Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Elmes 1 PDF
Jurnal Elmes 1 PDF
www.springerlink.com/content/1738-494x(Print)/1976-3824(Online)
DOI 10.1007/s12206-017-0831-8
(Manuscript Received September 14, 2016; Revised April 9, 2017; Accepted May 5, 2017)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract
In this paper, an original analysis of the geometric design of a parallel-axis cycloid helical gear drive and an investigation on its basic
meshing characteristics are presented. This type of gear drive consists of a pinion with one tooth and a cycloid-helix gear in continuous
line contact along the whole length of the tooth. Firstly, mathematical formulations of their tooth surfaces are derived based on the enve-
lope theory and homogeneous coordinate transformation. Secondly, the undercutting analysis is applied to determine the design con-
straint to avoid the undercutting on the cycloid-helix gear tooth surface. Then, the meshing characteristics including the contact lines,
surface of action, induced normal curvature are analyzed. Numerical example is presented to demonstrate the influence of design parame-
ters on the contact stress distribution. Finally, the loaded tooth contact analysis is performed to simulate the tooth contact condition and to
validate the stress distribution by the finite element method.
Keywords: Cycloid helical gear; Undercutting; Meshing characteristics; Loaded tooth contact analysis
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
T
where E1 = éë E sin j1 E cos j1 0ùû , ω1(1) = éë0 0 w1 ùû ,
T ¶r1 ¶r
where r1q = , r1y = 1 , G = r1v2 , F = r1q × r1v , D 2 = EG - F 2 ,
T
¶q ¶y
ω1(2) = ëé0 0 -w2 ûù . ¶f dj1 ¶f ¶f
E = r12q , f t = , fq = and fy = .
Submitting the Eqs. (8) and (9) into Eq. (7): ¶j1 dt ¶q ¶y
According to the theory of gearing [2], the singularity exists
f (q ,y ,j ) = w2 p r [ E cos(q + y + j1 ) - e(1 + i )cos(q )] = 0 . when the undercutting limit function g (q ,y ,j ) is equal to
(10) zero. After derivations, turning inequality Eq. (13) into equality,
4332 X. Li et al. / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 31 (9) (2017) 4329~4336
r1 (q ,y ), f (q ,y ,j ) = 0 . (16)
ì x1 = r cos(q + y ) - e siny
ï
Fig. 5. Illustration of three different types of undercutting on the nor- ï y1 = r sin(q + y ) + e cosy
mal tooth profile of the cycloid-helix gear: (a) Double undercutting, í (17)
ï z1 = py
r a < r (q ) < rb ; (b) single undercutting, r (q ) > rb ; (c) non-
undercutting, 0 < r (q ) < r a .
ïîcos(q + y + j1 ) - m cosq = 0 .
we obtain the singularity equation: Eq. (17) represents a family of contact lines on the pinion
tooth. A fixed value of j1 can determine one contact line of
g (q ,y ,j ) = pw12{ - e(1 + i )sin q [2 Eer cosq this family. Fig. 6 shows the radial projections of contact lines
on pinion tooth surface at different j1 . It is observed that
cos(q + j1 + y ) + 2(1 + i ) p 2 ( r + e sin q ) + Ee 2
contact lines are continuous curves along the whole length of
sin(q - j1 - y )] + a[(e 2 + 2 p 2 ) r + e 2 r cos 2q
(14) the tooth and move as the pinion rotates. Note that the exis-
+ (1 + i )(e3 + 4ep 2 sin q + Ee 2 sin(q - j1 - y )] tence of an envelope on the tooth surface is not desirable [3].
sin(q + j1 + y ) - E 2 (e 2 + 2 p 2 )[sin(q + j1 + y )]2 } The reasons are that a part of generating surface without con-
/2i 2 [e 2 + p 2 - e 2 (sin q ) 2 ] = 0 . tact lines is out of meshing, and conditions of heat transfer and
lubrication in the area close to the envelope are not favorable.
Hence, it is significant to analyze the envelope of contact lines.
Then we obtain the function r (q ) :
Based on the theory of gearing [2], the envelope of contact
lines on the pinion is satisfied by the following equations:
[e(1 + i )sin q - E sin(q + A)][-2e(1 + i ) p 2 sin q
- Ee 2 sin(q - A) + E (e 2 + 2 p 2 )sin(q + A)] r1 (q ,y ), f (q ,y ,j ) = 0, f t (q ,y ,j ) = 0 (18)
r (q ) = (15)
e(1 + i )[2(1 + i ) p 2 sin q + Ee cos(q + A)sin 2q
- E (e 2 + 2 p 2 + e 2 cos 2q )sin(q + A)] and with further simplification:
H = 11 mm
e = 2.5 mm, E = 25 mm, n2 = 5 ,
Case 1 H = 13.5 mm
r = 5.5 mm, 0 £ q £ 4p
H = 15 mm
r = 15 mm
e = 2.5 mm, E = 25 mm, n2 = 5 ,
Case 2 r = 5.5 mm
H = 13.5 mm, 0 £ q £ 4p
r = 7 mm
Fig. 6. Radial projection of the contact lines on the pinion gear tooth
surface at different values of j1 (rad): (a) j1 = 0 ; (b) j1 = p / 2 ; (c)
j1 = p ; (d) j1 = 1.5p .
Fig. 7. The surface of action and its normal cross section.
Fig. 10. (a) 3D Finite element model; (b) contact condition on the
values of the INC are observed within the range of q from 0 pinion tooth surface.
to 4p rad, meaning that there are four regions with higher
contact stress on the tooth surface locating in the correspond- bution of the proposed cycloid helical gear drive, the loaded
ing angle ranges. Fig. 8(a) shows the effect of different values Tooth contact analysis (TCA) was performed by using the
of H on the absolute values of the INC. Finite element method (FEM). Meanwhile, the loaded TCA is
Under the same design parameters, the absolute value of the used to validate the contact stress distribution predicted by the
INC increases in the ranges b and d with the increasing INC analysis.
H , while the tendency is opposite in the ranges a and c . It Before the loaded TCA, the precise three dimensional (3D)
indicates that the contact stress in the ranges b and d will solid model of the two gears are established as displayed in
increase as H increases, while in the ranges a and c the Fig. 9(a), according to the design parameters as e = 2.5 mm,
contact stress will decrease. Similarly, Fig. 8(b) shows the E = 25 mm, n2 = 5, r = 5.5 mm, 0 £ q £ 4p and H =
effect of the different values of r on the INC. The absolute 13.5 mm. In order to evaluate its meshing condition, a com-
value of INC increases in all the four ranges a, b, c and d puterized motion simulation of meshing process is carried out.
with an increasing r , meaning that the contact stress will The following behaviors are observed from the simulation: (1)
increase. However, as the value of r decreases, the absolute This gear drive can transmit rotational motion with a constant
value of INC increases in the ranges b and d , the tendency gear ratio; (2) no meshing interference between the conjugate
is opposite in the ranges a and c . The contact stress will tooth surfaces is found in the meshing process; (3) the conju-
also show the same tendency. As shown in both Figs. 8(a) and gate tooth surfaces are in continuous line contact along the
(b), the purple curves are under the same design parameters. It whole length of the tooth. Based on the parameters above, the
is observed the maximum absolute values corresponding to physical model of this the two gears are also manufactured by
the four ranges a, b, c and d are almost the same, meaning a 3D printer as shown in Fig. 9(b). The advantage of using a
that the maximum contact stress will be the same in the four 3D printer is the way that it facilitates a rapid design cycle and
locations. This means the maximum contact stress can be re- eliminates some manufacture difficulties.
duced by selecting the appropriate design parameters to im- The 3D model then transfers to the finite element analysis
prove the load capability of this proposed helix gear drive. software for the loaded TCA. For the pinion gear, a revolute
joint is built at the axle hole, where the pinion axis as the revo-
lute axis. Similarly, for the wheel. Besides, a 3D contact con-
5. Loaded tooth contact analysis
straint is constructed between the pinion and cycloid-helix
To investigate the tooth contact condition and stress distri- gear. After the constraints are built, a torque is applied to the
X. Li et al. / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 31 (9) (2017) 4329~4336 4335
pinion. Fig. 10(a) shows the 3D finite element model. A com- National Natural Science Funds for Young Scholar (Grant No.
patible element, solid 185 is used to mesh the solid models of 51605049), Science and Technology Program of Guangzhou
the pinion and cycloid-helix gear. To save the calculation re- City of China (Grant No. 2014Y2-00217), and Science and
source, the max sizes of elements are set as 2 mm. While for Technology Achievements Transformation Program of Ji-
the elements attached to the tooth surfaces, their max sizes are angsu Province of China (Grant No. BA2015177).
set as 0.1 mm to ensure the calculation accuracy. The material
of the pinion and cycloid-helix gear is steel with Young’s
References
modulus E = 2.05 ´ 105 MPa and the Poisson ratio m = 0.3 .
The input torque is set as 10 Nm, which is a very large torque [1] C. B. Tsay and Z. H. Fong, Computer simulation and stress
for the comparative small overall dimensions of the gears. analysis of helical gears with pinion circular arc teeth and
After the finite element model solved, the contact pattern gear involute teeth, Mechanism and Machine Theory, 26 (2)
and stress distribution on the pinion gear tooth surface can be (1991) 145-154.
obtained, as shown in Fig. 10(b). The contact line on the pin- [2] F. L. Litvin and A. Fuentes, Gear geometry and applied
ion gear tooth surface is a continuous curve along the whole theory, Cambridge University Press (2004).
length of the tooth, which is the same as the one displayed in [3] F. L. Litvin, V. Kin and Y. Zhang, Limitations of conjugate
the Fig. 6. Furthermore, as the same results predicted in the gear tooth surfaces, Journal of Mechanical Design, 112 (2)
INC analysis, there are four higher contact stress regions on (1990) 230-236.
the contact line corresponding to the four ranges a, b, c and [4] C. B. Tsay, Helical gears with involute shaped teeth geome-
d , and their maximum values of the Von-Mises stress are try, computer simulation, tooth contact analysis, and stress-
almost the same. The maximum values of Von-Mises stress analysis, Journal of Mechanisms Transmissions and Auto-
on the pinion gear tooth surface is 615.96 Mpa that is much mation in Design Transactions of the ASME, 110 (4) (1988)
smaller than the allowable stress (1200 Mpa). The loaded 482-491.
TCA also proves that the INC analysis is feasible to qualita- [5] T. Yeh, D. C. H. Yang and S. H. Tong, Design of new tooth
tively predict the contact stress distribution. profiles for high-load capacity gears, Mechanism and Ma-
chine Theory, 36 (10) (2001) 1105-1120.
[6] C. F. Chen and C. B. Tsay, Tooth profile design for the
6. Conclusions
manufacture of helical gear sets with small numbers of teeth,
In this study, a parallel-axis cycloid helical gear drive is International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture, 45
presented. The mathematical formulations of the pinion and (12-13) (2005) 1531-1541.
cycloid-helix gear tooth surfaces have been derived based on [7] F. L. Litvin, N. X. Chen, J. Lu and R. F. Handschuh, Com-
the envelope theory and homogeneous coordinate transforma- puterized design and generation of low-noise helical gears
tion. With this, the undercutting, meshing characteristics and with modified surface topology, Journal of Mechanical De-
loaded tooth contact analyses are performed. The analysis sign, 117 (2A) (1995) 254-261.
results lead to the following conclusions: [8] C. K. Chen and C. Y. Wang, Compensating analysis of a
(1) The tooth profiles of pinion and gear are the closed cir- double circular-arc helical gear by computerized simulation
cular and cycloid curves. This type of helical gear drive has a of meshing, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical
large gear ratio in small size due to the pinion with one tooth. Engineers Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Sci-
(2) The undercutting on the tooth surface of the cycloid- ence, 215 (7) (2001) 759-771.
helix gear can be determined according to the proposed design [9] F. L. Litvin and C. B. Tsay, Helical gears with circular arc
constraint. teeth simulation of conditions of meshing and bearing con-
(3) The conjugated tooth surfaces possess a continuous line tact, Journal of Mechanisms Transmissions and Automation
contact along the whole length of the tooth. The envelope of in Design-Transactions of the ASME, 107 (4) (1985) 556-
contact lines on the pinion tooth surface do not exist and the 564.
pattern of contact lines favors the conditions of lubrication and [10] Y. Zhang, Q. Wang, H. Ma, J. Huang and C. Zhao, Dy-
efficiency of this proposed helical gear drive. namic analysis of three-dimensional helical geared rotor sys-
(4) To provide the continuous transmission of rotation, the tem with geometric eccentricity, Journal of Mechanical Sci-
contact ratio in the longitudinal direction should be larger than ence and Technology, 27 (11) (2013) 3231-3242.
1 wherein the helical angle y should be larger than p rad. [11] J. Wei, P. Gao, X. Hu, W. Sun and J. Zeng, Effects of dy-
(5) The INC analysis can be used to qualitatively predict the namic transmission errors and vibration stability in helical
contact stress distribution between the two tooth surfaces and gears, Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 28
optimize the design of this type of helical gear drive. (6) (2014) 2253-2262.
[12] J. Wei, W. Sun and L. Wang, Effects of flank deviation on
load distributions for helical gear, Journal of Mechanical
Acknowledgment
Science and Technology, 25 (7) (2011) 1781-1789.
The authors would like to acknowledge the supports from [13] X. S. Xie and H. C. Yang, Kinematic errors on helical gear
4336 X. Li et al. / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 31 (9) (2017) 4329~4336
of triple circular-arc teeth, Journal of Mechanical Science gears: environmental effects and product quality, Interna-
and Technology, 28 (8) (2014) 3137-3146. tional Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing
[14] M. Liu, C. Zhu, H. Liu and C. Wu, Parametric studies of Green Technology, 1 (1) (2014) 37-41.
lubrication performance of a helical gear pair with non- [23] V. V. Stanovskoy, S. M. Kazakyavichyus, T. A. Remneva
Newtonian fluids, Journal of Mechanical Science and Tech- and V. M. Kuznetsov, Toothed wheel gearing (variants) and
nology, 30 (1) (2016) 317-326. a planetary toothed mechanism based thereon (variants),
[15] H. Zeyin, L. Tengjiao, L. Tianhong, D. Tao and H. Qiguo, USA Patents US20100095792 A1 (2012).
Parametric modeling and contact analysis of helical gears
with modifications, Journal of Mechanical Science and
Technology, 30 (11) (2016) 4859-4867.
[16] S. Oh, S. Oh, J. Kang, I. Lee and S. Lyu, A study on mod- Xuan Li is currently a Ph.D. student at
eling and optimization of tooth microgeometry for a helical State Key Laboratory of Mechanical
gear pair, International Journal of Precision Engineering Transmission, Chongqing University,
and Manufacturing, 14 (3) (2013) 423-427. China. He spent two years as a Visiting
[17] Q. Zhang, J. Kang, W. Dong and S. Lyu, A study on tooth Scholar at University of Cincinnati,
modification and radiation noise of a manual transaxle, In- USA. His research interests include gear
ternational Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufac- design and dynamics.
turing, 13 (6) (2012) 1013-1020.
[18] S. C. Yang, Mathematical model of a stepped triple circu-
lar-arc gear, Mechanism and Machine Theory, 44 (5) (2009) Chaoyang Li received his doctor's de-
1019-1031. gree in engineering from the State Key
[19] F. L. Litvin, A. Fuentes, I. Gonzalez-Perez, L. Carnevali Laboratory of Mechanical Transmission,
and T. M. Sep, New version of Novikov-Wildhaber helical Chongqing University, China. Dr. Li is
gears: computerized design, simulation of meshing and currently an Associate Professor in
stress analysis, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics School of Mechanical and Engineering
and Engineering, 191 (49-50) (2002) 5707-5740. at Chongqing University. His research
[20] D. Liang, B. K. Chen and Y. N. Gao, The generation prin- areas of interest include gear design,
ciple and mathematical model of a new involute-helix gear optimization and manufacturing.
drive, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engi-
neers Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, Bingkui Chen is currently a Professor
227 (12) (2013) 2834-2843. and Director for the State Key Lab of
[21] B. K. Chen, D. Liang and Y. Gao, Geometry design and Mechanical Transmissions at Chong-
mathematical model of a new kind of gear transmission with qing University, China. He is also Vice
circular arc tooth profiles based on curve contact analysis, Director of the CMES Gear Technical
Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part Committee and a member of the CMES
C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 228 (17) Gear Manufacturing Committee. Prof.
(2014) 3200-3208. Chen has conducted pioneering research
[22] J. H. Yun, M. S. Jeong, S. K. Lee, J. W. Jeon, J. Y. Park related to gear geometry, kinematics, dynamics and manufac-
and G. M. Kim, Sustainable production of helical pinion turing.