2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK

Digital Society with Vontobel

The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities
In Quintero, oil leaks and pollution from heavy industry is taking a heavy toll on the health of local citizens. Now the fight is on to
clean up one of Chile's so-called "sacrifice zones"

By NAOMI LARSSON
6:00 AM

ADVERTISEMENT

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 1/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK

Children playing in front of the AES Gener thermoelectric plant in the Valparaiso region. The The Quintero-Puchuncavi area is one of
Chile's "sacrifice zones"
Credit Getty Images / PABLO VERA / Contributor

One morning in late August 2018, Carolina Astudillo was leaving her house in Quintero, a Chilean coastal
town just two hours from Santiago, when she noticed a change in the air around her. As she reached the end of
the block she was already coughing heavily. She felt sick, a numbness in her limbs. “It was brutal. You almost
couldn’t breathe. My throat was sore, my arms and legs felt numb,” Astudillo says.
It’s not so unusual for residents of Quintero and the surrounding villages to feel like this. Many of her
neighbours suffer from respiratory illnesses like asthma. The air often tastes metallic, rather than of the sea.
Even the beach looks darker than it should be – instead of shells, the sand is littered with coal spilt from
incoming cargo ships. A few dead birds lie washed up just yards from where some families eat their picnics.

ADVERTISEMENT

But this time it was worse than normal. Several chemical gases, including methyl chloroform, nitrobenzene and
toluene, had leaked from the nearby oil and chemical plants that ring the town. Between September 21 and
October 18 that year, 1,398 people were treated for gas poisoning in local hospitals, according to the Chilean
Ministry of Health. The residents of the Quintero and Puchuncaví region had been hit by yet another pollution
crisis, another industrial accident.
Just a few kilometres from where Astudillo lives with her husband and children is the centre of Chilean
industrial development. It is home to some of the biggest and dirtiest industries: coal power plants, cement
plants, thermal power, natural gas. From just one copper smelter in 1964, there are now around 20 different
industrial facilities here, built as part of state plans to drive production. The park was meant to be the engine of
economic growth to launch Chile into the ranks of “developed” countries – an idea echoed by the West German

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 2/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK
minister of Economic Cooperation, Walter Scheel, who visited Quintero Bay during the construction of the
copper processing plant: “Chile is not an underdeveloped country but a nation in full swing toward
development,” he said at the time. But this development has come at a cost.
Quintero is known to residents and activists as one of Chile’s “sacrifice zones”, an area where pollution and
contamination are so high, that nature and the people living there have been squeezed out for the sake of
economic development. “We call Quintero the Chilean Chernobyl,” says Rodrigo Barría of Greenpeace Chile. “The
environment is broken without repair. The soil is broken, the water is broken. The people are sacrificed. This is
the kind of stuff that society prefers not to look at, because the people are poor.”
There are five of these so-called sacrifice zones in Chile, and for years communities have been fighting for their
rights to live in a healthy environment. Groups have campaigned, mostly in vain, for tighter industry
regulations, reparations, and for better health services.
For a time there was hope; last year campaigners won a historic victory when the Supreme Court confirmed the
government was ultimately responsible for the environmental contamination in 2018, and that it must take
concrete steps to prevent it happening again. While Chile spent most of last year preparing to host the
international environment conference COP25, President Sebastian Piñera introduced a 2040 decarbonisation
plan, and promised a decontamination plan for Quintero, attempting to normalise and freeze levels of
particulate matter, sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide within three years. The government claimed there would
be dramatic reductions. Copper company Codelco for example, is allowed to produce 1,000 tons of particulate
matter per year, but the plans would reduce that by 91 per cent to 89 tons per year.
But his promise is already fracturing. The decarbonisation plan would only close two of the oldest and least
productive power plants in the Quintero area by 2024, while environmental groups criticised the proposals for
not addressing the levels of arsenic or heavy metals in the region. Then all hopes for the state to present Chile as
a positive example were quashed when Piñera was forced to pull out of hosting the conference after a massive
social uprising broke out in the country in October 2019.

ADVERTISEMENT

Credit Getty Images / PABLO COZZAGLIO / Contributor

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 3/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK
Millions of people have since taken to the streets over deeply entrenched inequality. Protests broke out in the
capital over a rise in metro fares, but exploded into nationwide unrest over standards of living – from
privatisation of healthcare, indigenous rights, to the environment. Among the calls were an end to the sacrifice
zones: at the time, 20 children in Quintero were reported hospitalised from suspected sulphur dioxide
poisoning. “Nothing has been done, nothing has changed,” says Astudillo. “We've been abandoned.”
Katta Alonso, a 65-year-old activist who runs the group the Women of the Sacrifice Zone, lives in the
neighbouring village of Las Ventanas. Her home looks over the bay, once a popular destination for summer
holidays. She still remembers life before the industries came in. “The quality of life was marvellous. The
community lived off the ocean, the land and tourism. There were white sand dunes, wetlands with nature and
birds,” she says. “At the beginning it was disguised as an opportunity for work and progress. People bought into
it. But eventually people started noticing this wasn’t true.”
Residents became aware of irregularities just a few years after the facilities opened. In the late 60s there were
reports of cattle and horses dying, with land becoming increasingly infertile. Today people recount stories that
have become almost mythological – like the “green men” who worked in the copper refinery and later died of
cancer. Their organs reportedly had green pigmentations due to contamination. In 2013, the bodies of four
workers were exhumed; heavy metals like arsenic and mercury were detected in their bones.
Now, the impact is hard to ignore. The local fishing industry has been virtually wiped out because the stock and
ocean are too contaminated. High levels of arsenic have been reported in a number of species. In 2016, for
example, a species of crab known as Jaiba Peluda was found to have arsenic levels of 57.58mg/kg, far above
permitted levels of 2mg/kg.
Locals continue to face a daily battle with the air they breathe. Allergies are widespread. Sometimes school
children can’t spend their lunch breaks outside in the playground because the pollution levels are too high.
There are also frequent industrial accidents, including three major oil spills affecting the bay in the last six
years. The largest in 2014 when 37,000 litres of oil were dumped into the ocean after two tankers lost connection.
In 2011, more than 40 children fell ill after a chemical leak linked to a copper refinery causing nausea, vomiting
and fainting. An investigation found high levels of lead and arsenic in the school, located 500 metres from a
state-owned copper refinery, Codelco, and thermoelectric facility.
Coal continues to wash up on the beach as it spills during the transfer from ships to the thermoelectric plants. In
ADVERTISEMENT
2018 Alonso documented 146 days when coal had been found on the beach. By October 2019 it was 170 days. “It
affects all parts of your life – problems with mental health, there are people with learning disabilities, and there
are physical consequences like, for example, you can’t finish school because your body or mind can't take it,”
Astudillo says.
“Our rights to life aren’t recognised,” adds Maria Araya, president of the advisory council of the local hospital.
“The kids are vulnerable, they’re not able to do normal things. They can’t breathe outside sometimes, or can’t go
to school and or do exercise. Every day we're living we're sacrificing our kids. The percentage of people who are
sick with asthma, cancer, or have special needs, it's double the number of a similar sized commune.”
A recent report from Santiago’s Universidad Catolica found that living in a sacrifice zone is linked to greater risk
of illness and premature death. And despite the mountain of evidence over the years – from cancer rates to the
destruction of biodiversity – Florencia Ortúzar from the InterAmerican Association for Environmental Defense
(Aida), says the companies continue to operate this way because of lax regulations. For example, the World
Health Organization’s recommended maximum exposure to sulphur dioxide is 20 ug/m3 in a day, but Chile’s is
250 ug/m3.
“At the end of the day, industry is being favoured over human health,” says Ortúzar, noting that many of the
“important” industries for Chile’s economy are based in Quintero-Puchuncavi, including four coal-powered
thermal plants. Despite having major reserves of solar power and green energy, Chile’s race to development and
economic growth has been driven through these industries. Chile was the first South American country to join
the OECD, and has had the fastest-growing economy in the region.
She adds there are so many industries in one area that they don’t know the source of pollution “and no one
knows who is not complying. It’s like a black hole.” Last October Chilean prosecutors pressed charges against six
executives of state energy company ENAP in relation to the pollution crisis in 2018. But Cristian Muga, an

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 4/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK
attorney who represents ENAP workers, told Reuters: “It’s not fair to hold them responsible for a situation that
has been going on for years and that is the result of many activities taking place on the bay.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Credit Getty Images / PABLO VERA / Contributor

In part, the communities have been too weak to fight back against the economic power. “The sacrifice zones only
happen to vulnerable communities. They don't have any capacity to fight or to flee, they just have to stay there,”
Ortúzar adds.
Chile is still extremely reliant on these industries. Codelco is responsible for 11 per cent of the world's copper.
China is one of the biggest importers of Chilean copper, and around 60 per cent of total global copper demand is
for electrics; it’s in our household wiring, our plumbing
Forty per cent of the energy produced and consumed in Chile comes from burning coal, and the 28
thermoelectric plants that generate this energy are located in five locations across the country – in the sacrifice
zones. “The energy of the whole country depends on these terrible sacrifice zones where very few people live
that don’t have any capacity to fight back, they are poor, vulnerable. There is no way they are going to stop these
plants that are keeping the country alive,” says Ortúzar.
But it’s not an issue isolated to this small part of the Chilean coast; many of the businesses in Quintero-
Puchuncaví are foreign-owned: Aes Gener, which owns the Ventanas thermoelectric complex, is a subsidiary of
American company Aes. Enel, which owns a thermoelectric plant, is Italian. The coal that ends up washing on the
shores is imported from Colombia, Australia and the US.
People living thousands of miles away are bearing the brunt of larger environmental footprints. Per capita
carbon emissions in Chile are currently five metric tons, less than a third of those for the United States. “It is a
global issue. These are foreign companies destroying lives. Many of these companies have announced their
‘greenness’ internationally but they have their little sins here.” says Ortúzar.

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 5/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK
Quintero’s residents have been facing this long and complicated battle for years, but in some ways their needs
are simple. “It’s not realistic to think that the whole industrial park will close – there’s too much involved. What
we want is better ventilation, that the companies reinvest their money into making improvements to their
facilities or machinery, and to invest in the town,” say Astudillo.
They hope they can use the momentum of the social uprising and protests to highlight their plight. But it’s hard
to know what justice will really look like when the stakes are so high. “The state’s negligence is the main reason
for all this,” says Araya. “We are a sick population because the whole environment is sick: the air, land, water.”
Araya’s daughter died of cancer eight years ago at the age of 21. She was diagnosed with a brain tumour, and died
after what Araya says was just a 27-day-long illness. Now Araya focuses her fight on health services,
campaigning to bring in specialists to the hospitals, ensuring families can get all the information and the right
doctors they need when people get sick.
Despite her activism, she still struggles with the idea that her daughter’s cancer may have been related to
contamination in Quintero. “I would prefer to think that she was an exceptional case. I realise there are many
other cases that have developed similar types of cancer, so it would make sense, but,” she pauses, “it is fuel for
the fight.”

Digital Society is a digital magazine exploring how technology is changing society. It's produced as a
publishing partnership with Vontobel, but all content is editorially independent. Visit Vontobel Impact
for more stories on how technology is shaping the future of society.

More great stories from WIRED

🏙 A huge Airbnb scam is taking over London
🚙 Thinking of buying an electric car? Read this first
🍅 Why do modern tomatoes taste so bad?
ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

📢 How Slack ruined work

👉 Follow WIRED on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and LinkedIn

Get The Email from WIRED, your no-nonsense briefing on all the biggest stories in technology, business and science. In your inbox every
weekday at 12pm sharp.

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 6/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK

Enter email address SIGN UP

by entering your email address, you agree to our privacy policy

DIGITAL SOCIETY WITH VONTOBEL SCIENCE ENVIRONMENT

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECOMMENDED

Startups are reimagining the future of city life

In partnership with MINI
Promotion 13 Nov 2019

ADVERTISEMENT How Citymapper deals with the chaos of the world's cities
By VICTORIA TURK
Work Smarter 4 days ago

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 7/8
2/24/2020 The brutal reality of life inside one of the world's most polluted cities | WIRED UK

The odd reality of life under China's Orwellian propaganda app

By AMY HAWKINS
China 16 Apr 2019

The odd reality of life under China's social rating system

By CHARLES ROLLET
Privacy 05 Jun 2018

ADVERTISEMENT

Privacy policy and cookie statement

Cookie preferences

Code of Conduct

Terms & conditions

Careers

Contact

© Condé Nast Britain 2020

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/chile-quintero-pollution 8/8