You are on page 1of 6

Magazine

R1

red and green algae (and hence replaced almost all of the phycobilins
Primer embryophytic plants). Secondary (phycocyanin plus phycoerythin) by
endosymbioses of red and green chlorophyll b (or a variant thereof)
algae in other eukaryotes produced — one of these is the very small but
Algae further eukaryotic algae. Secondary very abundant warm-water marine
endosymbioses involving green algae cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus.
John A. Raven1 and Mario Giordano2 gave rise to the chloraracnhiophytes Chlorophyll b also occurs in green
and euglenoids, and those involving algae and embryophytes as well as in
Algae frequently get a bad press. red algae gave rise to apicomlexans. secondary endosymbioses involving
Pond slime is a problem in garden plus dinoflagellates, cryptophytes, green algae, the chlorarachniophytes
pools, algal blooms can produce haptophytes and heterokonts such and the euglenoids.
toxins that incapacitate of kill as brown algae and diatoms. Serial
animals and humans and even the secondary symbiotic events have Archaeplastida (Plantae):
term seaweed is pejorative — a been hypothesized for diatoms, with glaucocystophytes
weed being a plant growing in what an initial green algal endosymbiosis Glaucocystophytes are a small
humans consider to be the wrong followed by a red alga endosymbiosis. group of unicellular freshwater
place. Positive aspects of algae are Tertiary endosymbioses are also algae, demonstrated by molecular
generally less newsworthy — they known in dinoflagellates.The phylogenetic studies to be basal in
are the basis of marine food webs, phylogeny of algae is indicated in the Archaeplastida. These plastids
supporting fisheries and charismatic broad outline in Figure 1B, and the of these algae have similarities to
marine megafauna from albatrosses to first occurrence of cyanobacteria cyanobacteria in the peptidoglycan
whales, as well as consuming carbon and eukaryotic algae, as well as layer between the inner and outer
dioxide and producing oxygen. Here embryophytic plants and metazoans plastid envelope membranes, and
we consider what algae are, their and the rise in oxygen through time, phycobilisomes containing light-
diversity in terms of evolutionary are shown in Figure 2B. harvesting phycobilin pigments. These
origin, size, shape and life cycles, and phycobilisomes occur on the outer
their role in the natural environment Algal Diversity surface of the thylakoid membranes,
and in human affairs. Cyanobacteria (Cyanophyceae or as is the case for cyanobacteria
blue-green ‘algae’) and red algae, giving the
Defining algae The cyanobacteria resemble glaucocystophytes their blue-green
Algae are not readily defined. An eukaryotic algae in their physiology colour like that of many cyanobacteria
alga can be broadly described as and ecology, with the exception and some red algae.
an organism carrying out oxygen- that some of them can fix nitrogen
producing (oxygenic) photosynthesis without dependence on symbionts. Archaeplastida (Plantae):
that is not a ‘higher plant’ However, ultrastructural and then rhodophytes
(embryophyte). Figure 1A indicates molecular genetic studies clearly The rhodophytes are a large clade
oxygenic photosynthesis in terms of showed that cyanobacteria are of eukarotic algae — a few are
chemical substrates and products, gram-negative bacteria. It is unicellular, while most are multicellular
but not their stoichiometry. This now firmly established that the with many reaching a high level of
definition includes cyanobacteria and hypothesis proposed in the early complexity. As their name suggests,
eukaryotes in a number of clades twentieth century by Mereschowsky they are often red as a result of
with the eukaryotic algae originating that plastids of eukaryotic algae the presence of high levels of
from a symbiosis between a non- and of plants are derived from phycoerythrin. However, there are
photosynthetic eukaryotic cell and endosymbiotic cyanobascteria is also red algae, particularly those from
a photosynthetic cyanobacterium. correct. The term ‘blue-green’ (and fresh water, that are blue-green in
However, phylogenetic definitions ‘cyano-‘) comes from the colour colour, as well as some that are almost
of algae conflict with the ‘oxygenic of many cyanobacteria, resulting black. The mid-nineteenth century
photosynthesis’ part of the definition from the presence of phycocyanin Irish phycologist W.H. Harvey pointed
given above because there have been as a light-harvesting pigment out that the assigning of algae to the
multiple losses of the capacity for that absorbs red wavelengths. green, red and brown higher taxa is
photosynthesis. Such losses have also Others have phycoerythrin with best made on young stages in the
occurred in embryophytes, adding absorption in the green region of the life cycle of the larger organism. We
to the complexity of trying to define electromagnetic spectrum, between now know that this is because the
these lineages in functional terms. the blue and red absorption peaks smaller structures are optically thinner
While oxygenic photosynthesis is of chlorophyll a. Chlorophyll a is and therefore have a colour more
monophyletic, the eukaryotic algae are the light-harvesting pigment that closely related to their pigmentation
polyphyletic. This is explained by the also catalyses the photochemical and relatively unaffected by the self-
occurrence of serial endosymbioses. reactions of photosynthesis in all shading associated with the denser
The primary endosymbiosis oxygenic photosynthetic organisms, ‘packaging’ of pigments of older
giving rise to eukaryotic algae apart from a few cyanobacteria that specimens (‘package effect’). The
involved the incorporation of a have photochemistry catalysed by package effect is especially obvious
cyanobacterium by a eukaryote chlorophyll d that absorbs some in red algae with very thick thalli; in
to produce the chloroplasts of a radiation in the near infrared. Three these oganisms, pigment self-shading
clade including glaucocystophyte, clades of cyanobacteria have can result in almost complete photon
Current Biology Vol 24 No 13
R2

Figure 1. Algae.
(A) Schematic depiction of algal photosynthesis: algae carry out oxygenic photosynthesis; the term ‘oxygenic’ refers to the fact that algae, like
plant, generate O2 as a byproduct of water oxidation for the provision of electrons to the photosynthetic electron transport chain. CO2 fixation
occurs thanks to catalysis by the enzyme ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase (Rubisco), with consumption of the ATP and NADPH generated
using light as the energy source. (B) Summary of algal phylogeny: cyanobaceria were the first oxygenic organisms that then were involved in a
primary endosymbiotic event that gave rise to eukaryotic algae. Further secondary and tertiary endosymbioses generated other algal groups.
Descendents of the green algae, the charophytes are the progenitor of plants (embryophytes). Panel C, D and E describe the main modes of
reproduction of algae, which are capable of both asexual and sexual reproduction, with life cycles that may include a variable number of haploid
and diploid stages.

absorption across the visible spectrum chlorarachniophytes and euglenoids, to its morphogenesis, and recall the
that makes the thalli appear almost contain chlorophyll a as well as well aphorism attributed to Anton de Bary,
black. Finally, the red algae, and most as chlorophyll b. Some chlorophytes “The plant forms cells, not cells the
algae with plastids derived from red are unicellular, others are multicellular plant.” While it is the charophytes
algae by secondary endosymbiosis, and have significant complexity. rather than the chlorophytes that gave
have a form ID Rubisco. This was Some chlorophytes, with Caulerpa rise to embryophytic land plants, the
derived by horizontal gene transfer as the prime example, achieve a chlorophytes are the dominant taxon
from a proteobacterium, replacing the high level of differentiation with a of eukaryotic algae on land, both as
form IB Rubisco of cyanobacteria and superficial similarity to complex free-living organisms and in symbiosis
green algae and their derivatives the and rhizomatous embryophyte; with fungi as lichens.
chlorarachniophytes, euglenoids and differently from the embriophyte
embryophytes. they resemble, however, these Archaeplastida (Plantae):
organisms are unicellular or, perhaps charophytes (plus embryophytes)
Archaeplastida (Plantae): better, acellular. Such organisms Charophytes are predominantly
chlorophytes pose interesting challenges to the freshwater green algae, with some
The chlorophyte clade of green algae, view that differentiation among cells species inhabiting waters with large
like charophytes, embryophytes, within an organism is fundamental fluctuations in salt concentration,
Magazine
R3

or free-living on land. As the algal


clade ancestral to embryophytes,
charophytes are receiving particular
attention by practitioners of molecular
phylogenetics to determine the most
likely extant descendants of the algae
that gave rise to the embryophytes.
Thus far there is no conclusive
outcome to such analyses. Therefore,
there is no especially favoured role
for the largest and most highly
differentiated charophyte algae,
the Charales. These aquatic green
algae morphologically resemble
embryophytes such as the horsetails
(Equisetum spp.), but the internodes,
which are up to 100 mm long and 2 Figure 2. The evolution and diversity of algae.
mm in diameter, are single coenocytic (A) The size range of algae, homo sapiens is included for comparison. (B) Key events in the
biological history of Earth: cyanobacteria were largely responsible for the initial oxygenation of
cells — in some Chara species these
the planet, setting the stage for the subsequent evolutionary events that led to the radiation of
coenocytic cells are surrounded by the other algal groups and the appearance of metazoa and embryophytes.
much smaller corticating cells. This
arrangement, like that in the acellular
chlorophyte Caulerpa, facilitates the
movement of resources obtained by photosynthetic, apicomplexans, the diatoms are very probably the algal
different parts of the organism – that is marine Chomera and Vitrella have clade of marine phytoplankton that
nitrogen and phosphorus obtained by been described. is responsible for the largest fraction
rhizoids from sediment in great excess of primary productivity; diatoms are
of what is needed by the rhizoids, Alveolates: dinoflagellates also are common in fresh waters. The
and photosynthate that cannot be Dinoflagellates, the sister clade brown algae are almost all marine,
produced by rhizoids in sediments. to the apicomplexans, are a large and are ecologically dominant primary
group of mainly unicellular marine producers on rocky shores, especially
Rhizaria: chlorarachniophytes and freshwater organisms. Many in cooler environments. Larger
The marine unicellular dinoflagellates have lost their brown algae can appear very dark
chlorarchniophytes obtained their plastids and live as phagotrophs or brown, similar to the larger red algae
plastids from endosymbiosis parasites. The plastids of the basal appearing to be almost black. The
of a chlorophyte alga in non- dinoflagellates are derived from pigments of brown algae, like those
photosynthetic rhizarian cell. Other endosymbiotic red algae. However, of large optically dense chlorophyte
rhizarians are also photosynthetic; in a number of cases (tertiary algae such as larger species of
some acantharians, foraminiferans and endosymbiosis) these plastids have Caulerpa the brown algae have lower
radiolarians have endosymbitic algae, been replaced by plastids derived absorptance in the green relative to
predominantly dinoflagellates, while from other algae, including many that the blue and green than is the case for
the freshwater rhizarian euglyphid are photosynthetic by secondary phycosythrin-containing red algae.
amoeba Paulinella has endosymbiotic endosymbiosis. Others have
cyanobacteria (Synechococcus) that kleptoplastids, considered below. Chromista: haptophytes
are regarded by some as organelles, The haptophytes are mainly marine
although others disagree. Chromista: heterokontophytes and predominantly unicellular
(ochrophytes) algae. Their plastids were derived
Excavata: euglenoids The heterokontophytes are a diverse from secondary endosymbiosis
Euglenoids are a group of freshwater clade of eukaryotic algae, including of rhodophyte algae and their
and coastal marine flagellates, with secondarily non-photosynthetic pigmentation is generally similar
several genera that have lost the organims such as the oomycetes, to that of the other chromists. The
capacity for photosynthesis and a fungus-like group containing the marine phytoplanktonic haptophyte
grow by osmotrophy or phagotrophy. important plant parasite Phytophthora. Emiliania huxleyi is thought to be the
Their plastids, like those of The heterokontophytes obtained their globally most abundant (by number
chlorarachniophytes, are derived from plastids by secondary endosymbiosis of inividuals) eukaryotes, and it
endosymbiotic green algae. from a unicellular red alga, and they has been recently shown from size
retain the Form ID Rubisco of the fractionation, carotenoid pigments and
Alveolata: apicompexans red algae. The photosynthetic light- metagenomic studies that very small
The apicomplexans are mammalian harvesting complexes contain light haptophytes are very abundant in the
parasites with non-photosynthetic harvesting carotenoids and, with few marine phytoplankton.
plastids involved in some metabolic exceptions, chlorophyll c. Ecologically
processes such as the assembly very important heterokontophytes Chromista: cryptophytes
of iron-sulfur proteins. It is only include the diatoms and the brown Cryptophytes are unicellular flagellates
in the present century that basal, algae. The unicellular or filamentous in the plankton of marine and
Current Biology Vol 24 No 13
R4

freshwater habitats.As is very common charophytes and most red algae – can grow to up to 60 m long (Figure
in algae derived by secondary permitting (but not necessitating) 2A).
endosymbioisis of red algae, the transfer of resources from the One indicator of the extent of
cryptophytes have chlorophyllides parent to the zygote (matrotrophy). differentiation, or complexity, of
c as light-harvesting pigments. Many marine macroalgae have an multicellular algae is the number
However, they also have phycobilin alternation of phases (Figure 1E). of cell types. On this criterion, the
pigments that occur in solution in the There is a vegetative phase in their life multicellular brown and red algae (up
thylakoid lumen of the chloroplast cycle that is haploid (gametophyte) to 14 cell types) are more complex
rather than, as in cyanobacteria and and reproduces sexually; the than the multicellular green algae (up
glaucocystophyte and rhodophyte resulting zygote produces a diploid to 5 cell types), but are less complex
algae, in phycobilisomes on the outer vegetative phase (sporophyte) that than the embryophytes (up to 44 cell
surface of the thylakoids. undergoes meiosis, generating types).
haploid spores. The haploid spore
Algal reproduction regenerates the haploid vegetative The diversity of algal species and
Cyanobacteria occur in haploid (n) phase. Many red algae have an their habitats
state, whereas eukaryotic algae additional diploid phase, the diploid Using the definition of algae given
occur in either the haploid (n) or the carposporophyte. that is retained on above, estimates of the number of
diploid (2n) state. Cyanonabacteria the female gametophyte and allows algal species range from 30,000
do not have sexual reproduction, the release of more diploid spores to over a million; some estimates
while some unicellular, and most per fertilization event than would be suggest more than 200,000 species of
multicellular eukaryotic algae have a the case if the zygote was released. diatoms. There are several problems
sexual component to the life cycle, This additional complexity of the life with many estimates, for example,
sometimes with two or even three cycle has been suggested to be a what constitutes a species in the
phases. Asexual reproduction in response to a small fraction of eggs different algal classes. A conservative
unicellular algae involves cell division becoming fertilized because the male and defensible estimate is 72,500 algal
followed by cell separation (Figure gametes are non-flagellate. Other species.
1C). Formation of the algal colonies algae with non-flagellate gametes, The majority of algae are
involves cells remaining associated (e.g. some charophytes) have other photosynthetic and live in aquatic
after cell division, but without strategies. Some freshwater red habitats, although some grow on soil,
differentiation, distinguishing them algae have abbreviated life cycles including desert crusts. In all cases,
from multicellular algal organisms with where the sporophytes (2n) becomes algae that depend on photosynthesis
differentiation among vegetative cells a gametophyte (n) by vegetative live where there is sufficient light
including, in some cyanobacteria, meiosis. to permit photosynthetic growth; in
the heterocysts involved in aquatic environments the limit for
the assimilation of dinitrogen. Many shapes and sizes photosynthetic life is within, at most,
Reproduction of colonial and Many algae are unicellular, but 300 m of the water surface where the
multicellular algae involves asexual even among single cells there photon flux density (400–700 nm) is
and/or sexual unicellular stages, and, is a very large size range. In the not more than 10-5 that at the surface.
for some organisms, fragmentation. plankton, the range is from the A further example of algal growth
Many eukaryotic microalgae (e.g. 0.5 μm diameter of the marine under extreme conditions is growth at
many diatoms and green algae) are cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus very low water potentials on land and
known to have sexual reproduction and the 1 μm diameter of the marine also in very saline environments. The
(Figure 1D), and complete genome marine green alga Ostreococcus to limits for such organisms is seen in the
sequences of some eukaryotic algae the 1 mm diameter of the marine Dead Sea, where significant growth of
in which sex has not been observed diatom Ethmodiscus (Figure 2A). halotolerant green microlga Dunaliella
show that these organisms do have Among benthic (attached to a only occurs when surface waters are
the genetic apparatus needed for substrate) algae, unicellular forms slightly diluted by heavy winter rains.
meiosis, a process essential for can be up to 50 mm in diameter Some algae are desiccation-tolerant,
eukaryotic sexual reproduction. (the globose coenocytic marine and can survive (but cannot grow) at
Population genetic studies show green alga Ventricaria) and up to 8 very low cellular water content.
that some microalgae with no known m long (the branched coenocytic The majority of algae are free-
sexuality have low frequencies of green alga Codium). The benthic living, but a significant number
recombination; the mechanism marine green alga Caulerpa shows a live in or on other organisms.
in particular cases is difficult to significant degree of differentiation Some of these associations are
determine, although transformation into a horizontal tubular structure mutualistic symbioses with non-
involving cyanophages, and viruses analogous to a stolon, bearing photosynthetic ‘protists’ such ciliates,
of eukaryotic algae. is a likely upright photosynthetic assimilators foraminiferans and radiolarians,
mechanism. analagous to leaves of green shoots fungi (as lichens, mainly on land)
Sexual reproduction in macroalgae and colourless rhizoids penetrating and a number of metazoa including
often involves the release of gametes small-grained sediments or attached sponges, cnidarians, flatworms,
and fertilization into water body. In to rocks. These large coenocytic algae molluscs, tunicates and a vertebrate.
some organisms with dimorphic are best termed acellular rather than Many of these symbioses are
gametes the egg is retained by unicellular. Among multicellular algae fully photosynthetic and do not
the parent – for example, some the marine benthic brown Macrocystis require additional organic carbon.
Magazine
R5

An interesting case is that of algal phytoplankton than of embryophytes. animals, and of toxic eukaryotic
plastids in heterotrophic cells; Algae are at the basis of essentially all algae which can make shellfish unfit
since most of the algal cell is marine food chains, some freshwater for human consumption and directly
excluded from these associations, food chains and a small minority harm animals. Some of these negative
they cannot be considered to be of terrestrial food chains. Progress outcomes result from human activities
symbioses. One example is the is being made in allocating marine leading to the enrichment of water
marine ciliate Myrionecta that ingests phytoplankton productivity among bodies in algal nutrients. Indirect
cryptophycean algal cells, followed higher taxa of algae, using satellite effects, or those that would not
by digestion of all of the algal cells observations. necessarily be thought of by many
except the plastids (retained as While some algae can only grow people as related to algae, include
kleptoplastids) and nuclei. Retention in the light with inorganic nutrient forming the basis of food chains
of the nuclei means that the 90% or source, representative of many producing edible fish, and ecosystem
so of the genes needed for synthesis higher taxa are mixotrophic, i.e. use services such as oxygen production.
of plastids components that occur in external organic materials for their
the algal nucleus, as well as those in growth as well as light and inorganic The role of -omics in understanding
the plastid genome, are present within chemicals; some of these can grow algae
the ciliate — this may allow plastids in continuous darkness. In ecological The many cyanobacterial completed
to survive for longer than if the algal and biogeochemical terms, the most genome sequences, and the
nuclei were absent. important members of this group are increasing number of completely
Kleptoplastids without the planktonic phagomixotrophs, i.e. free sequenced genomes of eukaryotic
corresponding algal nuclei occur floating mixotrophs ingesting organic algae from a range of higher taxa are
in a few protists and molluscs particles. A few algae have lost the showing the potential for metabolic
(saccoglossan gastropods). These capacity for photosynthesis, and live pathways not previously suspected to
kleptoplastids can contribute entirely heterotrophically. occur, such as the Entner-Doudoroff
photosynthate to the consumer Algae, initially solely as variant of converting glucose into
organisms for periods of days to cyanobacteria, were responsible for pyruvate in a diatom. Metagenomics
(exceptionally) months in some producing all biogenic oxygen from has been very important in
saccoglossan sea slugs, although the Global Oxygenation Event about characterising uncultured, and (at
recent findings cast doubt on whether 2.35 billion years ago until the origin the moment) unculturable algae.
survival of sea slugs is increased by of a terrestrial embryophyte flora An example is the occurrence of a
this photosynthesis. Regardless of in the Ordovician (Figure 2B). The photosynthetic pigment characteristic
the significance of the kleptoplastid build-up of oxygen in the atmosphere of haptophyte algae in very small cells
photosynthesis, there is still the and ocean depends not just on (2–4 μm diameter) in environmental
problem of how plastids remain oxygen production from oxygenic samples from the open ocean.
functional for such long periods in photosynthetic organisms, but also Metagenomics has shown that the
the absence of the algal nuclei. While on the burial (mainly in the oceans) of cells with this pigment are indeed
there are differences in the number organic carbon which has escaped haptophytes, and from a previously
of plastid genes depending on the oxidation by heterotrophic organisms. uncharacterised clade. Of course,
source of the plastids (fewer in green (meta-)genomics has its limitations —
than in red of heterokont plastids), the Human involvement with algae knowing the size of these haptophytes
great majority of the genes involved As briefly discussed at the beginning relies on filtration rather than -omics.
in the synthesis of replacements for of this article, there are many ways
damaged plastid proteins are in the in which humans interact with algae. Summary
algal nucleus. Positive direct interaction of algae The algae are defined here are a
with humans include the use over functional group of organisms that
Algal contributions to global thousands of years of macroalgae carry out oxygenic photosynthesis
biogeochemical cycles as human food and the much more and are not embryophytes — they
Algae contribute about half of the total recent growth of microalgae as include both bacterial (cyanobacteria)
global primary productivity measured sources of health-promoting dietary and eukaryotic organisms. Oxygenic
as carbon. Most algal productivity supplements such as b-carotene and photosynthesis is monophyletic,
is carried out by phytoplankton. other antioxidants. Phycocolloids and its occurrence of in a majority of
Since phytoplankton contain more from macroalgae, such as agar and major eukaryotic clades is a result
nitrogen and phosphorus relative to carrageenans from red algae and of primary, secondary and tertiary
carbon than do embryophytic plants, alginate from brown algae, are used in endosymbiosis followed by genetic
more nitrogen and phosphorus is the food industry, in microbial culture integration of the endosymbionts into
assimilated globally by algae than by media and as soil conditioners. Yet the eukaryotes.
embryophytes. Phytoplankton cells to achieve large-scale commercial The algae have a great diversity
under natural conditions generally viability is the use of algae to produce of life cycles; many have a sexual
only live for days in the upper layer biofuels. component, and there is evidence
of water bodies before grazing, viral Negative direct interactions include of gene transfer in species lacking
lysis or sinking removes them, while ‘pond slime’ in garden ponds, green obvious. Algae have a great range of
embryophytes generally live for tides in estuaries, and blooms of toxic shapes and sizes, from spherical cells
weeks to centuries, so that there is cyanobacteria in fresh and brackish with 0.5 μm diameter to 60 m long
a much smaller global biomass of waters which have killed domestic multicellular thalli.
Current Biology Vol 24 No 13
R6

There are about 72,500 described


species of algae; they live in the
top 300 m of marine and inland
waters, and on land, as free-living
organisms or in symbiosis. Algae
make very large contributions to
biogeochemical cycles: they are
responsible for about half of global
primary productivity (carbon dioxide
assimilation and oxygen production).
Humans and algae have a large
number of interactions, both positive
and negative. As with many other
large groups of organisms, -omic
technologies are being increasingly
used in the study of algae.

Further Reading
Bell, G., and Mooers, A.O. (1997). Size and
complexity among multicellular organisms.
Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 60, 345–363.
Christa, G., Zimonis, V., Whoele, C., Tielers, A.G.H.,
Wagele, H., and Martin, W.F. (2014). Plastid-
bearing sea slugs fix CO2 in the light but do not
require photosynthesis to survive. Proc. R. Soc.
Bot. 281 in press. doi: 10/1098/mpt.2013.2493.
Cuvelier, M.L., and 21 co-authors (2010). Targetted
metagenomics and ecology of globally
important uncultured phytoplankton. Proc. Nat.
Acad. Sci. USA 107, 14679–14684.
Delwiche, C.F., and Timms, R.E. (2011). Plants.
Curr. Biol. 21, R417–R422.
Falkowski, P.G., and Raven, J.A. (2007). Aquatic
Photosynthesis. Princeton University Press,
Princeton, NJ.
Graham, L.E., Graham, J.M., and Wilcox, L.W.
(2009). Algae. Cummings Benjamin Publishing
Company.
Grimsley, N., Pédrian, B., Bachy, C., Moreau, H.,
and Piganeau, G., (2010). Cryptic sex in the
smallest eukaryotic green alga. Mol. Biol. Evol.
27, 47–54.
Guiry, M.C. (2012). How many species of algae are
there? J. Phycol. 48, 1057–1063.
Kerney, R., Kim, E., Hangarten, R.P., Heiss, A.A.,
Bishop, G.D., and Hal, B.K. (2011). Intracellular
invasion of green algae in salamander cells.
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 6497–6502.
Mitra, A., Flynn, K.J., Nurkholder, J.M., Berge, T.,
Calbet, A., Raven, J.A., Granéli, E., Glibert,
P.M., Hansen, P.J., Stoecker, F.K., et al.
(2014). The role of mixotrophic protists in the
biological carbon pump. Biogeosciences 11,
995–1005. doi: 10.5194/bg-11996–2014
Sanchez-Baracaldo, P., Ridgwell, A., and Raven,
J.A. (2014). A Neoproterpzoic transition in the
marine nitrogen cycle. Curr. Biol. 24, 652–657.
doi:10.1016/j.cub.2014.01.041
Uitz, J., Claustre, H., Gentili, B., and Stramski, D.
(2010). Phytoplankton class-specific primary
production in the world’s oceans: seasonal
and ibnteabbula variability from satellite
pbservations. Global Biogeo. Cyc. 34, GB3015.
doi@10.1029/2009GB003880.

1Division of Plant Science. University of

Dundee at the James Hutton Institute,


Invergowie, Dundee DD2 5DA, UK.
2Laboratorio di Fisiologia delle Alghe e delle

Piante, Dipartimento di Scienze della Vita e


dell’Ambiente, Università Politecnica delle
Marche, via Brecce Bianche, 60131 Ancona,
Italy.
E-mail: j.a.raven@dundee.ac.uk,
m.giordano@univpm.it

You might also like