Surrogacy Bill - Legal Loopholes, Homophobia & Commercialising Women

4/30/2019 Surrogacy Bill: Legal Loopholes, Homophobia & Commercialising Women
Featured (/) Latest (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie
8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs

To Answer
Alolika A. Dutta (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/alolika_a_dutta/) in #SansadUnplugged
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/category/campaigns/sansadunplugged/)
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/alolika_a_dutta/) 3 months ago
Editor’s Note: This post is a part of #SansadUnplugged (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/sansadunplugged), a campaign by Young

Leaders for Active Citizenship India (https://ylacindia.com/) and Youth Ki Awaaz where your elected representatives engage directly with
you on key policy issues that matter. Find out more and engage with those you vote for here
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/sansadunplugged).
On December 19, 2018 (https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/surrogacy-regulation-bill-passed-in-lok-sabha-10-points-1965215), the Lok Sabha

passed the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016. The Bill was cleared by the Cabinet, and subsequently referred
(https://www.news18.com/news/india/parliamentary-panel-invites-suggestions-on-surrogacy-regulation-bill-1370555.html) to a
Parliamentary Standing Committee (Health & Family Welfare) before its passage.
What Is Surrogacy?
Surrogacy is an arrangement, often legally backed up, where a couple commissions a woman (called a surrogate) to carry their child until
birth.
Is Surrogacy Inherently ‘Bad’?

No, of course not. It is permitted (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-28679020) in certain countries such as Russia and Ukraine. However,
surrogacy is banned in certain countries such as Canada and France. Conventionally, the practice of surrogacy has been looked down upon.
However, it has a number of advantages for all those who are involved, from the intended parents to the surrogate mother.
In case of traditional surrogacy, the surrogate mother is surgically inseminated with the father’s sperm, thereby making the surrogate mother
the child’s biological mother. However, with gestational surrogacy (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14640380), one or both parents
can be biologically associated with the child.
Unlike popular belief, the intended parents can experience different stages of pregnancy, from the embryo transfer to the baby’s birth. They
can interact with the surrogate mother and develop a bond with her. Surrogacy does not place the intended parents at an emotional
disadvantage.
 
(https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/facebook/offer?(https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/twitter/offer? (https://api.addt
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- 
url=https://
regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be- regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be- regulation
asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions asking/&pubi
About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs To About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs To About The S
Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp- Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp- Answer&pictu
content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy- content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy- content
450x300.jpg&pco=tbxnj-1.0) 450x300.jpg&pco=tbxnj-1.0)
https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy-regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/ 1/12
Actor Lisa Kudrow played Phoebe Buffay, a character in “F.R.I.E.N.D.S”, who became a surrogate mother during the course of the show, bringing the
issue into public view.
Surrogacy is a better alternative to adoption because it is subject to lesser restrictions than adoption. Often, the intended parents cannot access
adoption due to several agency restrictions on factors like age.
Surrogacy also has a higher rate of success as compared to fertility treatments for intended parents because surrogate mothers have already
carried other pregnancies and have a physiologically prepared uterus.
The process may be beneficial for mothers who have formerly suffered from trauma or miscarriages. There is another benefit as well.
Pregnancy often leads to Postpartum Depression (PPD), a form of clinical depression that occurs after childbirth, which can be avoided
through surrogacy. Especially in case of mothers who have had a child before and suffered from PPD, another pregnancy can be terrifying
because there is a 30% chance that you will have it again. This can certainly reduce the joy of parenthood.
Moreover, the surrogate mother is not at a disadvantage either because, in cases such as gestational surrogacy, she is less likely to develop a
bond with the baby for there to be any emotional ramifications. Added to that, a surrogate mother has probably experienced pregnancy before
and is, therefore, more mentally prepared to bear a child.
What Does The Surrogacy Bill Entail?

The Bill attempts to regulate the process of surrogacy in India, thereby prohibiting commercial surrogacy (commercial surrogacy refers to any
surrogacy arrangement in which the surrogate mother is compensated for her services beyond reimbursement of medical expenses and
provided a minimal insurance coverage). It allows and supports altruistic surrogacy (where a surrogate mother agrees to gestate a child for the
intended parents without being
 compensated monetarily in any way—in effect, free surrogacy) to
Indian married couples who cannot bear
children.
The Bill mandates that the surrogate mother and the intended couple
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- must be close relatives.
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- 
url=https://
As NDTV reports (https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/surrogacy-regulation-bill-passed-in-lok-sabha-10-points-1965215), the surrogate
mother and the intended couple need eligibility certificates from the appropriate authority.
Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-
The Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-
Bill allows only Indian citizens to avail surrogacy. Foreigners, non-resident Answer&pictu
Indians, and persons of Indian origin are banned from seeking
content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy-
surrogate mothers in the country. content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy- content
Gay, lesbian, and trans people, single parents, and live-in couples, are also not allowed to have children via surrogacy in India.
Couples that already have children will not be allowed to opt for surrogacy, though they would be free to adopt children under a separate law.
Also read: Karan Johar Has Twins Via Surrogacy, Twitter Responds With Homophobia (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2017/03/karan-
johar-twins-via-surrogacy-homophobia/)
Now, the discourse about commercial surrogacy has long been controversial and ethically problematic. Feminists, bioethicists, and a number
of medical professionals have argued that it is immoral to capitalise on women’s reproductive capacities. They believe that monetising
pregnancy will commodify babies leading to the dehumanisation and devaluation of women and children, and also act against social values.
Anupriya Patel, Union Minister of State for Health and Family Welfare. Image source: Wikimedia Commons.
Back in 2016, Anupriya Patel, Union Minister of State for Health and Family Welfare, told (https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/umbilical-
discourse-55751) Down To Earth, “People often say that surrogacy is a woman’s conscious choice. Our stand is that it is a very wrong notion
of the family to use the woman’s body to make money. Is she a child-producing factory? In many cases, we have found that family members
coerce women into taking up surrogacy.”
This explanation applies to altruistic surrogacy as well, even more so because in case of altruistic surrogacy, the woman is not even
compensated. Added to that, a majority of women decide to take up surrogacy willfully, for the remuneration.
Down To Earth recorded (https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/umbilical-discourse-55751) the story of a 28-year-old surrogate mother

from Anand district, Gujarat:
“With the help of surrogacy, I earned Rs 600,000 in April, 2015, and bought a house for my family. Earlier, we were living in rented room.
My husband is an auto-rickshaw driver, and I have two daughters. We want to educate our daughters and help them live a dignified life.
 
And to achieve this, I may need to go for surrogacy again. My husband’s earning is not even sufficient for food and clothing. Except
(https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/facebook/offer?
surrogacy, I don’t think I have any other option. (https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/twitter/offer? (https://api.addt
url=https://
I know many families who, if they don’t opt for surrogacy, will have to go to sleep hungry. In many families, the male members are not able
to get job; some are drunkards. I also know families, where members are sick, and the women have to come forward and opt for surrogacy
to treat them.”
This Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-
is the story of a lot of women across India, and such real stories Answer&pictu
are exactly why we should be questioning the legitimacy of this bill.
Here are a few questions that we should be asking.
1:Featured
Will A (/) Ban
LatestOn Commercial Surrogacy Really End The ‘Trade’?
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie
Instead, infertility clinics find legal loopholes or move surrogate mothers across borders. These activities expose surrogate mothers to great
risks. Commercial surrogacy cannot be eradicated by placing a domestic ban on it. An article that appeared in The Conversation
(https://theconversation.com/india-outlawed-commercial-surrogacy-clinics-are-finding-loopholes-81784) noted that:
“[W]hen India first banned surrogacy for gay couples in 2012, various infertility businesses in Delhi continued to sign on gay clients from
all over the world […] To avoid the ban, infertility clinics moved surrogate mothers across international borders into Nepal […] This
emerging trade route between Delhi and Kathmandu halted when an earthquake hit Nepal on April 25, 2015, killing 8,000 people and
injuring more than 21,000. While various governments airlifted babies belonging to their citizens, the fate of the Indian surrogate mothers
and how they got back home remains unclear.”
This kind of illegal activity is nearly inevitable if commercial surrogacy is banned. It will place surrogate mothers in dangerous situations that
lie beyond the scope of law enforcement and beyond the knowledge of the Government. Thus, it is very difficult to ban commercial surrogacy
the way this verdict attempts to. All it does, is ban legal commercial surrogacy.
A notice board with letters and photographs sent by various parents to the clinic as thanks at the IVF clinic at Greater Kailash. Photo by Ramesh
Pathania/Mint via Getty Images.
Then, there is also the case of IVF and recruitment of surrogate mothers from other countries who were then implanted with the embryo in
Mumbai by an infertility specialist, and then flown back to their own country. This is a loophole because in this manner, the ‘practice’ of
surrogacy goes on, in the absence of Indian surrogate mothers and Indian intended parents.
 
With a ban on commercial surrogacy, India could end up in a condition similar to that of Cambodia. In Cambodia, revealed The Conversation
(https://theconversation.com/india-outlawed-commercial-surrogacy-clinics-are-finding-loopholes-81784), “surrogate mothers from Phnom 
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- url=https://
Penh are being sent to Bangkok, Thailand to deliver babies. Thai law bans commercial surrogacy transactions, but enforcement agencies
are unable to distinguish surrogate mothers in hospitals from other pregnant women. Cambodian surrogate mothers are also being sent to
Laos, where there are no laws, to deliver babies in clinics staffed by Thai doctors who once worked in Thailand when commercial surrogacy
was still legal there.”
Evidently, all that a ban accomplishes is uproot the trade from one country and plant it in another. Also, illegal surrogacy has already grown to
become a $2 billion industry, banning it will push it further underground and only contribute to the illegality of it all. It will create an
international problem thereby widening the scope of commercial surrogacy and only benefiting the process. The problem with this is, it
aggravates the presence of commercial surrogacy by not just taking it outdoors (out of the concerned country), but also by placing the lives of
the surrogate mothers on slippery ground. It therefore, becomes an illegal trade which is difficult to monitor for the domestic government and
evidently, does not contribute positively to the country’s global image. Furthermore, this makes surrogate mothers very vulnerable because of
their helplessness. The surrogacy agencies provide housing and health facilities, and regulate their income. The lives of women become
uncertain and powerless because they cannot terminate their contract upon their will. They are dependent on the agency. Additionally,
because it is an illegal trade, they cannot seek legal remedy for any kind of abuse, financial issues, or medical malpractices, and in a new
country, they are not in a position to object to the procedures adopted by the surrogacy agency.
2: If A Ban Is Not The Answer, Then What Is?

The alternative is heavy regulation of commercial surrogacy, quite contrasting to the consequences of the ban. Supporting surrogacy with
proper screening, adequate documentation, and strict selection of cases in a supervised environment would have been more considerate, in
comparison to a ban which is a very extreme step.
Further, an actionable solution would be proper legislation to regulate surrogacy, which the government has stated in the Surrogacy Bill that
provides for the formation of a National Surrogacy Board, State Surrogacy Boards, and appointment of appropriate authorities for the
regulation of the practice of surrogacy. Surrogacy clinics should be licensed, authorised, and audited. However, adopting these measures and
banning commercial surrogacy are two steps in opposite directions. In order to judiciously utilise these provisions and facilities, we should be
permitting commercial surrogacy.
Even the arguments that oppose surrogacy from the sociological perspective can be easily debunked with a simple change in the social
perception of surrogate mothers, which is not being brought about by replacing commercial surrogacy with altruistic surrogacy. Surrogate
mothers should be treated as complete human beings who have the right to know who the intended parents are, the right to choose how they
get pregnant, the right to determine which contracts they sign, the right to refuse cesarean surgeries, and the right to maintain contact with the
babies they birthed. As long as the bodily autonomy, integrity, and dignity of surrogate mothers is respected, commercial surrogacy should
remain a permissible act. This, can again be achieved with an appropriate degree of government intervention and formulation of
comprehensive contracts.
A prohibition of commercial surrogacy is a glaringly regressive move considering that India has had some very progressive legal reforms in the
previous year.
Hence, the answer is definitely not prohibition. The answer is regulation. But, of course, a ban is an easier way out because stricter regulation
demands better legislative machinery and infrastructure. Ban culture, as a whole, is a convenient escape from accountability, on part of the
government. A ban on surrogacy shifts responsibility and repercussion, from the government to the people.
3: Why Is It Necessary For The Surrogate Mother To Be A Close Relative Of The

Intended Parents?
Surrogacy requires carrying a baby for nine months and not many close relatives will be willing to go that length. The proposition of only
allowing close relatives to be surrogate mothers is myopic to say the least, since altruistic surrogacy will only restrict the scope and benefits of
surrogacy.
 
4: Is Altruistic Surrogacy Any Better?
The idea that commercial surrogacy is exploitative is a myth, because
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- it views surrogacy from the lens of medical exploitation only. It isurl=https://
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- crucial

to note that commercial surrogacy is simultaneously, a source of income
regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be- for many unemployed women.
regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be- regulation
asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8
And, Questions
altruistic surrogacy is another form of exploitation in itself. Itasking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8
will lead to emotional abuse of female relatives by Questions asking/&pubi
making surrogacy, a
About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs To About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs To About
social obligation. It will just transport reproductive labor from the markets to the households by making women’s reproductive capacities into The S
aAnswer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp- Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-
free resource available for unquestionable consumption within families. Furthermore, since it is supposed to be altruistic in nature,Answer&pictu
the
relatives cannot demand any compensation for the physiological risks of gestation that are a part of pregnancy, not to forget the emotional
implications as well. This is just another form of labor, that is both emotionally and socially detrimental.
Nayana Patil, Medical Director at Akanksha Infertility and IVF Clinic in Kaival Hospital, Anand, Gujarat. Image source: YouTube.
Quoting Nayana Patil (https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/umbilical-discourse-55751), Medical Director at Akanksha Infertility and IVF
Clinic in Kaival Hospital, Anand, Gujarat, “Any force on a close relative either emotional or otherwise can amount to forced labour violating
Article 23 of the Constitution.” Nayana goes on to question the legitimacy of only providing medical compensation to surrogate mothers, she
objects to the feminist decisions of the court and states that restricting surrogacy to only married couples within the hetero-normative,
patriarchal structure of conventional, Indian society is an act of inequality. She states that this bill infringes upon the right to reproductive
autonomy and interferes with the personal decisions of the intending parents. Patel also said that “[t]he compensation a surrogate gets only
empowers her family. The government should not rely on feminist views to articulate its position. Article 14 of the Constitution guarantees
‘equality before the law and equal protection of laws to all persons’. Article 21 guarantees ‘protection of life and personal liberty of all
persons’. Restricting conditional surrogacy to married Indian couples and disqualifying others on the basis of nationality, marital status,
sexual orientation or age, does not appear to pass the test of equality and there is no connection with the intended objectives of the proposed
legislation.”
Last, instead of viewing commercial surrogacy as a means of exploitation, why not look at it as a source of income, as a profession, as providing
compensation for services delivered? Surrogacy is too high a price to pay for altruism.
Additionally, the debate against commercial surrogacy is similar to the debate against sex work. The body is not being ‘sold’, it is being
appropriately utilised in order to earn a livelihood. It is very easy to defame a profession with populist remarks, it is very easy to ban a whole
industry and not provide any subsequent compensation to the stakeholders. The Government should provide monetary reparations to the
women whose families are now at stake due to a lack of stable income and make immediate provisions for a minimum wage allowance
(unemployment allowance) or create compensatory jobs. The Government is liable to provide financial compensation. The surrogacy bill has
only made surrogate mothers more vulnerable to exploitation because of their joblessness, such a blanket ban on surrogacy will only turn out
to be more distressing for women previously engaged in the practice.
Also read: The Other Side Of Surrogacy: Women Forced To Sell Their Wombs For Money (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2014/06/side-
surrogacy-women-forced-sell-wombs-money/)
5: Is The Bill Feminist In Nature?

Well, the bill is anything but feminist. Quoting (https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/umbilical-discourse-55751) Sarojini and Sneha
Banerjee from Sama Resource Group for Women and Health, New Delhi, “The regulatory rationale seems to be centered on two axes—the
notion of an ‘ideal”’family and‘commerce’ in reproduction.” 
The Surrogacy Bill places women in a position of mandatory altruism which is a form of exploitation, regardless of who enforces it and
url=https://
whether it occurs with a household or outside one; exploitation and forced labor are not relative and subjective concepts, and altruism may not
always be voluntary. Close relatives who are women are subject to being forced into surrogacy that is assumed to be altruistic and voluntary.
Do you see how this Bill will inevitably place women in an insecure position? Gender violence can occur and has occurred within families
before, and because it takes place within families, women feel emotionally abused and incapable of seeking redressal. After all, speaking up
against a relative is far more difficult than speaking up against a professional surrogacy agency.
Sneha adds, “It is interesting that the phenomenon of commercial surrogacy is found to be objectionable only because the woman acting as
the surrogate receives remuneration. Apart from this aspect, there is no difference between what is known as commercial and altruistic
surrogacy.” This Bill will only rob women of an income for rendering services that they’ve always rendered.
Also, by making surrogacy a moralistic argument, medical concerns have been sidelined. The post-natal requirements of surrogate mothers
have not been attended to. Sneha and Sarojini also added that “[t]he bill has also left out the commercial and profit-driven industry of the
Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ARTs), which is overwhelmingly found in the private healthcare sector. Infertility treatment using
ARTs and IVF has been available commercially in India for over three decades now. Yet there is no regulation that governs this sector.
Though guidelines were formulated by the Indian Council of Medical Research in 2005, they are not legally binding. While it is important to
debate surrogacy, at the same time, the ARTs industry, which drives it, must also be regulated.”
Hence, surrogacy is only a specialised part of the bigger industry of assisted reproduction; solely regulating commercial surrogacy will not
bring about any major changes in the industry.
 
url=https://
Illustration by Matri Dore. Source: Youth Ki Awaaz (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2015/11/ban-on-commercial-surrogacy-in-india/).
6:About
WillTheA Ban Bill
Surrogacy OnThat
Commercial Surrogacy
Our Government Needs To Affect
About TheBill
The Surrogacy Economy?
That Our Government Needs To About The S
Yes, Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-
it will. Banning commercial surrogacy will send the booming medical tourism industry crashing to its doom. Answer&pictu
Many Indian fertility clinics and banks advertise online, providing a range of information for overseas clients from countries such as Britain,
the United States, and Australia. It is a lucrative, $400 million-a-year business with over 3,000 fertility clinics across India that recruit poor,
uneducated women to carry the embryos of others through to birth. The industry sees it as a win-win situation: childless couples see their
dream come true with a genetic child and the impoverished Indian surrogate mother gets a generous income. The surrogate mothers are the
primary beneficiaries in the surrogacy process, particularly from the financial perspective.
The surrogacy tourism industry not only supports individual women, but also the economy as a whole. About 80 percent of babies born
through surrogate mothers are taking place for foreigners, not Indians. Medical tourism companies have made significant profits from
commercial surrogacy by using sophisticated Internet-based strategies to market comprehensive services to prospective fertility patients.
Designed to bridge the distance between healthcare consumers in developed countries on the one hand and healthcare providers and
surrogates in developing and transitional-economy countries on the other, these services depend on low prices and lack of regulation in India
to keep costs and hassles to a minimum. Fertility tourists come to India in search of surrogates from a wide range of countries, including
Britain, France, the United States, Canada, Singapore, Japan, Australia, the Middle East, and Israel. The discrepancy between access to
treatment at home and access abroad is perhaps the most significant contributor to the growth of fertility tourism in general and commercial
surrogacy in particular. Hence, it is clear that the surrogacy industry has contributed significantly in sustaining the Indian economy. With a
large clientele overseas, Indian infertility clinics received significant revenue through commercial surrogacy. Evidently, commercial surrogacy
as a practice is not the problem, the problem is its repercussions which can be controlled with stringent regulations.
7: Why Does The Bill Place Restrictions On Single Parents And Live-In Couples?
According to the amendments approved by the cabinet, commercial surrogacy including sale and purchase of human embryo and gametes will
be prohibited while, the health ministry stated (http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=177806), “ethical surrogacy to the needy
infertile couples will be allowed on fulfillment of certain conditions and for specific purposes.” The amended Surrogacy Bill aims to benefit
“infertile married couples who want to avail ethical surrogacy” and protect the rights of surrogate mothers and children born out of
surrogacy.
There is an elementary problem with this- the necessity of marriage which again, indirectly restricts commercial surrogacy. Why is access to
surrogacy limited to married couples? When live-in couples are recognised under the law, why not permit them to form a family?
Necessitating marriage will also lead to psychological stress between couples who desire to have a child, and surrogate parenthood is premised
on the notion of providing the opportunity of parenthood to everyone incapable or unwilling to have a child naturally. The restriction on single
parents is unjustified too, because in many cases, single parents have successfully nurtured children.
Also, according to the Bill, surrogacy will only be permitted to couples, married for at least five years and who cannot conceive a child
naturally.
 
url=https://
8: Why Can’t Surrogacy Be An Openly Accessible Option? Why Is Infertility A

Necessary Prerequisite?
Neetu Sharma, in LiveMint (https://www.livemint.com/Politics/LNv4btZv8L53qiD6x1WqiJ/Surrogacylaw-may-limit-chances-of-
parenthood-for-many-coupl.html), observes: “Under the Bill, ‘infertility’ is a condition that has to be medically proven by a couple to be
eligible to commission a surrogacy. The Bill defines infertility as the inability to conceive after five years of unprotected sex or medical
conditions preventing a couple from conception. This definition does not cover all cases in which a couple is unable to bear a child, such as
weak uterus, multiple miscarriages, fibroids, hypertension and diabetes. Such medical conditions which are becoming very common with
changing lifestyles will not qualify a couple for altruistic surrogacy.”
Also, the Right to Life includes the right to reproductive autonomy, which includes the right to procreation and parenthood. It is not for the
State to decide the modes of parenthood. Constitutionally, the State cannot interfere in the prerogative of a person(s) to have children,
naturally or through surrogacy.
Also read: As An Indian IVF And Surrogate-Born Child, I Am More Than Just A ‘Made In India’ Product!
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2017/03/are-make-in-india-goods-and-services-protected-equally-2/)
Hence, these are a few questions

 that still remain unanswered. The surrogacy regulation bill is insensitive
 and inconsiderate, to say the least.
Surrogacy is a complex medical procedure with social, cultural, biological, and economic repercussions, and this bill does not do sufficient
justice to all the dimensions of surrogacy. A ban is not the answer, a ban is never the answer and it is essential to bring the ongoing ban culture
url=https://
to an end. It is necessary to question the legitimacy of the bill and critically understand its medical as well as societal relevance.
Tell us your thoughts and observations on this Bill. Your article will contribute to the way your elected representatives are
presenting bills, defining policies and creating change in the Parliament. Response article will be shared with respective Member of
Parliament, and in many cases - suggestions are included in the drafting of future policies.
Write a response
Featured (/)
(/me/)
Latest (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie
Like what you read? Recommend or share it ahead.
 (https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/facebook/offer?url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy-
regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill

That Our Government Needs To Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy-
450x300.jpg&pco=tbxnj-1.0)
 (https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/twitter/offer?url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy-regulation-
bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill That Our

Government Needs To Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy-
 (https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/email/offer?url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy-regulation-
bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill That Our

Government Needs To Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/11183916/pregnancy-
(http://voxpop.youthkiawaaz.com/10-youthmanifesto2019?utm_source=Mobile_Banner&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)
Alolika A. Dutta
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/alolika_a_dutta/)
6 Following | 16 Followers
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/alolika_a_dutta/) Follow
 
(https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/facebook/offer?
Did you know you can add a post on Youth Ki Awaaz (https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/twitter/offer?
too? Get started here (/me/). (https://api.addt
url=https://
asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8
Similar Posts Questions asking/&pubi
Explained: Why The Women’s Reservation
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/04/womens- Answer&picture=https://dz01iyojmxk8t.cloudfront.net/wp-
Bill Is A Crucial Tool For Gender Justice Answer&pictu
reservation-bill- (Https://Www.Youthkiawaaz.Com/2019/04/Womens-Reservation-Bill-A-Necessity/)
a-necessity/)
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/anuparna2/)Anuparna Majumder (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/anuparna2/) in
#SansadUnplugged
4 days ago
Brain Drain Cess: A Fair Deal Or A Retrograde Flow?

(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/04/making-
a-gain-out-of- (Https://Www.Youthkiawaaz.Com/2019/04/Making-A-Gain-Out-Of-Brain-Drain/)
brain-drain/)
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/saurabh/)Saurabh Parmar (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/saurabh/) in
#SansadUnplugged
23 days ago
This Bill Seeks To Dismantle The Art Of Bhrashtachar Perfected By Politicians Over Years
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/04/representation-
of-peoples-act- (Https://Www.Youthkiawaaz.Com/2019/04/Representation-Of-Peoples-Act-Amendment-Bill/)
amendment-
bill/) (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/ninonering/)Ninong Ering (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/ninonering/) in
#SansadUnplugged
25 days ago
Comments
You must be logged in to comment.
Trending Post ›
Kalank: A Love Triangle So Predictable, It Could Have Been Written

(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/04/kalank- By Pythagoras
movie-review/) (Https://Www.Youthkiawaaz.Com/2019/04/Kalank-Movie-Review/)
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/hriday_ranjan/) Hriday Ranjan (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/hriday_ranjan/) in Culture-
Vulture (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/category/art-and-culture/)
April 19, 2019
 2914
At A Pub In Hyderabad, I Saw How Zomato Is Helping Homophobic Businesses Flourish

(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/04/zomato-
is-supporting- (Https://Www.Youthkiawaaz.Com/2019/04/Zomato-Is-Supporting-Homophobic-Businesses-
homophobic- Flourish/)
businesses-
ourish/) (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/indrajeet_ghorpade/)IndraJeet Ghorpade
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/indrajeet_ghorpade/) in Cake
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/category/cake/)
April 17, 2019
 4379
 
UPSC Is A Disease In Our Country (Https://Www.Youthkiawaaz.Com/2019/04/Upsc-Is-A-
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/04/upsc-
is-a-disease-in- Disease-In-Our-Country/)
(https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/facebook/offer? (https://api.addthis.com/oexchange/0.8/forward/twitter/offer? (https://api.addt
our-country/) 
url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- url=https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2019/01/surrogacy- url=https://
(https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/nitin_gurjar/) Kunwar Nitin Pratap Gurjar (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/author/nitin_gurjar/) in
regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be- Society (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/category/society/)
regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be- regulation
April 15, 2019
About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs To About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs To  3725 The S
About
©Featured (/)Pvt.Latest
YKA Media Ltd. (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie
 (https://www.facebook.com/youthkiawaaz)  (https://twitter.com/YouthKiAwaaz)  (https://plus.google.com/+YouthKiAwaazO cial)
 (https://www.youtube.com/youthkiawaaz)  (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/contact-us/)
Home (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/) About (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/about/) Terms (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/terms-
 
url=https://

Surrogacy Bill - Legal Loopholes, Homophobia & Commercialising Women

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Surrogacy Bill - Legal Loopholes, Homophobia & Commercialising Women

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

4/30/2019 Surrogacy Bill: Legal Loopholes, Homophobia & Commercialising Women

Featured (/) Latest (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie

8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill That Our Government Needs

Editor’s Note: This post is a part of #SansadUnplugged (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/sansadunplugged), a campaign by Young

On December 19, 2018 (https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/surrogacy-regulation-bill-passed-in-lok-sabha-10-points-1965215), the Lok Sabha

Is Surrogacy Inherently ‘Bad’?

Featured (/) Latest (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie

What Does The Surrogacy Bill Entail?

Down To Earth recorded (https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/umbilical-discourse-55751) the story of a 28-year-old surrogate mother

2: If A Ban Is Not The Answer, Then What Is?

3: Why Is It Necessary For The Surrogate Mother To Be A Close Relative Of The

5: Is The Bill Feminist In Nature?

Featured (/) Latest (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/latest/?utm_source=Menu&utm_medium=YKA&utm_content=Views)  PM Brie

8: Why Can’t Surrogacy Be An Openly Accessible Option? Why Is Infertility A

Hence, these are a few questions

Like what you read? Recommend or share it ahead.

regulation-bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill

bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill That Our

bill-2018-8-questions-that-we-should-be-asking/&pubid=ra-4def7e3f1fcc751a&ct=1&title=8 Questions About The Surrogacy Bill That Our

Brain Drain Cess: A Fair Deal Or A Retrograde Flow?

Kalank: A Love Triangle So Predictable, It Could Have Been Written

At A Pub In Hyderabad, I Saw How Zomato Is Helping Homophobic Businesses Flourish

 (https://www.facebook.com/youthkiawaaz)  (https://twitter.com/YouthKiAwaaz)  (https://plus.google.com/+YouthKiAwaazO cial)

Home (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/) About (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/about/) Terms (https://www.youthkiawaaz.com/terms-

You might also like