Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CME EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVE: Readers will recognize hand, foot, and mouth disease, identify the key clinical
CREDIT findings in adults, and triage more severe cases
A B
C D
FIGURE 1. (A) Palmar lesions in a previously healthy 16-month-old boy, typical of those
seen in hand, foot, and mouth disease (HFMD). He also had features of atypical HFMD in
that he presented with an eruption resembling eczema herpeticum, with lesions negative
The United for herpes simplex virus 1 and 2 by polymerase chain reaction testing. (B) Sole of the foot
States has of the same patient. (C) Hard- and soft-palate lesions in a 31-year-old man diagnosed with
HFMD who also had concomitant vesicular lesions on his palms and soles. (D) Onychoma-
had several desis in a 3-year-old boy diagnosed with HFMD.
outbreaks in
has had several outbreaks in the last 3 years.
the last 3 years ■■ OUTBREAKS AROUND THE WORLD Although HFMD is not one of the diseases
The disease was first described more than 40
years ago, with several large outbreaks in the that must be reported to public health au-
last 16 years. thorities in the United States, from Novem-
1998—An outbreak in Taiwan affected ber 2011 to February 2012 the US Centers
more than 1.5 million people, mostly children. for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
Severe cases numbered just over 400, and 78 received reports of 63 possible cases: 38 in
children died.4 Alabama, 17 in Nevada, 7 in California, and
2008—China,5 Singapore,6 Vietnam,7 Mon- 1 in Connecticut.1 Fifteen of the patients were
golia,8 and Brunei9 were stricken with an out- adults, and more than half had contacts who
break that affected 30,000 people and led to were sick.
more than 50 deaths. The most recent US outbreak, in Ala-
2009—An outbreak in the Henan and bama,12 was atypical because it occurred in the
Shandong provinces of eastern China killed 35 winter.
people.10
2010—In several southern Chinese re- ■■ CAUSED BY ENTEROVIRUSES
gions, more than 70,000 people were infected, HFMD is caused by infection with a variety
with almost 600 deaths.11 of viruses in the genus Enterovirus, a large
2011 to the present. The United States group that in turn is part of the larger Picorna-
538 CLEV ELA N D C LI N I C JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOL UME 81 • N UM BE R 9 S E P T E M BE R 2014
REPASS AND COLLEAGUES
TABLE 1
Oral ulcers: Differential diagnosis of hand, foot, and mouth disease
Hand, foot, and Aphthous ulcers Herpetic
mouth disease Herpangina (“canker sores”) gingivostomatitis
Cause Coxsackievirus A16 Coxsackievirus A Unclear Herpes simplex
Enterovirus 71 virus 1
Consider systemic disease
Others
(Behçet, human immuno-
deficiency virus infection)
Age group Children younger than Children ages 3 to 10 More common in children Infants and young
age 10 and adult con- and adolescents children
tacts
Typical features Vesicles that become Ulcers that affect the Painful, shallow ulcers Tendency to coalesce
ulcers pharynx, tonsils, and surrounded by erythema
Perioral vesicular
soft palate.
Involvement of the Tendency to remain lesions common
tongue, palate, Little tendency to bleed isolated
Gingivae bleed easily
and buccal mucosa
Not present in keratinized
Prodromal symptoms
surfaces
include fever
Recurrent aphthous
stomatitis is the most
common cause of oral
ulcers
Seasonal Spring and early Summer and early No No
incidence summer fall
viridae family.13 The taxonomy of this genus isolated a strain of coxsackievirus A6 that
is complicated and subject to revision; species caused extensive rash and nail shedding.15
include coxsackieviruses, polioviruses, entero- Among the 63 possible cases of HFMD report-
viruses, and echoviruses. They are all small, ed to the CDC from November 2011 to Febru-
nonenveloped, single-stranded RNA viruses. ary 2012, specimens for clinical testing were
The most common strains that cause obtained in 34, and 25 of those demonstrated
HFMD are coxsackievirus A16 and entero- coxsackievirus A6 infection.3
virus 71. In addition, coxsackievirus A6 may
be emerging, and many other coxsackievirus ■■ FEVER, ORAL ULCERS,
strains have been directly implicated, includ- RASH ON HANDS AND FEET
ing A5, A7, A9, A10, B2, and B5. The typical clinical manifestations of HFMD
Coxsackievirus A16 is the leading cause are fever, stomatitis with oral ulcers, and an
of HFMD. exanthem affecting the palms, soles, and other
Enterovirus 71 is the second most common parts of the body. These last less than 7 to 10
cause of HFMD and has also caused outbreaks. days, usually occur during the spring to fall
It usually results in benign disease. However, months, and have a benign course.
among the causes of HFMD, it is associated The incubation period is 3 to 5 days, with
with more prominent central nervous system a prodrome that may include fever, malaise,
involvement14 and is the most common cause abdominal pain, and myalgia before the onset
of viral meningoencephalitis in children. of oral and cutaneous findings. Painful oral ul-
Coxsackievirus A6. In December 2011, cers may precede the exanthem and can result
the California Department of Public Health in dehydration.16
CL EVEL AND CL I NI C J O URNAL O F M E DI CI NE V O L UM E 81 • NUM BE R 9 S E P T E M BE R 2014 539
HAND, FOOT, AND MOUTH DISEASE
TABLE 2
Skin rash: Differential diagnosis of hand, foot, and mouth disease
Hand, foot, and Erythema
mouth disease Varicella multiforme Drug eruption
Cause Coxsackievirus A16 Varicella-zoster virus Herpes simplex virus Exposure to drug
Enterovirus 71
Age group Children under the age Most cases in preadoles- Most cases age 20 to 40 Any
of 10 and adult contacts cent children
Typical features Exanthem affecting the Subcentimeter lesions Target lesions 1 to Morbilliform
palms and soles lasting associated with intense several centimeters in or maculopapular
less than 7 to 10 days, pruritus diameter exanthema most
sometimes preceded by common
Spreading from face
painful oral ulcers
and trunk to extremities Pruritus
(centrifugal)
Starts in the trunk
Vesicles with central and may spread
umbilication (“dewdrop to other areas
on a rose petal”) and
subsequent crusting
Does acyclovir help? Shelley et al36 treat- A16. Shelley et al proposed that acyclovir
ed 13 patients (12 children and 1 adult) with may enhance the antiviral effect of the pa-
acyclovir within 1 to 2 days of the onset of tient’s own interferon.36
the HFMD rash and reported that it was ben- Intravenous immunoglobulin has been
eficial, with significant relief of fever and skin used in severe cases during outbreaks in Asia,
lesions within 24 hours of starting therapy. with retrospective data showing a potential
These anecdotal results have not been rep- ability to halt disease progression if used before
licated, and acyclovir is not an established the development of cardiopulmonary failure.
treatment for HFMD. However, this has not been studied prospec-
If acyclovir does help, how does it work? tively and is not currently recommended.16 ■
Acyclovir, like other common antiviral medi-
cations, inactivates thymidine kinase, an en- ACKNOWLEDGMENT: We would like to thank Dr. Salvador
Alvarez of the Mayo Clinic Department of Infectious Disease
zyme produced by herpesviruses but not by and Dr. Donald Lookingbill of the Mayo Clinic Department of
HFMD-causing viruses like coxsackievirus Dermatology for their collaboration.