Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Book Review - City of Joy - LT Sen-1-1
Book Review - City of Joy - LT Sen-1-1
INTRODUCTION
3. The author of The City of Joy, Dominique Lapierre, 56, has written a
string of bestsellers. In 1960, Lapierre and American Larry Collins wrote a
book answering why Paris, condemned in 1944 to an apocalyptic destruction
by Hitler, escaped undamaged by the war. Is Paris Burning? became an
instant success. Seven years later, they produced...Or I'll Dress You in
Mourning, about the Spanish Civil War. In 1971 Lapierre and Collins wrote O
Jerusalem, the story of the birth of the state of Israel and of the beginning of
the Arab-Israeli conflict. In 1975 their Freedom at Midnight described life in
India at the end of British rule and the accession to independence of the
Indian and Pakistani people. The Fifth Horseman in 1980 became another
publishing success, translated into thirty languages.
5. Dominique Lapierre has touched many people through his life and
work. His first taste of fame followed the summer when he was 17 years old
and left Paris with US$30, worked aboard a ship, disembarked in the United
States and managed a 30,000-mile jaunt around North America. This
adventure led to Lapierre's first best-selling book, A Dollar for a Thousand
Miles. Since then, he has continuously searched for new messages and
stories. While completing military service in 1954, Lapierre met an American
soldier named Larry Collins. An everlasting friendship-and a valuable
partnership-sprang from this meeting. Years later, they would collaborate on
some of the century's most memorable books including Is Paris Burning?,
which was made into a major motion picture boasting 30 international
stars; ...Or I'll Dress You in Mourning, O Jerusalem, Freedom at Midnight, and
The Fifth Horseman, books read by millions of readers in more than 30
languages.
CRITICAL ANALYSIS
12. This story is about human beings who live in abject penury suffering
from a scourge of diseases, hunger, malnutrition, eunuchs but above all
“EXISTENCE”.
13. The book is covered in three chapters. It tells the readers about the
lives of an Indian man who works as a rickshaw puller, a doctor from the
United States and a polish priest. It takes place in one of the slums of
Calcutta, India.
14. Max Loeb is a Doctor from the USA who’s disillusion by his
luxurious life style in the States. This guilt he’s experiencing will not go away
while he is working in the western part of the USA so he decides to fulfill
himself in another way and goes to Calcutta to find some enlightenment. In
Calcutta he meets Stephen Kovalsky (Polish Priest) who has made it his
mission to help the people of Anand nagar (one of the slums in Calcutta). Its
an area where the poorest people of Calcutta live. Inside this area is a large
Leper colony (and they are shunned by the poor as well as the rich).
15. Despite the shocking condition of this place Max comes face to face
(for the first time in his life) with the people who really need his help and care
while he’s helping them, he sees that humanity and compassion can bloom in
the most devastating of places. It’s a sort of rejuvenation and resurrection for
the Doctor, as he says ‘The smiles of my brothers in the city of joy are the
lights that will never be extinguished in me”.
16. The life of Hasari Pal (a poor farmer) changes when he and his
family move to Calcutta. As Hasari looks for a better life, he gets a job pulling
a rickshaw. Here starts a gruelling story about the lives of people in a vicious
cycle of problems where each family member must work to have some shelter
and food.
4
17. The death of Hazari Pal at the end of the book doesn’t elicit a
cathartic feeling in the readers. But you feel for a Father who’s duty is to get
his daughter married even if it means selling his bones, flesh and blood after
his demise.
18. But Anand nagar (meaning the city of joy) is not in a state of
dystopia. One can sense the joy and fervour in the way people celebrate
festivals, weddings and other events (just as we do). But just that the reader
wishes that this spring of joy should be a little longer than the winters of
woe…
QUALITY OF PRESENTATION
19. The book is neatly designed, and is divided in three parts, the
aspects of which are covered in 72 chapters in paragraph format.
20. This book was originally written in French and has been translated
to English by Kathryn Spink. The presentation is impressive and lucid and the
language is well organized and easy to understand. The chapters have been
meticulously framed and the author made the subject more interesting and
reader friendly.
21. The book is a paperback edition. The quality of the paper used is
excellent and the binding is also very good. The cover of the book induces
interest among the readers to read the book the book is reasonably priced
and the clarity of print is commendable.
22. Effort put in by the author to assemble the subject was well
researched and is highly recognizable.
5
RECOMMENDATION
23. From the military point of view this book has no relevance however
its significance from the humanitarian point of view is unquestionable. This
book is a testament to the indominable human spirit unbowed by the most
disturbed circumstances.
24. Its heroes shows us how majestic the human spirit can be infact
CITY OF JOY redefines all our perspectives. This is a book of epic
proportions and an engrossing account of the fantastic battle of human
solidarity, fraternity and courage.
25. It shows the problems faced by the poor in India and the squalid
conditions in the Leper colony and slums of Calcutta.
CONCLUSION
29. The book of a few hundred pages may leave lasting impressions on
its readers and has truly succeeded in spreading hope and joy to millions of
readers, if not inspiring a few more selfless people to devote their lives to
helping the poor and downtrodden.
6
- Mother Teresa