Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://www.crimsonpublishers.com
Abstract
Lean manufacturing is an applied methodology of scientific, objective techniques that cause work tasks in a process to be performed with a
minimum of non-value adding activities resulting in greatly reduced wait time, queue time, move time, administrative time, and other delays. This work
addresses the implementation of lean principles in a footwear manufacturing industry in order to evaluate present Process Cycle Efficiency (PCE) and
lead time prior to developing an improved strategy to bring the improved PCE and to reduce the lead time. At the present state, the PCE was found
15.28% and after the implementation of lean tools, it would be 34.05% at the future state where lead time would also be reduced by 55.09% evaluated
by Pareto analysis and value stream mapping tools. The production flow was optimized by minimizing several non-value added activities and time such
as bottlenecking, machine breakdown, queue time, waiting time, material handling time, etc. Eventually, this study will be useful in developing a more
generic approach to design lean environment in the management system of the studied reputed Footwear Industry in Bangladesh.
Keywords: Lean tools; VSM; Lead time; PCE; Technology assessment; Casual shoe
Abbreviations: PCE: Process Cycle Efficiency; D/T: Down Time; C/T: Cycle Time; U/T: Up Time; VD: Value Added Time; NVD: Non-Value Added Time;
VSM: Value Stream Mapping; M/C: Machine; RPM: Rotation Per Minute
Introduction
the sum of its value added work content time. On the other hand,
Finished leather, the main material of footwear, is solely
applications of lean manufacturing in the continuous process sector
supplied by the local tanneries. Tanneries in Hazaribagh were
have been far fewer [5]. It has sometimes been argued that in part,
started in 1960 by Punjabi what was then Pakistan and grew
this is because such industries are inherently more efficient and
faster and after the independence of Bangladesh in 1971, became
have a relatively less urgent need for major improvement activities.
a ‘cash cow’ to earn foreign currencies [1]. Now Bangladesh is set
Managers have also been hesitant to adopt lean manufacturing
to emerge as the next manufacturing hub for the global footwear
tools and techniques to the continuous sector because of other
industry. It is one of the leading manufacturing industries based
characteristics that are typical in this sector. These include large,
on raw material, geographical condition and work force and
inflexible machines, long setup times, and the general difficulty in
is highly favourable for the growth of footwear industry [2].
producing in small batches. While some lean manufacturing tools
Lean manufacturing is based on the Toyota Production System
might indeed be difficult to adapt to the continuous sector, this
developed by Toyota which focuses on eliminating waste, reducing
does not mean that the approach is completely inapplicable; for
inventory, improving throughput, and encouraging employees to
example, [6-12] examine aspects of continuous production that are
bring attention to problems and suggest improvements fix them
amenable to lean techniques and present a classification scheme to
[3]. Lean manufacturing has increasingly been applied by leading
guide lean implementation in this sector. Features of a typical lean
manufacturing companies throughout the world. A core concept
manufacturing model include one unit at a time production; non-
of lean manufacturing is pulling production in which the flow on
value added time eliminated production in the work content time
the factory floor is driven by demand from downstream pulling
only, and relocation of required resources to the point of usage.
production upstream. Some of the changes required by lean
In the present day of manufacturing, the assembly line can be
manufacturing can be disruptive if not implemented correctly and
formed easily for any industry whether it is a small-scale or a large-
some aspects of it are not appropriate for all companies [4]. A lean
scale industry. When the tact times are calculated for every part
manufacturing facility is capable of producing the product in only
manufactured in the industry through different part movements,
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh.
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
18
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
Figure 2: Present value steam mapping (VSM) of casual shoe production line.
D/T (Sec) C/T (Sec) U/T (%) D/T (Sec) C/T (Sec) U/T (%) D/T (Sec) C/T (Sec) U/T (%)
Note: Sewing m/c speed: 276rpm; Lasting m/c speed: 274rpm; Finishing m/c speed: 50 pairs per hour, Batch production-7000 pairs.
Table 2: Present lead time of casual shoe production line.
Pre-Lasting 0 1770
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh. 19
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
It helps to draw the required production steps with mentioning considered as the heartbeat of any process line. By this way, the
required labour, C/T, U/T, C/O and batch size. By observing the present takt time of studied production line was 13.19sec i.e. it took
present scenario of regarding production line, it can be known 13.19sec to produce a single case of Casual shoe production. By this
like as what number of labour is needed at different production study, it was tried to reduce the present takt time with the proper
unit? How much is VD & NVD time present? Where & what kind implementation of lean tools.
of improvement should be done? It helps to calculate the PCE, lead
Pareto analysis
time and tact time.
It is a statistical technique in decision making that is used for
Present PCE of casual shoe production line
selection of a limited number of tasks that produce significant
PCE is measured as the percentage of the ration of VD time overall effect. It uses the Pareto principle – the idea that by doing
and lead time, where lead time is the summation of VD and NVD 20% of work, 80% of the advantage of doing the entire job can be
time. In the observed production line, the VD and NVD time were generated. Or in terms of quality improvement, a large majority
found as 15270sec and 84600sec, so the lead time was 99870sec of problems (80%) are produced by a few key causes (20%) [23].
and consequently, the PCE was 15.28% which could be considered The Pareto Principle also is known as the “80/20 Rule” which is the
as the below of internationally comparative level 25% [19]. idea that 20% of causes generate 80% of results [24-26]. In this
Throughout this study, it was strived to improve the present PCE study, by using this tool it was tried to find out the 20% of causes
with the proper adoption of lean tools such as VSM, Pareto analysis, that is generating 80% NVD activities. This tool focuses on the most
Pareto chart, 5S, and JIT. damaging causes on a project. In this essence, David stated that the
application of the Pareto chart consisting of causes for downtime
Present takt time of casual shoe production line
or NVD activities along the X axis while the Y axis represents the
Takt time is considered as the time that is required to produce cumulative percentage of downtime. Most of the NVD activities
a single unit of daily capable quantity of commodities [22]. The were documented on sewing, pre-lasting, post –lasting and finishing
studied production line runs for two shifts per day, each shift steps where these were frequently observed due to different causes.
was for 33600sec excluding lunch time and planned downtime; The highest frequency of NVD activities that derived the downtime
therefore, the available time for the run of the studied production was found for toe lasting problems while skipped stitches were the
line was 67200sec with the daily customer demand of 5094cases lowest frequency.
where each case contains 140 pair’s Casual shoe. Takt time is
Table 3: Causes of delay times for pare to analysis of casual shoe production line.
Different causes of NVD activities or downtime at different activities were arranged in downward movements in terms of their
production stages were documented in Table 3 with their frequency frequency. 5S and JIT would be effective initiatives to remove these
in terms of percentage and cumulative of percentage. Pareto chart most frequent causes [27].
is constructed in Figure 3 where the responsible causes for NVD
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh.
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
20
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
Improvement Strategies modular step. 5S is not only a means to increase the profitability of
a firm but also allow companies to reveal potential strengths and
In order to remove the 80% NVD activities, indeed it is
capabilities that were hidden before [28]. It consists of Japanese
emergence to take some improvement strategies such as increase
words-Seiri (Sort), Seiton (Straighten), Seiso (Sweep and Clean),
skill manpower, continuous improvement, and involvement of JIT
Seiketsu (Systemize), and Shitsuke (Standardize). The basic and
philosophy within the production management system.
underlying concept of 5S is looking for waste and then tries to
Increase skill manpower eliminate it. This concept implies that go there instantly where a
problem occurs; checkout the problem; take a temporary measure
It was observed that most of the assistant operators were not
on spot; find out the main causes beyond the problem, if need
enough skilled to handle the machine breakdown immediately. But
uses the five WHY? Question; and finally standardized to prevent
for this reason, the maintenance time was as high as not acceptable.
reoccurrence [29]. In a production process line, a good change or
So, it is suggested to hire some skill manpower as operator and
the improvement can be achieved by many ways such as reduction
assistant operator especially for sewing, lasting and finishing
of inventory, reduction of production time, reduction of defective
machine. The effective training program should be arranged
parts etc. In this essence, a strategic plan is developed prior to
prior to make capable of operator and assistant operator towards
implementing the 5S in the observed Casual Shoe production line
reducing the maintenance time.
in order to remove the recognized NVD activities. Towards the
Continuous improvement implementation of 5S, it would be needed a proper plan or vision
which could be formulated by the management of foot wear sector.
Continuous improvement is one of the most effective and basic
The vision plan should be incorporated with the theme of reducing
tools of lean production which is also known as Kaizen. It is a long-
lead time, NVD activities or manufacturing waste and improving
term approach to work systematically to seek and to achieve small,
PCE. The plan of 5 Supplemented consisting of team work, training
incremental changes in processes in order to improve the efficiency
work, multi-skill scope and learning environment. To implement
and quality. Kaizen can be applied to any kind of work, but it is well
a new plan, teamwork will be an effective wheel to bring the plan
known for being used in lean manufacturing. Kaizen is a Japanese
into practical. An effective training program should be arranged
term that reveals the meaning as “good change”. Basically Kaizen is
frequently prior to need for the sake of 5Sincorporation within the
considered as a systematic approach for continuous improvement.
existing production management system. An attempt should be
5S is one of the most popular tools for effective continuous
constant in order to find out the problem at each and every stage
improvement. Towards the NVD activities reduction, 5S is the first
of the Casual Shoe production line. A persistent endeavour should
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh. 21
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
be kept on creating a way to eliminate the arising problems and if to raw material, thus ‘‘pulling’’ all requirements just when they
this way being effective, it must be documented and if not keeping are required [33,34]. Actually, there are no unified steps towards
on try towards an effective way beyond the elimination of problems the JIT implementation; because, the production phenomenon of
for NVD activities. different factories varies from each other. Moreover, the ability of
the different techniques in different factories depends deeply on
Just in time (JIT)
a specific manufacturing environment. However, benefits from
JIT is a Japanese management philosophy which has been these programs have often been limited because of unreliable
applied in many Japanese manufacturing organizations since the or inflexibility [35]. Indeed, it is needed a reliable and flexible
early 1970s. It was first developed by Taiichi Ohno in the Toyota environment towards the JIT implementation. In the observed
manufacturing plants as a means of meeting consumer demands Casual shoe production line unwanted and unnecessary NVD
within the minimum delays [30]. The lean production firstly waiting time were observed as very common between each two
focuses on what is most commonly thought of as ‘just in time’ stages, especially in raw material inventory and finished goods
management which is considered as one of the basic principles inventory which could be reduced by JIT implementation. In order
of lean manufacturing. It is the idea of producing exactly what the to JIT implementation, some suggestions were proposed like as-
customer wants, in the quantities they want, where they want it
a. Prepare the plant and its personnel for flexibility towards
when the customer wants it without being delayed or held upon
involving themselves within the JIT principles
inventory [31]. Inman & Bulfi [32] implied that JIT implementation
provokes to reduce hurdles like as long change over time; unlevelled b. Regarding personnel should be careful to the shortest lead
production schedules; highly variable production processes; large time and high quality by concentrating maintenance and quality
container sizes; severe bottlenecks and long lead time.
c. Strive to produce with no waste by focusing on inventory
A system where a customer initiates demand and the demand control
is then transmitted backward from the final assembly all the way
The Future States of Casual Shoe Production Line
Future VSM of casual shoe production line
Finally, the future VSM is constructed as shown in Figure 4 predicted that 50% NVD time of raw material inventory and shoe
which reported a promising reduction in NVD time and lead time production steps could be reduced. The 80% NVD time of sewing,
with improved PCE and up time. Table 4 outlines the value stream pre-lasting, pot-lasting and finishing steps could be reduced after
analysis report of casual shoe production line for the future state. the implementation of lean tools. At future state, the total labour is
It is found that after the implementation of lean tools PCE will be found17, but it was 25 at present state i.e. after the implementation
improved at internationally competitive level. Based on intense of lean tools at least 07labors could be the relief for another work.
observation, brainstorming and previous regarding studies it is Then up time of sewing, lasting and finishing machine is found
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh.
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
22
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
consecutively 96%, 95% and 93% while it was consecutively 82%, at future state, the promising outcomes bring with the reduction
77% and 66% at present state. At future state, it is also found the of labour, NVD time and lead time, and improved uptime and PCE.
PCE will be 34.05% while it was 15.28% at present state. Therefore,
Table 4: Future lead time of casual shoe production line.
Expected PCE at future state production. Throughout this study, it was tried to reduce the takt
time. At future state, after the adoption of lean tools, the takt time
At future state, it is expected that after the proper
is found 12.89sec while at present state production phenomenon it
implementation of lean tools NVD time from 84600sec to 29580sec
was found 13.19sec.
and thus the lead time would be reduced from 99870sec to
44850sec. As earlier, it is mention that PCE is measured as the Achievement of lean tools adoption
percentage of the ratio of VD time and lead time and consequently
A promising achievement is predicted with the reduced NVD
at future state, the PCE is found 34.05% which is considered as the
time, lead time and takt time, and improved PCE. An improvement
internationally competitive level 25% [19].
comparison between present and future state is given in the
Expected takt time of future state following Figure 5. At future state, it is seen that the NVD time will
be reduced 65.03%, lead time will be reduced 55.03%, takt time
In earlier, it is mentioned that takt time is the heartbeat of a
will be reduced 2.73% and PCE will be improved 122.84%. But all
production process line. Takt time is the time that needs to produce
of these alluring achievements basically depend on the successful
a single unit of production. As it is lower indicates the faster of
implementation of proposed lean tools.
Technology Assessments range and innovation scope of studied footwear industry [36,37]
(Figure 6) (Table 5).
Assessment of technology system components sophistication
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh. 23
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
Figure 6: Assessment of technology system components sophistication range and innovation scope of studied footwear industry.
Table 5: Revised the scoring table for assessing degree of sophistication of THIOs using a 9-point overlapping scoring scale with 10 for
ideal best.
Technology Low Primitive Score: Medium traditional High modern Score: Top Emerging Score:
Ideal Best Score: 10
Components 1-2-3 Score: 3-4-5 5-6-7 7-8-9
Assessment of product market value using integrated business and technology strategies of Casual shoe [36,37] (Figure 7).
Figure 7: Assessment of product market value using integrated business and technology strategies of Casual shoe.
Conclusion improving the PCE by using of lean tools. It focuses the renovation
of operations by eliminating the NVD time and lead time and
This study provides a case analysis of the improvement of
improving the PCE through VSM, Pareto Analysis, 5S, and JIT. In a
a Casual shoe production line by reducing the lead time and
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh.
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503
24
Aspects in Mining & Mineral Science Aspects Min Miner Sci
nutshell, it is inferred that a set of lean tool is an effective way to 17. Pavlović K, Božanić V (2012) Lean and six sigma concepts. International
identify and eliminate the manufacturing NVD activities and time. Journal for Quality Research 6(1): 615.
2. Sayid Mia MA, Alam NM, Ahmad F, Uddin KM (2017) Footwear industry 20. Rother M, Shook J (1999) Learning to see: Value stream mapping to add
in Bangladesh: Implementation of six sigma methodology. Industrial value and eliminate muda. The Lean Enterprise Institute Inc, USA.
Engineering & Management 6: 211. 21. McDonald T, Aken EM, Rentes AF (2002) Utilizing simulation to enhance
3. Womack JP, Jones DT, Roos D (1991) The machine that changed the value stream mapping: A manufacturing case application. International
world. Harper Collins Publishers, USA. Journal of Logistics Research and Applications 5(2): 213-232.
4. Hobbs DP (2003) Lean manufacturing implementation: A complete 22. Frandsen A, Berghede K, Tommelein ID (2014) Takt-time planning and
execution manual for any size manufacturer. J Ross Publishing USA, p. the last planner. Production Planning and Control Proceedings, Norway.
264. 23. Pareto V (1935) Trattato di sociologia generale firenze engl: The mind
5. Abdullah F, Rajgopal J (2003) Lean manufacturing in the process and society dover.
industry. Proceedings of the IIE Research Conference Portland, USA. 24. Kimber RJ, Grenier, Robert W, Heldt JJ (1997) Quality management
6. Ahmad M, Dhar N, Benson R, Burgess B (2005) Model for establishing handbook.
theoretical targets at the shop floor level in specialty chemicals 25. Dyche J (2002) The CRM handbook: A business guide to customer
manufacturing organizations. Robotics and Computer-Integrated relationship management.
Manufacturing 21(4-5): 391-400.
26. Arthur LJ (1992) Rapid evolutionary development-requirements,
7. Melton T (2005) The benefits of lean manufacturing: What lean thinking prototyping & software creation, John Wiley & Sons, USA.
has to offer the process industries. Chemical Engineering Research and
Design 83(6): 662-673. 27. Sayid AM, Alam NE, Murad ABM, Ahmad F, Uddin MK, et al. (2017)
Waste management & quality assessment of footwear manufacturing
8. Radnor Z (2000) Changing to a lean organization: The case of a industry in Bangladesh: An innovative approach. International Journal
chemicals company. International Journal of Manufacturing Technology of Engineering and Management Research 7(4): 402-407.
and Management 1(4-5): 444-454.
28. Harry MJ (1998) Six sigma: A breakthrough strategy for profitability.
9. Cook RC, Rogowski RA (1996) Applying JIT principles to continuous Quality Progress 31(5): 60-64.
process manufacturing supply chains. Production and Inventory
Management Journal 12-16. 29. Tsuchiya K, Soon F (2008) The practice of good housekeeping (5s &
kaizen). Singapore Productivity and Standards Board, Singapore.
10. Billesbach JT (1994) Applying lean production principles to a processing
facility. Production and Inventory Management Journal 40-44. 30. Womack JP, Jones DT, Ross D (1990) The machine that changed the
world. Macmillan Publishing Company, Canada.
11. Abdullah F, Rajgopal J, Needy KL (2002) A taxonomy of the process
industry with a view to lean manufacturing. Proceedings of the American 31. Monden Y (1998) Toyota production system-an integrated approach to
Society for Engineering Management Florida 314-321. just-in-time. (3rd edn), Engineering & Management Press, Georgia.
12. Abdelmalek F, Rajgopal J, Needy KL (2006) A classification model for 32. Inman R, Bulfi RL (1991) Sequencing of JIT mixed-model assembly lines.
the process industry to guide the implementation of lean. Engineering Management Science 37: 901-904.
Management Journal 18(2). 33. Feld WM (2000) Lean manufacturing: Tools, techniques, and how to use
13. Kumar RD, Mohanram PV, karthik SG (2011) Process cycle efficiency them, The St. Lucie Press, London.
improvement through lean: A case study. International Journal of Lean 34. Nahmias S (2001) Production and operations analysis, fourth ed.
Thinking 2(1): 46-58. McGraw-Hill, USA.
14. Womack JP, Daniel TJ (1996) Lean thinking: Banish waste and create 35. Tajiri M, Gotoh F (1992) TPM implementation: A Japanese approach
wealth in your corporation, USA. McGrawHill Inc., USA.
15. Sayid Mia MA, Alam MN, Uddin KM (2017) Footwear industry in 36. Mia AS, Alam NE, Uddin MK Court shoe production line: Improvement
Bangladesh: Reduction of lead time by using lean tools. JECET 6(3): 251- of process cycle efficiency by using lean tools. Leather and Footwear
259. Journal Balkans, Romania.
16. Young HK, Frank TA (2006) Benefits, obstacles, and future of six sigma 37. Sharif NM (2012) Fundamentals of technological innovation for global
approach. Technovation 23(5-6): 708-715. competition. Book of knowledge viewgraphs.
Volume 1 - Issue - 1
How to cite this article: Md Abu S M, Md Nur-E-Alam, Farid A, Kamal U M. Implementation of Lean Manufacturing Tools in Footwear Industry of Bangladesh. 25
Aspects Min Miner Sci. 1(1). AMMS.000503. 2017. DOI: 10.31031/AMMS.2017.01.000503