Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Iodo Povidona
Iodo Povidona
Pseudomonas cepacia
RUTH L BERKELMAN, M.D.; SHARON LEWIN, M.D.; JAMES R. ALLEN, M.D.; ROGER L ANDERSON,
Ph.D.; LAWRENCE D. BUDNICK, M.D.; STANLEY SHAPIRO, M.D.; STEPHEN M. FRIEDMAN, M.D.;
PETER NICHOLAS, M.D.; ROBERT S. HOLZMAN, M.D.; and ROBERT W. HALEY, M.D.; Atlanta,
Georgia; and New York, New York
Pseudomonas cepacia was recovered from the blood Materials and Methods
cultures of 52 patients in four hospitals in New York over EPIDEMIOLOGIC INVESTIGATION
7 months from April through October 1 9 8 0 . At City Hospital Center at Elmhurst we reviewed blood cul-
Epidemiologic investigation in one hospital indicated that ture log books for January through October 1980 to identify all
the positive results of blood culture represented Pseudomonas isolates and all bacteriology reports for June
pseudobacteremias and implicated a 1 0 % povidone- through October to identify isolates of P. cepacia from sites
iodine solution used as an antiseptic and disinfectant other than blood. We further reviewed medical records of all
(Pharmadine; Sherwood Pharmaceutical Company, patients with blood cultures positive for P. cepacia and abstract-
Mahwah, New Jersey) as the source of contamination. ed information on age, sex, underlying illnesses, indications for
Physicians who drew blood cultures positive for P. cepacia blood cultures, and use of intravenous therapy and medications.
were more likely to have left povidone-iodine on the skin We interviewed pharmacy and central supply personnel about
before venipuncture (p=0.026) and were more likely to distribution of supplies to the various areas of the hospital and
have applied povidine-iodine to the blood culture bottle laboratory personnel about methods for processing and han-
tops and to have left it there while inoculating the blood dling blood culture specimens.
culture media ( p = 0 . 0 0 7 ) than those who drew cultures
We conducted a case-control study at City Hospital Center at
negative for P. cepacia. Direct inoculation of Pharmadine
Elmhurst to ascertain whether blood cultures positive for P.
into brain-heart infusion broth yielded P. cepacia;
cepacia were significantly associated with the medical service.
however, 2 weeks after the first cultures, the same
We used a table of random numbers to select 118 control cul-
Pharmadine bottles were culture negative. The iodine
tures from the 2360 blood cultures obtained between 30 June
concentrations of the contaminated Pharmadine solutions
and 4 October 1980. We excluded six cultures from final analy-
were similar to those of 1 0 % povidone-iodine solutions
sis: two that were positive for P. cepacia, one that was actually a
distributed by other manufacturers.
pleural fluid culture, and three for which service was not re-
corded. We compared the bacteriology reports of the remaining
P O V I D O N E - I O D I N E SOLUTION is widely used in hospitals 112 with those of the 17 cultures positive for P. cepacia to
and other health care institutions as a skin and mucous identify differences in services of origin.
A questionnaire was administered to 35 medical and 12 pe-
membrane antiseptic and as a disinfectant. Unlike other diatric house staff working during the investigation. Only the
classes of antiseptics and disinfectants (1), povidone- responses of the 30 medical and 10 pediatric house staff who
iodine solutions have not previously been reported to be indicated that they routinely obtained one or more blood cul-
intrinsically contaminated. tures per week were included in the epidemiologic analysis. We
compared the blood culturing techniques of the medical house
In October 1980, City Hospital Center at Elmhurst
staff with those of the pediatric house staff and the techniques of
reported to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) that the medical house staff who had drawn the cultures positive for
17 blood cultures obtained over the preceding 3 months P. cepacia with those who had not drawn cultures positive for
were positive for Pseudomonas cepacia. An epidemiolog- the organism.
ic investigation was conducted by hospital personnel, the We telephoned infection control personnel at 27 hospitals in
the New York City area, including all those with more than 500
New York City Department of Health, and C D C at this
beds, and requested them to review their microbiology laborato-
hospital and subsequently at three other New York City ry records for 1980 to identify all isolates of P. cepacia. In the
hospitals identified as having had clusters of blood cul- three hospitals that identified five or more blood cultures posi-
tures positive for P. cepacia over the previous 6 months. tive for P. cepacia, we reviewed the medical records of all pa-
We describe herein the epidemiologic investigation that tients with cultures positive for P. cepacia. Techniques and
products used at each of these hospitals were compared to iden-
implicated contaminated povidone-iodine solution pro- tify those used in common.
duced by one manufacturer (Pharmadine; Sherwood
Pharmaceutical Company, Mahwah, New Jersey) as the LABORATORY STUDIES
source of the problem and that established that the posi- Available blood isolates from three hospitals and isolates re-
covered from povidone-iodine solutions were identified by stan-
tive blood cultures were pseudobacteremias (that is, false-
dard biochemical testing (2) in the Epidemiologic Investigations
positive results of blood culture). We also present find- Laboratory Branch, Bacterial Diseases Division, Center for In-
ings of subsequent laboratory studies that have further fectious Diseases, CDC. Kirby-Bauer antimicrobial susceptibili-
defined the problem. ty testing (3) was done on all isolates identified as P. cepacia.
The following special laboratory studies also were done.
• F r o m the Hospital Infections Branch a n d Epidemiologic Investigations Labora- Isolation of Pseudomonas cepacia from Povidone-lodine So-
tory Branch, Bacterial Diseases Division, Center for Infectious Diseases, Centers lutions: Fifty-four bottles of Pharmadine solution and 11 sets of
for Disease Control, Atlanta, Georgia; a n d M t . Sinai Services at City Hospital Pharmadine swabsticks (Sherwood Pharmaceutical Company)
Center at Elmhurst, M t . Sinai School of Medicine; N e w York City D e p a r t m e n t of
Health; a n d Bellevue Hospital Center, N e w York University School of Medicine, from 19 manufacturing lots were obtained from the stock of
New York, N e w York. three of the hospitals investigated and were examined for the
32 Annals of Internal Medicine. 1981;95:32-36. ©1981 American College of Physicians