Sophie Pennetisr
Mark Bowers
Suilaume Eoin
Arup
BIG Architects
Keywords
1 = Ultra-thin glaze, 2 Cold bent glass
3 Sculpture
Abstract
Utra-hingass is nether a new proguet
not new othe building envranment. tis yt
very tle utilized in translucent facades for
silfess, detailing and cost reasons. This
taper describes the elaboration ofa cold bent
Llira-thin glaze sculpture, frm concept to
procurement, sith explorations worth he aye
ofthe facade designers, The design tools, FE
analysis and testing procedure and fabrication
ofthe glass elements are documented
‘Introduction
Inthe building environment, transportation,
household ar artsticapplicatins, glass is
general formed by lumping process, at
Geformation ofthe glass, which means that
‘the glass shaped without the use of heat
tony by application ofa sustained lading
This engages the glass structural not only
25 rigid bady transferring oad like in the
audacious Serves dela Vilete by Pater Rice
land RER but where the glass comaounds are
“subject to permanent internal bending forces
Like in ather project RFR projects, such asthe
Avignon and Strasbourg railay stations.
The present work, ofa much smaller scale.
Shaping ultra-thin glass
«sculpture made of cla bent 200m glass
strips, where the stanly andthe git of
the systomis ensu
forces ofthe glass, lacked into the strips
connected to one anathe: The seulpture
sessures 750mm by 750mm on lan and
7OOmm in height. This project demonstrates
how a iterative analysis of the geometry and
the internal orcs can result into ng ree
form system, a process thats scalable ta the
built environment
‘The use of thn glass in the ult environment
has many advantages. Asif and thin glass
facade system allows for the redution of the
lass weight supperted by the superstrctur,
Impacting ranspottation casts and energy
Jemands as resul. The dural of glass
‘or eorresve envionment and
ina chemi
ta Vien accel, ie ser
hermetic, compared to cther thin materials
suchas pljcarsonate or ETFE, and ultimately
‘the optical clarity af the glass s unequaled
Until ow thin glass products such as
ing Goria nd Willow glass are used in
the bulding environment within a laminate
compound many for interiarlatapplications
suchas wall cladding [Caring Inc, 2016)
This atcle presents the fundamentals of glass
cold bending, the properties ofthe thin glase
product use forthe project, the elaboration ot
the geometry the structural analysis and t
fabrieaton,
resistant ana
2Cold bent glass
Cold bending 2 glass element consi
deforming telactialy without the use
of heat Maintaining the pending force i=
required to keep the curvature ofthe glass
‘element. The geometry resulting fom the
clastic deformation of lat elements i ealed-a
developable surtace. Ths requires na distertion
othe orignal at alemant, ae siecussed in
further aetai in chapter 4
Cold bensing is particulary interesting in the
built environment for the eeason that does
not requie any heating process. The bending
process can secur in actory ar ons, a
Virlually at any ambient temperature
Te facades of sevaral architectural projact
comport old bent glass panels, such as the
-hvignon tain station in France a the [AC
Headquarters in New Yor respectvly Figure
1 and Figure 21 For these two projects, glass
sheets were assembled in insulated Glass
Units ICU] and the limiting component wasn't
the glas tel but the shear ofthe primary
seal othe (GU. This liilaion led lo larger
curvature adi than the one the glass sheets
lone could sustain, Hare the geometry al
to keep exch strip in place and the structure
stable only because o tothe connection to the
adjacent lass pieces
‘lass warm bending ~ also called two step
bending, cols-laination bending, amination
bending - consists of ling up sheets of glass
and interlayers) bending the stack onto a
support jig and then laminating iin atoctve
When the intial Bending force is removes and
the laminate removed from the jg the shear
inthe intriayer prevents the acsermly fom
completly fattening. The use af he term
warm for this fabrication process derives rom
the fact thatthe lamination process reautes to
heat up the compound to ensure the adhesion
of the interlayer tothe glass. The lamination
temperature, which degends onthe interlayer
raters and pressure is aparoximately 80
to "40 de. which whichis wal below the
otening temperature of glass, which exceeds
600 degC. Given the relative softness of certain
interlayers, the glass laminate may pata
Figure 12.3 Cold bent glass architectural project precedent lef right): Strasbourg Railway station (2011, AREPrDuileul)
AC Headauarters (2007, Gehry archtecsl Strasbourg Railway station (2007, AREP»Dutileul!
a
GB, cep class performance Days 2017
-T6-spring back (Knippers, Fduth, Baden
Pennetier, 2014 time history study 0
warm ben laminates
The glass panels of he Stras
station have been curved u
Figure 3
arg train
9 this process
3.Ultrathin glass
hicknesses between 2 and 22 mm. Thing
refers to 210 mm thickness and ultrathin is
posed or smaller thicknesses, from of 25
d
Whereas mast ofthe archi
um to 2mm ex
al glass
facades s soda-lime glass praduced ona feat
tex have a ferent chemical composition
and ferent fabri
ion process
Goria glass is composed a
Figure 48.6
tis produced in thickness ranging rom
0.2100. 7mm bya proprietary fusion-draw
acess Boia is then chemically tempered
in potassium
ie, which provides a
surface compression sess preventing crack
rogagaion.
Willow glass, used fort
roti
neten,.s an alae boroalum
lass [Corning Inc, 2014). tis fabricated by
proprietary arliow process [Corning In,
2016) In thes process, the glass infusion
‘verfiow out of gutter on both sides down
and fuses at the bottom point of the gute
ee Figure
Unlike Gora glass, Willow glass ism
chemicaly tempered and present a breakage
ne of annealed glass,
iets
iter sitar
Willow gla ie produced in sheets up to
by 1200mm or spools of 1300%mm wide,
300 meer ong. The minimum bend
rads, deending on handing and suriace
weathering, i 80mm forthe 100 um nominal
Sickness and TBOmm (ar the 200 um naminak
thickness [Corning Inc, 2016)
ring the Benaing radi tothe bet
charts provi ing [Corning in
4 design value of 0 MPa was extrapoates
Fetained forthe design ofthe sculpture. nthe
built environment, atrial reduc
should be us
oncomitantiy with reduction
factors associated with lar example but not
Limited to] shape size, load
shattering in lang thin laces. Willow glace i=
nated ater the oh
‘uring the fabria
Dt the overtow usee
ee
BENDING STRESS (MPa)
SeaRTTTE UTEP STEEP i aA LiEGaE
NDING RADIUS (mim)
Figure 7- Bending stress of
7
GPD Glass Performance Days 2017 RR4 Geometry
‘The deformation of inextensble at sheets
results in a developable surface. tis specific
case of ruled surface, which does nat only
apply to inextensible materials. For example, 2
hyperbolic paraboloid isa ruled surface which
can be built rom the translation in space of
straight lines itcan be but wth extensible
‘nylon fabri but not rom paper.
Developable surfaces comprise of cylinders,
cones and tangent surfaces of spaces curves
(Cottman and all as shown in Figure 8. Conical
shapes are ordinarily described bya planar
Curve and apex point. Inthe context ofthis
sculpture, we used a variation of conical
shapes define by a space curve and apex point
for each ofthe elements constituent ofthe
‘geometry.
Figure ¥itstrates each step through the
‘generation ofthe geometry for this project. At
firs ase of helicodal curves were created
and tistorted smoothly to create desired quide
‘cures (Curve Set 1), The resulting curves
are free form and da not comply mith any
(geometrical rule, apart rom the fact that they
‘eed to not overlap
‘irs set of cones (Cone Set 1} was generated
from each curve to an apex point I placed
within the elicoidal set of curves (Curved Set
‘LA second set of cones (Cone Set 2) was
generated rom each curve to an apex pint
P2 located above PI so thal every adjacent
‘surface intersects eachother The Curve set
2s defined bythe intersection ofthe two
Sets of cones, Lastly the two cone sets were
trimmed bythe Cure Set 2 creating the final
<éevelopable surfaces used forthe sculpture,
‘parametric model allowed the ine tuning
‘ofthe oometyin order to control the local
‘agivs of curvature
Figure 8 Tis of developable surfaces
Figure 9~ Geometvie principles
5 Analysis
This project being a sculpture, it was at firstly
analyzed to sustain gravitational and bending
forces.
‘An trative process involving the round
trp between maximum bending stresses
‘assessment and the geometry adjustment was
performed ina 3D medeing soltware packages
[Rhino and Grasshopper. Since each stip
in pure bending, the principal curvature and
bending srese can be derived ram Eq 1 and
Eq, below,
M= EVR Eq.
‘5 Eu2R 1Eq2)
With €: Young's modulus of elasticity INmm®)
|: Mernent of inertia Irmmél
RR: Curature radius (mm)
ts Glass thickness mm)
Figure 10 shows a mapping ofthe principal
‘curvature along ane strip of glass.
When required, the construction points and
‘generative curves ofthe strips geometry were
adjusted in order to maintain a maximum
‘stress of 35 MPa, This value, which is smaller
than the allowable stress extrapolated in
chapter 3, was arbitrarily set forthe rst
iterative process, allowing additonal reserve
‘capacity forthe elects gravity loading and
potential buckling effects. Utimatey the FE
analysis proved that the effect of gravy was
negligible for this specific geometry scale and
‘lass thickness,
Figure 10 Principal curature mapping only
‘one strip show for clay]
‘Alter the parametric study has been
performed, the strips were flattened and
imported int finite element analysis
oftware [Sirand7l. For the analysis, 2
Young's modulus of elasticity of 75 GPa and a
Poisson's ratio of 0.225 were used. Each strip
was composed of approx. 200 plate elements
‘of max. 20m with. The thickness ofthe
‘material was 200 um. The model totaled 2560,
plate elements. Each stip was intial fat and
lid by inks othe nades ots final pesition
[see Figure 1A staged non-linear static
‘analysis was then used to deform gradually the
‘trips while the bending stress increase was
monitored
a
GB cep class Performance Days 2017
-78-Figure 11- Links used for imposing
displacement on mesh nodes
‘rom fat fbovel ben elon!
Figure 12 shows the analysis steps. The glass
strips are ported 2s lat geometry inthe FE
nalys's enuironment ang =nrink ins pl
‘them inta postion A the last etage, when
‘the glass strips are cold bent into position,
asjacentnades a the rags are coupled
‘ogether by sti spring Links andthe loag
redistrbtes between the glass elements
‘The maximum stresses under tending case
and ater assigning gravly tothe structure
ware below the maximum allowable stresses,
sath maximum at supports locations.
6 Models
For the fabrication, the 30 geometry was
‘attened and laid out on sheets, Two
sty models were bul rior to the inal
construction othe sculpture desk model
and 2 full-scale model Figure 13 shows the
fabrication steps of scaled model made
af OSmm thick PETS plastic strigs and
assembles by hand with tape, The tie plastic
Scaled model, an assembly 130 130m plan by
1a0rnm high assembly of 20mm large sti,
served as communication fo0l and a first 100"
othe fabrication sequence
‘The second fll scale madel was fabricated
vith Imm PETG fils. Iwas used ae 3
template forthe agjusment af the supports
nd jigs uses for the glaze sculpture. The
‘ul seal fabrication sequence was validated
vith this medel, The connection detaing and
assembly are not siscussed herein,
7 Glass cutting process
‘The glass elements were provided ang CNC
‘by Coresx nc, based in Virginia [USA
‘The friction pictures show in order:
Lnraling he Wilow glass spoo, the GNC
cutting operation strips cus for testing and