Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GEOTECHNICAL INSTRUMENTATION
WORKSHOP
Company
LOGO
Menara PJD, JKR Headquarters, 26-27 October 2010
Course Outline
2 Site Monitoring
1
10/22/2010
Geotechnical Engineer
2
10/22/2010
Risk Assessment
Risk Evaluation
with Cost-
Benefit Analysis
Risk Mitigation
(Pro-active)
Risk Reduction
(Defensive)
Risk Avoidance
3
10/22/2010
Numerical Analysis
Geotechnical Engineering Risk Management
observation method
boundary element risk assessment
finite difference instrumentation
Surface Geo-structures Ground Improvement
discrete element
e.g. embankments, landfills e.g. densification, Mechanical Engineering
finite element
remediation drilling
instrument
Geochemistry
excavation
waste
Materials Ground Construction
leachates
Site Exploration Movements practice
durability types
reconnaissance earthquake experience
properties
drilling liquefaction
geosynthetics
in-situ testing sinkhole
laboratory testing
geophysics 7
Genesis/Geology
Geotechnical
Triangle
Morgenstern (2000)
Precedent,
Empiricism,
Experience,
Risk-management
Ground Appropriate
Behaviour Model
4
10/22/2010
Engineering Judgement
Engineering Judgement
Past Theoretical
Experience Concepts
Experience
Knowledge
Judgement
Experimental
Observations Methods
Experience Judgement
Knowledge
Directly or Knowledge of all
Familiarity gained
indirectly from kinds & from many
from Experience
others different sources
5
10/22/2010
Work Scope of
Geotechnical Engineer
Natural geologic materials of inherently
variable nature do not necessarily follow well-
Scope defined natural laws, hence rendering
prediction in high uncertainty.
Soil-Structure
Interactions
Earthworks
Time
Foundations Dependent
Behaviours
Groundwater
Related
Problems
11
Work Scope of
Geotechnical Engineer
Natural
Terrain
Instability
Basement
Excavation Tunnel PVD Ground Dredging
Underground Treatment Reclamation Stability &
Space & with Erosion
Foundation Preloading Protection
6
10/22/2010
Why Instrumentation?
Observation
with
Measurements
Theoretical
Development
7
10/22/2010
Benefits of Instrumentation
Design Verification
& Optimisation
Construction &
Operational Safety
If you can not get high quality and reliable data, then better
don’t initiate any instrumentation scheme because it will
create more problems than being advantageous.
Pitfalls of Instrumentation
Design Rectification
Realistic Construction
Cost & Time
8
10/22/2010
Forensic Investigation
Stakeholders
Project Objectives
9
10/22/2010
Responsibility
Instrument
Installation Data
Collection
Responsibility
• Acceptance tests
• Instrument installation
Instrumentation
• Establish baseline reading Specialist
Field • Maintaining & calibrating instruments regularly
Instrumentation
Service • Data collection, processing & presentation
10
10/22/2010
Parameters to be Monitored
Types of Measurement
Planning Cycle
Define
Project
Conditions Controlling
Mechanisms
Response
Actions
Questions
to be answered
Measurement
.vs. Purpose &
Prediction Parameters
to be measured
11
10/22/2010
Project Conditions
Questions to be answered
12
10/22/2010
Causes
Effects
Controlling Mechanisms
13
10/22/2010
Measurement .vs.
Prediction
Analysis
Prediction
Measurement
Don’t forget to
apply Engineering
Judgement
Hazard Warning Level
Red
Amber
Green Timely
Cautionary
No action Contingency
Measures
Action
Response Actions
14
10/22/2010
Dilemma of
Instrumentation
Specification
15
10/22/2010
Contractual Arrangement
Main Contractor
Consultant Consultant (PMC) Main Contractor (PM)
(PMC) Main Contractor
Site Supervision
Consultant Subcontractor
Site Supervision Instrumentation Team
Site Supervision Team Specialist
FirmSubcontractor
Team Subcontractor
Instrumentation Construction
Specialist Firm Works
Construction
Instrumentation Construction Works
Specialist Firm Works
Procurement Approach
Professional Service
Lowest Bid Tender
Independence
16
10/22/2010
Good Practices
Partnership to Instrument
Manufacturers/Suppliers
Good Practices
17
10/22/2010
Course Outline
2 Site Monitoring
Data Processing / Analysis,
3 Interpretation & Actions
Measurement
Uncertainty & Reliability
Accuracy Precision
Conformance
Sensitivity Resolution
Linearity Hysteresis
Error Noise
18
10/22/2010
Conformance
19
10/22/2010
Measurement Deviation
20
10/22/2010
Course Outline
2 Site Monitoring
21
10/22/2010
Parameters to be
Measured
Deformation/Movement
Inclinometer
Extensometer
Ground Movement Marker
Tiltmeter
Crackmeter
Water/Earth Pressure
Piezometer, Observation Well
Earth Pressure Cell
Parameters &
Measurement
Load/Stress/Strain
Strain Gauges
Load Cell
Thermal
Thermal Coupler
Flow
V-Notch Gauge
Vibration
Accelerometer
22
10/22/2010
Inclinometer
Reading :
Inclinometer +(θ+δ
+(θ+δ)
{+(θ+δ) − [−(θ−
(θ−δ)]}/2 = θ
Checksum Review : d1 + d2 + d3
+(θ+δ
+(θ+δ)
{+(θ+δ) + [−
[−(θ−
(θ−δ)]}/2 = δ
×Sinθ
L× θ A+ A- θ3
d1 + d2
−θ
L −δ
θ θ2
A- Reading : −(θ−
(θ−δ)
d1
A- A+
+θ θ1
+δ A+ Reading : +(θ+δ
+(θ+δ)
θ+δ)
Inclinometer
Unpredictable & Uncorrectable
Total
Sensor Bias
Predictable & Correctable
Sensor
Error
Shift, Positioning, Systematic
Sensitivity Systematic
Casing Errors
Drift & inclination & Error
Rotation Curvature
Total Error = ε
Random × √(No. of Readings) + ε Systematic × (No. of Readings)
23
10/22/2010
Inclinometer
Reading, y k = Sensitivity Drift (Drift in Pre-amplifier)
y = k Sin x + b
Depth Rotation
Curvature in Casing, Positioning Error Misalignment of Sensor
Vertical Probe Placing,
Cable Stretching, Rotation
Ground Settlement Error Angle
α
B0 A0
Inclinometer
No Correction With Zero Shift Correction
Change Deflection Change Deflection
Error
Error
24
10/22/2010
Inclinometer
Spiral Probe
Twisted casings lead to incorrect magnitude of
movement in the A and B directions.
Application :
To check orientation of the inclinometer
grooves for necessary correction for
direction of resultant movement.
Readings show movements in unlikely
direction α α
B
A α
R =d/Cosα
Check installation quality
If α = 10°°,
Deep casing installation R =A/Cos α =1.015A
Inclinometer
25
10/22/2010
Inclinometer
Inclinometer
Inclinometer (Vertical)
26
10/22/2010
Inclinometer
Horizontal Profiler
0 0
-250
Water Load
-2
452T-19/06/2001 -200
-20
-4
1530T-20/06/2001
-6 1630T-21/06/2001 -150
G5 (36m) (36m)
-10 -60 at Water Load of 2521Ton (36m)
2007T-24/06/2001
Hogging
-50
-12 2087T-25/06/2001 Predicted Raft Deflection Profile G2
(24m)
G3
(30m)
G6
(36m)
G9
(36m)
-80 0
2295T-26/06/2001
Sagging
-14
at Water Load of 2500Ton
-16
2521T-27/06/2001 50
-100
2721T-28/06/2001 G1 G4
-18 100
2910T-29/06/2001 (24m) (30m)
G10 G13
-120
-20 2960T-29/06/2001 (30m) (24m)
150 G12
G11
-22 2947T-30/06/2001 (30m) (24m)
-140
-24
2922T-01/07/2001 200
1517T-02/07/2001
-26 -160 250
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Distance From Starting End of Inclinometer (m) Distance From Staring End of Inclinometer (m) Distance From Staring End of Inclinometer (m)
Inclinometer
Horizontal Profiler
27
10/22/2010
Data Evaluation
Deflection Deflection
Data Presentation
Good Practice :
Use of exaggerated horizontal scale shall
be avoided because “errors” are magnified
& could be misinterpreted.
Change plot (incremental deformation) is
useful to emphasize the location of
deformation zone.
28
10/22/2010
Case Studies
Course Outline
2 Site Monitoring
29
10/22/2010
Myths in Instrumentation
Myths in Instrumentation
30
10/22/2010
Common Problems
Common Problems
31
10/22/2010
Common Problems
Advices
Paradox :
• Appearance of apparently unmotivated
change are often the first sign of distress
• Observations of overall phenomenon
become more relevant than “spot”
occurrence.
32
10/22/2010
Applications
Basement
Excavation Tunnel PVD Ground Dredging
Underground Treatment Reclamation Stability &
Space & with Erosion
Foundation Preloading Protection
33
10/22/2010
Concrete Dam
34
10/22/2010
35
10/22/2010
Case Studies
References
Sources :
Dunnicliff, J. (1988), ”Geotechnical Instrumentation for Monitoring Field Performance”. Wiley-Interscience Publication.
Geotechical Intrumentation News (http://www.bitech.ca/news.htm)
Liew, S.S. (2010), "Lessons Learned from Case Histories", JKR Sabah One-Day Short Course on Slope Engineering, Promenade Hotel,
Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, 30 June 2010
Liew,S.S. (2010), “Dam Safety Monitoring and Surveillance in Malaysia”, Conference on ASIAWATER 2010, jointly organized by The
Malaysian Water Association (MWA), 6th – 8th April 2010
Liew, S.S.; Lim, Wei & Lau, L.S. (2010), “Investigation of Soil Nailed Slope Distress at Fill Ground & Remedial Solutions”, The
17th Southeast Asian Geotechnical Conference, Taipei, Taiwan, 10 to 13 May 2010 Liew, S.S.; Lee, S.T. & Koo, K.S. (2010),
“Failure Investigation of Piled Reinforcement Soil Wall & Excessive Movements of Piled Embankment at Soft Ground,
Malaysia”, The 17th Southeast Asian Geotechnical Conference, Taipei, Taiwan, 10 to 13 May 2010
Liew, S.S.; Ting, D.I. & Low, Y.H. (2010), “Piling Foundation Design & Construction Problems of Tank Farm in Reclaimed
Land over Untreated Soft Marine Clay in Malaysia”, The 17th Southeast Asian Geotechnical Conference, Taipei, Taiwan, 10
to 13 May 2010
Liew, S.S. (2009), “Role of Geotechnical Engineer in Civil Engineering Works in Malaysia”, CIE-IEM Joint Seminar on
Geotechnical Engineering, Yilan, Taiwan, 26 to 27 August 2009
Liew, S.S. & Khoo C.M. (2008), "Lessons Learned from Two Investigation Cases of Ground Distresses Due to Deep
Excavation in Filled Ground", 6th Int'l Conf. on Case Histories in Geotechnical Engineering, 11-16 Aug 2008 , Arlington,
Virginia, United States.
Liew, SS (2008), "Case Studies of Support of Open Excavations and Distressed Retaining Walls in Malaysia" Seminar on
"Deep Excavation and Retaining Walls", Jointly organised by IEM-HKIE at Tropicana Golf & Country Resort, Petaling Jaya,
Malaysia, 24 March 2008.
Liew S.S. & Khoo C.M. (2007),"Performance of Soil Nail Stabilisation Works for a 14.5m Deep Excavation at Uncontrolled Fill
Ground", Proc. 16th Southeast Asian Geotechnical Conferences, Malaysia.
Liew S. S. & Tan S. K. (2007), "Performance of Reinforced Soil Wall Supported on Stone Columns", Proc. 16th Southeast
Asian Geotechnical Conferences, Malaysia.
Liew S.S. & Khoo C. M. (2006),"Design and Construction of Soil Nail Strengthening Work over Uncontrolled Fill for a 14.5m
Deep Excavation", 10th International Conference on Piling and Deep Foundations, 31 May - 2 Jun 2006, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands
Liew S.S. & Liong C.H. (2006),"Two Case Studies on Soil Nailed Slope Failures", Internationals Conference on slope, 7 - 8
August 2006, Kuala Lumpur
36
10/22/2010
References
Sources :
Liew, S. S., Liong, C. H. & Low, C. L., (2004), “Four Landslide Investigations in Malaysia”, 15th SEAGC, Bangkok, 22 - 26
November 2004.
Liew, S. S. & Choo, E. L., (2004), “Bending Moment Interpretation of Structural Element with Measured Deflection Profile”,
Malaysian Geotechnical Conference, 16-18 March, 2004, Sheraton Subang, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia.
Liew, S. S., Kowng, Y. W. & Gan, S. J., (2004), “Interpretations of Instrumented Bored Piles in Kenny Hill Formation”,
Malaysian Geotechnical Conference, 16-18 March, 2004, Sheraton Subang, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia.
Liew, S. S., Gue, S. S. & Liong, C. H., (2003), “Geotechnical Investigation and Monitoring Results of a Landslide Failure at
Southern Peninsula Malaysia (Part 1: Investigating Causes of Failure)”, International Conference on Slope Engineering, Hong
Kong, 8-10 Dec 2003.
Liew, S. S., Gue, S. S. & Liong, C. H., (2003), “Geotechnical Investigation and Monitoring Results of a Landslide Failure at
Southern Peninsula Malaysia (Part 2: Back Analyses of Shear Strength and Remedial Works)”, International Conference on
Slope Engineering, Hong Kong, 8-10 Dec 2003.
Liew, S. S. , Tan, Y. C., Ng, H. B. & Lee, P.T., (2003), “New Approach of using Jacked Anchors as Reinforcements in Soil
Stabilisation Works for a Cut-And-Cover Tunnel with 17m Deep Excavation”, International Conference on Foundation,
Dundee, Scotland, 2-5 Sep 2003.
Liew, S. S., Gue, S. S. & Tan, Y. C. (2002), "Design and Instrumentation Results of A Reinforcement Concrete Piled Raft
Supporting 2500 Ton Oil Storage Tank on Very Soft Alluvium Deposits", Ninth International Conference on Piling and Deep
Foundations, Nice, 3 - 5 June, 2002
Liew, S. S. (2002), "Pile Design with Negative Skin Friction" Course Lecture for Geotechnical Engineering at Puteri Pan
Pacific Hotel, Johor Bahru
Liew, S. S. & Gue, S. S. (2001), “Massive Creep Movements of Post-Glacial Deposits in Kundasang Areas”, GSM-IEM Forum
: Engineering Geology & Geotechnics of Slopes, Kuala Lumpur
Liew, S.S.; Gue, S. S., & Tan, Y. C. (1999), “Instrumentation Results on Negative Downdrag Force of Abutment Piles
Underneath the Reinforced Earth Wall Embankment”, 5th Int.. Symp. on Field Measurements in Geomechanics., Singapore.
Machan, G. & Bennet, V. G. (2008), “Use of Inclinometers for Geotechnical Instrumentation on Tranportation Projects – State
of the Practice”, Transportation Research Board
Mikkelsen, P. K. (2003), “Advances in Inclinometer Data Analysis”, Symposium on Field Measurements in Geotechnics
(FMGM) 2003, Oslo, Norway
Thank you
Lord Kelvin (1827 - 1907) :
When you can measure what you are speaking
about, and express it in numbers, you know
something about it; but when you cannot
measure it, when you cannot express it in
numbers, your knowledge is of a meagre and
unsatisfactory kind; it may be the beginning of
knowledge, but you have scarcely in your
thoughts advanced to the state of Science,
whatever the matter may be.
37