Professional Documents
Culture Documents
• Gender typing: the process by which a child becomes aware of his or her gender and acquires motives, values, and behaviours
considered appropriate for members of that biological sex in a culture; acquiring gender specific female or male roles
Definitions
• Sex = biological identity
• Gender = social and cultural identity as male/female, appropriate ways they should act - how does a child learn that they are a boy,
and a boy is 'x'
• Gender-role standard = a behaviour, value, or motive that society deems more appropriate for males/females
• Even from physical and cognitive perspective there are differences between female and males, for example spatial orientation;
however, many differences are based on stereotypes in our society
• From a cognitive perspective the male brain is bigger than the female brain, but that doesn't mean they are smarter, females have
more neural density; this isn't a suggestion about cognitive capacity
• Most developmentalists can agree that males and females are far more psychologically similar than they are different
• We find that fathers are the ones that push gender stereotypes; and if a girl is a tomboy thats okay, but if a boy acts in a non-
masculine way that is more catastrophic
Cultural “myths”
• Many gender-role stereotypes are 'cultural myths"
• Gender-role stereotypes are well-ingrained cognitive schemes that we use to interpret and often distort the behaviour of males and
females
• What are some gender-stereotypical beliefs we have in our society?
• Girls are more social than boys
• Girls are more suggestible than boys
• Girls have smaller brains, therefore boys excel at higher-level cognitive processing tasks
• Boys are more analytical
• Girls lack achievement motivation
• Girls don’t do as well in maths than boys
• Girls are more emotional than boys
Home influences
• Parental expectations about sex differences become self-fulfilling prophecies
• (1) Parents expect sons to outperform daughters in math
• (2) Parents attribute their sons' successes in math to ability but credit their daughters' successes to hard work, e.g., "Go see Dad; he's
the math brain" (reinforcing the belief that girls lack mathematical talent)
• (3) Children begin to internalize their parents' views, so that boys feel self-confident and girls more inclined to underestimate their
abilities
• (4) Suspecting they lack ability, girls become less interested in math, value it less, less likely to take elective math courses, and
become less inclined that boys to pursue careers that involve math
Scholastic influences
• Teachers also have stereotyped beliefs about the relative abilities of boys and girls in particular subjects; believe that boys have
more ability in math but that girls try harder
• 1) Gender identity: knowledge that one is either a boy or a girl and gender is an unchanging attribute; children as young as two
or three know,
• 2) Gender-role stereotypes: preconceive stereotypes/ideas about what males and females are supposed to be like, that may be
inaccurate, but still lingering in society
• 3) Gender-typed patterns of behaviour: child's tendencies to select same-sex playmate and to favour same-sex activities over those
normally associated with the other sex
• Fast-moving masculine games and "action" toys may simply be more interesting than the plaything and pastimes (e.g., dolls,
dollhouses, dishes, cleaning and care-taking utensils) often imposed on girls to encourage their adoption of a nurturant,
expressive orientation
• Girls by adolescence come to prefer many of the prescriptions for the feminine role; probably for biological, cognitive, and social
reasons
• Bodies assume more womanly appearance and girls feel they need to become more "feminine" if they hope to be attractive to
members of the other sex
• Attaining formal operations and advanced role-taking skills
• More susceptible to gender intensification pressures and thus more inclined to conform to the social prescriptions of the female
role
• Mexican American families: For example, Mexican-Americans have very clearly differentiated gender-role socialization
standards.
Evolutionary Theory
• Males and females face different evolutionary pressures over the course of human history and natural selection process conspired
to create fundamental differences among males and females that determined gender divisions of labor
• Males, who need only contribute sperm to produce offspring, can best ensure that their genes survive by mating with multiple
partners and producing many children; therefore, they should become more competitive, assertive, and aggressive because these
attributes should increase their chances of successfully attracting mates and procuring resources
• Females must incest much more to achieve the same objective, taking nine months from conception to the birth of each
offspring and years to raise each to ensure that their genes survive; to successfully raise children, women presumably evolved
in ways that would make them kind, gentle, and nurturant and prefer men who would display kindness toward them and would
provide resources (food and protection)
• Women and men still have a particular way of thinking when selecting a mate
• Males and females may be psychologically the same but differ in any domain in which they have faced different adaptive
problems, e.g., male spatial skills were essential for hunting, and with pressures to provide food they would develop greater
spatial skills
• Children at young age can differentiate between boys and girls toys - they say this is because it is because of genetics
• First critical event occurs at conception as the child inherits either an X or Y chromosome from the father; second critical point
development of male internal reproductive system or female internal reproductive system; third critical point is growing penis and
scrotum or female genitalia
• When a child is born social factors come into play and then biological factors come into play again at puberty, when large
quantities of hormones are released, stimulating the growth of the reproductive system, the appearance of secondary sex
characteristics, and the development of sexual urges
• All these factors combine to provide basis for an adult gender identity and gender-role preference
• Evidence for biological influences on gender-role development
• Genetic Influences
• X-linked recessive trait: an attribute determined by recessive gene that appears only on the X chromosomes; because the gene
determining these characteristics is recessive (that is, dominated by other genes that might appear at the same location on X
chromosomes), such characteristics are common among males who have only one X chromosome; also called sex-linked trait
• Timing of puberty: biological variable regulated in party by our genotypes, and it has been found that people who reach
puberty late preform better on visual/spatial tasks than those who mature early
• However, later research indicates that spatial performance is more heavily influenced by their previous involvement in spatial
activities and their self-concepts than their timing of puberty; males have strong masculine self-concept and experience with
spatial toys and activities
• Hormonal influences
• "Wrong" hormones given to women during prenatal period with negative consequences, e.g., women given progestin, which
converts to male hormone testosterone by the body, or adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) which causes females to be born with
external genitalia that resembles those of a boy
• Androgenized females: females who develop male-like external genitalia because of exposure to male sex hormones during the
prenatal period
• Androgenized girls were more likely to be tomboys who payed with boys and preferred boys' toys and activities compared to
traditional girls' toys
• Social-labelling influences
• Money and Ehrhardt insisted that social-labelling influences can modify or even reverse biological predispositions (surgery and
gender reassignment)
• Money concluded that there is a "critical period" between 18 months and 3 years of age for the establishment of gender identity
• Cultural influences
• Differences across cultures in what people expect of boys and girls
• Tahiti: few distinctions are made among boys and girls
• Mead’s study of tribal societies
• Arapesh – both males and females were taught to be expressive
• Mundugumor – both genders were taught to be “masculine”
• Tchambuli – from Western standards, males more feminine, females more masculine
• So despite biology, their characteristics and identity was determined by the culture
• So you see we are tossed back and forth from nurture and nature
Psychobiosocial viewpoint
• Psychobiosocial model: perspective on nature/nurture interactions specifying that specific early experiences affect the organization
of the brain, which in turn influences one's responsiveness to similar experiences in the future
Freud’s Psychoanalytic Theory (children are passive and genetics determine gender role development)
• One's preference for a particular gender role emerges during the phallic stage of psychosexual development
• Phallic stage: Freud's third stage of psychosexual development (from 3 to 6 years of age) in which children gratify the sex
instinct by fondling their genitals and developing an incestuous desire for the parent of the other sex; females envy the penis, boy
identifies with the father because he wants to take over role but fears father chopping off the penis
• During this stage children begin to emulate and identify with the same-sex parent
• Identification: child's tendency to emulate another person, usually the same-sex parent
• Males = oedipus complex and females = electra complex
• Males become gender typed as they identify with their father to resolve the Oedipus complex
• Freud believe gender typing is more difficult for a girl (because she lacks a penis); but f athers encourage feminine behaviour in
females, and act that increases attractiveness of the mother who serves as the girl's model of femininity
• By trying to please her father a girl is motivated to incorporate her mother's feminine attributes
• Evaluating Freud's theory:
• Lack of research support
• Children at this age are so ignorant about differences between male and female genitalia
• Research suggest that child identifies with the parent that is nurturing and comforting
• Children notice characteristics and classify themselves according to that, like gender detectives, start to create schema
• That is they first establish a stable gender identity and then actively seek out same-sex models and other information to learn how to
act like a boy or girl
• Basic gender identity: the stage of gender identity in which the child first labels the self as a boy or a girl; around preschool
years (2-3 years of age), they recognize they are either a boy or girl and organize any information the environment gives them
around that
• Gender stability: the stage of gender identity in which the child recognizes that gender is stable over time (ages 4-5); they
understand and accept that if 'I'm a boy I will always remain a boy,' and if girl cuts her hair might think she 'is a boy'
• Gender consistency: the stage of gender identity in which the child recognizes that a person's gender is invariant despite changes
in the person's activities or appearance (also known as gender constancy); superficial changes has no effect on their sex, they
realize it doesn't matter if they cut their hair
• Self-socialization begins only after children reach gender consistency
• Criticisms of Kohlberg’s Theory
• Research has shown that:
• Gender-typing begins well before children acquire a mature gender identity
• Gender reassignment is very difficult after age 3
Gender Schema Theory (Martin & Halverson) (another way of approaching it - information-processing theory)
• Like Kohlberg they believe that children are intinsically motivated to acquire interests, values, and behaviours that are consistent
with their 'boy' or 'girl' self-images, but unlike Kohlberg, they argue 'self-socialization' begins as soon as the chid acquires a basic
gender identity
• Establishment of a basic gender identity motivates a child to learn about the sexes and to incorporate this information into gender
schemes; look at the environment for consistency of their schemas
• Gender schemas: organized sets of beliefs and expectations about males and females that guide information processing
• First children construct a simple in-group/out-group schema: one's general knowledge of the mannerisms, roles, activities, and
behaviours that characterize males and females
• Children also construct an own-sex schema: detailed knowledge or plans of action that enable a person to perform gender-
consistent activities and to enact his or her gender role
• Once formed gender schemas structure experience by providing a framework for processing social information; they are more likely
to encode and remember information consistent with their gender schemas and to forget schema-inconsistent information or to
otherwise distort it so that it becomes more consistent with their stereotypes
• Example: Children who heard stories in which actors performed gender-atypical behaviours, e.g., girl chopping wood, tended to
recall the action but to alter the scene to conform to their gender stereotypes, saying that a boy had been chopping wood
An Integrative Theory
• Biological theories account for major biological developments
• Social-theories account for differential reinforcement processes
• Cognitive development explains the growth of categorization skills
• Gender schemas are also important as are models as children age
• Between the ages of 3 and 7, gender-related issues are very important to children. This is the time when they are starting to firmly
classify themselves as boys and girls…. They are starting to know that they will always be boys and/or girls.
• As children develop they learn that gender stereotypes don’t always apply
• Older children are more willing than younger children to ignore stereotypes when judging children
• Starting at age 2, boys are more physically and verbally aggressive than girls.
• They are more likely to be physically aggressive toward other boys rather than toward girls
• Girls display covert forms of aggression snubbing others or undermining social status or relationships.
• Boys and men are more aggressive in virtually all cultures and in nonhuman species
• Parents are more “feeling-oriented” with daughters than with sons. They are more likely to talk about their emotions with daughters
than with sons. They are more likely to emphasize the importance of considering others’ feelings with their daughter than with their
sons.
• Parents
• From birth, fathers tend to interact more with sons than daughters while mothers interact more with daughters than sons
• Mothers play traditional games like peek-a-boo whereas fathers play more physical, rough-and-tumble activities
• Parents treat sons and daughters similarly, except for gender-related behavior
• Example: a dad might urge his frightened son to jump off a diving board (Be a man!) but not be so insistent with his daughter
(That’s okay, honey!).
Peers
• By 3 years of age, most children’s play shows the impact of gender stereotypes:
• Boys prefer blocks and trucks
• Girls prefer tea sets and dolls
• Young children are even critical of peers who engage in cross-gender play
• Once children learn rules about gender-typical play, they often harshly punish peers who violate those rules
• Between 2 and 3 years of age, children begin to prefer playing with same-sex peers
• Children spontaneously select same-sex playmates. Adult pressure is not necessary.
• Boys and girls prefer same-sex playmates even in gender-neutral activities such as playing tag or doing puzzles.
Gender Identity
How d we develop a sense of being male or female?