Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Gary Olson
Abstract
Mirror neurons, the brain cells believed to be the basis for empathy, have
recently been identified in the human brain. And yet we’re left to explain the
disjuncture between this deep-seated, pre-reflective, moral intuition and the
paucity of actual empathic behavior, especially in certain cultures. I suggest
that answers may be found in the bidirectional connection between culture and
brain development.
Introduction
“Mirror neurons,” the brain cells many neuroscientists believe are the
basis for empathy, were discovered in macaque monkeys in 1996 (Gallese,
1996; Iacoboni, 2008, 2009; Rizzolatti and Sinigaglia, 2008). Located in area F5
of the premotor cortex, these neurons fired not only when the monkey
performed an action but also when it was watching the same action. The
monkey’s neurons were “mirroring” the activity she was observing.
Later, the existence of mirror neurons in the human brain was strongly
inferred by Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) but proof remained
elusive. Now, for the first time, we have direct recorded evidence for their
presence. Roy Mukamel and colleagues (Mukamel et al., 2010) recorded their
data from the medial frontal and temporal cortices in 21 patients (with their
consent) awaiting surgery for intractable epileptic seizures at UCLA’s Medical
Center. The researchers “piggybacked” onto intracranial depth electrodes
implanted into the patient’s brains as part of a search for a potential surgical
treatment. The research team recorded activity in 1,177 neurons in the 21
patients and concluded that “these findings suggest the existence of multiple
systems in the brain endowed with neural mirroring mechanisms for flexible
integration and differentiation of the perceptual and motor aspects of actions
performed by self and others.”
The mirror neurons in the same affective brain circuits are automatically
mobilized upon feeling one’s own pain and the pain of others and this neural
circuitry is the basis of empathic behavior in which actions in response to the
distress of others is virtually instantaneous. Valayanur Ramachandran, director
of the Center for Brain and Cognition at the University of California at San Diego
(UCSD) observes that “We used to say, metaphorically, that ‘I can feel
another’s pain,’ but now we know that my mirror neurons can literally feel your
pain” (Slack, 2007). Ramachandran, who terms them “empathy neurons” or
“Dalai Lama neurons,” writes that “In essence the neuron is part of a network
that allows you to see the world from the other person’s point of view, hence
the name ‘mirror neuron’” (Ramachandran, 2006). Where comparable
experience is lacking, “cognitive empathy” allows one to “actively project
oneself into the shoes of another person” by trying to imagine the other
person’s situation (Preston, 2002; Preston et al., 2007; Singer & Lamm, 2009).
This “ability to perceive, appreciate, and respond to the affective states of
another” emerges as early as two years of age as the child becomes aware of
another’s emotional experience (Decety and Michalska, 2009; Decety, 2008;
Decety et. al., 2008; Tomasello, 2009)).
I’ve been pondering the nature of empathy for over two decades, initially
as a pedagogical challenge and later, given advances in neuroscience as a
broader field of inquiry (Olson, 1987, 2008). And for me, one of the most
vexing questions that remains to be explained, and the burden of this paper is
to ask why, if “. . . we are not alone, but are biologically wired and evolutionarily
designed to be deeply interconnected with one another” (Iacoboni, 2008, p.
266), so little progress has been made in extending this empathic orientation
toward distant lives, to those outside certain in-group moral circles? Given a
world rife with overt and structural violence, one is forced to explain why our
deep-seated moral intuition doesn’t produce a more ameliorating effect, a
more peaceful world?
Finally, in that context, there would seem to be a cautionary note here for
scientists as intellectuals. Crehan argues “Gramsci’s concern is always with the
process by which power is produced and reproduced or transformed and how
intellectuals fit within this rather than with individual intellectuals themselves”
(p. 143). A cultural neuroscience or neuro-anthropology that fails to account
for class will have, at best, no explanatory value and, at worst, further obfuscate
reality under the guise of value-free scientific inquiry.
References
Butler, E. A., Lee, T. L., and Gross, J. J. (2007) “Emotion Regulation and Culture:
Are the Social Consequences of Emotion Suppression Culture-
Specific?” Emotion, 7, 1, 30-48.
Chiao, J. Y., Harada, T., Komeda, H., Li, Z., Mano, Y., Saito, D., Parrish, T.B.,
Sadato, N., and Iidaka, T. (uncorrected proof). Dynamic Cultural
Influences on Neural Representations of the Self.
Chiao, J. Y., Harada, T., Komeda, H., Li, Z., Mano,Y., Saito, D., Parrish, T. B.,
Sadato,N. and Iidaka, T. (2009) “Neural Basis of Individualistic and
Collectivistic Views of Self.” Human Brain Mapping 00:000-000 (2009),
pp. 1-8.
Choudhury, S. (2009) “Culturing the adolescent brain: What can neuroscience
learn from anthropology?” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience,
December 2, 2009, 1-9.
Decety, J., Mihalska, K. J. and Akitsuki, M. (2008) “Who caused the pain? An
fMRI investigation of empathy and intentionality in children,”
Neuropsychologia, 46, 2607-2614.
de Waal, Interview (2007) “Frans de Waal,” Interview with Tamler Sommers, The
Believer, 5, 7, n.p.
de Waal, F. B. M. (2008) “Putting the Altruism Back into Altruism: The Evolution
of Empathy,” Annual Review of Psychology, 59: 279-300.
Dinstein, I., Thomas, C., Behrmann, M., and Heeger, D. J. (2008) “A Mirror to
Nature,” Current Biology, 8, 1.
Nature,” Current Biology, 8, 1.
Dominguez, D. J. F., Turner, R., Lewis, E. D., and Egan, G. F. (2009) “The brain in
culture and culture in the brain: A review of core issues in
neuroanthropology.” In: J. Y. Chaio (Ed.) Progress in Brain Research, 78,
43-64.
Gallese, V., Fadiga, L., and Rizzolatti, G. (1996) “Action recognition in the
premotor cortex.” Brain, 1192: 593-609.
Hedden, T., Ketay, S., Aron, A., Markus, H. R., and Gabrieli, J. D. E. (2008)
“Cultural Influence on Neural Substrates of Attentional Control,”
Psychological Sciences, 19, 1, 12-17. (on line 26 Dec. 2007),
DOI:10,1111/j1467-9280.2008.02038x.
Henrich, N. and Henrich, J. (2007) Why Humans Cooperate. New York: Oxford
University Press.
Hickok, G. (2009) “Eight Problems for the Mirror Neuron Theory of Action
Understanding in Monkeys and Humans,” Journal of Cognitive
Neuroscience, 21, 7, pp. 1229-1243.
Iacoboni, M. (2008) Mirroring People. New York: Farrar, Strauss and Giroux.
Kitayama, S., Karasawa, M., and Mesquita, B. (2004) “Collective and personal
processes in regulating emotions: Emotion and self in Japan and the
United States.” In: Philiippot and R. S. Feldman (Eds.) The Regulation of
Emotion (pp. 251-273). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Lewontin, R. C., Rose, S., and Kamin, L. J. (1984) Not In Our Genes. New York:
Pantheon Books.
Losin, E. A. R., Dapretto, M., and Iacoboni, M. (2009) “Culture in the mind’s
mirror: How anthropology and neuroscience can inform a model of the
neural substrate for cultural imitative learning.” In: J. Y. Chaio (Ed.),
Progress in Brain Research, pp. 175-190. Elsevier Press.
Mauss, I. B., Bunge, S. A., and Gross, J. J. (2008) “Culture and Automatic
Emotion Regulations.” In: M. Vandekerckhove, C. von Scheve, S. Ismer,
S. Jung, and S. Kronast (Eds.), Regulating Emotions, pp. 39-60. London:
Blackwell.
Miller, W. (1999) “Social Change and Human Nature,” Monthly Review, 50, No.
9.
Molnar-Szakacs, I., Wu, A., Robles, F. and Iacoboni, M. (2007a) “Do You See
What I Mean? Corticospinal Excitability During Observation of Culture
Specific Gestures,” PLoS ONE, 2(7): e626,
DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0000626.
Mukamel, R., Ekstrom, A. D., Kaplan, J., Iacoboni, M. and Fried, I. (2010)
“Single-Neuron Responses in Humans During Execution and
Observation of Actions,” Current Biology.
DOI:10.1016/j.cub.2010.02.045.
Parenti, M. (2006) The Culture Struggle. New York: Seven Stories Press.
Ramachandran, V. (2006) “Mirror Neurons and the Brain in the Vat,” Edge,
January 10, 2006.
www.edge.org/3rdculture/ramachandran06/Ramachandran06index.html+jam.
Rizolatti, G. and Sinigalia, C. (2008) Mirrors in the Brain. New York: Oxford
University Press.
Sherman, D. K., Kim, H.S. and Taylor, S. E. (2009) “Culture and social support:
Neural bases and biological impact.” In: J. Y. Chaio (Ed.), Progress in
Brain Research, 178, pp. 227-237. Elsevier Press.
Stout, S. (2006) The Sociopath Next Door. New York: Broadway Books, 2006.
Tangney, J. P., Stuewig, J. and Mashek, D. J. (2007) “Moral Emotions and Moral
Behavior,” Annual Review of Psychology, 58: 345-72.