Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RUMOURS
insightsonindia.com/2020/03/20/rstv-the-big-picture-section-505-tackling-rumours
Introduction:
1/4
Delhi police got over 3,000 distress calls from people panicked over riot-related rumours
like violence, arson and stone pelting across the national capital. Around one-fifth of
these calls on the emergency 100 and 112 numbers came from Shaheen Bagh in South
East Delhi and nearby areas in South Delhi. Panic gripped residents across the national
capital following false rumours of violence but the police denied any incident and
appealed for calm. Besides the PCR calls, several people from within Delhi as well as
outside called up police officials, including officers, directly to verify information about
violence breaking out, the officer added. The rumours prompted senior police officers to
come on ground and quell the hoax while also taking to social media to control panic.
The Delhi Metro Rail Corporation also shut down the entry and exit gates of seven metro
stations but did not give any reason. The stations were reopened later. The police said it
was closely monitoring the social media accounts spreading fake news or rumours and
action will be taken against them
2/4
It does not amount to an offence, within the meaning of this section, when the
person making, publishing or circulating any such statement, rumour or report,
has reasonable grounds for believing that such statement, rumour or report is true
and makes, publishes or circulates it in good faith and without any such intent
as aforesaid.
The speed and reach of social media has meant that subversive rumours and fake
news get aired with impunity.
This has resulted in serious law and order problems. In India, this phenomenon
has assumed dangerous proportions.
Fake news on WhatsApp has led to lynchings and communal flare-ups in many
parts of the country. This menace needs to be curbed.
Too stringent a policy of policing social media could violate the individual’s right
to privacy.
3/4
It’s not easy to force Facebook Inc., the owner of WhatsApp, to give up on the app’s
unique selling proposition to the user of complete end-to-end confidentiality.
Messaging platforms act as mere conduits for encrypted information.
They deny decrypting or intercepting messages sent through their platforms.
Traceability would undermine end-to-end encryption, weaken consumer privacy
and cybersecurity.
Since WhatsApp users converse outside Indian boundaries, the storage of a foreign
user’s data could come with its own jurisdiction issues.
Asking a foreign company to establish an entity in India is only asking for greater
control without clearly identifying the potential harm.
WhatsApp’s recent decision to restrict forwarding of messages to five users may
only have limited impact in curtailing rumours.
4/4