Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ejemplo Etnografía PDF
Ejemplo Etnografía PDF
Abstract
This paper presents how data collection strategies within ethnographic field research
were used in the school setting to learn more about student’s attitudes in Physical
Education (P.E.). In particular, the researcher was interested to understand the views
of secondary school girls towards trampolining as part of their P.E. lessons, and to-
wards participating in the after school Trampoline Club. Ethnographic method was
used to conduct fieldwork and present data utilising a range of participant observa-
tion opportunities including covert and overt observations and recorded interviews
with both the students and the P.E. teachers. A key question for the researcher at the
start of the study was, is trampolining just another thing to do or does it contribute
something positive to a student’s education? The results indicated that overall, the
girls had mainly positive attitudes and opinions about doing trampolining in school
with common themes supporting this emerging throughout the study. For example,
for most of the students trampolining was seen as a fun activity which provided a
sense of enjoyment and importantly, a sense of achievement in a structured but re-
laxed atmosphere - regardless of pupils ability level. This was a significant finding
which gave rise to a number of questions about the purpose of trampolining in P.E.
and highlighted the dissonance between students perceptions of an activity and its
educational merits.
77
Journal of Qualitative Research in Sports Studies 1, 1
should be included in P.E. lessons. One activity that can be included is trampolining
which in some schools forms part of the Physical Education curriculum. Research-
ing students attitudes towards P.E. (such as Luke and Sinclair, 1991; Graham, 1995)
could form an important part of a teacher’s understanding as to why pupils like doing
certain activities in P.E., such as trampolining and dislike others.
The researcher currently has a active interest in the sport of trampolining and is also
progressing onto PGCE Initial Teacher Training for P.E.. Consequently the research
ideas at the start of this study are personally and professionally grounded and have
stimulated an interest to investigate the following points:
1. To find out the attitudes and opinions of girls towards taking part in tram-
polining at school.
2. To investigate the types of physical activity that girls prefer to take part in.
3. To look at the attitudes of girls towards the PE curriculum in general.
78
Jacqueline McCabe and Clive Palmer
eries were grounded in the data, stemming from observations and interviews.
This field research centred on gathering information about girls attitudes towards
trampolining. Unlike positivistic methods, ethnographic methods allow the re-
searcher to ‘get close’ to the subjects in question as Grills (1998:16) suggests “…by
‘getting close’ ethnographers provide a texture, an immediacy, and a depth of under-
standing that cannot be attained by research strategies that keep the social world at
arm’s length”. In other words, if the research takes place outside the field of study such
as sending out questionnaires, it may be less effective for gathering data about other
people’s view of the world. Attitudes are often influenced or reinforced by an indi-
vidual’s beliefs and feelings towards a particular situation which may lead to certain
behavioural intents. Therefore, student’s attitudes might often be linked to the value
they place upon the activity at the time of doing it and could be seen as relatively sta-
ble dispositions. Because attitudes can be dependent on individual perceptions of the
situation, they cannot be measured directly but can be noted from their observable
behaviour (Wesson, Wiggins, Thompson and Hartigan, 2000). Consequently, engag-
ing in observations were seen as appropriate methods to obtain the data required for
this study.
79
Journal of Qualitative Research in Sports Studies 1, 1
more positively in the research as it developed. This in turn helped to create more
trust between the researcher and the P.E. teachers who authorised access to classes
and individual students. The interview questions were developed from the data col-
lected through observations of classes and clubs, at which the teachers were always
present.
• quite a noisy session but students who are spotting seem to be concentrating.
• comments like “I did it” or “miss can we get on now” all showing a sense of enjoy-
ment.
Theoretical Notes included making notes of any theories or inferences that came to
mind during the sessions that could give explanations for the way in which the pupils
behaved at that particular time. For example a section of the field notes made during
Observation 4 read as follows:
80
Jacqueline McCabe and Clive Palmer
• The pupils were constantly chatting to each other during the activity -could have
been conversations about the activity or about what they had done in school that
day as this was an after school club.
• There is a different structure to this “club” compared to the lesson” – the teacher’s
interaction is different (less strict?) - Student’s response is different more relaxed – is
it seen as their time to do as they please?
• This is not quite a youth club but not quite a PE lesson either – what am I observing
here?
• The role of the teacher here is clear at one level – to facilitate/provide the club – and
she seems to have a really good rapport with the students. I don’t think a sport tram-
poline coach would put up with the lax attitude and atmosphere – compared to my
own training experiences – competition demands.
• If the teacher is really teaching in this after school club when the atmosphere is
different, what is she doing during the day? – when the atmosphere and their role
changes to a more authoritative one?
Methodological notes were also made during the observations, which took into ac-
count the impact on the data resulting from the researcher’s position and level of in-
teraction they could have in a given situation. The notes should briefly indicate what
the researcher can do and cannot do and how bias and weaknesses in the data might
be created. For example, the following is a section of methodological notes from an
early observation where the researcher’s role was “complete observer”, the positive
and negative aspects of this were noted.
Example of Methodological Notes (Observation 1 – P.E. lesson):
+ve - not interrupting the lesson environment – I am able to see what they do naturally
in their class – although some are aware that there is a stranger sat on a bench appar-
ently doing nothing which may make them act differently. How could I still get such a
good view but not be detected?
-ve - don’t get to hear what the pupils are saying unless they are shouting loud. I am too
far away, but if I get closer their behaviour might change.
When carrying out each observation it was important to note the social role the re-
searcher was engaged in as part of the participant observation spectrum, that is, from
being a “complete observer” to a “complete participant” in the trampolining lesson.
Hammersley and Atkinson (1995: 99-109) explain the application of four types of
theoretical social roles in participant observation, detailing the possible consequenc-
81
Journal of Qualitative Research in Sports Studies 1, 1
es for the researcher and the data in each case. These roles, in the context of this
research on girls attitudes toward trampolining, are explained below:
1. Complete participant - the researcher takes part in the trampoline ac-
tivities as a coach or, in a teaching assistant role. Aim – to become ac-
cepted as part of their ‘natural setting’– complete involvement.
4. Complete observer - the researcher does not engage in the activity with
the group – the main research task was to observe the trampoline activ-
ity and record.
This framework was used to indicate the social role of the researcher in each observa-
tion of trampolining whether in P.E. or after school club. Each level of participant-
observation altered the level of interaction that the researcher had with the students
being researched. Consequently, this had an impact on the data in a significant way
which is to do with, recognising researcher bias (Bailey, 2007; Silverman, 2005; Ham-
mersley and Atkinson, 1995). The close proximity of the researcher (as an outsider-
adult) could have influenced the behaviour of the girls by changing what they would
normally do and say in their own company. Furthermore, if the researcher’s role was
revealed to the trampoline group they may have become suspicious and alter their
behaviour. It may be that, quite simply, their knowledge of being watched is sufficient
to change their behaviour whether they are observed from near or afar. Consequent-
ly, researcher bias is always present in the data and it is up to the researcher to think of
ways to reduce this bias, perhaps by thinking of new strategies to collect more data.
In terms of covert research, this created opportunities to collect new data from dif-
ferent perspectives, implicitly, by deception. This was achieved by assuming the role
of trampoline coach, thereby getting closer to “the action” with a group of students
who did not know at that stage that the ‘coach’ was in fact a researcher eavesdrop-
ping on their dialogue and behaviour in close quarters. This strategy also presented
new challenges for recording and working with the trampoline groups in the longer
term. That is, if a group/individual discovers they have been deceived from the start,
they seemingly have good reason not to trust the researcher in the future. Covert
82
Jacqueline McCabe and Clive Palmer
research also raised some ethical issues concerning informed consent and the use of
data in the writing up and reporting stages. In this particular study, the formalised
process of conducting qualitative research and keeping the teachers and supervisors
informed at every stage of the project helped to develop data collection in a useful
way. The professional demands of the school setting for researchers to be present dur-
ing lessons (passes, signing in/off site), and the non-threatening nature of this study
also helped to reduce ethical concerns. However, they are highlighted in this paper to
indicate they are very important issues to address if researchers are to conduct their
investigations responsibly.
For the students, the researcher’s position was as a stranger to them. Therefore, the
information noted could be said to be a fair representation of what went on in the
natural setting – given that the students were aware of an unfamiliar person in their
space. Agar (1980) suggests that a researcher’s status as a stranger or outsider to a
social system can contribute to one of the major difficulties facing an ethnographer
in the field. That is, that as a result of this outsiders-status, access to information can
be limited; this was true of the researcher’s experience at this particular point in the
study. How to get closer to the students whilst not upsetting the natural exchanges in
this situation was the next challenge.
The social role for the participant observations changed by progressively moving
closer to the students to be in proximity of their conversations and behaviour. In
order to achieve this, the researcher had to create a meaningful role for themselves
for the students to accept this new person in their company. The role of teaching as-
sistant at first, and latterly, trampoline coach was assumed, this being a useful person
for them to interact with during the trampoline sessions. The researcher was also now
a familiar figure to the students so the status and impact of being a stranger at their
lessons may have diminished. However it was acknowledged in the methodological
notes that the researcher’s presence as a mature teacher-like figure could alter the
dialogue and natural balance of their social exchanges. It is worth noting that in the
school setting, students would only ever be around a trampoline in the presence of
a qualified adult for safety reasons so perhaps their dialogue and social demeanour
83
Journal of Qualitative Research in Sports Studies 1, 1
These comments were not prompted by questions from the researcher rather, they
are just examples of utterances around the trampoline. The students seemed to enjoy
their trampolining but there has to be more to their motivation for it, than just ‘jump-
ing up and down’. The next challenge was to increase the researcher’s level of interac-
tion with the students in order to gain more insights into their behaviour whilst si-
multaneously answering their questions and demands for coaching to improve their
trampolining. With this development the role of participant-as-observer remained;
the researcher was clearly not their school teacher, but more requests were being
made by the students to increase the researcher’s interaction with them. For example,
an observational note recorded:
Students seemed to be more comfortable with me being there and interacted with
me a lot more – I tried not to influence their behaviour towards me or between
them.
This phase of data collection was more covert than overt as the real purpose of the re-
searcher was not divulged to the students but equally, it was not withheld either. The
teacher who was present was informed of the researcher’s intent and tactics to collect
data during this particular visit. It was evident from the observations and interviews
and that there was a sense of fun and enjoyment when taking part in the trampoline
lessons. For example, after a number of weeks of observation, the students were asked
to give their opinions about the trampoline sessions by “describing trampolining in
three words”. A selection of responses showed a range of opinions including:
different, lively, fun, adventurous, bouncy, enjoyable, good, jumping and exercise
The statements suggest that the girls held some positive attitudes towards trampolin-
ing and doing this activity as part of their P.E. lessons. However, just because tram-
polining is “fun and bouncy” the researcher was beginning to question whether the
students appreciated any educational value in participation. For instance, if trampo-
84
Jacqueline McCabe and Clive Palmer
lining were suddenly removed from the curriculum would it be valued differently by
these students? (This situation is quite realistic as the opportunity to do trampolining
only exists because there is a qualified member of staff to offer it.)
The students reported that they like to have a choice in what they do for P.E. and
found that doing trampolining was different and a more exciting option compared
to the other sports in P.E.. During some short interviews with the Year 7 students,
they were asked to give their opinions on how they felt about trampolining and the
reasons why they attended the after school trampoline club. The responses covered
the following:
…You get to learn other stuff
…Because now there’s nothing to do after school so I just came here…its better
than doing nothing
…Just bouncing
…Cause its fun
…Yeah, with me mates and that
Again these responses also show a sense of enjoyment and fun stemming from tram-
polining and some strong social motivations for taking part in the activity. For ex-
ample, the students mentioned that being with friends was important as well as being
able to go to the club after school because they felt there was nothing else to do. This
could either indicate that the students genuinely enjoyed the activity or that they just
liked to keep active rather than doing nothing, maybe to avoid laziness or because
there was no other sports provision in the area. During these interviews some of
the students also mentioned that they enjoyed the trampoline club because they got
to learn new skills. This could suggest that learning new skills rather than getting
external rewards, intrinsically motivated some of them. One student indicated that
she enjoyed the opportunity that trampolining gave her because it could be done in
her leisure time without the added pressure of being assessed as she might be in P.E.
lessons.
Sport England (2005) carried out research into the attitudes of girls towards P.E. and
found there were three key elements that girls wanted from their lessons. These in-
cluded:
1. A choice of activity
2. To have fun and enjoy what they were doing
3. To have the teacher get more involved in the activities
The Year 11 students chose to do trampolining for their general P.E. lessons over other
85
Journal of Qualitative Research in Sports Studies 1, 1
activities that were offered to them. This indicates that they had some sort of positive
attitude towards the activity. These opinions ranged from suggesting that trampolin-
ing was “different” to saying that it was “enjoyable”. However, from the observations
when the researcher was “complete observer” with this Year 11 group, as well as dur-
ing the Year 8 and Year 9 trampoline lessons, the researcher felt that many of the
students saw trampolining as ‘an easy way out’. This was because all they needed to do
was “jump up and down” to take part in the lesson and “have fun” at the same time.
In saying that, most of the students liked the opportunity of learning and develop-
ing new skills on the trampoline but this depended on the knowledge and patience
of the teacher in charge. Coaching the co-ordination of actions and developing the
confidence required to learn new skills is very demanding and time consuming. In
P.E. with relatively high numbers of students, it is easy to see why the teacher might
limit their coaching input to just controlling a session of jumping up and down and
having fun without injury.
Conclusion
This study helped the researcher to understand how and why trampolining was of-
fered in these secondary schools as part of P.E. and in after school clubs. From stu-
dent’s language it seems clear that they understand the enjoyable elements of the
activity and could express this very well. Admittedly, a small number of students
did appear to be more interested in having aimless fun on the trampoline rather
than directed fun and skill learning. However, the majority of students enjoyed the
physical challenge that trampolining presented them. This could be observed in their
performances and repeated attempts to achieve a difficult action or link a routine. It
may be significant that the students who really tried hard to link small routines could
not verbally express what they found challenging in the activity, over and above “it’s
fun and bouncy”. That is, they seemed to lack the vocabulary to describe what the
researcher was seeing and comprehending as valuable educational outcomes from
their performance, for example knowledge of; weight transference, co-ordination
and linkage, balance and torque in flight, sighting, eccentric and concentric forces,
body conditioning for efficient biomechanical action and aesthetic features of flexion
and extension. This realisation has reaffirmed for the researcher that trampolining is
a worthwhile activity as it promotes participation and stimulates learning and enjoy-
ment in P.E.. However, to help the students realise some of these outcomes it seems
important to create opportunities to teach them about these theoretical concepts
which may be a difficult task to achieve in reality. If this is not achieved or at least
worked towards, trampolining may risk becoming the “easy way out” or the “easy op-
tion” in P.E. for the student and, perhaps significantly for the teacher as well.
86
Jacqueline McCabe and Clive Palmer
References
Agar, M. H. (1980) Professional strangers: An informal introduction to ethnography. Aca-
demic Press, New York.
Bailey, C.A. (2007) A guide to qualitative field research (second edition). Sage Publications,
London.
Capel, S.A. and Piotrowski, S. (2000) Issues in Physical Education, Issues in Subject
Teaching. London; New York, Routledge. (e-Book)
Denzin, N.K. (1997) Interpretive Ethnography. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Graham, G. (1995) Physical Education through students’ eyes and in students’ voices: intro-
duction. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 14, 364-371.
Grills, S. (1998) Doing Ethnographic Research: Fieldwork Settings. Sage Publications: Thou-
sand Oaks, California: USA.
Hammersley, M. and Atkinson, P. (1995) Ethnography, principles in practice. Routledge,
London.
Laker, A. (2003) The future of Physical Education- building a new pedagogy. Routledge Re-
search in Education; 6. New York.
Luke, M. D. and Sinclair, G. D. (1991) Gender differences in adolescents’ attitudes towards
physical education. Journal of Teaching Physical Education, 11, 31-46.
Schatzman, L. and Strauss, A.L. (1973) Field research strategies for a natural sociology.
Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Sport England (2005) Women and girls in sport project [online]. Available at: www.
sportengland.org/women_and_girls_project.pdf [Accessed 3rd November 2006]
Silverman, D. (2005) Doing qualitative research. Sage Publications, London.
Stewart, A. (1998) The ethnographers method. SAGE University paper.
Wesson, K., Wiggins, N., Thompson, G. and Hartigan, S. (2000) Sport and PE: A complete
guide to advanced level study. Second Edition. Hodder and Stoughton, London.
Wolcott, H.F. (1998) Ethnographic research in education. In R.M. Jaeger (Ed.) Complemen-
tary methods for research in education, (pp.187-210). Educational Research Association,
Washington, DC: USA.
87
Journal of Qualitative Research in Sports Studies 1, 1
88