Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CSIRO PUBLISHING
A series of energetic salts based on 1,2-dinitroguanidine were successfully synthesised and fully characterised using
1
H NMR, 13C NMR, and IR spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, elemental analysis, and differential scanning calorimetry.
The results show that all the salts possess higher detonation properties (detonation pressures and velocities ranging from
24.8 to 30.3 GPa and 7665 to 8422 m s1, respectively) than those of trinitrotolouene (TNT, 2,4,6-trinitromethylbenzene).
The thermal stability and thermal kinetic parameters were also investigated to give a better understanding of the physical
and chemical properties of these energetic salts.
in every salt, and other signals were associated with the cations The C–N bond lengths range from 1.3065 to 1.3875 Å while the
accordingly. In the IR spectra, several main absorption bands N–N bond lengths range from 1.3294 to 1.4171 Å. Obviously,
which belong to the N¼O asymmetric stretch and the N–N all the C–N or N–N bond lengths are between the normal C–N
asymmetric stretch were observed at around 1520, 1360, 1320, and N–N bond lengths (1.47 and 1.45 Å, respectively) and the
and 850 cm1. The intense absorption bands in the range of normal C¼N and N¼N bond lengths (1.28 and 1.25 Å, respec-
3100–3500 cm1 can be assigned to the N–H bonds of the salts. tively). It is indicated that the bonds in the 1,2-dinitroguanidine
In the ESI-MS spectra, a single signal (m/z ¼ 148) assigned to cation and dinitroguanidine anion tend to be average. Fig. 1b
the 1,2-dinitroguanidine anion was observed in negative ion presented the three-dimensional packing diagram of the tri-
mode, and other signals associated with the cations were aminoguanidinium 1,2-dinitroguanidine salt. Since the amino
observed accordingly in the postive ion mode. In addition, all groups are excellent hydrogen bond donors, and nitro groups are
the elemental analysis results are highly consistent with the hydrogen bond acceptors, intra- and intermolecular interactions
calculated values. were formed. As shown in Fig. 1b, the dashed lines indicate the
strong hydrogen bonding formed between the hydrogen atoms,
nitrogen atoms, and oxygen atoms. The discrete triaminogua-
Crystal Structure nidinium cation and 1,2-dinitroguanidine anion are linked into
Crystallographic data (excluding structure factors) for the a 3D network by extensive intra- and intermolecular hydrogen-
structure of 5 has been deposited with the Cambridge Crystal- bonding interactions. Hydrogen bond lengths are summarised as
lographic Data Centre, CCDC, 12 Union Road, Cambridge follows: N(7)–H(7A)O(2), 2.558(12); N(6)–H(6A)N(9),
CB21EZ, UK. Copies of the data can be obtained free of 2.674(10); N(1)–H(1A)O(2), 3.115(11); N(8)–H(8A)N(11),
charge on quoting the depository number CCDC-995416 2.649(11); N(10)–H(10A)N(7), 2.670(11); N(1)–H(1B)
(Fax: þ44-1223-336-033; Email: deposit@ccdc.cam.ac.uk, O(4), 2.558(12)]; N(1)–H(1A)O(3), 3.071(11); N(6)–H
http://www.ccdc.cam.ac.uk). (6A)O(1), 2.987(10); N(7)–H(7A)O(4), 2.924(10); N(8)–H
Single crystals suitable for X-ray measurement were obtai- (8A)O(1), 2.972(10); N(9)–H(9A)N(2), 3.168(10); N(10)–
ned by slow evaporation of a methanol–aqueous solution of salt H(10A)O(3), 2.977(10); N(11)–H(11C)N(4), 3.258(11) Å.
5. A crystal with dimensions 0.3 mm 0.3 mm 0.1 mm was
chosen for X-ray determination. The data were collected with Thermal Decomposition Kinetics
a Bruker SMART APEX II CCD X-ray diffractometer using The thermal stabilities of the 1,2-dinitroguanidine-based ener-
graphite-monochromated MoKa radiation (l 0.071073 nm). The getic salts were investigated using differential scanning calo-
structure was solved by direct methods (SHELXTL-97) and rimetry (DSC). Their thermal decomposition kinetics were
refined by full-matrix-block least-squares methods on F2 with studied at the heating rates of 5, 10, 15, and 208C min1. As a
anisotropic thermal parameters for all non-hydrogen atoms. representative example, thermogravimetric (TG)-DSC curves
Crystal data and refinement results are summarised in Table 1. for the decomposition process of the aminoguanidinium 1,2-
Fig. 1a shows the molecular structure of triaminoguanidi- dinitroguanidine salt 3 which were obtained at different heating
nium 1,2-dinitroguanidine (5). It is seen that the molecular rates are shown in Fig. 2. It was found that, with increasing the
structure of the triaminoguanidinium 1,2-dinitroguanidine salt heating rate, the TG-DSC peaks of the decomposition tem-
was made up of one triaminoguanidinium cation and one 1,2- peratures (Tp) shifted to higher temperatures and the exothermic
dinitroguanidine anion which are distributed in different planes. peaks of the DSC curves appeared more and more clearly. This
observation may be attributed to the ‘thermal hysteresis’ of the oxygen balance, detonation velocity, and detonation pressure
heat transfer effect at different heating rates. are summarised in Table 3. In order to assess the potential of
The Kissinger and Ozawa’s methods were also jointly emp- the newly prepared 1,2-dinitroguanidine-based salts, ener-
loyed to calculate the kinetic parameters such as activation getic properties of the traditionally well known energetic
energy (Ea), pre-exponential constant (A), entropy of activa- materials 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) and 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,
tion (DS¼6
), enthalpy of activation (DH¼
6
), free energy of activa- 6-trinitrobenzene (TATB) are also listed in the table.
¼
6
tion (DG ), and the critical temperature of thermal explosion (Tb). The onset temperatures for thermal decomposition of the
As shown in Table 2, the apparent activation energy (E) physical properties were determined by using DSC at a heating
obtained using Kissinger’s method (Ek) agreed well with that rate of 58C min1, and no melting point was observed. As shown
obtained using Ozawa’s method (Eo), and the linear correla- in Table 2, salt 5 has the lowest thermal degradation temperature
tion coefficients (r) are very close to 1. Thus, the results were (Td 1458C) while salt 6 has the highest thermal degradation
credible. The salts possessed an acceptable heat-resistant capa- temperature (Td 2218C). However, all the thermal degradation
bility considering the values of Tb ranging from 416.7 to 504.4 K. temperatures of the salts are lower than those of TNT (Td 2958C)
Additionally, the other thermodynamic parameters such as DS6¼, and TATB (Td 3188C).
DH6¼, and DG6¼ are also given in the table to provide a better Density and heat of formation are two important physical
understanding of the thermal behaviour of these salts. properties for an energetic material since these parameters
are directly related to detonation velocity and detonation pres-
Properties of the 1,2-Dinitroguanidine-Based Salts sure. From Table 2, the densities were found to range from
The physical and chemical characteristics of these energetic 1.59 to 1.69 g cm1, and salt 7 exhibited the highest density of
salts, such as density, thermal stabilities, heat of formation, 1.69 g cm1. Although all the densities of these energetic salts
are lower than that of TATB, the densities of salts 6 and 7 were
100 5 K min⫺1 higher than that of TNT. The densities of all the investigated
90 10 K min⫺1 energetic salts are not high enough, especially salts 6 and 7,
80 15 K min⫺1 which are just on par with TNT. This may be the reason why the
70 20 K min⫺1 calculated detonation properties of these materials show disap-
pointing performances. However, all the investigated salts are of
60
nitrogen-rich materials, and large amounts of nitrogen are
50
released during the decomposition process. It is expected that
40 all the above-described materials are applicable in propellant
30 and gas generating compositions.
20 The heat of formation is also an important parameter to be
10 considered since it is usually taken as the indicator of the ‘energy
0 content’ of an energetic material. Recently, significant progress
exo
⫺10 has been made in the theoretical prediction of the thermody-
⫺20
namic properties of energetic salts. The heat of formation can be
calculated for salts with good accuracy (including the heats of
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 formation of cations and anions, as well as the lattice energy of
T [K] salts). The calculation of the heat of formation of the anion,
cation, and the salts were based on the isodesmic reaction
Fig. 2. Thermogravimetric-differential scanning calorimetry curves of (Scheme 1). It is found that all the cations have a high positive
salt 3 at different heating rates.
3 481.9 98.3 11.1 0.97 100.5 0.97 462.7 36.1 94.5 111.2
4 420.1 139.2 15.9 0.97 139.6 0.97 409.6 56.83 135.8 112.5
5 416.7 116.2 13.9 0.98 117.3 0.98 404.4 18.7 112.8 105.2
6 441.7 294.5 35.4 0.98 290.9 0.98 436.1 429.6 290.9 103.6
7 504.4 184.6 19.1 0.97 183.5 0.97 492.9 116.6 180.5 123.0
8 225.9 280.8 26.2 0.98 288.5 0.99 491.6 221.9 276.7 376.8
A
Extrapolated onset temperature.
B
Apparent activation energy obtained using Kissinger’s method.
C
Pre-exponential constant.
D
Linear correlation coefficient obtained using Kissinger’s method.
E
Apparent activation energy obtained using Ozawa’s method.
F
Linear correlation coefficient obtained using Ozawa’s method.
G
Extrapolated onset temperature.
H
Activation entropy.
I
Activation enthalpy.
J
Activation Gibbs free energy.
1040 B. Hu et al.
NO2 NO2
NO2 100 % HNO3
20 % oleum N AgNO3 N Ag ⫹
N ⫺
H2N N NO2 H2N N NO2
H 2N NH2 H
1 2
Energetic
base M⫹Cl⫺
Energetic salts
⫹ ⫹
⫹ H2N ⫹
M⫹ Cation NH2
NH2
NH
H2N N N NH2
H 2N N NH2 H H H2N N N NH2
H H H
3 4 5
H H NH2
⫹ H N N ⫹ N N ⫹
H N
H3N N N NH3 O2N N NH2 H2N NH2
N N N N
H H HN N
⫹
6 7 8
heat of formation ranging from 667.4 to 2302.0 kJ mol1 With the data of density and heat of formation, detonation
while the 1,2-dinitroguanidine has a heat of formation of velocity and detonation pressure as other two important para-
108.3 kJ mol1. The lattice energies of the dianionic salts meters were calculated using the Kamlet–Jacobs equations. The
are ,3 times larger than the monoanionic salts because of calculated detonation pressures of the new salts ranged from
their greater molecular masses and lower densities bringing 25.3 (salt 3) to 30.3 GPa (salt 6). The calculated detonation
about a concomitant decrease in the heat of formation. Besides, velocities ranged from 7665 (salt 7) to 8422 m s1 (salt 6). The
all the salts possess a high positive heat of formation and salt 6 calculated data show that the salts exhibit superior detonation
has the highest heat of formation. This may be a result of the velocity (D) and detonation pressure (P) to those of TNT
tetrazine skeleton and the higher nitrogen content of salt 7. (P 19.5 GPa, D 6881 m s1) and salt 7 has similar values to
Synthesis and Characteristics of Energetic Materials 1041
C5(0.256)
C5(0.113)
N9(⫺0.073)
N11(⫺0.102) N1(⫺0.225)
N11(⫺0.264) N9(⫺0.069) N4(⫺0.069) N1(⫺0.264)
H10(0.323)
N4(⫺0.138)
O13(⫺0.033) O3(⫺0.003)
O13(⫺0.096) O3(⫺0.096)
Fig. 3. Optimised structure and charge distribution in (a) 1,2-dinitroguanidine and (b) the anion at B3LYP/6–311þG(d,p) level.
Fig. 4. (a, c) The highest occupied molecular orbital and (b, d) lowest unoccupied molecular orbital of 1,2-dinitroguanidine and
its anion.
those of TATB (P ¼ 31.2 GPa, D ¼ 8114 m s1). Unsurprising- and NBO analyses based on the optimised structure of the
ly, salt 6 has a higher detonation velocity and detonation neutral molecule and the anion of 1,2-dinitroguanidine (B3LYP/
pressure than the other five salts because of the difference in 6–311þG(d,p)) were carried out by using Gaussian 03. As
its density and heat of formation. Although the investigated salts shown in Fig. 3a, b, all the N and O atoms carry negative charge
have superior detonation properties to that of TNT, they obvi- while all the C and H atoms carry positive charge and atoms
ously show no melting point, and therefore, would not be usable N6 and H10 carry the highest negative and positive charge
as melt cast explosives. (0.437 e and 0.323 e, respectively). In the 1,2-dinitroguanidine
Oxygen balance (OB) is the index of the deficiency or anion, all O atoms carry more negative charges (0.556 e) than
excess of oxygen in a compound required to convert all car- that of the neutral molecule (0.229 e), and the negative charges
bon into carbon monoxide, and all hydrogen into water. The are distributed more symmetrically compared with the neutral
sensitivity, strength, and brisance of an explosive all some- molecule which indicates that the more negative O atoms in the
what depend on the OB. From Table 2, the OBs of the 1,2- anion can form stronger hydrogen bonds with the hydrogen
dinitroguanidine salts were between 43.11 (salt 7) and atoms in the cation. In addition, a large p-bond conjugate system
21.82 % (salt 6). Although all the OBs were negative, they were is also found in the 1,2-dinitroguanidine.
less negative than that of TNT (74.0 %) and TATB (55.8 %). The highest occupied molecular orbitals (HOMOs) and
For a comparison, dinitroguanidinate salts such as the ammo- the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMOs) of the
nium salt, hydrazinium salt, guanidinium salt, 1,3,5-triamino- neutral molecule and anion of 1,2-dinitroguanidine are shown
guanidinium salt (TAG), urea salt (Ur), 5-aminotetrazolium salt in Fig. 4. In the neutral molecule, the atoms N1, N4, O2, and O3
(5-AT), 1-methyl-5-aminotetrazolium salt (1-MAT), 1,4- occupy the HOMO and the other part of the 1,2-dinitroguanidine
dimethyl-5-aminotetrazolium salt (1,4-DMAT), and 1-amino- molecule occupies the LOMO. In the anion, most of the
3-nitroguanidinium dinitroguanidinate (ANQDNG) reported by HOMO and LUMO are overlapped except atoms N6, H7, and
Klapoetke et al. have been also cited.[16,17] It is found that all the H8 which participate in the LUMO. Obviously, atoms in the
salts reported by Klapoetke et al. have a higher density than the 1,2-dinitroguanidine anion occupy more frontier orbitals than
salts reported in this paper except for GDNQ and 1,4-DMAT, that in the neutral molecule. The results indicate that the
thus these salts have higher detonation properties according to 1,2-dinitroguanidine anion is more reactive and easily attacked
Kamlet–Jacobs equations. Among these salts, the compound by other reagents to form new compounds.
hydrazinium 1,2- dinitroguanidinate (HyDNG) has the highest
density, detonation pressure, and detonation velocity which Conclusion
may be due to inter- and intramolecular hydrogen bonding as
A family of 1,2-dinitroguanidine-based energetic salts were
stated in the paper. It also can be seen that the decomposition
successfully prepared and fully characterised. The salts exhibit
temperature of these salts range from 111 to 2258C, and
good physical and chemical properties, such as densities
compound HyDNG has the lowest decomposition temperature
(from 1.59 to 1.69 g cm1), heats of formation (from 69.0 to
while compound 3,4,5-triaminotriazolium 1,2-dinitroguanidine
795.4 kJ mol1), detonation velocities (from 7665 to 8422 km s1),
(8) has the highest decomposition temperature. This is because
and detonation pressures (from 24.8 to 30.3 GPa). They were
salt 8 has a large p-bond conjugate system in the molecule which
higher than the traditional energetic material TNT and similar to
can increase the stability of the compound.
TATB. Additionally, thermal stabilities of the salts were eval-
uated, and the results showed that these salts possessed
Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) Analysis acceptable heat-resistant abilities, with Tb values ranging from
In order to give a better understanding of the chemical and 416.7 to 504.4 K. All the results show that these salts can be
physical properties of 1,2-dinitroguanidine, molecular orbital potential candidates for energetic materials.
1042 B. Hu et al.