You are on page 1of 8

Plant Breeding 105, 33—39 (1990)

© 1990 Paul Parey Scientific Publishers, Berlin and Hamburg


ISSN 0179-9541

Institut fiir Pflanzenbau und Pflanzenziichtung,


Georg-August-Univcrsitdt, Gottingen (Germany, F.R.)

Variation of Seed Glucosinolates in Lines of Brassica napus


K. K R A L I N G , G . ROBBELEN, W . THIES, M . HERRMANN and M. R. AHMADI

With 4 figures and 2 tables

Received March 15, 1990 I Accepted March 22, 1990

Abstract The biosynthesis of the glucosinolates is far


from being clear in many details. From several
The glucosinolate (GSL) pattern of 93 resynthesized
studies it is supposed that alkenyl GSLs are
(resyn) rapeseed lines was examined over three years,
and five stable genotypes with distinct GSL profiles derived from methionin and indolyl GSEs
were identified. Typically the resyn B. napus profile from tiyptophan (UNDERBILL 1980). The al-
exhibited progoitrin as the main GSL, but contained kenyl GSLs PRO and gluconapoleiferin
sinigrin. The different GSL patterns of the four (GNL) may be produced by hydroxylation of
deviating lines are discussed with respect to the GNA and GBN, respectively. In the synthesis
proposed biosynthetic pathway. Within the resyn of indolyl GSLs, GBC seems to be the precur-
and further extensive breeding materials, screening sor of the hydroxylated, methoxylated, and
for Io'w lndolyl GSL contents resulted in finding one sulfated analogues (MGDANELL et al. 1988). In
genotype with an extremely low 4-hydroxy-gluco-
order to find also genetical evidence for these
brassicin and glucobrassicin content. Furthermore,
other lines were identified, differing over a wide
pathways, genotypes would be extremely
range of indolyl GSL contents. The values were helpful exhibiting different GSL patterns in
stable over two years. particular those with one individual GSL
dominating.
Key words: Brassica napus — resynthesized Following the identification of alleles re-
rapeseed — glucosinolate content — biosynthetic
sponsible for a reduced alkenyl GSE content in
pathway — indolyl glucosinolate — genetic stability
the Polish cultivar 'Bronowski' and their trans-
fer into breeding material, so called 00-varie-
ties, i.e. low in erucic acid content in the seed
oil and low in GSE content of their meal, were
More than 90 different glucosinolates (CSEs) released after a surprisingly short time. But in
are known up to now in the genus Brassica these 00-varieties depending upon the low total
(FENWICK et al. 1983). The main GSE groups GSE content, now the share of the^ indolyl
occurring in seeds of B. napus are alkenyl- and GSEs may reach over 50% (own unpublished
indolyl CSLs. In the seeds, gluconapin results). Genotypes with reduced indolyl GSE
(GNA), progoitrin (PRO), and glucobras- contents, therefore, received the particular at-
sicanapin (GBN) are the dominating alkenyl tention of the breeders. Since the GSE pattern
GSLs, and 4-hydroxy-glucobrassicin (4OH) is a rather uniform trait within the convention-
and glucobrassicin (GBC) are the major in- al breedmg material, a broad spectrum of
dolyl GSLs. Several investigations have shown rapeseed Unes has been analyzed, in particular
that the glucosinolate pattern in B. napus is genotypes resulting from resynthesis based on
rather uniform (ANJOU et al. 1977, ADAMS et al. divergent B. oleracea and B. campestris par-
1983). Therefore, efforts to use glucosinolate ents. This analysis revealed some GSE profiles
profiles for cultivar identification were unsuc- uncommon in B. napus. The results are de-
cessful (ADAMS et al. 1985). scribed in this paper.

a s . Copyright Clearance Cenlc," Code Statement: 01 79-954 1/90/050 1-0033$02.50/0


34 KRALING, ROBBELEN, THIES, HERRMANN and AHMADI

Materials and Methods Desulfoglucosinolates were analyzed by using a


Waters HPLG equipment, consisting of two pumps
Plant material: 93 rapeseed lines derived from ex- model 510, an autosampler 710B, a controller 721
perimental resynthesis by interspecific crosses of and an UV-detector model 441 at a wavelength
B. oleracea X B. campestris (GLAND 1982) were dril- setting of 229 nm. Data were transmitted to a Waters
led in the field in small observation plots (3.2 m'') in data module M730 and to a Gommodore G128 com-
September 1986. In each resyn line at least 5 plants puter by using a Waters M777 Data Transfer Mod-
were selfpoUinated using paper bags just before ule. Separation was carried out by using a Macherey-
flowering. The bags were removed after flowering, Nagel Nucleosil G-18 column (200 X 4 mm i.d.,
and completely mature seeds were analyzed by 5 |»m particle size) and a linear solvent gradient frotn
HPLG for their GSL contents (see Table 1). Geno- 1% to 19% acetonitrile in water over 18.5 min,
types with deviating GSL profiles were planted in followed by a linear gradient to 1 % acetonitrile over
the following two years in the same manner as in 2 min and 1.5 min at isocratic condition. The flow-
1986, but with larger plant numbers. For compari- rate was 1.8 ml/min at 35°C.
son, varietal lines were examined for their GSL The identification of glucoberteroin (BER) was
pattern. accomplished with the help of seeds from Berteroa
In order to identify genotypes with a low indolyl incana (L.) DG, which contained 62.0 //mol of this
GSL content, all B. napus germplasm of the Plant GSL (= 70% of all GSLs) per g seed. This seed
Breeding Institute of the University of Gottingen material was kindly supplied by Dr. W. Dersch,
was analyzed in the summer of 1988. Institute of Plant Physiology, Gottingen.
Prescreening for low indolyl glucosinolate con-
Analytical methods: About 200 mg seeds were tents was accomplished by using a newly developed
homogenized in a mill (modified IKA mill). GSL photometric test (TlllES 1990). In this procedure, a
extraction was carried out in polypropylene cen- red coloured coupling product of the indolyl GSLs
trifuge tubes at 75°G in a waterbath. For the first with p-diazobenzenesulfonic acid (Fluka 33490) is
extraction step the homogenized seeds were heated obtained in the presence of o-phosphoiic acid and
for 10 min in 2 ml 70% aqueous methanol and determined by usmg a multichannel photometer
200 ^(1 6mmol glucotropaeolin (GTL)/1 water as in- (Flow Laboratories, Titertek Multiskan MG) at a
ternal standard (prepared according to THIES 1988). wavelength setting of 510 nm.
After centrifugation (5 min, 2,500 X g) the pellet
was extracted a second time, using 2 ml 10% aque-
ous methanol. 500 ^l\ of the combined extracts were
pipetted on the top of a small ion-exchange column Results
containing 20 mg Sephadex DEAE-A25 in the for- Altogether 93 resyn lines were examined for
miate form. The column was washed with 2 X 1 ml their GSE pattern. Variation of the total GSE
of sodium acetate buffer (20 mmol/1; pH 4.0). Desul-
fation was achieved by 75 fd 0.5% (w/v) of purified
content and of the relative concentration of
sulfohydrolase (E.G. 3.1.6.1, type HI, Sigma individual alkenyl GSEs is shown in Table 1.
Ghemical Go.) and an incubation time of 16 h at The sinigrin (SIN) content reached a mean of
39 °G. Desulfated GSLs were eluted with 1.5 ml 3.5% and a highest value of 13.9%. PRO
water. After filtration (0.45 ^m) 70 ;(l of filtrate dominated with an average content of 51.1%,
were used for the HPLG analysis. whereas its hypothetical precursor GNA exhi-

Table 1. Alkenyl glucosinolate contents (/(mol/g seed) of 93 resyn genotypes of B. napus in 1987

Abbreviation Trivial name Side chain Gontents


Minimum Maximum Mean

SIN Sinigrin 2-Propenyl- S.0 7.6 1.9


GNA Gluconapin 3-Butenyl- 3.6 46.3 14.7
GBN Glucobrassicanapin 4-Pentenyl- 0.0 6.6 2.3
PRO Progoitrin 2-Hydroxy-3-butenyl- 2.4 36.7 28.1
GNL Gluconapoleiferin 2-Hydroxy-4-pentenyl- 0.0 2.2 0.7
ALY Glucoalyssin 5-Methylsulphinylpentenyl- 0.0 6.7 1.3

total alkenyl GSLs 10.5 127.0 83.1


Variation of Seed Glucosinolates in Lines of Brassica napus 35
% GSL

80 -

60 -

40 -

20 -

K5 H 89 H 80 H 200 H 143
Lines
Fig. 1. Glucosinolate patterns of five resyn genotypes

bited an average value of 2 6 . 8 % . Eine H89 was whereas in H 89 the hydroxylation step (for-
striking with a G N A content as high as mation of P R O ) was obviously reduced. In
8 4 . 2 % . In general, mean shares of the pent- line H 200, the pentenyl GSEs, in particular
enyl GSEs G B N , G N E , and glucoalyssin G B N and AEY, were increased. Eine K 5
( A E Y ) with 4 . 2 % , 1.3%, and 2 . 4 % , respec- represented the typical resyn B. napus profile
tively, were rather low in comparison to the with P R O as the main GSE, but also contain-
b u t e n y l GSEs. Unexpectedly low was the total ing sinigrin. Finally, the resyn line H 143 was
G S E content of line H 143 with 10.5/<mol/g found to contain a Iow total GSE content, but
seed. T h e remaining lines exhibited high total with a relative high content of indolyl GSEs
GSL contents confirming earlier results (58.2 % I). O t h e r hnes being unstable in respect
( G L A N D 1982). O u t of these 93 resyn lines 20 of their GSE profile showed strong variation of
g e n o t y p e s were selected with rather deviating individual alkenyl GSEs from year to year and
G S L profiles and tested the following year. plant to plant.
D u e t o nonreproducibihty of the parental GSE For the identification of genotj'pes with low
values of 1987 in 1988, only 14 resyn lines were indolyl GSE contents the absolute measure
carried over in 1989. The final examination of ",fnnol/g seed" was used and not the relative
these lines for their major individual GSLs concentration due to the varying amotint of the
over t h r e e years revealed five stable genotypes total GSEs in this material. Table 2 represents
with distinct GSE profiles (Fig. 1). The resyn the variation of the two analyzed indolyl GSEs
hne H 80 exhibited a higher SIN content. in resyn and breeding material. Neither in the

Table 2. Indolyl glucosinolate contents (/imol/g seed) of 93 resyn genotypes (res) and a large number of
breeding lines (bre) of B. napus in 1987

Abbreviation Trivial name Side chain Gontents


Minimum Maximum Mean

GBC Glucobrassicin 3-lndolylmethyl- 0.0 1.3 0.3 res


0.0 0.9 0.3 bre
4OH 4-Hydroxygluco- 4-Hydroxv-3-indolylmethyl- 2.3 9.7 7.6 res
brassicin 2.6 6.1 4.3 bre
36 KRALING, ROBBELEN, THIES, HERRMANN and AHMADI

resyn nor in the breeding material sources for Discussion


alleles were found conditioning sufficiently The screening of 93 resyn genotypes over three
low 4OH concentration. The resyn genotypes years finally revealed five genotypes exhibiting
all together exhibited a high level of 4OH as unusual glucosinolate patterns (Fig. 1):
compared to the conventional material. No The resyn line K 5 representing a typical
differences in the mean GBC content were high glucosinolate "resyn Brassica napus pro-
detected. Therefore, in 1988 additional germ- file" differs from the traditional breeding mate-
plasm was investigated particularly to detect rial (ROBBELEN and THIES 1980) only by a higher
material with low indolyl GSL contents. Fol- SIN content.
lowing the prescreening of ca. 850 plants by
the newly developed rapid test towards low as In the resyn line H 89 the predominant
well as high values, 80 samples were analyzed glucosinolate is GNA. Similar resyn forms
by HPEC for confirmation. With this more have been described by GLAND (1982). These
exact method one line was found exhibiting an lines exhibited normal fertility, but had only
extremely low 4OH and GBC content. Fur- 36 chromosomes. H 89 also was completely
thermore, other lines differing over a wide fertile which was demonstrated by single plant
range of indolyl GSE contents were identified. yields of more than 100 g in wide stands; but it
To examine whether the selected genotypes has been proven that this line possesses the
were stable in respect of their indolyl GSE normal diploid chromosome set of 38 chromo-
contents, the materiai was again tested under somes. GLAND et al. (1981) as well as SANG and
field conditions in 1989. Figure 2 represents SALISBURY (1988) identified such GNA profiles
the 4OH and GBC contents in 1988 and 1989 in B. campestris, too. Thus, in H 89 the
of four selected genotypes and one 00-cultivar B. campestris genes responsible for GSE-
('Eirabon'). Eine B 24 contained only biosynthesis are obviously dominating. Ac-
0.5 //mol indolyl GSEs within 1 g seed ( = cordingly, our selected line is not only charac-
0.4 % of the total GSE content), which was terized by a low level of PRO, but also by the
stable over two years. Eine WDE also exhi- lack of GNE, the hydroxylated analogue of
bited a clear reduction of the indolyl GSE GBN.
content (= 2.3% of the total GSL content) In the resyn line H 80, GNA and PRO were
compared to the cultivar 'Lirabon', whereas found as the major GSE components. Here,
hnes N C Q and E 98 exhibited higher values the hydroxylation rates for butenyl- and pent-
(7.1% and 12.5%, respectively, of the total enyl GSEs are reduced as compared to the GSE
GSL content). pattern typical for B. napus genotypes; the
Ijmol GSL / g seed
Snm of all GSLs

GSL (year)
CZ] 4OH (88)
^ 4OH (89)
CZLH GBC (88)
B i GBC (89)
B 24 WDE Lirabon NCQ E 98
Lines
Fig. 2. Range of indolyl glucosinolate content in the genotypes examined
Variation of Seed Glucosinolates in Eines of Brassica napus 37

same step, on the other hand, is enhanced in not be completely separated from gluconastur-
H 89. Further on, the SIN content in H 80 is tiin (NAS). SANG and SALISBURY (1988), did not
increased indicating that in this resyn line describe such diversity of pentenyl GSLs in
genes of both parental genomes are expressed. their cultivars, the type 1 of which contained
Up to now, such a profile has never been GBN only.
described in the literature. Considering the The resyn line H 143 had the lowest total
hydroxylation rates in K 5, H 89, and H 80, it GSL content together with a remarkably high
is striking that in the case of a reduced butenyl- relative and absolute indolyl GSL content.
hydroxylation rate also the pentenyl-hydroxy- Profiles described for low-glucosinolate lines
lation rate is correspondingly decreased. This by ADAMS et al. (1985) and SANG and SALISBURY
might indicate that only one enzyme is neces- (1988) differed from H 143 by exhibiting PRO
sary for both hydroxylation reactions. as the dominant GSL, whereas H 143 con-
In the resyn line H 200 concentrations of tained more than 50% 4OH. Therefore, this
GSLs with five C-atoms in the side chain are line should be helpful in studies analyzing of
equally increased. Not only the biosynthesis of 4OH as a repellent.
the thio-GSLs GBN and GNL, but also the Our investigation demonstrates the exist-
synthesis of the sulfinyl GSL ALY is en- ence of different alleles involved in the biosyn-
hanced. After chain elongation and the ex- thesis of GSLs in B. napus, although differ-
change of the amino acid function, the first ences in the GSL pattern between cultivars
pentenyl GSL to be expected in the biosynthe- were not found (ADAMS et al. 1983, 1985).
tic pathway (cf. Fig. 3) should be glucoberte- However, ADAMS et al. (1989) investigating
roin (BER). In accordance with the hy- swede were able to distinguish nine cultivars
pothesis, the amount of BER is also consider- by comparing the relative proportions of indi-
ably increased in the seeds of H 200: 1.9 /imol/ vidual (JSLS in medulla extracts.
g seed were detected instead of 0.2 /.imol/g Due to the low alkenyl GSL content in 00-
which are usually found in B. napus seeds. cultivars the percentual share of indolyl GSLs
However, the HPEC chromatogramme, increases and, therefore, variation of indolyl
shown in Fig. 4, demonstrates that BER can- GSL content becomes more important. Our

^ 1) 1)
^^ 3L-Metiilorimc ;^- 4U-lv

Hvdrnxv- ^' Progoitrin Gluconapoleiferin


Alkeml-GStj: 2)

14)
11 4)
1 1

Alkenvl-GSt.i Sinigrin Gluconapin Glucobrassicanapin

(-S-)
f'
— ^ Glucoibervirin
1
—>-
t"
Glucoenicin ' >• Glticobeneroin
1 >
1 1
1 4)

Y T Y
SuKnvt-GSt..! Glucoiberin Glucoraphanin Glucoalyssin
(SO-) 1 1 1
1
|4) |4)
Y' Y Y
(-SO2-) Glucocheirolin Glucoerysolin N.N.

PrommUGSU Pentenvl-GSt s
Fig. 3 . Hypothetic pathway for the biogenesis of alkenyl-glucosinolates in seeds of Brassica species. The steps
involved are: 1) chain elongation, 2) exchange of the "amino acid function" by a "glucosinolate function",
3) loss of the methyl group and introduction of a double bond, 4) oxidation
38 KRALING, ROBBELEN, THIES, HERRMANN and AHMADI

GSE content is controlled at least by three


genes (EEIN 1970) and determined by the ma-
ternal genotype rather than by the genotype of
the embryo (KONDRA and STEFANSSON 1970),
only one recessive low alkenyl type is detect-
able out of 100 F3 seeds harvested from Fi
plants. On the other hand, for the indolyl
GSEs BucHNER (1988) supposed that the hy-
droxylation of GBC to 4OH occurs in the seed
and is under the control of the embryo; but
GBC may be produced in the pods and is then
transported into the seeds. Therefore, in our
low indolyl GSE type the transport mechanism
or the hydroxylation step might be blocked
implying different selection strategies. At any
rate reduction of the total GSE content by
convential backcrossing seems to be the most
appropriate method at present. Due to the high
alkenyl GSE content of B 24, a greater popula-
tion size is necessary to screen for both GSE
types. For breeding cultivars with low total
GSE contents, the segregating population
should be prescreened by using the photo-
metric test detecting indolyl GSEs. By this
means, selected genotypes can be backcrossed
with 00-genotypes without considering the al-
kenyl GSL content.

Fig. 4. Chromatogramme obtained after HPEC sep- Zusammenfassung


aration of seed glucosinolates of the resyn line H 200
Unterschiede in den Samenglucosinolaten
von Rapslinien (B. napus)
screening for indolyl GSEs revealed a wide
range of 4OH contents from about 0.5 to Im Herbst 1987 wurden die Glucosinolatmu-
10 ^mol per g seed (Fig. 2). One lme (B 24) ster von 93 resynthetisierten (resyn) Linien be-
developed from a cross between a yellow stimmt. Die resyn Einie K 5 enthalt Sinigrin
seeded resyn genotype and a brown seeded und reprasentiert damit das typische resyn
B. napus line was found with an extremely low B. napus-Muster mit Progoitrin als Haupt-
indolyl GSE content. Meanwhile, further glucosinolat. Nach dreijahriger Prtifung wur-
studies have shown that there is no correlation den vier Einien mit abweichenden GSE-Mu-
between the traits yellow seed coat and low stern identifiziert. So zeichnen sich H 89
indolyl GSE content. Such a genotype is the durch einen hohen Gluconapingehalt und
first of its kind which has been described. In H 143 durch einen niedrigen Gesamt-GSE-
the present 00-cultivars, only aliphatic GSEs Gehalt aus. Die resyn Einie H 80 weist einen
are reduced by alleles derived from the cultivar hohen Sinigringehalt auf, und in H 200 waren
'Bronowski'. Therefore, the usual OO-forms die Pentenyl-GSEe erhoht. Die verschiedenen
are characterized by a rather high amount of GSE-Muster werden in bezug auf den bisher
indolyl GSEs, since these GSEs become in- noch hypothetisehen Biosyntheseweg dis-
creasingly important the more the alkenyl kutiert.
GSEs are eliminated. Our line B 24 will be Im ersten Ansatz blieb eine umfangreiche
most helpful for further reduction of the total Auslese auf niedrige Indolyl-GSE-Gehalte er-
GSE content in rapeseed cultivars. However, folglos. In weiteren Untersuehungen wurde
genetic studies are necessary to develop ap- jedoch ein Genotyp gefunden, der uber zwei
propriate breeding strategies. Since the alkenyl Jahre extrem niedrige 4-Hydroxy-Glucobras-
Variation of Seed Glucosinolates in Lines of Brassica napus 39

sicin- und Glucobrassicin-Gehalte aufwies. , G. ROBBELEN, and W. TllIES, 1981: Variation


Zusatzlich konnten weitere Einien mit ver- of alkenyl glucosinolates in seeds of Brassica
species. Z. Pfianzenzuchtg. 87, 96—110.
schiedenen Indolyl-GSE-Gehalten nach-
KONDRA, Z . P., and B. R. STEEANSSON, 1970: In-
gewiesen werden. heritance of the major glucosinolates of rapeseed
(Brassica napus) meal. Can. J. Plant Sci. 50,
Support of this work by the Bundesministerium fiir 643—647.
Ernahrung, Landwirtschaft und Forsten (BMFL), LEIN, K.-A., 1970: Quantitative Bestimmungs-
Bonn, and the Gemeinschaft zur Forderung der tnethoden fiir Samenglucosinolate in Brassica-kv-
privaten deutschen landwirtschaftlichen Pflanzen- ten und ihre Anwendung in der Ziichtung von
zliehtung (GFP), Bonn, is gratefully acknowledged. glucosinolatarmem Raps. Z. Pflanzenziichtg. 63,
137—145.
MCDANELL, R . , W . J . MCLEAN, A. B. HANLEY, R .
K. HEANEY, and G. R. FENWICK, 1988: Chemical
and biological properties of indole glucosinolates
(glucobrassicins): A review. Food Chem. Toxic.
References 26, 59—70.
ROBBELEN, G., and W. THIES, 1980: Variation in
ADAMS, H . , J. G. VAUGMAN, and C. R. FENWICK, rapeseed glucosinolates and breeding for improved
1985: The limited chemotaxonomic value of quality. In: S. TsUNODA, K. HlNATA, and C.
glucosinolates for cultivar identification in Brassica GOMEZ-CAMPO (eds.), Brassica Crops and Wild
napus E. var. oleifera (Metzg.). Z. Pfianzenzuchtg. Allies, 285—299. Japanese Sci. Soc. Press, Tokyo.
95, 97—102. SANG, J. P., and P. A. SALISBURY, 1988: Glucosino-
, , and , 1989: The use of glucosino- late profiles of international rapeseed lines (Brassica
lates for cultivar identification in Swede, Brassica campestris). J. Sci. Food Agric. 45, 255—261.
napus L. var. napobrassica (E.) Peterm. J. Sci. Food THIES, W . , 1988: Isolation of sinigrin and gluco-
Agric. 46, 319—324. tropaeolin from cruciferous seeds. Fat Sci. Tech-
, , R. K. HEANEY, and G. R. FENWICK, nol. 90, 311—314.
1983: Relative glucosinolate contents of rapeseed , 1990: Photometric determination of indolyl
seed and seedlings. Eucarpia Crueiferae Newsletter glucosinolates in seeds of rapeseed. Fat Sci. Tech-
8, 50—51. nol. 92, 161—164.
A N J O U , K . , B . LONNERDAL, B . UPPSTROM, and P. UNDERHILL, E. W . , 1980: Glucosinolates. In: E. A.
A M A N , 1977: Composition of seeds from some BELL and B. CHARLWOOD (eds.). Secondary Plant
Brassica cultivars. Swedish J. agric. Res. 7, Products. Enzyclop. Plant Physiol. New Series
169—178. Vol. 8, 493—511. Springer Veriag, Berlin —
BuCHNER, R., 1988: Analyse und Biologie der Heidelberg — New York.
Glucosinolate in Raps (Brassica napus E.). Diss.,
FB Agrarwiss., Universitat Gottingen, 111 pp.
F E N W I C K , G . R . , R . K . HEANEY, and W. J. MUL- Authors' addresses: Dr. K. KRALING, Prof. Dr. G.
LIN, 1983: Glucosinolates and their breakdown ROBBELEN, Prof. Dr. W. THIES, Dipl.-Biol. M.
products in food plants. CRC Critical Rev. Food HERRMANN, Institut fiir pflanzenbau und Pflanzen-
Sci., Nutr. 18, 123—201. ziichtung, Universitat, Von-Siebold-Str. 8, D-3400
G L A N D , A., 1982: Gehait und Muster der Gottingen (Germany, F.R.); Dr. M. R. AHMADI,
Glucosinolate in Samen von resynthetisierten Raps- Seed and Plant Improvement Institute (S.P.I.I.),
formen. Z. Pfianzenzuchtg. 88, 242—254. Mard-Abad Avenue, Karadj (Iran).

You might also like