Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Segall 2018
Segall 2018
111
112 Music Therapy: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
TABLE 8.1
Research on Music Therapy and Wellness With College Students
Author, Year Music Therapy Intervention(s) Outcomes
Montello (2010) Improvisation Decreased levels of performance-related injuries
Bittman et al. (2001) Group drumming Ability to change hormonal responses to stress
Mungas and Silverman Single-session group-based wellness Reduced stress
(2014) drumming intervention
ways in which relaxation can be found. Robb (2000) Exposure to long periods of stress can have both
compared the outcomes of four relaxation techniques physiologic and psychological consequences, such
and their ability to affect anxiety and perceived relax- as fatigue, depression, isolation, and poor nutrition
ation. The conditions examined were music-assisted (McGonigal, 2015). For students, learning methods to
PMR (M + PMR), PMR, music listening, and silence. manage their stress can create life-long coping skills.
Outcomes of the research demonstrated that each of Designing brief interventions increases the likelihood
the techniques is effective in treating anxiety and per- of student participation and the likelihood of increased
ceived relaxation, but mean score differences of the benefit from services. Even single-session interventions
M + PMR showed the greatest amount of change. can affect student levels of stress.
Music therapy can also play a role in treating the col- Mungas and Silverman (2014) implemented a single-
lege-age musician. Often, musicians experience perfor- session, group-based wellness drumming intervention
mance-related injuries. These injuries are often caused to examine its effect on the affective state of college stu-
by high levels of stress, high expectations, leaving home dents. Fifty undergraduate and graduate students repre-
for the first time, and high extracurricular demands senting various majors participated in a 45-min active
such as homework, auditions, competitions, and group drumming music making intervention (Mungas &
relationships (Montello, 2010). Music therapy plays Silverman, 2014). Students in a beginning guitar course
a unique role in addressing the needs of college-age served as the control group. Quantitative and qualitative
musicians. Through improvisation, musicians become data were collected before and after the test. Qualitative
reacquainted with their initial passion for music. responses were collected to evaluate student perceptions
Improvisation also serves to encourage spontaneous of the session’s impact and measured using the Quick
creativity, auditory discrimination, meaningful expres- Mood Scale. The Quick Mood Scale is used to measure
sion, and staying present (Montello, 2010). Additional affective states, such as drowsiness, anxiety, depression,
music therapy interventions such as musical charades, aggression, confusion, and diminished coordination.
musical self-statements, and group music improvisa- Statistical between-group differences were found at post-
tion can help meet the wellness needs of musicians. test in the areas of awake/drowsy, relaxed/anxious, cheer-
Other group interventions such as group drumming ful/depressed, friendly/aggressive, and clear-headed/
also provide wellness benefits. confused. Quantitative analysis demonstrated higher
The role of group drumming was explored to deter- posttest score means in each affect area when compared
mine its effect on the changes of stress-related hor- with the control condition. Qualitative results indicated
mones and the enrichment of particular immunologic that participants in the experimental group felt comfort-
measures for college students (Bittman et al., 2001). able during the intervention and stated an overall posi-
Inspired by evidence-based music therapy research tive experience. One participant commented that the
protocols, four experimental groups received a single- breathing activity “…helped me to relax and focus on
session group drumming intervention. The control the stress in my body” and another participant stated, “I
groups did not receive music therapy services. Results really liked the group drumming because we got to be
suggest that a music therapy group drumming inter- creative and interact as a group. There was no pressure”
vention may produce neuroendocrine or immunologic (p. 290). Group drumming interventions led by music
effects that may play a role in the overall wellness of an therapists facilitate creative, low-pressure experiences for
individual. Future research in this area should explore students to relieve stress and encourage healthy breath-
the relationship between the length of intervention and ing in a therapeutic environment (Mungas & Silverman,
duration of impact and how multiple group drumming 2014). Table 8.1 summarizes research on music therapy
interventions might affect those with chronic illness. to enhance wellness with college students.
114 Music Therapy: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
TABLE 8.2
Research on Music Therapy and Wellness With Working Professionals
Author, Year Music Therapy Intervention(s) Outcomes
Smith (2008) Single-session music therapy intervention utilizing live Self-reported lower levels of stress and tension.
music accompanied progressive muscle relaxation Increased feelings of relaxation
Lesiuk (2010) Preferred music listening Work quality and employee affect
TABLE 8.3
Research on Music Therapy to Enhance Wellness for Inmates in Correctional Facilities
Author, Year Music Therapy Intervention(s) Outcomes
Cohen (2009) Group singing Elevated levels of feeling respect, making friends, family
interactions, and fellow inmates
Cohen (2012) Group singing both within the prison and Increased levels of emotional stability, sociability, happiness,
in the community and joviality
Segall (2016) Group singing Improvement in levels of perceived stress
Silber (2005) Group music making Development of interpersonal skills, self-expression, and
self-control
with the unique stressors found within this environment. child within the past year (AARP, 2015). A caregiver
Participants in the study demonstrated diminished levels can be a parent tending to a child with disabilities, a
of stress and increased levels of relaxation and benefitted nurse caring for a patient, a teacher encouraging their
from receiving opportunities for self-expression. Group students, or a spouse supporting an aging spouse.
singing is another type of music therapy intervention that Caregiving takes many different forms and include
address wellness within this population. parents, spouses, teachers, neighbors, and even chil-
To examine the effects of well-being, two inmate dren. In fact, it is estimated that 1.4 million children
choirs were created (Cohen, 2009). Choir one com- between the ages of 8 and 18 years provide care for
prised only inmates and performed within the con- an adult relative (Family Caregiver Alliance, 2016).
fines of the correctional facility. Choir two consisted Grandparents represent most of those receiving care
of inmates and community volunteers and performed from children, and they often live in the same house-
outside prison walls. As measured by the Friedman hold (Family Caregiver Alliance, 2016). Although
Well-Being Scale, significant between-group differences these diverse caregiving roles differ outwardly, they
were found in areas of emotional stability, sociabil- have similar needs relating to physical, psychosocial,
ity, happiness, and joviality for those inmates in choir and cognitive wellness.
two. Group music-making opportunities also serve to Providing care can be such a consuming role that
enhance interpersonal skills, self-expression, and self- often the caregiver’s own wellness suffers. In addition
control. Silber (2005) initiated a multivoice choir to to spending time with his or her own family and job
present female inmates opportunities for peer relations responsibilities, the average caregiver spends an addi-
and techniques for relating to authority and exploring tional 25 h per week providing care for the recipient
self-empowerment. Group singing opportunities not (Family Caregiver Alliance, 2016). Incidence of burn-
only enhance inmate wellness, but can also translate out or compassion fatigue can result in poor nutrition,
to community wellness through changing perceptions. exhaustion, depression, and isolation. The role of the
A 12-week choral program for both inmates and caregiver can last for 1 year or 20 years depending on
community volunteers was implemented to explore the patient’s needs. For members of this population,
community members’ perceptions of inmates and caring for oneself is imperative to maintain the physical
inmates’ perceptions of their social competency (Cohen, and emotional requirements of caregiving. Many care-
2009). Inmates answered open-ended questions. givers are so accustomed to putting the needs of others
Qualitative data resulted in the identification of many first that they fail to make time for themselves (Qualls
themes relating to feelings of self-respect, creating new & Williams, 2015). Acknowledging the importance of
relationships, enhancing familiar relationships, and self-care is so important that the Web site of the Ameri-
improving relationships with fellow inmates. Table 8.3 can Association of Retired People (AARP) dedicated an
summarizes research on music therapy to enhance entire section of its Web page to resources for caregivers
wellness for inmates in correctional facilities. (AARP, 2015).
One valuable method music therapists often use
Caregivers to teach self-care to caregivers is songwriting (Klein
Approximately 43.5 million people in the United & Silverman, 2012). Using two groups of caregiv-
States have provided caregiving services to an adult or ers to explore the impact of a self-care education
116 Music Therapy: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
TABLE 8.4
Summary of Research on Music Therapy for Wellness With Caregivers
Author, Year Music Therapy Intervention(s) Outcomes
Baker et al. (2012) Active music listening, moving to music, and Improved caregiving, spousal relationships,
singing preferred songs and caregiver wellness
Klein and Silverman (2012) Songwriting Increased levels of fun and appreciation
O’Kelly (2008) Songwriting Meaningful expression, elevated levels of
health, and caregiver satisfaction
intervention, Klein and Silverman created and labeled on how to use them in the therapists’ absence. This
a discussion group and a songwriting group. Partici- allows couples the flexibility to benefit at their most
pants received both interventions (discussion and ideal time without having to wait for a music therapist.
songwriting) and condition order was randomly Listening to music together, moving to music together,
assigned. Through Linguistic Inquiry and Word and singing songs together elevate the relationship
Count, quantitative analysis identified themes of par- between couples, increase satisfaction of the caregiver,
ticipant responses in each group. Themes identified in and enhance the quality of life of the caregiver (Baker
the two groups included distraction from stress, fun, et al., 2012). In a study by Baker et al. (2012), couples
group cohesiveness, therapeutic insight, appreciation, who participated in therapist-designed treatment pro-
comments on the presentation, and reinforcement of grams reported an improvement in spousal relation-
subject matter. Only participants in the music therapy ship, an increase in satisfaction with caregiving, and an
condition reflected themes of fun and appreciation in increase in the well-being of the caregiver. The results
comparison with the psychoeducational group (Klein of the study by Baker and colleagues reinforce the idea
& Silverman, 2012). Music interventions are beneficial that music therapy interventions can address several
not only for the caregiver but also for the individual goals simultaneously. See Table 8.4 for a summary of
receiving care. research on music therapy for wellness with caregivers.
Active music therapy interventions such as song-
writing offer flexible, specific, and creative outlets Older Adults
for caregivers to express themselves, remain healthy, By the year 2030, the US population of adults 65+ years
and meaningfully engage with those for whom they will be 73 million, nearly double of what it was only
care (O’Kelly, 2008). Through songwriting, clients 20 years earlier in 2010 (Irving & Beamish, 2014, p.
can verbalize challenging feelings, initiate therapeu- xxvii). Not only is the aging population growing, but
tic discussion, and enhance self-awareness within the average life expectancy has also increased over the
a therapeutic setting. Songwriting’s requirement of past 50 years. Children born in 2015 are expected to live
organizing words and putting them to song reintro- 78.8 years (Xu, Murphy, Kochanek, & Arias, 2016), an
duces caregivers to the concepts of being creative and increase of 12% since 1965, when life expectancy was
finding joy in life (O’Kelly, 2008). Educating caregiv- 70.2 years (Arias, Heron, & Xu, 2016). Longer life expec-
ers on the potential wellness challenges related to tancies require individuals to work longer and remain
their role can help them to remain healthy, happy, active, meaningful contributors to their communities
and meaningful contributors to their loved one’s (Irving & Beamish, 2014, pp. 124–125). In addition,
wellness. longer life spans have societal implications for financial
Caregiving relationships involving couples benefit longevity, employment, and medical care. Regardless of
from meaningful engagement. Addressing the needs of age, staying well is desirable and critical.
the caregiver is important to enhance role satisfaction Wellness-based music therapy interventions are
and to sustain a caregiver’s ability to provide services becoming increasingly important as the older adult
(Baker, Grocke, & Pachana, 2012). Couples benefit from population continues to grow. Wellness interven-
finding ways to continue interaction even when cogni- tions for older adults should focus on acquiring new
tion is compromised because of dementia. Music thera- skills, structuring leisure time through musical devel-
pists can design interventions and educate their clients opment, decision making, and social engagement
CHAPTER 8 Music Therapy and Wellness 117
TABLE 8.5
Summary of Research on Music Therapy for Wellness With Older Adults
Author, Year Music Therapy Interventions Outcomes
Belgrave (2014) Intergenerational group piano lessons Older adults: Lifelong learning, increased socializa-
tion, mastering a new skill. Students: Experiential
learning, demystification of older adult stereotypes
Clements-Cortés (2014) Group singing Feelings of energy increased and feelings of pain and
anxiety decreased as a result of participation in the
intervention
Kumar et al. (1999) Group music therapy Older adults with Alzheimer disease showed in-
creased melatonin after music therapy and at 6-week
follow-up
(Belgrave, 2014). Through Piano Wizard technol- 16 sessions. Through 1:1 interviews, primary themes
ogy, older adults and student music therapists work were revealed regarding participants’ experiences,
together to learn music. During this 10-week wellness- including community building/making new friends;
based music program, seniors come together and enhanced positivity; singing makes me feel well; less
learn to read music and to play the piano. This pro- anxiety; and increased mood, energy, and alertness
gram runs in partnership with music therapy students (Clements-Cortés, 2014).
from a nearby university. In addition to addressing issues related to the psy-
Students in the Piano Wizard project engage with chosocial and cognitive aspects of wellness, music
the seniors as a complement to their coursework. therapy can address issues related to sleep quality, an
Topics and discussions covered in the classroom are important aspect of wellness that affects many older
applied directly to the piano class as an experien- adults and all areas of wellness. Sleep plays a central
tial learning component. While seniors are given an role in the quality of life and can be affected by many
opportunity to learn, socialize, and grow, college stu- factors such as stress, lack of exercise, medications,
dents can transfer their classroom knowledge into the and the natural aging process. Lack of sleep affects
real world. For some students, this may be their first mood, muddies clear thinking, and affects a person’s
time interacting with this population. These inter- ability to manage everyday stressors. Sleep deficien-
generational experiences can be helpful in demystify- cies can compromise the ability to function success-
ing the older population and teach students how to fully on a daily basis. Recorded music can help induce
interact with this group. After the completion of the sleep duration, quality, and efficiency. Sixty healthy
10-week program, the participants present a concert older adults without cognitive impairment, medical
for each other, their friends, and family. Wellness- issues, sleep medications, or caffeine were asked to
based interventions such as the one described ear- listen to their preferred sedative music for 45 min at
lier address a variety of goals relating to cognitive bedtime for 3 weeks (Lai & Good, 2006). Participants
functioning, psychosocial engagement, and physical who listened to music demonstrated better sleep
mobility (Belgrave, 2014). scores regarding quality of sleep, perception of better
In a study by Clements-Cortés (2014), 16 older sleep, longer periods of sleep, greater sleep efficiency,
adults of varying levels of cognitive functioning partic- shorter sleep latency, less sleep disturbance, and less
ipated in a community choir. Led by two music thera- daytime dysfunction (Lai & Good, 2006). Sleep is an
pists, choir members met once a week for 16 weeks. important component of wellness for all ages, not just
Participants completed Likert-style assessments older adults. In a study by Kumar et al. (1999), older
regarding mood, pain, anxiety, happiness, and energy adults with dementia showed increased melatonin
before and after each choir rehearsal. Self-report mea- levels after music therapy, which may contribute to
sures for happiness and mood increased at every ses- enhanced relaxation and sleep quality. Table 8.5 sum-
sion. Feelings of energy increased and pain decreased marizes research on music therapy for wellness with
for 14 of 16 sessions, and anxiety decreased for 11 of older adults.
118 Music Therapy: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
stress between the patient and the caregiver. Providing could be incorporated outside of the music therapy group
support for each of these roles simultaneously is essen- and into their daily lives.
tial to enhance the wellness of both the caregiver and the Therapeutic discussion was facilitated by the music
patient. Wellness-based music therapy programs offer therapist to establish an atmosphere of sharing, sup-
creative, effective, and rewarding opportunities for care- port, and community. To facilitate the varying levels
givers to attend with their loved ones or those they care of music reading and cognitive functioning, the sheet
for. These can be achieved through group handbell choirs. music was modified to meet the reading levels of each
The following case example shows how a handbell participant.
choir focuses on improving various aspects of wellness Individuals who had difficulty raising the lower, heavier
for both the patient and the caregiver. Examples of this handbells were assigned higher, lighter notes. Those
kind reinforce the concept that even during illness we can who could play several bells/notes simultaneously were
have wellness-related goals. assigned multiple handbells. Those who needed to play
just one note were given one handbell. Music used in this
Wellness goals for caregivers way provides flexibility, adaptability, and opportunity for
• Relaxation, stretching/movement, stress management growth. With members functioning at their highest, indi-
• Self-expression, peer support from other caregivers, vidual level, the group could perform music.
mood elevation, decrease isolation Interactions such as these set the stage for patients and
caregivers to engage in an environment of normalcy. To
• Meaningful interactions and socialization
participate in an enjoyable activity with others who under-
• Enhanced spiritual support stand each other provides a sense of community, under-
standing, and support. Modifications made by the music
Wellness goals for individuals with Parkinson disease therapist enabled the patients with Parkinson disease to
• Novel use of information through music reading and function independently of each other. Sessions were often
new instrument play characterized by laughter, reminiscence as inspired by
• Playing instruments, stretching, rhythmic breathing song choice and lyric analysis, feelings of accomplish-
• Song choice, lyric analysis and related discussion ment, and encouragement of others. Participants in the
session became more confident of their musical skills as
• Maintain independence, develop positive relationships
evidenced by their requests of increasingly difficult music
with caregiver
from the music therapist. Those with more musical expe-
• Spiritual support rience assisted those who needed help. One participant
with advanced Parkinson disease was able to assist a
Music therapy interventions group member with the rhythm of a particular piece. The
• Learning how to read music or learning to read new participant reflected, “It makes me happy to know I’m still
songs, learning to play a new instrument, cognitive good for something.”
coordination of incorporating music reading and Interventions such as this demonstrate that even within
instrument playing the experience of illness, wellness goals exist and are wor-
• Warm-ups, playing handbells (Handbells can be of thy of attention.
various shapes and weights. The physical movement
of playing a handbell requires coordination and range Case Example #3
of motion.) Population: Older adults 55+ years and college students
• Lyric analysis, reminiscence 18 to 2 years.
Setting: Intergenerational choir.
• Group cooperation to make music, rapport building
Intergenerational choirs provide opportunities for the
through collective group processing
young and old to work together through group singing
interventions. Music choice within the settings consists of
Sample session outline familiar and unfamiliar music to facilitate learning. Groups
Sessions began with gentle upper body warm-ups that such as these provide wellness opportunities for both the
may be appropriately completed in either a chair or stand- young and the old.
ing position. Individuals at various stages of Parkinson dis-
ease might either be independently mobile or be utilizing Wellness goals for older adults
assistive devices such as walkers or wheelchairs. Exer- • Music learning and conversation
cises were adaptable to meet any level of ability to provide
• Maintain flexibility, respiratory function
challenging exercises for a variety of abilities for caregivers
and patients. Emphasis was placed on deep, diaphrag- • Decrease isolation, maintain awareness of others,
matic breathing to encourage relaxation and release of expand social circles
stress. Participants were reminded of how these exercises • Increase socialization, elevate mood
continued
120 Music Therapy: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
Wellness goals for young adults initiate competitive step goals, and provide employee
• Increase awareness of self and others, demystify the massage or yoga classes to participate in during breaks.
aging stereotype Google, perhaps widely known for its innovative work-
place atmosphere, exemplifies workplace wellness by
Music therapy interventions for older adults offering high-quality food/nutrition and creative work
• Learn new songs, encourage memorization, engage in spaces and encouraging employees to work in ways that
conversation with young adults, recall familiar songs function best for them. Some organizations are offering
music therapy interventions to enhance employee mental
• Engage in movement/choreography to address issues
health and wellness. Music’s ability to affect physiologic
of mobility, flexibility, posture, and fine/gross motor
measures such as heart rate and blood pressure reinforce
movement
its impact on maintaining focus of attention and problem
• Encourage group participation in music making solving, important elements of job performance. Anticipat-
• Lyric analysis, reminiscence ing the needs of employees can help determine the types
of wellness objectives that might be most appropriate.
Sample session outline Work in hospice care can be challenging in several
Wellness sessions were conducted at an assisted living wellness-related areas. Staff members, such as social
facility in a multipurpose room. One-hour sessions began workers, chaplains, physicians, nurses, and certified nurs-
with stretching and vocal warm-ups. Exercises were cre- ing assistants, are at high risk for compassion fatigue,
ated to accommodate various levels of ability—those who burnout, and isolation because of the solitary aspect of
used wheelchairs or walkers or who moved independently the field. Members of a patient team may not interact with
could participate. Group members were reminded to one another outside of team meetings. This can cause
transfer these breathing exercises into their daily routines hospice workers to feel isolated from their colleagues.
to optimally address levels of stress and anxiety. Students Interdisciplinary engagement can provide support to
alternated sitting next to an older adult and aided if needed. maintain wellness in an environment at risk for stress, iso-
To accommodate issues relating to visual acuity, lyr- lation, and job dissatisfaction. This can be a helpful exer-
ics were projected onto a screen at the front of the room. cise for corporations whose varying levels of management
This functions not only to increase eye contact between may have limited interaction. For example, Certified Nurs-
the choir and the director, but also to improve posture ing Assistants are not always in direct communication with
and nonverbal communication between singers and song physicians. The knowledge of both disciplines, however, is
leaders. imperative to achieve optimal patient care. Interventions
Familiar and unfamiliar songs present opportunities for that allow open and productive communication between
each age group to learn new material and enhance cog- these two disciplines enhance communication and, ulti-
nitive functioning. Familiar music has benefits relating to mately, provide optimal care for the patient. Each disci-
reminiscence, mood elevation, and confidence of partici- pline has a unique knowledge of the patient from two very
pation. Learning new material is advantageous because different perspectives.
it requires enhanced, more complex, cognitive process-
ing. Although some choir members expressed a distaste Goals in corporate settings
for learning new material at first, after the music became • Increase movement and physical relaxation/stretching
increasingly familiar, choir members began to like the • Encourage self-expression and stress relief
music more. • Enhance mood, professional peer interaction, team
Older adults in the intergenerational choir particularly building
enjoyed engaging with the young adult participants. Often,
after rehearsals, group members spent time visiting as
Sample session outline
inspired by the session. Older choir members often remark
Group drumming interventions are beneficial because
how enjoyable it is to have “new life” and the presence of
they are feasible, effective, and able to accommodate
youth brings out the life in the older adults. New friend-
various levels of skill and ability. Drum circles also allow
ships are made, thereby enhancing the quality of life of
participants to receive an immediate and satisfying music
both the young and the old.
experience.
Employees sit in a circle, utilizing a relatively large
Case Example #4
space. Placed in front of each chair is a drum. Drums may
Population: Working professionals.
be of various sizes, timbres, and shapes. Shakers, claves,
Setting: Drumming/percussion group.
and bells are also incorporated into this intervention. The
Increasingly, companies are promoting health and
music therapist/drum facilitator begins with simple rhythms
wellness programs for their employees. Some companies
and engages the group in call and response, improvisa-
make available programs offering discounts on gym mem-
tion, and fill-in-the-beat–type drumming exercises. For the
berships, create work-out facilities within their buildings,
CHAPTER 8 Music Therapy and Wellness 121
participants, interventions such as this encourage group to observe and attempt to identify the emotion. Partners
listening, leadership, creativity, and cross-discipline inter- take turns. After pairs have shared their emotions with
action. This also serves as an icebreaker for the group and each other and discussed the accuracy of each other’s
for participants to become familiar with their instrument. guess, pairs turn inward and participate in a larger group
Throughout the intervention, the music therapist/drum discussion.
facilitator highlights the connections between drumming Participants may find that they have similar, identical,
and the work place environment. or entirely different feelings about their respective posi-
In an effort to enhance leadership and team building, tions within the corporation. Regardless of the similari-
individuals within the group may be given an opportu- ties, or lack thereof, an opportunity for discussion, rapport
nity to be the guest drum facilitator. This presents unique building, and team work is established through discussion
opportunities for the entry level professional to direct top- led by the therapist. Feelings can be difficult to discuss,
level executives. Senior executives also have a chance to and rapport-building time may be required to establish an
show a more human side of their persona through creativ- environment conducive to sharing. Through instrument
ity and humor. The newness of the music levels the playing play and nonverbal communication, pathways for these
field for all participants. discussions can be built quickly and meaningfully, which
Drumming interventions can also facilitate learning allow productive sharing to happen more efficiently. Brief
of names and verbalizing job-related stressors/benefits intervention styles such as these are important in corpo-
and promote cross-disciplinary engagement. Drumming rate environments where time is limited and schedules
allows individuals to communicate through music, are hectic. Professional interactions such as these can
thereby encouraging safe self-expression and meaningful enhance both professional performance and patient care.
conversation. Even though such interventions are brief, they are
focused and efficient, which can be an important element
Case Example #5 for professionals. Time is of the essence for many areas of
Population: Medical professionals. therapy. Defining an objective and carrying it out efficiently
Setting: Drumming/percussion group. provides the most meaningful results.
continued
122 Music Therapy: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
Children are then asked to go into the circle and choose done with two to three participants, the therapist stops the
one instrument from the selection provided (making playing (self-control).
choices/decision making). The therapist then encourages One participant in the group creates a simple rhythm
each child to play the instrument, explore its sounds, and be (improvisation, leadership, following directions). Through
creative in how it is played (improvisation, self-expression). eye contact only, the leader invites another group mem-
Through nonverbal direction, the therapist instructs partici- ber to repeat the rhythm (improvisation, conversational
pants to “start” and “stop” playing their instruments (focus skill development). Continuing with this pattern around the
of attention, following directions). Through continued use room, each group member is given an opportunity to par-
of nonverbal directions, the therapist instructs participants ticipate and to observe appropriate leadership and conver-
to play loud or soft (follow directions/focus of attention). As sational skill development. It is important throughout the
participants continue to play, the therapist encourages one intervention for the music therapist to direct participants’
of the children to approach the front of the room and be the attention to the music objectives used to address the well-
“conductor” (leadership, peer respect). After this has been ness goals.
PROVISION OF SERVICES both the clinical and academic fields augments under-
Funding standing of practice and promotes the effective use of
Many music therapy services are reimbursable through music therapy services. Music therapists working in the
insurance or provided through programming (Simpson field must consistently educate the public in both for-
& Burns, 2004). For the most part, however, wellness- mal and casual settings what the discipline of music
specific interventions are currently not reimbursable. therapy offers. Ultimately, continued education regard-
Organizations such as hospitals, skilled nursing facili- ing music therapy as a discipline enhances patient care.
ties, and assisted living facilities, however, acknowledge An understanding of music therapy’s role in wellness
the value of wellness-based music therapy services and will not only enhance patient care, but also enable
often allocate funding for this work through grants, related professions to understand the impact music
donations, or private pay. As music therapy and well- therapy can have on the wellness of the patients.
ness continue to demonstrate effective outcomes, reim-
bursement opportunities will likely follow. Research
The role of research remains an important element in the
Referral Pathways and Collaboration incorporation of wellness-based programming. Design-
Music therapy continues to establish itself as an effec- ing meaningful experiments that can objectively reflect
tive treatment within many fields. Music therapists the impact of music therapy on wellness-based goals will
must remain vigilant in advocating for their profession further solidify the effectiveness of music therapy within
and educating related fields on music therapy’s ben- this population. It also serves to substantiate the need
efits to patient care. Interdisciplinary team meetings for services. Collaboration is the key to broadening and
occurring in medical and educational settings involv- strengthening the body of research that examines music’s
ing staff, teachers, parents, and academic advisors ben- role within wellness. Healthcare is becoming an ensemble
efit from understanding how music therapy helps the production, and examining music’s influence within an
patients and students in incorporating wellness goals interdisciplinary approach is especially valuable.
into their care plans. When related disciplines under-
stand how music therapy assists their patients in main-
taining wellness goals, referrals increase. Not only can CONCLUSION
an understanding of the music therapy and wellness The development of a mind-body approach to health-
interventions enhance patient care, but an awareness of care, an evolving definition of wellness, and medical
the impact of collaboration across disciplines can also advancements affecting the life span make living a life
enhance patient outcomes. characterized by wellness crucial. Individuals, work-
places, and service providers are recognizing the role
that wellness interventions are playing and are seeking
AREAS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH ways of making these services available. Young and old
Education and Collaboration alike benefit from maintaining a wellness lifestyle and
Education regarding what music therapy can provide are viewing music therapy as a means to achieve that
remains of utmost importance. Collaboration within goal.
CHAPTER 8 Music Therapy and Wellness 123
Mori-Inoue, S., & Ilich, J. Z. (2015). Music therapy as an ave- Smith-Osbourne, A., & Felderhoff, B. (2014). Veterans’ informal
nue to promote healthy eating, exercise and bone health in caregivers in the “sandwich generation”: A systematic review
children. Bone Abstracts, 4, 58. http://dx.doi.org/10.1530/ toward a resilience model. Journal of Gerontological Social
boneabs.4.P58. Work, 57, 556–584. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01634372
Mungas, R., & Silverman, M. J. (2014). Immediate effects of .2014.880101.
group-based wellness drumming on affective states in uni- Watsford, M. L., Murphy, A. J., & Pine, M. J. (2007). The
versity students. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 41, 287–292. effects of ageing on respiratory muscle function and
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2014.04.008. performance in older adults. Journal of Science and Medi-
National Wellness Institute. (2016). NWI’s six dimensions of cine in Sport, 10, 36–44. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
wellness model. Retrieved from http://www.nationalwellness. jsams.2006.05.002.
org. Weinstein, R. (2004). The stress effect. New York, NY: Penguin
O’Kelly, J. (2008). Saying it in song: Music therapy as a care Group.
support intervention. International Journal of Palliative Nurs- Xu, J. Q., Murphy, S. L., Kochanek, K. D., & Arias, E. (2016).
ing, 14, 281–286. Mortality in the United States, 2015. NCHS data brief, no 267.
Qualls, S. H., & Williams, A. A. (2015). Caregiver family therapy: Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics. Re-
Empowering families to meet the challenges of aging. Washing- trieved from https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/
ton, D.C.: American Psychological Association. db267.htm.
Reed, M. (2015, October 29). Stress in college: Experts provide Yinger, O. S., & LaPointe, L. L. (2012). The effects of participa-
tips to cope. USA Today. http://college.usatoday.com/2015/ tion in a group music therapy voice protocol (G-MTVP) on
10/29/college-student-stress/. the speech of individuals with Parkinson’s disease. Music
Robb, S. L. (2000). Music assisted progressive muscle relaxa- Therapy Perspectives, 30, 25–31. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/
tion, progressive muscle relaxation, music listening, and si- mtp/30.1.25.
lence: A comparison of relaxation techniques. Journal of Mu-
sic Therapy, 37, 2–21. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jmt/37.1.2.
Saxon, S. V., Etten, M. J., & Perkins, E. A. (2010). Physical change FURTHER READING
& aging: A guide for the helping professions. (5th ed.). New Harmat, L., Takács, J., & Bódizs, R. (2008). Music improves sleep
York, NY: Springer Publishing Company. quality in students. The Journal of Advanced Nursing, 62, 327–
Segall, L. E. (2016). The effect of a music therapy intervention on 335. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2008.04602.x.
inmate levels of executive function and perceived stress. (Un- Hooyman, N. R., & Kiyak, H. A. (2008). Social gerontology: A
published doctoral dissertation). Tallahassee, FL: Flori- multidisciplinary perspective (8th ed.). New York, NY: Pearson
da State University. Education, Inc.
Silber, L. (2005). Bars behind bars: The impact of a women’s Linnemann, A., Ditzen, B., Strahler, J., Doert, J. M., & Nater, U.
prison choir on social harmony. Music Education Research, 7, N. (2015). Music listening as a means of stress reduction in
251–271. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14613800500169811. daily life. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 60, 82–90. http://dx.doi.
Simpson, J., & Burns, D. S. (2004). Music therapy reimburse- org/10.1016/j.psyneuen.2015.06.008.
ment: Best practices and procedures. Silver Springs, MD: World Health Organization. (2017). Constitution of the World
AMTA. Health Organization: Principles. Retrieved from http://www.
Smith, M. (2008). The effects of a single music relaxation ses-
who.int/about/mission/en/.
sion on state anxiety levels of adults in a workplace environ-
ment. The Australian Journal of Music Therapy, 19, 45–66.