Verification Control

SAP2000 Concrete Frame Design Verification Examples Filename: #VALUE! User Switches (Overrides Cells E2 thru E5):
Verif manual version: 22.0.0 Solver: Default
Path to SAP2000.exe: C:\SAP2000\Sap2000.exe Delete Files: Yes (Applies to analysis files only, not input or output files)
Path to data files: C:\SAP2000\Verification\Design Examples\Concrete Frame 32 Bit: Default
Last checked: Process: Default

Run This Max % Diff From Applies to Applies to Applies Applies

Code Region Code & Example Number Example Title Example Check This Example Version 22.0.0 Version Level Time Checked Ultimate Advanced to Plus to Basic Comments
American ACI 318-08 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
American ACI 318-08 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
American ACI 318-11 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
American ACI 318-11 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
American ACI 318-14 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
American ACI 318-14 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Australian AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Australian AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Australian AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex003 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced T-Beam Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
British BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
British BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Canadian CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Canadian CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Canadian CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Canadian CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Eurocode EN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Eurocode EN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Indian IS 456-2000 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Indian IS 456-2000 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Italian NTC 2008 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Italian NTC 2008 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Korean KBC 2009 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Korean KBC 2009 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mexican RCDF 2004 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mexican RCDF 2004 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
New Zealand NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Doubly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
New Zealand NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Singapore SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Singapore SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Turkish TS 500-2000 CFD Ex001 Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes
Turkish TS 500-2000 CFD Ex002 P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column Yes Yes Not Checked Yes Yes Yes Yes

Page 1 of 103
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008c.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:07:54 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008c.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008d.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:03 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008d.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008e.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:13 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008e.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008f.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:25 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008f.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-009a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:42 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-009a.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-009b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:52 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-009b.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-010.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:09:04 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-010.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-011.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:09:16 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-011.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:10:19 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012a.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:13:47 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012b.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012c.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:14:46 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012c.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012d.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:18:09 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012d.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-013.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:18:36 PM)
 Data exported to Example 5-013.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-001.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:21:28 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-001.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-002.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:21:41 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-002.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-003a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:25:18 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-003a.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-003b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:28:41 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-003b.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-004.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:28:51 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-004.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-005a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:41:38 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-005a.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-005b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:41:48 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-005b.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-006.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:55:46 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-006.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-007.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:14:16 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-007.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-008.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:16:45 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-008.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-009.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:17:23 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-009.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-010.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:21:18 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-010.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-011a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 12:27:24 AM)
Data exported to Example 6-011a.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-011b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:42:42 AM)
Data exported to Example 6-011b.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-012.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:05 AM)
Data exported to Example 6-012.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-001.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:14 AM)
Data exported to Example 7-001.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-002.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:24 AM)
Data exported to Example 7-002.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-003.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:50 AM)
Data exported to Example 7-003.mdb
 Problem Number Access Database File XML Database File
ACI 318-08 CFD Ex001 ACI 318-08 CFD Ex001.mdb ACI 318-08 CFD Ex001.xml
ACI 318-08 CFD Ex002 ACI 318-08 CFD Ex002.mdb ACI 318-08 CFD Ex002.xml
ACI 318-11 CFD Ex001 ACI 318-11 CFD Ex001.mdb ACI 318-11 CFD Ex001.xml
ACI 318-11 CFD Ex002 ACI 318-11 CFD Ex002.mdb ACI 318-11 CFD Ex002.xml
ACI 318-14 CFD Ex001 ACI 318-14 CFD Ex001.mdb ACI 318-14 CFD Ex001.xml
ACI 318-14 CFD Ex002 ACI 318-14 CFD Ex002.mdb ACI 318-14 CFD Ex002.xml
AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex0 AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex001.mdbAS 3600-2009 CFD Ex001.xml
AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex0 AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex002.mdbAS 3600-2009 CFD Ex002.xml
AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex0 AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex003.mdbAS 3600-2009 CFD Ex003.xml
BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex0 BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex001.mdbBS 8110-1997 CFD Ex001.xml
BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex0 BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex002.mdbBS 8110-1997 CFD Ex002.xml
CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex0 CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex001.mdbCSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex001.xml
CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex0 CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex002.mdbCSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex002.xml
CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex0 CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex001.mdbCSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex001.xml
CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex0 CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex002.mdbCSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex002.xml
EN 2-2004 CEN CFD ExEN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex001.m EN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex001.xml
EN 2-2004 CEN CFD ExEN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex002.m EN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex002.xml
IS 456-2000 CFD Ex001IS 456-2000 CFD Ex001.mdb IS 456-2000 CFD Ex001.xml
IS 456-2000 CFD Ex002IS 456-2000 CFD Ex002.mdb IS 456-2000 CFD Ex002.xml
NTC 2008 CFD Ex001 NTC 2008 CFD Ex001.mdb NTC 2008 CFD Ex001.xml
NTC 2008 CFD Ex002 NTC 2008 CFD Ex002.mdb NTC 2008 CFD Ex002.xml
KBC 2009 CFD Ex001 KBC 2009 CFD Ex001.mdb KBC 2009 CFD Ex001.xml
KBC 2009 CFD Ex002 KBC 2009 CFD Ex002.mdb KBC 2009 CFD Ex002.xml
RCDF 2004 CFD Ex001 RCDF 2004 CFD Ex001.mdb RCDF 2004 CFD Ex001.xml
RCDF 2004 CFD Ex002 RCDF 2004 CFD Ex002.mdb RCDF 2004 CFD Ex002.xml
NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex001.m NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex001.xml
NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex002.m NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex002.xml
SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex001.mdSS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex001.xml
SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex002.mdSS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex002.xml
TS 500-2000 CFD Ex00 TS 500-2000 CFD Ex001.mdb TS 500-2000 CFD Ex001.xml
TS 500-2000 CFD Ex00 TS 500-2000 CFD Ex002.mdb TS 500-2000 CFD Ex002.xml
ACI 318-08 CFD Ex001
American
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (k-in) 1460.4 1460.4 0.00%
As (in )
2
2.37 2.37 0.00%
Vu (kips) 37.73 37.73 0.00%
Av/s (in /in)
2
0.041 0.041 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
1 0.00 Not Checked
2 0.000 Not Checked
2 0.000 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
ACI 318-08 CFD Ex002
American
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.000 1.000 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
ACI 318-11 CFD Ex001
American
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (k-in) 1460.4 1460.4 0.00%
As (in )
2
2.37 2.37 0.00%
Vu (kips) 37.73 37.73 0.00%
Av/s (in /in)
2
0.041 0.041 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
1 0.00 Not Checked
2 0.000 Not Checked
2 0.000 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
ACI 318-11 CFD Ex002
American
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.000 1.000 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
ACI 318-14 CFD Ex001
American
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (k-in) 1460.4 1460.4 0.00%
As (in )
2
2.37 2.37 0.00%
Vu (kips) 37.73 37.73 0.00%
Av/s (in /in)
2
0.041 0.041 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
1 0.00 Not Checked
2 0.000 Not Checked
2 0.000 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
ACI 318-14 CFD Ex002
American
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.000 1.000 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex001
Australian
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 415 415 0.00%
As (mm )
+ 2
2550 33.512 7509.21%
Vu (kN) 226 226 0.00%
Av/s (mm /m) 2
0.50 0.50 0.00%
\
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
0 0 Not Checked
0 0.000 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
2 0.00 Not Checked
Verification Control
AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex002
Australian
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.001 1.000 0.10%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
AS 3600-2009 CFD Ex003
Australian
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced T-Beam
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 462 462 0.00%
As (mm )
+ 2
3351.2 3351.2 0.00%
Vu (kN) 231 231 0.00%
Av/s (mm /m) 2
1.205 1.205 0.00%
\
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.000 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
3 0.00 Not Checked
Verification Control
BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex001
British
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 165.02 165.02 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
964.1 964.1 0.00%
Vu (kN) 92.04 92.04 0.00%
Asv/sv (mm /mm)
2
0.231 0.231 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
2 0.00 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
BS 8110-1997 CFD Ex002
British
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.995 1.000 -0.50%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex001
Canadian
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mf (kN-m) 415.00 415.00 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
2466 2466.000 0.00%
Vf (kN) 226.31 226.31 0.00%
Av/s (mm /mm) 2
0.379 0.379 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
2 0.00 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
CSA A23.3-04 CFD Ex002
Canadian
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.987 1.000 -1.30%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex001
Canadian
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mf (kN-m) 415.00 415.00 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
2466 2466.000 0.00%
Vf (kN) 226.31 226.31 0.00%
Av/s (mm /mm) 2
0.379 0.379 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
2 0.00 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
CSA A23.3-14 CFD Ex002
Canadian
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.987 1.000 -1.30%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
EN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex001
Eurocode
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
MEd (kN-m) 165 165 0.00%
As (mm )
2
916 916 0.00%
VEd (kN) 110 110 0.00%
Asw/s (mm /m)
2
249.5 249.5 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
0 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
Verification Control
EN 2-2004 CEN CFD Ex002
Eurocode
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.006 1.030 -2.33%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 21.1.0
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
IS 456-2000 CFD Ex001
Indian
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 170.00 170.00 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
1006 1006 0.00%
Vu (kN) 113.33 113.33 0.00%
Asv/s (mm /mm)2
0.333 0.333 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
2 0.00 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
IS 456-2000 CFD Ex002
Indian
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.998 1.000 -0.20%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
NTC 2008 CFD Ex001
Italian
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
MEd (kN-m) 165.02 165.02 0.00%
As (mm )
2
933 933 0.00%
VEd (kN) 110.0 110.0 0.00%
Asw/s (mm /m)
2
345.0 345.0 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
Verification Control
NTC 2008 CFD Ex002
Italian
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.000 1.000 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
KBC 2009 CFD Ex001
Korean
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 360 360 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
2109 2109 0.00%
Vu (kN) 180.0 180.0 0.00%
Av/s (mm /m) 2
515.0 515.0 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
0 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
0 0.0 Not Checked
Verification Control
KBC 2009 CFD Ex002
Korean
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.006 1.000 0.60%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
RCDF 2004 CFD Ex001
Mexican
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 290.38 290.38 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
1498 1498 0.00%
Vu (kN) 154.9 154.9 0.00%
Av/s (mm /m) 2
563 563 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
Verification Control
RCDF 2004 CFD Ex002
Mexican
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 1.000 1.000 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex001
New Zealand
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Doubly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 510 510 0.00%
As (mm )
+ 2
3170 3170 0.00%
As- (mm2) 193 193 0.00%
Vu (kN) 255 255 0.00%
Av/s (mm /m) 2
1088.6 1088.6 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
0 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
Verification Control
NZS 3101-2006 CFD Ex002
New Zealand
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.994 1.000 -0.60%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex001
Singapore
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Mu (kN-m) 294.30 294.30 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
1555 1555 0.00%
Vu (kN) 160.23 160.23 0.00%
Asw/s (mm /mm)2
0.730 0.730 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
2 0.00 Not Checked
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
SS CP 65-1999 CFD Ex002
Singapore
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.995 1.000 -0.50%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control
TS 500-2000 CFD Ex001
Turkish
Shear and Flexural Reinforcement Design of a Singly Reinforced Rectangle
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Md (kN-m) 165.02 165.02 0.00%
As (mm ) 2
1022 1022 0.00%
Vd (kN) 110.0 110.0 0.00%
Asw/s (mm /mm)2
0.2415 0.2415 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
2 0.00 Not Checked
0 0 Not Checked
1 0.0 Not Checked
4 0.0000 Not Checked
Verification Control
TS 500-2000 CFD Ex002
Turkish
P-M Interaction Check for Compression-Controlled Rectangular Column
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output Percent
Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
D/C Ratio 0.993 1.000 -0.70%
Results From Current Analyses
Number of Decimal Result for % Diff From
SAP2000 Result Places Comparison Version 15.0.1
3 0.000 Not Checked
Verification Control