1.

Jose loaned a sack of rice from Maria to be returned after a month for the purpose of exhibiting it in
their store. Is the loan a commodatum or mutuum? Explain. (5pts)
2. Pepe and Paolo agreed in a contract of commodatum, wherein Pepe will let Paolo use his car for
fetching his children in school until the end of the month. Later, Paolo contended that he already
owns the car because ownership has been transferred to him. Is the contention of Paolo correct?
Why? 5pts
3. Josefa lent his car to Pablo with the agreement that she can demand the return of the car at any time
on her own will. What kind of contract of commodatum was agreed? Explain. 5pts
4. Julie and Joe agreed in a contract of commodatum that Julie will lend her car to Joe until June 5, 2020
in order to be used as a family only. However, Joe used it as a Grab car to ferry passenger for a fare.
The car was destroyed by the lava of Mt. Pinatubo on May 2020. Julie asked for the price of the car
and damages from Joe, however, Joe asserted that she is not liable because the loss was through a
natural calamity. 10pts
5. The bailee cannot retain the object borrowed from the bailor, except what situation? Explain. 10pts

1. Jose loaned a sack of rice from Maria to be returned after a month for the purpose of exhibiting it in
their store. Is the loan a commodatum or mutuum? Explain. (5pts)
2. Pepe and Paolo agreed in a contract of commodatum, wherein Pepe will let Paolo use his car for
fetching his children in school until the end of the month. Later, Paolo contended that he already
owns the car because ownership has been transferred to him. Is the contention of Paolo correct?
Why? 5pts
3. Josefa lent his car to Pablo with the agreement that she can demand the return of the car at any time
on her own will. What kind of contract of commodatum was agreed? Explain. 5pts
4. Julie and Joe agreed in a contract of commodatum that Julie will lend her car to Joe until June 5, 2020
in order to be used as a family only. However, Joe used it as a Grab car to ferry passenger for a fare.
The car was destroyed by the lava of Mt. Pinatubo on May 2020. Julie asked for the price of the car
and damages from Joe, however, Joe asserted that she is not liable because the loss was through a
natural calamity. 10pts
5. The bailee cannot retain the object borrowed from the bailor, except what situation? Explain. 10pts

1. Jose loaned a sack of rice from Maria to be returned after a month for the purpose of exhibiting it in
their store. Is the loan a commodatum or mutuum? Explain. (5pts)
2. Pepe and Paolo agreed in a contract of commodatum, wherein Pepe will let Paolo use his car for
fetching his children in school until the end of the month. Later, Paolo contended that he already
owns the car because ownership has been transferred to him. Is the contention of Paolo correct?
Why? 5pts
3. Josefa lent his car to Pablo with the agreement that she can demand the return of the car at any time
on her own will. What kind of contract of commodatum was agreed? Explain. 5pts
4. Julie and Joe agreed in a contract of commodatum that Julie will lend her car to Joe until June 5, 2020
in order to be used as a family only. However, Joe used it as a Grab car to ferry passenger for a fare.
The car was destroyed by the lava of Mt. Pinatubo on May 2020. Julie asked for the price of the car
and damages from Joe, however, Joe asserted that she is not liable because the loss was through a
natural calamity. 10pts
5. The bailee cannot retain the object borrowed from the bailor, except what situation? Explain. 10pts