Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Portia Is The Heroine Of: William Shakespeare
Portia Is The Heroine Of: William Shakespeare
Despite Portia's lack of formal legal training, she wins her case by
referring to the details of the exact language of the law. Her success
involves prevailing on technicalities rather than the merits of the
situation. She uses the tactics of what is sometimes called a
Philadelphia lawyer. However, the concept of rhetoric and its abuse
is also brought to light by Portia – highlighting the idea that an
unjust argument may win through eloquence, loopholes and
technicalities, regardless of the moral question at hand – and thus
provoking the audience to consider that issue.
Who Is Shylock?
The Loan
Antonio's best friend, Bassanio, needs money to win the hand of the
beautiful Portia, a wealthy heiress. Antonio's money is tied up in his
merchant ships abroad, so he cannot give his friend any money.
Shylock agrees to loan Bassanio 3,000 ducats, or gold coins, for
three months but requires Antonio to sign a notarized agreement. If
the loan is not paid on time, Shylock will cut off a pound of
Antonio's flesh. Antonio must not feel too worried, because he signs
the agreement. Most of us are familiar with the practices of loan
sharks, but Shylock takes it even further! He seriously intends to cut
off a pound of Antonio's flesh should he default on the loan.
As the story progresses, Antonio's ships are lost at sea, leaving him
unable to pay the debt. In the meantime, Bassanio succeeds in
winning Portia's hand, partially by passing a test her father devised
for her suitors.
When Bassanio finds out about Antonio's hard luck, Portia gives
him 6,000 ducats to pay off the loan and save Antonio's life.
However, Shylock is far more interested in revenge than money.
When his own daughter, Jessica, runs off with a Christian named
Lorenzo, Shylock is only concerned about the money and jewels she
takes with her, and not her safety.
Shylock's Justification