Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A. Rustoiu S.Berecki Cultural Encounters
A. Rustoiu S.Berecki Cultural Encounters
Edited by
ERZSÉBET JEREM and WOLFGANG MEID
Series Minor
38
CULTURAL ENCOUNTERS
IN IRON AGE EUROPE
Edited by
IAN ARMIT, HRVOJE POTREBICA, MATIJA ČREŠNAR,
PHILIP MASON and LINDSEY BÜSTER
BUDAPEST 2016
Front Cover
Digital image showing detail of face of female figure on the Vače situla
(produced by Adrian Evans and Rachael Kershaw, and reproduced
courtesy and copyright of the National Museum of Slovenia
/Bradford Visualisation/ENTRANS).
Back Cover
Lidar image showing the Iron Age hillfort of Poštela near Maribor in Slovenia,
and its surrounding landscape (prepared by Dimitrij Mlekuž, and reproduced
courtesy of the Institute for the Protection of Cultural Heritage of Slovenia).
ISBN 978-963-9911-83-3
HU-ISSN 1216-6847
2016
ARCHAEOLINGUA ALAPÍTVÁNY
H-1250 Budapest, Úri u. 49.
Desktop editing and layout by Rita Kovács
Printed by Prime Rate Kft.
Contents
ALEXIS GORGUES
Trade in a liminal zone: commercial encounter and transformation
in the Iron Age north-west Mediterranean ............................................. 167
ANA DELGADO HERVÁS – MERITXELL FERRER
Feeding an emporion: gastronomies and
identities in Empúries, north Catalonia (5th century BC) ....................... 211
LOUP BERNARD
From the farm to the hillfort:
what happens to a Celt when a Greek settles at his door? ..................... 235
FABIO SACCOCCIO
The Venetic-Etruscan-Celtic encounters
in the Po River lowlands (north-eastern Italy) ....................................... 247
SIMONA MARCHESINI – ROSA RONCADOR
Celts and Raetians in the central-eastern Alpine Region during
the Second Iron Age: multidisciplinary research ................................... 267
AUREL RUSTOIU – SÁNDOR BERECKI
Cultural encounters and fluid identities
in the eastern Carpathian Basin in the 4th-3rd centuries BC ................... 285
SVETLANA SHARAPOVA
It is traced on bone: social identity in bioarchaeological research
of Iron Age populations of the Trans-Urals and western Siberia ........... 305
Cultural encounters and fluid identities
in the eastern Carpathian Basin in the 4th-3rd centuries BC
Abstract
The eastern part of the Carpathian Basin experienced a process of “Celtic colonisation”
during the second half of the 4th century and at the beginning of the 3rd century BC. These
movements are indicated by cemeteries displaying specific elements of the funerary
rite, ritual and inventory. One result of this process is the appearance of some new
communities, created by the cultural amalgamation of the locals with the newcomers.
This article discusses the manner in which new identities were constructed and expressed
at both communal and individual level, as well as their degree of fluidity in particular
circumstances. The cultural interactions between newcomers and locals, and the ways
in which the social and cultural identity of individuals, groups and communities was
expressed, can be identified by analysing the information provided by funerary contexts.
These include a series of burials belonging to several representative cemeteries from this
region, like the ones at Muhi-Kocsmadomb, in eastern Hungary, Pişcolt, in north-western
Romania, Remetea Mare – Gomila lui Pituţ in Banat and Fântânele–Dâmbu Popii, in
Transylvania.
Keywords: collective identity, eastern Carpathian Basin, Late Iron Age, funerary practice,
cultural interaction
western European regions gradually advancing to the east. Their movements are
indicated by cemeteries displaying specific elements of the funerary rite, ritual
and inventory (Fig. 1). One result of this process is the appearance of some new
communities, created by the cultural amalgamation of locals with the newcomers.
These groups of ‘colonists’ were ethnically and even tribally heterogeneous,
consisting of individuals originating from different communities and regions,
and this is shown by the diversity of their personal objects, costumes, practices
etc. At the same time, the local communities consisted of people with different
ethnic and cultural origins (mainly indigenous and north-Pontic); these already
experienced another process of cultural hybridisation at the end of the Early Iron
Age. Consequently, the manner in which the new communities of the Late Iron
Age constructed and expressed their identity is very diverse (e.g. RUSTOIU 2008,
69–70, fig. 27; ALMÁSSY 2010; RUSTOIU 2012; 2014). This article discusses the
manner in which new identities were constructed and expressed at both communal
and individual level, as well as their degree of fluidity in particular circumstances.
The cultural interactions between incomers and locals, and the ways in
which the social and cultural identity of individuals, groups and communities
was expressed, can be identified by analysing the information provided by
funerary contexts. Funerals are likely to have been social events through which
the mourners expressed and reiterated the status of the family or of the social
group, while also informing, more-or-less formally, the wider community about
their social or familial connections (Fig. 2). As such, the nature of the funerary
assemblage may reveal the strategy employed by mourners seeking to build and
preserve the memory of the deceased and to perpetuate their identity (WILLIAMS
Age see RAMSL 2003; 2015). Some relatively recent studies point to the fact that a
single ‘theory of colonialism’ or “model of colonization” cannot be drawn (DIETLER
2005, 54–55). Such models and their effects are different according to the historical,
cultural or social frameworks in which the respective communities evolved (see for
example the three main types of encounters proposed in GOSDEN 2004). At the same
time the ‘colonisation’ cannot be regarded as a simple movement from one territory to
another, as it presumes a diverse range of interactions between the ‘colonists’, having
their own personal and group identities and agendas, seeking to impose their own
norms, habits and ideology, and the ‘colonized’ who also have specific identities and
are either exerting various forms of resistance, or are expressing a degree of openness
towards integration in the newly built communal structures (GIVEN 2004). These
diverse interactions are contributing to the transformation of individual and group
identities, leading to the creation of some new ones through ‘creolization’ or cultural
‘hybridization’ and even through the re-invention of some traditions etc.
Cultural encounters and fluid identities in the eastern Carpathian Basin 287
Fig. 1. The advance of Celtic groups towards the eastern Carpathian Basin, showing
cemeteries beginning in the La Tène B1/B2 (circles) and La Tène B2 (dots) periods
(after RUSTOIU 2008). Cemeteries cited in text: 1. Muhi-Kocsmadomb;
2. Pişcolt; 3. Remetea Mare; 4. Fântânele-Dâmbu Popii
2003, 10; WELLS 2007, 472–474; RAMSL 2014a, 201–203, fig. 18.1/b; 2014b, 71,
fig. 1).
An analysis of the cemeteries from eastern Hungary and Transylvania indicates
that, although the Celtic arrival resulted in the cultural reconfiguration of these
regions, the interactions between the colonists and the indigenous populations
differed from one community to another. As a consequence, a single cultural
model of these interactions cannot be defined for the entire area in question. In
some cases, the local populations preserved their traditional funerary rite and
288 Aurel Rustoiu – Sándor Berecki
Fig. 4. Fântânele-Dâmbu Popii: grave nos. 7 (1) and 1 (2), containing both indigenous
and La Tène pottery (photo: I. H. CRIŞAN)
292 Aurel Rustoiu – Sándor Berecki
Fig. 5. Pişcolt. 1. The assemblage of La Tène grave (no. 36) with weapons (belonging
to the first phase of the cemetery); 2. The assemblage of La Tène grave (no. 180)
without weapons (belonging to the first phase of the cemetery); 3–4. The assemblages of
indigenous grave nos. 198 and 203 respectively (after NÉMETI 1988).
Cultural encounters and fluid identities in the eastern Carpathian Basin 293
Fig. 6. Sanislău cemetery dating to the end of the Early Iron Age. 1. Different types of
cremation graves; 2–3. The assemblages of grave nos. 19A and 21 respectively
(after NÉMETI 1982).
294 Aurel Rustoiu – Sándor Berecki
203 from Pişcolt may be ascribed to the indigenous population. They suggest
that some locals preserved their cultural identity after Celtic colonisation, at
least in funerary contexts. The dress accessories of Celtic type from the grave
no. 203 suggest, however, the tendency of the local population to integrate into
new communities by adopting the bodily ornamentation of the newcomers. It
has to be noted that bodily ornamentation played an important symbolic role in
social communication and the visual expression of social or ethnic affiliation2
(e.g. EICHER 1995; ALDHOUSE-GREEN 2004a, 40–53; 2004b; ARNOLD 2008,
375–379; WELLS 2008, 64–84). Thus, the aforementioned contexts from Pişcolt
are relevant in questions regarding the identification of indigenous individuals,
and of relations between locals and newcomers. This is not a unique situation,
and similar examples were also identified in other cemeteries, such as Remetea
Mare, in Banat.
The cemetery from Remetea Mare – Gomila lui Pituţ, which was partially
destroyed by sand extraction, consists of 20 burials dated to La Tène B2a. With a
single exception3, these are cremation burials, with remains placed in a pit or an
urn. A series of cremation burials from this cemetery, and their associated La Tène
assemblages, points to some funerary rites and rituals specific to Central European
Celtic communities. Amongst these are graves (nos. 1, 9 and 10) with weapons,
including swords of the Hatvan-Boldog type and shields with a bi-valve boss,
typically associated with Celtic expansion at the end of the 4th century and the
beginning of the 3rd century BC (Fig. 7.1: grave no. 9). Meanwhile, grave no. 8,
which contains a rich garment assemblage (Fig. 7.2), indicates a female inventory
specific to the La Tène context (RUSTOIU – URSUŢIU 2013; MEDELEŢ ms).
Grave no. 17 stands out due to a series of elements which differ from those
encountered in funerary contexts ascribed to the Celts (Fig. 7.3). The grave
contains a cremation, with the remains placed in a lidded urn. Both the urn and
the lid belong to the local handmade repertoire. The urn contains, aside from the
2
T. S. TURNER (2012, 486) notes that “Man is born naked but is everywhere in clothes
(or their symbolic equivalents)… The surface of the body, as the common frontier of
society, the social self, and the psychobiological individual, becomes the symbolic
stage upon which the drama of socialization is enacted, and bodily adornment (in all its
culturally multifarious forms, from body-painting to clothing and from feather head-
dresses to cosmetics) becomes the language through which it is expressed”.
3
The cited exception is an inhumation grave belonging to a woman, suggesting a
matrimonial alliance between individuals from Remetea Mare and a southern Danubian
community (cf. RUSTOIU 2004–2005; 2008, 126–134; 2011, 166–168 etc.).
Cultural encounters and fluid identities in the eastern Carpathian Basin 295
Fig. 7. 1–2. Colonist graves (metal artefacts only) from the La Tène cemetery at
Remetea Mare, with and without weapons respectively; 3. Indigenous grave no. 17 from
Remetea Mare; 4. Funerary urns from the Zimnicea cemetery on the Lower Danube
(after RUSTOIU 2008; RUSTOIU – EGRI 2010;
RUSTOIU – URSUŢIU 2013; ALEXANDRESCU 1980).
296 Aurel Rustoiu – Sándor Berecki
cremated bones, three early La Tène brooches, whilst one curved and one folding
knife with a bone hilt were placed in the pit near the urn (RUSTOIU – URSUŢIU 2013,
326, fig. 12.1; MEDELEŢ MS). Both the funerary rite and the types of vessels used to
contain the cremated remains have close analogies in a series of cemeteries of the
local populations from the Lower Danube region, for example, that at Zimnicea
(Fig. 7.4; ALEXANDRESCU 1980). Consequently, the aforementioned grave may
be ascribed to an individual who was buried according to the traditional funerary
norms of the local population. However, as at Pişcolt, the dress accessories of
La Tène type point to the tendency of the locals to integrate by adopting the
costume of the Celtic colonists. Meanwhile, the remaining grave goods such as
the curved knife, which resembles a sickle, has analogies in the Alpine region,
having been brought from Central Europe to the east by colonist groups (for
analogies see RAMSL 2009, 139, 143, fig. 1). The curved shape of the knife blade
also resembles that of some domestic knives from the eastern Carpathian Basin
(e.g. SZABÓ – TANKÓ 2006, 337, fig. 9), which might have led to its adoption
and use by local people. Folding knives similar to that from Remetea Mare are
also encountered in a series of Celtic funerary contexts from central and eastern
Europe (e.g. finds from the cemeteries at Belgrade-Karaburma, Ménfőcsanak and
Chotin: TODOROVIĆ 1972, pl. 22/6, 24/7; UZSOKI 1987, pl. 10/5; RATIMORSKÁ
1981, pl. 8/6), and from the Lower Danube region (e.g. the cemetery at Zimnicea:
ALEXANDRESCU 1980, fig. 59/11). Thus, in spite of some Central European La
Tène elements, the funerary rite and ritual identified in some burials from the
Celtic cemeteries in the Carpathian Basin indicate the perpetuation of certain
funerary traditions belonging to local populations, who chose to preserve a series
of symbolic elements that allowed them to express their own identity.
One grave from the cemetery at Fântânele–Dâmbu Popii illustrates another
particular situation that differs from those already presented. The aforementioned
cemetery, dated to the La Tène B2–C1, consists of 94 burials. The funerary
rite is specific to the Central European area, but some elements of the grave
assemblages point to the cultural amalgamation of colonists with the local
communities. In only two cases did the ceramic funerary inventory consiste
exclusively of local vessels. One of them is cremation grave no. 10, where the
remains were placed in an oval pit (Fig. 8.1). The pit contained two different
compartments created by a ‘box’ made of split beams. The cremated bones were
placed in the north-western compartment, together with two handmade vessels
and two bronze brooches of early La Tène type. One handmade bowl with an
inverted rim and a meat offering were placed in the opposite compartment, along
Cultural encounters and fluid identities in the eastern Carpathian Basin 297
Fig. 8. 1. Fântânele–Dâmbu Popii: grave no. 10 with timber structure and indigenous
pottery (after RUSTOIU 2008); 2. La Tène graves with timber structures from Ludas (left)
and Malé Kosihy (right) (after TANKÓ – TANKÓ 2012 and BUJNA 1995).
298 Aurel Rustoiu – Sándor Berecki
with the curved blade of an iron knife (RUSTOIU 2008, 77–78, fig. 35; 2013, 6,
fig. 6). All of these elements of the funerary rite, including the timber structures
found in some burials, are encountered in some La Tène cemeteries from the
Middle Danube region. Amongst the examples is a cremation grave from Malé
Kosihy, in south-western Slovakia (Fig. 8.2 right; BUJNA 1995, 86–87, fig. 78),
and another from Ludas in north-eastern Hungary (Fig. 8.2 left; TANKÓ – TANKÓ
2012, 254, fig. 7). In both examples, the funerary pit included compartments
containing the cremated remains and grave goods. Lastly, the placing of knives
of different types together with meat offerings is frequently encountered in Celtic
burials from the Carpathian Basin (e.g. NÉMETI 1993, 119–120; SZABÓ – TANKÓ
2006, 337, fig. 9). Accordingly, these elements of ritual, which have analogies in
Central European La Tène contexts, suggest that grave no. 10 from Fântânele –
Dâmbu Popii may be ascribed to a Celtic colonist. In this context, local handmade
vessels from the grave assemblage may reflect the cohabitation of colonists and
indigenous populations, and the hybridisation of culinary practices.
In conclusion, the interactions between Celtic colonists and local populations
differed from one community to another. In general, the elites of the colonist
groups imposed norms of expression of individual and collective identity brought
from their homeland. This aspect is illustrated by the preservation of specific
funerary rites and rituals, and also of particular styles of bodily ornamentation
that were intended to define the social status and function of certain privileged
groups within communities. One example is the placing of panoplies of arms in
burials belonging to warriors.
Meanwhile, indigenous populations expressed different degrees of resistance
towards new identity norms imposed by the colonists. In some cases, locals
continued to practice traditional funerary rituals, with the aim of preserving
elements of an ancestral identity. In other cases, they were assimilated relatively
fast and ended by obscuring their own origin behind some symbolic elements
belonging to the newcomers. The adoption of some garment accessories of the
colonists reflects, to some extent, this process of integration.
The burials from the Pişcolt and Remetea Mare cemeteries provide relevant
examples of the manner in which indigenous people attempted to express their
own cultural identity within newly established communities. At the same time,
they also reflect processes of integration and assimilation of these individuals
within the new cultural and social environment. On the other hand, grave no. 10
from Fântânele, which belonged to a colonist, indicates the process of cultural
Cultural encounters and fluid identities in the eastern Carpathian Basin 299
Acknowledgements
References
ALDHOUSE-GREEN, M. 2004a
An Archaeology of Images. Iconology and Cosmology in Iron Age and Roman
Europe. London – New York, Routledge.
ALDHOUSE-GREEN, M. 2004b
Crowning Glories: Languages of Hair in Later Prehistoric Europe. Proceedings
of the Prehistoric Society 70, 299–325.
ALEXANDRESCU, A. D. 1980
La nécropole Gète de Zimnicea. Dacia 24, 19–126.
ALMÁSSY, K. 2010
Some new data on the Scythian-Celtic relationship. In: Jerem, E. – Schönfelder,
M. – Wieland, G. (eds), Nord-Süd, Ost-West Kontaktewährend der Eisenzeit
in Europa. Akten der Internationalen Tagungen der AG Eisenzeit in Hamburg
und Sopron 2002. 9–25. Budapest, Archaeolingua.
ARNOLD, B. 2008
“Reading the Body”: Geschlechter differenz im Totenritual der frühen
Eisenzeit. In: Kümmel, C. – Schweizer, B. – Veit, U. (eds), Körperinszenierung-
Objektsammlung-Monumentalisierung: Totenritual und Grabkult in frühen
Gesellschaften. 375–395. Münster – New York – München – Berlin,
Waxmann.
300 Aurel Rustoiu – Sándor Berecki
BUJNA, J. 1995
Malé Kosihy. Latènezeitliches Gräberfeld. Katalog. Archaeologica Slovaca
Monographiae 7. Nitra, Archeologický ústav Slovenskej akadémie vied.
COLLIS, J. 2010
The Celts. Origins, Myths & Inventions. 3rd edition. Stroud, The History Press.
CRIŞAN, I. H. 1975
La nécropole de Fîntînele et son importance pour le problème des Celtes de
l’Europe Centrale. In: Fitz, J. (ed.), The Celts in Central Europe. 185–186.
Székesfehérvár, István Király Múzeum.
DIETLER, M. 2005
The archaeology of colonization and the colonization of archaeology.
Theoretical challenges from an ancient Mediterranean colonial encounter.
In: Stein, G. J. (ed.), The Archaeology of Colonial Encounters: Comparative
Perspectives. 33–68. Santa Fe (NM), School of American Research Press.
DIETLER, M. 2006
Culinary encounters: food, identity and colonialism. In: Twiss, K. C. (ed.),
The Archaeology of Food and Identity. 218–242. Carbondale (IL), Southern
Illinois University.
EICHER, J. B. 1995
Introduction: Dress as Expression of Ethnic Identity. In: Eicher, J. B.
(ed.), Dress and Ethnicity. Change across Space and Time. 1–5. Oxford –
Washington DC, Berg.
GIVEN, M. 2004
The Archaeology of the Colonized. London, Routledge.
GOSDEN, C. 2004
Archaeology and Colonialism. Cultural Contact from 5000 BC to the Present.
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
HELLEBRANDT, M. 1999
Celtic Finds from Northern Hungary. Corpus of Celtic Finds in Hungary III.
Budapest, Akadémiai Kiadó.
MEDELEŢ, F. ms.
Necropola La Tène de la Remetea Mare (jud.Timiş). Unpublished manuscript.
MEGAW, M. R. – MEGAW, J. V. S. 1996
Ancient Celts and modern ethnicity. Antiquity 70, 175–181.
Cultural encounters and fluid identities in the eastern Carpathian Basin 301