Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/15577227
CITATIONS READS
53 1,064
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Vittorio Porciatti on 24 August 2015.
treatment of amblyopia never found their way into clin- Table 1 The age and ocular condition of each of the 50 patients in
ical routine; their efficacy was questionable and their the open study
side effects relevant. Patient Age (years) Condition
Recently, it has been shown that levodopa improves
temporarily some visual functions in amblyopia [7, 10]. 1 13 Anisometropia
Duration of improvement is short, and side effects are 2 12 Anisometropia
not to be neglected. 3 9 Anisometropia
4 10 Strabismus
Cytidine-5-diphosphocholine (CDP-choline or citi- 5 9 Anisometropia
coline) has been used for many years to improve con- 6 14 Anisometropia
sciousness level in patients with post-traumatic cerebral 7 33 Strabismus
lesions and as a complement to levodopa in Parkinson's 8 9 Anisometropia
9 26 Anisometropia
disease patients. Even if animal experimental studies are 10 10 Deprivation
still unsufficient, it appears that citicoline improves 11 10 Anisometropia
membrane ATPase activity. It modulates the turnover 12 10 Deprivation
of catecholamines and serotonin. In particular, stimula- 13 12 Deprivation
tion of dopamine metabolism has been documented in 14 37 Strabismus
15 15 Anisometropia
the nigrostriatal dopaminergic system [18]. Citicoline 16 20 Anisometropia
absorption is increased in cerebral lesions. Citicoline 17 9 Deprivation
has been shown to ameliorate severe glaucomatous vi- 18 9 Anisometropia
sual field deficits for at least 4 months in about 60% of 19 17 Strabismus
20 18 Anisometropia
treated patients [16, 17]. We therefore started to use citi- 21 20 Anisometropia
coline in amblyopia in 1991 and have obtained encour- 22 22 Anisometropia
aging results [3]. Our preliminary findings are reported 23 12 Anisometropia
here. 24 14 Anisometropia
25 14 Strabismus
26 12 Deprivation
27 21 Anisometropla
Materials and methods 28 23 Anisometropla
29 17 Anisometropla
Sixty patients with amblyopia took part, 50 in an open study and
10 in a double-blind study. They were selected from among the 30 15 Anisometropla
31 13 Anisometropla
patients of the Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus Service
32 16 Anisometropla
of the University of Modena and from the private practice of one
33 29 Anisometropla
of the authors (E.C.C). Their age was chosen to be beyond the
34 18 Anisometropla
plastic period of the visual system and ranged from 9 to 37 years
35 20 Anisometropla
(mean 16.6 years). All patients had previously been treated unsuc-
36 32 Strabismus
cessfully for amblyopia and were aware that they were participat-
37 16 Anisometropia
ing in an experimental study. A consent form was signed by the
38 21 Anisometropia
patient or, if applicable, by their parents. Of the 50 patients partic-
39 16 Deprivation
ipating in the open study, 32 had anisometropic, 12 strabismic and
40 15 Anisometropia
6 deprivation amblyopia (Table 1). Their visual acuity in the
41 28 Anisometropia
sound eye was 6/12 or better; that of the amblyopic eye ranged
42 12 Strabismus
from 6/60 to 6/6 (Table 2). Of the 10 patients in the random dou-
43 17 Strabismus
ble-blind study, 7 had anisometropic and 3 strabismic amblyopia
44 15 Anisometropia
(Table 3). Their visual acuity in the amblyopic eye ranged from
45 12 Strabismus
6/60 to 6/9; that of the sound eye was 6/6 or better (Table 4). 46 9 Strabismus
Visual acuity was always measured with the same charts in the 47 11 Anisometropia
same examining room. The upper measurable limit of visual acu- 48 18 Anisometropia
ity was 6/4.5 because of limitations of the charts. First, linear 49 20 Strabismus
acuity was measured with Snellen Es, separated by the same space 50 22 Strabismus
which included the letter of a given size (UEs). Then, separate Es
acuity was measured with letters projected on a screen (SEs). Visu-
al acuity measurements were repeated in all patients on 3 consec-
utive days before starting treatment, in order to exclude a training
effect. All patients had been exposed for many years to visual were all tested by P.B. and C.S., who were unaware of the content
acuity measurements because of their condition. They were all of the vials.
reliable observers. Visual acuity was tested in both eyes of all patients, starting 1
A daily dose of 1000 mg citicoline (Neuroton; Nuovo Con- week after the beginning of treatment and continuing at weekly
sorzio Sanitario Nazionale, Rome) i.m. for 15 days was prescribed intervals for 1 month and then on a monthly basis. Duration of
to the first group of patients. Five white unlabelled boxes with follow-up ranged from 6 to 18 months for the open study and was
three vials each, for a total of 15 vials, were given to the 10 patients restricted to 6 months for the double-blind study. A statistical
in the double-blind study. In five boxes the vials contained citico- analysis of variance for repeated measures was performed on the
line and in five they held physiological solution with additives. natural logarithms of the results of the open and the double-blind
The boxes were numbered by E.C.C., who knew the key. Patients studies. Specifically, differences in visual acuity before and 4
309
months after treatment were evaluated separately for the sound found both in the sound and in the amblyopic eye and
and the amblyopic eye. was statistically significant (P <0.001) (Fig. 1). The be-
haviour of normal and amblyopic eyes was different
(P<0.001). The amount of improvement could not be
Results correlated to the age of the patients. In the amblyopic
eye, the separate Es acuity varied widely. Details of the
The effect of one course of 15 i.m. injections of citicoline responses are presented in Table 2. The separate letter
1000 mg improved visual acuity in 46 (92%) of 50 pa- acuity was always better than the linear acuity in the
tients in the open study (Table 2). The improvement was amblyopic eyes. A difference between separate and lin-
310
Table 3 The age and ocular condition of each of the 10 patients visual acuity expressed in 6/
in the double-blind study
Patient Age (years) Condition
I
1 14 Anisometropia
2 9 Anisometropia
3 11 Strabismus
4 22 Anisometropia
5 17 Anisometropia
6 15 Anisometropia 2 0
7 13 Strabismus
8 12 Strabismus
9 28 Anisometropia
10 19 Anisometropia 4 0
References
1. Bietti GB (1957) Sur la possibilit6 3. Campos EC, Benedetti P, Schiavi C, 5. Duffy FH, Snodgrass SR, Burchfiel
d'un traitment m6dicamenteux des Scorolli L (1992) Risultati preliminari JL, Conway JL (1982) Bicuculline re-
ph6nomens suppressifs en vision sull' impiego della citicolina nell' am- versal of deprivation amblyopia in the
binoculaire dans le strabisme. Probl bliopia. Boll Soc Med Chir Modena cat. Nature 260:256-257
Act Ophthalmol 1:391-399 107:357-360 6. Gottlob I, Charlier J, Reinecke RD
2. Bietti GB, Scorsonelli M (1955) 4. Domenici L, Berardi N, Carmignoto (1992) Visual acuities and scotomas
Azione dell' 0/2 sui fenomeni di sop- G, Vantini G, Maffei L (1991) Nerve after one week of levodopa adminis-
pressione in visione binoculare degli growth factor (NGF) prevents the am- tration in human amblyopia. Invest
strabici. Riv Med Aeronaut 18:23-34 blyopic effect of monocular depriva- Ophthalmol Visual Science 33:2722-
tion. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2728
88:8811-8815
312
7. Harwerth RS, Smith EL, Duncan GC, 11. Nagcl A (1871) Die Behandlung der 16. Pecori Giraldi J, Virno M, Covelli
Crawford MLJ, Noorden GK yon Amaurosen und Amblyopien mit GP, Grechi G, De Gregorio F (1989)
(1986) Effects of enucleation of the fix- Strycknin. Klin Monatsbl Augen- Therapeutic value of citicoline in the
ating eye on strabismic amblyopia in heilkd 9: 264-267 treatment of glaucoma (computerized
monkeys. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 12. Noorden GK yon (1985) Amblyopia. and automated perimetric investiga-
27:246 254 A multidisciplinary approach (Proctor tion). Int Ophthalmol 13:109 115
8. Kasamatsu T (1982) Enhancement of Lecture). Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 17. Virno M, Pecori Giraldi J, Grechi G,
neuronal plasticity by activating the 26:1704-1716 Covelli GP, De Gregorio F (1989)
norepinephrine system in the brain: a 13. Noorden GK von (1990) Binocular vi- Valore terapeutico della citicolina nel
remedy for amblyopia. Hum Neurobi- sion and ocular motility. Theory and paziente glaucomatoso (indagine peri-
ol 1 : 49-54 management of strabismus. Mosby, metrica computerizzata). Boll Ocul 68
9. Kasamatsu T, Pettigrew JD (1976) St. Louis [Suppl 2] :251-258
Depletion of brain cathecolamines: 14. Noorden GK von, Crawford MLJ 18. Virno M, Pecori Giraldi J, Pellegrino
failure of ocular dominance shift after (1992) The lateral geniculate nucleus N, Taverniti L, De Gregorio F, Se-
monocular occlusion in kittens. Sci- in human strabismic amblyopia. In- dran L (1993) Farmaci attivi sulla
ence 194:206-209 vest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 33:2729- emodinamica oculare. Boll Ocul 72:
10. Leguire LE, Rogers GI, Bremer DL, 2732 [Suppl 2] 1-20
Walson R Hadjiconstaninou-Neff M 15. Noorden GK von, Crawford MLJ,
(1992) Levodopa and childhood am- Levaey RA (1983) The lateral genicu-
blyopia. J Ped Ophthalmol Strabis- late nucleus in human anisometropic
mus 29:290-298 amblyopia. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
24:788-789