Sa/thel « cba. EEA AB FAT Aas Bas el BUF BH rae ed 8s 4y Fas MS eee Ast BSF7| 24 ZEW] Wa ¥ Ss MBA" ASR" BSA «tease gede + USRSHATA AAAS vee SUG ABSA Development and Application of Calibration Interval Analysis Program for Measurement Quality and Reliability Improvement Byoung-sun Park’ + Ung-Hwan Ahn™ - Joong-Jae Cho” * Standards & Quality Management Team, Korea Research Institute of Standards and Science ** Technology Value Development Team, Korea Research Institute of Standards and Science ‘s** Department of Information Statistics, Chungbuk National University Key Words : Calibration Interval, Measurement Quality, Measurement Reliability, Reactive Method, Maximum Likelihood Estimation Method Abstract In recent years, the widespread application of quality management and measurement reliability has put increasing emphasis on procedures for periodic instrument calibration. By optimizing calibration intervals, unnecessary calibrations can be minimized, thereby reducing costs. Moreover, optimizing intervals will prove compliance with regulatory directives while ensuring maximal compliance with reliability targets. In this paper, we present Calibration Interval Analysis Program developed using several establishment method ologies of calibration interval for measurement quality and reliability improvement. Also, we perform calibra tion interval analysis for some measurement instruments and analyse its results. LA = aa 2 mao] BeAole} oF AC WA(calibration)]2} HE BA SAMA Sa 3Ay)e9] FIILS AAA Bal awe] SF 7| BE Syrladel ashe Fo] Gh, SE EA 7 Arps WEYa QE LSS UAAAMA al 24(material measure)+} EEZA(reference ma- S| Bs} Wel) BAare BsalBoly Wah terialo] VERHE a4} clo PSsh= Fo] HE) MASSES AS SQ71SS AS] Sy, AH Ab of a] a H Aol] BAS As Ae R4ge48 delta, Awe S Hy alo ap da AIS ul ech, 2 Mae] PSA QAACS Roja Ech, Let F471] MAF7I\9} Bestel, Fe]4e}o] B+ BH le F971G2 Whee] ¥sae] ole S7A BAIA £988 A) AGIA Wt 4 alsles] by Sao] 7eaqoe aa AR FAA “SS wae AD Bol Yay Bell SAFO Bey H 7A AALS WAFS AAspaLzp TE HOE eee 9) ANdahs, 4, AR, Ge FAME + a1AAA} bspark@kriss.re.kr SS Aetele] Pe4oe 3 NES Agsoyos SBazeesia, th. He Hejyoe Bel $Me Whe 1SRE AG] WASHES AGHAST SSAC" a] ]apo} zp Al BATE AVIS ASSES s}st ald. £8 AT 2005 4a AAR Shea) AAS. BAF AloVoAE 497) WB ay wv FAA BAe] FSA, WY a, Ra) HAF] AVS AM M]ES ajar You, SHA AIAAE £344] S454) aos = 4719] ABE Fae] AVIS ge waz 7] AB DHSS a7stat seh. SARE eA WAM 7B} ho Ee}ele} a ANE BP, dal APAPW) ABE Sy 71S Hse} AAjoe WY S Aaa} a Bete APE AM Meloy, Ve SEMA AAShs AL Fe USAOR VSO} APRs ME APM. oe SUR Age} das nd RBME SSM Sol Boye Sz 4, A7} SUES) Wt SS PAR Sa RAPE AS. Beeches Bos, asa BAS AY EA wZe] MSe BE Sy as} 4 Aas Aaa earls Rae + QV ach Oe Azpgol=e Bslst Aa) Alagoa AAA #7] ABS SA AY] BES ape] Bap AS AAG WAH] Agel gles Ae aa} Rado] Sala AWS BAK aSsy7) wee AMA) IPAS] EA MAS olafseD o]S ABS sol BE le] Fo] gat vs] kha} yl & HS Hse] S7] wWeole}st St F Ve. Ma F871) BAF7] Bas Baste] 959] APNE AMY F APU SS Salo} ozael AZo] AHL APD YoOo\ackson, et al, (1987), Castrup(1989), Wyatt e¢ al(1991), Castrup et al(1994), Carbone(2004), Macii et al(2004), Nunzi et al(2004) “$), NCSL RP-1(1996)o 4% AA WAT] AAs} BUA] S4ow wes ES ANA AFR] ol Folia geh. well, Ue) APM MAF7] 29 WHS] Say Be 59719] F7] Hels} Welsto} Be eps of ah AFPSIVHASA, 1984 | S447] 71a BAS, 1995; AHSAN, 2001 ; VRE Hata, 2004). salut leet Arse saad lA 2b) 7) AAT selate] A] BR + 9 He] ASH4] SHOe else] APapso] Bs M341 8/55 de) Ase Ae] lack t+ leh wey eels ub Abgalaeya| Sq Sa BAS Wh} Bch ASAol|u Aagqel Sa7\2] B77] Bes Mele, 21B714) Alte WAF7] -A48WAS Fol AB wae} MLE YY S188] BA BSE Fe Bas] Bt SIGS ATAIRG. LH 7A Fa S47] AB BQ Be Bg oF AeoleS Huse] oe Aube Zerg] AS2OLH OE F7] BAS FA ohn, 2 ashe vist. EAlstsich, Wa 2s Wat) Adel eee aap BR oelel Azo spo} ABT, Sg 2] WA) AE BAF] AB WBS SoA A Eada JS AEA FA WSS 7M Th. Ades WW BAF) BA BeBe] A Ast S24, wg lA Gole} gel WH] BA aot Se ay, ste Fa saz et a7) AY Pa BL AspS wat. YAS ty. Foe 6g Ese) AS BE ate ste} tes}atstch. 2, MB8F7] ABS) Uy aa w glole] 22: BBF1E BAS HAE le 742) Bes 7)83} SAU WS Balok SH, clo) Wa a Be SA7/z SS Uae) Bala adel ABIES MMslojok Beh. Aeksjos 3q7] 9] BREE SAG Dat BE Babel sto} 4 + das, & AAs 4 ues Basel Use aepapal hahaa ach. 275 Holy at TH a = o S71 a/310N) ml AZAKN) fe. | 7 BSE OD ~ » das) © Ba ABBA) ° qe maa) ° 28 S319) « BAe 8 wa2Ko) 2 A] BBA) aA GRAN) APSE WAAAHN) AA AbA(N) BAY Fe] 2.84]2H0) we Hele) 2A/FES) AEA BA i3aMl1 8/57 3. FR BBE) AB WHS] 27 aA) Ags]. a7 AYSLe So] 24 oly ae AX F7] 28 Ws SHS RAT | nd o]4 Ale S poe e WS (Reactive) ‘3 as} 319--73(Maximum Likelihood Estimation : MLE) BH Se] alc WS BWA As W_oSHE| gleleja] wes ato] FS A*sHS ALE, NCSL RP-1(1996) BUA BANA. oO] MBS Baal gavel s of al wd ABA O|H/Aapol BSsto} F7| 8490 lolli, w]it4} Assy] AS A AS Be Wa, otek: FH Als|Eo Walshe Fe BBs BAI BG wREAC|D qa 2a zo] APH PHS Bech. HL) We $ WHEEE Al, A2, A3 SA SH eh AL SBS mt Fazio] We 8a} 25} oo] S Aste] Geb F718 Basta, AQ -WYyS ay S874 Ae Sal F7] AGHA aelstel + 7S BAA, AB WMS ad Syed FT AS SARA QAR F792] 24 AS ahbshn Agee}. MLE YS altel HE 44 Als|Ee] aS EMSA Weslo] H71E BIA. o] WAS ae Sel Bla Bae F71 BAe] 7eetehe Bae Re we, Melas Saeed) ose a SS) SAs4 Ge} ge] AF5]71 sed BAS AA Ne) oles S7sh= Fee] seh. EDIE 2374) Aetsat 27 WAF7] AA WIS SIA B AFA We Zengol ASd AZ WSs; Ge Betsimple approach) ERE MLE Wo} ste] AAhsp1E eeh. 3.1 A3 34a (Interval Test Method) oO} wee ase F712] 248 +s] GA aa BAA BAS Fale] 7] BY ARS Wetsh 2, £40] Baarhy wae Bed) Fold a BEF Ye FS BAD Agee. Hao So} Wale] MES <1g 2H) aalstsich eF ANAL S}o1 hth. 4a E93) Male ge Ae DHF EY 22a WS! Ss Tart = Mat Tae Tag) Else Tpit = IAt 10? Logg + 0.5) End If End If Else '%-7] $7t Frit = Int 10 “® CT, 0.5) End If RN F7) S7S, RR Sh 298 PY AS FA FE a AeA ach. +4 #7] 24S We Vase 9} Deh. #7] 24 aS If R>R* Then #7] FA y=(R-RYVG=C) If y>25 Then SE D> 77] a8 aas If Tyas? 2Fuue Then Tne = Bang Else If Zeist? 1-2fing and Tiong >0 Then Tee = 12mg Else If Zia‘ eng/2 Then Tyee = Fang 12 Else ei End If If Loec? 122mg and Tone? Then Tc 1.2L one End If If Lec? Tmax and Inu > 0 Then r= ores End If If Tre Fain Then Tyee Faia <# 40] Al Suesel ef AAoe * AG FA) ear ABEL, B71) APES at BPLSA <¥ Sol] allel CVS] lay AS 4ow 47/7} SASS Ba Veh 3.2 MLE BY <29 22 449719) ag ole] Bah A1zhH We 44 Aso) WS YE Woe, 44y al Er we le] AE Babe} ape} gaeche AS BHD Yeh. o] Ao aug az] EE SHE Sg as|m7h Algol whe esse BE BAS 2 FUCHS AS PMc} lee WES Aga 1244 71S ASsaAt se Aol MLE S82) 718 ela FA Bzlole} et +same M348H1 8/59 suet. RO sums R' 4 BH OAH NE (0) #1 <2¥ 3> Ab] de 4a Asse] wat 2) MLE WHS 3g ole] Bs} A]ztel) mp = 49 AE BAGS Mato} cyst Age w ‘BS o|Se}31, FE 4 Uikelihood function ) AA) VES FEVERS Asta aleh. o} wel Oe 7s} Make EAlsste} ala}sha <4 49} ch. 3.21 AZ HHS] BA WA F714 WAS We 77] BAGS Ga Alziel] BAS AHS LEAH ayesJo} ach. old AHS 2] OPES ols 4871s) Zag) a AP Hs BE Bbselest Welz ws4] agch> wae aa. 2eA8 exe ey te OR le@:aas onal ae, OF eM 2302 saan 38 He ta Quin nenoUn —.eeweas ene a ay Rn amas <2¥ 4> MLE Yas) 7st aap BE AS WY oF Babel Aldon ahah fet 7 a) ORS ORE AS CHE Gee BA oh ee AS} leye All RE Me < Le alla] 4B BAIS. Be) Sa7Sol SUS BWP wy = Ae Aledo as WA NEV A, | Aa}A)zr fol) Se SARE Alzhel] EGSHS S| ANS FE net Hla A S478 BAe LF S8717b SA ole Be4) BA) eS A} BA VAch BHM te WA BAP o] Us BAN SA71S9] SAS se EAA on, lave aS Ale Re AOR A) 3 B+ Olle] AS BI + ach. lee A BTS EAS] Male, Se & sgoletat AS] a wepo}e} So] Yay H2 7) Oe Fes aeolech. Med BME se}o]E7} BSd MAT (RC), te T/A SA] FBS Sto AAMC. ep] Be ZEAlrol ae a EWS Ashe Lae AT TTS AM ABE a+ VS Asa Bro] Vee wep eyS FAs ay leh. 3.2.2 $4 Asis Bay Be Sool Ul ole Fela coll He RW | she BaP Sol HER Fall. o) MSHE WYF7] AYR eA die 44 VS & Be BF lee UVa MAF) ABE ols ANUS G+ 97] Weelch cee Wat = Aysp] Haste} Pe AL LIV] He Al AHSs]o] Row, B aes] MRI relly = 83} 23} e}Ho] alztol we} Age sey] Bol AS 7st ze Bake stejs}at. ole] ale Ba BH at PES Sasa oh Sap ach Bae" w RU AD=e~%, 3.2.3 heboe] YB Alle Be HB © de Weel Ae wep] FA Ay (Da) F014) 2H} (failure rate) 2} WE] of F8sh= Ue He Ges} dh. RA, 1D) NCSL RP-1(1996) ALaDAOLANS 414 Sf els 9} oh Se 5 A9] BEL A71OR Amst sehGove Al. oS el. REAL AWM AAS SF MABE oh] Aare St Sales + Ga a dae get AE TR PAF ol AA Ssh Yo] Foal, 4 Le N= Yin, G= Ba, Tap Bint (ay VIA ee Bel SA ARE FA} Folch of BEAD 7 SIs] HSER ola] gle see @ Boz Ue Aap gopalch, Pr No failure before T) =F @) ADS 1G Sa Bo] BAS + ate GIN=e @ PVA B= A Ca SME 92] HE Hel gat SAAS UEC Do ge A] 2] RE Ee 3 Be] death. 1 Dy=— 5 in(GIN) © os} Be Boe Sela F8e dso = spl 2 MLE BAS o]Seq] Gol] SpE, we UU Bae Sage) SE AEE Aer, @ MLE BR) Se aepH Ey Fy lal MU Bae S8RS AS] Malo} 4] (Del #14) 33} Ze] 214 asl) 8) B(exponen- tial failure rate) Sev]e} 92] APE YS EN. 69) F740] Bae F n,2] FANE S e: 9) S871S9] AUS SHY HSS des] pee % “WAl(binomial probability lawl 23h $0}2] Holt Pelee tgs} go] Bag, Pr(G, passes) = Gray MR.) 6) o] AS ashe FEM HS AB Qo] H oath. eS sarap Mt OF RU, 1" gy 48 S83) sis ONS se WHF71 BA BeBe YY Bs o) NY FAS Gel] ste] 12] logs) ») BATE OLE AAyoS Aolzch, +, (net; Cry FO=-G0n 1) = O23 AF FBS U7) MAH A (BS ell G ate] Solok Meh. OF A= 1, m=N, = G, H=T eb Agate, Ay (Se) ale HE 4] Gly Fo} Al ala} Ho] BBS G7} Ach, SRE 4 OE e-1S AIDE BHs) at Palzlz] Meh. wep] aS) BPH gh ON FE-MEWF BE VAGBISE lB | oo) HR AS FHS Ale] Waste, WA 09] JX Haste] Bea}, 249) Fe =A GMA Fla BE WH] FIR D7 a th EBs gol ste] Faye] PASS Bap = Rol WAH. IAS Hs} Ao] Ho] 4c}, . 4 (mtg, FO= DCm yee ® Ale oe Aol lat ool et aS why 2s eth. FO) = 1 FG) (10) | HAS Ole] Bost PAB + RS 7% SAE AVS FE AS Rah tah ena] Bayt Hela wr] WS solace. B a F9] A BSG Hg} VS wypr]o] ye Sapgol fai ALAS sach. FOF OG) a 0.00001 (un 42) ASRS A (Vel B= 62] MLE Woh, Ne PAA OBA ABH SOlAlch. OAS BF 38 A (oats SPIE) 62) ERS MLE we) Ie Fy -Aakel Ooh 97 Az ale, cleye] Agel Alle gee et dg gol FAYE A.Beaeesia RCt9) " RULB)=e* 3.24 Ay BBX By aay Ge BW MLE Wael Jato] Bago] gal 218 o)B AG ahok so}, c= 4g aslo} ugh HSA RAS] BAS sho] Ao} eet wet a US aetsha tH, ole] We ofe] 74) Bete] Bas teel4 Ada ate) Feet Bas ag aor Meh, ole Ae MAYS Fepyoe B HIE AF WAY BYS AAe OSM Wesabe lt MTE(Measuring and Test Equipment) 2} le] Sey WAL, easel VF, ALB z}o] ALS Bey Rds AI Pas] zo]y Foeyy aag AB] +BatA) Ach. PE ool as} 2 AS OLE Bsa, ol BH Aeshst 23} BF UE LAS ooley7} 7 SRS Wels} a Sat Bao) Ab BBVA YSU > VE BT & BRAS Bol ey Agee. O awa aa A= Bde] We Ady age saa (ack of fit” ANBAR 4) R(t), i=1,2, yk Mele] PAP IOR WHE QI}; Heo} EVE FANA Wel BWI] THM SH Dap BA UPS LASS Hlavee}. ‘A¥PAoy 9 3}9} ALE} ‘E+! 23}9] ALLO ulay Agjzjow ae AAe BUS PARE Roe e+ ge. os AM AREA 7} a) AA|So} ghrp.

AMY AIS He WAAR 221 df SS. MS. Fo b ar us, | Fo st | am] tes) pss | __ms, | Prie=ry 2} “kom | > MS, eF WS. ga | eA) 29) ss Wa [aml RSS Yow R= BRR), 255-8 Boy) WAR IRR +R), 1SS= RSS-ESS= F F(R R)'= Bi nAR-R)? POPU m,n. Hiaaaxtt 2/61 wet Beale] woley7t weet aay ach a, Lss7} Ess BU} AM, 1 BBS Betsy] Sra t+ Ach Essel] Hah Sz isso] a 2He Foo] S7 we] EWR Axel sw, WF Fy = ASE Bde] Ay 48S B+ eh. gep 44 F,9| so] 2A BFS 4, 9 she) BES E % 71% 2ls}%E(rejection confidence level) (~ ») Ho] 243 BUS 4s] Ve los we a+ ach. @ 2d AB Ee Ags Eo ae ad alge) olFelz}e 42 Age wes es ues Bas a asks sygol debi Ae. ARE az aa 2 AVE Bao] de Bees AVA 7d Be PAPER WE Belo] BP Roleb Hage + Neh A Bale] de ARI Agel ye At AslrEo] SAS ABE a lola] S43] ERY B47} Arpt sezhe, Bal(economic) # UFA(democratic) 71% F BGS AVES BAD BAA) WET. lee AGS SIAO = Tat FER, 495} Ze] Bo] sole 4p 7 AIE alo de CUS Weber alg] = Bde Agsed BSA + ach Ne cH (a2) 4714 ce Sl He At AS Eela, Noe BYo] S8he 2¥s] 271, rest ke RO te dela. R&.9)=1-R (13) eV RE SH ASele. 4 24 GE 4 He Fe14) olE9] Ae Ye Bake hla, a 42399) AW AE Bol lal dae ork. 3.25 BAF] AA © Baz7| A de Asis Bao] AGs|a, galzl BOPCnd Of Period) SH AS|= Rel) PE aAYT7] Aro Ae A H)Sts AS + Meh.o/eel - et. BBA Ag S83] Mas sie ae 7aF7| 24 eawS ie Wee RC TO)=R a4) TS A Aa AAO] A¥Sshe}e chyo}ayyt, Ae ME oso) HE BAS wes AF] IW Woe TBA] Se BH7p WPaeh, o] Fa awwoes | we] tgs EME Mallolch + AAo2 FE-GEWS AHI 7) AS FE WeOSA, wet alt +Asz] Vera, rs] ol R70) Rel B W7A S77 trial-and- error SH Nal TS Bech @ Wat?) alzjea To We Abs} set Asleae aed we #7) WH] QF5ol7)= Bass Wray) Ma} oF AR Sas AE Bo] we Gas By 7rek= Ho] seh seleHe AF We alo]eys) EAS ASe Yo] RIS Me Bays Ae 7p AE GNA WBS We}. wep] wae] Wp of ASS $ Me AAAI WHS Tasks A AESHS WMH Lele} ME) Sys aa POEM AAI Bs US + ae. TH He VAs} Ht WIS 9} 1B WAND a, ole 7b Ss] Woe we alee 1-ael disto} aatac}, Re,,D) +2. Vat Re, I=R (15) R(x,B)—a,¥ Varl Ble, B))= RK a6) @, 2 HS ALEHE] Sojacy, 1n-a=7he [1 fae 41 (15) 4 OS MES GEE R19) ol sto] Bit ZAbso ZA7S}o} PA Blo], a7) 7 aad $48 AE UF RULD)S aaey] wel dese rela} seh als ae BH Aol HAH Bch. 4, 14847] #4 Zea WA Aeusheel Sale jet Mae oF 2 74] wae) sla] AB rests, alae FNS WADA BH APS AAD 71S 44s] Add 4 was Asso] Wes + Sth, S}eb AS HO MLE Sol) YR ag #7] ABA soya] AAA BW sso] Salad WMS BAZ BSA?) Gel alate] ezb Hol 1S ASHE HIE BE esol VS + Ue}. Mey] oye ASS Boe + We Be 28s Mesto] AbSAVE 7B Ws] ols Sao] UG BAA MITE ASA + D = EP Baye] Aas] ats, ole Aye apolye Fe] 7) 7] 28 Was So AB BSMLE Wael le wea7] HA EBS 7b aac. WE BRIABS PHPS 71wkoOs Wweb) eA EYES PAHRat, DBE MySQLE A} Basieh. o] Bl Wwe WYF7] BA BE AB) SOF FA SSS Ahstsu7} Bet. 41 2847] 24 Berg 27 MV ZZ ASS she] Helz} Bae) & Syl Fa BAF] BA AMS] 27) BL 42 2947] 24 ZB] 54 Ota Be apa mee BaF7) BAL BBO}Beaeesl) WE S SAS Molt Bzeless Role}. 7)ee] AG38 77] B44] ZEnMSe BF gels ape SEE ABAHSS] BAS LE BH} we, = ERAGE USE 4495] Aeapt dal AS 2+ VES spaic. @ soley wfol~ = SEUGS BE og ye Aes ole) OAS ty S13) 71B/Ia, $87) ABSa 718, ABA, BBY, AM) Aw), ay YA vio] (24 AAA Sse ZE dole] Wag a SD SO] BF golepo|Assjo} elajea] a Aso] AWE + YES asic}. ajo]ejwjo|as MSA}2] MySQL AbB8}9.c} @ D8 lS Gele} He) 744.27] (Import) Ui7\(Export) 7's ale E Serge WA oe slelels] wo B Fett ASA BAYS Hee] dy S47) wa 18 FIOLE]7} 957 she seve) EASHE BF-0} EOS # RBIGOz 77Q7|(Impor)s FF Ske 753} DB) AA Aa HE HY Agr 9} HY ole SMSVEVS 9} wpe xds) yy) Export)S HF We SS ATs get. @ B 7s] WAS ASA le Ho]A By WH R447] 24] Z21G-2 PHPS 7)yho. = Awersay LIAS TAPLHA, oly} FSA ASSSL QE MeL Bsa} PS yy Ve solAS Sa At Pes] As +e 2+ VES seach, © FA 24 14 mele) Bay 7's = SE2BWS VS, 2a, AAA, Sa 7) Si Po] IRM Za so] We lB apeley S ARG + ME ss ASTOSa yp} wy 18 oles] Ho] WE} SS AY 7HseaEs 3} ach. © B4 Axe) We Hd BS AA) F7| 24 4 Asay ASE OS VS of We FAAS 7Hoe BE ET(MS Excel, ISG AVE A3 Interval Tester 22218, Mathematica, aeaat 8/63 SAM7/4| Minitab HSS WSs} ASaarh, 43 24 ]% dele] Be] S471) BBF7] HAS WTS Bao S47) 2 AAA Bus} wy o]e vlolel7} =z FALE ATA, oe WHA Beye + she WES Zhe] VAIS Mwsyou, o| Ao ALE LAR HES] APERS S| ZH 27H] 9} 7H SAS Sst} et. 43.1 UAV/7R BB WEY (CLA 6) oO} SoA Alt a7 S53} 7] Sal AA/71at Aw APR +4, Ail S29] ale + ged. <1d © Maye BB SS RYZE Hel 43.2 4471 Ax Be ((29 7) °) So Alt S871SS SHett 7)SSa Sa7\s4 ae ae 8 74, A SS Teac. 28 34 wlolE] Export 44 shel 44 Bae BA o] Aye ey ANG wa le sole} Be] ol ola] Qe Sg7]9) WB ole sbolels wt 22, 2 ATO WS ABZ MLE WUEsuas Mag4ainit 8/65 YW EW $e 2947] EA Mange o]Pep | 7) BAS Hass YS hapa, ae. 441 AZ BH Ie TAF] 24 A3 Nol ste] maAt7] BAS + eyststa} BH BF, AY So] 2713 see WE [43] HES Se ap <1g 145} VS AB yy 1 e4 alae B+ le. ones Reese <9 L4> AB #4 WHS) Bape EAS ASS HRS] USS ) a) Ad ee Weece Aes dest ae. @: 2877) BA GHB ed Sar/Aazays wa Ae @-O 84 Se 2 a Sia eyag Alo eH AHF YASS @: E48 ws 7172 Aa gaz ya ISHS te 49 d= oe & She Va @ Se She 884} S35} wl B(= (100 - SE AS) WZ A Wa B @: 24 2 RES BAU 24a ost AS aa @ ALG AS Woe F718 “a” ds VA ©: Ade 44 ed HIE “VW UHE We @ 6 @ 7] WS WBA AB ASE = 1 - F AFH % BAZ Wel 1B ast S F7] Be Reel de EY a] Sas VS Foy AS ASA] We ARLUS Wg} st = asa ade da ae 7189) oe BAS Fa 1 AB WHS] HA) Fe BeAHA]) ate] SAG 1D>E Ha Belo dete} AZ zl Hol le By das} 71S AQ RRA Asp} Ve BFE Belch, 442 MLE Sule 1% ma#7] BA MLE el) 2]s}o] WBA7] BALE -Ppayspseah ae BF, 5} ZL MLE We] BAL A7/SS +P alc 2) MAMA Us7el ay AYES To} Astps1 A) ZS yuh ate.seas . Se. ZEA 49 Eaa} Asis gue ae maF7| 24 MeIwS Ew Be =OO980S08 © 2 HAS] UBS 444 al Soe Beate dest ge. aH eo et zh Del Yo 712s Aa ade Va te S49 AE We % BAe Wa seo] RF 7)o} et Aslea AWS Aa ‘I ae ae % B42 VA +S 77] a UE] He HANS BD AMAZ|A)Ze] GR AVLUS AAA} 3} = ay “a” GAR da ABA NE He} BYS Ta 2 e $3 eel asiel MLE BA Yor le BA OB 71E Aas) ale Bole = dee, age gas zl oe pee BA] Asp} <2g 18>~<3¥ 20>] Al ssolgh o. Azo] dejo] Aloe Aw7Z ach © aa 84 as} ash MLE Yo] et Wal BA As} aot na QA BASIM A at BA Aa} <2¥ 1>= Al Bel aslo} SIMCHA) Bue Tasks del 7 Baa ae oT ea aate, skeble) 27] 44 Sol ae dae ame ade + sid. <2Y 17> MLE Was] BA AR 7 Ag ae (lA) <1@ 19> MLE Sale) 2] eb AY BAY As} aha: 21-SIMBuaeetais @ AF SAME Ge Ae BA Aap <2d 20>2 24 Bol cste] MLE WS ASRS Ho) 7] Vol et A BA Ashes, SA) seole) Bo) Ha Sol ee aye Qa S Sls + Qo. SAH 20> MLE “hHel) 21g AE Ay yp ahd: 7\=-MLE 5. #2 S87Ilo He DIR BA a sy ash EMIS Aes AVasgalal Aes SA71S9l Usto] Qa ASH a Ve F719) Aa BS TMs I Verse} ye 7] By AM] HITS AES] Aste], WR Fast > ANS AAS VSRS IAT Aol] west Hige241 8/67 she Ba Bg ole qeolels +Falato} zt 3y7] WE AZ WAS MLE Deol Ne 7] BAS Bat, 2 ASE Uae. WAI s} Ae. E4 oy SA71BE AQ Wa Lok 372} SASSA, SVEA, MYLES} 71E} 4A] $87\(@ 40), SPRT, Thermal Mass Flow- meter, EEAWS APsaAch. dA Aad 44 71s) A WY le lolejs] Huts ~<# 16>3} eh. 249] 8A ase As, Bay depae a3 gold 17 MLE Ye] 272] al B2] $4718 BA ola dele Bu Ba Bal 4a 47) & 3 2: on a4718 (aa: @) Solel Pa 7b aaa | AeA nat aaah 18. 1999.01 ~2003.12 2,987 40 131 EBSA) 12, 1999.01~2003.12 | 3,632 35 84 Wesel) 12, 1999.01 ~2003.12 496 3 34 aad 12. 2002.01 ~2004.12 62 = 1 ‘SPRT (aeazigeca) 18 2001.01 ~2004.12 101 10 16 ‘Thermal Mass Flowmeter 6 2003.11 ~2005.09 231 2 3 REAY 18, 2000.07 ~2004.12 1,093 Zz 1468/HEM . OBE. REM AY Bas) AS Oe He UIT EA Benes! We a Ss <# 8> Sara Bab 25} Ho] We NE Se Sat As ote] Be NE » st aaa #15 Be HE BF, He Ie HS KS C 1502 EBEA £5 %S WOE BF, ASA SS are Paiste] Be) MARS g SAL £16 %S Hope BF, Aa a= Bt aad iste) Ge) Vaas TA} Aa) D8 71H gal 1,000 cA aaa RS RBIS NTO se 2 aol7} Bee rp a! aes HASH) Bol At, Ae} 43}2 We SRT 5) O84 Go) a wy BE aS ae, G@ewalgecs | 4 ane Be ia oe Fase eh ‘Thermal. Mase Mevveter [#1 BFSE Wee 44, 184 232 Be ae Has a) EEAd A ADA MBSE MBA Accuracy HE] AS F492] Wo) Stability= 71E2= Bab Za} oP Wee 7171 aS S47)/8 24 Oe BR 7S z Atay aaa my ae (a @ AEE RE =A 200207 ~200312, 730 oma age: 2954) 200301 ~200312 548 ee eae & oe Wea SAl 200301 ~200312 548 alt Hee" 21 (2) gam 200401 ~200412 548 © 3] 88471" : 10000 (2) SPRIESASATS EA) 200307 ~200412 730 aa eon oa es ‘Thermal Mass Flowmeter 200502~200507 274 oie ore ae oA eet ERAT 200307 ~200412 730 BFS" 90.) #)° AS RMLE FS AS BH," AB AS YH, * MLE AS TS <# 10> BAF7] BA FY Aah: SEAS] BF as) in | ay aa ted Ba | gen ea jofaa| ase | 3% Me a * | = la@a:e| 7 | 93 [ae | ae SIM_| MLE 347] 374 | 276 73.79 18 4 10 Lucas 20 19 95.00 17 55 55, Ono sokki 30 2B 93.33, 8 18 43, Onsoku. 54 16 29.62 18 9 2 Az Rion 82 72 87.80 19 19 24 Tes 17 15 88.23 12, 25 24 Yokogawa 115 98 85.21 18 18 19 Yokogawa 3604 93 79 84.94 18 18 18 Onsoku OS-11 54 18 33.33 18, 9 3 ad Rion NA-24 27 23 85.18 19 20 20 Ono sokki LA-210 18 16 88.88 18 25 25 Yokogawa 3604A 22 18 81.81 18 15 15Bazeeeiz) gaat 3/69 BBF7] #4 TY Asp: AURA] Bs aa | on | as a Lal AA ag aia | aia | asi aa ag Me # | # aie] 7 Ale | Ae sim_| MLE Sal 3iL_| 248 | 79.74 12 iL 9 Tokyo 33 [26 | 778 | 13 | 13 9 Custom w | 1s | 3823 [13 w [a7 Hioki 64 [50 | 7eaz | 13 | 13 AZAt | Minolta 31 24 | 7741 13 13 Tes wf a [ sa | wz | i | 2 Topcon 25 21 84.00 13 12 12 Yokogawa 66 [57 | 8636 | 12 | 12 u Tokyo ANA F9 26 | a | 8076 | 13 10 [ 10 lioki 3421 16 12 75.00 12 7 7 Hiioki 3422 a [is [ 7.00 | 13 7 =a | Hioki 3423 24 [20 | 8333 | 13 2 | 12 Tes 1330 20 | 19 | 95.00 | 12 a [4 Topcon IM-2D qo | a7 [e947 [13 19 [19 Yokogawa 3281 45 [37 [ e222 | 3 | 13 5a 2947] 24 +8 Az}: Thermal Mass Flowmeter2] 2-4 ut ay ae 3 IN oa AZM ag vr | an | alas | 2% roi — - | # [cease | 7 SIM_| MLE sa7i 60 | 31 51.66 6 3 2 2 AZAL | Volumetries 2 [13 | 442 | 6 1 1 Jain-LRM 32_[ is | 5625 | 7 4 2 zd Volumetrics 14342-3 16 8 50.00 6 2 1 Jain-LRM v2.0 32 [7 | saz | 7 3 2TO/siAl « OBA. BA 42 B00} Aes dae He UaF7| 4 BIB Wee Bs <# 14> RYT] BA FY As: Gadel B+ mae IN a eee es MEAL se vii | va] ase | 28 — = | = |C:®) AB | ale | Ae SIM | MLE za a S-Type 28 27 96.42 13 59 59 M977] BA FY Bat: SPRTS BP aelw |] es Faz BA | ae ve foi || ase | 3t — + | = [ae] 7 Bre lad ala SIM _| MLE a7 15 6 40.00 19 4 4 RYT] BA FY As: REA] BF Wt | IN ay aa ari | or | ass | 2% # | + la@asw] F771] 3 224 | 164 | 73.21 is | 14 Guildline 39 | 14 | 35.89 ig _| 10 42 | 34 | 80.95 ig_| 18 L&N 18. 9 | 50.00 13, ESI 46 | 43 | 93.47 ig { 19 34 [25 | 73.52 ig | 19 Guildline 23 7 | 3043 | 21 ier 37 | 29 | 7837 Tinsley i9 [| 18 | 94.73 YEW 26 | 21 | 80.76 SR-1 24 | 17 | 7083 SR-10 24 | 19 | 79.16 SR-100 25 | 17 | 68.00 SR-1K 15 | 60.00 SR-10K 19 | 73.07 ‘SR-100K yz | 63.15 SR-IM 16 | 80.00 ‘SR-10M 13 | 81.25 AAS Sls + Vc. o} Wl F7] AVS Ha oF #7| 48°] 7Hs@ Boe Bez] MLE Wael | 2 238 288 AU Ae Ea} Baa Uo Ase wee + Mz)eb, MLE YASS BAS of S Belch. 1aRow AZ Yao] vjal Beet Hay WS] ols ATMS AS ARIASBuses al AG. oe 4) a} Fh] qalajow 3071 1421 BPH MLE BAY Yo) as 2B) BE AHS az Wa oe Ra Sy] Ase Deh Ae] udasiea say. Bae AVS] ES] MLE Wo] ya 221 F7] asp S| “HE Ba"E ASS BUS] AB NS G wel la ASS AS, aD “gq” yee gq Ad Fa 47) AHS Sola] BAY WA 7I7] FS aes jS{ou payojage a FS EAR oleh. lee AMRSS AA AAS ALS E22 SHQ WA Aspolny, We AVA BP wep zp}4o2 age rI7) ASA St SE AES Wa Se agg a Qo] WE 2 7S AZo} et Fue + sath. Oo] mh abe Ho] ah Pale 4 Ax AACS NFS] wee jae Wt ay 71% APBSSL ME AFA} Ba ALT} Fs] 9] a Se S422 DysHe A YA] Aye] aA F7it AVE Soy FAY area oF RS Rel, 6.4 2 Ue UAB A-Ss|a gle FA7I9] wg Ut B F719} Bespo] S7wA7|aelgays B28 2 SAAS S479] QUBHE, ot AB, ASEA, 23 DABS SS Betsto} ap 4D M4 WES Aozy zyqo 2 DQF1S 240 + VD Blew Yoo, HAF?) AVS AW ol Sze) BW Gee AF 7 AB PASS AMID Yeh A= Spa} AA BHIAE ASE S719) ele] By qos F7| 249 Gays Wawqe ala a F718 Agate deste APE Al Me a Bolt. ols AAA WAH?) Aaa) gloiy ah BAB so] SAA 7S Bz aes17] WEI LARA] BEALS] o]Az WAS o];y an ol 4 dol BE ozgo] VS we oh4e AES] Ssh MLS ER PES] 7] HE ole} ARB ee, Wey BeBe AMAT] Byago] w A¥7] BAL Wa VBA Wee) oles ae AAS 1S Selo] WV Wasp] wWAaF7] Mi3a2¥11.8/71 Sed ¢ WE ZS38 FZ wTas Wrst oh EM BS GLE osteo] Se ESS a Seo] AWE ZBago] det Ha Sata, HA qos Aga Fa Salo} Het wy o} 4 eS Bese] oS ye Zergo] 4g A SAVAPVEWASY LAS +¥she] AMS Nal BAO Berge) epyyap BEIS FelseAe. el AHA) BR tg 7)zelA] Sg7]2] wg t7] ABS Hal BA eal] He APA wo] a EALS BIMID BAIA solo] +ayst Ao) SHS) Foz, AAA ASSL She S-a7lel date} s}4]e]2 Bel 7Iel 77) ES ANT & he 2h) WATS Agee} we ASAe]u AA4o# SQ7Se gayoe A AISA Fa 2 AEs} ys} Bay asp S 7G + AS welch. Boe BEE ob ey Re Saziq Ae 23, 418 US SS DAG 2H ae @ ABT BA FMP F7} SAS Het Lge Mae] way AS AG eA see #072 yiae. ADEA (1) 2Sa(984), “Saeavb S7Re Abe) S712] AA Marl? Aad Be AP", vat SEAUe Hg]7],, 124, 2B, pp. 33-36. [2] AU71EHAQOOD, AMWAY F719} ASE FAIVIS Ht F871E 71S me aH, 18REa, [3] @444717124 BA1995), “MAAA AY #7| 24 2 ZAM BA NS NE We a Ts, SWAG [4] GH REAHAFA2004), VAWYSR AVE als ALARA"), KRISS/IR--2004-072, pp. 174-198. Carbone, P2004), “Performance of Simple Response Method for the Establishment and Adjustment of Calibration Intervals”, IEEE Transactions. on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 53, No. 3, pp. 56~76. [6] Castrup, H.(1989), “Calibration Require-reper age. 26m AY BUS NS BUS se WIS BA ETB He [7] [8] ments Analysis System”, the NCSL 1989 Workshop and Symposium, Denver. Castrup, H. and Johnson, K. M.(1994), “Tech- niques for Optimizing Calibration Intervals”, Proceedings of the ASNE Test & Calibra tion Symposium, Arlington. Jackson, D. and Castrup, H.(1987), “Reli~ ability Analysis Methods for Calibration Intervals : Analysis of Type III Censored Data”, Proceedings of the NCSL 1987 Work~ shop & Symposium, Denver. Macii, D., Tavella, P., Perone, E., and Carbone, P.(2004), “Accuracy Comparison, Between Techniques for the Establishment of Calibration Intervals : Application to Atomic Clocks”, JEEE Transactions. on In~ strumentation and. Measurement, Vol. 53, No. 4, pp. 1167-1172. National Conference of Standard Labor- atories(1996), “Establishment and Adjust- 10) ment of Calibration Interval mended Practice RP-1. (11) Nunzi, E., Panfilo, G., Tavella, P., and Carbone, P.(2004), “Stochastic and Reactive Methods for the Determination of Optimal Calibration Intervals”, Techincal Report ADIT-04-0589. (12] Wyatt, D. and Castrup, H.(1991), “Managing Calibration Intervals”, Proceedings of the NCSL 1991 Workshop and Symposium, Albuquerque. , Recom-