TEACHER RETENTION: WHY DO BEGINNING
TEACHERS REMAIN IN THE PROFESSION?
Dr. Duane Inman
Associate Professor of Education
Charter School of Education and Human Sciences
Mount Berry, GA 30149
Dk. Lest Mariow
Associate Professor of Education
Charter School of Education and Human Sciences
Mount Berry, GA 30149
As beginning teachers continue to leave the profession within the
first several years of entering, educators must identify factors
which cause teachers to remain in the profession, as well as fa
tors related to attrition if the current teacher shortage is to be
remedied. The purpose of this study was to examine the report-
ed attitudes of beginning teachers in order to identify perceived
positive aspects of teaching as factors which may lead to teacher
retention. The sample, which comprised part of an ongoing study
seeking to survey teachers within various areas within the Unit-
ed States, was composed of teachers from randomly selected
schools in Georgia. The Professional Attitude Survey, a 10 item
survey instrument designed to gather information regarding 21
characteristics related to teacher career stability, was sent to the
teachers of randomly selected schools. Teachers were requested
to respond to questions related to demographics, teacher back-
ground, reasons for remaining in the profession, and job
satisfaction, Retention factors identified by the participants are
discussed and recommendations for retention are provided for
teacher education programs, administrators, and the community.
Continuing concern in the education
field, as well as in the United States and
society at large, is centered on the high
rate at which beginning teachers leave the
profession. Over the years studies have
revealed that most teachers who leave have
fewer than 10 years of teaching experience
Many reports indicate 25%-50% of begin-
ning teachers resign during their first three
years of teaching (Voke, 2002; Fleener,
2001; NEA, 2001; NCES, 1999; Haselko-
m, 1994). Other reports state that nearly ten
percent leave in their first year (Recruiting
New Teachers, Inc., 2000). While accurate
measures of teacher attrition are important
if school systems, administrators, and
potential teachers are to effectively plan
for the coming years, the need to identify
factors which cause teachers to remain in
the profession is perhaps of greater impor-
tance (see end notes).
The purpose of this study was to per-
form a conceptual analysis of reported
current attitudes of beginning teachers in
605606 / Education Vol. 124 No. 4
order to identify perceived positive aspects
of teaching as factors which may lead to
teacher retention.
Attrition and Retention
Previously, educational researchers have
primarily examined factors such as demo-
graphics, teacher background, professional
environment, and lack of support systems
which were identified as predictors of
teacher attrition. The reasons teachers pro-
vided for leaving were less often due to
insufficient salaries than to a lack of pro-
fessionalism, collegiality, and
administrative support (Bolton, 2002;
Recruitment and Retention Project, 2001;
Mills, 2001; Metropolitan Life Survey of
Former Teachers, 1986). Additionally,
while retirement and reduction of school
staff were reported reasons for some attri-
tion, the more frequently cited reasons were
family, personal circumstances, and job
dissatisfaction (Voke, 2002). More recent-
ly, disruptive students, uninvolved parents
and invasive bureaucracy were identified
as contributing to the demoralization of
teachers (McDonough, 2003), and to influ-
encing the inclination of teachers to leave
the classroom.
Today’s teachers face an increasing vari-
ety of classroom conditions, including
English Speakers of Other Languages and
language immersion classrooms, inclusion
and state mandated programs, as well as a
need for increased knowledge and skills
in such diverse areas as portfolio assess-
ment, technology, cooperative learning,
and a wide variety of specific instruction-
al strategies (Potter, Swenk, et.al., 2001).
‘The new educational conditions, goals, and
reforms are compounding, for the begin-
ning teacher, what is already a complex
professional challenge. Teachers just enter-
ing the classroom experience “classroom
or reality shock” and often mistake the
uneasiness they feel as an indication that
they have made a mistake in their choice
of profession. Although many beginning
teachers expect to stay in the profession,
others view teaching as transitional to other
jobs in education or in other occupations.
If the positive aspects of their new job are
not emphasized, many new teachers will
look elsewhere (Teacher Retention Unit,
2002).
The Recruitment and Retention Project
(2002) identified three major classes of
factors that influence teacher retention:
external factors, employment factors, and
personal factors. Although external factors
including retirement incentives, alterna-
tives outside of teaching, salary, and the
availability of other teaching positions
impact a teacher's decision to stay or leave
the profession, personal factors and
employment factors often provide many
more compelling reasons.
Population
This sample, which comprised part of
an ongoing study which seeks to survey
teachers within various areas within the
United States, was composed of teachers
from randomly selected schools in Geor-
gia. Using the State’s public school
directory, each county within the state was
assigned a number. Gay’s Table of Ran-
dom Numbers (1996) was then used to
identify 50 counties. The same procedure
was then used to identify five schools per
county. The principal of each selected
school was contacted by mail and request-ed to provide information from 5 teachers
(K-8). Principals then, according to their
individual methodologies, contacted the
teachers in their schools and obtained their
participation in completing the surveys
Instrumentation
The Professional Attitude Survey, a 10
item survey instrument designed to gath-
er information regarding 21 characteristics
related to teacher career stability, was sent
to the teachers in each participating school.
Teachers were requested to respond to
questions related to demographics, teacher
background, reasons for remaining in the
profession, and job satisfaction. The pilot
study of this instrument was conducted in
Fall 2000. Test-retest stability was mea-
sured to determine the stability of scores
over time. A group of approximately 100
teachers completed the survey, once in Sep-
tember and once in November 2000. The
scores from each were correlated and the
coefficient of stability was calculated to
be 0.90.
Procedures
One thousand two-hundred fifty sur-
veys were sent out to participating schools.
A packet of information was sent to the
principal of each identified school from
the random sample. A cover letter and
copies of the survey instrument were
included in each packet. If the principal
agreed to his/her faculty's participation in
the study, the principal distributed the sur-
vey instrument to the teachers. The teachers
independently completed the surveys and
returned the self-addressed, stamped sur-
veys. Only those interested participated.
Forty percent of the 500 returned were clas-
Teacher Retention... / 607
sified as coming from beginning teachers
having fewer than ten years of experiences.
For those participants or principals who
wanted to know the results of the survey,
such information was requested by the indi-
vidual providing their name and address.
All information obtained by the survey was
anonymously reported in group totals only.
Results
Demographics.
As is evidenced in Table 1, of those
identified as beginning teachers, 47% had
fewer than four years of teaching experi-
ences with 53% having between four and
10 years of teaching experience. Of those
with fewer than10 years of experience,
15% were kindergarten teachers, 47% were
elementary teachers, and 38% were mid-
dle school teachers. Eleven percent were
male and 89% female. The cultural com-
position of the group was 76% white, 13%
African American, 5% Hispanic, 1%
Native American and 1% Asian.608 / Education Vol. 124 No. 4
Table 1
Demographic Information
Hispanic | 5%
Native
American | 1%
Asian 1%
No 4%
Response
Ethnic Ongin Years) Classroom Current Teaching Gender
Teaching Placement
write 78%