Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ordinary, peaceful people ask why criminals If cages kill the parts of men that eyes can’t
in cages can’t work out their problems; why can’t see, what do they leave behind?5
they make themselves better in that time they
spend “away” from society? Why do they have
to grab and fight and kill over every little thing?
An old friend of mine, Jim Compton,
phrased this question differently:
”Why do dogs fight?”
He was asking for a particular answer:
“Because they can’t talk.”
Compton, like those ordinary peaceful
people, thought that because men can talk, they
will. Or should.
1
If criminals belong in cages, why do we put dogs in cages? (Trick question.)
2
Mortality statistics are unavailable for American prisons prior to the year 2000. But 1970 was the real line of demarcation. American
prisons received substantial reform beginning in the 1970s—but this led to a prison population explosion.
(Too many survivors.)
3
It is, in fact, a fine thing to tell someone they mustn’t steal when you have quite enough for yourself, your family, and any thought of
your future needs. Morality costs more when your pockets are empty. Having nothing is an agony even for the best of men; what is it to a
man that’s far from the best? Even Job prayed for death when he was reduced to nothing (6:8-9).
4
A man who has nothing wants for everything.
A man who has everything still wants something.
What men share in common is wanting.
5
I have my suspicions. HG Wells called them morlocks. When men are kept in conditions considered unfit for the normal members of
their society, what are they to become? Presumably, normal members of the society created by the conditions.