Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/282038356
CITATIONS READS
0 76
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mitchell Maltenfort on 24 November 2015.
abstract
The purposes of the current investigation are to evaluate the epidemiology of water
sport injuries at a coastal tertiary trauma center and to determine the association of these
activities with spinal column injury and to determine whether aquatic trauma injuries
differ significantly from those that occur terrestrially. A retrospective review of a con-
secutive series of 105 patients with aquatic-based mechanisms of injury admitted to a
Level II trauma center over a 3-year period, as well as a matched control cohort with
terrestrial-based mechanisms of injury, was conducted. Patients were treated at a Level
II trauma center from January 1, 2008, to December 31, 2010. All patients received a
full trauma work-up on arrival. Patients were identified retrospectively from a pro-
spectively collected database (N=5298). Eligible patients were identified from billing/
coding data as having mechanisms of injury related to an aquatic setting. Patients
were evaluated using standard trauma protocols. Spinal column and cord injury
occurrence and differences between groups were reviewed. Personal watercrafts ac-
counted for the majority of injuries (n=39). Cervical (33.3%), closed-head (25.7%),
and thoracolumbar (21.9%) injuries accounted for the majority of injury types. The
cervical spinal column and the spinal cord were at an increased risk of injury in the
aquatic injury cohort (P<.0001). The current data show the high incidence of spinal
column and cord injuries in this patient population relative to controls. Practitioners
who care for trauma patients near an aquatic environment should be aware of the
high prevalence of these injuries, with proper spinal cord preservation protocols in
place to optimize outcome. [Orthopedics. 2015; 38(9):e813-e818.]
The authors are from the New York Medical College (IK), Valhalla, New York; and the Rothman
Institute of Orthopedics at Jefferson University Hospital (AO, KER, LSA, MM, FT), Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania.
Mr Kane, Dr Maltenfort, and Dr Tjoumakaris have no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Dr Ong is a paid consultant for Smith & Nephew and Stryker. Dr Radcliff is a paid consultant for Glo-
bus, Medtronic, and DePuy. Dr Austin receives personal fees from Tornier.
Correspondence should be addressed to: Fotios Tjoumakaris, MD, Rothman Institute, 2500 English
Creek Ave, Bldg 1300, Egg Harbor Township, NJ 08234 (Fotios.Tjoumakaris@rothmaninstitute.com).
Received: October 3, 2014; Accepted: January 6, 2015.
doi: 10.3928/01477447-20150902-60
S
everal studies have been conducted due to the high-force nature of these mech-
on fracture epidemiology in the anisms combined with the possibility that Table 1
setting of specific risk factors, such the event may occur in shallow water near
Patient Demographics
as bicycling,1,2 motor vehicle collision,3 the shoreline, which can lead to headfirst
Aquatic Terrestrial
and even airplane injuries.4 A large-scale encounters with the ocean floor. Demographic (Case) (Control)
evaluation has not been done for the epi- The purpose of the current investigation
Male, No. (%) 75 75
demiology of water-based recreational was to evaluate the nature and mechanisms (71.4) (71.4)
injuries occurring over several years at of injury of recreational water sports in a Age, mean, y 37.19 38.85
a populated coastal city. Summer in a coastal environment. In addition, the au- Female, No. 30 30
coastal region is often accompanied by a thors sought to determine whether the risk (%) (28.6) (28.6)
surge of unique traumatic incidents asso- of spinal cord and column injury or other Age, mean, y 34.50 36.30
ciated with the aquatic environment and types of bodily injury were more signifi- ISS, mean 8.89 9.30
related recreational activities.5,6 There is cantly associated with water-based activi-
LOS, mean, d 5.41 6.02
an increase in tourism to these regions ties relative to those that occur on land in a
Abbreviations: ISS, injury severity score;
and many of the incoming ocean-goers defined trauma population. LOS, length of stay.
are less familiar with the risks and dan-
gers associated with water-based recre- Materials and Methods
ational activities compared with individu- Institutional review board approval act tests, Wilcoxon rank sum tests, and a
als who encounter them more often. By was obtained for this study. All patients Bonferroni correction.
examining the epidemiology of injuries were retrospectively identified from a pro-
arising from this seasonal-specific set- spectively collected database of patients Results
ting, it is believed that more favorable admitted to the trauma service at the au- During the study period, there were
patient outcomes can be obtained through thors’ local tertiary trauma center situated 5298 trauma admissions, 1672 of which
efficient injury management. on the East Coast. This trauma database occurred during the summer months. Trau-
Spinal cord injuries in particular are and registry are maintained by the admit- ma patients were then excluded from the
devastating injuries that can result in per- ting trauma service and collect patient de- case group (n=5193) if they did not meet
manent impairment of function and loss mographic data relating to mechanism of the criteria of having a mechanism of in-
of quality of life, and in some instances injury, injury severity score (ISS), length jury originating from a recreational water
can be fatal.7 Optimum outcome is often of stay (LOS), complications encoun- sport. In the aquatic injury group, there
achieved when the health care team car- tered, transfusion requirements, surgical were 75 men (mean age, 37.19 years) and
ing for these injured patients is well sea- procedures performed, age, gender, and 30 women (mean age, 34.50 years), with
soned in caring for these injuries with cur- medical comorbidities. a mean ISS of 8.89. Mean LOS was 5.41
rent spinal protocols and treatments (eg, Patients enrolled from January 1, days, with a mean LOS in the intensive
American Association of Neurological 2008, to December 31, 2010, served as care unit (ICU) of 5 days.
Surgeons guidelines8), including spinal the cohort population of patients. This Twenty-eight (26.7%) patients re-
immobilization and nonoperative vs op- represented 5298 patients admitted as an quired surgical stabilization. Mecha-
erative stabilization. alert during this time frame. Patients for nisms of injury included 24 (22.9%)
Spinal cord injuries are most common the case group were eligible for inclu- wave-runner accidents, 15 (14.3%) boat-
following high-energy mechanisms, which sion if they were admitted/injured in the ing accidents, 14 (13.3%) bodyboarding
are involved with numerous recreational context of water-based activity or rec- injuries, 13 (12.4%) falls, 11 (10.5%)
activities.9-15 These include contact sport- reational sport (eg, swimming, surfing, diving accidents, 9 (8.6%) body-surfing
ing activities,16-18 motorized vehicle opera- boating, personal watercraft use). This accidents, 9 (8.6%) surfing accidents,
tion, and falls.19 On coastal waters, a vari- led to 105 patients eligible for inclusion. 8 (7.6%) hits by a wave, 1 (1.0%) tubing
ety of recreational activities exist that carry For comparative analysis, a control group accident, and 1 (1.0%) explosion.
a predisposition to spinal cord and other of patients (matched by age, gender, and Complications included 9 (8.6%) in-
traumatic injuries.20 These include surf- ISS) were also obtained from admissions fections, 6 (5.7%) cases of pneumonia/
ing, personal motorized watercraft opera- during the same time frame and from the atelectasis, 2 (1.9%) pre-hospital cardiac
tion (ie, riding a wave-runner or boating), same larger cohort (Table 1). Patients arrests (traumatic arrests, not due to oc-
swimming, kayaking, and bodysurfing. In- in both cohorts were analyzed in similar clusion of coronary arteries), 2 (1.9%)
juries often occur following these activities fashion and compared using Fisher’s ex- incidences of deep venous thrombosis,
pears to arise from several outlier patients and all water-based fatalities based on au- cervical spine injury: a review of motor-
cycle, moped, and bicycle accidents at a
who required an extended hospital stay topsy information.30 level 1 trauma center. J Neurotrauma. 2014;
due to numerous other factors, including A limitation of this study was the ret- 31(15):1329-1333.
injury care, continuing health manage- rospective nature of the analysis. Retro- 3. Kaufman RP, Ching RP, Willis MM, Mack
ment, and inability to obtain placement in spective studies may be more susceptible CD, Gross JA, Bulger EM. Burst fractures
of the lumbar spine in frontal crashes. Accid
an appropriate care facility. Therefore, it to selection bias. Although all data were Anal Prev. 2013; 59:153-163.
is unclear whether this value reflected the collected prospectively, it was not record- 4. Manen O, Clément J, Bisconte S, Perrier E.
care necessary for the presenting injuries. ed with the current study in mind and it is Spine injuries related to high-performance
aircraft ejections: a 9-year retrospective
Although there are no known large- possible that pertinent data may have been
study. Aviat Space Environ Med. 2014;
scale epidemiologic studies of coastal overlooked. Patients who expired at the 85(1):66-70.
water sport injuries published, there have scene of the accident would not have been 5. Chalmers D, Morrison L. Epidemiology of
been studies that tangentially touched included, making it reasonable to assume non-submersion injuries in aquatic sporting
and recreational activities. Sports Med. 2003;
on the issue. A study of male patients there is some degree of survivorship bias 33(10):745-770.
who sustained spinal injuries related to present. It was surprising to the investiga- 6. Giustini M, Ade P, Taggi F, Funari E. Acci-
water-based incidents related diving and tors that neither group included any fa- dents in recreational waters. Ann Ist Super
alcohol use to the likelihood of injury.21 talities from the time emergency medical Sanita. 2003; 39(1):69-76.
Individual mechanisms have been exam- services assumed care of the patients until 7. Jazayeri SB, Beygi S, Shokraneh F, Hagen
EM, Rahimi-Movaghar V. Incidence of trau-
ined and their epidemiologies reported. discharge. Although this is an encourag- matic spinal cord injury worldwide: a sys-
Recreational boating and the risks and in- ing scenario, it is not the typical situation temic review. Eur Spine J. 2015; 24(5):905-
juries associated with that activity was the experienced while dealing with as many 918.
subject of a recent epidemiologic study, high-velocity mechanisms of injury as 8. Hadley MN, Walters BC, Grabb PA, et al.
Guidelines for the management of acute cer-
which showed that the most likely cause were included in this study. vical spine and spinal cord injuries. Clin Neu-
of death on the water was human error.22 rosurg. 2002; 49:407-498.
Another study examined canoeing, kayak- Conclusion 9. Selvarajah S, Schneider EB, Becker D, Sad-
owsky CL, Haider AH, Hammond ER. The
ing, and rafting and the injuries associated To the authors’ knowledge, this is the
epidemiology of childhood and adolescent
with participation in these activities.23 largest epidemiologic series to date on traumatic spinal cord injury in the United
Waterskiing24 and personal watercraft- aquatic and water sport injuries. The data States: 2007-2010. J Neurotrauma. 2014;
31(18):1548-1560.
related injuries25,26 were examined and show the high incidence of spinal column
10. Nijendijk JH, Post MW, van Asbeck FW.
showed a high increase in injuries related and spinal cord injuries in this patient Epidemiology of traumatic spinal cord inju-
to personal watercraft use and guidelines population relative to controls. Practitio- ries in the Netherlands in 2010. Spinal Cord.
for safer recreational uses were suggested. ners who care for trauma patients near an 2014; 52(4):258-263.
Skimboarding injuries27 were also exam- aquatic environment should be aware of 11. Rahimi-Movaghar V, Sayyah MK, Akbari H,
et al. Epidemiology of traumatic spinal cord
ined for their prevalence to result in lower the high prevalence of these injuries, with injury in developing countries: a systematic re-
extremity injury; however, there were no proper spinal cord preservation protocols view. Neuroepidemiology. 2013; 41(2):65-85.
trauma admissions following a skimboard in place to optimize outcome. Awareness 12. Wang H, Xiang Q, Li C, Zhou Y. Epidemiol-
accident during the time frame that was of the associated risk of closed-head inju- ogy of traumatic cervical spinal fractures and
risk factors for traumatic cervical spinal cord
examined in the current study, suggest- ries should also be taken into account dur- injury in China. J Spinal Disord Tech. 2013;
ing that these injuries tend to not qualify ing the workup of patients involved in these 26(8):e306-e313.
for admission to a trauma center. Wave- high-risk activities. Future strategies aimed 13. Sekhon LH, Fehlings MG. Epidemiology,
demographics, and pathophysiology of acute
related injuries were examined and at preventing these injuries in seasonal visi- spinal cord injury. Spine (Phila Pa 1976).
showed a high risk for the elderly due to tors and native coastal inhabitants should 2001; 26(suppl 24):S2-S12.
preexisting cervical spondylosis result- be a critical part of any comprehensive re- 14. Tator CH, Edmonds VE. Acute spinal cord
ing in central cord syndrome following gional trauma program. injury: analysis of epidemiologic factors.
Can J Surg. 1979; 22(6):575-578.
hyperextension of the neck, as well as the
15. Yang R, Guo L, Wang P, et al. Epidemiol-
ocean-goer with weak swimming skills.28 References ogy of spinal cord injuries and risk factors
Other studies have looked at water-based 1. Jecmenica DS, Alempijevic DjM, Aleksan- for complete injuries in Guangdong, China:
injuries and deaths without the context of dric BV, Pavlekic SB, Baralic I, Antic BZ. a retrospective study. PLoS One. 2014;
Injuries of the cervical spine in motorcycling 9(1):e84733.
engagement in a water sport. These stud- and bicycling traffic accidents. Acta Chir Iu- 16. De Jonge MC, Kramer J. Spine and sport. Se-
ies include an examination of pediatric in- gosl. 2010; 57(1):135-140. min Musculoskelet Radiol. 2014; 18(3):246-
juries in relation to any source of water29 2. Hooten KG, Murad GJ. Helmet use and 264.