You are on page 1of 5

Clinical

The use of mime therapy as a


rehabilitation method for
patients with facial nerve paresis
Carien HG Beurskens, Pieter P Devriese, Ide van Heiningen, Rob AB Oostendorp

Since 1980, patients with sequelae of peripheral facial nerve paresis have been treated with mime therapy at
the physiotherapy department of the University Medical Centre in Nijmegen, which aims to rehabilitate facial
expression. Mime therapy was developed by Jan Bronk (a mime actor) and Pieter Devriese (an
otolaryngologist) in the 1970s, using the principles of mime for patients suffering from either lack of facial
movement or uncontrolled movements. Both therapists and patients reported benefits of mime therapy;
most importantly, an improved symmetry of the face.
There is a belief within the profession that evidence-based treatment is required to scientifically
substantiate physiotherapy. A detailed description of the mime therapy treatment is essential for performing
a randomized controlled trial, which is currently underway.
This article aims to comprehensively describe the historical development and clinical characteristics of mime
therapy and to give insight into its usefulness as a tool in the treatment of patients with facial nerve paresis.
Key words: facial nerve paresis, mime therapy, physiotherapy
Beurskens CHG, Devriese PP, van Heiningen I, Oostendorp RAB (2004) The use of mime therapy as a rehabilitation
method for patients with facial nerve paresis. Int J Ther Rehabil 11(5): 206–10

T
o date, more than 1000 people with trauma or other causes. In 1974, they explored the
facial nerve paresis have been success- possibilities of mime with patients. A treatment plan
fully treated with mime therapy in was devised, consisting of a series of exercises, with
Nijmegen, the Netherlands. The House- most patients receiving individual treatment. Patients
Brackmann scale (House and Brackmann, 1985) started therapy after a minimum of 1 year following
Carien HG Beurskens
is Physiotherapist, and a more detailed grading system – the later onset of the paralysis, as sequelae had to be stable.
Department of Sunnybrook Facial Grading System (Ross et al, From 1977 to 1979, 24 patients were treated.
Physiotherapy, University 1994) – are used as outcome measures. These Initially, mime therapy consisted of massage of
Medical Centre, 6500 tools have shown that facial symmetry at rest and the face and neck, breathing and relaxation exer-
HB Nijmegen, the
during movements improves and synkinesis cises, exercises to coordinate both halves of the face
Netherlands, Pieter P
Devriese is decreases after mime therapy. and expression exercises. The conceptual basis of
Otolaryngologist, Ear mime therapy in the 1970s was that when facial
Nose and Throat THE HISTORY OF MIME THERAPY expressions are damaged, it is essential to mobilize
Department, Academic the whole body to re-facilitate emotional and com-
Medical Centre, the
In 1975, the Department of Facial Research at the municational possibilities. Massage, breathing and
Netherlands, Ide van
Heiningen is Mime Wilhelmina Gasthuis in Amsterdam introduced a relaxation exercises will relax the whole body,
Artist, Dutch Mime film entitled Peripheral Facial Paralysis. Jan Bronk which will consequently relax the face.
Centre, the Netherlands (1927–1985), director of the Dutch Mime Centre, Coordination exercises will result in symmetry of
and Rob AB illustrated in this film the function of the mimetic the face, while other exercises are necessary tore-
Oostendorp is
muscles (Figure 1). This film, aimed at medical stu- educate expressive possibilities.
Physiotherapist,
Professor in Allied dents and doctors, emphasized the importance of In 1976, a report was given at the International
Health Care, University early examination and treatment of patients with Facial Nerve Symposium in Zurich on the first
Medical Centre, the facial nerve paralysis, or paresis. During the making experiences of treating patients with facial paresis
Netherlands of this film, Jan Bronk and otolaryngologist Pieter (Devriese and Bronk, 1977). The year 1981 saw the
Devriese came into contact with each other. publication of a booklet giving details of mime ther-
Correspondence to:
Carien HG Beurskens It occurred to Bronk and Devriese that mime apy, which had to be revised several times and trans-
c.beurskens@fysioth. might help in rehabilitating patients with an lated into English (Devriese and Bronk, 1981;
umcn.nl impaired facial expression as a result of Bell’s palsy, Beurskens et al, 1988; Devriese et al, 1998).

206 International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation, May 2004, Vol 11, No 5

l Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation.Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 130.113.076.026 on February 27, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All righ
the expressive possibilities of movement normally
WHAT IS MIME? occurring unconsciously. For example, the mouth
Mime is a performance art based on non-verbal corner can be pulled down extremely fast, which
expression. The best-known form of mime is pan- gives a completely different expression than that
tomime and may be compared to figurative painting caused by allowing the mouth corner to drop
– the picture tells the story. The best-known pan- gradually.
tomime players are the masked players of Greek ■ Alertness and awareness of the direction of
antiquity, the actors of the 16th Century Commedia movement. The direction can be towards or away
dell’Arte, the great silent film actors and Marcel from the body, displaying different emotions.
Marceau. The movements used in mime are dis- ■ Expression. Mime is an art of movement and an
tilled from reality. Real life is analysed and inter- art of communication. The purpose of mime is to
preted as new theatrical signs and images. Mime deepen the individual’s capacity for non-verbal
demands a highly refined control of the body. communication.

MIME CORPOREL Physiotherapy and mime therapy


In 1980, after being trained by Jan Bronk, physio-
A new form of mime – mime corporel, was founded therapists began to treat patients. They were moti-
by Etienne Decroux (1987). The body and movement vated to learn mime therapy as results of other
analysis in mime corporel is fundamentally different treatments were dissatisfying (Beurskens et al,
from that of the medical world. Whereas practitioners 1994). Specific items were elaborated, such as
such as physiotherapists analyse the body in terms of stretching of facial muscles, the inhibition of synki-
its anatomical structure and relate movement to func- neses by counteracting movements and coordina-
tion, mime corporel analyses the body and its move- tion exercises between the affected and normal side
ments entirely in terms of expression possibilities in of the face. The medical history and anamnesis
space. The basic principles of mime corporel are: were improved by the introduction of standardized
■ Movement is rhythm of the body in space and time intakes. Measurement instruments were used, which
■ The essence of movement is made visible by were necessary for objectifying the sequelae of the
exaggerated movements. paresis and for evaluating the therapy.
To perform, the mime artist has to learn to ‘isolate’ On 11 January 1985, Jan Bronk died at the age of
and to ‘articulate’, respectively to move and to 57 years. After his death, the first two trained phys-
emphasize, specific movements. iotherapists continued to give courses. A grant in

DEVELOPMENT OF MIME THERAPY

Jan Bronk took the analysis of Decroux a step fur-


ther. As a teacher at the mime school, he developed
the analytical principles into a teaching model. In
addition, he adapted mime for a wider social appli-
cation and was especially interested in its possibili-
ties in the area of health care. He developed a way
of working using functioning capabilities to help
activation in less well functioning areas. He also
made an analysis of the face, especially emotional
expressions, in order to help patients with facial
nerve paresis.
In analysing the face, it is not possible to consider
an expression as a separate entity as every facial
movement, however slight (or even an absence of
movement), results in an expression of some kind.
Analysis using the principles of mime corporel
includes:
■ Breathing. Facial expression is a part of a total
‘mood’ reflected in the body. The impairment of
facial expression will be reflected by tension Figure 1. Jan Bronk,
elsewhere in the body. Breathing will reduce illustrating the mimetic
tension. musculature (drawn in red)
■ Articulation – i.e. helping to prevent differing and the facial nerve (in
expressions becoming mixed up. Mime teaches yellow).

International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation, May 2004, Vol 11, No 5 207

l Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation.Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 130.113.076.026 on February 27, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All righ
Clinical

1990 made it possible to start a mime therapy therapy, the necessity of doing homework and the
course for 18 paramedics, given by eight teachers integration of exercises into daily life.
from various disciplines. The course leads to clini-
cal specialization in treating patients with peripheral Self-massage
facial paresis. The names of the mime therapists Patients are taught to massage their face and neck
(physiotherapists and speech therapists) who have daily for about 10–15 minutes, to relax the facial
followed the course are included in a register. musculature and promote circulation. Massage
involves knowing one’s own face and discovering
MIME THERAPY TODAY which areas have reduced or heightened tension. It
consists of effluerage and massage of both sides of
The aim of mime treatment is to promote symmetry the face. Stretching exercises of the affected side
of the face at rest and during movement; the patient follow to relieve mimetic muscles involved in
being simultaneously taught to control synkineses. synkinesis. Stretching is performed in a slow manner,
This will result in reduced stiffness and increased following the course of the muscles, with the thumb
emotional readability. On a disability level, it results of the heterolateral hand placed into the mouth on the
in fewer problems with eating, drinking and speak- affected side and opposed to the fingers (Diels,
ing, and on a health level it promotes wellbeing and 1995). In cases of lagophthalmos (inability to close
improves participation in social activities. Mime the eyelids fully), the upper eyelid can be stretched
therapy nowadays consists of: for about 15 seconds (Aramideh et al, 2002).
■ Anamnesis, patient information about treatment
and prognosis Breathing and relaxation exercises
■ Self-massage of face and neck As a result of the facial nerve paresis, increased
■ Breathing and relaxation exercises muscle tone can be present not only in the face, but
■ Specific exercises to coordinate both facial in the whole body. In the presence of synkineses,
halves and to decrease synkineses muscle tone is increased and stress will only further
■ Eye and lip closure exercises this. From a holistic point of view, the mind does not
■ Letter and word exercises function separately from the body, thus relaxing the
■ Expression exercises (Devriese et al, 1998). face also requires relaxation of the body. Patients are
The average number of treatment sessions is ten taught to recognize tension and to feel the difference
(each session lasting approximately 45 minutes) and between tension and relaxation in general, especially
the patient attends once weekly or less. Follow-up in the facial musculature. Relaxation exercises are
treatment is usually planned after 3 or 6 months. carried out as described by Schultz (1960).
The therapy is composed of sequentially structured
exercises. Patients have to complete homework on a Coordinating both facial halves and decreasing
daily basis, helped by a homework book. synkinesis
Nowadays, owing to new insights and experience, This is done through:
mime therapy starts when degeneration is visible ■ Basic exercises with variation in amplitude and
(synkinesis). This can be after 3 months following speed
onset of the paralysis. A mirror is used as feedback ■ Exercises for one side of the face
instrument, as it is necessary to see how exercises ■ Relaxation of the lower jaw
are performed and whether synkinesis is present ■ Exercises of the mouth (e.g. smiling, pouting)
when treatment is started. and of the eye, with simultaneous inhibition of
synkinesis through slow, small movements and
Anamnesis, patient information about treatment counteraction (Figure 2).
and prognosis These exercises will create an improved coordina-
Often patients referred for physiotherapy have tion between the two halves of the face, enabling
received a minimum amount of information the patient to display facial movements and emo-
regarding prognosis, treatment possibilities and tions in a more symmetrical way.
coping with their problems. The first treatment
session is used to explain the cause, course and Eye and lip closure exercises
prognosis. To objectify the actual situation of the These exercises are necessary when the eye does not
facial paresis, the Sunnybrook Facial Grading close properly. Exercises are performed with
System, the House-Brackmannn scale and the Facial variations in speed and force. Lip closure exercises
Disability Index (VanSwearingen and Brach, 1996) are necessary for eating, drinking and rinsing and
are used. Photos and/or videos of the patient at rest comprise exercises of the cheek (filling the cheeks
and making five facial expressions are made. The with differing amounts of air) and eating and
patients also receive information regarding mime drinking exercises while keeping the eye open

208 International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation, May 2004, Vol 11, No 5

l Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation.Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 130.113.076.026 on February 27, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All righ
(small movements). Helping to create a better lip facial muscles more consciously while expressing
closure enables the patient to feel better during emotions can help the patient to cope with the dis-
functional and social activities. tressing after-effects of the paralysis.

Articulation PRESENT SITUATION


These exercises are performed to increase the
patient’s awareness of lip movements and the posi- In the Netherlands, 200–250 patients are treated
tion of the mouth for various sounds. Vowels as a, e, yearly with mime therapy. Currently, there are
i and o and consonants such as p and b are used for approximately 30 mime therapists working mainly in
the position of the lips. Word exercises concentrate an academic setting. Mime therapy courses are given
on the correct position of the mouth. An increased at the physiotherapy department of the University
articulation will give patients more self-esteem dur- Medical Centre in Nijmegen.
ing communication. Nowadays, mime therapy can also be applied (in an
adapted way) for patients after a nerve and/or muscle
Expression reconstruction (Beurskens et al, 1998). Besides plastic
Throughout the therapy, it is vital to try to develop a surgery and psychological guidance, mime therapy is
conscious connection between the use of certain available as a third modality to treat sequelae of facial
muscles and facial emotional expression. Exercises nerve paralysis. The authors feel that all three modali-
can be performed in two ways: working from the ties should be available in medical centres where
use of certain muscles towards a mood, or working patients are referred (Devriese et al, 1998).
from a certain mood as a starting point for a move-
ment. For example; the patient can be asked to raise SUMMARY
his or her forehead, or to perform an expression
depicting amazement. Mime therapy is a promising treatment based upon
Various moods may be evoked by asking the clinical reports and is predominantly used in the
patient to knit the brow, open the eyes wide, stick Netherlands. Both therapists and patients report
out the lower lip or tighten the lips. These expres- positive changes in facial symmetry following Figure 2. (a) Synkinesis of
sive exercises can be used throughout the whole mime therapy. Evaluating patients who have under- the eye while pouting and
mime therapy programme. Learning to use the gone mime therapy in the past few years with the (b) inhibition of synkinesis.

a. b.

International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation, May 2004, Vol 11, No 5 209

l Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation.Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 130.113.076.026 on February 27, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All righ
Clinical

House-Brackmann scale reveals that most of them There is not much known about the working
improve by one grade. mechanism of mime therapy – for example, is it
Mime therapy is not yet implicated for patients plasticity of the nervous system or a learning of
with neurological conditions such as stroke, owing to new motor skills? Further research has to be carried
the fact that central facial paralysis is associated with out concerning this aspect. IJTR
many other problems (such as aphasia).
Physiotherapy for patients with stroke is more Conflict of interest: none.
focused upon other impairments and health prob-
Aramideh M, Koelman JHTM, Devriese PP, Speelman JD,
lems, such as mobility of the upper extremities. Ongerboer de Visser BW (2002) Thixotropy of the levator
For an international introduction of mime therapy, palpebrae muscle as the cause of lagophthalmus after peripheral
facial nerve palsy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatr 72: 665–7
there has to be an evidence base. A randomized Beurskens C, Burgers-Bots I, Devriese PP, Idler J (1988)
controlled trial has just been completed at the Mimetherapie. Huisdrukkerij AZU, Amsterdam
Beurskens CHG, Oosterhof J, Elvers JWH, Oostendorp RAB,
University Medical Centre in Nijmegan, studying Herraets MEJ (1994) The role of physical therapy in patients
the effectiveness of mime therapy in correcting with facial paralysis: state of the art. In: Stennert ER, ed. The
Facial Nerve. Proceedings of the VIIth International Symposium
facial asymmetry, disabilities in eating, drinking on the Facial Nerve. Springer-Verlag, New York: 125–6
and speaking and psychosocial problems. The Beurskens CHG, van Rossum-Herraets MEJ, Manni JJ, Nicolai
J-PA (1998) Physiotherapy following a hypoglossal-facial
results of this study will provide evidence for the nerve interpositional jump graft. J Clin Rehabil 1: 37–45
efficacy of this treatment. Decroux E (1987) Words on Mime. 2nd edn. Ed Drama
Publishers, Seattle
Devriese PP, Bronk J (1977) Non-surgical rehabilitation of facial
expression. In: Fisch U, ed. Facial Nerve Surgery. Kugler
KEY POINTS Medical Publications, the Netherlands: 290–4
Devriese PP, Bronk J (1981) Rehabilitation of facial expression.
Theoretical backgrounds and exercises. Huisdrukkerij AZU,
Amsterdam
■ Elements of mime and physiotherapy are combined to create a new treatment Devriese PP, Beurskens C, Heiningen van I (1998) Rehabilitation
for patients with facial nerve paresis. of facial expression by mime. Huisdrukkerij AZU, Amsterdam
Diels HJ (1995) New concepts in nonsurgical facial nerve reha-
■ Emotional expression exercises are essential for patients with facial nerve paresis. bilitation. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 9: 289–315
House JW, Brackmann DE (1985) Facial nerve grading sys-
■ Mime therapy is a promising treatment based upon clinical reports. tem. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 93: 146–7
Ross BR, Fradet G, Nedzelski JM (1994) Development of a sensi-
■ Plastic surgery, psychological guidance and mime therapy should be available in tive clinical facial grading system. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol
medical centres where patients with facial nerve paralysis are referred. (suppl): 180–1
Schultz IH (1960) Das Autogene Training. Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart
■ A randomized controlled trial is needed to give mime therapy an evidence base. VanSwearingen JM, Brach JS (1996) The Facial Disability Index: reli-
ability and validity of a disability assessment instrument for disor-
ders of the facial neuromuscular system. Phys Ther 76: 1288–300

COMMENTARIES

Neuromuscular facial retraining pro- The key points addressed in the change of facial function, expres- randomized controlled trial study
grammes are receiving more recog- article in describing mime therapy sion and self-image. With mime that is underway sounded encour-
nition in the United States as a result components were head and neck therapy, the patient may be able to aging for validating mime therapy
of evidence-based outcomes being massage, breathing and relaxation ‘act out’ some of his or her emo- efficacy.
reported. However, the use of mime exercises, coordination and expres- tion and use this non-verbal com- A barrier to this type of approach
therapy for facial nerve rehabilitation sion exercises, letter and word exer- munication art as he/she develops may be the view of the health-care
is a lesser-known treatment cises and eye and lip closure improved facial expression and community that mime therapy is
approach. After reviewing this arti- exercises. This programme sounds movement. superfluous. But, the objectives of
cle, this approach sounds very comprehensive and definitely The article also included the use mime therapy described in this arti-
promising and worth a closer view. addresses facial function, as well as of mime therapy for reduction of cle and the ongoing research of this
The authors of this article did a rehabilitation. synkinesis, through gentle, slow type of intervention should help to
nice job of overviewing the histori- Mime therapy emphasizes facial stretches and exercises. Synkinesis decrease criticism.
cal development and providing a emotional expression, which is so can greatly decrease normal facial Mime therapy certainly sounds
thorough description of mime valuable in working with this popu- expression and should be like a treatment approach that
therapy principles. The basis of lation. The use of mime therapy addressed in all facial retraining should be further investigated.
mime therapy is non-verbal com- may help the patient psychologi- programmes.
munication that can be used as a cally, because of the importance The use of universally recognized Gaye W Cronin
Director
communication art. Obviously, placed upon the patient being in facial grading scales to measure
Neuromuscular Facial Retraining
non-verbal expression is extremely touch with his/her face, mood and progress, such as the House-
Program
important in facial nerve rehabilita- expressions. Brackmann and Sunnybrook Atlanta Ear Clinic
tion. The overwhelming problem In the treatment of patients grading scales, helped to lend Atlanta
voiced by this population is their with facial nerve paresis, many further creditability to mime Georgia 30342
lack of normal facial expression. appear depressed owing to their therapy. Also, the inclusion of the USA

210 International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation, May 2004, Vol 11, No 5

l Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation.Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 130.113.076.026 on February 27, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All righ

You might also like