Chapter six: Special electrical
practice for oil, gas and chemical
tankers
Tanker Classification
Hazardous Zones
Electrical Ignition of Gas
Apparatus Gas Groups
‘Temperature Class
Types of Explosion Protection
Ex‘d’ Flameproof Enclosure
Ex‘i’ Intrinsic Safety
Exte’ Increased Safety
Ex‘n’ Non-Sparking
Ex‘q’ Sand Filled
Ex‘o’ Oil Immersed
Ex‘p’ Pressurised Enclosure
Ex‘s’ Special Protection
Certification and Identification
Electrical Testing in Hazardous Areas
Maintenance of Ex-protected Apparatus
Ships that transport bulk quantities of oi, ga5 and liquid chemicals are subject to special codes
of practice regarding their electrical installations. Statutory authorities and classification
societies generally base their tecommendations on Publication 92 of the International
Electrotechnical Commission. The object of all such guidance isto prevent the hazards of fire
and explosion occurring on board these tank ships
Spaces in tankers where explosive gas-air mixtures may be expected to be present are called
‘dangerous’ or ‘hazardous’. All other areas being regarded as ‘safe’. The best way (0 avoid
explosions caused by electrical equipment is simply not to install such equipment in the
hazardous areas. However. special electrical equipment is permitted and this chapter will
provide a guide to the range and maintenance of such explosion (Ex)-protected equipment.
Tanker classification
Shore practice for hazardous areas is to divide the areas into three zones (01,2) which
recognises the degree of hazard by indicating the likelihood of an explosive gas-air mixture
being present. This practice is not used on tankers. However, electtical equipment is
manufactured on the basis of such zones - see tater section on z0nes
On tankers, areas are designated as either ‘dangerous space’ or ‘normally-safe’ spaces. A
dangerous space is defined as an area where Rammable gas-air mixtures would normafly b&
expected to occur. The degree of hazard or danger presented by a dangerous space is
determined, initially, by the nature of the flammable cargo of the tanker. On this basis, four
types of tanker are recognised:
TYPE A ~ Oil tankers intended for the catriage in bulk of non-boiling oi) cargoes having a
flash point (closed test) of 60°C or less. These include crude oil carriers. gasoline carriers, etc
TYPE B - Oil tankers intended for carriage in bulk of non-boiling oil cargoes having a flash
Point (closed test} in excess of 60°C. These include tankers for carrying bituminous or
asphaltic products, or for carrying diesel or fuel oils.
6!TYPE C- Gas carriers intended for the carriage in bulk of liquetied petsotewm 835 (LPG) or
Yiquified natural gas (LNG),
TYPE D - Tankers for the carsiage in bulk of other flammable liquid cargoes. This includes,
those cargoes which are potentially more dangerous than those conveyed by TYPE. A and
TYPE C tankers, and those products which exhibit chemical instability
TYPE A TANKERS
DANGEROUS SPACES
Cargo tanks.
Cofferdams adjoining cargo tanks.
‘Cargo pump rooms
Enclosed or semi-enclosed spaces immediately above cargo tanks, or having
bulkheads above and in line with the cargo tank bulkheads.
s Enclosed os semi-enctosed spaces immediately above cargo pumprooms, or above
vertical cofferdams adjoining cargo tanks, unless separated by a gastight deck and
suitably mechanically ventilated.
6. Spaces. otter than cofferdams, adjoining and below the top of the cargo tanks, e.g
trunks, passageways and holds.
7. reason open deck, or semi-enclosed spaces on open deck. within at least 3m of any
cargo oil tank outlet or gas oF vapaut outlet
8. reason open deck over all cargo tanks, including all ballast tanks within the cargo
tank block and to the full width of the vessel plus 3m forward and aft on open deck. up
to a height of 2.4m above the deck
9. Compartments for cargo hoses.
10. Enclosed af sentivenclosed spaces having a direct opening into any oF the spaces or
areas mentioned above.
Electrical equipment and cables should anty be focates im dangerous spaces when It is
absolutely necessary.
Only intrinsically Safe (Exi) electrical equipment iy allowed inside cargo tanks.
Electric motors are not permitted in cargo pump roaras.
Flameptoof (Exd) of Pressurised (Exp) luminaires may be used in pumprooms. The switches
and fuses for the tuminaises must be located in 4 normally safe space outside the pumproom.
At least two independent circuits must be provided for the lighting. Uf maintenance is carried
‘out on the luminaires of one circuit this circuit must be de-energised while the other circuit
provides sufficient light for the wark to be safely completed.
QUESTION
‘Tanker pumprooms require two separate lighting circuits. How ean the circuits be arranged
so that the luminaires can only be opened up when the cortect circuit has been isolated?
ANSWER
Many tankers use the following arrangement: The luminaires on one of the circuits have bolts
With a different size oF type of head to thave on the Suminaires supplied by the other eircuit
Typically, these would be two different types of triangular bolt head.
The keys to remove the bolts ure actually the operating handles of the circuit isalators. A key
can only be removed from its trapped position on the switch after the circuit has been isolated.
‘This key can only open up those luminaires connected to the cireuit which has been isolated.
Cable runs are permitted through most dangerous spaces except cargo tanks, providing they
ace contiauausly monitored for earth leakage
Flameproof (Exd) or Pressurised (Exp) luminaires ace permitted in enclosed or
semi-enclosed spaces immediately above a cargo tank. above a cargo pump room and in
compartments for storing cargo hoses. The switches and fuses must be located in normally
safe area and must switch hoth lines of the circuit (i.e, double pole switching),
62TYPE B TANKERS
Dangerous spaces are not defined for vessels of this type, but it is recommended that care be
exercised so that potential sources of ignition are reduced as far as possible. Also, the
following practices shoud be followed:
1 Use intcinsicalty safe (Exi) for any monitoring or instrumentation equipment which
is in direct contact with oil in the cargo tanks or in the Oil circuits.
2. Cargo pump motors should be increased safety (Exe} type if they are located in the
cargo pump room.
3. Allportable electrical equipment used in the cargo tanks mast be suitably explosion
protected
TYPE C TANKERS (Gas Carriers)
DANGEROUS SPACES
1 A space in the cargo area which is not equipped with approved arrangements to
censure that its atmosphere is at all times maintained in a safe condition
2 An enclosed space outside the cargo area through which any piping terminates,
unless approved arrangements are installed to prevent any escape of product vapour
into the atmosphere of that space
3 A cargo containment system with cargo piping
4) ahold space where cargo is carried in a cargo containment system requiring
secondary barrier:
(3) ahold space where cargo is carried in a cargo containment system not requiring
a secondary barrier
4. Aspace separated from a hold space described ia (i) hy asingle gastightsteet
boundary,
3. A cargo pump room and cargo compressor room.
6. Azone on open deck. or semi-enclosed space on open deck. within 3m of any cargo
tank outlet, gas oF Vapour outlet. cargo piped Mange, cargo valve or of entrances und
vemilation openings to a cargo pumproom and cargo compressor rooms.
7. The open deck over the cargo area and 3m forward and aft of the cargo area on open
deck up to a height of 2.4m above the weather deck.
8. A zone within 2.4m of the outer surface of a cargo containment system where such
surface is exposed to the weather
9. Aneenclosed or semi-enclosed space in which pipes containing products are located.
1). A vompartment for cargo hoses
11, Anenclosed or semi-enclosed space having a direct opening into any dangerous
space oF arew
The recommendations for the use of electrical equipment in dangerous spaces are the same
{or this type of vessel as they are for TYPE A tankers, There are. however, two important
._ additional recommendations for gus carriers
Cargo Pump Motors Submerged cargo pump motors and their cables are permitted in cargo
tanks subject (0 the atmosphere of the tank being controlled to prevem presence of a gas-air
mixture when the motors are energised
Gas Compressor Motors - These motors are allowed. undet certain circumstances. tobe sited
in the same space as the compressors, In these instances the motors are required to be
pressurised (Exp) with air. inert gas or water
‘Alternatively. an increased safety motor within a flameproof enclosure may be used (Exe.d)
TYPE D CHEMICAL CARRIERS
The products catried in these vessels may produce explosive gas-air mixtures and can also be
intensely corrosive. Jn cases like this electricat equipment must not only be explosive
protected but also designed to withstand corrosion
These products are categorised as follows ia arder ta give euidance on the electrical
equipment which would he suitableTYPE OF CHEMICAL PRODUCT
Products which have similar properties to those carried by vessel types A. B and C
The recommendations given for those vessels would apply.
Products which are considered to be more hazardous than those in 1
The extent of dangerous arcas is increased from 3m to 4.5m,
Products which are susceptible to chemical instability which creates flammable
eases.
Special arrangements would be required for this type of product.
Products which will damage any clectrical equipment with which they come inte
contact, Materials and enclosures must resist the corrosive effect of these products
Hazardous zones
Hazardous areas are classified into *ZONES' which indicate the probability of an explosive
gas-air mixture being present and, therefore, the likelihood of an explosion occurring.
Zone 0
Zone 1
Zone 2
In which an explosive gas-air mixture is continuously present, or present for
long periods.
te which an explosive gas-air mixture is likely to occur in normal operation
In which an explosive gas-air mixture is not likely t@ occur in normal
operation and, if it occurs, will exist far anly a short time
An area which is not classified Zone 0. 1 or2 is assumed 10 be a non-hazardous or ‘yale’ area,
Examples of this zoning applied to ships could be:
ZONE 0 Interior spaces of oil cargo tanks. pipes. pumps. ete.
ZONE 1 Enclosed or semi-enclosed spaces on the deck of
tanker, the boiler firing area on a yas carrier using methane boil-offas 3 fuel
and battery rooms.
ZONE 2 Open spaces on the deck of a tanker
The cargo pump rooms of tankers are. at present. considered 2s falling somewhere between
ZONE 0 and ZONE 1
Electeical ignition of gas
Gases can be ignited by heat generated from various electrical sources when concentrated
above the Lower Explosive Limit (LEL), e.g
“i
ay
(iii)
fv)
wy
(vi)
(vii)
Arcing between switch contacts
‘Accing between a live conductor and earth
An internal arcing fault within an electrical enclosure
‘Overheating causing “hot spots
Anelectrostatic spark discharge between charged bodies or between a charged body
and earth
Chemical action
Lightning strikes.
Apparatus gas groups
The flammable gases in which explosion protected elecirieah equipment may have 1 operate
are grouped according to the amount of electrical energy, in the form of an are, which is
needed
Gases associated with the mining industry a
to ignite the gas.
Jassed as GROUP 1. all other industrial gases
are classed as GROUP II in tour sub-groups according to their ease of ignition.
6/4ENCLOSURE GROUPS BS4683 PART 2 1971
[Group of Enclosare[Gas or Vapor —
[__T__|Methane (Firedamp)
[-——1a-—“Tamonia
Industrial methane
Blast furnace gas
‘Carbon monoxide
Propane
Butane
Pentane
|Hexane
Heptane
iso Octane
Decane
Benzene
Xylene
{Cyclohexane
|Acetone
Ethyl methyl ketone
Methyl acetate
Ethyl acetate
n-Propyl acetate
Butyl acetate
Amyl acetate
Chloroethylene
IMethanut
Ethanol
iso Butanol
n-Butanol
Amyl alcohol
Eshy) nitrite
118 Buta-T. 3 diene
Ethylene
Diethylether
Ethylene oxide
It should be noted that equipment certified for use in GROUP LIC may also be used for HA
and IB
Equipment certified for IB may be used for A.
Equipment certified for HA may be used with no other group.
‘The gas grouping ean affect the design and construction of some types of explosion protected
equipment (Exd and Ex).
Temperature class
This detines the maximum surtace temperature of the components in the electrical equipment
under normal and fault conditions. This maximum surface temperature must not exceed the
{as ignition temperature
The Cemperature class is stated with reference 10 maximum ambient temperature of 40°C,
should any other reference temperature be adopted, regulations require that this
temperature be shown on the equipment
Ueisimportant to note that the apparatus ges grouping and temperature class are not related
For instance. hydrogen requires very little spark energy to ignite. but the surface temperature
necessaey for igcition is verw high (SOFC).
6/5‘The following table relates the temperature class to the maximum surface temperature under
fault conditions.
“Temperature Class] Maximum surface temperature]
T BUC
300°C
200°C
| 35°C
Jone
85°C
For example, an electric motor may have @ maximum sprface temperature of 120°C and
would be classed as T4. Temperature Classifications and Apparatus Groups for all Group II
gases can be found in BS $345 Part I, 1976
Types of explosion protection
There are a number of different constructional techniques employed in preventing electrical
equipment causing explosions in hazardous areas. Some techniques, such as flameproof
enclosures, have long been established but others, such as intrinsic safety and increased
safety, are the result of more recem developments in clectronics and materials.
{t has been internationally agreed that explosion protected equipment be identified by the
symbol ‘Ex’ followed by a letter indicating the type of protection employed.
‘The following table Tists the types of protection and their symbols
Type of Protection
| Mlaméproof enclosure
intrinsic safety
incensed satery |
‘non-sparking {
| powder fitea
oil immersed
pressurisation
special protection
‘Some equipment may use more than one of these types of protection in its construction. {5
this case, the primary type of protection is quoted first, For example, un increased safety
motor with a fameproof terminal box would be marked Exe.d.
Ex'd’ Flameproof Enclosure
‘A flameproof enclosure is one which will withstand, without damage. an explosion of the
flammable gas within itself, and will prevent transmission of the flame which could ignite the
gas in the surrounding atmosphere
FS EBa
ae aN 9
NN
RY
6/6Ee Eee sero
Flameproof enclosures are of heavy construction and access to them is by means of covers
which fit onto wide, machined flanges, and are secured by a large number of bolts.
‘The pressure set up by the internal explosion is released through the small gap between the
wide, machined flanges, and this cools the rush of gas sufficiently to prevent it from igniting
any external flammable gas.
‘The width of flange and the maximum allowable gap depends on the type of gas present (gas
roupins
Standard lect! equipment can be used wih his eypeof enclosure
screwed int
{(ehown in heevy tin
oth length
‘QUESTION
A ship's battery locker is fitted with a flameproof luminaire marked Exd Ile T4. Is this
luminaire certified for use in the battery room?
ANSWER
Yes - The hazard is hydrogen gas from the batteries which requires apparatus designed for
use in apparatus gas group Ile. The ignition temperature of hydrogen is 560°C and the
temperature classification ofthe fuminaire is T4. This means that it's surface temperature will
not exceed 135°C. so the temperature classification is OK.
Ex‘? intrinsic safety
‘These are circuits in which no spark nor any thermal effect produced under prescribed test
conditions (which include normal operation and specified fault conditions) is capable of
‘causing ignition of a given explosive atmosphere. Generally. this means limiting the circuit
conditionsto less than 30V and SOmA. Naturally. this restricts the use of Exi protection to low
power instrumentation, alarm and communication circuits. The design of the circuit will
depend on the type of gas present (gas grouping),
In the UK two grades of Intrinsic Safety are recognised based on the safety factor of the