You are on page 1of 6

Geriatr Gerontol Int 2009; 9: 75–80

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Impact of low cost strength


training of dorsi- and plantar
flexors on balance and functional
mobility in institutionalized
elderly people
Fernando Ribeiro,1 Fantina Teixeira,2 Gabriela Brochado2 and José Oliveira1
1
Research Centre in Physical Activity, Health and Leisure, Faculty of Sport, University of Porto, Porto,
and 2Physiotherapy Department, Health School of Vale do Sousa, Gandra, Portugal

Aim: To evaluate the effects of a low cost strength training program of the dorsi- and
ankle plantar flexors on muscle strength, balance and functional mobility, in elderly
institutionalized subjects; and to determine the association between strength gain and
balance and/or functional mobility gain.
Methods: Forty-eight volunteers were recruited and equally divided into two groups:
intervention (aged 78.44 1 3.84 years) and control (aged 79.78 1 3.90 years). Both groups
were tested at baseline and outcome for ankle dorsi- and plantar flexors muscle strength,
balance and functional mobility. The intervention group participated in a 6-week program,
three-sessions-per-week, of resisted ankle dorsi- and plantar flexion exercises using elastic
bands.
Results: In the intervention group, maximal isometric dorsi- (from 8.4 1 0.45 to
12.6 1 0.95 kg; P 2 0.001) and plantar flexors strength (from 13.0 1 0.85 to 17.5 1 0.93 kg;
P 2 0.001), balance (from 14.6 1 0.54 to 22.3 1 1.81 cm; P 2 0.001) and functional mobility
(from 18.4 1 0.51 to 11.0 1 0.66 s; P 2 0.001) increased significantly after the 6-week
strength training program. In the control group, no significant differences were detected.
In the intervention group, a significant correlation between plantar flexor strength gain and
balance gain was found (r = 0.826; P = 0.01).
Conclusion: The proposed low cost strength training of dorsi- and plantar flexors
improved strength, balance and functional mobility in institutionalized elderly people;
moreover, the improvement in plantar flexor strength was associated with the improve-
ment in balance.

Keywords: ankle, balance, elderly, functional mobility, strength.

Introduction
Accepted for publication 3 November 2008.
Decreased mobility among older people is often related
Correspondence: Mr Fernando Ribeiro MSc, Research Centre in to a combination of impairments in balance, gait and
Physical Activity, Health and Leisure, Faculty of Sport, Rua
lower limb strength, which are also risk factors for falls
Dr. Plácido Costa, 91; 4200-450 Porto, Portugal. Email:
fernando.silva.ribeiro@gmail.com and dependency in activities of daily living.1–3
All authors designed and performed the research and contrib- In old aged people, muscle weakness due to sarcope-
uted to manuscript redaction. nia is responsible for the development of frailty and

© 2009 Japan Geriatrics Society doi: 10.1111/j.1447-0594.2008.00500.x 兩 75


F Ribeiro et al.

significant disability.4,5 Especially in institutionalized Table 1 Description of subjects (values are


elderly subjects, muscle strength can deteriorate to a mean 1 standard deviation)
point where it becomes critical for independence of
transfers and walking.6 Because strength loss is associ- Intervention group Control group
ated with functional decline, falls and need for health Age (years) 78.44 1 3.84 79.78 1 3.90
care, improving strength might improve outcomes. The Height (cm) 165 1 6 167 1 5
published work suggests that lower limb strength Weight (kg) 73.6 1 4.94 75.2 1 3.60
improvement is associated with mobility task improve-
ment, in areas such as gait, gait speed, transfers, stoop-
ing, stair climbing and chair rise performance.7 Strength
training exercises seem to play a key role in preventing control subjects continued their normal activities. The
falls among older adults, with several authors suggesting characteristics of the subjects regarding chronological
that the participation of elderly subjects in strength age, weight and height are presented in Table 1.
training programs increases muscle mass and Participants were ambulatory and did not use walking
strength,8–10 dynamic balance,8 therefore reducing the aids, did not have any medical history of lower back or
risk of falls7,8,11 and reducing the incidence of lower extremity pathology, any diagnosed vestibular or
osteoporotic fractures.8 central nervous system pathology, postural hypotension
With the growing aging population, the number of or cognitive impairment severe enough to interfere with
falls will likely increase in coming years. Therefore, the ability to follow instructions, or any other medical
there it is necessary to develop and implement low cost, conditions that may have affected their ability to partici-
time-efficient, exercise intervention programs targeting pate in the study.
particular muscle groups in order to increase strength, The study was approved by the local ethics commit-
functional mobility and balance in older adults and, tee. All participants provided written informed consent
subsequently, to decrease the risk of falls. Moreover, in and all procedures were conducted according to the
a recent review concerning the efficacy of resistance Declaration of Helsinki.
training on balance in older adults, Orr et al.12 suggested
that it could be more prudent to center the strength
Strength assessment
training on specific muscles essential to balance, such
as the hip abductors and adductors, knee flexors and A dynamometer (Globus Ergometer, Globus, Codogne,
extensors and ankle plantar flexors and dorsiflexors, Italy) was used to assess the maximal isometric strength
than provide whole-body or lower extremity strength of the ankle plantar flexors and ankle dorsiflexor
training. In this sense, the purpose of this study was muscles. Maximal isometric strength was assessed in
to evaluate the effects of a low cost strength training each subject’s dominant limb, defined as the limb used
program of the ankle plantar flexors and dorsiflexors on to kick a ball, which was the right limb in all partici-
muscle strength, balance and functional mobility, in pants. Ankle plantar flexor muscle strength was tested
elderly institutionalized subjects. Additionally, it was with the subject in the supine position with the hip and
also our objective to determine the association between knee extended and the ankle in neutral dorsiflexion.
muscle strength gain and balance and/or functional Ankle dorsiflexor muscle strength was tested with the
mobility gain. subject in a “long” sitting position with the hip flexed
70–80°, the knee extended and the ankle in neutral
plantar flexion.13 The subject was asked to dorsiflex and
Methods plantar flex the ankle actively as a warm-up. One prac-
tice trial was given prior to testing for each movement.
Subjects
The mean of the three measurements was used for data
Forty-eight institutionalized volunteers who were analysis. Each trial lasted 5 s so the subjects could be
70 years of age or older (range, 72–87 years) were instructed to increase their strength to maximum over
recruited to participate in this study and divided into that period. Instructions were standardized for each test,
two groups: intervention and control. The intervention and the digital display on the dynamometer was covered
group was composed of 24 older adults, seven men and to minimize experimenter bias. Strength assessment was
17 women. The control group was composed of 24 performed in all subjects by the same examiner with the
older adults, nine men and 15 women, who did not same instrument.
want to participate in the strength training program.
Both groups were tested at baseline and outcome for
Balance and functional mobility assessment
ankle dorsiflexor and plantar flexor muscle strength,
balance and functional mobility, but only the inter- Balance was assessed using the Functional Reach Test
vention group received strengthening exercises while (FRT) and functional mobility was assessed using the

76 兩 © 2009 Japan Geriatrics Society


Strength, balance and functional mobility

Timed Up and Go Test (TUG). Before the assessments, identified the strength of the resistance applied. Partici-
the subjects were asked to perform two TUG and FRT pants were started at a Theraband color for each muscle
practice trials in order to familiarize themselves with the that was consistent with their initial strength capacity.
assessment procedures. Subjects used the same shoes in The starting level of Theraband was determined by
the two assessment moments. finding the point at which the participant could perform
The FRT is a performance-based test that measures 6–8 repetitions of the exercise with good quality (e.g.
the maximal distance an individual who is standing can full range of motion, no substitution with other muscle
reach forward while the feet are in a fixed position. A groups) before fatigue. The participant exercised three
level yardstick was secured to a wall at the height of times per week, progressing to 3 sets of 10 repetitions
the participant’s acromion process, and the participant for each exercise. Once the participant could perform 3
raised his or her dominant arm to approximately 90° of sets of 10 easily with a given color of elastic band, the
shoulder flexion. Participants were asked to reach as far resistance was increased by replacing the elastic band
forward as possible without raising their heels, taking a with the next color. During the course of the 6-week
step or touching the wall. The starting and final posi- intervention, the physiotherapist used these guidelines,
tions were denoted relative to the yardstick so that a coupled with his clinical knowledge, to determine the
reaching distance could be attained. Distance reached appropriate time for and amount of increased resistance
was attained by taking the average of three trials.14 for each participant.
To measure the TUG, subjects were given verbal
instructions to stand up from a chair, walk 3 m as
Data analysis
quickly and as safely as possible, cross a line marked on
the floor, turn around, walk back and sit down. The All data was analyzed using SPSS ver. 13.0 (SPSS,
time taken for subjects to rise from a chair, walk 3 m, Chicago, IL, USA) statistical software. Average values
turn and return to the chair was measured (in sec- are given mean 1 standard deviation. An independent
onds).15 Time taken was attained by taking the average Student’s t-test was performed to compare: mean age,
of three trials. mean weight, mean height, baseline and final muscle
strength, balance and functional mobility between the
intervention group and control group; the mean per-
Strength training program
centage of isometric muscle strength gain between ankle
The strength training program was initiated within dorsi- and plantar flexor muscles; and the mean per-
2 days of baseline testing. Intervention group subjects centage of gain in balance with the gain in functional
were supervised by a physiotherapist in a 6-week mobility. To test mean differences between moments in
program, three-sessions-per-week, of resisted ankle the measures of muscle strength, balance and functional
dorsiflexion and ankle plantar flexion exercises using mobility, a paired Student’s t-test was used. Pearson’s
elastic bands (Theraband, Hygenic Corporation, Akron, correlation coefficient was calculated to assess if
OH, USA). Each session lasted for approximately strength gain was associated with improvement in
15 min and included a 5-min warm-up and 5-min cool- balance and/or in functional mobility. The level of sig-
down. Elastic resistance for each participant was sys- nificance was set at P = 0.05.
tematically increased during the 6-week program. The
control subjects were asked not to initiate any new exer- Results
cise program during the 6-week period. Within 2 days
of the end of the intervention/control period, all sub- All 48 subjects successfully completed the study. At
jects were retested for post-test measures of strength, baseline, no significant differences were detected
balance and functional mobility. between groups in any of the variables. In the interven-
This progressive resistance exercise program incorpo- tion group, mean maximal isometric strength and mean
rated the physiological principles of overload and speci- values of FRT and TUG increased significantly after
ficity and was consistent with the American College of the 6-week strength training program. However, in the
Sports Medicine guidelines for strength training. The control group, there were no significant differences in
exercises were designed to improve lower extremity strength, balance and functional mobility. At the end of
strength at slow velocities of movement. After a 5-min the strength training program, the intervention group
warm-up consisting of gentle stretching and marching performed significantly better in FRT and TUG and
in place, each participant was systematically positioned expressed higher isometric muscle strength than the
to perform exercises for ankle dorsiflexor and ankle control group (Table 2).
plantar flexor muscles. Figure 1 shows the mean gain induced by the
Therabands, a color-coded series of elastic bands strength training program in the intervention group. No
with varying tensions, were used to provide progressive significant differences were found in the isometric
resistance to the muscles. Different Theraband colors muscle strength gain when comparing muscle groups.

© 2009 Japan Geriatrics Society 兩 77


F Ribeiro et al.

Table 2 Muscle strength, balance (FRT) and functional mobility (TUG) before and after the strength training
program period in both groups

Intervention group Control group


Before After Before After
Dorsiflexors (kg) 8.4 1 0.45 12.6 1 0.95* 8.5 1 0.53 8.4 1 0.52**
Plantar flexors (kg) 13.0 1 0.85 17.5 1 0.93* 12.4 1 0.73 11.7 1 0.62**
FRT (cm) 14.6 1 0.54 22.3 1 1.81* 14.6 1 0.92 14.6 1 0.82**
TUG (s) 18.4 1 0.51 11.0 1 0.66* 18.9 1 1.73 19.6 1 1.08**
*Significantly different before versus after; P 2 0.001. **Significantly different between groups; P 2 0.001.

100.00 using FRT and functional mobility using TUG. These


tools are commonly available all around the world; they
80.00 are safe, reproducible and require minimal equipment
and training to be administered. Functional mobility is a
60.00 term used to refer to the balance and gait maneuvers
Mean%

used in everyday life (e.g. getting in and out of a chair,


40.00 walking, turning).15 The TUG is a simple and inexpen-
sive tool that was developed to screen functional mobil-
20.00 ity.15 Within research, the use of the TUG has increased
over the last few years, and it is recommended by several
0.00 geriatric societies when screening for risk of falling.16,17
Dorsiflexors Plantar flexors FRT TUG
The strength training program was performed in
Figure 1 Isometric muscle strength, balance (FRT) and ankle muscles (dorsiflexors and plantar flexors), because
functional mobility (TUG) gain (mean percentage) in the these muscles have a major role in the maintenance of
intervention group. Error bars are 95% confidence intervals. balance and functional mobility. In response to a pos-
tural perturbation, a human subject will slow the centre
In the same way, when comparing the gain in balance to of mass by generating muscle torque at the ankle or hip
the gain in functional mobility, no significant difference (ankle and hip strategy) or by taking a step. The primary
was observed. muscle groups used to activate these balance strategies
In the subjects participating in the strength training are the ankle dorsiflexors and plantarflexors, knee
program, a significant correlation between plantar flexor extensors and flexors, and hip abductor and adduc-
strength gain and FRT gain was found (r = 0.826; tors.12 In stance, a subject seems to responds to large
P = 0.01); 68.2% of the FRT gain was explained by the external postural perturbations through hip strategy,
strength gain of the plantar flexors. and to smaller perturbations through ankle strategy.18
The ankle strategy requires adequate ankle muscle force
Discussion to correct the postural sway and to keep the centre of
mass located above the foot.19,20 A crucial role seem to
The proposed low cost strength training of dorsi- and be played by the ankle dorsiflexors, as they stop back-
plantar flexors induced significant improvement in ward movement produced by a destabilizing movement,
muscle strength, balance and functional mobility. lift the forefoot and contribute to the creation of a
Moreover, it was found that strength gain of the plantar counter-movement that helps to re-equilibrate the
flexors was significantly associated with gain in balance. body.21 Older adults with a history of falls have less
This program was a low cost, because it required than half of the knee and ankle strength of non-falling
minimal equipment, minimal facilities and minimal subjects. The strength decline is more pronounced in
staff. The program was simple and no specific and/or the ankle than in the knee; and at the ankle such a
expensive installations and/or equipment was required. decline is even greater in the dorsiflexor muscles.22–24
It was also time-efficient, as it only took approximately Ankle dorsiflexion strength is a significant and indepen-
15 min to perform the entire program. In our opinion, dent predictor of sit-to-stand performance,25 and
this low-technology, progressive resistive exercise strongly associated with balance and functional ability.26
program can be implemented in almost all elderly insti- Compared to other muscles of the lower limb, the dorsi-
tutions under the supervision of a rehabilitation team. flexors seem to be the best predictor of falls in
Given the wide variety of balance-demanding tasks older people;13,27 moreover, ankle dorsiflexor and ankle
required in daily life, it was decided to evaluate balance plantar flexor muscle strength help to differentiate

78 兩 © 2009 Japan Geriatrics Society


Strength, balance and functional mobility

between elders who had experienced multiple falls and comprised of individuals that did not want to partici-
elders who had not fallen.28 pate. This could reflect higher levels of motivation and
The aged-related modifications on motor system can health consciousness in the intervention group com-
be viewed as examples of an inevitable, genetically- pared to the control group. Future study should be
programmed process that causes both decline and randomized. Second, strength was assessed isometri-
physiological adaptation in neuromuscular function. cally and the strength program required dynamic con-
These modifications, involving the loss of cells, lead to tractions; a dynamic measurement of strength, more
the reduction in complement of motor neurons and specific for the training exercises, might have been able
muscle fibers, inducing, in turn, the reduction of muscle to show a better association between strength gain
mass and strength, especially in the lower limbs.29 and balance and/or functional mobility gain. Third, the
However, participation in a regular exercise program is number of male subjects that participated in the study
an effective intervention/modality to reduce or preven was small and did not allow a subanalysis by sex. Future
t a number of functional declines associated with aging.8 studies should take into consideration these limitations.
The low cost strength training program of the ankle In conclusion, the results of the present study show
plantar flexor and dorsiflexor muscles used in this study that the proposed low cost strength training of dorsi-
induced strength gains of significant magnitude. This and plantar flexors improved strength, balance and
data is supported by several studies30,31 that showed that functional mobility in institutionalized elderly people;
the participation of elderly subjects in strength training and that improvement in plantar flexor strength was
programs increases muscle mass and strength. Lord associated with improvement in balance.
et al.32 and Chandler et al.7 separately reported that a
10-week strengthening exercise program promoted
References
approximately the same increase in strength as reported
in the present study. It is interesting to note that the
1 Guralnik JM, Ferrucci L, Simonsick EM, Salive ME,
present results are similar to those reported by Krebs Wallace RB. Lower-extremity function in persons over
et al.9 in a 6-month study of elastic band resistance the age of 70 years as a predictor of subsequent disability.
training at least three times a week. Indeed, short-term N Engl J Med 1995; 332: 556–561.
(8–10-week) exercise programs that have targeted the 2 Myers AH, Young Y, Langlois JA. Prevention of falls in the
lower extremities resulted in significant improvements elderly. Bone 1996; 18 (Suppl 1): S87–S101.
3 Tinetti ME. Clinical practice. Preventing falls in elderly
in strength and balance among older adults.33,34 persons. N Engl J Med 2003; 348: 42–49.
The strength training program used in this study 4 Fried LP, Tangen CM, Walston J et al. Frailty in older
induced significant balance and functional mobility adults: evidence for a phenotype. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med
improvement, which in turn may confer a modest Sci 2001; 56: M146–M156.
degree of protection from injurious falls among these 5 Bortz WM 2nd. A conceptual framework of frailty:
a review. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2002; 57: M283–
institutionalized older adults. The improvement in M288.
balance and functional mobility is not unexpected, 6 Bautmans I, Van Hees E, Lemper JC, Mets T. The
because, as explained earlier in the discussion, the ankle feasibility of Whole Body Vibration in institutionalised
muscles have a major role in the maintenance of balance elderly persons and its influence on muscle performance,
and functional mobility. Human subjects respond to balance and mobility: a randomised controlled trial
[ISRCTN62535013]. BMC Geriatr 2005; 5: 17.
postural disturbances primarily through movement at 7 Chandler JM, Duncan PW, Kochersberger G, Studenski S.
the ankles and hips (ankle and hip strategy); however, Is lower extremity strength gain associated with improve-
sufficient strength in the ankle muscles is required ment in physical performance and disability in frail,
to perform adequately the ankle strategy of postural community-dwelling elders? Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1998;
control.18 79: 24–30.
8 American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand.
Plantar flexor strength gain explained 68.2% of the Exercise and physical activity for older adults. Med Sci
FRT gain. Better balance, expressed by FRT values, Sports Exerc 1998; 30: 992–1008.
could in part be explained by improvement of plantar 9 Krebs DE, Jette AM, Assmann SF. Moderate exercise
flexor muscle strength. The strength gain of this muscle improves gait stability in disabled elders. Arch Phys Med
group contributed to the explanation of the score on the Rehabil 1998; 79: 1489–1495.
10 Breen L, Stewart CE, Onambélé GL. Functional benefits of
test (i.e. FRT) that measured the distance that an indi- combined resistance training with nutritional interventions
vidual who is standing can reach forward while the feet in older adults: a review. Geriatr Gerontol Int 2007; 7: 326–
are in a fixed position, because this test requires con- 340.
trolled contractions of the plantar flexors to ensure 11 Mecagni C, Smith JP, Roberts KE, O’Sullivan SB. Balance
balance while the subject tries to perform maximally on and ankle range of motion in community-dwelling women
aged 64 to 87 years: a correlational study. Phys Ther 2000;
the test. 80: 1004–1011.
Our study had some limitations. First, all of the 12 Orr R, Raymond J, Fiatarone Singh M. Efficacy of progres-
subjects were volunteers and the control group was sive resistance training on balance performance in older

© 2009 Japan Geriatrics Society 兩 79


F Ribeiro et al.

adults: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. 25 Lord SR, Murray SM, Chapman K, Munro B, Tiedemann
Sports Med 2008; 38: 317–343. A. Sit-to-stand performance depends on sensation, speed,
13 Daubney ME, Culham EG. Lower-extremity muscle force balance, and psychological status in addition to strength in
and balance performance in adults aged 65 years and older. older people. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2002; 57: M539–
Phys Ther 1999; 79: 1177–1185. M543.
14 Duncan PW, Weiner DK, Chandler J, Studenski S. Func- 26 Menz HB, Morris ME, Lord SR. Foot and ankle charac-
tional reach: a new clinical measure of balance. J Gerontol teristics associated with impaired balance and functional
1990; 45: M192–M197. ability in older people. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2005; 60:
15 Podsiadlo D, Richardson S. The timed “Up & Go”: a test 1546–1552.
of basic functional mobility for frail elderly persons. J Am 27 MacRae PG, Lacourse M, Moldavon R. Physical perfor-
Geriatr Soc 1991; 39: 142–148. mance measures that predict fall status in community-
16 Sletvold O, Tilvis R, Jonsson A et al. Geriatric work-up dwelling older adults. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1992; 16:
in the Nordic countries. The Nordic approach to compre- 123–128.
hensive geriatric assessment. Dan Med Bull 1996; 43: 350– 28 Lord SR, Clark RD, Webster IW. Postural stability and
359. associated physiological factors in a population of aged
17 Guideline for the prevention of falls in older persons. persons. J Gerontol 1991; 46: M69–M76.
American Geriatrics Society, British Geriatrics Society, and 29 Vandervoort AA. Aging of the human neuromuscular
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Panel on system. Muscle Nerve 2002; 25: 17–25.
Falls Prevention. J Am Geriatr Soc 2001; 49: 664–672. 30 Frontera WR, Meredith CN, O’Reilly KP, Knuttgen HG,
18 Horak FB, Shupert CL, Mirka A. Components of postural Evans WJ. Strength conditioning in older men: skeletal
dyscontrol in the elderly: a review. Neurobiol Aging 1989; 10: muscle hypertrophy and improved function. J Appl Physiol
727–778. 1988; 64: 1038–1044.
19 Kuo AD, Zajac FE. A biomechanical analysis of muscle 31 Kalapotharakos VI, Michalopoulos M, Tokmakidis SP,
strength as a limiting factor in standing posture. J Biomech Godolias G, Gourgoulis V. Effects of a heavy and a
1993; 26 (Suppl 1): 137–150. moderate resistance training on functional performance
20 Winter DA, Patla AE, Frank JS. Assessment of balance in older adults. J Strength Cond Res 2005; 19: 652–657.
control in humans. Med Prog Technol 1990; 16: 31–51. 32 Lord SR, Caplan GA, Ward JA. Balance, reaction time,
21 Wolfson LI, Whipple R, Amerman P, Kleinberg A. Stress- and muscle strength in exercising and nonexercising older
ing the postural response. A quantitative method for women: a pilot study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1993; 74:
testing balance. J Am Geriatr Soc 1986; 34: 845–850. 837–839.
22 Whipple RH, Wolfson LI, Amerman PM. The relationship 33 Schlicht J, Camaione DN, Owen SV. Effect of intense
of knee and ankle weakness to falls in nursing home resi- strength training on standing balance, walking speed, and
dents: an isokinetic study. J Am Geriatr Soc 1987; 35: 13–20. sit-to-stand performance in older adults. J Gerontol A Biol
23 Studenski S, Duncan PW, Chandler J. Postural responses Sci Med Sci 2001; 56: M281–M286.
and effector factors in persons with unexplained falls: 34 Yates SM, Dunnagan TA. Evaluating the effectiveness
results and methodologic issues. J Am Geriatr Soc 1991; 39: of a home-based fall risk reduction program for rural
229–234. community-dwelling older adults. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med
24 Wolfson L, Judge J, Whipple R, King M. Strength is a Sci 2001; 56: M226–M230.
major factor in balance, gait, and the occurrence of falls.
J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 1995; 50: 64–67.

80 兩 © 2009 Japan Geriatrics Society

You might also like