Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COM 1
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Index
2
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Options View
Markets are still volatile with mainline index NIFTY 50 on average making intra-day moves of 370 points in
April while it made 520-point moves in March. The VIX, a real-time volatility index of NIFTY closed at 49.74
on last Thursday and is still very high compared to its average historical values. And IV percentile, which
ranks the current VIX compared to its past values in 1 year, is still high around 93. Overall, volatility is still
high and markets are moving in a fast-paced manner in both directions.
Last week, in the newsletter I made the argument that it’s better to avoid short volatility options trades as
long as the IV percentile (IVP) stays above 90 and exit short volatility trades if IV percentile crosses above
90. To test this hypothesis, I did an options back-testing to see if this makes sense.
I did this options back-testing on NIFTY and BANKNIFTY with following conditions
• End-of-day (EOD) options data starting from 2014 to current was considered for this study.
• We enter a Short Straddle options strategy when IV Percentile crosses above 90 or crosses below 90.
This strategy involves selling 1 quantity each of at-the-money (ATM) put and call option. This
strategy gains from collapse in volatility and theta depreciation as time passes. If the underlying
moves much faster in one direction, then this strategy will lose.
• Trade is exited after 20 days or when 100% stop-loss is hit – whichever happens first.
3
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
The options back-testing results for Nifty show that the short straddle strategy gains smartly if placed when
IV percentile crosses below 90 and the same strategy makes losses if placed when IV percentile crosses
above 90. Though both strategy conditions show comparable win rates, the second strategy (IVP crosses
above 90) has larger average losses compared to the average gains made while in the case of first strategy
(IVP crosses below 90) the average gains made were almost equal to average losses but due to higher win
rate, the strategy as a whole showed decent returns.
4
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
The options back-testing result for Banknifty short straddle strategy shows that this strategy performs
equally well both when IVP crosses above 90 or IVP crosses below 90 with comparable results characteristics
like average returns, profit factor and win rate.
Take away
The options back-testing results show that in Nifty it is better to avoid short volatility trades like short
straddle when IVP crosses above 90 and in Banknifty it doesn’t make any big difference if the short straddle
is placed when IVP crosses above or below 90. This can be due to Nifty being a low volatile balanced index
with stocks from diverse industries while Banknifty being a highly volatile bank specific index.
- Raghunath Reddy
5
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Short-term price structure is bullish. A super pattern has got triggered above moving average and bullish
count cluster is open.
6
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
X%-Breadth indicator of Nifty 50 is at 98%. Meaning, almost all stocks of Nifty are in bullish swing. Not only
Nifty index but breadth of all sectors is also at extreme levels, it is at 100%. Meaning, all sectors are in
bullish swing.
Most of them are above 90%. Meaning, there is a strong participation in this uptrend but it also indicates
exhaustion. Long-term trend being down, a caution needs to be applied when breadth is in the overbought
zone.
Such extreme levels of breadth can be followed by price or time correction. If a trend is strong, it will lead to
some short-term consolidation that will correct the breadth. Till then, position size can be reduced. If trend
reverses, we will get the bearish pattern on the price chart to trade.
If trend reverses, look for continuation pattern in relatively weak stocks or sectors - they could not perform
even when Nifty did well.
7
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Follow-through
Follow-through is very simple yet effective tool of price pattern trading. In TradePoint software, there is a
scanner follow-through to all types of price patterns. Every follow-through pattern also opens vertical count.
Follow-through scanner will show list of bullish and bearish stocks with open vertical counts as shown in
below table.
8
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Sector Performance
Below is a table showing current performance and breadth of all sectors. It is calculated on different
timeframes, and higher timeframe has given more weightage in the method.
9
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
The Nifty has seen a sharp rally of 20.3% from the March 23 low of 7,610. Not many would have anticipated
this kind of a sharp pull back. And, if this kind of a rally was not anticipated, there is a slim possibility that
many would have participated in it.
The feeling now with many stock market participants would be: Have I missed the bus? Is the market going
to run away without me?
These are logical questions but once you have an objective method to assess the underlying conditions and
devise a plan accordingly, then the job becomes easier thereafter. You just have to diligently follow your
plan.
Let’s put the recent rally in perspective and understand how the market breadth has panned out and let’s
also consider if the rally is broad-based.
Here is the PF-X% breadth indicator capturing the Nifty 50 breadth across 3 box sizes – 1%, 3% & 5%.
In 1% & 3% box sizes, the breadth indicator has moved into overbought zone, indicating exhaustion. In the
5% box size, the indicator is in neutral zone at 56%.
Let’s also take a look at the breadth in Nifty 450 stocks (Nifty 500 minus the Nifty 50 stocks). Have a look at
the chart below.
10
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
It is positive to note that the recent rally has percolated to the broader universe as well with breadth
indicator for Nifty 450 basket venturing into the overbought zone in 1% box size.
What is even more promising is that the breadth indicator in 3% box size for the Nifty 450 stocks is also on
the verge of getting into the overbought zone. This suggests that the buying interest is not confined to
Nifty 50 stocks alone and it is much more broad-based.
If you look at the chart daily P&F chart of Nifty 50 index in 0.1% box size, the “set-up” has turned bullish and
there are open upside vertical counts too that are activated. The only cause of concern from the short-term
perspective is that the breadth in 1% box size is at an extreme zone. This might trigger some consolidation
or correction. Considering that the broader universe is also at or near extreme zone, it would make sense to
await a correction or consolidation before taking fresh exposures.
Have I missed the bus? The answer is a resounding No! Even assuming the best-case scenario of the worst
being over for the markets. In that case, Nifty 50 index would be expected to make new highs sooner than
later. But, remember price does not rally or fall in a linear or one-sided fashion.
There will be pull backs along the way, especially when the breadth reaches overbought zone. So, do not
get disheartened and look for opportunities. The short-term scenario looks bullish, but this can change as
quickly to bearish. Be conscious of that and have a well-defined exit plan.
Personally, am planning to take some exposure in Nifty 50 index when the breadth cools off to neutral zone
and if there is a fresh breakout in the index thereafter. My exit plan is a close below the recent swing low in
the P&F chart which is at 8,000. So, if I end up buying Nifty 50 ETF or an index fund, my exit will be when the
Nifty 50 index closes below 8,000. This is my plan and it suits my risk profile and investment horizon. It may
not necessarily suit your style. By all means chalk out a different plan and execute it. The key here is to have
a plan according to your requirements and more important is to execute it without any deviation.
- B. Krishnakumar
11
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Chart Studies
EQUITAS
Observations:
• Current formation on 1% box-value chart is probable bearish ABC with bearish 4 column triangle
breakout.
• There is a series of bearish anchor column from 105 levels and also one of the underperformers on
the RS chart.
• A close below 37 will trigger a fresh bearish pattern.
• Pattern will negate above 43.
12
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
BATAINDIA
Observations:
13
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
NMDC
Observations:
14
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
FEDERALBNK
Observations:
• Current formation on 1% box-value chart is Probable bearish ABC with Triangle formation.
• Price has taken resistance near 78.6% retracement level.
• A close below 39 will trigger a fresh bearish pattern.
• Pattern will negate above 43.
- Raju Ranjan
15
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
These price patterns can be made objective in Point & Figure chart by defining a condition ‘O’ at same level
or ‘X’ at same level as shown below.
16
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
In fact, it is the reason why these patterns are called as Double-top buy and Double-bottom sell.
‘X’ at same level pattern indicate that there is a resistance. One box above the previous high will trigger a
breakout. Same way, ‘O’ at same level shows that there is a demand pattern but one box below prior low
triggers a bearish breakout pattern.
But if breakout is not triggered - it shows that the supply (resistance) or demand (support) at that level is
significant. We need confirmation to define this pattern of support or resistance.
17
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
First possibility needs more confirmation and chart analysis. Second, is also known as ‘Double-top buy after
support’ and ‘Double-bottom sell after resistance’ patterns.
Scanners for these patterns are readily available in TradePoint in pre-defined scanner list and also in system
builder.
Below are some current chart examples showing breakout after pattern of support or resistance.
18
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
19
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
These patterns are applicable on all instruments, timeframes and box-values. We can scan for these
patterns, apply indicators and perform chart analysis to improve the probability of success.
These patterns can prove very useful on higher box-value charts because they show price is at long-term
support or resistance level. Have a look at below chart of HAVELLS.
20
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Box-value of above chart is 5%. The price has been in strong uptrend, but there were support formations
during the trend that gave pullback trading opportunities. It showed that price is retesting previous
important demand level.
These patterns on higher box-value charts can prove very useful for all types of traders and investors
including short-term traders.
Support or resistance on higher box-value indicates that important price point is being tested. If price turns
and produces another bullish column after support or bearish column after resistance on these box-values,
it can be a very significant impulsive move even for short-term or medium-term traders. It offers an
opportunity to participate in the trend after the pattern of reversal.
1) It will take time to confirm the reversal (Even column reversal on 5% box-value chart will need a reversal
move of 15%)
2) Stop-loss is not affordable on such type of higher box-value charts to take trade or invest based on them.
21
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
The support pattern turned to a column of ‘X’. The support was around 1125 levels.
A double-top buy on this chart got formed at 1175 levels, it was also a Low-pole follow-through pattern.
The long-term support that was seen at 1125 levels on higher box-value chart could be traded at 1175
levels on lower box-value chart.
22
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Below is another example:
We saw example of PNB earlier. Below is a chart showing the pattern on 0.25% box-value when resistance
pattern got formed on 5% box-value chart.
23
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
This simple pattern can prove very useful and scan-able on Point & Figure chart.
Long term support and resistances showing by higher box-value charts are more reliable. We can trade
them based on price patterns on lower box-values. They offer better risk reward opportunities.
Entry and exit should be as per the price pattern you are trading on lower box-value chart. For example, it is
double-top buy pattern on 0.25% chart that got triggered after ‘O’ at same level pattern on 5% box-value
chart – the stop-loss should be at double-bottom sell level on 0.25% chart or when the pattern you are
trading on 0.25% chart gets negated.
What if stop gets triggered for bullish pattern on lower box-value chart and support pattern is still
intact on higher box-value chart?
First of all, give yourself pat on the back for following the stop. It is good that you are out of the trade with
affordable stop. If another bullish pattern gets triggered and support pattern is still intact on higher box-
value chart – forget your past trade and enter again.
1) Run Point & Figure scanner for ‘O’ at same level on box-value 5%
2) Save the result in a group and give it a name. For example, group name is ‘Chal dekhte hai’ ☺
3) Run a scanner for Double-top buy on 0.25%v box-value on ‘Chal dekhte hai’ group.
1) Run Point & Figure scanner for ‘X’ at same level on box-value 5%
2) Save the result in a group and give it a name.
3) Run a scanner for Double-bottom sell on 0.25%v box-value on that group.
24
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Why 5%?
It is not a rigid requirement. I also check it on 8% or 10% box-values. You can experiment with other higher
box-values as well.
You can also take advantage of System Matrix tool here. Create a system ‘O’ at same level from system
builder. Then go to Matrix -> P&F System Matrix and select that condition on different box-values.
Below chart shows ‘O’ at same level pattern selected for 0.25%, 1%, 3%, 5% box-values. When result shows
1, pattern exists on that box-value. When result is 0, there is no pattern.
You can experiment with different box-values on this tool and also look for candidates at important support
or resistance levels on multiple box-values.
10% can be a useful box-value for mid-cap stocks because they have a higher volatility than the frontline
stocks in percentage terms.
Below is an example of a mid-cap chart on 10% box-value. We can look for breakout in their 1% box-value
when they are at important support levels on long-term chart.
25
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
Major P&F patterns such as ABC, trend lines, Anchor column follow-through or indicators etc can help you
to trade these candidates on lower box-value charts.
This can be a very useful method of finding candidates even when you are trading the stock on some other
charting method.
To know the breakout level in advance, you can also run scanner like ‘Not-double top buy’ or ‘Not double-
bottom sell’.
With this, we are trading very important reversals derived from higher box-value chart. We are going to
trade patterns and not assumptions. Hence, we know the entry, exit and pattern negation levels in advance.
Same thing is possible on Renko chart as well. By looking for setups bricks at same level. In the next release,
we will make scanner for ‘brick at same level’ available.
26
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
The setups discussed above are also applicable to Currency, Commodity and Mutual Fund schemes.
- Prashant Shah
27
DEFINEDGE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
DISCLAIMER
Investments in securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing.
The information and opinions in this report have been prepared by Definedge Research and are subject to change without any notice.
The report and information contained herein are strictly confidential and meant solely for the intended recipient and may not be
altered in any way, transmitted to, copied or redistributed, in part or in whole, to any other person or to the media or reproduced in
any form, without prior written consent of Definedge Research. The information and opinions contained in the research report have
been compiled or arrived at from sources believed to be reliable and have not been independently verified and no guarantee,
representation of warranty, express or implied, is made as to their accuracy, completeness, authenticity or validity. No information or
opinions expressed constitute an offer, or an invitation to make an offer, to buy or sell any securities or any derivative instruments
related to such securities. Investments in securities are subject to market risk. The investor is advised to take into consideration all risk
factors including their own financial condition, suitability to risk return profile and the like, and take independent professional and/or
tax advice before investing. Opinions expressed are our current opinions as of the date appearing on this report. Investor should
understand that statements regarding future prospects may not materialize and are of general nature which may not be specifically
suitable to any particular investor. Past performance may not necessarily be an indicator of future performance. Actual results may
differ materially from those set forth in projections. The information/ data herein alone are not sufficient and should not be used for
the development or implementation of an investment strategy. Any calculations made are approximations, meant as guidelines only,
which you must confirm before relying on them. The recipient(s) before acting on any information herein should make his/her/their
own investigation and seek appropriate professional advice and shall alone be fully responsible / liable for any decision taken on the
basis of information contained herein. Definedge Research, its research analysts, partners, officers, employees and associates accept
no liabilities for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of this report. The analyst hereby certifies that opinion expressed
in this research report accurately reflect his or her personal opinion about the subject securities and no part of his or her compensation
was, is or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendation and opinion expressed in this research report.
Definedge Solutions
28