Pre-workout supplements: which

ones are the best?

March 5, 2019
|

Asker Jeukendrup

Pre-workout supplements are popular. What do they consist off? What do they do?
Are they useful? What is the evidence?  Are they safe to take? What strikes me, is
that the most frequently asked question is: which one is the best? and the question
not often asked is: do they work? or are they necessary?
 
The magic blend
Pre-workout supplements often contain a mystery blend of ingredients ranging from
caffeine to BCAAs to creatine to some more exotic ingredients. These supplements
are claimed to bring your body in a state of “readiness” for the training! Although
there are hundreds of these supplements on the market and they are all different,
there seem to be a few ingredients that can be found in most of these products. A
recent study showed that 44.3% of investigated supplements contained a
proprietary blend of ingredients. This means that the exact amounts are not
disclosed and thus it is impossible to link the potential effects to any of the
ingredients. If we want to evaluate the effects of these pre-workout supplements,
we need to look at the evidence behind each of these ingredients. We will start with
some of the most common ones, because if they are in all products, they must be
the most effective ingredients. In the infographic the most common ingredients are
listed according to a recent publication (1).
 
Beta alanine
Beta alanine ingestion over a period of several weeks can increase the muscle
buffering capacity because the concentration of muscle carnosine may increase.
One of the side effects of beta-alanine is parasthesia (tingling fingertips and nose).
The higher the dose the more severe the side effects. But some people like it
because now the supplement you are taking seems to do something... you notice
something after taking it... so it must work. The amounts of beta-alanine found in
most pre-workout supplements is far too small to have these effects. Besides that,
the carnosine concentration needs about 4-6 weeks to increase, thus just taking a
small dose just before exercise will have no effect at al.
 
Caffeine
It is known for a long time that caffeine improves alertness and can improve
endurance exercise performance. The evidence that it improves performance
during high intensity exercise workouts and resistance training is much less
convincing, but it is possible. Caffeine, in whatever form would need to be ingested
about 1 hour before the workout.  One could also argue that the source of the
caffeine does not matter. For example, drinking coffee would have the same effect
as the synthetic caffeine in most of these pre-workout products, so we would not
necessarily need a pre-workout supplement for this effect. 
 
BCAA
Branched-chain amino acids or BCAAs is a group of three essential amino acids:
isoleucine, leucine and valine. BCAAs are building blocks for protein and leucine
also has a role in turning on protein synthesis. Studies have shown that BCAA
alone are ineffective in raising protein synthesis and they would have to be
ingested with protein. One way to do this is a supplement but chicken for example
has more essential amino acids and more BCAA than most supplements. So why
not eat the protein. Besides that, this is not an acute effect and there is no need to
take it before exercise. Studies show that protein post exercise is at least as
effective or more effective. So why not just have a meal after exercise? Also other
claims of BCAAs do not seem supported with evidence (read more here).
 
Citrulline Malate
Citrulline malate is another amino acid that is produced in the body through the
other amino acids that are consumed. Some studies have used citrulline as a
precursor for arginine, with the goal to improve blood flow. The effects have been
very small and several studies have not been able to find any effects. 
 
Creatine
Creatine is a popular supplement. It is one of the few that has evidence that it can
be beneficial in some situations for some people. If body stores of creatine are
suboptimal, creatine supplementation for 5 days (high doses of 20 g per day) have
been shown to restore the creatine stores. Studies have shown that higher muscle
creatine concentrations are linked to improved repeated high intensity exercise
performance. Creatine ingested at 3g/day for 30 days will achieve the same.
However, ingesting 1-3 grams of creatine just before a workout will not improve that
workout. 
 
Electrolytes
Electrolytes like magnesium, potassium and sodium are buzz words. If we call them
”salt” this is seen as “bad” ingredient and the message is to reduce salt intake. If we
call them “electrolytes” they become “good” and we need them before a workout.
The reality is: they will not do anything before a workout and you don’t need them.
It is marketing fluff.
 
Protein
Protein delivered to the body through pre-workout drinks and meals will help it to
increase protein synthesis by delivering more amino acid building blocks. The result
is increased muscle growth. But most sources of protein will do this and there is no
need to have protein pre-exercise.
 
Taurine
An amino acid, taurine is used in energy drinks. It is not exactly clear what it is
supposed to do and research does not support a role in exercise performance. 
 
Vitamin B12
Vitamin B12 plays an important role in metabolism and erythropoiesis. However,
there are no studies that show that vitamin B12 affects exercise in any way,
especially if there is no deficiency. 
 
You will get the picture by now. We discussed a list of ingredients that are popular
in pre-workout supplements and we must conclude that caffeine is the one
ingredient that may affect subsequent performance. The rest of the products are
mostly fillers and marketing gimps. Some products may contain illegal ingredients
with unknown health effects or with known negative effects. The one that has
received most attention is probably DMAA.
 
DMAA
DMAA is sometimes added to pre-workout supplements. DMAA (1,3-
dimethylamylamine) is an amphetamine derivative that has been marketed in
sports performance and weight loss products, many of which are sold as dietary
supplements. DMAA is linked with brain haemorrhage and several deaths have
been linked to its use as a dietary supplement.  DMAA is a drug and not a dietary
ingredient, and DMAA-containing products marketed as dietary supplements are
illegal and their marketing violates the law in many countries (including USA,
Canada, New Zealand, Sweden, Australia, Finland, the UK, and Brazil. Despite
multiple warning letters from the FDA as of 2018, the stimulant remains available in
sports and weight loss supplements. For a subgroup of consumers the fact that
they are banned means that they must be very effective! In fact
supplement manufacturers on their web sites proudly display that the supplements
are banned. A quick google search took me to a web site that showed all the
"banned" products and the mentioned "it is basically legal meth"... There seemed to
be some confusion between legal and banned... 
 
DMAA is also included in various products under different names including the
following: 
1,3-DMAA
1,3-Dimethylamylamine
1,3-Dimethylpentylamine
2-Amino-4-methylhexane
2-Hexanamine, 4-methyl- (9CI)
4-Methyl-2-hexanamine
4-Methyl-2-hexylamine
Dimethylamylamine
Geranamine
Methylhexanamine
Methylhexanenamine
DMAA may have received a lot of attention, but there are many other ingredients
used in pre-workout supplements with unknown health effects. These ingredients
are in some cases not even listed on the label. 
 
Summary
So, in summary, pre-workout supplements are claimed to get you ready for your
workout. They contain a mix of ingredients. The consumer is tricked into thinking
that the more ingredients something contains, the better, it must work. However, if
you have 10 ingredients that don’t work, or 20, it does not make a difference.
Having said this, these supplements may work to some degree. They may act as a
placebo. They are part of a ritual. The ritual could be a cup of tea, some stretching,
some loud shouting, or maybe you could hit yourself in the face a few times… but
(with the exception of caffeine), the supplement does not seem to help the workout
because of the action of its ingredients. 
 
References 
 
(1) Jagim AR, Harty PS, Camic CL. Common Ingredient Profiles of Multi-
Ingredient Pre-Workout Supplements. Nutrients. 2019 Jan 24;11(2). pii: E254. doi:
10.3390/nu11020254.