay, Inc. v Clave, 124 SCRA 638
(1983)
Tramat Mercantile, Inc. v Court of Appeals, 238 SCRA 14 (1994) Carag v NLRC, 520 SCRA 28
(2007)
Sanchez v Republic, 603 SCRA 229 (2009)
V. Powers of Corporations
A. General Powers – Section 35, RCC; pp. 234-248, Villanueva; Annotations, RCC Text Book
VI.
9. Power to make reasonable donations
10. Power to establish pension/retirement/other plans for
directors, trustees, officers and employees
11. Power to exercise such power as may be
essential/necessary to carry out its purpose
SEC OGC Opinion No. 14-33 (November 18, 2014)
6. Power to invest corporate funds in another
corporation/business or for any other purpose – Section 41, RCC
7. Power to declare dividends –
Section 42, RCC
SEC MC No. 11, Series of 2008
8. Power to enter into Management Contracts –
Section 43, RCC
C. Ultra vires Acts of Corporations – Section 44, RCC; pp 249-254, Villanueva Stocks and Stockholders
– Sections 59-72, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book
A.
B. C. D. E.
F.
G.
Nature of Shares of Stock – pp. 496-500, Villanueva Magsaysay-Labrador v. Court of Appeals, 180
SCRA 266 (1989)
Original Dealings with Shares of Stock (Subscription) – Sections 60 and 71 Consideration for stocks –
Section 61, RCC
Doctrine of Indivisibility of Subscription – Section 63, RCC
Watered Stocks –
Section 64, RCC
Philippine Trust Corp v. Rivera, 44 Phil 469 (1923) Share Transfer and Restrictions- Section 62, RCC
Interport Resources Corp vs Securities Specialists, Inc., 792 SCRA 155 (2016) Lingayen Gulf Electric
Power Co. vs Baltazar, 93 Phil 404 (1953)
H. Stock Certificates – Section 62 and 72, RCC; pp.528-543, Villanueva
Teng v SEC, 784 SCRA 216
(2016)
Ponce v Alsons Cement Corp, 393 SCRA 602 (2002) Insigne v Abra Valley Colleges,
764 SCRA 261 (2015) Guy v Guy, 680 SCRA 214 (2012)
I. Appraisal Rights – Sections 80-85, RCC Turner v Lorenzo Shipping, 636 SCRA 13 (2010)
Corporate Books and Records – Sections 73-74, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book;
C. Financial Statements
VIII. Merger and Consolidation – Section 75-79, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text Book; pp 646-692,
Villanueva
IX.
X. XI.
Special Corporations
A. Educational Corporations – Sections 105-106, RCC; Annotations, RCC Text
Book B. Religious Corporations – Sections 107-114, RCC: Annotations, RCC Text Book C. One Person
Corporations – Sections 115- 132; Annotations, RCC Text Book
XII.
XIII.
4. Reportorial Requirements
A. Foreign Investments Act of 1991 and its Implementing Rules and Regulations
XIV.
and other Powers / Miscellaneous Provisions - Section 154-172; Section 177-188; Annotations,
RCC Text Book
Power of the SEC to Investigate and Impose Penalties and Sanctions/ Administrative