Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT: Focusing on an incidence of coastal water entrainment into the Kuroshio frontal region,
we looked at the fate of anchovy larvae Engraulis japonicus originating from coastal spawning
grounds and entrained into the frontal region with the coastal low salinity water. Drifters were re-
leased in the low salinity water of the Kuroshio frontal region, and observation and sampling were
conducted during drifter tracking from 18 to 21 May 1997. Naupliar copepod abundance and copepod
production were high in the low salinity water at an early phase of the tracking, but decreased with
elapsed days. Anchovy larvae were most abundant on the coastal side of the Kuroshio, especially in
the low salinity water. Their ages estimated from otoliths were consistent with those inferred from the
advective transport speed from the coastal spawning ground. The estimated biological mortality rate
of first-feeding larvae (less than 7 d old) in the low salinity water was 0.71 d–1, which was high com-
pared to rates previously reported for Engraulis spp. This high mortality could have been caused by
poor nutritional conditions due to decreasing copepod production and abundance, suggesting that the
offshore entrainment of fish larvae originating from coastal water could be unfavorable for their
survival. The encounter with a frontal eddy would enhance food production and the subsequent sur-
vival of anchovy larvae in the frontal region; otherwise, they may perish due to low food availability.
KEY WORDS: Anchovy larvae · Offshore entrainment · Kuroshio front · Larval survival
Resale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisher
In addition, it has been reported that larval and juve- MATERIALS AND METHODS
nile anchovy are broadly distributed to the far east of
the Japanese coast, corresponding to a recent increase Observations of the Kuroshio front off the central Pa-
in the Japanese anchovy stock (Takahashi et al. 2001). cific coast of Japan were made from RV ‘Hakuho-Maru’
This suggests that the larval survival in the offshore from 18 to 22 May 1997. Four drifters were released in
water could be of importance, particularly to the an- the coastal water marked by low salinity, and tracked
chovy in the Kuroshio region in recent years. from 16:10 h on 18 May, to 06:21 h on 21 May, for 46 to
The objectives of this study are to quantify the time 54 h. The drifters were composed of a surface buoy and
changes in the abundance and food availability of a 2 × 5 m drogue centered at a depth of 18 m below the
anchovy larvae being entrained from the coastal water sea surface. The drifter’s position was monitored using
to the Kuroshio front, and to examine the effect of the the ship’s radar linked to a global positioning satellite
interaction between the Kuroshio and its coastal water system (GPS). Following the drifters, physical and bio-
on larval survival. In this context, we focused on an logical surveys were conducted at night along 3 tran-
incidence of coastal water entrainment into the Kuro- sects (Fig. 2; Line 1, Stns D1 to D6; Line 2, Stns D13 to
shio frontal region off the Enshu-nada Sea, one of the D18; Line 3, Stns D25 to D28). The drifters were re-
major spawning grounds of Japanese anchovy off the trieved after the Day 2 survey (Line 3). A fourth transect
Pacific coast of Japan (Funakoshi et al. 1984). The main (Line 4, Stns D29 to D34) was conducted along the same
spawning period of the anchovy in the Enshu-nada Sea longitudinal section as Line 3 to describe detailed phys-
is from spring to autumn; the peak frequently occurs in ical and biological structure on a wider spatial scale.
spring (Funakoshi 1990). Along each transect, temperature and salinity were
The ocean color image (ADEOS/OCTS) of the study measured by a Seabird CTD (Seabird Electronics) de-
area taken on 18 May 1997 is shown in Fig. 1, and de- ployed to 500 m depth. The CTD data were depth-aver-
monstrates that coastal water was entrained into the aged into 1 m depth strata. Larvae were collected using
Kuroshio front. Taking this opportunity, we released the Ocean Research Institute (ORI) net with 1.6 m dia-
drifters in the coastal water and sampled larval meter and 0.33 mm mesh size (Omori 1965). The ORI
anchovy along the drifter track from 18 to 21 May net was fitted with a flowmeter to estimate the volume
1997, when the drifter moved through the Kuroshio filtered and towed for 3 to 5 min at a speed of 1 m s–1.
frontal region. During the drifter tracking period, we The larval sampling was conducted in the surface layer
investigated the time change in the distribution and (ca. upper 2 m depth), where most of anchovy larvae
abundance of anchovy Engraulis japonicus larvae and were found in the Kuroshio and its coastal area at night
their prey organisms. The nutritional condition, growth (Nakata et al. 2000). Larval abundance was standard-
and mortality of the anchovy larvae were also esti- ized to number of individuals under 1000 m3. Up to
mated. 40 individuals of the anchovy larvae in the sample were
t 2 − t1
and 20, respectively. The sampling was conducted once
at each station due to time constraints, because all where Ct 1 is the density of the cohort at time 1 (t 1), Ct 2 is
samplings along one transect had to be completed dur- the density of the same cohort at time 2 (t 2). The larval
ing the night to reduce potential bias associated with cohorts were divided into 2 groups: first-feeding larvae
net avoidance by the larvae. and post first-feeding larvae (hereafter post larvae). The
In the laboratory, fish larvae were sorted from the mortality rate was estimated for each group, based on
preserved samples. The standard length (SL) of an- the data from the first transect (Line 1, Fig. 1) at Day 0
chovy larvae, the most dominant species, was mea- and the third transect (Line 3, Fig. 1) at Day 2, taking the
sured, and naupliar copepods in the water samples larval growth from Day 0 to Day 2 into account. The age
were counted without identifying species. range of the first-feeding larvae at Day 0 was less than
We use Paracalanus sp. for nucleic acid analysis of 5 d old and that of the post larvae was 6 to 18 d old.
female copepods. This species is one of the dominant We further defined the high salinity water associated
copepods in the Kuroshio frontal region (Hirota 1995). with the Kuroshio (psu > 34.55, referred to hereafter as
The quantities of DNA and RNA in the individual ‘the Kuroshio water’), moderate salinity water (34.35 <
anchovy larva and 10 adult female Paracalanus sp. psu < 34.55) and low salinity water (psu < 34.35), refer-
from each station were determined by the fluorescence ring to Kasai et al. (2002).
240 Mar Ecol Prog Ser 248: 237–244, 2003
Fig. 3. Vertical profiles of temperature, together with distribution of low salinity water (indicated by the shaded area) across
the Kuroshio front measured along transects (Lines 1 to 4; Stns D1 to D6, D13 to D18, D25 to D28 and D29 to D33, respectively) in
the Enshu-nada Sea from 18 to 22 May 1997. Open triangles denote the drifter position. Note: no CDT observations for Stn 34
Fig. 4. Distributions of naupliar copepod abundance, RNA:DNA ratios of female Paracalanus sp. and abundance of anchovy
larvae across the Kuroshio front measured along transects (Lines 1 to 4; Stns D1 to D6, D13 to D18, D25 to D28 and D29 to D34,
respectively) in the Enshu-nada Sea from 18 to 22 May 1997. Shaded areas denote the low salinity water
Okazaki et al.: Offshore entrainment of anchovy larvae and their survival in the Kuroshio front 241
Table 1. Mean density of the first feeding larvae (less than 5 d 1986), suggesting that entrainment of coastal larvae
old at Day 0 sampling) and the post larvae (6 to <18 d old) frequently occurs in the Kuroshio region. The low
in the low salinity water. Apparent mortality rate (Z) and
salinity water discharged from estuaries along the
survival rate (during 2 d) of each age cohort are also demon-
strated. Day 0 and Day 2 samplings include Stns D4 and D5 coast moves through the coastal region of the
and Stns D25, D26 and D27, respectively Kuroshio with a speed of about 5 to 10 cm s–1 (Imasato
& Qio 1987). Assuming that the distance from the
Age cohort (d) Larval densities (ind. 1000 m– 3) coast to the Kuroshio front was 50 to 100 km, the low
at Day 0 Day 0 Day 2 Z Survival salinity water could take 6 to 23 d to get to the
sampling sampling sampling (d–1) rate (%) Kuroshio front, which is consistent with the age range
<5 1810.0 263.3 0.96 14.5 (4 to 25 d old) estimated for the anchovy larvae
6–18 3066.9 2153.6 0.18 70.2 collected in the low salinity water. Therefore, these
anchovy larvae were likely transported together with
coastal water from their spawning grounds to the
The mortality rate estimated above could be biased Kuroshio frontal region.
by diffusion during the drifter tracking period. Assum- Although high naupliar abundance and copepod
ing that time change in the width of low salinity water RNA:DNA ratios were obtained in the low salinity
on the transects from Day 0 (about 15 km) to Day 2 water at Day 0, both decreased in the subsequent tran-
(about 25 km) was mainly due to the diffusion in the sects (Lines 3 and 4). According to Kasai et al. (2002),
cross-frontal direction, the diffusive loss due to this nutrients were already depleted in the low salinity
cross-frontal diffusion was approximately 40% per 2 d. water at Day 0, suggesting that primary productivity
Therefore, after correcting for the diffusive loss in the rapidly declined in the surface water. This could lower
larval density decline, the net (biological) mortality secondary production. Furthermore, the RNA:DNA
rates for the first-feeding larvae and for the post larvae ratios of the anchovy larvae in the low salinity water
were estimated to be 0.71 and –0.08 d–1, respectively. also decreased in the latter transects. The significant
Further, the RNA:DNA ratios of anchovy larvae in positive correlation between RNA:DNA ratios of an-
the low salinity water at Day 0 were compared with chovy larvae and naupliar abundance was consistent
those of Day 2. As shown in Fig. 7, a significant decline with several other recent studies, e.g. Canino et al.
in the larval RNA:DNA ratio was detected between (1991), Bailey et al. (1995) and Chícharo et al. (1998).
Day 0 and Day 2 (ANCOVA, p < 0.01). This indicates The results of our study mentioned above indicate that
that the larval nutritional condition at Day 2 was biological production in the Kuroshio frontal region
degraded from that at Day 0. could not be sustained or accelerated by the coastal
water entrainment. Instead, the frontal eddy, as was
shown in Lines 3 and 4, may play an important role in
DISCUSSION the biological production and larval survival in the
Kuroshio frontal region.
Larvae originating from coastal water have been Although there has been no information on the mor-
collected in the Kuroshio front (Hattori 1970, Kuroda tality rate of Japanese anchovy larvae in the Kuroshio
region, that of northern anchovy larvae in the Califor-
nia Current region was reported to range from 0.13 to
0.23 d–1, over a period of yolk-sac absorption through
to ca. 25 to 30 d old (Hewitt & Methot 1982). In the
southern Brazilian Bight, the mortality rate of larval
anchovy was 0.064 d–1 from 15 to 35 d (Kitahara & Mat-
suura 1995). Castro & Hernandez (2000) reported the
mortality rates of the Peruvian anchovy Engraulis rin-
gens off central Chile to be 0.05 and 0.07 d–1 for the
first 35 d. Our estimate of the biological mortality rate
(0.71 d–1) of first-feeding larvae is appreciably high
compared to the mortality rates reported previously for
Engraulis spp. The mortality rate of post larvae, after
correcting for diffusive loss, was negative, suggesting
that it could be distorted by the immigration of larger
Fig. 7. Scattergrams and least squares regressions of standard
larvae from the outside and that the biological mortal-
length (SL) and RNA:DNA ratios for anchovy larvae in the ity must be much smaller than that of the first-feeding
low salinity water on Days 0 and 2 larvae. In general, mortality of marine fish is a size-
Okazaki et al.: Offshore entrainment of anchovy larvae and their survival in the Kuroshio front 243
the Kuroshio and its adjacent waters off Honshu, mainland Kuroshio Current for anchovy recruitment. ICES J Mar Sci
of Japan. PhD thesis, University of Tokyo (in Japanese) 57:143–152
Kimura S, Kasai A, Nakata H, Sugimoto T, Simpson JH, National Research Institute of Fisheries Science (1995) Distri-
Cheok JVS (1997) Biological productivity of meso-scale bution of eggs and larvae of pelagic fish species around
eddies caused by frontal disturbances in the Kuroshio. Japan. National Research Institute, Fisheries Agency Re-
ICES J Mar Sci 54:179–192 sources Management Research Report Series A-1,
Kimura S, Nakata H, Okazaki Y (2000) Biological production Yokohama
in meso-scale eddies caused by frontal disturbances of the Norcross BL, Shaw RF (1984) Oceanic and estuarine transport
Kuroshio Extension. ICES J Mar Sci 57:133–142 of fish eggs and larvae: a review. Trans Am Fish Sci 113:
Kitahara EM, Matsuura Y (1995) Growth and mortality esti- 153–165
mate of the southwest Atlantic anchovy Engraulis ancho- Okazaki Y, Nakata H, Kimura S (2002) The effects of frontal
ita larva from Cape Santa Marta Grande in southern eddies on the distribution and food availability of anchovy
Brazil. Arch Fish Mar Res 42:251–262 larvae in the Kuroshio Extension. Mar Freshw Res 53:
Kuroda K (1986) Distribution properties of ichthyoplankton, 403–410
especially the Japanese sardine and the Pacific mackerel Omori M (1965) A 160-cm opening-closing plankton net-I.
eggs and larvae near the Kuroshio front south of Cape Description of gear. J Oceanogr Soc Jpn 21:20–28
Shionomisaki, southern Japan. Bull Tokai Reg Fish Res Saiz E, Calbet A, Fara A, Berdalet E (1998) RNA content of
Lab 119:109–122 (in Japanese) copepods as a tool for determining adult growth rates in
Lee TN, Atkinson L, Legeckis R (1981) Observations of a Gulf the field. Limnol Oceanogr 43:465–470
Stream frontal eddy on the Georgia continental shelf, Sato C, Kimura R, Nakata K, Umeda S, Suzuki M (1995)
April 1977. Deep-Sea Res 28:347–378 RNA/DNA ratio of first-feeding larvae of Japanese sar-
McGurk MD (1986) Natural mortality of marine pelagic fish dine. Fish Sci 61:538–539
eggs and larvae: role of spatial patchness. Mar Ecol Prog Shiomoto A, Matsumura S (1992) Primary productivity in a cold
Ser 34:227–242 water mass and the neighborhood area occurring off Enshu-
Mitani I (1990) The biological studies on the larvae of Japan- nada in the late summer of 1989. J Oceanogr 48:105–115
ese anchovy, Engraulis japonica Hottuyn, in Sagami Bay. Takahashi M, Watanabe Y, Kinoshita T, Watanabe, C (2001)
Spec Rep Kanagawa Prefectural Fish Exp Stn 5:1–140 (in Growth of larval and early juvenile Japanese anchovy,
Japanese with English abstract) Engraulis japonicus, in the Kuroshio-Oyashio transition
Nakata K (1990) Abundance of nauplii and protein synthesis region. Fish Oceanogr 10:235–247
activity of adult female copepods in the Kuroshio front Takita T (1988) Engraulididae. In: Okiyama M (ed) An atlas of
during the Japanese sardine spawning season. J Oceanogr the early stages fishes in Japan. Tokai University Press,
Soc Jpn 46:219–229 Tokyo, p 9 (in Japanese)
Nakata K, Nakano H, Kikuchi H (1994) Relationship between Tsuji S, Aoyama T (1984) Daily growth increments in otoliths
egg productivity and RNA:DNA ratio in Paracalanus sp. in of Japanese anchovy larvae, Engraulis japonica. Bull Jpn
the frontal waters of the Kuroshio. Mar Biol 119:951–596 Soc Sci Fish 50:1105–1108
Nakata K, Zenitani H, Inagake D (1995) Differences in food Yamamoto T, Nishizawa S, Taniguchi A (1988) Formation and
availability for Japanese sardine larvae between the retention mechanisms of phytoplankton peak abundance
frontal region and the waters on the offshore side of in the Kuroshio front. J Plankton Res 10:1113–1130
Kuroshio. Fish Oceanogr 4:68–79 Watanabe Y, Kuroki T (1997) Asymptotic growth trajectories
Nakata H, Kimura S, Okazaki Y, Kasai A (2000) Implications of larval sardine (Sardinops melanostictus) in the coastal
of meso-scale eddies caused by frontal disturbance of the waters off western Japan. Mar Biol 127:369–378
Editorial responsibility: Otto Kinne (Editor), Submitted: February 11, 2002; Accepted: September 17, 2002
Oldendorf/Luhe, Germany Proofs received from author(s): February 4, 2003