Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: (1963) Chemical Industry Report, Journal of the Air Pollution Control
Association, 13:10, 496-507, DOI: 10.1080/00022470.1963.10468211
siderably cheaper to transport the sulfur produce a gas containing sulfur dioxide. since this is readily and economically
rather than the sulfuric acid. A few This is then oxidized to sulfur trioxide available.
plants produce sulfuric acid from sulfur- and recovered as sulfuric acid. The The dried gas mixture comprising
bearing materials but this is usuaUy potential pollutants are sulfur dioxide, chiefly nitrogen, sulfur dioxide (SO2),
under special circumstances such as sulfur trioxide, sulfuric acid mist, and oxygen (and carbon dioxide in the case
those that prevail at Coppers Hill, the oxides of nitrogen as explained in of sludge burning plants) is passed over
Tennessee, and Trail, B. C. what follows. a catalyst (usually vanadium) and
The sulfuric acids of commerce are: about 96 to 98% of the SO2 converted
Processes (in equipment called converters or con-
Chamber acid—60° Baume (78% Contact Process verting systems) to sulfur trioxide (SO3).
H2SO4) The reaction temperature used is from
Oil of Vitriol—93.19% H2SO4 The straight sulfur burning plants
commonly melt sulfur and burn it in a 770° to 840°F at the point of final con-
Sulfuric acid—98-99% tact with the catalyst. The SO3 so
Oleum—20—45% free SO3( in 100% stream of dried air. The reaction is
S + O2 -> SO2. Temperatures of from formed after cooling is contacted with
H2SO4) high strength (99%) sulfuric acid which
1000° to 1500°F are encountered. The
As has already been mentioned, the gas stream is then cooled to close to absorbs it (circa 230°F). The residual
contact process produces by far the ambient temperature. In most cases in gases pass to the atmosphere.
greatest proportion of sulfuric acid. which sulfur-bearing materials are the
The older process, the chamber process, source of sulfur (ores and acid sludges Chamber Process
is still used in some few locations, such as those; from oil refineries) SO2 is generated as described above
notably adjacent to acid phosphate ordinary atmospheric air is used and the under "Contact Process" except that
fertilizer plants which do not require a resultant sulfur dioxide-bearing gases there is no air or gas drying. The hot
high strength sulfuric acid. In the case are cooled to close to ambient tempera- gases pass through a Glover tower where
of all processes, the first step is to burn ture and subsequently dried. The dry- their heat concentrates the weak sul-
the sulfur or sulfur-bearing materials to ing agent in all cases is sulfuric acid, furic acid from the lead chambers to
CINDER 1,026.0 LB
A H = +125,488 BTU f-AH =+855,588 BTU ,H»+101.374 BTU
© COMBUSTION OF PYRITES - 3,694,842 BTU © HEAT EVOLVED IN FORMING H2S04 = - 1,685,352 BTU
(D HEAT LOSSES + 2,11 1,746 BTU © HEAT EVOLVED IN DISSOLVING H2S04 = - 364,012 BTU
(3) HEAT EVOLVED IN FORMATION OF H 2 S0 4 - 326,868 BTU © HEAT LOSSES = + 2,569,097 BTU
(4) HEAT ABSORBED IN CONCENTRATION OF ACID + 62,226 BTU © HEAT EVOLVED IN DISSOLVING H20 = - 13,483 BTU
(5) HEAT ABSORBED IN DECOMPOSITION OF NITRIC ACID + 7,000 BTU © HEAT LOSSES FROM PIPELINE = • 13,483 8TU
<6) HEAT LOSSES t 107,334 8TU © HEAT LOSSES = t 164,894 BTU
Materials and heat balance of a chamber plant. (Courtesy of Texas Gulf Sulphur Co.)
Fig. 1. Materials and heat balance of a chamber plant. (Courtesy of Texas Gulf Sulfur Company.) (This photo is reprinted from ACS Monograph 144,
"Manufacturer of Sulfuric Acid," by permission of Reinhold Publishing Corporation.)
CONVERTERX
4f*SS \
Fig. 2. Flow diagram of a typical "Type SM" sulfur-burning contact sulfuric acid plant. (This photo is reprinted from ACS Monograph 144, "Manufacturer of
Sulfuric Acid," by permission of Reinhold Publishing Corporation.)
final strength of 60° Baume and also sible because of the physical chemistry since the mist, once formed, is very dif-
strips out oxides of nitrogen gases from of this exothermic reaction. The ficult to remove.
the Gay Lussac tower return acid. The equilibrium 2SO2 + O2 -*• 2SO3 is
Chamber Process
gases then enter chambers constructed temperature sensitive, lower tempera-
of lead or other suitable materials where tures favoring the formation of more As noted above, 98% conversion can
they react with nitric oxides. The SO2 SO3. However, the rate of the reaction be expected. This means that in a
is thus converted to liquid sulfuric acid is also temperature sensitive but in the typical chamber plant to which a 7.5%
to the extent of 98%. The gases then opposite direction, so if the reactor tem- SO2 gas is fed, the emitted gases would
enter the aforementioned Gay Lussac perature is too low the reaction goes too contain 0.17% SO2. The quantity of
tower for recovery and recycle of the slowly to be economically feasible. The nitrogen oxides vented is best controlled
oxides of nitrogen, the residual gases concentration of SO2 entering the con- by careful control of process conditions.
passing to the atmosphere. verters can be expected to vary from
572% in the sludge-burning plants to Acid Recovery Processes
Acid Recovery Processes 10% in certain sulfur-burning plants. Variable amounts of sulfuric acid mist
Some years ago weak sulfuric acid This means that the gases going to the can be expected from concentrators.
was concentrated either in evaporators atmosphere may contain from 0.19% to Comments above under "Contact Proc-
heated by steam, submerged com- 0.47% SO2 by volume. ess" apply to regeneration from refinery
bustion, or some other means. Few if Equipment to remove the relatively sludges.
any of these plants remain. Those that low concentrations of SO2 released is not
do can be expected to emit sulfuric acid economically feasible, and it is generally Raw Material Storage and Handling
mist probably containing small amounts adequate to vent the exit gases through Some dusting may occur during un-
of SO2. The principal acid recovery a tall stack so that diffusion into the loading, storage, and handling of brim-
process today is the regeneration of atmosphere can dilute them to an ac- stone (solid sulfur). Any such dusting
sulfuric acid from refinery sludges. ceptable level. Height of stack required is usually quite localized and does not
These sludges are burned in a combus- will depend upon several factors, in- carry off the plant property. In case of
tion chamber along with fuel oil for pur- cluding mass emission rate of the con- outside storages, "capping" of the piles
poses of heating. In most instances taminant, temperature of exit gas, exit is often effected to minimize dust losses
sulfur is also burned in this combustion stack velocity, local meteorological con- during windy weather. This "capping"
chamber to increase the SO2 content of ditions, topography, and area land uses. usually consists of molten sulfur sprayed
the gas stream. The most common Applicable diffusion formulae, such as over the pile to form a thin, solid crust.
method of burning these sludges is to variations of the Bosanquet and Sutton Handling of brimstone is normally car-
atomize them into a combustion cham- equations, are available as guides for ried out in enclosed conveying and
ber which has previously been heated determining stack height necessary to elevating equipment which presents no
by the burning of oil. The mixture of maintain ground-level concentrations of particular dust problems.
gases so formed is then cooled and SO2 sufficiently low to present no prob-
subjected to a very thorough cleaning lems in the area. (Detailed informa- REFERENCES
process and dried through contact with tion may be found in reference 6.) 1. Industrial Chemicals, Faith, Keyes
sulfuric acid. From this point on, the SO3 emissions occur when through ab- Clark, 2nd edition, John Wiley & Sons,
processing is as described above under normal operation absorption of SO3 is Inc., New York, pp. 743-751.
"Contact Process." incomplete. This may be due to feed of 2. Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology,
an inadequate amount of sulfuric acid Kirk-Othmer, The Interscience En-
cyclopedia Inc., New York 13: 458-
Air Pollution Control Aspects to the absorber or too high temperature 505.
in the absorber. Upon emission to the 3. Chemical Process Industries, Shreve,
Contact Process atmosphere SO3 immediately forms a McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc.,
mist of H2SO4 which is clearly visible as a New York, pp. 353-386.
The contaminants from the contact 4. "Current Status of Sulfur Dioxide and
process are SO2, SO3, and H2SO4 (sul- white plume. Under abnormal condi- Sulfur Trioxide," Louis C. McCabe,
furic acid) mist. tions or when making high strength President, Resources Research, Inc.,
As noted above, conversion of SO2 oleum (fuming sulfuric acid) a faint to Washington, D. C, Presented at
moderate plume appears. Control of National Petroleum Assn., Cleveland
to SO3 is accomplished to the extent (April 19,1961).
of from 96% to 98%. 100% conversion H2SO4 mist emission is best achieved by 5. The Manufacture of Sulfuric Acid,
of SO2 to SO3 is not economically pos- improving the operation of the absorber, ACS Monograph No. 144, West-
WATER
(NOT RECIRCULATEO)
PRODUCT ACID
STORAGE TANK
Duecker, Reinhold Publishing Corp- Introduction (1) Reaction of salt and sulfuric acid
oration, New York. resulting in production of hydro-
6. "Evaluation of Weather Effects," Air Hydrochloric acid, commonly referred gen chloride gas and sodium sul-
Pollution Hand Book, Magill, Holden, to as muriatic acid, is a solution of
and Ackley, Published by McGraw- fate (salt cake).
Hill Book Company, Inc., New York. hydrogen chloride (HC1) in water. {2) Burning chlorine in a slight excess
Section 5. This acid is commercially marketed in of hydrogen.
(8) As a by-product from the chlorin-
Hydrochloric Acid Manufacture, Report ation of organic compounds.
No. 3
various strengths as follows:1 Up until the early 1930's only a very
small proportion of the total hydro-
Specific
°Be Gravity %HC1 chloric acid produced in the United
This report, published as In- States resulted from other than the salt-
formative Report No. 3 of the 18 1.142 27.92
acid process. In 1935, 86% of the acid
Air Pollution Control Associa- 20 1.160 31.45
produced for sale was derived from the
tion's TI-2 Chemical Commit- 22 1.179 35.21
tee began to move through the salt reaction and 14% from chlorine-
14-step approval procedure as out- In addition, some anhydrous hydrogen hydrogen combustion, by-products, and
lined in the March Journal on chloride gas is produced, usually for im- other sources. In 1947, only 53% of the
August 20, 1962. In accordance mediate consumption in nearby plant acid production for sale was salt acid;
with the latest procedures adopted
at the Technical Council Meeting of processes. 4% was from chlorine-hydrogen, and
December 10, 1962, and approved The manufacture of hydrochloric 43% from by-products and other
by APCA's Board of Directors, it is acid involves the generation of hydrogen sources. In the same year, the per-
now published as representing the chloride gas and its absorption in water centages relative to total production
"best thinking of the Association."
It is an extremely timely and in- for the aqueous solutions. There are were 39%, 20%, and 4 1 % respectively.
formative report. three principal processes used to pro- Total production in 1933 amounted to
duce hydrogen chloride: 200,000 N. T. (net tons) hydrochloric
acid (basis 20° Be) as compared to cylindrical mantle. This muffle is en- packed tower system or a cooled ab-
1,350,000 N. T. (same basis) in 1947.3 closed in a firebrick furnace suspended sorption tower followed by a packed
In 1961, this production had increased on steelwork. The furnace is force draft tail tower.
to 2,938,330 N. T. (basis 20° Be) with fired above the muffle and hot flue gases The packed tower system3 usually in-
only 10% from salt; 13% from chlorine- circulated around it, with the major cludes a connected set of S-bend tubes
hydrogen; and 77% from by-product.4 portion of the heat being transmitted followed by one or more packed towers
Actual production of hydrochloric acid through the cover or arch and radiated in series. Gas flows from the purifica-
by the salt-acid process less than to the charge on the hearth. The com- tion system through the S-bend tubes
doubled from 1933 to 1961 whereas total bustion gases are discharged to the then through the towers. Independent
hydrochloric acid production increased atmosphere through an elevated stack. acid cooling and circulating facilities
almost 15-fold during the same period. The feed materials are charged to the are provided for each tower and tower
This emphasizes the impact of the center of the hearth and the reacting acid strengths decrease successively
rapidly expanding field of halogenated mass slowly pushed around by rabble from first to last tower. Fresh water is
organics. It is interesting to note that arms, underdriven by a shaft extending added at the last tower (tail tower) and
in 1961, more acid was made by the up through the bottom section of the make overflows to the previous tower
hydrogen-chlorine process than by the furnace into the muffle. The reacting (stronger acid) etc. Overflow from the
salt-acid process. mass is gradually moved by the rotating first tower passes through the. S-bend
rabbles towards the periphery of the tubes where the final step in acid con-
The Processes muffle during which time the reaction is centration to product strength occurs.
Mannheim Process
completed and the salt cake is then dis- Water is circulated over the tubes to
charged continuously through a chute provide cooling.
In this process, common salt (NaCl) to conveying equipment which carries The cooled absorption tower3 sys-
and sulfuric acid (H2SO4) in slight excess it to storage. tem has proved to be a more efficient,
are continuously charged to the muf- Dust collecting systems are sometimes economical, and compact unit than the
fle of a Mannheim furnace where the used for removal of solids entrained in packed tower system, and is rapidly
reacting mass is heated by indirect heat the reaction gases leaving the furnace. supplanting this method for absorption
to 1400 to 1600°F. At some locations This solids removal from the gas stream of hydrogen chloride. Commercial
where sodium acid sulfate (NaHSO4, may be effected in settling chambers, designs include the use of water-jacketed
also called niter cake) is available as a cyclones, or similar type equipment. packed tantalum towers with acid and
by-product from nitric acid manu- The gas cooling system3 may employ gas in countercurrent flow and im-
facture, the acid sulfate is used instead a series of silica S-bends through which pervious carbon "falling film" tower
of sulfuric acid. Formulas for chemical the reaction gases, containing approxi- systems,5 in which the gas and acid
reactions are as follows: mately 30% to 70% HC1, pass with flows are co-current. In this "falling-
Salt-acid: 2NaCl + H2SO4 = Na2SO4 cooling water being circulated over the film" type system, cooling is carried out
+ 2HC1 outside of the tubes. Shell-and-tube in parallel, vertical, water-cooled,
Salt-niter cake: NaCl + NaHSO4 heat exchangers of nonporous graphite wetted-wall columns. Gas and weak
= Na2SO4 + HC1 are also used in this service. Tempera- acid from the tail tower flow downward
ture of the gas leaving this cooling sys- cocurrent in the cooler-absorber counter
Hydrogen chloride evolved from the re- tem approximates 100°F. In some to the upwardflowof cooling water in the
action passes through dust collecting, cases packed towers are used to accom- shell. Water is fed to the tail tower
cooling, purifications, and condensing plish this gas cooling. Strong acid is (packed) for absorption of residual hy-
systems to an absorber. The process is recirculated over the tower and the acid drogen chloride in the gas stream.
operated under a minus pressure recirculation system is provided with Weak acid from this tail tower con-
actuated by exhaust fan or ejector lo- coolers. stitutes the feed acid to the "falling-
cated at the exit of the absorption sys- In the purification system, coke filters film" absorber, with this acid being con-
tem.3 Pressure in the muffle is main- are employed for removal of sulfuric centrated in the absorber to product
tained slightly below atmospheric (0-0.5 acid mist present in the gas stream, as strength and drawn off the bottom of
inches of water vacuum). well as any fine solids which may have the tower.
A Mannheim furnace2 consists of a reached this stage of the process. These After passing through the packed tail
refractory (or cast iron) hearth, 11 to filters are usually relatively large vessels tower, the gas stream is emitted to the
18 feet in diameter, with a silicon car- packed with graded coke. atmosphere through an elevated stack.
bide (or cast iron) cover separated by a Absorption facilities may comprise a In operations where the vent gas is cool,
ion
chloride as a by-product. These types
Gas Purification . & of reactions are usually carried out
Absc
Cooling under anhydrous conditions so that the
(C) Sulfuric Acid hydrogen chloride is evolved as a gas.
Drip-Process If hydrogen chloride gas is the desired
product, the reaction products are fed
Hydrochloric
Acid Product to a condenser or still to separate the
organic products from the hydrogen
(A) FURNACE - Mannheim Type chloride. If aqueous hydrochloric acid
(B) DUST REMOVAL - Settling Chambers, Cyclones, Traps is wanted, absorption equipment like
IC) GAS COOLING - Tube Coolers or Packed Towers that described for the Mannheim opera-
(D) PURIFICATION - Coke Filters tion is used. If the organic product is
(E) ABSORPTION - Cooler-Absorbers or Packed Towers low boiling (e.g., trichloromonofluoro-
methane, dichlorodifluoromethane), the
aqueous absorber usually is located just
after the reactor so that the hydrogen
chloride is removed from the reaction
CHLORINE-HYDROGEN COMBUSTION products before the organics are further
Exhaus t
i" Water treated. If the organic product is high
boiling, it is usually removed from the
HC1 reactor stream first, by condensation,
Combustion Gas and the hydrogen chloride subsequently
Chamber Cooling absorbed. By-product acid usually con-
tains organic impurities, and depending
on its end use may require further puri-
Hydrogen fication.
Hydrochloric
I
Chlorine
Acid Product Air Pollution Control Aspects
Hydrogen chloride gas combines
readily with water and its solubility is
relatively high (at 140°Fits solubility is
56.1 parts of HC1 in 100 parts of water).
this vent gas may form a slightly visible "suck-back" of mictants, and explosion Its solution in water is accompanied by
white plume on days of moderate to high diaphragms in the combustion chamber. the evolution of considerable heat so that
relative humidity. This vented gas is Purging of the: system with an inert gas adequate cooling must be provided for
primarily nitrogen and oxygen from air such as CO2 after an interruption in in the design of absorption facilities.
leaks into the system and contains a operation is an additional precautionary Emissions of hydrogen chloride from
very small amount of unabsorbed hy- measure. absorption facilities during normal
drogen chloride and a trace of chlorine. Because of the high temperature operations are exceedingly small be-
Comparative volume of exit gas stream (2200°F) of the product gas from the cause water is the scrubbing medium in
is small. chlorine hydrogen reaction, the mate- the tail tower at the end of the system,
rial of construction of the combustion resulting in practically complete re-
Chlorine-Hydrogen Process moval of HC1 from the exit gas stream.
chamber is critical. Water cooled
This process3 for hydrogen chloride graphite or steel combustion chambers Unabsorbed gases that do remain are
generation is used in cases where chlo- have proved satisfactory. Silica or vented high in the air so they are very
rine and hydrogen are available as by- brick-lined vessels are sometimes used. unlikely to cause any air pollution prob-
products from other nearby plant opera- If hydrogen chloride gas is the desired lem. Upsets in operating conditions can
tions, such as electrolysis of alkaline product from these facilities, gas-cooling occur, however, which may result in
chlorides (caustic cells). equipment only is included. If aqueous temporary, localized fumigations.
Chlorine is burned in a slight excess of hydrochloric acid is to be the end In Mannheim furnace operation, the
hydrogen to produce hydrogen chloride. product, gas-cooling and absorption pressure maintained in the muffle is very
The facilities consist of a combustion facilities as described for Mannheim slightly below atmospheric, just enough
chamber, chlorine burner, necessary con- operations are provided but without gas to draw the hydrogen chloride gas being
trol and safety devices, and hydrogen purification units. generated by the reaction from the
chloride processing equipment. The muffle through the system to the ab-
process operates under a slight positive By-Product Hydrogen Chloride sorber. If blockages or leaks occur in
pressure. The chlorine burner is similar The manufacture of chlorinated or- the system, or the exhaust fan at the
to a gas burner with the chlorine being ganic chemicals by the reaction of exit of the absorber fails, the furnace can
introduced through the gas jet and chlorine and an organic compound often lose its draft and some hydrogen chlo-
hydrogen replacing the inlet burner air. results in the formation of hydrogen ride gas would be emitted to the at-
Since hydrogen and chlorine form an ex- chloride as a by-product. For ex-, mosphere through the salt cake dis-
plosive mixture, safety provisions must ample, methane (CH4) from natural gas charge and other parts of the furnace.
be incorporated in the system. These can be chlorinated to give methyl chlo- Pressure points located at various stages
may include automatic gas shut-offs in ride (CH3CI) methylene chloride throughout the entire process are
case of failure of either gas supply, (CH2C12), chloroform (CHC13), and routinely checked and recorded by the
flame monitors with automatic shut-offs, carbon tetrachloride (CCI4) with the operator. This record pinpoints loca-
liquid seals in the gas lines to prevent simultaneous production of hydrogen tions of any trends in resistance build-